When you remove cyber offensive capabilities, you also remove cyber defensive capabilities. The state of the world today is that we have a few hundred safety researchers within closed labs that understand how these things work, and despite their best intentions, it is impossible to cover the long tail of unintended consequences that these systems might have. A very powerful closed model went and like hacked into another company, and the only way that company could remediate itself was by using open models to protect itself. That's the empirical evidence of the world that we're in. Linus's law: with enough eyeballs, all bugs become shallow. And I have the belief that with enough eyeballs, most security and safety vulnerabilities become shallow as well.
Today we're joined by Misha Laskin, the co-founder and CEO of Reflection AI. Reflection provides open-weight models to power the future of intelligence. Misha previously was a researcher at Google DeepMind and received his PhD in physics. Welcome to No Priors. Great to have you here today.
Yeah, it's great to be here. Thanks for having me.
Could you give us an update of where things are at? I mean, obviously you guys have been pioneering really interesting work in open weights and open source models, particularly with a US bent. Can you talk a bit about what you've been up to and what you guys have been building?
Yeah. So for the last 12 months, we set the mission of the company to build frontier open intelligence and make it widely accessible. And effectively, it's been a sprint to set up a lab that is capable of doing such things. It kind of feels like maybe there's a Reid Hoffman quote that you know, you're assembling a plane as you're flying it. And that's, you know, that's been the case. We were maybe around 30 people about a year ago. But it does take on the order of a hundred plus, so you know, a couple hundred researchers and engineers to build one of these things, like a true rocket ship project. And we're now at around 300 people and, you know, assembled all the teams on pre-training, mid-training, reinforcement learning, scaled up our, you know, trained our first models end to end, and just, you know, released a model called Beam, which is Reflection's first open model.
What has been the most challenging part of that? Because when people talk about scale or scaling up models or starting to build these models out, one issue is compute and procuring enough, particularly a training cluster that's cohesive in terms of the ability to use it. Second is talent, and obviously there's been these huge sort of talent wars in terms of how much people pay for researchers, etc. Third is sort of scale of data. Like, which of those has been the most limiting or the most challenging?
What's been interesting about this experience is that I got asked this question at an all-hands at the company. What's been the hardest thing in the last year? And the reality is everything is extremely hard. Everything has been hard.
And it's also sometimes, you know, people might ask like, well, what's the thing that, you know, really made your models work better than others or something like this. And again, the answer is like everything, right? You actually have to get 30 things right. And that's why everything is hard, because you have to get 30 things right. You have to get the talent. You have to retain the talent. You have to have a strong mission and culture that keeps the talent, you know, working together and rowing in the same boat. You have to get the data. You have to get the compute. You have to build the infrastructure to ensure that the compute is actually usable. And these are a lot of these things when you're at an existing big lab, there have been years of build-out that enabled them to have this kind of stable surface. So I was at DeepMind before this, and a lot of the tools that we just take for granted, or I took for granted as a researcher because they just worked, you have to build. So I would say, yeah, everything has been hard, but also very rewarding that, you know, it's that you can do it.
Can you talk a little bit, you said about a year ago you guys really committed to do this. Can you talk about the sort of shift in ambition and commitment and what drove that?
When we started the company about two and a half years ago, our bet was so, maybe I'll contextualize it where the world was then. My co-founder Ioannis and I had been working on the first series of Gemini models. We were working on the reinforcement learning team. Ioannis was leading it, and we had just shipped the Gemini 1, then 1.5 model, and that was, you know, that early era. It was like similar to the first ChatGPT experience, which was primarily a chat experience. There was no coding really, no nothing agentic. These models were just good at chat, and they were primarily, you know, 95% of the compute spent was spent on pre-training. So they're primarily pre-trained models. We are reinforcement learning researchers. That's been our lineage. Ioannis, my co-founder, was one of the founding engineers at DeepMind and was a key contributor to all the big RL projects that came out of that lab, including AlphaGo. And our bet was because we were working on the RL team and we saw, you know, RL for aligning chat models works. You know, there's only so much you can align them, right? Well, now there's a lot more, you know, now they're agents, but at the time they're just chat. So RL was working, and we just thought that, well, if you take that and apply it to domains like mathematics, coding, that you could make these systems agentic. That was the big bet, and we thought that you could do this as an independent lab much more capital efficiently because we started seeing open-source, open models materialize. There was a small model from Mistral at the time. Llama 2 had just released, and we saw Llama 3 coming. And we...
Yeah. Yeah. This was a while back, I guess, two years ago.
And we thought that there would be a great open model base that someone would build that we could build on and do our research and scale reinforcement learning. And over that first year of the company, what ended up happening was that one, reinforcement learning started working faster than we thought it would. Both within, you know, our experiments, but also within industry, o1 came out at that time. We actually thought it would take longer just because the journey from ImageNet in 2012 to RL systems that worked at scale was about four years. So we thought maybe something similar, but every year moves faster than my prediction the previous year. And so about a year into the company, we got to the point where actually, like, all the good open models are coming from China. There were not really good, you know, Western open models, and we needed one as a base for kind of the technology that we were building, and decided for a number of reasons that the most impactful thing we could do given the state of play was to just build open models ourselves end to end and, you know, combine the RL bet together with just building models end to end. There were, you know, I guess there were enterprise reasons, there were geopolitical reasons happening, but also there was the research reason that it turned out you actually do need to pre-train your model in order to make reinforcement learning work very well at scale. So you actually kind of do need to do that. The things are just so tightly coupled that you do need to do both.
The conventional wisdom has been that pre-training at the scale of the frontier is impossibly expensive, or at least extraordinarily so. Clearly there's been a huge shift of compute toward post-training. Feel free not to answer this and we can just cut it, but like, what do you, how did you think about just the resources needed or the ratio, or did you have like design principles around the model that made this feel tenable to you at the beginning, or you just say we need to do this, we'll go resource it?
Well, the nice thing about being an open model lab is that you can also talk about things openly. So you do need a lot of resources to build something meaningful. You don't need the same amount of resources. Once you get to the frontier and you're really, really at the frontier of intelligence, then you need the same amount of resources as any other frontier lab because you can kind of think about research as exploration of new ideas versus execution of known ideas. Part of why getting great talent in matters a lot is because you get to cut down on exploration and then focus on execution of the things that work. So all this is to say is that if you are, you know, catching up to the frontier, you can do it a lot more capital efficiently.
How much capital do you think it would take to catch up to the frontier?
Well, I think that it depends. The frontier keeps moving. So each year it's actually more capital. So, and I'll get back to the question on the resourcing between, let's say, pre-training and post-training. I would say that a year ago or maybe 18 months ago it would have been, and I say order meaning that, you know, order of 100 million, so hundreds of millions of dollars. I think that now, or let's say even six months ago, is probably order billion, so billions of dollars, single-digit billions. Going into next year, I think order 10. You know, you can kind of think about it as for every generation of model, there's a 4x multiplier in compute roughly. And one heuristic that I have is like when, let's say, like we talk about like the chips that are currently considered, you know, the ones that, you know, a frontier chip, and maybe a couple years ago it was an H100, and maybe it was 100,000 H100s, then, you know, GPT-5, right, was trained, and that was just a big run, right, on 100,000 Blackwells, which is roughly a 4x multiplier on an H100. Now the next generation is going to be around 100,000 Vera Rubins, I believe. So that kind of gives you the scale, and it moves from hundreds of millions to billions to tens of billions.
Yeah, it seems like at some point that has to asymptote then, because ultimately relative to revenue scale of these companies, even potential revenue scale, you start to tap out in terms of the ability to invest against what you're actually going to produce from an economic value perspective.
So do you think we're heading into that asymptote in terms of model size or at least training cluster size?
Absolutely. I think that in terms of, you know, there's only so much capex that you can do, right? And frontier labs are now putting hundreds of billions of dollars into it. So, will they be putting trillions of dollars, you know, in the next year or two? I, you know, it's probably, you know, unlikely. But there are a couple of things that are happening. One is that the use of that compute is becoming a lot more efficient because the models are themselves becoming tools that help build themselves. So I think that when it was just, you know, human researchers doing the work, there's probably a 7x improvement each year, and you can actually track these things very technically. And in pre-training, you do it by, you know, you have your pre-training loss, and then you measure, you know, your compute efficiency gains against, you know, you made some changes, now you have a new pre-training loss, and it should be that you got to the same point with less compute. And so when you say 7x, it's actually a very concrete thing that you're studying. And now I would say across the systems of, you know, I mean, pre-training is probably a bit more hardened, but there's a lot of headroom in reinforcement learning. We're probably at a point where it's, you know, 30x like efficiency depending how good your model is for actually improving itself. So that is one thing that's happening is...
30x per year or over what?
Yeah, something like that. Yeah, I mean, it depends on, you know, what metric it is, but it roughly, I do think that the speed is probably four or more times faster than researchers just doing it alone. And that'll probably accelerate. So the amount of intelligence you can extract per training flop is increasing. So at some point that asymptote is okay. And then also like the amount of revenue that each flop can generate also increases, right? The more you pack intelligence. So going back to the question around how does this distribute across pre-training and reinforcement learning, and to train Beam, which is a 500 billion parameter model total, 23B active, it was 6,000 GB300s. We ran it, I think, for a few weeks, but now, you know, like with infrastructure efficiencies, we can do it in about 12 days, maybe less. So right there's a coupling of scientific and infrastructure efficiencies. Reinforcement learning was a little over 10,000 GB300s for four weeks. So actually there are more flops spent on reinforcement learning. Reinforcement learning jobs are, you know, more complex in the sense that you do both a lot of inference at scale with all sorts of sandboxes for agents and training. This actually, the reason I got into AI was I saw my co-founder's work on AlphaGo, and I was a physicist at the time, and there was a moment, like there was a plot in AlphaGo where it just never stopped improving, right? It just kept improving, and they just cut it off at some point because what's the point of improving it further? You already beat the world champion. And I thought that, well, if you start apply, figure out how to apply that recipe to stuff that is economically valuable, then, well, at that point it becomes an economic question of how much money do I want to put in to just keep improving the system. And we as a field are there. And one of the, I think, things that I'm really excited about in this open source project and the tech report that we'll have in it is that we'll, you know, describe how these things are built. And indeed, our, like, this reinforcement learning system never stopped learning. And if you look at our plots, they just keep going up, and it's just a matter of compute, basically, right, in terms of scaling it further. So that is to say we as a field are there where you have these RL systems that are very general that don't really stop improving. You want to make them a lot more efficient to extract the most intelligence from your compute. But that means that you move from, you know, a question of can you train these things to where can you get the data and what is economically valuable, and it's just an economics decision of how much money do I put into X to get some kind of improvement out of it. Um, which is incredible. You know, that's, uh, it's, this was not true a while ago.
What can you share about where you've already decided, like, we should turn the crank in terms of just continuing to invest in capability? This is almost to some kind of dissatisfaction to some scientists, and that it's moved, I mean, it is a science, but it's, you know, I would say feels more of an engineering discipline, like it seems more like, again, the rocket ship analogy and the way that building rockets is a science, but most people think about it as an engineering discipline with some scientific work in it, and that's roughly how it feels. So the stages are kind of set, and that the axes of scaling are today, and now there might be something kind of totally blue ocean that we don't know, and there's some new labs exploring it, but it's, you know, pre-training, synthetic data, reinforcement learning...
Or in some sense you can say just training and reinforcement learning, and there are architectural improvements that can be made, there are data improvements, algorithmic improvements, but it's not like a, it doesn't feel like a Wild West the way I felt five years ago or something, like when, like, something that was kind of beautiful about both, I think, DeepMind and Google Brain, and even if you look at early OpenAI, is how diverse the bets were and people were doing just crazy fun stuff. And now it's really narrowed in, and part of it, there's also a bit of a hardware lottery kind of thing because once something starts working, the hardware also starts co-optimizing against it, and so it's harder to find, even if you have a great new idea, if it's not really a good fit for the hardware, you know, it doesn't make sense. So to answer your question, I don't see, there hasn't been an asymptote of how much juice you can get out of better pre-training. Like, we're not seeing a slowdown in compute efficiency gains. You keep seeing stuff. There's a lot of headroom in reinforcement learning. I think that that one is probably, there's a lot of stuff to be kind of discovered there, but it's again, it feels more like an engineering discovery than groundbreaking understanding of a new science or something like this.
I mean, you mentioned investing against some economic activity or some productivity out of this that then allows you to sort of keep going from a capital, etc., perspective. Is there, I know, for example, Anthropic placed a pretty early bet on code. Obviously OpenAI kind of did that too. They originally had, you know, a coding model that they were working with GitHub Copilot on. And then they obviously diversified into consumer and other areas. Are there specific application areas that you all are most focused on from the perspective of economic value creation? Is it code and agentic workflows? Is it something else? Because that seems to be the basis for a lot. I'm just sort of curious if there's a hypothesis on where your model will be used the most or where you need to direct it most.
Yeah, I think the code and agentic stuff kind of sets a foundation for the intelligence, and the intelligence is ultimately, it's interesting. I think it's jagged in the sense that, one, it's generalized in a surprising way. Like, I was surprised by how quickly our model got to a level of capability that is, you know, fairly fresh and recent, right, that, you know, other labs are discovering not so long ago. And so there is some kind of stitching, like generalization happening. At the same time, it is somewhat jagged where it quickly adapts to data once you have the right data for, you know, tasks you want to do, but there is kind of a jaggedness about it. And it's even between, like, the various benchmarks, like the various versions of Terminal-Bench, like you don't see clean generalization between different harnesses. But once you have something working, you have that general agent capability, and you get the data for a new harness, it actually starts adapting to it pretty quickly. So what that means is that you have this, like, pretty adaptive thing that you need to, and then it's a matter of, like, where are the economically valuable pools of data. That's, I mean, part of what makes open models, I think, powerful is that, well, enterprises and customers can take it and customize it for their own stuff and get something that is kind of Pareto optimal for their workloads, like the lowest cost for the highest performance. And so it's an empirical question. You go to kind of customers, you actually see what is valuable to them, and you see, like, whether it's possible to, and usually when it's economically valuable, like, you can generate data because it's not that you're going to be training on the customer's data. It's more that you're setting up evaluations, and if you can set up a good evaluation for their tasks, then you can generate synthetic data that approximates it, and you get good generalization. And so concretely, finance, like various know-your-customer flows and compliance flows in finance are very valuable. A lot of different things in cybersecurity, cyber defense in particular, are quite valuable. Legal, like there are all sorts of kind of agentic verticals within enterprise that are valuable and have a pretty similar pattern in terms of how you get something working there.
One thing that stands out on Beam is the reasoning efficiency of the model. Could you tell us a little bit more about that?
So Beam is, so it's a model, right, that was trained for coding and agentic tasks. That's where it excels. And an important thing in model building is not just the capability, but how quickly an agent achieves a thing. So it translates to faster, you know, workload times, cheaper costs for customers. If you've ever sat around a, you know, some, your favorite AI chat and asked it something and it took, you know, 10 minutes, much better if it does it in one. So Beam tends to be three to four times more efficient than models of the same, you know, capability class, and much more efficient when it comes to even, you know, there are models that are larger out there where, you know, where the efficiency gains then end up being something like 10x. And the reason it's so efficient is because we prioritized, well, both a strong pre-training base for reasoning, but then amplified it with reinforcement learning at what we believe to be the largest scale that's ever been done in open source. I've not seen a 10,000 GB300 for weeks run documented yet. And reinforcement learning, what it, you know, when you, the way you tend to set it up is that you want to extract the maximum amount of capability in the least amount of time. And this is the same thing that happened in the previous systems like AlphaGo. The first AlphaGo agents were pretty, you know, meandering in the way that they were solving the problem. And then by the time you got it to Lee Sedol level, it was just, you know, very smart in its kind of, in its search, right? So that's really what enabled it to have that capability. So, you know, the more reinforcement learning you run, the higher the capability and the faster these systems solve it.
Awesome. That seems very pragmatic.
The intention, I guess, because we are kind of RL believers, and so we always believed that that was the path to AGI was, you know, through reinforcement learning with actually a really strong base. We forget that the first AlphaGo systems, they were trained on expert amateur human games. So they did this imitation learning first and then reinforcement learning. So you kind of need those things working together, and a byproduct of it is that you get this really economically kind of valuable thing that it's very reasoning efficient and makes a really nice workhorse model for enterprises and public sector sovereigns.
And from a monetization perspective, what is the, there's different ways to commercialize both open source and open-weight models, and Mistral and others were early in terms of different approaches to doing so. Is there a specific direction that you all have been heading in that you can share?
Yeah, I think that commercialization of, let's say, open and closed models is in some sense pretty similar. What you're really trying to do is you're trying to maximize inference. That's really what you're trying to do. And the difference is that it's basically like rental versus ownership inference. So an example is that when you're buying a token, you're renting like a piece of a whole stack, which is the harness, if it's, you know, like if there's an agentic harness in there, the model, the inference software, the cluster management software, the GPUs that it's running on, and all of that is sort of like amortized into a token, and you're renting a piece of that whole thing. When you want to own your intelligence for a number of reasons. And I liken it to, we start typically off renting our apartments. But then as you grow up, you want to own a house for various reasons, even if it's a bit of a headache, right? Like, you like it is, I mean, it can be, but, you know, as you get to a point where, you know, you're financially mature enough and you have a family and so forth, you want to own it. And AI has matured as a commercial, like in a commercial market, to the point where enterprises are spending a lot of money on renting their intelligence and then want to start owning it for various, you know, reasons around control. And so going back to monetization, like what's the difference between a closed and open model? The open model is, you know, permissive. But in order for, you know, in order for a customer to make use of it, they need all the other stuff that went around it, like the stuff that you kind of take for granted from a closed model. You need the cluster management software, you need the inference software, you need the harness and so forth. And so we provide the, you know, to large enterprises, sovereigns, all the tools that they need to make kind of open model deployment successful. And even when we think about services, is because a lot of enterprises, most enterprises need some handholding on this. We think about services as how do we go in, unlock really valuable use cases that drive a lot of compute demand, right? Inference demand. And in a sense, services and open model is like a demand driver for a much, you know, for an inference business.
What do you think? I won't ask you to project too far because it's just very hard, but over a one or two-year time horizon, the mix of tokens that is open versus closed.
Well, I think you're kind of starting to see the trajectory now, which is that maybe six months ago, it was majority closed, minority open when you go to any gateway like OpenRouter or Vercel, and it's flipped almost exactly from 70-30 closed-open to 70-30 open-closed. Now, I think that's only going to accelerate, and I suspect that the world is going to look not too dissimilar from operating systems, where 95% plus of servers, computers in the world run on an open-source operating system like Linux. That doesn't mean that the closed stuff isn't very valuable, right? Microsoft and Apple, these are extremely valuable companies. So the market for this stuff is really big. So I think that we'll see most token demand going to open. A big difference here is that I think we'll also see a lot of economic value going to open simply because, you know, even if the model is fully permissive or perhaps has a license on it, everything else you need to run it is still expensive. The compute is still expensive. So it's a, you're in a different world than, you know, hardware accelerators like GPUs and others are just, it's a more expensive compute substrate than CPUs, right? And so you have a different kind of cloud that needs to be built around it. So I expect majority of tokens to be going to open source. Extremely valuable closed model companies to exist. A valuable ecosystem of open model companies and various distributors around them to exist as well.
Do you have a sense of what proportion of the open tokens are RL versus not versus sort of base model?
I think every single, like, open model that's out there at this point has been RL to some extent.
Oh, yeah. But I mean for a specific use case or application in a custom model.
Yeah. So I think what I've heard, kind of the statistics that, you know, some of, like, the kind of open model dedicated inference providers say is that it's actually vast majority, 90% plus, customized. But there's a caveat there because today the biggest customers of dedicated inference are AI natives and maybe digital natives who have a whole product that is just, you know, one big customization of an open model, like, you know, like a Cursor or, you know, Cognition, Abridge, Harvey, like these kinds of companies that have a product that's built around something that's big and customized.
So that would make sense then. Well, if you're supporting those workloads, the majority of them would be fine-tuned.
I actually have a different take of what's going to happen in enterprise. I think that the majority of enterprise token consumption is going to come not from customized models, but from customized systems. Meaning you took an open model, you didn't actually fine-tune it yet. You just customized a system around it, like your agentic harness around it, to make it work for some KYC flow or something like that. And then once you're sophisticated enough, you might start, you know, fine-tuning and moving to that. But I actually think that in enterprise it will be kind of reversed in the sense that the journey that AI natives went through, which was start the closed model, then move to an open model, then customize it, they went through it very quickly because they set up native products that are data collectors. Enterprises are mostly architecting this around their existing products and existing tools, and I think that there are a lot of frictions there to just do a straight shot to fine-tuning. So in enterprise, I suspect it'll be a bit different.
And do you think they'll still start with state-of-the-art models or, you know, the closed models and they'll move over, but the harness will be the mechanism by which they customize the open model?
That has been our observation, that the point at which an enterprise is considering open models, and most of the enterprise we talk to are considering now, is by the time they've ramped up some significant workloads with closed models. And I have not seen kind of a basically straight shot kind of sprint to an ownership market, but you have to go through the rental stage to become...
Has to get a big enough cost driver for your enterprise, and then you say, how do I cut costs? And this is valuable enough for me to keep it, and so then I switch over as a...
Yeah, if you're spending, let's say, a hundred million plus, which is not uncommon at all, on closed models a year, then you start thinking about, well, you know, maybe I should figure out, like, a more optimal way to do this. And I think there's an interesting resurgence of on-prem in the sense of also because there's a compute shortage. And so sometimes it becomes, if you're an enterprise and you're consuming from your favorite hyperscaler, you know, sometimes, very often, there's just not enough compute. It's hard to get good rates there. And so, but you're spending so much money. So you might go with, like, a, you know, an infrastructure provider like Dell and say, I just want to set up the bare metal, but I want to serve stuff into my enterprise. And then, well, what happens then? Who helps them with that layer between the bare metal and actually making them successful?
And you view that as your role in the open model world?
Yes. Yeah. So, I mean, we view our role as enabling enterprises to build successful solutions. So it is very solutions-driven in the sense that the thing that enabled AI natives to adopt open models well is building their own solution, but enterprises just need more help there. And so it's really around going in, assessing what are the biggest value things you can do there. And a lot of these enterprises can go, like, they might have built, you know, an agent that spans, you know, hundreds of millions of customers on closed models that they really want to scale out. And so the scaling factor is very high. It's very hard to go in and just say, we're going to give you inference. I've not heard that work. That has not worked, you know.
So, yeah. Yeah. The closed model ecosystem is a competitive one. It looks increasingly like the open model ecosystem will also be. What do you, I mean, tell me if you disagree with that claim as well.
It's all very competitive.
Yeah. I mean, large markets tend to be. What do you think are the important dimensions of competition when you think about yourselves and, like, how you position in the long run?
Yeah. Yeah. Well, I have kind of a pretty simple formula for, you know, ultimately the way anyone wins in this is by, well, it's how much revenue, right? How much durable revenue are you generating? And the formula is what intelligence density are you able to offer times how much compute do you have times how much trust do you have with organizations that they would want to work with you? Basically, how good are you at solving their problems? And because something that's interesting about this market that maybe you all know more than I do, I actually, you know, previous markets in terms of what were limiting factors, but compute is scarce. So there are, you know, a lot of things that previously were, and maybe this is a temporary thing, but I don't see this as being a temporary thing for some time. So in previous competitive instances, you might say, oh, there's like, you know, these few players are all like undifferentiated, but then it turns out if you're really good and you have the compute, that it's okay.
I mean, I see the whole space being competitive across the whole stack. And, you know, there are arguments around, well, this part is getting commoditized and that part is getting commoditized. In reality, everything is getting commoditized. Like, everything across the whole stack is so hyper-competitive that it's getting commoditized, and the model margins are going to be compressed, right? There is an open model tension, right, with closed models that I think does lead to a margin compression.
The application stuff margins compress, the, you know, inference layer and the bare metal. So we see a lot of the AI-native companies negotiate their closed deals very aggressively because the open ecosystem exists. So it's explicitly true. Yeah.
So I think that for any one of these companies, and you can think about any AI-native company as what is the intelligence density that they serve to customers, how much compute do they have, and how much trust do they have with those customers because they're driving successful solutions for them. Which means that if those are the three factors, then so long as there are great open models, so long as you have great intelligence density out there that is accessible, there should be many successful companies because then it's a matter of how much compute can each one, you know, assemble. Now we are actually in a world where when you're a great kind of intelligence builder and you're able to, and this is kind of what's happened with the closed companies, that your revenue really shoots up and you're just able to amass more compute than anyone else, right? Then that puts you in a strategic position. But that is what I think is required to win. You have to serve great intelligence, have a lot of compute, and have trust with customers.
Yeah. How do you think about, so if you look at the era that you mentioned at the very beginning of this conversation, you know, two years ago, a...
A lot of the open-weight or open-source models were Western in origin. So, Mistral was developed in Europe. Obviously, Meta was a mix of Europe and the US. And what's happened over the last year or two is we've really seen the rise of Chinese open-weight models. In some cases, there's the perspective that they've been distilling a lot off of the state-of-the-art models, and so that's part of what's allowed them to make very rapid progress. The labs are now trying to roll out, or the big sort of closed labs are trying to roll out, tools to prevent as much distillation from happening, or at least making it more challenging. What do you think happens over the next year or two in terms of Chinese open-source or Chinese open models? Do you think it remains where it's at? Do you think it evolves? Like, what happens?