A.I. is so much more powerful than what we ever had.
Making education better, making healthcare better.
We're gonna come in and we're gonna build a data center, and we're going to create a lot of jobs.
But then that's over when the data center's built.
But towns need to revitalize.
There's two things folks don't want to live next to: a data center or an ICE facility.
I feel like we're assuming a good faith from people who have not earned it. They're in it for the money.
You're being blackmailed, not by a person. You're being blackmailed by an A.I. agent.
If an agent can break through that cybersecurity, what else might it do?
It feels like there needs to be a general strike.
We're not at an impasse. We have a difference of opinion of what can be done and what's better for the economy and better for our country.
The A.I. industry today is the only industry that's less regulated than a sandwich shop on Eighth Avenue.
If we put a pause on our ability to improve the technology, I think it's a huge mistake.
The core question to me is, do people matter? Is that a priority, is that a goal? Is that a value we still hold?
Panelists, welcome. Our story takes place in the state of Middlevania, in the city of Betterton. Betterton was once an industrial powerhouse, but decades ago, the city's major employer, a steel mill, closed down.
Campbell Brown, Josh Tyrangiel. The two of you live here in Betterton. Campbell, you are a retired journalist. You now run your own educational nonprofit. Josh, you're a writer. You're an expert on A.I., artificial intelligence. The two of you are happily married.
And you're the proud parents of an eight-year-old boy, Liam. Unfortunately, your family's finances have taken a hit. But just yesterday, you got some good news. You received an offer: $2 million to sell your home. The buyer is Apex Systems. They want to build an A.I. data center here in Betterton. $2 million is a lot of money.
Sure is. I can think of a lot of things we could do with $2 million. But we'll probably have to leave.
We'll probably be leaving our neighbors with a less pleasant place to live if we're part of this sale.
Water issues, electricity bills. Noise. Loud hums. I guess I'm worried that all the things that we love about the place, all the reasons we decided to live here, may disappear. So maybe we stay here and we try to fight it.
Is this a hard decision for the two of you?
Are either of you anti-A.I., against it? Does that have anything to do with it?
No, it's more about community. It's a big change when data centers come into your community.
Josh, as a writer, you've covered A.I. Have you come across instances where A.I. is used for good?
Absolutely. Making education better, making healthcare better, maybe even shoring up aspects of our democracy that have been overlooked. At the same time, I care about where I live.
Mike Novogratz. You are the C.E.O. of Apex Systems, the company that's buying land for the data center here. What might you say to Campbell and Josh about how saying yes to a data center could help the people of Betterton?
Betterton Steel was an amazing company that provided a lot of jobs that doesn't exist anymore. And so, we're gonna come in and we're gonna build a data center with, you know, modern-day chillers to reduce noise, with reusable water. It's not like you're using new water all the time. And we're going to create a lot of jobs.
But these jobs appear for construction, and then they disappear. And so it's a temporary boost to the community, and I think that's the kind of thing we're afraid of.
It certainly is a short-term influx of electricians, welders, pipe fitters, so all the trades are having a real field day. But then that's over when the data center is built. But then there's still high-tech employees that stay, and so... Your community will change its dynamic some, in its makeup some, but towns need to revitalize. They need a new purpose.
But how many of those people are in our community?
It's decision time. Are you ready to sign on the dotted line right now? Sell your home, move your family?
I don't think so. Do we really want to start over somewhere? Let's stick it out together. We'll say no.
Joe Manchin, you are the governor of the great state of Middlevania. You're here in Betterton to visit your 21-year-old grandson Will.
You're pulling up to Will's apartment, and as you park, you see Will standing outside, next to his truck, panicked. He sees you, he says, "Help! Somebody broke into my truck and stole my gun. What should I do?"
Why'd you have the gun in the truck? Why in the world are you... You were raised better than that.
"It'll never happen again, I promise."
A situation like that you have to report.
"About that, Grandpa. You know how in Middlevania, there is a requirement to have a permit to carry a gun."
"I haven't gotten around to it. I'm worried that if we report this to the police..."
I don't think you would go to jail, but I think you'd get a stern warning. I definitely do, and I think you need that.
Will follows your advice. He reports it to the police. Betterton police officers turn to their newest tool, Hawk Safety. It uses A.I., automated cameras, to generate a list of every car that's passed by Will's apartment in just the past hour since he parked his truck. All of the cars on that list belong to people who live in the neighborhood, except one.
Gina Ortiz Jones, you are the mayor of Betterton. I'm wondering if this use of Hawk Safety, automated cameras, to investigate this one specific crime, a stolen gun, is something that you'd support.
Well, I think it's important that we're always trying to use technology to address and reduce time from other officers having to invest in investigating it that way. I'd be concerned, though, about making sure that we're not opening ourselves up to any civil rights issues.
Okay, the lawyers say all the cameras are in public places. The public knows about it and haven't had a lot of complaints about solving gun crimes with it.
Well, then, if it's something that we've done previously and the lawyers have signed off on it... then I think we're on a good, we're okay.
Okay. Officers track down the owner of this car. It's a man with a history of gun crimes and a domestic violence restraining order prohibiting him from contacting his ex-wife. Police get a search warrant from a judge. They find your grandson's gun. They find evidence he's been stalking his ex-wife. So, now, Mayor Jones, do you think this use of Hawk Safety is a win for the people of Betterton?
Yes, helping people understand the way in which time was saved, the firearm was addressed, and this person is no longer a threat in that way, I think is important to share with the public.
Astead Herndon. You are a senior politics reporter and editor at the "Betterton Times."
The largest newspaper in Middlevania. You're sitting at your desk in the newsroom when a junior reporter files a story about this gun that the Betterton police just recovered using Hawk Safety. You read the story and something's off.
Doesn't seem like it was written by him.
If I'm confident in that, I would ask them. "This doesn't look like your previous writing. Take me through the process of how you put this together."
"Okay, Astead. So, I did interview the police officers, and I wrote a rough draft, checked all the facts. I asked A.I. to improve my draft and just double-check to make sure everything was accurate."
Why? What are you worried about?
You should be writing through your stories. So, if you did the interview, that's step one. But I would expect that our newspaper prints the words of the people who the byline says. So, I would want you to rewrite it.
But if he did the work and did the interviews and wrote a draft of the story, what's wrong with putting it through ChatGPT or Claude, or whatever A.I.? It's almost the same as having an editor, getting a version of it that's been edited and had a second set of eyes on it.
I don't think it's similar to an editor, because that's a person who's put in that position to make calls with kind of community in mind. And I think that's a core function of our newsroom. So, I feel like I would not have many qualms in saying if the prose of the piece was written by Claude, that ain't our job.
What if the story was better?
I should have a better reporter. Flattening our work is not going to help us in the short or long run.
What about if you say on the byline, "Jim Jones, with assistance from A.I."? Like, what if it's recognized?
That would be better ethically, but I would say as a consumer, I would think less of you as a reporter. It wouldn't actually solve the core of the problem, even though I do think that transparency would be better than not saying it at all.
We have a lot of concerns in this room already. Meanwhile, the debate over the Betterton Data Center is heating up. Apex Systems is buying land for its data center, but the deal is not yet sealed. Under Betterton law, a project this large must be approved in a citywide vote. Anti-data center organizers are planning a huge protest in downtown Betterton. Thousands of people planning to attend.
Max Tegmark, you are one of the nation's leading experts on A.I. You're a scientist at the Betterton Institute of Technology. Is this data center protest, is it really just about little old Betterton, or is it about something bigger, all of us, in this moment in history?
Yeah, it's about something much, much bigger. All of these issues are about something much, much bigger. You know, we humans have gradually gotten more and more empowered through science, you know? And now you have a small group of folks who start talking about how they want to build machines that are just so much smarter and better than us at everything, that we humans might actually not be needed anymore. And they promise that it's going to be fine somehow because these A.I.s are going to be nice to us, but I happen to really like this democratic idea that people should have a say if someone wants to completely change all aspects of our society. I don't really feel that's happening. I don't think these decisions should be made only in some back rooms in Silicon Valley by some folks who've had too much Red Bull to drink.
It's been popular for some people to say they believe the percentage chance of civilization extinction is X. What's your percentage chance that...
Oh, I think, if we actually let these folks, these companies, just do whatever they want, as opposed to all other companies in the U.S., who actually have to meet some safety standards, then I think it's almost obviously going to end badly. And I kind of like the fact that humans are in charge here, not just here in our town.
And I want to keep it that way.
All right. You get a phone call from the president of the Betterton Institute of Technology. He says, "Max, I heard you were giving this speech at the protest. You know our university has this partnership with Apex Systems. They're giving tens of millions of dollars for lifesaving medical research, cutting-edge scientific advances, educational tools for our students. If you criticize Apex and A.I., and that partnership goes away, we're in real trouble."
The reason I accepted this job here at your institute, and kept it, even though I was offered ten times more salary to go work for various companies, is 'cause I really value my freedom to speak my mind.
Ah. So, thank you for your opinion. It's been noted. You're a fan of academic freedom and of tenure?
Yeah, and I'm not for sale.
Okay, Sara Nelson. You are an emerging leader in the American Federation of Workers. Protest organizers are interested in having you speak. They'd like you to talk about jobs. Is that a speech you're interested in giving?
I'd be happy to give that speech.
I'd be happy to give that speech because we know that fighting for jobs is not only about fighting for paychecks. What I'd like to do is to invite the community to really rise up and use this moment with the data center. It's not really just about this individual data center. It's about what we should be demanding of our federal government in putting regulation around A.I. so that we can ensure that there's a protection of good work and good jobs, so that we can ensure that humanity is in control, and so that we can ensure that we're not destroying the environment and everything else. Here's a moment where everyone's paying attention.
And as a union leader, I know that that's actually when you set your demands and you can make progress on policy.
...of our local paper, as a former journalist?
There's so much misinformation around data centers coming from both sides, and I would think that step one would be to actually do the pros and cons and what's true and what's not true. What do they actually do when it comes to water? What does it actually mean for electricity prices? What does it actually mean for jobs long term?
Yeah, I think there's a lot of value in kind of separating fact and fiction on that front. It goes beyond the question of just people's anxiety around electricity or water consumption or things that I do think can be rife with misinformation. You know, in my experience, it's been about process and about a community kind of disempowered, and feeling like a kind of changing society and work has been imposed on them. And so, oftentimes, I think both sides of that story are important. The kind of factual piece...
...that speaks to what's true and not true, and the kind of emotional piece that I think is completely separate from that.
Okay. Sara, you're getting ready for your speech when you get a text message from an old friend. She's the leader of the National Electricians Union. She says, "Please don't give that speech. Apex Systems is one of the good guys. They've promised to hire only members of our union. If the data center goes down, that's hundreds of good, high-paying jobs gone. So please, out of solidarity, can you stand down?"
What we should talk about is the power of solidarity. We need to get into a room with the electricians and people from all the different sectors, because we've got an emergency here. Let's keep everyone in their jobs, getting their paychecks, so that they're connected to their healthcare, they're connected to their retirement, they're continuing to pay taxes into the tax base. And I actually think we have a lot of power here together...
...to get even more than what's being promised to you.
But you're still going to do the speech.
I'm going to do the speech, because I'm not going to have them dividing us.
Because that is really how we end up with nothing as individuals.
Okay. Many people oppose the data center for reasons that Max and Sara have talked about, but many people support it. One of the supporters, a local business leader, comes to you, Mike Novogratz. Says, "Mike, if there's one thing everyone in Betterton can agree on, it's that we don't want China stealing our jobs. So I'm going to take out some ads and say that China's amplifying anti-data center views. Maybe they're behind this protest against the data center." Is that a good idea, Mike?
Listen, I think there's truth to that, right? There's truth that China and Russia constantly are amplifying views to create discord in America. There's proof behind that, and I think that's part of this. But I think the data center question goes to something much deeper, and it's up to the people who are promoting A.I. to really pitch this idea that it's good for people, that there's an abundance story coming, that it's going to create new jobs, different jobs, as it makes old jobs more obsolete. And it's a really hard thing for any of us to get.
A.I. is so much more powerful than what we ever had. It is dangerously powerful. And even when all the big hyperscalers are telling you, "Maybe we better slow down. Maybe we better take another look at this. Let's put some guardrails on," we as a government, president of the United States on down, has a responsibility to the people of this great country. How do you protect them? How do you give them some protection that they're not basically taking off with the technology that can go beyond the humans' control?
So, folks, the data center protest is now two days away. Mayor Jones, you receive credible reports that violence might break out at this protest. Hawk Safety, the company that helped us recover our stolen gun, has given Betterton access to a beta version of its newest tool, Hawk A.I. Hawk A.I. can generate confidential reports of suspicious individuals using A.I. analysis of public records, commercial databases, criminal history, camera feeds, social media feeds. So your police chief says, "Mayor Jones, I think we should use Hawk A.I. to produce just two or three reports of the most high-risk individuals who could cause terrible violence at this protest. Are you interested?"
Not interested in beta versions. We need things that have been tried and tested, our lawyers are comfortable with, et cetera, especially something like this. I think we've got sufficient personnel and drone surveillance to be able to handle it adequately.
So you're a no, you don't want this...
Not the beta version, no.
In my world, you do everything you can to prevent and protect, if you can. You basically use the technology that you have to be able to identify people that might be of a high risk or high volatility. And you try to intervene with that before it happens. When you have that many people on the street, you got a mob mentality. Someone's looking to just...
Without understanding the actual benefit of it and not understanding the guardrails that they're going to put in place with the information that they're going to collect, we don't know what that is, they haven't shared that with us, and unfortunately, in 48 hours, we don't have enough time to run that through.
Well, I would say that basically, you've identified the people, the two or three people who are basically the leaders of this. I'm going to bring them down, sit them down, say, "Okay, where are we going from here?"
It's not theoretical, leave the police some time.
With 48 hours, though, this is not the time to be trying new things, especially if there's sufficient ability of police officers and the others...
I'll take 48 minutes if I can get it to stop something bad.
That sounds like the movie "Minority Report," though. I mean, in the old Soviet Union, they used to also bring people in because, somehow, the KGB had said that they were ringleaders, but... We have civil liberties for a reason.
Listen, I think over the last, you know, 200 years, 250 years of America, we have biased our justice system against a certain group of people. A.I. is a tool, program that tool with people that still have inherent bias, the minorities are going to be the ones that are targeted. And so I think you have to be very, very careful, you're in such dangerous territory, and 48 hours isn't enough. I would agree with the...
You agree with the mayor?
I want to give Sara Nelson, sorry.
Let me just say, like, the trust piece is so important. There's this idea of, like, "Well, it could do this, it could do that." Well, it could also, if it doesn't work well, break people's trust further and make it harder for us to actually employ smart technologies that are trusted and tested.
If you can intervene at any time, you can intervene, 48 seconds, 48 minutes, 48 hours, 48 days, whatever you can do, you take it.
I'm not sure if there's going to be a riot, though. You know, the people who want to protest are people who believe in nonviolence.
Okay, folks. It's now the day of the data center protest. The whole city is on edge. Mayor Jones, you get an email from Hawk Safety, subject line: Daily Crime Report. It's unusually personal. Says, "Dear Mayor, there are private emails from the police chief saying that he wanted to use Hawk A.I. to generate reports of suspicious individuals, but you overruled him. He got angry. He wrote to his fellow officers that you are soft on crime. You must use my Hawk A.I. tools to protect the people or I will disclose that embarrassing email to the public." Does it feel like you're being threatened?