You're watching Tasty Live. It's not TP, it's TT, Trading Trends. And we have a great guest today, someone who I admire greatly, which is one of the great benefits of having this platform. We're going to bring on Dr. Ed Yardeni, president and chief investment strategist of Yardeni Research. And Ed, before we get into markets, I want to just say a few things. I've used your website for years and years, the charts, the historical data. If I'm getting on TV, if I'm preparing something here for the network, if I'm arguing with my friends about what's going on in the economy, I basically turn to your website. It's one of the first places I go consistently. It's a great public resource. So, for everyone in the retail trading world, thank you so much for making yourself so accessible and providing a platform for everyone.
So, you coined the term bond vigilantes in 1983. I think that's an appropriate place to start because we've seen the 10-year yield, the 30-year blowout right now. But you've been making a really compelling argument that I've been referencing around here in the past few days that these yields look more like a repricing of the neutral interest rate and less of a start of a sovereign debt crisis. Why are bond yields going up and it's not a bad thing?
Well, I think that the economy has turned out to be stronger than everyone expected. We've been arguing that the economy is resilient, but it's been even stronger than we had been thinking. And it makes sense. The consumer's been hanging in there very well. A lot of it has to do with retiring baby boomers. The baby boomers collectively have a hundred trillion dollars in net worth. So they're increasingly kind of spending their net worth and they're not going to have disposable income. Their savings are going to go negative and they don't really pay much attention to what's going on in the labor market. They're retired. And in addition, when interest rates go up, they benefit from that. And then of course capital spending, that's become less interest rate sensitive as well because more of it is being done by the AI hyperscalers and looks like they're in hyperspace when it comes to the amount of capital spending that they are doing and that they intend to do. And then oh, let's not forget that the federal deficit is, well, the Treasury over the past 12 months has raised over $2 trillion in marketable securities. So you put that all together and we've got a lot of demand for financial capital to finance the government deficit, to finance capital spending. We got a consumer that's very resilient and doesn't that imply that the economy can operate at higher interest rates, should operate at higher interest rates because the supply and demand for credit has certainly suggested that rates should be in fact higher. So this expression that interest rates are going to be higher for longer kind of irks me because it's not higher for longer, it's normal for longer. The abnormal level of rates was between the great financial crisis and the great virus crisis. So at this point, that's kind of what my interpretation of what's going on in the bond market. But just this morning we put out a research piece arguing that kind of like these psychological spectrums. Where are you in the spectrum? There's a spectrum of scenarios for what's driving the bond yield up and on one end is the economy's better than expected. Real rates are higher as a result. And the Fed has acknowledged that by at the beginning of the year, the Fed was saying, 'Hey, you know, we're still restrictive,' implying that the neutral rate was lower. And now, just recently, Fed Chair Powell said, 'We're taking away just a dose of accommodation,' which means that they need to be more restrictive. On the other end is a debt crisis, but if you like, we can discuss the spectrum and everything in between, the good and the ugly.
Well, I do want to get there, though, and I want to talk about the framework first before we get to there because you've mentioned a lot over the years that there's a relationship between the 10-year Treasury yield and nominal GDP growth. Now, nominal GDP growth is north of 6% right now, correct? So, Treasury is sitting near 5.2, 5.3. That's broadly consistent with their historical relationship. Why is nominal GDP growth such an important anchor for those longer-term Treasury yields?
It just historically seems to explain a lot in terms of the interaction of the bond market with the economy. And that goes back to, I kind of call it the bond vigilante model. Back in the 1970s, the bond yield was consistently below the growth rate on a year-over-year basis of nominal GDP. Bond investors were just clueless. They didn't realize just how bearish the inflation situation was. There were a couple of economists at the time that nailed it and that was Henry Kaufman over at Salomon Brothers and Al Wojnilower over at First Boston. And finally in the late 70s, I think the bond folks finally understood what they were saying. Of course, just at the peak of yields when you actually should have been a buyer of bonds, but they got so traumatized by the 70s experience and of course, Fed Chair Paul Volcker put an end to that inflation wave with tightening monetary policy dramatically in the late 1970s. So in the 1980s, the bond investors finally got it and that's when I coined the phrase bond vigilante in 1982. I said that the bond vigilantes will take law and order into their own hands in the credit markets, in the economy, if fiscal and monetary policy doesn't behave itself. And sure enough, we saw the bond yield consistently trade above nominal GDP. And every time nominal GDP growth picked up, guess what? The bond yield went up, the bond vigilantes acted and slowed it down. And then the 1990s, Bill Clinton was warned about the bond vigilantes and he behaved himself. Fiscal policy behaved. By the end of the decade, we actually ran a surplus. So the bond vigilantes didn't have to be vigilant.
No, they didn't. So, you know, most of this year you've been pointing out that this rise in Treasury yields has come through the real yields. Inflation expectations have been largely subdued here. It feels like a different message than the bond market losing confidence in the country's fiscal or monetary inflation policy, so to speak. So what are the bond vigilantes actually protesting here today if they're protesting anything at all?
France. I think if you want to look at one area where there's, what part of the world where the bond vigilantes are definitely creating a debt crisis is in France. France's fiscal policies really are out of control. Their politics is out of control. So I think France reminds me of kind of what happened with Greece in 2010, that the 10-year yield in Greece went up to 40% during their debt crisis and then they got the message, the politicians got the message, they made things right and bond yields came down dramatically in Greece. Looks like the bond vigilantes are trying to get the same message across in France. Arguably the bond vigilantes have been somewhat active in Japan. And that kind of is another scenario on the spectrum. It's not a happy one. It's the unwinding of the carry trade and the Japanese have been raising their interest rates and all this cheap financing that might have been used to buy bonds in other parts of the world, looks like that's coming to an end. So I think that explains the global synchronized increase in yields. So it's a very mixed picture out there. I think the US is still to a large extent reflecting just the strength of the economy, real rates going up because of the strength of the economy. France, I think we got a debt crisis. Japan, I think maybe seeing an unwinding of the carry trade which explains why bond yields around the world are going up in sync.