CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Nick Shirley
YouTuber & Independent Journalist

I Investigated Gavin Newsom’s $15.6 Billion Disaster

📅 Sep 22, 2026 Nick Shirley Interviews 9 MIN 111745 VIEWS 52 SEGMENTS · 7 SPEAKERS
In this video, Nick Shirley travels to California’s Central Valley to investigate the California High-Speed Rail project. One of the largest and most controversial infrastructure projects in the country. California has already spent more than $15 billion on the project, yet passenger service has not begun. Nick visits the construction area, talks to people on the ground, and takes a closer look at where the money has gone, what has actually been built, and why the project has taken so long. Official financial reports show $15.6 billion had been spent through January 2026, while the current b...

What Nick Shirley said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

Nick Shirley investigates California's High-Speed Rail project, arguing it is failing. He claims ridership and revenue projections were wildly overstated, and that the project cannot attract private money or be built as planned, calling it unlikely to materialize in our lifetime. He criticizes the route through the Central Valley instead of I-5, saying it duplicates Amtrak, and that Central Valley residents, including his constituents in Merced, won't be able to afford tickets. He highlights homes being built on the alignment, farms split in half, and a lack of transparency from the High-Speed Rail Authority. He states the project is Governor Newsom's pet project, tied to his presidential ambitions. He confronts Senator Cortez, who defends the project and a $1 billion per year for 20 years funding commitment, while Shirley notes no track has been laid and Newsom said privately it's not possible.

Key takeaways

  1. Shirley claims ridership and revenue projections were wildly overstated and no private sector money exists for the project.
  2. Shirley says the route through the Central Valley is wrong and that constituents in Merced won't be able to afford to ride it.
  3. Shirley asserts the project is Governor Newsom's pet project and failure could prevent his presidency.
  4. Shirley reveals homes are being built on the rail alignment, and ranches will be split, harming farmers.
  5. The High-Speed Rail Authority lacks transparency, and no track has been laid despite promises of completion by 2020.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
200 mph Projected train speed metric 0:27
2020 Original promised completion date timeline 2:11
$1 billion Annual funding for 20 years approved by Senator commitment 7:35
100 billion dollars Additional funding needed estimate metric 4:55
200 billion dollars Upper estimate of additional funding needed metric 4:55
10 or 11 times Cost increase for buying developed land metric 2:56
20 years Funding commitment duration timeline 7:35
21 construction projects Ongoing construction projects cited by Senator metric 9:31

Chapters

  1. 0:00Opening remarks supporting the project
  2. 1:00Admitting overstated projections and doubts
  3. 1:41Homes built on the alignment
  4. 1:54Impact on farmers and ranches
  5. 3:20Route choice and ridership concerns
  6. 4:29Lack of transparency and funding needs
  7. 6:16Questioning political motives
  8. 7:35Confronting Senator Cortez
  9. 8:03Senator defends project and funding

Questions asked in this interview

2
  1. 4:13And that requires you now having to travel to both sides, right?
  2. 8:11It's happening. Have you been there?
Forum Speaker 0:00 ↗
Good morning, and thank you all for coming to the California High-Speed Rail Authority Industry Forum. Personally, I've been supportive of the high-speed rail project since my time as mayor of the city and county of San Francisco. Actually, it's a bit of an understatement. This is the biggest infrastructure project in California's history. We know for a fact that an infrastructure project of this scope and of this magnitude will create hundreds, literally hundreds of thousands of jobs, both now and for generations to come. And we know that our state's economy will be better overall with another option besides airports and freeways of moving people and goods all over our state. We're talking about sitting back comfortably, probably with a cup of coffee or tea in hand, and a laptop online, while the landscape flies by us at over 200 mph. We're talking about bringing the United States into the same transportation playing field as they've had for generations in Europe and Asia. We're not just planning for a political term, we're planning for decades to come.
Interviewee 1:00 ↗
We wildly overstated the ridership projections. We manipulated some of the revenue projections. There's only one true high-speed rail system in the world that generates real profit. I mean, it's a burden, politically speaking. Analysis would conclude that there's no private sector money, and there's no capacity for this to be built. But that said, if that were the process, you would kill the project, of course. Break with the tribe, there's consequences. I doubt very much even the most optimistic assessments of the next decade, the facts seem overwhelming that this project is not going to materialize in our lifetime.
Nick Shirley 1:41 ↗
In order for the high-speed rail to actually happen, they'd have to go through and buy each and every single one of these houses that is currently being built. They're building the high-speed rail while these people are building houses on the alignment. How will the farmers be affected from the high-speed rail?
Farmer 1:54 ↗
Ranches that have been contiguous for hundreds of years will now be split.
Nick Shirley 1:57 ↗
Why do you think California continues to move forward with the plan of the high-speed rail when it looks like there's no future for it here inside of California?
Interviewee 2:05 ↗
I think it's a pet project of the governor, and if he fails at this, then he won't become president of the United States.
Nick Shirley 2:11 ↗
Do you think in 20 years the high-speed rail will be done? It's promised it's going to be done in 2020.
Interviewee 2:16 ↗
Might be, might not.
Nick Shirley 2:18 ↗
So this location right here was actually bought in 2006 for developers to develop this land, and then they set forth the plan to actually go through with the high-speed rail in 2008. In order for the high-speed rail to actually happen, they're going to go through and buy each and every single one of these houses that is currently being built. Keep in mind right now they're building the high-speed rail while these people are building houses on the alignment. Let's go talk to a city manager right now. And how is it possible right now that here in California you have a government who is spending billions upon billions of dollars for this high-speed rail? Meanwhile, a construction site is right here where they're building houses on where that high-speed rail is supposed to go.
City Manager 2:56 ↗
We don't really know. Typically government buys all of the alignment up front, that way you don't have cost of buying it once it's developed like this will bring it up 10 or 11 times what bare land value would be. So we don't really know. Communication's pretty sparse, so we're left mostly in the dark.
Nick Shirley 3:11 ↗
Do you think this high-speed rail has just been some sort of fantasy for the people inside of Sacramento and the politicians of California?
City Manager 3:20 ↗
Look, you've got a project that duplicates Amtrak's current service route. I will tell you from a ground perspective, we don't understand why they're sticking two rail lines next to each other that are going to serve the same areas.
Nick Shirley 3:32 ↗
And how many more cases of this do you think are inside of this alignment for the high-speed rail?
City Manager 3:37 ↗
I don't think this is atypical. I think this has happened quite a bit up and down the valley.
Nick Shirley 3:41 ↗
California actually abandoned the route from San Francisco to Los Angeles. Now they're focusing from Merced to Bakersfield. And so the high-speed rail will actually not even be servicing people from Los Angeles to San Francisco.
The high-speed rail bridge ends over there. It continues over here onto this road, but as you'll see, it then has to go through a bunch of farmland just like this. Now, they have the road right here for the high-speed rail, but in other locations, do they have it? We're going to speak with a farmer right now.
Now, we're in the middle of an orchard right now. How will the farmers be affected from the high-speed rail?
Farmer 4:13 ↗
Ranches that have been contiguous for hundreds of years will now be split. And that requires you now having to travel to both sides, right? Your infrastructure has to be pulled from one side to the other, whether it be irrigation, power supplies, and even just operationally, it's just going to make everything real inconvenient.
Nick Shirley 4:29 ↗
When California brought about the plan for the high-speed rail, did you guys vote on it, or did you guys have any say so with it, or do you even think it's going to happen?
Farmer 4:35 ↗
You know, all the voters had a chance to vote, and it passed. But it was very vague on the ballot. No one knew where it was going to go. To me, they're putting it in all the wrong spots. It was to serve two different populations, the north of the state and the south, and where they're starting to put it is just going to impact an area that didn't need the high-speed rail to begin with.
Nick Shirley 4:55 ↗
They're allocating millions and billions of dollars to this each and every single year, and now they're saying they're going to need almost a hundred billion dollars more, if not two hundred billion dollars. What could farmers of California do if they had a hundred billion dollars invested into them?
Farmer 5:10 ↗
Oh, man. It could revolutionize the state. I mean, agriculture has been the backbone of this state since its founding. And we're not investing in water infrastructure. We're not investing in energy infrastructure. And it's sad, because we're worried about a train that's going to serve a small sector of the population. And what really needs to be done is something that's going to be good for all of us in the state.
Nick Shirley 5:33 ↗
So, pretty soon, we could see a high-speed rail come right through here where all these almonds are at, and people are going to be suffering because of it.
Farmer 5:40 ↗
Yes, and there'll probably be no one on the train.
Nick Shirley 5:42 ↗
A lot of you have questions about the route they chose to take for the high-speed rail. They could have gone through I-5, which would have connected Los Angeles and San Francisco a lot smoother. Instead, they're going through the Central Valley. How does this affect the people of California? And will people in the Central Valley even be using the high-speed rail?
Interviewee 5:58 ↗
Well, the people in Central Valley probably won't be using the high-speed rail. The cost of high-speed rail is so high right now that probably the prices to even ride high-speed rail will outprice any of the people that live in the Central Valley. My constituents in Merced won't be able to afford to ride the high-speed rail.
Nick Shirley 6:16 ↗
And why do you think California continues to move forward with the plan of the high-speed rail when it looks like there's no future for it here inside of California?

25 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Shirley, N. (2026, September 22). I Investigated Gavin Newsom’s $15.6 Billion Disaster [Interview transcript]. Nick Shirley Interviews. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3128250/

MLA

Nick Shirley. "I Investigated Gavin Newsom’s $15.6 Billion Disaster." Nick Shirley Interviews, 22 Sep. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3128250/.

BibTeX
@misc{shirley2026_3128250,
  author       = {Nick Shirley},
  title        = {I Investigated Gavin Newsom’s $15.6 Billion Disaster},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Nick Shirley Interviews. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {sep},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3128250/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}