Dude, I've been a fan of you for over 20 years because I grew up listening to hip-hop, and everybody in hip-hop knows who you are. So, I'm very excited to have a conversation with you.
One of the fascinating things that Jimmy I told me about you was you made a very unusual decision coming out of a record label. Like, you could have started your own record label and you said, 'No, I'm not going to start a record label. I'm going to go full on into advertising and marketing.' Can you tell me about that?
It was 1999 and I get a lot of credit for seeing that whether it was Napster, MP3s were going to shift the music business from the CD. We started to see signs of it, but it was very in it was in the fledgling, you know, stages of that. So, I didn't quite see it. What I did see was an industry that didn't know the difference between good and great. What I mean by that is that when an industry is booming, sometimes when it's booming because of the business model itself, mediocre gets rewarded and like and then over time it catches up. But in the beginning, mediocrity is applauded and financially awarded. And I knew that because we were selling CDs for $16 and people were paying for it when there was only one song on the album that that wasn't going to sustain itself. Like there was something wrong with that. Like why would you pay $16.99 and you only liked the first single and executives were getting paid tons of money on that, you know, idea and they weren't even talented. And I'm like, this is going to have to cave in.
Outside of that, what I seen was an advertising business that felt like archaic. The advertising business at the time looked at the world through the lens of black, white, Hispanic. And I'm like, that's not the way people relate to products in marketing. It doesn't No one looks at them and goes, well, oh, they're speaking to me because I'm I'm white or like that's how I prefer to get spoken to because I'm black. Like these things weren't real. And the music business did teach me that. The music business taught me that the idea that people listen to certain records had nothing to do with their ethnicity. DMX was selling in Iowa. The radio station in Iowa didn't play DMX. Where Eminem was being played was being was being purchased in Harlem. It had nothing to do with white and black. But why were products treated that way? Why would like we're gonna, you know, when you want to sell a Cadillac to a black person, you put a deep voice over like the new Cadillac Escalade. Nobody wants that. And Spanish people don't want an ad that just says Hola. Like these things don't work. My whole idea was like, why don't you just find shared values? Like if you're an 18-year-old African-American from Compton and you're an 18-year-old white kid from Greenwich, Connecticut, and you like skateboarding, like it doesn't make a difference if you just speak about skateboarding, you're both going to find the shared value in that in the culture of skateboarding. But this other thing that was happening just felt like it was dying. And I knew that if I got into that industry, I could make a difference.
But what Jimmy, I think, admired most is that like you you didn't care what was expected, like you didn't make the decision that everybody else was making or the decision that was expected of you. It's like you you forge your own path.
So I'm giving you the rational, you know, how I seen it. The idea of seeing it that way and then jumping and to go into a business in which you didn't understand.
Yeah. Look, I can reference a lot in the Jimmy podcast. It's not that I want this podcast to like be the advertising for all your others, but you know, you've had a lot of interesting people and there's a is a lot of six degrees of separation in the way we think. When the unknown is a better option than the known, run in that direction, run towards darkness. And the unknown was what I didn't know, right? The advertising business. But the known was this industry that was going in the wrong direction, in a direction where they was selling one song for a lot of money. They had a monopoly on the distribution of CDs and they control radio and MTV and those things didn't seem like they were going to last forever. So running towards the unknown became very easy. Not because oh and also 'cause I was 29 years old, right? And I didn't have a family yet. I didn't have kids. I had already made a lot of money. I had already done well. So, I wasn't like needing money and I didn't have like a family that was relying upon me to like earn instantly. If I didn't make that decision at that point in time, I would have never made it at all to change industries. [__] it. We going in the advertising business.
And I had a big proof point. The proof point was when I was at Sony, I made the soundtrack. I was fortunate to make the soundtrack for the film Men in Black. I had known Will Smith and his manager James Lassiter for many, many years. And when they were making that film, they wanted to make the soundtrack. They were making it with Sony, who also distributed that film. I was a Sony executive and they, you know, said, 'Look, you know, Stoute, you know, you do this.' I wanted to do it. I I was excited to do it. And the song became a hit. Right. Here comes the men in black with Will. But what was bigger than the song was the glasses. And he said, 'I make these look good in the movie.' It was all in the music video. God knows what the impressions were when you measured that, if you measured it in today's sort of metrics. And the glasses became contagious because of the popular culture impact of that song in that video and I'm like if we're in the music business why aren't we getting paid off those glasses? Like why do Ray-Ban has nothing to do with any of this other than they gave Will the glasses? Like why aren't we make so the guy in the company that did product placement for those glasses. While I was thinking this, he was trying to find me 'cause he wanted to find the next thing that did that. And I was like, if we could sell 14 million glasses or whatever the number was, I could do this [__] all the time.
The idea that Jimmy was putting the Beats headphones in music videos was literally a derivative of that idea. I had seen that idea very early and my peers and others in the industry would tell you that. I seen that I was I was infatuated with the idea and to the to the point that I left the industry to learn the advertising business to understand the language, the dialogue, the people, the movements, the shakers. I wanted to understand that business. So I put I immersed myself in it not by studying it by quitting and doing it. Jimmy allowed me to do that. I had worked for him at that time. I had left in Sony, had gone to Interscope. I'd done great work with Interscope. Jimmy and I was close. He's a mentor of mine. And when I told him I wanted to do it, the deal was like, 'Look, man, I got your back, but bring the deals to Interscope first.' So, a lot of the early things that I had done were based around Interscope artists. And I mean I I I got great great stories about me, Jimmy and Steve Jobs, you know, trying to get bring when I was working on McDonald's early around the I'm loving it launch. We wanted to do was around the same time as iTunes was launching and the thing about Apple at that time the stock was at 9 or 10, you know, very you know it was like there and you know it was so in 2001 I I not to go over but Enron had just...
Take this wherever you want, man.
In 2001 the Enron thing happened, right, where the CEO and the CFO, they had they they no longer could the CFO couldn't say, oh well, the CEO told me to do it, that's why I did it. That was Sarbanes-Oxley came out of this whole thing and everyone was scared about insider trading. So I remember when we knew that the iPod was coming because of Jimmy's relationship with Steve, we all wanted to buy stock in Apple and the stock was like nine. Not that we knew that nine was cheap. We just knew that that something good was going to happen. And we were all scared to death about Ste. We were like, 'No, we're going to we're going to go to jail and we're going to be Jeff Skilling.' I like, 'No, no, no, no, no.' But back during that time, I was transitioning out and you know, the iPod launched before the iTunes. People think they launched at the same time. So when iTunes launched, the one thing about Apple at that time is if they could put distribution, the expense of distribution to a third party, Steve was all about that. He was all about how can I find somebody else. Remember HP was the partner for the iPod. They they're the ones who put it in all of the Best Buys and Circuit Cities or whatever the retailers were around the world. Apple didn't have the sales team to do that.
And they didn't have their stores.
They they relied on a third party to do that. They did HP. HP happened to be one of my clients, Carly Fiorina at the time. And with iTunes, same type of thing. Who could we get to distribute it? Jimmy was trying to get a deal done with Coca-Cola. An executive at Coca-Cola, Steve Heyer, turned it down twice. I was representing McDonald's and we wanted to do I had the idea we're going to do the music meal, you know, Big Mac and large fries and or hamburger fries and a song. And McDonald's turned him down as well. The the the executive at McDonald's sort of was like posturing and Steve went nuclear. I mean nuclear on them. I mean, at the time he went he said some [__] to them. I was like, 'Holy shit.' He said like like it's like you're in a meeting and like the meeting hasn't quite gone bad yet, but it's going directionally in a place where you kind of predict that it's going to not end correctly. And he he seen that coming and he just said, 'Man, don't you don't you guys know you make food that kills kids?' It's like, 'Oh shit.' Now, I'm a young executive trying to I'm trying to do the right. I'm trying to come up. Jimmy knows Steve Jobs. I got McDonald's. Jimmy and I have worked together. We're doing the tango. We're going to go bring this McDonald's, iTunes, Apple thing together, you know? And then he says that and the guys at McDonald's are looking at me like, 'You walk me into this shit.' And I'm like, he's just playing, man. He don't he don't mean that. I I remember that feeling at that time. It was like [__] the [__] am I doing?
Did they try to kick Steve Jobs out of the meeting? How'd the meeting end?
Kick Steve Jobs out of the meeting?
It was. First of all, the meeting was at Apple. They weren't kicking Steve Jobs out of any meeting.
So, we're we're actually going to do an episode with Ed Catmull, who's the founder of Pixar, and he worked with Steve Jobs for a long I think he worked with Steve Jobs uninterrupted for like 24 years.
And he tells a story about what a meeting with in his autobiography Creativity Inc., what a meeting with Steve Jobs is like. Remember the ma I think it was like Magnavox.
Of course Magnavox, they made video games, they made television.
Yeah. And they used to have this commercial probably in I don't know maybe '80s or '90s where somebody's like sitting in a chair and the the music is so loud it's like blowing the guy's hair back.
Was it Magnavox? It could have been Maxwell.
Or Maxwell. Sorry. Yeah. And uh.
Yeah, that that makes more sense. And Ed Ed's like, 'You remember that commercial?' I was like, 'That's what it's like being in a meeting with Steve Jobs. He's just so so overpowering. He's like just such a force of nature. Like kind of blows you back in your chair.'
Look, I didn't have the exposure to Steve Jobs like that. That was I was in that'd be two meetings with him, where I mean like real meetings where like there was feedback and that kind of thing. And that was that. I mean, I'm I'm close with Eddy Cue and he tells amazing Steve Jobs stories along with Jimmy. That was just my version of getting a taste of it and it was like, holy [__].
I want to tell you about the presenting sponsor of this podcast, Ramp. I have been reading a lot about SpaceX lately. SpaceX is one of the most valuable private businesses in the world, and one of the main themes in the history of SpaceX is constantly attacking and questioning your cost. Ramp helps many of the most innovative businesses in the world do exactly that. The median company running on Ramp cuts their expenses by 5%. And one thing SpaceX has demonstrated is that a religious dedication to controlling costs can help actually increase revenue because you can pursue opportunities you couldn't otherwise. And we see that in the Ramp data too. The median company running on Ramp also grows their revenue by 16%. So, when you're running your business on Ramp and your competitors are not, you have a massive competitive advantage that compounds over time. Ramp is the only platform designed to make your finance team faster and happier. Many of the top founders and CEOs I know run their business on Ramp. I run my business on Ramp and you should, too. Go to ramp.com to learn how it can help your business save time, save money, and grow revenue. That is ramp.com.
I found one of my all-time favorite quotes when I was reading the book Zero to One. The quote says, 'The single most powerful pattern I have noticed is that successful people find value in unexpected places. And they do this by thinking about business from first principles instead of formulas.' That is exactly what AppLovin has done with their advertising platform. AppLovin connects you with over a billion potential new customers inside mobile games. AppLovin allows you to capture undivided attention. AppLovin ads are full screen video ads that are watched for an average of 35 seconds. That is retention that blows other ad platforms out of the water. And you can launch on AppLovin in minutes. You set the goal and AppLovin achieves it. There's no complex setup, no expertise needed, and AppLovin scales quickly. They can put your ads in front of over a billion potential customers. Other businesses have seen immediate results, have scaled to hundreds of thousands of dollars of spend per day, and increased their revenue by millions. So, you want to get started quickly before all of your competitors are on AppLovin. And you can do that by going to applovin.com. That's applovin.com.
Going back to the Ray-Ban bands. So, you were at Sony.
When you're Is that the first time that you're like, 'Oh, wait, wait. There's like a you can translate cultural influence to sales like business success.' Is that the first time where it clicked or was there something that happened before that?
I had known it intuitively growing up in Queens and being around hip-hop my whole life. Much my, you know, at 16 when I was 16 was 1986 when you know Run DMC performed at Madison Square Garden and like it was Fresh Fest. It was like a sort of the the coming out party of that hip-hop could have actual rock stars. So that was my wheelhouse. And the only reason why I wore Adidas shell toes was because of them. Like we knew that. So it wasn't like it was a new idea or you know Grand Puba advertising for Sprite which is an amazing amazing.
Wait, did you do that deal or is that before you?
That was way before me. And I remember when he said, you know, the the line, like he said the line, you know, first thing first, obey your thirst and like he talked about Sprite. Like you've seen these things or St. Ides malt liquor. You should look at these ads with with with Ice Cube and St. Ides. Like these these these things were so powerful that hip-hop would be working with these brands and like it would influence urban culture immediately. And when I talk about urban culture, I'm talking about dense cities, not even black kids. I'm talking about just dense inner city, you know, I use it as a measurement of space, density of people. They would gravitate towards these products that these artists talked about either in their in their music or did blatant acts for. So by the time I had gotten to Will Smith and Men in Black, I mean, I had seen it for 25 years, but it still wasn't mainstream cultural impactful yet for reasons that I still don't understand. Like it was very clear and obvious. But you know, like most things, when the alternative is working, when the incumbent can still rely on the old business practice, they won't disrupt themselves. They'll just keep doing that, right? Like, why would I invest any money in understanding hip-hop when Kenny G is still selling? I mean, no disrespect to Kenny G, Michael Bolton is still selling, whatever it may be. But if those things are still working, you're not going to pay attention to Wu-Tang. You're not going to pay attention to things like this. Or if you're still selling under in a world in which you can say, 'I'm going to target white consumers.' I used to talk about this all the time, like like black consumers are the best consumers in the world because they buy products that aren't marketed to them. I I grew up in a world where I'd see African-American women buying products, L'Oreal products, in which there was only white women with blonde hair on the box or in a commercial and African-American women would buy it or the same thing with African-American men and and like people took advantage of that. But when brands leaned into being authentically connected to where culture was, which also spoke to those segments, they were taking market share. They were taking that attention. So to me, it was just a matter of time before it tipped and that became the new marketing paradigm. And that's why I called my company Translation because I wanted to translate that cultural insight for Fortune 500 companies. And the first company that gave me a shot that's still my client today is McDonald's.
Okay. So, this is what what I was curious about. So, you're at Interscope. What are the assets that you have when you start Translation? So, you're young, you don't have a family, you can take more risks, you have an insane network, you've already been you were managing Nas at that time like what were the asset the non-financial assets you had going into this like jumping into a new industry?
When I first left, remember I said I learned first, right before I started Translation, my marketing services company. I learned and I worked at an intern company before that.
It's called Arnell Group.
So, I worked at this company and I not I worked at I became partners with when I left the the record business. You know, I was making a couple million dollars a year at 29 and I went into an agency in which I got paid $150,000 and 20% equity. I didn't necessarily understand the value of equity at all. I certainly understood $150,000 was a lot less than 2 million, 2.5 million, but I wasn't even betting on the equity, man. I was really betting on the education. I sincerely mean that. I I did not know what was going to happen at all, but I knew I was going to learn. That was the period in which I had gotten exposure to certain clients like McDonald's and Reebok. So at Reebok, that was a client that when I was partners in this agency, I'd met Adam Silver at that time who was the deputy commissioner of the NBA because we were doing all the marketing. Reebok had the license for the NBA and I was doing all the marketing around the throwback jerseys and then like I was seeding them and all the artists back then were wearing throwback jerseys. So it became this really big deal that like wow this guy knows what he's doing. He has you know I had gotten that's where the market was going but I gotten a lot of credit because it was just selling like crazy and and Reebok was the beneficiary of it as the NBA license. They were the NFL and the NBA licency at the time. Gentleman by the name of Paul Fireman was founder of Reebok who did an amazing job. He trusted me and and and put a lot of investing behind my ideas. And then the thing that was like the loudest was this idea that every artist wanted to be a basketball player and every basketball player wanted to be a rap artist. And I came up with this platform called the sound and rhythm of sport. And we made this commercial for Reebok with Allen Iverson and Jadakiss and it was explosive. And I had Hype Williams, a music video director, shoot it. And no one thought like it was like this sounds crazy today. I mean to think, but it was like how could Hype Williams a music video director shoot a TV commercial? I'm like I don't even know what you're saying. It's not a TV commercial. It's entertaining content, whether it's a music video, right, which was Men in Black, or a 60-second same idea, but you call it a TV commercial only because you run it on television, not because the format is different, just because you're running it on television. So music videos ran on MTV, but if you took the music video off MTV and made it a 60-second spot, just run it on television, it's a television commercial.
I heard you like six years ago say you're like everything is advertising. That like you jumped advertising earlier, people thought you were bugging. That's the term you use. Like everything is advertising. I just talked to Brian Armstrong about this, founder of Coinbase, and he said the same. It's like everything is marketing. It's just like you have to entertain or get people's attention and then you get a message across that serves some kind of thing you want to happen in your business. In his case, you know, the new products that Coinbase is building or the financial performance of, you know, the stock or whatever the case is. But I love that you everything is advertising.
Again, at that time, it was just, you know, when you're trying to explain something that you fully don't understand, but you just know it's instinctively correct, it's hard to get people to buy into it because they're like, most people are risk averse. So, it's like, why would I what are you talking about? Like, why would this guy be able to shoot a TV commercial? He's never shot one. I'm like, because it's the same thing. I mean, what is a music video? It's an advertising for a song. It's a TV commercial for a song if you ran it on television, right? So, anyhow, we shot this content as we've evolved. And it blew the [__] up because it was Jada rapping to the sound of a basketball bouncing. And Allen Iverson can dribble a basketball and make it sound like a beat. So, it sounded just like any other hip-hop beat, but it was literally a ball bouncing while this guy rapped over it. And the commercial was beautiful and it was boom. And that changed the trajectory of Reebok. And when that happened, that was a big deal. And then I started doing artist deals around sneakers. I did the Jay-Z S. Carters.
But that's the first ever non-athlete shoe deal. This is again why I wanted to talk to you. You just see stuff before anybody else.
Yeah, we did that. We did the the G-Unit. Was just hot at that time.
What was the marketing? Didn't didn't and you guys did something smart if I remember correctly like wasn't didn't Jay put out a mixtape around the It was like the.
S. Carter. We did the S. Carter mixtape, which was a mixtape around the the the sneaker marketing the sneaker the S. Carters. Then we did a commercial with 50 and Jay-Z. No one understood it at the time like why would you be doing this? Like why are we spending money on this? And I'm like, at the time I all I could say to them was like, it's like a commercial. Imagine trying to sell a product to housewives, to women overall, and you got Martha Stewart and Oprah. That's what this is. This is like the equivalent of the that level of power between these two guys. And that's the only way I could explain it to somebody who didn't understand it, you know. And you know, the S. Carters were big, the G-Units were big. Then I did the Pharrell sneaker and Pharrell would tell you that was his foray into footwear and gives me a lot of credit for like his path in the design because I gave him that opportunity very early. What's clear was Nike wasn't doing lifestyle at that time. They thought like Just Do It was all about athletes and performance. So, what I was trying to do was tap into the truth, which was people were wearing sneakers, not to perform at all, just so it could match their hat, their shirt, that other thing. It was it was fashion. So, I just started choosing guys that didn't want to work out or run or jump at all. Jay-Z being the number one version of that. Like, he doesn't, right? He doesn't give you the athletic vibe. He gives you the vibe of like, I'm chilling. And then it was 50 and then it was Pharrell and it was all just playing along the lines of of fashion.
Dude, how many people are wearing Jordans, not playing basketball on them?
It was the only white space left because there was no way I could market Reebok as the as the agency of record at the time. I told Paul I like Mr. Fireman. There is no way I can convince a 16-year-old they can jump higher or run faster than Nike and Reebok. Like like that's not happening. Okay, so like let's go into the other thing which is the non-performance stuff. And it got so hot that we got a chance to go into the performance business again and we were trying to sign Kobe and I have great stories of you know pitching Kobe. First of all, I signed Kobe to a record deal recording contract when he was a rookie. And then we pitched LeBron. That's how me LeBron and I became good friends to this day. When we pitched LeBron and he there's a famous story of LeBron. We're pitching him for Reebok. We, you know, they send a plane, everybody wants to sign him. I I tell Paul while he's coming from Akron, we're flying from New York to to Boston to meet him there. And I'm like, Paul, we do this in the record business and it works. You give an artist an advance and you give it you bring the advance right there like in cash in a duffel bag. And it Well, that has been done in the music business, but this was like this was gonna be a check. And I I seen Paul [__] this was some balling [__] call his wife 'cause he couldn't get the company to get the check. And his wife wrote a personal check for $10 million and the driver when we landed had the check. We went to the meeting and Paul says, 'LeBron, I know you know $100 million, you know, Adidas is going to offer that when you go see them next, and then Nike is going to offer that when you see them. I'll match that deal and give you a $10 million signing bonus right now to not take those meetings. That's the number. We'll give you the number plus the $10 million.' So, Paul took my advice all the way. LeBron, he's he's going back. He has to be in homeroom the next morning. Okay.
He's in high school, right?
He's in high school. He's going back to homeroom the next morning. He's in there with his mom and and his team, his agent at the time. But he's clearly LeBron James. He's he's making the decision. We leave the meeting. He asks for some room. We leave the boardroom. Paul and I, we go in the other room. We're like, 'Oh, you think he's going to do it?' I'm like, 'Man, I think so. I like it's $10 million, man. The guy we're paying him exactly what he's going to get paid. We're not This is just a bonus. It's not This is not coming from the money. This is a signing bonus to sign it now and not take the other meetings.' We come back in the room. This 18-year-old kid says, 'No, I'm betting on myself.' He didn't say that, but we knew that he was going to take the other meetings. He walked away from $10 million check signed to his name to go back to the projects in Akron and back to homeroom. I I applauded him because I knew at that moment in time that the world had changed when a young African-American that was in poverty knew that his talent was bigger than that check. It taught me a lot. It taught me a lot of where the world was going and that we were already there. And it's something that I'm proud of him for to this day. Not that Reebok was the bad choice or anything like that. It wasn't even about that. It was the fact that he believed in him more than the money at that moment in time. That was a big shift for a community of people.
But I think that's one of the main themes that runs through your entire career is like you're encouraging other people around you to like bet on themselves. Even the story you told about the Ray-Ban bands. We sold the glasses. We didn't get anything for it. Like I read Andre Agassi's phenomenal autobiography called Open and he goes out one night is hung over and you know he's a wild boy and he winds up playing a tournament the next day, wins the tournament, but he's wearing Oakleys like the crazy multicolored ones and just because his eyes are bloodshot, he's hung over, right? He wins a tournament, there's a crazy photograph that gets put on like the cover of Sports Illustrated. He winds up selling a ton of Oakleys. Did he get equity in Oakley? No. You know what he got? He got a Dodge Viper sent to his house by the founder of Oakley. So, it's like if that guy bought you a $60,000 or $80,000 car, how much money did he make? Yeah. And so, your whole thing is just like, why aren't why are you giving it away? Why don't you This is very entrepreneurial.
It It happens all the time again when the incumbent is already making money doing what they're doing. When you're making all this money, if you're in the record business at that time, think about this. The music business used to sell singles, right? So you'd buy the single for $4.99 or $3.99 and then the single was a way to get you to buy ultimately buy into the artist for a less expensive price and then ultimately when they dropped the album they buy the album. When the CD came, they didn't even [__] around and sell singles no more. They removed the single.
The single was on cassette.
The single was a cassette.
Or 45 or you know back before that. But it was a cassette. So when they stopped selling singles, they wanted the artist so badly that one song, one music video, you heard Hot in Herre and you seen that video, you're $16.99 without even knowing what song number 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 was. You didn't give a [__] And the industry took advantage of.
Let me tell you what happens in that environment. You spend all your time making one single, the rest of the album, right? So the creativity suffers because they're buying it anyway. So let's just try to make the first single. What's the thing that's going to work on MTV and what's the thing that's going to get on radio? That thing. In fact, a lot of artists would make an album and then go to like all the top producers just to make the first single. So they'd make a whole album with one guy or two guys and then go to one specific person to make a song that was the radio record, and that song could sound like nothing else on the album. They didn't give a [__]. They just wanted to sell, obviously, the thing, and it worked. So when you're making that margin on that product, the last thing on your mind is who's making money off the glasses, all of the [__] that's being sold in the music video.
What are the other businesses that we should be building on the back of this because we're giving it away? And that's what Jimmy talked about. Why don't we own the end customer? Why don't we build businesses with artists?
Why don't we build businesses with artists? When I first started UnitedMasters, my music distribution company, the first thing I tried to do, the only thing I wanted to do was build a universal, uh, not a record company, agnostic CRM system. My whole idea was like, if like anything else, you go on Amazon, it's like if you buy this, then you buy that, right? So if they're selling you toilet tissue or whatever, they're selling you the next thing. There's a plunger, there's this, there's other things that have associated with that product that you just bought.
My whole thing is that if you listen to Yeezy, Yeezys, the Kanye album Life of Pablo, you know, 30 times, why isn't the next thing I'm referring to you a pair of Yeezys or a hoodie that he made? It's not that.
And the record companies and the artists had no CRM tools. Every other, you know, product that I've seen, um, digital product, you found a way to go, okay, the margins are going to be a lot lower, but the remarketing is going to be cheap because I know who the customer is. So even if I make this amount of margin on the first transaction, the fact that I now have your name and your taste, I can sell you the next product. This is what you talk about that you learned Jeff Bezos knew about selling windshield wipers. Once you bought on the platform and he had your intelligence, your information, he could find out what else you wanted and he could speak to you directly. The record business doesn't own their customers at all. I mean, at all. I have a theory around this, at least as of late.
If the artists knew who their fans were, they wouldn't need a record company at all.
If you're an artist and you have 200,000 people who love you, you know how much money you can make with those 200,000 people selling them higher margin items, or selling them the music and then the higher margin items like hoodies and t-shirts and merchandise and other things that go back to the essence of why they fell in love with you in the beginning. When the record companies cut the deal with Spotify and this whole 70-30 split, they had all the leverage in the world. In fact, they took equity in Spotify. The record companies owned a piece of Spotify. There was a big thing that came out. It's like, was that value passed along to the artist who was the leverage that they utilized in order to get that equity? But putting that to the side, rather than negotiating the equity, why wouldn't you renegotiate the access to the data, the real access to the data,
so that the artist would know if you listen to that? If Taylor Swift has a fan that listened to her album 700 times, why wouldn't Taylor Swift be able to communicate directly with that fan to sell him the ticket directly, sell her the fan the gear directly?
The record companies, I believe, never negotiated that when they had that leverage because they didn't even want to have to share that information with the artist. Time has passed and maybe there's privacy laws around it, but they could have still had the option to opt in. Like, do you want Taylor Swift to be able to contact you? [__] yeah. [__] yeah. Do you want Kendrick Lamar to be able to contact you? [__] yeah. Beyonce? Hell yeah.
But they didn't negotiate that because then they would have to share that, and once the artist had direct connection to their fans, record companies would then become obsolete. I was trying to build CRM tools for the artist. So like any other brand would have CRM tools. These CRM tools would allow you to, you know, navigate with your customer and that you could be able to manage that relationship.
The rude awakening was there is no data to be gotten. There's no data to be gotten. Meaning that the data source, Spotify or YouTube or whatever it was, were not going to ever give you the user IDs, right? So like on...
Apple wouldn't either, right?
No. Or Apple. No, they're not going to give you the user IDs. So it's not like if that phone downloaded something, you know, or streamed something x amount of times, I wouldn't be able to send an advertisement directly to that phone. They wouldn't allow you to do that. Years later, there was a law around it, GDPR, that talked about this. So that definitely got in the middle of this, and it was around Facebook and voting and things of that nature that sort of brought this to light. But prior to that,
if it would have been shared and the artist had an opportunity to get that intelligence, and the fans had a chance to allow the artist to get an opportunity to that intelligence through those platforms, I think we'd be talking about a completely different industry today. When I was building UnitedMasters, that I started in 2017,
the idea about building an independent distribution company was driven by the premise that the record business at one point, for many decades since its inception, was you have to find a record company in order to find an audience. You get a record deal, we control radio. We're going to get you on the radio. We're going to get you on MTV. Oh my god. Because trying to get on MTV and radio if you didn't have a record company at a point in time was almost impossible. Since this whole digital content revolution, artists would find audiences before they found a record company. So if they found an audience before they found a record company, why would they have to give over their rights? Why would they have to sell off their name, image, and likeness in perpetuity to somebody because they gave them a half a million dollars when they were 18, 19 years old in the beginning of their career? So we started UnitedMasters with the premise to invert the economics so that the artists got the lion's share of the economics because they actually did the work.
They kept the ownership. That's why you called it UnitedMasters.
Yes, you got it. And Ben Horowitz was a big supporter of that in the beginning. Tim Cook strongly believes in that. Tim Cook is a big believer. It's the Apple ethos to support and give the creative tools. They believe in that. Whether it's an architect, a designer, or an artist themselves, they believe in that at its core. So it's not like it's an idea that doesn't have massive support behind it, but it takes a generational shift because the artists for so long, it was Stockholm syndrome. They're stuck in these deals. They believe that if I'm signing to a record company, A, I'm going to get a lot of money. They're going to make me global. I'm going to get awards, you know, and recognition around it. So I'm going to keep doing that.
Then you have another generation of artists that are coming up right now that are like, are you [__] crazy? I own my [__]. I market myself anyway. These guys don't do anything for me. At least I don't believe they do. I rely on myself first and foremost. I am the best marketer of myself. I'm the best marketer to my audience of myself than anybody else can do, a third party can do. So I'm betting on that. So you have artists, independent artists right now that are blowing the [__] up, that are doing really well. You know, we have an artist on UnitedMasters, a big extra plug, he's made $20 million this year. I mean, more, more, more. And it's his, and he owns this, and it's something that he can give to his family, his kids, he owns it. This idea, when you seen years ago, like people ask, like when Prince wrote slave on his face, Prince changed his name from Prince to a symbol to get out of a contract because Warner owned his name, image, and likeness. So he said, if I change my name to a symbol, doesn't that navigate me out of the contract that I signed? Wrote slave on his face, one of the most successful artists of all time, wrote slave on his face because he knew that I don't even own the [__] that came out of my brain.
When you explain this to technology companies, I explain this to Larry Page, he was the first guy that invested in UnitedMasters. I said, could you imagine if every time a seed investor came in, they actually owned the IP and intellectual property? They owned it. That's what it is in the music business. The guy comes in first and gives you a check for half a million dollars. He owns your name and image and likeness. The people look at you, you can't be [__], that can't be real. I'm like, I swear to God that's real. That's why these artists at the end of their career, they die broke because they don't own anything. It's owned by the person who discovered them. It's not owned by them. Even though they have the unique gift to create something that others can't, they don't own it.
They actually have the thing that's rare and therefore valuable.
Yes. And why I love where we are today and the democratization that digital has provided is that an artist can now, and not only musicians, artists, painters, but like, I'm a painter, I draw on Substack, I'm a writer, I'm a journalist,
Podcasters, like I don't need the publisher to be a third party that owns this anymore. I can find an audience on my own.
And the power in that and the economics in that, the long-term value of that is something that we've never seen before in the hands of the actual creators.
Deel is how the best founders turn the world into their talent pool. I've been studying how history's greatest founders operate for a decade. And one thing they all have in common is they understand that recruiting and hiring the very best talent is your most important priority. A players recognize other A players, which is why top companies like Ramp, Shopify, ElevenLabs, Uber, and DoorDash all use Deel. Many of the top founders I know have personally invested in Deel after using their product. And what they discovered is that Deel is the best company in the world at building infrastructure for global hiring. Deel will help your business hire, pay, and manage any worker anywhere in the world so you can retain the best talent anywhere and spend the rest of your time focusing on what you do best, delivering value to your customers. The founder of ElevenLabs has a great description of the value Deel can give your company. He said, 'We built ElevenLabs to break down language and communication barriers. With Deel enabling us to hire and support exceptional talent anywhere, we can accelerate our innovation and bring more voices, stories, and ideas to every corner of the world.' Deel is trusted by over 40,000 businesses. Learn how they can help your business today by going to deel.com/enra. That is deel.com/enra.
There's a long history of the music industry, you know, the executive industry essentially [__] over artists. I read Jay-Z's fantastic book Decoded, and he talked about reading this book called Hitmen,
And I think it was all the stuff crazy going on in the '70s and '80s and, oh, '60s, '60s, yeah, '50s, '60s, '70s, crazy book.
You have to read that book. It's almost like reading, uh, it's like the movie that they turned the book into, Goodfellas.
That's what it feels like when you read it.
What was the name of the book that turned into Goodfellas, the movie?
But Jay-Z's point was just like, all it did is like, I just read the book, I'm like, I'm going to avoid that, wise guys.
Okay. So I read Jay-Z's, like, I read the book and I'll just avoid doing that. And then he came into the game independent. I think he, the founding of Roc-A-Fella. So he got it, and he got it back in what, '96. How the hell are you still telling the story in 2000?
You know, Jay got it because he was turned down. Record companies wouldn't sign him.
A guy that talented, they wouldn't sign him.
He had no choice but to go independent.
He figured it out. And then when he got independent, he obviously figured it out. Master P figured it out. Cash Money figured it out to a certain extent. Because there's different versions of this. There's different versions of guys figuring it out. Like there's a figuring it out where you're like, I own the whole [__] thing. It's mine and you're my partner and I pay you a percentage. Right? Then there's a version of it like, look, I'm not going to allow one contract to hold everybody, which was Wu-Tang's thing. RZA had a record deal and it didn't work. Then he came back and invented this thing called Wu-Tang and he made sure that he did not sign what he had signed prior when he was Prince Rakeem, an artist.
All those artists could be allowed to sign. Wu-Tang was signed one place, but the artists had the right to sign in different places. They weren't stuck under one agreement. Right? So what happened in the record deal, like if I signed a group, that if anybody in that group ever went solo, they also had to be with me. That's what record companies' deals looked like at the time. So if I signed you in a group, if you decide to break off from the group, you're with me first. When he did the deal immediately with Wu-Tang, none of them had to sign with the record company that originally, BMG, RCA, which originally gave them the deal. That was a breakthrough. That guys got hot off the album, the Wu-Tang album, and it was signing deals in other places. People had never seen that before. And then when you seen Master P, No Limit, this was independent and putting out number one, top five records every week and talking about how much money they were making and selling records out the trunk. It was like, what are they doing down in New Orleans? These guys were finding ways in resourceful manners and were making a ton of [__] money. But how did they get in? How did they get on radio or MTV if they were independent?
This idea, the power of emerging subculture,
They were building something on the way up. Remember, man, if you get 200,000 people who love you, the amount of money in that is tremendous. And they grow with you. They didn't need MTV and radio at the time. They may have had a local radio station. They were down in New Orleans. They had a community of people who bought into this idea and they were building No Limit Records and that contagion and growth kept going throughout the South. And, you know, at some point MTV had to play it. You couldn't be left out, right? So it wasn't about you needed it at some point because it was so popular versus it needing you to break.
Okay. So this is the difference between like top-down record companies at the time. They're like, we have these relationships with national radio and MTV. We're going to make you a star. We're going to push it from the top down. Master P and these other guys, they did bottom up. I remember hearing Sean Parker on an interview one time and he said this unnamed record company executive was just like, you know, give me anybody in the world, even though they're not talented, and with enough push behind them, I can make them a popular musician. Basically saying they controlled the system.
They did control the system. They controlled radio.
Is this related to what you were saying earlier how mediocrity was like...
You know, and I'll use references like I said, you know, Kenny G, who's a great musician, or Michael Bolton. And sometimes I just say these things because I know it brings like shock value, but just to make the point, I shouldn't know the Britney Spears song Oops!... I Did It Again. There's a lot of NSYNC songs I shouldn't know, but they were pounded in your brain. You couldn't avoid it because MTV and radio, local radio, they had a monopoly on it. So all of a sudden you started listening to this music. By the way, I grew up my whole life thinking Hall & Oates was black because you wouldn't even, you would listen to these songs and they were like... There were a time in the '70s where there were no music videos. So you'd hear the voices and like a lot of these artists were trying to sound African-American or like R&B artists. So you would hear it and you'd be like, I guess they are black, and then you find out, you know, obviously they were not. But like when they controlled the system, they could push something on you and the power of repetition will force you to have some recall whether you like it or not. Now that's a whole another story. But the awareness is more than there. And like if I got a 50/50 shot because you already heard it, I love those odds versus the shot that you never heard it at all.
Repetition is persuasive. So again, I think we both have a love of, like I love to study the advertising industry. And I'll go back to like the early 1900s when it was just copywriters were the best advertisers. But even if you think about the '50s and '60s when they're building all the massive advertising firms, the global advertising firms on Madison Avenue, it's like they all talk about this for 100 years. You're not repeating your ads enough. Repetition is persuasive. Do it over and over and over again. And if you see all the deals we do with our partners, you can't buy an ad on any of my podcasts, a single ad. You're doing at least a year, in many cases many, many years. You have to repeat this. It's so important.
So going back to you're realizing, hey, what is the purpose of a record label? You're essentially creating almost like a record label infrastructure in UnitedMasters or through UnitedMasters, but the artists maintain ownership.
So you're taking the parts like you guys can market better than we can. You have control. Like I've watched all your interviews. I love Russ, the rapper Russ.
You've done a bunch. Yeah. I've taken so many ideas.
He's so [__] good. The way he explains it, his passion around it. Dope as [__].
And I've taken ideas from the way he markets his music to the way I run my podcast. It's the exact, I don't see any barriers here. It's the same thing. Whether you're a filmmaker, you mentioned a writer earlier, a rapper, a podcaster, a founder, it's all the same thing.
Painter. Russ is a rapper, but he's really an entrepreneur.
His product is... Yes. First of all, he is an entrepreneur.
Like, full stop. A good one.
We should tell people that don't know him, he's the first person in history, a single person, that wrote, recorded, engineered, produced, mixed, and mastered an album that got a billion streams. A single person.
I don't know all of the stats around him as an artist, him as a business person, and how prolific he is at explaining his business and the amount of songs he puts out, knowing that, you know, if you don't like this song, I may put out 12 songs and then you like the 13th song and then all of a sudden you like song number one and then this whole catalog. When he was explaining that at the beginning of my sort of entering his journey, I was just blown away by how prolific he was as a business guy to explain it. And then, you know, Chance the Rapper, like there were a lot of guys that took independence in the whole digital era and like took it and turned it on its head and they were proud about it. I don't want a record deal. Are you [__] crazy, P? You can't give me $200 million. You can't buy me out of this [__]. That was a next step. Like when I just talked about LeBron James saying, 'I wouldn't take the $10 million.' That's Russ saying, 'I wouldn't sell my publishing for $200 million.' Right? Like you start to realize the power of ownership.
There's a funny story I got to tell you about Russ. He might have said it to you on the interview you did with him, which again, both of them were excellent. When his business manager said, 'Hey, this company wants to buy, you know, your catalog,' he goes, 'I just need to know the number.' You obviously know the answer is no. I just want to know the number so I can put it in a song. I can rap about the fact I turned down this much money.
Lil Russell, Russ, Tobe Nwigwe, Big X tha Plug, Larry June, Brent Faiyaz, there's so many artists that your audience may not even know their name. They're making so much money because they're independent. And now you're watching the artists that were signed for many, many years. Usher is an independent artist now. Usher's independent. Usher was the first independent artist to play the Super Bowl.
Then Bad Bunny, Bad Bunny is an independent act.
Yes. He signed to Rimas. Bad Bunny is an independent artist. These guys are making a fortune.
They own themselves.
That's the future of the music business. That's the future of all of these media businesses. You own this podcast. What does it mean? You, the power of that. [__] look at Joe Budden. When I talk about Russ, I think about Joe Budden too. Joe Budden walked away from a lot of money, man.
And you know, forget me and going into the advertising business. This guy left, you know, a rap career, whether he left the career or the career left him. He went into the podcast business very early and he's done an amazing job. Then he turned down Spotify and went to Patreon because he wanted to work directly with fans. He said, I don't want any obfuscated version of money. I want to know exactly what I want to get paid, exactly what I deserve, because I have the audience who pays me directly, and he uses Patreon.
These are great things that are breakthrough in business models.
I look at all of these artists as solo entrepreneurs, as SMBs. The SMBs that used to be flower shops and bodegas and this, that, and the third are now streamers, independent artists, influencers, podcasters, vloggers, and writers on Substack. They're the new SMBs.
And I don't think industries have caught up to that idea yet.
I don't think the insurance companies understand it. A lot of the new fintech companies understand that, but there's so many incumbent industries that don't see that yet. So they're still looking at the old version of SMBs and they're so locked in with that.
You know who gets it? Like it's the founder companies because just like you had that observation when you were 29 years old, it's like I'm in this industry that's like maybe dying or this can't be sustained, it's being attacked by technology, right? You're not going to sell these high-margin CDs anymore when Napster exists. Same thing that Jimmy realized, you realized as well.
And so like even look at like some of our big partners, like I'm a huge partner with this company called Ramp. It's like, it's a founder-like company. They think like founders and they place a huge, huge, a multi-year bet on me because of all they asked. They didn't, there's no numbers, you talk about being intuitive, they didn't even know how big the audience was. All they said is like, us and all of our founder friends, the most elite people are listening to you, let's figure out how to work together.
And that's what Hell Founders say. He's like, I don't care if State Farm hasn't come to podcasting, they have now, but like all the money that's flowing from TV and radio is going into podcast.
I've seen this with Cash App, was in very, very early. It was a marketing guy at Cash App, so [__] good, seen it early, placing bets on emerging subculture.