Back
Antti Kleemola
Chief Digital Officer, Finnair Oyj

Finnair Antti Kleemola and Solita Marko Taipale

🎥 Apr 27, 2023 📺 Solita ⏱ 28m
How does the human and computer automation interact now and in the future by Antti Kleemola, CIO and Executive Board ...
Watch on YouTube
Transcript (36 segments)
I
Interviewer0:21
Okay hi there, we're going to have a bit of conversation with Antti regarding the topic. But before we go to the conversation part, I'm going to give a bit of definition of automation for our conversation. So to define automation, it's a use of technology in terms of tasks or processes without or with very minimum intervention from human beings. It may involve a wide range of technologies ranging from robotics, AI, software tools, and whatnot. But for our conversation, we're actually more focused on the human aspect and how the collaboration between human and machines will happen. We're going to discuss mainly on two themes: one is the role of automation in terms of leadership and decision making, and the second one is value of automation, how it's perceived. So let's start with the role of automation. What do you think is the key benefit for, for instance, for Finnair? What's the key benefit of having the automation in there?
A
Antti Kleemola1:42
Yeah, there are multiple ones. If we start with the traditional ones, you have the cost efficiencies, how you make sure that you are able to do things faster, getting things faster to market. Then the second part could be that you are having your revenue sources increased, which are actually both our strategy. So the whole strategy of Finnair is based on automation at the moment. We are looking into revenue gains and cost gains. But the big thing for us from AI and automation is that you actually are able to do things at a much bigger scale than you would be able to do with just humans or standard computing. In our operations, the decision on which plane to run or delay is done by AI. We analyze the whole network 24/7, 365 days, trying to figure out if something happens. Previously, humans made decisions based on passenger count, but now because we are a network airline, we run planes in different locations simultaneously, and AI makes the most optimal flight plan. For example, previously the most important flight in the morning was Helsinki to Shanghai, but actually it's Oulu to Helsinki because if that lands in time, it can go to Rome, pick up Italians to go to Japan, which are the most valuable customers.
I
Interviewer5:05
Okay, I think that distinction is kind of clear at the same time, and I think it gets challenged all the time. If you think about the future and what it brings, I think this interaction is getting more and more complicated.
A
Antti Kleemola5:20
Yes, it is. And we can now see that everybody in the audience and at Finnair has been playing around with ChatGPT and figuring out new ways of doing things, amazed by the simple UI that allows you to test things out. Previously it was like alchemy, but now it's just a tool. As Jing was saying, the co-pilot is going to come in, so it's going to be your partner in doing everything. Obviously there's a fear of change on the individual and corporate level.
I
Interviewer5:52
How do you deal with that?
A
Antti Kleemola6:03
It's a really important topic. I think the whole thing of adapting AI is more about change management. The technology is there, everybody can take it into use, it's cheap to trial and test, but it's all about change management. How do you make sure that you make long-lasting changes in your processes and the way the organization runs, and also the culture that we embrace data-driven decisions and having AI as our co-pilot in flying the planes. So that's the important part. How do we enable the whole organization and culture to adopt AI in everything we do?
I
Interviewer6:52
How would you reflect that on the individual level? How people will embrace that change? What have you done for Finnair in your context?
A
Antti Kleemola7:01
It's a really good point. Of course it's personal, always depends on the individual tasks. But how we have approached it is that we have a systematic way. With the use of AI, we have given one team the option to use AI. First they were a bit scared, but then they embraced it when they saw the first demos. They realized that this thing they thought was in the future is here today, and their role changed. They are no longer doing that part of the process and have a different ability to do more and interact better with AI, freeing time from everyday tasks to make new processes and new business cases.
I
Interviewer9:47
Let's move to the value of automation. We already discussed the benefits, so maybe I would go from the risk point of view. How do you derisk or how do you deal with the challenges of automation?
A
Antti Kleemola10:02
If we start, airlines is an interesting spectrum. We have our own everyday AI within the planes already, the real co-pilot. Automation that runs and lands planes has been there for decades, now improving. It removes human risk. In some cases it's better to rely on automation, in others on humans. You need to balance. With external data and AI, you can find new risks. For us, brand is critical, so we do social media analysis to understand perception of changes.
I
Interviewer11:36
I think you're describing that the world is complex and we can't foresee all outcomes. We need to be reactive. How about when we talk about the value, there's always the question of what's the value of automation. How do you go about answering that?
A
Antti Kleemola11:59
Of course, when you need to value the investment, there are multiple ways. Direct financial benefits like scaling teams, quicker time to market, better decisions. But the hard part is justifying without trying. So it's a leap of faith, but you need an agile approach to test and figure out the value rather than making a huge business case with wrong assumptions.
I
Interviewer13:19
That challenges leadership in terms of predictability. How do you see connecting the value and role questions? What's the role of leadership in enabling that conversation?
A
Antti Kleemola13:42
It always starts from the leader itself. In an organization, it needs to start from the board and CEO understanding the value and talking about it top-down, but also bottom-up from people doing everyday tasks. They realize that having an assistant allows them to innovate and be more productive. It's multi-dimensional. Our example is disruption management. When a plane is delayed, we need to accommodate passengers. We want to provide a personal experience, understanding their preferences.
I
Interviewer15:31
How do you see the impact of automation on Finnair? If you step back, what's the impact?
A
Antti Kleemola15:48
It's at the core of everything we do. It's the next level competitive advantage. We want to be the first to move. It brings value to operations, better customer experience, and employee experience by removing cumbersome tasks. We are looking at end-to-end processes where automation helps the whole process.
I
Interviewer16:42
And what's your role in it?
A
Antti Kleemola16:53
I've been an executive board champion or sponsor. In the disruption management case, I'm there to challenge the team and ask stupid questions because I'm not an airline person. I've been at the company for 10 months, so I can still ask why we are doing these steps. With better data and AI, do we need that task at all? Can we let customers make self-service selections?
I
Interviewer17:51
How would you describe the use of automation in your work? What does it mean for you?
A
Antti Kleemola17:57
Personally, I'm hoping for the co-pilot to get rid of PowerPoints. Nowadays, it's more about using external data to help decision making. Previously you couldn't analyze external happenings, now you can look externally and understand possibilities. That's been the biggest changer.
I
Interviewer18:35
How do you feel about it? Is it humbling?
A
Antti Kleemola18:40
It is humbling. Sometimes you feel a bit small. Also coming back to the role of CIO, do we need this role in the future? I don't think so in the long term because skills need to be learned by everyone with the help of automation and low code.
I
Interviewer19:23
You're describing it at corporate and individual level. It challenges all of us. Going to the closing, you mentioned the future. How do you see human-machine interaction in the future?
A
Antti Kleemola19:48
First, it will be an assistant helping you with tasks. Then it will provide new insights and experiences. In the end, it will be a marriage of AI and human in almost every role. You need to find the balance, like in a real relationship. You might even argue with AI, but so far only one winner.
I
Interviewer20:31
That marriage point touched me. I'm a mediator in marriage conflicts as a hobby. So it's going to be a mediator of AI and humans. Well, thanks for the chat. It was eye-opening and interesting. Thank you, Mar.
M
Moderator21:05
Thank you very much for this conversation. Now before we start with the questioning, I have a question for you. Based on this conversation and what you've heard this morning, would you say that you'd rather have more or less AI-supported decision-making in your own work? You can say more or less. This time I'm going to judge you if you say 'I don't know'. Take your time. Meanwhile, I really appreciate the common theme about how it's not about AI taking over, but creating more space for people and a combination of top-down and bottom-up approach. How do you as an organization encourage this culture of collaboration and communication between automation and human decision-making?
A
Antti Kleemola22:06
At the moment, we have the strategy execution where we support different teams building strategic capabilities with AI and external data. We also have open demos within the company to share ideas. It's about trying it out but being careful with inside data. Safety first, but moving forward with tools to test and learn.
M
Moderator23:06
Again, we have great questions from the audience. I'm sometimes hesitant because we're looking at job losses. This is a question you wanted us to ask: Do you personally believe that automation will cause job losses in IT professions in the upcoming years?
A
Antti Kleemola23:27
My personal thoughts are no. If you look at industrial development, humans have been given more ability to have free time or do more. We have always selected to do more. So it will enhance capabilities. The bigger issue is that if AI takes over little tasks, we don't train people to do those tasks, so how do we jump the junior phase? That's a challenge for learning and development.
M
Moderator24:01
I want to put on my devil's advocate hat. In Danny's presentation, he mentioned that in 3 years, efficiency gains from low code might be 4X, not 4% or 40%. If professionals are doing 4X, is there demand for that?
A
Antti Kleemola24:50
That's a great question. If you look at 5G, how many use cases do we have? So if we have more ability to do things faster, how do we utilize that? My Instagram cat videos are much faster.
M
Moderator25:16
A question from the audience: How do you see automation affecting top-level management? Could the role of CIO be replaced by AI and an assistant? For Finnish audience, we have legislation that CEO must be a person. But let's look broader. You already mentioned CIOs. What are your thoughts on the boardroom?
A
Antti Kleemola25:50
It's a valid point. I've had a chat with a person who is already using AI for board work. It's happening. It starts with having an external view because board members don't have company insights. With AI, you can bring external data to every decision point, even live at meetings. That will change board interaction and better equip board members to challenge leaders.
M
Moderator26:31
There was one more question. For the cabin crew, we're going to see humans in planes. There are different roles. What's your tip of the day for people in the audience who are thinking how to move forward with so many different roles in the company?
A
Antti Kleemola27:19
It depends on your daily tasks. Start with what you have and build from there. Use AI to assist yourself to be better in that role. Learn from external data and views to become better at your job. Then build from there. You could go in a completely different direction and create a new career.
M
Moderator28:16
Excellent. Let's look at the results. You submitted your answers for the poll. 85% said more, 5% said less, 8% said I don't know. So only 8% I have to find. Good. I want to say thank you.