CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Bill Gurley
General partner at Benchmark, Benchmark

#651: Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Finding Outliers, Insights from Jeff Bez...

📅 Aug 05, 2026 BlackNova Productions 137 MIN 2 VIEWS 268 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Brought to you by Protekt's REST (https://protekt.com/tim) sleep supplement, Athletic Greens's AG1 (http://athleticgreens.com/tim)  all-in-one nutritional supplement, and Shopify (http://shopify.com/tim)  global commerce platform providing tools to start, grow, market, and manage a retail business.  Bill Gurley (@bgurley (  / bgurley  ) ) has spent more than 20 years as a general partner at Benchmark. Before entering the venture capital business, Bill spent four years on Wall Street as a top-ranked research analyst, including three years at Credit Suisse First Boston. Bill also maintains...

What Bill Gurley said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

Bill Gurley discussed his investment philosophy, emphasizing the importance of understanding industry dynamics through Michael Porter's Competitive Strategy and the asymmetric nature of venture capital returns. He reflected on missing Google as his biggest career mistake, noting the need to bias toward positive outcomes. Gurley shared his approach to building conviction, exemplified by OpenTable and Uber, and highlighted the power of network effects. He critiqued the current valuation reset, advising entrepreneurs to abandon old mental models. Gurley dismissed the metaverse as a future platform, suggested Meta could double its stock by shutting down VR, and praised Amazon's culture of experimentation under Jeff Bezos. He advocated for less tribal thinking and discussed regulatory capture, proposing 'Losing Party Pays' as a reform.

Key takeaways

  1. Missing Google was Gurley's biggest career mistake, driven by conventional red flags, but asymmetric returns mean investors must bias toward positive outcomes.
  2. Gurley predicts Meta's stock would double if it shut down its VR efforts, citing annual spending of $5-10 billion.
  3. Valuation multiples like price-to-revenue are a 'hack proxy'; Twilio fell from 70 times gross margin to 3 in a short window.
  4. Open source is increasingly used defensively, as with Android and Kubernetes, to commoditize suppliers and counter competitors.
  5. Gurley believes self-determined career paths are easier than ever, but 70% of people report career regret.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
120 Valuation Larry Page sought from Benchmark for Google other 11:23
80 Valuation at which Google deal was completed other 11:23
35 Restaurants closed by a top OpenTable salesperson in one month metric 33:57
17% Penetration rate a CFO assumed was the ceiling for OpenTable other 37:26
14 Meta's price-to-earnings multiple metric 1:21:15
23% Meta's growth rate metric 1:21:22
5% Percentage of IPOs that were profitable in 2020-2021 metric 1:22:22
$44 billion Government program to pay doctors for EHR implementation other 2:04:41

Chapters

  1. 0:00Michael Porter and industry analysis
  2. 8:24Sell-side vs buy-side analyst
  3. 11:23The Google miss and asymmetric returns
  4. 33:57Building conviction and network effects
  5. 44:14Benchmark's partnership model
  6. 53:27Book recommendations for entrepreneurs
  7. 1:14:52Valuation reset and financial literacy
  8. 1:24:03Metaverse skepticism
  9. 2:04:38Regulatory capture and political tribalism

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 1:56Shopify is a platform, as I mentioned, designed for anyone to sell anything, anywhere, giving entrepreneurs the resources once reserved for big business. So what does that mean?
  2. 10:40Like was missing Google the result of a flaw in the set of rules that you had at the time or was it just a collateral miss?
  3. 25:04How many analysts were invited to such an event?
  4. 33:10Are there other examples of translating in that way?
  5. 43:36So would the guiding principle in a case like that be the percentage of ownership that you would end up with?
  6. 58:46What else do you think open source could be applied to or might be applied to?
  7. 1:13:06Would you mind just expanding on either or both of those?
  8. 1:25:12You don't want to wait in line at the postal office in your second life, right?
  9. 1:31:03What are some lesser known or undervalued competitive advantages?
  10. 1:45:37But where do you think Shopify fits in or doesn't fit into that?
  11. 1:56:33If you were to give a presentation on cultivating anti-tribalism, probably have a sexier headline to it, but what might that lecture or class contain or blog post?
  12. 2:04:12... out of curiosity, if you had to give or had to, if you were invited to give and agreed to give a TED talk, but you couldn't give it on venture capital, couldn't do investing, couldn't do career advice, what might you give your TED talk on?
Tim Ferriss 0:00 ↗
This episode is brought to you by Protex Rest Supplement, a new take on getting deeper and more restorative sleep. I was introduced to this by former Navy Seal Nick Norris, who has been on this podcast, and as a mutual friend of ours put it to me, it's very annoying that Nick has no physical weaknesses. This is somebody who can climb like a spider. He has incredible abilities as a rock climber. He is incredibly strong and can also run ultramarathons. It's quite something to behold. And this is one of the tools that he uses. So, Protects Rest Supplement helps provide consistent restful sleep without any habit forming ingredients or groggy side effects. Simply add it to your last glass of water before bed and it goes to work. So, I tried this after I mentioned to Nick that I was avoiding melatonin due to next day sluggishness and its possible effects on testicular function. So, I was trying to wean myself off of things like that. This rest cocktail has worked wonders and I've made it part of my sleep toolkit. It is literally on a counter about 20 feet from where I'm recording this right now. Pro tip number one, if you have trouble opening the packets, just use scissors. Don't make it hard. Pro tip number two, mix the packets with water. Do not skip that step and chug it alone. I've learned from experience. Rest has no added sugars, artificial sweeteners, or artificial ingredients. Protect is veteran-owned, and they make all of their products right here in the USA. And right now, Protect is offering you 30% off both flavors of their rest formula. Visit protect.com/tim. That's spelled p r o t kt.com/tim to claim this special offer today. One more time, protect.com/tim. P R O T KT for 30% off. Use code tim at checkout. And just to remind you, protect.com. That's protect with a k.com/tim and code tim.
This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Shopify is one of my favorite companies out there, one of my favorite platforms ever. And let's get into it. Shopify is a platform, as I mentioned, designed for anyone to sell anything, anywhere, giving entrepreneurs the resources once reserved for big business. So what does that mean? That means in no time flat, you can have a great looking online store that brings your ideas, products, and so on to life, and you can have the tools to manage your day-to-day business and drive sales. This is all possible without any coding or design experience whatsoever. Shopify instantly lets you accept all major payment methods. Shopify has thousands of integrations and third-party apps from on demand printing to accounting to advanced chat bots. Anything you can imagine, they probably have a way to plug and play and make it happen. Shopify is what I wish I had had when I was venturing into e-commerce way back in the early 2000s. What they've done is pretty remarkable. I first met the founder, Toby, in 2008 when I became an adviser, and it's been spectacular. I've loved watching Shopify go from roughly 10 to 15 employees at the time to 7,000 plus today, serving customers in 175 countries with total sales on the platform exceeding $400 billion. They power millions of entrepreneurs from their first sale all the way to full scale and you would recognize a lot of large companies that also use them who started small. So get started by building and customizing your online store again with no coding or design experience required. Access powerful tools to help you find customers, drive sales, and manage your day-to-day. Gain knowledge and confidence with extensive resources to help you succeed. And I've actually been involved with some of that way back in the day, which was awesome. The build a business competition and other things. Plus, with 24/7 support, you're never alone. And let's face it, being an entrepreneur can be lonely. But you have support, you have resources, you don't need to feel alone. In this case, more than a store, Shopify grows with you and they never stop innovating, providing more and more tools to make your business better and your life easier. Go to shopify.com/tim to sign up for a $1 per month trial period. It is a great deal for a great service. So, I encourage you to check it out. Take your business to the next level today and learn more by visiting shopify.com/tim. One more time. Shopify.com/tim all lowercase.
Hello boys and girls, ladies and germs. This is Tim Ferriss. Welcome to another episode of the Tim Ferriss Show, where it is my job to deconstruct world-class performers across many, many disciplines. My guest today, I'm so happy to have him, is Bill Gurley. You can find him on Twitter, Bgurly. That's Gur L E Y. Bill has spent more than 20 years as a general partner at Benchmark. Before entering the venture capital business, Bill spent four years on Wall Street as a top-ranked research analyst, including three years at Credit Suisse First Boston. Bill also maintains a blog on the evolution and economics of high technology businesses called Above the Crowd, which you can find at abovethecrowd.com. Over his venture career, he has worked with such companies as GrubHub, Nextdoor, OpenTable, StitchFix, Uber, and Zillow, among many others. Bill has a BS in computer science from the University of Florida and an MBA from the University of Texas. He's also a chartered financial analyst. Bill is a board trustee at the Santa Fe Institute, a research and education center focused on the study and understanding of complex adaptive systems. Bill, nice to see you. Thanks for making that time.
Bill Gurley 5:50 ↗
Thanks for having me.
Tim Ferriss 5:52 ↗
All right. So, I wanted to start with a number of things that I've seen pop up repeatedly in various forms in doing prep for this conversation. And the first I wanted to get your take on and expansion on is Michael Porter's book Competitive Strategy subtitled Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors which you have described I believe as the most efficient short form MBA that one can find. Could you please explain what this book is and if you still hold that opinion why you hold that opinion.
Bill Gurley 6:26 ↗
If you do go to get an MBA like in the first semester or whatever, they usually make you take a corporate strategy course and it's the first book assigned. It's like extremely well-known business book. There's a belief in Silicon Valley that an MBA is worthless and people on it all the time. And yet I would say 80 or 90% of the entrepreneurs I meet would benefit greatly by reading the first three chapters of this book. And it's really just about trying to understand the dynamics of industry. One of the most common mistakes entrepreneurs make is they come up with some kind of technological breakthrough in their own mind, but they don't spend any time analyzing the industry structure or whether the go to market is going to be possible or not. And the book just has a wonderful framework for thinking about the competitive dynamics of an industry and whether or not you'd be able to break in or be successful or maintain success.
Tim Ferriss 7:30 ↗
This actually makes me think more broadly of frameworks and recipes as it were for making decisions. Back in the day, you were a sell-side analyst and I would love for you to define what that is and also just define buy-side versus sell-side. And at that time, at one point at least, the top three analysts covering the PC industry retired. And I'm reading from a transcript on Medium. Dan Benton, David Chorus, if I'm correctly pronouncing that, and Charlie Wolf, and then Charlie became the adviser for Young Analysts, so you got to work with him. Here's the part that's of interest to me. So Dan and David became friends, so they both gave me all of their financial models, and I'm curious what they gave you. What were those models? And do you still use any of those models?
Bill Gurley 8:24 ↗
No, no, no. So they were company specific, but let me let me start with the sell versus buy. So, and the industry's changed over the years, but a sell-side analyst is someone who does research on behalf of an investment bank that is presumably going to make money from trading on their trading desk that someone sends your way because they valued the research. So, you're providing research to help sell stocks. Like, that's how you're going to get paid. The buy side is anyone at a mutual fund who's trading for their own account. If you're a buy-side analyst, you don't publish. Like it doesn't get public because you're using that as proprietary information. The sell-side stuff gets broadcast broadly and usually when someone changes estimates or you hear about a ratings change, that's usually a sell-side analyst that has made a decision to change something and that's what ends up on CNBC.
Tim Ferriss 9:18 ↗
And so a sell-side analyst, this is going to sound very naive, but a sell-side analyst could make a recommendation to buy, right? They could make a recommendation like a strong buy recommendation or a strong sell or somewhere in between the two. That's I think where my Long Island brain was having trouble grasping controversy about that because the bank makes money in multiple ways and they question whether people are biased or not. And then you had the whole Henry Blahett thing from the 2000 period. So it's complicated.
And could you describe I know that you don't at this point use them any longer, but the company specific models. What were the models?
Bill Gurley 9:51 ↗
I was super fortunate my entire career by being in places where windows opened up that I was able to take advantage of. But the situation you described, I landed on Wall Street very fortunately started covering an industry and there's a magazine called Institutional Investor that polls the buy side and ranks the analyst. And the top three analysts in the category I entered all retired within one year and they all became friends partially from my own networking like I was reaching out to them but the models they shared were the models they had built on the companies we all covered so their own particular version of Dell's financials or Compaq or Microsoft and so it just helped me have a better understanding. I could see what they did that kind of thing.
Tim Ferriss 10:40 ↗
Got it. What I'm trying to unpack also through the course of this conversation is just how you think about models and making decisions. I find that interesting. So this is hopping around a little bit, but you did not pursue Google as an investment in 2002 and you had some investing rules of thumb in place. And I suppose what I'm wondering is how you think about rules as an investor in the sense that it seems like perhaps to be consistently great you need rules, but if you have rules, you're inevitably going to miss some great opportunities, but perhaps that's okay. How do you think about rules? Like was missing Google the result of a flaw in the set of rules that you had at the time or was it just a collateral miss?
Bill Gurley 11:23 ↗
Let me work my way back to it because it's clearly the biggest mistake of my career. So, it's something I've thought about a lot. Yeah. So, I think any investor starts with just building bedrock and that comes from reading and there's a ton of books in history you can read. You can go through, you know, all the Buffett letters as an example. You know, you can read Peter Lynch's One Up on Wall Street. There's my good friend Mike Mauboussin has put out some amazing books that are a lot more nuanced about stock prices, that kind of thing. A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton Malkiel. And then you build your bedrock and then you know you're out there and you're looking for an opportunity. So I think public stocks are a little different than venture, but there's some overlap. But you're looking for a reality that you think's going to emerge that's not priced into the stock. So that requires you both to think you know where the world's going and also to know what the expectations are currently embedded in the stock because if you just have the same opinion that's already embedded, you're not going to make any money. There's a great piece by Howard Marks where he talks about you have to be right and contrarian. You know, you can't just be right. You have to be right and contrarian. And that's more difficult. There's a famous saying that I'm sure has been uttered on your podcast before, but strong opinions loosely held. And yes, I think all investors have to work within that framework because things change. There's many many variables, none of them are constant. They're all dynamic. And the minute you set a very hard rule, then you might be setting yourself up for a mistake. And venture I have found is a world where that happens frequently. And so the Google example and it's really important to say that we didn't lay chase like they presented there were 25 employees. Larry and Sergey presented they presented to I'm sure a whole bunch of firms and we didn't lay chase. We should have laid chase but we didn't. At the time Yahoo was at $10 down from like 80. Excite was going bankrupt. So search didn't look that exciting from an external viewpoint. You had two PhD founders who had never been a CEO before and were insistent they were going to be good as a CEO. Normally that's a red flag. You know, two PhD founders. There's just a number of things where you would make a list and say, 'Oops, you know, this probably isn't what you want to do.' Now, I'd like to highlight, and I always do, the two best venture capitalists in the world at the time, John Doerr and Mike Moritz, kind of locked hands and said yes. Right. And so, it'd be erroneous for me to say like, oh, if you were a well-studied venture capitalist, you obviously get to know at that point in time because the two best didn't. And I think it's just the subtlety of the game. There's a great reality in venture that a lot of people talk about now, but you can only lose one time your money. And in a case like Google, you make what? 10,000 times your money. And that asymmetric result means you have to bias towards positive in a situation like that. The odds are just ridiculously different. And so what should have happened is I remember one of my partners looking at Larry and saying, 'What does it take to get this deal done right now?' Because he was a closer he was a closer type. And Larry said 120 pre. And we should have said, 'How about 150?' Like if I could go back, if I could go back, but you can't go back. Deal got done at like 80. So below what Larry had told us, but still obviously historic.
Tim Ferriss 15:06 ↗
So, how did you then revise your rules of thumb or rules moving forward after that, if at all? Like, is a case like that? Granted, it turned into what Google is now, so it's easy to maybe punish yourself for not laying chase, but how did things change after that?
Bill Gurley 15:28 ↗
You know after that the firm did Twitter, Snapchat, Uber, you know, we got some right, you know, after the dead. And around that time, I remember we used to give a book out to our LPs, our limited partners, our investors at every annual meeting. And I think Bruce had just read The Rational Optimist, which is a Matt Ridley book. And he started using a phrase at our partner meeting, what could go right. And because of this asymmetric outcome thing where you could make 10,000 times your money and only lose once on the downside, it was the right frame of mind. So it's very easy to get into a trap in venture where getting no right feels like a win. And it's just not that. I mean, obviously, you can't do every deal, you know, you can't do every investment, you'll go broke. But getting overly jazzed about correctly identifying a negative or a no, it's just not that big a deal. It's not the job. The job is to find the outliers.
Tim Ferriss 16:34 ↗
So my my experience, granted it's limited in some respects, but my experience and perception of Benchmark is you guys are very very selective, more selective than a lot of venture capital firms and a lot of angels who maybe like the poker player who doesn't mind his or her bankroll. Yes, you can only use one extra money, but if you do lose all of your money, the jig is up.
Bill Gurley 16:56 ↗
Yeah, that's the problem with the complete opposite theory. You can't just do every investment you make. We have another challenge, Tim, which is we've for a variety of reasons have chosen a strategy where we don't let our money walk around without our work product and our involvement. And so, right, we go on a board if we make an investment and we usually become the largest shareholder on the board. And as a result, our limitation is our board seats more than the capital. Actually, you can't do 20 of them. Not well.
Tim Ferriss 17:28 ↗
So, you mentioned Howard Marks, Oak Tree Capital, who's been on the podcast twice. Very, very impressive fellow. So, I've seen you mention two investors, and I'm sure you've mentioned more, but two have come up repeatedly in various interviews and so on. Howard Marks and Stan Druckenmiller. Could you please speak to what makes them impressive or interesting to you?
Bill Gurley 17:52 ↗
Sometime in the last four or five years when interest rates wouldn't get away from zero for so long, I told myself I have to learn more about macro because I just know nothing and it's causing all kind of problems in my industry. I had been reading Howard's work for years. One of the things I just love about people like Howard and Buffett does it, but like people who archive their thought process just as part of their own process. But it's quite kind if you're a learner in the field to have someone of that capability that insist upon writing these letters and making them public, which they've done. I started reading Howard's work when I was on the sell side 25 years ago, and I've gotten to know him now, and he's in addition to being very very bright, he's also just a wonderful human and fun to interact with. There aren't many people, if you study financial history, most people, and Buffett included, will tell you macro's impossible. Like, you shouldn't even try. And the two individuals you mentioned are two of the only ones that are known for being successful in macro investing. Howard mostly by being one of the most successful and longest tenured investor in the bond market and Stan taking more kind of single individual bets that are macro in nature. Going back to his success with Soros, he's become kind of famous in the past 12 months for predicting the inflation situation we're in and being very loud about it.
Tim Ferriss 19:25 ↗
Could you if you don't mind just give a definition it could be simple of macro investing for people who may not know that term.
Bill Gurley 19:32 ↗
If you go to business school there's two economic class you can take microeconomics and macroeconomics. Microeconomics is a lot about what's discussed in competitive strategy the Michael Porter book. So it's about the interaction between firms within an industry pricing that kind of thing competitive dynamics. Macro is the study of economies, you know, writ large. And I'm fascinated with complex systems. Our economy is certainly one of those things, as is weather and whatnot, which is why I've gotten involved with the Santa Fe Institute. But they're nearly impossible to predict, and it's where you get into real, real trouble. There might be a variable you're not tracking that has never flipped from 0 to one. And when it does flip from zero to one, all your models, all your planning are out the window because this other thing's different this time. And you can I mean it's why no one can predict the weather more than 5 days in front of us, right? Because there it's just too dynamic and too complex. And most people feel that way about macro.
Tim Ferriss 20:38 ↗
Let me go back in time a little bit revisiting the sell-side analyst side of things. So I believe at one point and I could be getting the terminology wrong but you were an Institutional Investor which you already mentioned Institutional Investor all-American or all America research team.
Bill Gurley 20:55 ↗
Partially because those three people left the field but yes.
Tim Ferriss 20:59 ↗
What allows someone to land on that list.
Bill Gurley 21:03 ↗
So it's a poll of your customers. It's a poll of the buy side. So they literally poll the buy side in each industry and say who was most helpful. I will tell you that and I don't know this probably came from some book I read in business school but when I showed up and this is a framework someone could use but when I showed up on Wall Street in one of the very first weekly meetings they introduced us to the Salesforce. The Salesforce is the individual at your firm responsible for that account for Fidelity, for Wellington, for teachers, you know, of Texas or whatever. And they own the relationship. And somewhere in my youthful wisdom, I decided to ask each salesperson, is there one client that will spend 30 to 45 minutes with me as a new analyst and just tell me what they want? Like, I'm just going to ask them questions. I'm not gonna have anything for them. I just want to know how I can serve them best. And I did like 20 of those interviews before I had started the job. That's a roundabout answer to how do you get on the list? Because I knew what they were looking for at that point in time.
Tim Ferriss 22:13 ↗
What made you a good analyst? And let me explain why I'm asking. I'm asking because one of the advantages that you bring to a board, which you've already discussed, to a board of a startup in the art of company building is your in-depth understanding of how the public markets work. And if a company is aiming for going public and so on, you have knowledge that scares a lot of other folks who might intimidates or befuddles a lot of folks who might otherwise want to be on the board. So, so I'm curious to know what made you a good analyst.
Bill Gurley 22:43 ↗
The thing I learned in those interviews both in terms of the because I would also ask them who does a really good job of this and then if I could I'd try and befriend that person. But what I heard frequently back was and this is a little different from what the world perceives. You know, I don't really need you to make this buy or sell recommendation. Like what I would really get a huge benefit from is if you provide a point of view or a piece of analysis that causes us to think differently about a particular company or industry. Can you go off and do some work that other people haven't thought of that causes us to question that makes us want to talk to you and hear what you're thinking? And so that became really the essence of what I was focused on. And partially from listening to them and partially from mimicking and copying David Chorus who you mentioned, I started doing a weekly fax at the time. And David was doing that before he quit. And so I started doing it too. And interestingly, the Wall Street firm tries to keep your content closed within their customer set. And it's not very loyal to my firm, but it became very obvious to me that a sell-side analyst that was more well-known was more powerful, more impactful. And so I intentionally started expanding the distribution of this weekly pieces as far and wide as I could.
Tim Ferriss 24:16 ↗
How did you expand that distribution?
Bill Gurley 24:19 ↗
I would leverage the salesforce and get them to give me fax numbers. That's where I started. I then started developing industry relationships, which is important because you're covering these companies. You start going to investor days. The buy side is talking to these companies as well. And so I started getting some of them on board. And then probably the most successful hack of my career happened when I was invited to attend Stewart Alsop's Agenda conference which I think was in Phoenix at the time and used to be it was the conference everyone went to. So Gates would be in the front row, Ellison would be there. They would stay for the whole thing. You could walk up and talk to him. Michael Dell was there. Like everyone was there.
Tim Ferriss 25:04 ↗
How many analysts were invited to such an event?
Bill Gurley 25:07 ↗
I don't know. Charlie had been invited and Charlie got me in and I don't even remember Rick Sherlund was probably there. He's a famous Microsoft analyst and you know it's kind of what Code is today but the difference back then way back then was the most famous founder CEOs sat through the whole thing and were available the whole time. Today if one of them speaking they come in the back door they go on stage they leave like they're not around. So it was pretty cool.
Tim Ferriss 25:35 ↗
What was the hack at the conference?
Bill Gurley 25:38 ↗
So this was around the time where the Palm Pilot launched. And so in the lobby of the conference, they were selling them. They weren't free. They were selling a Palm Pilot. And I think it was like $200, $300, I can't remember. But they had put the contact information for every attendee at the conference in the Palm Pilot. And so I ran some quick math. People weren't really doing like cost of customer acquisition back then, but I think it was like 70 cents a name or something like that of the most influential people in the entire tech industry. And so I bought the Palm Pilot. I took it home and I spammed the four or 500 most important people in the tech industry with my weekly newsletter.
Tim Ferriss 26:24 ↗
Did you end up developing close or closer relationships with any of them because of that newsletter?
Bill Gurley 26:32 ↗
I think so. And I think also just a reputation, right? It's actually not that surprising today, right? There's plenty of content influencers all over the place now with Substack and everything. It was just a version of that when there weren't as many people doing it. It started with fax and became email. And today I just mostly tweet. I don't force the distribution out of these other things anymore and I'm not as frequent but yeah I mean it's a common way to build a reputation in a network. I mean you do this with your own life.
Tim Ferriss 27:03 ↗
Yeah I do. I do. So so let's come back to the point you made of helping your clients think differently presenting them with something that helps them to think differently. And I'd like to connect that to a story I'd love you to tell which is about what you learned from a food analyst. And the question that might come before that is how did you meet the food analyst? Like why were you even having a conversation?
Bill Gurley 27:28 ↗
Well, first of all, all the analysts share a floor. So we're all physically proximate. So the person that covers food or telcos or electric utilities, we're all in the same group. And the firm had efforts underway which Charlie Wolf ended up running to try and educate the analyst in a common framework or whatever so that we would all be better at what we do and that kind of thing. And for reasons that I mean I guess birds of a feather flock together for reasons I don't remember. Me and Michael Mauboussin the food analyst started spending a lot of time together and we're still close friends today. He's involved at Santa Fe and I see him frequently and he's done amazing things himself and released several books and he's quite well known. So we started hanging out together. He had just read a bunch of books on a framework called return on invested capital which Stern Stewart had published on McKinsey had a book called Valuation they still do that uses this type of analysis and he was spreading it was the word proselytizing through the analyst group and you know I was a sponge at that point in time so I said sure so I took the framework and ran it on all of my companies it turned out just by happenstance that Dell stood out like a sore thumb with ridiculously high ROIC numbers versus the rest of the industry. Like night and day, like 20 to 1, wasn't even close. And in fact, it was so ridiculous like the first time I showed him, Michael didn't believe it was true. And so we got in the numbers and that kind of thing. And there's probably like 10 super lucky things that happened in my life. But him giving me that framework and then at the exact same time Dell as a company had made two stumbles. They had a options trade that went bad and their laptops had caught on fire. And so the stock was in the ditch. It was trading at six times earnings. And we had discovered, if you will, through this framework that they had a massive competitive advantage because of this return on invested capital thing. And so we went to a strong buy on a broken stock and it went up 100x in the public markets from there. And I became close friends with Michael and Tom Meredith who was CFO at the time. They did all the work. I was just along for the ride, but it was very fortunate. But that helped put Bill Gurley on the map in the same way that maybe eBay really thrust Benchmark into the limelight.
Tim Ferriss 30:09 ↗
Very much so especially with the buy side community.
So Michael I just wanted to double check this. There's a chance I've read a book of his. Did he write a book called Think Twice Harnessing the Power of Counter Intuition or he's written four or five books.
Bill Gurley 30:25 ↗
And he's got great content. He did a Google talk that's on YouTube that I'd highly recommend people watch. It's just fascinating. He's been on a show a couple times. So yeah, he's worth checking out.
Tim Ferriss 30:37 ↗
So in that particular case of proselytizing, did Michael do that? Was he proselytizing and sharing this ROIC idea because he had peers who were non-competitive and it was sort of a deposit in the karmic bank account to hopefully have some reciprocation or is he just a nice guy? It just seems like the environment that would not be true in all environments, right? That someone would take this new insight and share it widely.
Bill Gurley 31:09 ↗
I think he's a natural learner and maybe that's what you would attribute Howard Marks' writing to. You know, you ask people who do that. You know, you ask Buffett, why do you write your letters? Like I think people believe that it helps their mental frameworks if they write stuff down and it challenges them. Even when I write a blog post from the minute I have an idea or a compulsion to say, 'Hey, I'm going to write about this topic.' the process through which you actually put the words to paper and structure the paragraphs, structure the argument, you know, you get smarter. Sometimes you decide, oops, I was wrong. Like, you learn by putting it all together. And Michael's always been that way. He's pretty much built a career out of being someone who studies companies, valuation frameworks, how investors win. I mean, he's gone deep on things like Myers-Briggs on different investors and like, you know, structural, how do you organize an investment team to be most all kinds of stuff like that. It's what fascinates him. And he's a synthesizer. So, I think some of the best non-fiction writers are synthesizers. People say, 'Oh, Michael Porter, competitive strategy, 14 other people had written that stuff before.' Well, he wrote it in a really compact way that's easy to read. That's super helpful. And Michael does that with, you know, he goes out and reads the stuff that's super hard to read, that's overly academic or whatnot, and packages in a way that people can consume.
Tim Ferriss 32:43 ↗
I remember Kevin Kelly said to me once, and I'm paraphrasing, but I really enjoy Kevin Kelly. For people who don't know, look him up kk.org. And he was saying, 'I don't write to express what I think. I write in order to think or discover what I think or clarify what I think.' So the taking of the ROIC from in this case let's just say food and applying it to Dell was this sort of translational move.
So I want to read something from I think this was a Vox interview and can't believe everything you read on the internet but it would make sense. So this is related to OpenTable. So having come out of OpenTable being successful this is quoting you. I was trying to think of other industries where if you put a network on top of it, it would absorb waste and make it more efficient and more usable. And this is within the context of looking for something that would basically appear like Uber, right? So not working within the taxi framework, but with black cars. And I'm just curious where else you've applied that type of translation where you see a case study or a successful proof, right, of a network being laid on top of something and then applying it to something else. Are there other examples of translating in that way?
Bill Gurley 33:57 ↗
Absolutely. And by the way, OpenTable was our impetus to do OpenTable was based upon something like that. So in 1996, Brian Arthur, who was at the Santa Fe Institute back then, published an article in Harvard Business Review called Increasing Returns in the Two Worlds of Business. And it was really the first piece that talked about network effects. Of course, Microsoft was already starting to really take off, but this idea of network effects is that some industry is going to be structured where you get win or take most. And the more successful you are, you get locked in. And Brian talked about things just like the Microsoft UIs like you know how Word works you get comfortable with how it works and then like switching has cost and those kind of things and sharing documents collaboration and you know Zoom obviously has massive network effects. So we started looking for those things because they tend to cause outlier outcomes. So I can remember and this gets into back to your rule stuff when I met with Chuck Templeton the founder of OpenTable and you had three restaurants. You had to believe a lot to get from that point to the global phenomena that it became. And the bet that we talked about making when we said okay let's go do this thing is if we get enough restaurants on this thing then the consumers will come and if the consumers come then people will have to get on you know and that's what happened but you had to believe it because otherwise at the time we were selling PCs to restaurant owners and guess what they didn't have connectivity at the time so we had to partner with someone to get like broadband installed which wasn't easy I mean, it was all bad. So, your normal rule set, we're putting a piece of hardware in a small to medium business that didn't have a lot of money. And we had to provision a broadband. So, you would normally go, don't do that. But I remember my favorite proof point of that network effect, and then I'll get to some of the other models. At one point we were reviewing the Salesforce productivity and our model when we scaled up the business said we had our each salesperson had to close four restaurants a month and at the time we were up to 7.7 so we were feeling pretty good. Things were starting to break our way and in the board meeting they laid out the list of all the salespeople and one of them had done 35 35 restaurants in a month and so I asked the question who is that salesperson and OpenTable started in San Francisco and we played local game we didn't go everywhere at once we built liquidity city by city anyway that salesperson was the one salesperson left in San Francisco where we had 90% penetration. So the 35 were coming out of that last 10 and that individual was basically taking orders and that you know to me was like oh yeah the network effects really working here. And so anyway we look for that some other frameworks SaaS.
Tim Ferriss 37:01 ↗
Could I actually pause for one second before you get to SaaS? So you talked about you have to believe, you mentioned you have to believe a lot of things can go right in order to invest in a business like OpenTable at the time. I would love to know what contributed to your ability to have conviction. I mean how much of it was potential network effects versus total addressable market versus founder versus other stuff?
Bill Gurley 37:26 ↗
I would say in some of these verticals, both OpenTable and Uber, there were years and years and years where everyone thought the TAM was too small. In fact, oh, here's a great story. This was in 99, so this is a 23-year-old story, but I had successfully recruited a CFO from a public company, which you could do back in those glory days, to come into OpenTable. And one day I showed up early for a board meeting and the CFO comes to me and he says, 'Bill, I'm going to quit.' And I said, 'Okay.' I go, 'Why are you going to quit?' And he goes, 'This business will never work.' And I said, 'Okay, why will it never work?' And he says, 'Well, my model says it'll never work.' So I said, 'Show me your model.' So we look at the model, I dive in, and he has frozen penetration in each city at 17%. And he had come from a retail business and I go, 'Why did you freeze it at 17%.' And he said, 'Oh, no one gets more than 17% market share. All the businesses I've worked with because I believed in network effects.' I was like, 'We're going to get 99. We're not stopping at 17. We're going to get 99%. You don't understand how this is going to work.' And that's because I believed in network effects. And he didn't. And when we filed the S1, I really wanted to FedEx.
Tim Ferriss 38:44 ↗
Did he stay or did he leave?
Bill Gurley 38:45 ↗
No, he left. He quit. And I decided not to FedEx in the S1. I figure he had seen it. But by then we were kicking off, you know, massive cash flow each quarter.
Tim Ferriss 38:57 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. So, you were talking about models and I interrupted you. You were going to jump to
Bill Gurley 39:02 ↗
Yeah, I was just going to mention a bunch of them. I mean, so yeah. So I did my first SaaS deal in 99 and that category of companies is still bearing for people who have made tons of money you know and now it's common but at the time it wasn't and you transformed an entire industry open source you know Benchmark's probably had I don't know eight or nine successful open-source companies where you've used that model to attack an industry that's pre-existing but where someone has proprietary technology social networks I mean, we were fortunate to be in Twitter, Snapchat, Instagram, and Matt Kohler, who was a partner at Benchmark, developed kind of a six sense on what a breakout social network looks like. And we've had a few that miss, too. I mean, but the outsized nature of the wins are so high. So, there's like four or five different ones, right, that we look for network effects. And you get good at, you start to understand what works, what doesn't, what leads to success, what doesn't. I mean there's nuances right in open source with that business model which is you're basically packaging support and reliability because someone could just download it for free so how do you charge and this goes back to Michael Porter but if you have a very consolidated industry of big companies they don't pay they just hire the people that know how to use the product so we were in MySQL as an example Google and Yahoo were two of the biggest customers never paid us a penny you need that product to go into the corporate world where people want that kind of handholding and that's where you get paid. So you can't just be oh I love open source because then you get into something where it's serving a much more finite set of customers and then you can't make the model work. So you have to learn the esoteric nuances. But anyway, yeah, there are many veins in venture that get mined over and over and over again if they're big enough.
Tim Ferriss 41:01 ↗
Just a quick thanks to one of our sponsors and we'll be right back to the show. This episode is brought to you by Athletic Greens. I get asked all the time what I would take if I could only take one supplement. The answer is invariably AG1 by Athletic Greens. If you're traveling, if you're just busy, if you're not sure if your meals are where they should be, it covers your bases. With approximately 75 vitamins, minerals, and whole food sourced ingredients, you'll be hard-pressed to find a more nutrient-dense formula on the market. It has a multivitamin, multi-mineral greens complex, probiotics, and prebiotics for gut health and immunity formula, digestive enzymes, and adaptogens. You get the idea. Right now, Athletic Greens is giving my audience a special offer on top of their all-in-one formula, which is a free vitamin D supplement and five free travel packs with your first subscription purchase. Many of us are deficient in vitamin D. I found that true for myself, which is usually produced in our bodies from sun exposure. So, adding a vitamin D supplement to your daily routine is a great option for additional immune support. Athletic Greens is running a special offer just for this month of January. Usually when you try Athletic Greens, they give you a 5-day supply of travel packs plus a year supply of vitamin D3 plus K2. But for January, you get 10 travel packs plus that D3 plus K2. So if you've been thinking about giving AG1 a try, there is no time like today. You can try AG1 by Athletic Greens at athleticgreens.com/tim. One more time, that's athleticgreens.com/tim for a free one-year supply of vitamin D and 10 free travel packs.
This maybe a novice question, but I'm curious. What rules did you guys have around bet sizing? Right. To use a sort of maybe a poker analogy. How do you think about the parameters around the size of the check that you cut just in terms of long-term strategy?
Bill Gurley 43:00 ↗
Benchmark's a very particular firm. We've wandered off course a couple times, but we've always come back to our kind of home base and we've remained committed and focused to very early stage investing and we're pretty much market takers on what that first check size is.
Tim Ferriss 43:18 ↗
What do you mean by that?
Bill Gurley 43:19 ↗
There's a competitive dynamic in the industry that kind of defines what a series A check looks like or you know sometimes series B. And if we thought something was going to be an outsized winner, we wouldn't miss it because market was saying that had to be 15 or 5. It's more like a ticket.
Tim Ferriss 43:36 ↗
15 or 5. You're talking about 15 or 5 million, right? So would the guiding principle in a case like that be the percentage of ownership that you would end up with?
Bill Gurley 43:45 ↗
Something we care way more about than the size of the job. Yeah. And we're not the only one. A lot of venture firms operate that way. So board seat is the constraint and then ownership is the optimization variable. Whatever the math is that follows out of that is what you take.
Tim Ferriss 44:04 ↗
So to be right and contrarian, I'm curious how you cultivate that in partner meetings. What is the format of a successful partner meeting when someone's getting up and saying,
Bill Gurley 44:14 ↗
Well, one thing I would offer as a preamble to at least our process is the founding partners of Benchmark did something that was not hadn't been done before in venture, which is they created an equal partnership. And most business partnerships, and this includes private equity and law firms and real estate firms, there's a hierarchy. And the people that have been there the longest sit at the very top and they take an outsized amount. And some of our founding partners had worked at those firms and felt like the young people did more of the work and therefore you know it wasn't conducive to the right type of internal behavior. And so they created this notion of an equal partnership and even today when we go hire a new partner they come in and they have an equal seat at the table. We just divide the pie which is very different. The reason I think that's important to any discussion about our own processes, I think that has a number of dynamics that kind of emerge from being equal. I think everyone's voice is heard. Whereas if you had a hierarchical firm and the big boss walked in and said blah blah blah like that would carry so much more weight right here and so you feel like your voice is heard when you come in. I think we root for one another. If I'm at a hierarchical firm that's up or out, I'm kind of competing with my peers here because we're going
to divide it equally. I want our new partners to be as successful as I possibly can. And I felt that on the way in and I feel the desire to do it on the way out. Those are just natural emergent properties. So then to come around to your question like how do you be contrarian? How do you have... Well, I mentioned like we have this phrase, what could go right? Like you're just constantly thinking devil's advocate in your mind and devil's advocate on the positive side. Like what would it take for this thing to break out? Like are we making a mistake? Could this... could you imagine this being really, really big and what would have to happen for that to happen? When someone new comes along, you'd be surprised. I have specific memories of new partners coming in and we'll just tell them bring all the companies you meet in like just bring them in and those companies will present and then we talk about them afterwards and that's where the partner meeting.
Yeah. And that's where the learning process gets passed down. I'm sure just like storytelling in a tribe 300 years ago or 400 years ago, right? Like that is that dynamic. And a lot of people say venture is at the end of the day a pattern recognition job, but we also talked about those rules can get you in trouble. So you're trying to create these kind of loose pattern recognition so that you can be helpful and identify things and then you want to pass those along and then you got to constantly check it, you know, because of what we said about how you could miss something. But when that new partner comes in and those are happening, I can remember and I'll leave the names out, but one of the new partners like he brought in company one, no, company two, no, he's very frustrated. And then company 10 he brought in, we were like, try and close that immediately. Like just the complete opposite. And he remembers that too. You starting to learn, you're starting to pick up the collective wisdom of the group. It is a bit of an art form because in that window between when you meet a company and when you might try and close the investment...
Tim Ferriss 47:43 ↗
I bet you the average is under 60 days.
Bill Gurley 47:48 ↗
Oh yeah.
Tim Ferriss 47:49 ↗
Yeah. It might even be closer to 3 weeks. And so it all happened super fast. Was there any feedback that you recall or could just hypothetically imagine you gave that new partner that helped him or her to hone in on the 10th that was then a yes closes immediately?
Bill Gurley 48:09 ↗
A lot of it goes back to what you might pick up in competitive strategy. The two books that I would put for the venture community for the startup community that I would put as next level right on top of competitive strategy are Innovator's Dilemma which does an amazing job of describing why startups can compete with big companies, amazing, and Crossing the Chasm which does a really good job of explaining how a startup should kind of sequence their customer base as they grow and they're both fundamental and you just pick up a number of these different things and I'll give you an example because you start to develop intuition. So a company where we had a quick yes on that I'm on the board of is called HackerOne. So at the time of HackerOne's founding there were four companies that used white hat hackers to make their sites more secure. Microsoft, Google, Facebook and Mozilla. They were the only four. No one else did it. And yet people would say I remember seeing an interview with Sheryl Sandberg where she said someone asked her about privacy and security and she says well the best thing we have is this bug bounty program and she talks about it for a while and the crowd applauds. One of the individuals that worked on the Facebook program came up with a business idea of why don't we build this for the other companies in the universe like every other company in the universe. And when they presented, we didn't even discuss the company. The minute they left, we were like, 'Okay, how are we going to close this?' Everyone had just jumped to yes because it seemed so logical that there's no way this thing's great for these four companies and no one else. And it turned out that those four companies had a group of like 20 or 30 people running the program, which other companies couldn't do. So, it's just natural that if you ran that as a service, people would jump in. That's one that we got to fast.
Tim Ferriss 50:09 ↗
So, you've mentioned a number of your partners, Matt Cohler, who was also very helpful for Uber, seems to be very good at using himself as the guinea pig, very smart guy. What are some of the lessons you've learned from your partners? And that could be anyone, you know, but Fenton, Lasky, Cohler, we don't even necessarily have to mention names. I'm just curious what their superpowers are or what you have adapted learned from them.
Bill Gurley 50:37 ↗
I'd probably go back to some of the founding partners because those were the ones that I learned from. You know, one of them I'd say from Bruce Dunlevie is just have a really big tent. We're in a networking business where you're trying to look under every rock for the next possible deal. And cutting off avenues of information or flow is just a really stupid idea. And so it ties in with what could go right, but just be super open-minded. And so Bruce had been involved with a company that I think was in a software tools space. The name escapes me, but we could look it up. And had developed a lot of friendships down the organizational chart at the company. And one day, one of the engineers from that company comes to him and says, 'I'm working on this marketplace thing called eBay.' And he was from a different industry because he had developed that relationship that came in. Now, it turned out that Bob Kagle was much more excited about eBay than Bruce was. And so, Bruce made that intro because we're equal partnership. That's all cool. And Bob ends up doing the deal and, you know, becomes the number one ranked VC in the land. But it all came from that relationship. So the older I get, like I just take the time, be kind, be available. It pays off. At least in our industry, it pays off big time. So that's one. Another one is just, and this is more specific to venture, but unless you're super lucky, there were two VCs I know that were very fortunate. Cohler and Roelof, it's Koyi Roelof with YouTube and Matt with Instagram where they had a hit two years in. But for the vast majority of venture capitalists, they don't have a liquidity event till year 8 or 9. And so it's easy to doubt yourself. And 3 years in, people like to use the child age analogy. You've got 12 year olds becoming 13 year olds and your whole portfolio is like that with acne all over their face and you can really lose confidence. And so one thing that a lot of my partners did was just it's going to be okay. Get back out there, you're doing fine. You know, that kind of thing, which was way more helpful than you could possibly imagine because the anxiety was like spiking.
Tim Ferriss 52:57 ↗
I want to come back to open source in a minute, but first I'm wondering, you've mentioned a number of books that are sort of broadly applicable to entrepreneurship and I'm sure translate to, as you mentioned, investing in a number of capacities. If you were advising someone or just mentoring someone who wanted to learn how to be a good angel investor or venture capitalist in tech, what might you suggest to them in terms of approach or resources, books, anything?
Bill Gurley 53:27 ↗
I'll give you a few more books and then obviously the world's different today. The content consumption is so different. But there's a book I love called Startup by Kaplan. And...
Tim Ferriss 53:37 ↗
Yeah, I bought that when I first moved to Silicon Valley in '99. That was one of the very first books.
Bill Gurley 53:44 ↗
Yeah, it's just fantastic. And he was in the first portable computers like every one of them failed. Every one of them, but they all raised massive amounts of money. He on his ride home every day had a cassette tape and left like an archive or a diary which makes the book so good because the details are fantastic.
But they had the best venture capitalist. They had the best advisors. They had the best executives. And the executives that were in this was GoCorp I think that were there all went on to do amazing things. But this company failed hard. And...
Tim Ferriss 54:26 ↗
I think it's nice to combine a book of failure with all the books of success. Just I just think it's super educational. Interestingly, if you read that, you should probably also simultaneously watch the General Magic documentary.
Bill Gurley 54:42 ↗
It's so good because they were a competitor with GoCorp. So, it'd be and the same story and the people there all went on to wild success.
Tim Ferriss 54:51 ↗
Yeah. It's like the Jodorowsky's Dune where Giger who went on to create the iconic design for Alien and Aliens. I mean, they're just these failures that contain an all-star team and fail for any number of factors, but General Magic, I just want to second that recommendation. Fantastic. If people want an additional inside look, listen to my interview with Tony Fadell, which goes into great depth on that.
Bill Gurley 55:18 ↗
And on Tony, I'd read his new book, Build.
Tim Ferriss 55:21 ↗
It's solid. Yeah, it's very strong.
Bill Gurley 55:23 ↗
And it's got a lot of frameworks, you know, and you can agree with them or not agree with them, but I do think entrepreneurs benefit from frameworks because just running by the seat of your pants like you need a framework for having weekly meetings. You need a framework for executive recruiting, you need a framework for development of your team. And there are a lot of good ones. There's probably 20 good ones of each of those, but the worst thing you can possibly do is have no framework and just kind of seat to your pants. And by the way, that's the most frequent solution. The absolutely no framework. I would mention Shoe Dog. I don't know if the reality had as many near-death experiences as the book makes it sound like, but it's good to see the tenacity you need. This is the Phil Knight Nike book, but like the tenacity you need to make it is high.
Tim Ferriss 56:21 ↗
Yeah.
Bill Gurley 56:21 ↗
And so if you're starting a company because you think it's going to be a good lifestyle, holy shit you're in for a rude awakening.
Tim Ferriss 56:30 ↗
Yeah. So the same writer who penned Shoe Dog in reality is the same person who did Open, the autobiography of Agassi, which is another spectacular...
Bill Gurley 56:40 ↗
And apparently the new Harry book that I...
Tim Ferriss 56:43 ↗
Oh, no kidding. All right. That's a selling point because I think it's Moehringer is spectacular.
Bill Gurley 56:50 ↗
Okay. So, Shoe Dog. So, so far these are company building books which is totally valid for kind of high-tech macro if there is such a thing. I think Ridley's two books, The Rational Optimist and How Innovation Works are just fantastic and spectacular. They're much higher level, but they're really, really good.
Tim Ferriss 57:09 ↗
What makes them good?
Bill Gurley 57:11 ↗
The first book Ridley has this point of view that I think is very hard to dispute that the vast majority of wealth creation and increase of standard of living for humans on the planet come from two things commerce and what he calls ideas having sex. So if you think about, you know, if someone comes up with a new farming technique the marginal cost of that is zero. And if you pass it along to someone, their productivity improves. And so, you know, it's super powerful in my mind, especially when I think about people. A lot of people on the planet want to improve standard of living with a lot of people. And I look at what Deng Xiaoping did in China and say, I don't know that any other human in the history of the world has unlocked as much standard of living increase as this one human by bringing capitalism to China. And anyway, it's something that really speaks to me.
Tim Ferriss 58:08 ↗
Yeah. Much smaller scale, but people should study Lee Kuan Yew. Okay. And this whole Singapore, well, just the whole Singapore story. I mean, basically taking it from a swamp to what it is today is just incredible. So, but I agree on the Deng Xiaoping piece.
Bill Gurley 58:22 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. So, then on other content, like the world's way different now, right, with podcasts and blogs and Twitter and all these kind of things. So no matter what you're doing, but especially if you want to do venture attack, like there's lots of people that talk their book, that talk their game, like follow, listen, read, consume, consume, read, read, read, read. I don't think you can get too much information.
Tim Ferriss 58:46 ↗
Let's segue to open source. What else do you think open source might be able to solve? And I've had some reasonably direct experience with watching, I suppose, one example of what you described, which is Automattic. And very good friend Matt Mullenweg. I'm an adviser to Automattic. And for those who don't know, Matt, who's been on the show multiple times, was a lead developer of WordPress, very familiar with open-source, and then has built a sort of services and enterprise-grade secure stable solution for many different businesses and people in the form of Automattic. So, I'm deeply interested in this and I know you are as well. You're a big fan of open source. What else do you think open source could be applied to or might be applied to?
Bill Gurley 59:31 ↗
First of all, I think people are relatively familiar with the big individual software projects. Linux being the most well-known. It's over 20 years old now. It's clearly the most used operating system in the world. And what people might not know about it is a lot of scientists believe it's the most secure. And that's kind of counterintuitive. Oh, all the code's public. How could it be the most secure? But it gets beat up the most, you know, because it's used the most.
There's a great piece of writing, an incredible piece of writing called The Cathedral and the Bazaar that was the first kind of magnum opus on why this open-source thing might work. And another thing people don't get is the cathedral and the bazaar compared are you trying to build up like the gaudy church or a bazaar which is super flat and wide and obviously built by lots of people and the thing is open source is way better at complex problems than simple problems and it's the very complex problems that would be hard for a single company to do. And so if you're building an operating system, it might have all kind of edges on how it integrates with other systems, you know, different drivers you might need and the world is able to build that whereas an individual company it would be very difficult. And so we started to see that in MySQL and there have been others like MongoDB and we're in one called Elastic and like there's been a lot of successful companies around single software frameworks. Something started happening about 10 to 15 years ago which is people started using open source in more complex ways and in sometimes using it defensively rather than offensively. So the most well-known is probably Android. Apple had come out with this smartphone. You could only get it on AT&T. It scared the shit out of everybody, not just Google, but it scared the shit out of all the other telcos. It scared the shit out of all the other handset manufacturers. And so Google did this clever thing. They said, 'Oh, we're going to create a competitor, but it's going to be open source, so you can trust us.' Now, there's different versions of how open something is. And Android's not very open, but at the time, compared to the threat of Apple, it seemed like a much better trade. And so, they got the world behind them on this thing, and it took off. Since then, that model's been repeated in some esoteric ways. Facebook has something called the Open Compute Project and if you want your hardware to go into the Facebook data server room, it has to be compatible with their open-source framework. And what that means is no one can have an IP claim against Facebook because you've basically sworn off your IP. So they're commoditizing the stuff they're going to purchase. You know, since then AT&T and China Mobile have worked with the Linux Foundation to do the same thing for the wireless and wireline equipment stack. So, they're defining open standards for their next-gen products. And if you're a supplier that wants to sell to them, you have to agree to those standards. And once again, you're out of the IP game so they don't get held up. It's very clever stuff.
Tim Ferriss 1:02:58 ↗
Would you mind just expanding on that a little bit? Well, let's go to the Facebook one because it's more understandable.
Bill Gurley 1:03:03 ↗
It's called the Open Compute Foundation. It's managed by the Linux Foundation acts as a steward much in the way that the crypto world thinks a DAO manages this loose federation. The Linux Foundation does that. Linux has been a DAO for 25 years. It's super interesting. And so that group, they're like a nonprofit overseer of the project. Break ties. They do patent defense which I think is super interesting. So they pull patents and no one sues within the open source project but if someone were to come attack it you know you'd go out after them. So anyway Facebook has all these equipment in their data center networking equipment storage equipment computers software. So they just created this thing called the Open Compute Foundation that defines open standards for how all these products work. And so if you want to be on their purchasing list, you say, 'Yes, we are compatible with this open standard.' And it once again, it basically commoditizes that equipment.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:05 ↗
So it just gives Facebook more leverage with...
Bill Gurley 1:04:08 ↗
A broader spectrum of suppliers.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:10 ↗
Every one of these things has a website and you can go see. And so now, you know, Amazon and Google, they're all part of Open Compute.
Bill Gurley 1:04:18 ↗
I got it. So you can't get, if I'm understanding you correctly, tell me if I'm missing something. They're trying to create conditions such that they wouldn't end up back in the day when I moved to Silicon Valley, I worked in storage area networking and EMC at the time was pretty famous for kind of being a black box. Like if anything broke, if anything went wrong, like you needed EMC to fix it or upgrade it.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:40 ↗
And so to avoid being held hostage or losing leverage with suppliers...
Bill Gurley 1:04:46 ↗
Facebook made this move. Is that a fair description?
Tim Ferriss 1:04:48 ↗
Absolutely. And then another high-profile one, Google was very worried about Amazon.
Bill Gurley 1:04:53 ↗
That's genius. I mean, it's very smart.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:55 ↗
Oh, it's super clever. Google was very afraid of Amazon running away with the cloud services business in AWS. And so, they had a piece of technology called Kubernetes. And this was right around when Docker and containerization took off. And Kubernetes was an orchestration layer for containers.
Bill Gurley 1:05:13 ↗
What a bizarre name. What was it? Kubernetes sounds like an Italian pasta.
Tim Ferriss 1:05:18 ↗
Well, here's the thing, though. They decided that it was in their best interest to take this technology and gift it to an open-source consortium. They got the Linux Foundation to manage it. And they went out and recruited IBM and HP and all these other vendors to say, 'Oh, yeah, we'll support Kubernetes.' Because everyone wanted to make sure that people weren't locked in to Amazon. And eventually it got so successful that Amazon had to announce support for Kubernetes. And now if you need to move a workload from Google to Amazon, there's a common framework for which to do that. And so you're less locked in.
Bill Gurley 1:05:59 ↗
So this seems like it's become at least based on the examples you gave like a very refined reliable counter punch that Google uses.
Tim Ferriss 1:06:09 ↗
I call it defensive corporate strategy.
Bill Gurley 1:06:12 ↗
Yeah. Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 1:06:13 ↗
I'll give you two more. Very recently, well, there's always been Open Street Maps. And that's kind of interesting because it's data rather than, you know, but the Open Street Maps team was very kind of non-commercial. So, they didn't like when Apple and Google's obviously running away with the maps business. So, if you just look this up, like within the past 4 weeks, there's a new open-source map group that's going to live on top of Open Street Maps that has Facebook and Microsoft and the other parties that don't want Google to run away with it. And quite frankly, I think that's pretty cool if you talk to actually someone you should have on if I think that would be really cool is Jim Zemlin, who's run the Linux Foundation for this whole time. Oh, because good idea.
Bill Gurley 1:06:58 ↗
He's a huge believer, and this kind of ties into Matt Ridley's ideas having sex, that not having IP is actually great for the world because it just creates constraints for people being able to take advantage of things. And so mapping super interesting to me because it's data oriented. There's something called RISC-V, which is an open-source processor, believe it or not, that has a lot of momentum. Now you'll see people on the earnings calls for ARM they'll start is this a competitor is this going to be a problem because it's completely free and China is a big backer of open source and you could understand why because the west has accused them of IP theft so this is a world where you can't be accused.
Tim Ferriss 1:07:43 ↗
Safe space, it's a safe space.
Bill Gurley 1:07:45 ↗
They're investing like crazy but I wonder what's possible. I'll give you some kind of grander ideas. First of all, I think autonomous vehicles should definitely be open source. I think everyone benefits. Safety's higher. Communication layers are better. The idea that you would use artificial intelligence to figure out whether a light is red, yellow or green is really stupid because it's a state machine. It is in one of those three states and that could be communicated into the software. Like you don't need to infer that. That's a known thing. But you need a common language and your test suites could all be used by everyone. Academia could be working on the same thing that the corporations are. Safety's higher, easier for government to get involved if it's a single standard. And I wonder about other things like the NIH gives out $40 billion a year and many of these projects end up as research that leads to a drug that leads to having a 17-year patent life and get sold at 300 grand a year or whatever. Like why wouldn't we say if you take NIH dollars, your research is open source? Why do we use government dollars to fund stuff that becomes proprietary? It didn't make any sense to me.
Tim Ferriss 1:08:59 ↗
Yeah, this is something that you and I can have a conversation about separately. Yeah, this is...
Bill Gurley 1:09:06 ↗
I look at the state of nuclear energy where the costs are high because of regulation, not because of the actual product and I wonder what if the globe had a standard for, you know, fission-based nuclear reactor like wouldn't we get to lower price points? Wouldn't we get to safer products? Like wouldn't they get more evolved? It seems possible to me.
Tim Ferriss 1:09:28 ↗
Are there any companies that are on a short list of companies you would love to see exist or types of companies like anything that's just kind of a bee in your bonnet or has been for any period of time?
Bill Gurley 1:09:39 ↗
Yeah, I give you a few. So, one, and this one's kind of well known in the venture industry, but everybody talks about something called the interest graph, and they wonder why there isn't an internet website that kind of links everyone that is tied to a specific interest. And there are companies that people talk about as being close, like Pinterest or Quora or Twitter, but I don't think any of them have really pulled it off.
Tim Ferriss 1:10:08 ↗
Would Reddit fall anywhere? Especially with some of the subreddits, they're getting close, you know, and people have talked about kind of like a holy grail, but like there's not anyone that's I think just...
Bill Gurley 1:10:21 ↗
Really, really nailed it. And if you did, you would have this combination of really cool unlock for people because if you were into quilting, you'd be immediately connected with everyone else, you know, that's on your level and you could imagine that kind of thing. But then the advertising performance would just be off the charts because you've kind of bucketed everyone into these places. I actually think Twitter still has a huge opportunity on this front, but it'd have to build a top-down version of Twitter rather than the speed thing, which is super hard for a lot of people.
Tim Ferriss 1:10:55 ↗
What do you mean by top down?
Bill Gurley 1:10:57 ↗
I think you could take all the information that's flowing in Twitter and all of the influencers that are in there and build an algorithm that would score who's smart about certain things. Let's make it super simple to convey the point. If you look at stocks, so they already have a UI unique individual identifier for each stock with the dollar symbol thing. But right now, the only way you can kind of you could do a search, but there's a ton of noise. What if you had a page where for each stock you had a list of the top stories of the day and that could be pulled out of the Twitter feed by knowing which people are the axes on that individual stock which you could infer simply with the data that's already in there. You can imagine that for sports teams. So, I could have Twitter sports that is a top-down version that's using the information in the feed, but then presents it more like a standard newspaper would, if you understand what I'm getting at. That one's one. I'm highly interested in people feel free to reach out in any variation or new take on LinkedIn. I just think it kind of stopped, you know, and it stopped 10 years ago. One idea that...
Tim Ferriss 1:12:14 ↗
Aren't you semi-retired, Bill? Aren't you kind of semi-retired?
Bill Gurley 1:12:19 ↗
People will probably steal.
Tim Ferriss 1:12:20 ↗
Your version of retirement is super intense.
Bill Gurley 1:12:22 ↗
Yeah, people may steal this and that's okay, but I hope they reach out to me. It feels to me like you could have paid rank for people, you know.
Tim Ferriss 1:12:32 ↗
Okay.
Bill Gurley 1:12:32 ↗
And so I don't think the skill thing on LinkedIn works because it's public. So you get all this performance art where people are just, you know, being nice. But what if you had people maybe privately opining on who they think is smartest on particular topics? You could develop a really cool product that would be unique to each individual because what you see, Tim, would be different than what I see because it starts by who you trust and then what you see is... Anyway, I think that's a really interesting concept.
Tim Ferriss 1:13:06 ↗
Yeah. Yeah, I wonder, you know, if Twitter could actually use the literal page rank by correlating verified accounts, although it's become kind of unusable for me because it was kind of pay-for-play for a while, so it's difficult to filter now. But if people have websites that are their personal websites, just looking at the page rank, it seems like from a computing side, pretty easy to do. One thing Twitter could do that would just be super industry is create a leaderboard for every topic under the sun and then the things you could build once you had that would be super compelling. Yeah. Let's talk about Twitter specifically a tweet thread and feel free to amend this, but I'd love to have you walk me through this particular thread. This is from spring of 2022, so not that long ago. And here it goes. So there are four points under an intro, and I'll just read it if you don't mind. So, an entire generation of entrepreneurs and tech investors built their entire perspectives on valuation during the second half of a 13-year amazing bull market run. The quote unquote unlearning process could be painful, surprising, and unsettling to many. I anticipate denial. Number one, and maybe we could just do these point by point. Well, we don't have to. I'll do two at a time. Number one, previous all-time highs are completely irrelevant. It's not quote unquote cheap because it is down 70%. Forget those prices happened. Yeah, I got I screwed myself on that first one. Second one, and valuation multiples are always a hack proxy, dangerous to use. If you insist 10x should be considered amazing and an upper limit over that, silly. So, let's sit on those two for a second. Would you mind just expanding on either or both of those?
Bill Gurley 1:14:52 ↗
There's an unfortunate reality in the venture world that really became very crystal clear to me through a conversation with Howard Marks actually, but it's structurally set up. You know, people talk about boom bust and cycles, but this is set up more like a sawtooth. So risk on happens very slowly almost like the roller coaster nickn... but when it crashes if it's interesting to you I explain or do my best job of explaining why it's structured this way when it crashes it happens all at once so it's more like a saw tooth than a sine wave and it just crashes and it's painful and that just happened and it happens it looks like it happens every 7 to 15 years, you know, and I thought this was going to happen six years ago. I even wrote some things. I was way early. It took six more years and it got ridiculously crazy. But it took so long from '09, which was the last kind of and '09 wasn't as hard a reset as '01, but from '09 to 2013, because so many entrepreneurs are young, you know, you had people grow up that had never seen a reset. And...
Tim Ferriss 1:16:10 ↗
Yeah.
Bill Gurley 1:16:11 ↗
Risk on is a lot like the boiled frog. Like you don't know what's happening.
Tim Ferriss 1:16:16 ↗
Would you mind just quickly defining risk on for people listening? What do you mean by that?
Bill Gurley 1:16:20 ↗
So the community as a whole takes on more risk gradually without realizing they're doing it. And their mental models and their frameworks adjust daily to what's happening. And so their thought about how the world works is really a window of 5 years or maybe 3 years, not 30 years. For many of them, they don't have the 30-year perspective. And when the going gets good, greed takes over and you weigh the data points that feel good to you and are going to make you confirmation bias.

123 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Gurley, B. (2026, August 5). #651: Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Finding Outliers, Insights from Jeff Bez... [Interview transcript]. BlackNova Productions. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/1179484/

MLA

Bill Gurley. "#651: Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Finding Outliers, Insights from Jeff Bez...." BlackNova Productions, 5 Aug. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/1179484/.

BibTeX
@misc{gurley2026_1179484,
  author       = {Bill Gurley},
  title        = {#651: Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Finding Outliers, Insights from Jeff Bez...},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, BlackNova Productions. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {aug},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/1179484/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}