CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Nick Shirley
YouTuber & Independent Journalist

Confronting Pro-Palestine Protesters in NYC

📅 Oct 13, 2026 Nick Shirley Interviews 15 MIN 174978 VIEWS 97 SEGMENTS · 4 SPEAKERS
In this video, Nick Shirley went to a massive pro-Palestine protest in New York City to hear what protesters had to say about Israel, Gaza, and the ongoing conflict. I wasn't there to argue. I wanted to listen, ask questions, and give people a chance to explain their views. But things quickly got heated as protesters began confronting me. From intense exchanges to some pretty unexpected conversations, here's what happened when I walked into the middle of a pro-Palestine protest in NYC. Watch until the end and let me know what you think in the comments. Thanks for watching, if you enjoyed t...

What Nick Shirley said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

Nick Shirley, a YouTuber and independent journalist, confronts pro-Palestine protesters and Zionist supporters in New York City, engaging in heated debates over the Israel-Gaza conflict. He challenges a Zionist protester on claims of genocide, media truthfulness, and Israel's relationship with America, with the protester defending Israel's actions as self-defense and rejecting genocide allegations. Shirley discusses Hamas tactics, civilian casualties, and the conflict's complexity, stating he cannot take a side. He also interacts with passersby and protesters, addressing accusations of trolling, praising American flags, and criticizing those who avoid confrontation. Throughout, Shirley maintains a confrontational style, pushing for substantive conversation while navigating aggressive responses.

Key takeaways

  1. Shirley argues the civilian-to-combatant casualty ratio in Gaza is significantly lower than the urban warfare average, citing a one and a half to one ratio.
  2. Shirley accuses Hamas of prolonging the war by not returning hostages and using tactics like embedding in civilian areas.
  3. Shirley confronts protesters, calling them cowards for avoiding fights, and supports pro-Israel figures like Nick Fuentes.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
450,000 Palestinians evacuated due to IDF leaflets metric 10:05
60,000 Estimated Palestinian casualties per Hamas numbers metric 10:05
17,000 Hamas terrorists embedded in civilian population metric 10:05
48 Number of hostages to free for peace commitment 8:36
83 Average daily deaths in Gaza metric 8:03

Chapters

  1. 0:00Protest Encounter and Trolling Accusations
  2. 1:17Discussion on Israel and Palestine at UN
  3. 2:55Zionist Protester on Self-Defense and Truth
  4. 3:56Debate on Netanyahu and US-Israel Relations
  5. 5:21LGBTQ Rights and Gaza Survival Question
  6. 6:08Claims of Attacks and Violence Against Jews
  7. 8:01Genocide Accusations and Response
  8. 10:05Casualty Ratios and Hamas Tactics
  9. 13:55Hostage Release and Prolonging War
  10. 14:17Confrontation and Claims of Cowardice

Questions asked in this interview

9
  1. 2:13I don't agree with everything you say, but I respect going out there, you know what I mean?
  2. 2:58Why should I apologize for what's right?
  3. 3:39Did anyone cry when some innocent Germans were killed during World War II?
  4. 4:49Of course, why not support Israel?
  5. 6:17Why don't you tell the people to leave Israel alone?
  6. 7:42What happened to your buddy with the Jew flag?
  7. 9:02Have you talked to anybody? Have you listened to anybody?
  8. 10:05Their numbers, which are so minuscule compared to the famines and the genocides that the free Palestine movement uses to align themselves, okay?
  9. 15:39Name it. Is it a genocide?
Nick Shirley 0:00 ↗
Are you happy with the turnout today? Always could be bigger. What? Always could be bigger. Always could be bigger. How you doing, sir? How am I trolling people?
Protester 0:09 ↗
We've seen you on Twitter. We're famous.
Nick Shirley 0:13 ↗
Really? I'm glad you're seeing my videos. I appreciate it. Thanks for watching them.
Protester 0:16 ↗
And that's how I know you're a troll.
Nick Shirley 0:18 ↗
I don't troll anybody. Look at you. You're... Are you all right?
Protester 0:23 ↗
Shut up. You're an [__].
Nick Shirley 0:24 ↗
Oh, I'm an [__]. He's shaking everybody, like literally shaking. Well, you can have a conversation with me if you'd like to provide some substance for the channel.
Protester 0:35 ↗
Thank you, Charlie Kirk. Thank you, Charlie Kirk.
Nick Shirley 0:37 ↗
What do you mean?
Protester 0:39 ↗
Because I think that you're trying to take his attitude of being open-minded and talking to everyone, but I liked him. I admired him. You're an [__]. I've seen you on Twitter. You're a troll, you're an [__], and you like to instigate fights. I'm not worried about you, what you do, whatsoever. Charlie Kirk, I could respect. Not you, sorry. And if he's your idol, you've got to change your attitude, honey.
Nick Shirley 1:03 ↗
He's not my idol. He's a great man.
It's funny when those people come at me for instigating, they end up being the ones who get triggered themselves. They're the ones who get the rage bait. All right. Look, we have Israel here now. Israel and Palestine. We made it here to the UN. They were putting everyone in here. Look, you have the Israel flags.
Thank you. How are you doing? What the [__], yo. What's good? How are you guys doing? Good to see you, man. Love the flow, bro. Beautiful locks. I like the hat, too. America first. That's what's up.
Passerby 2:13 ↗
Thank you. I appreciate that. I've seen your videos on YouTube Shorts, bro. I don't agree with everything you say, but I respect going out there, you know what I mean? It's good stuff. It's good stuff.
Nick Shirley 2:22 ↗
You don't need to agree with everything I say.
Passerby 2:25 ↗
It's America, man.
Nick Shirley 2:26 ↗
What do you think of Nick Fuentes?
Passerby 2:28 ↗
I like Nick Fuentes. I think he's a... And he does say a lot of true stuff.
Nick Shirley 2:34 ↗
Yeah, exactly. Everything he says. He loves Nick Fuentes. You, too.
You don't bow down to the state of Israel. We got the Trump flag out here. How you doing, man? You're doing good. What's your sign say? Or what's your flag say?
Zionist Protester 2:50 ↗
Unapologetically Zionist, Harut, New York City. I don't apologize for being [crying].
Nick Shirley 2:55 ↗
Why are you unapologetically Zionist? How are you?
Zionist Protester 2:58 ↗
Why should I apologize for what's right?
Nick Shirley 3:01 ↗
And what do you think of the truth of what we're being told? I just talked to a lady, asked her what she thinks the truth is. She says what she's seeing from the New York Times, all these other media outlets. Do you think we're being told the truth on the Israel side and on the Palestinian side?
Zionist Protester 3:18 ↗
We're not being told the truth about Israel. We're not doing anything wrong. We're defending ourselves. We were in the middle of a cease-fire on 10/7 when Hamas and Palestinian terrorists invaded our homes and tortured our people and kidnapped. This is a result of being invaded.
Nick Shirley 3:35 ↗
What do you think about them saying, 'Well, they're killing innocent children. They're committing genocide.'
Zionist Protester 3:39 ↗
There is no genocide. The population is growing, and sometimes in war innocent people are killed. Did anyone cry when some innocent Germans were killed during World War II? No. They didn't invade our homes. If they didn't murder and torture us, we wouldn't be in this position.
Nick Shirley 3:56 ↗
And do you think Bibi Netanyahu is the best leader for right now, or do you think there...
Zionist Protester 4:00 ↗
He was elected by the people. His party, Likud, was voted in by the majority of Israelis. Okay, I'm not living there. I can't vote.
Nick Shirley 4:08 ↗
Do you support Netanyahu? Do you think he's a good guy?
Zionist Protester 4:12 ↗
I think he's doing his job. I wouldn't want to be in his shoes. He's making very difficult decisions. You know, he's doing the best he can. So, yes, I support him.
Nick Shirley 4:20 ↗
A lot of people here in my chat have questions. Oh, let's see. And I have a question for you. A lot of people in my chat, and a lot of younger people in the younger generations, are worried about the relationship that America has with Israel. Do you worry that there are stuff that goes on like... Do you think everything is always America first, or do you think sometimes we do put Israel first, or do you think they have too much say in our politics?
Zionist Protester 4:49 ↗
I don't think that we put Israel first. I think we support Israel, and we should. It's the only democracy in the Middle East. So, and we do business with Israel. Israel does business with us. You know, we reciprocate. Of course, why not support Israel?
Nick Shirley 5:04 ↗
Yeah, because they are the only country in the Middle East that does hold Western values, right?
Zionist Protester 5:09 ↗
Exactly. And everybody is welcome. You know, you don't have to be Jewish to visit Israel. Everybody can visit. They should go and enjoy it. Go to the beach in Tel Aviv. It's fantastic.
Nick Shirley 5:21 ↗
What percentage... I asked this guy the same question. But what percentage of these people do you think would survive in Gaza?
Zionist Protester 5:27 ↗
What percentage will survive? The majority are going to survive. They're not out there committing a genocide. There are still thousands of...
Nick Shirley 5:33 ↗
As far as like what group? Like a lot of these people are members of the LGBTQ+ community, stuff like that.
Zionist Protester 5:39 ↗
Well, the LGBT community is not welcome in Gaza. They're more than welcome in Israel. They have the biggest gay pride parades in the Middle East.
Nick Shirley 5:46 ↗
Like I saw a feminist for Palestine today.
Zionist Protester 5:50 ↗
Well, feminists are allowed in Israel.
Nick Shirley 5:52 ↗
Yeah.
Zionist Protester 5:53 ↗
You know, but they're not allowed in Gaza. They're not allowed in Palestine. Well, women are... you know, it's a male-dominated society.
Nick Shirley 6:02 ↗
Thank you guys for your time. We appreciate you guys for being out here. How you doing, sir?
Protester 6:05 ↗
Hey Nick, how's everything?
Nick Shirley 6:06 ↗
You got the body cam on, you're ready.
Protester 6:08 ↗
I always have my body cam on, especially you know that. You saw what happened to you the other day. People throwing water at you.
Nick Shirley 6:14 ↗
You ever get attacked for being a proud Jew out here?
Zionist Protester 6:17 ↗
I have been attacked. I've been threatened. They've threatened my mom. They've called my mom's house and threatened her. I've gotten stuff thrown on me. I've gotten water thrown on me like you. I've gotten people spit at me. These are the violent side. This is the reason why Gaza is getting what they get because these people are violent. And then they worry, then they say, 'Why are you defending yourself?' Well, if you start violence, you can't complain if somebody's going to defend themselves. It's the same thing with October 7th. They committed atrocities. They committed violence against Israel. And Israel's retaliating against them. And on top of that, you have Yemen shooting rockets at Israel. You have Iran shooting rockets at Israel. And then they scream to free Palestine. Why don't you free Israel? Why don't you tell the people to leave Israel alone? Israel is a peaceful country.

46 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Shirley, N. (2026, October 13). Confronting Pro-Palestine Protesters in NYC [Interview transcript]. Nick Shirley Interviews. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3128248/

MLA

Nick Shirley. "Confronting Pro-Palestine Protesters in NYC." Nick Shirley Interviews, 13 Oct. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3128248/.

BibTeX
@misc{shirley2026_3128248,
  author       = {Nick Shirley},
  title        = {Confronting Pro-Palestine Protesters in NYC},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Nick Shirley Interviews. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {oct},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3128248/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}