This is Bloomberg Businessweek daily reporting from the magazine that helps global leaders stay ahead with insight on the people, companies, and trends shaping today's complex economy, plus global business, finance and tech news as it happens. The Bloomberg Businessweek daily podcast with Carol Massar and Tim Stanback.
I want to bring in Christine Aquino because she oversees the markets live blog here at Bloomberg. And I would imagine you had an incredibly busy day just going through these numbers. Before we bring you in, Christine, taking a look at the equity markets, the S&P 500 fell 1.8%, the Nasdaq Composite down 2.9%, the Dow down a little over 1%. How do you explain today's selloff?
I mean, honestly, Tim, the explanation eludes many of us watching markets today because, you know, before today, the explanation was that, oh, well, this is just a rotation, right? We've seen this before. This has actually been happening beneath the surface, even though the index level moves haven't necessarily shown it. We've seen investors kind of go back and forth out of tech and to non-tech sectors and then back again. And then today that theory just went out the window because everything was solidly sold. I mean, even I was looking at the equal-weighted S&P 500 earlier, it was still in the green at the beginning of the session. That fell by the wayside by the close. And so now it's kind of the question is, a broad sell-off, is it a foot...
Also the question I have is, right, well the VIX ended up closing so close around 4:15 minutes after...
But yes, exactly. So it closed below 20. It was at 19, a spot for it there. So even then we saw it spike around 24, 25 earlier today. We did see, we were talking about this earlier, that volatility and some of it coming in toward the closing bell.
So whenever you're speaking with your sources, whether they're watching price technicians, what do they think that means for like the setup potentially? Does that bode well if you're going into Monday?
Yeah, I mean, very interesting to us, because again, right, even in volatility markets, there's so much going on beneath the surface that the index moves aren't necessarily micro levels. Absolutely. And we're seeing kind of a lot of hedging to one side or the other beneath that surface. And so, you know, what that's telling me is, you know, there's not one kind of macro or catalyst, one big catalyst that's moving everything. There's a lot of kind of different little things that investors are responding to. And that's where we're not necessarily kind of seeing those big index moves apart from today, that we've seen and moving forward that really I think maybe creates a little bit more bifurcation in markets.
Right. And that's kind of the big question, the existential question that we're trying to get at is what's going to separate the winners and losers now heading into next week from the earnings perspective. Was it cash? And then just in a broad markets perspective, is it right? We might have to have this conversation with you on Tuesday afternoon.
Because that could be one that shows us that, okay, maybe investors are continuing to, at least right now, award companies, their favorite companies that are not spending so much on CapEx.
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, that seems to have become the sticking point now in this earnings season, right? Because even though we've seen still kind of a healthy set of results from the big tech companies, but it really is all about that cash flow now, that CapEx figure and whether they're showing enough to justify how much they're spending on...
I know Apple, though, I'm kind of interested in how their push toward hardware and products is going to fare when we're in this environment where affordability is also an issue.
Yeah, but I've had a look at how quickly they sold out. And we don't know the exact inventory of foldable phones because it's a $2,000 phone.
That's true. You have to be at a certain part of the K to drop two K on.
Yeah, that's right. Yeah, I mean, yeah, perhaps the K-shaped economy is going to help them in this case, catering to those, the premium part of the K.
Stay with us. More from Bloomberg Businessweek daily. Coming up after this.
Special day, a lot of stocks lower, but shares of Intercontinental Exchange, the parent of the New York Stock Exchange, up, up today and up more than 9% in the last two days. The company having the best two-day run going all the way back to March of 2020. This after ICE's third-quarter adjusted earnings per share beat the average analyst estimate. And then in the wake of the print yesterday, we get news that seven analysts who cover the company raised their price targets by an average of 5.5%. That's according to data from Bloomberg. On top of that, our colleague Kat Dougherty broke the news that ICE joined forces with one of the market operators behind the offshore crypto trading platform Hyperliquid, as it seeks to bring perpetual futures products into U.S. regulated markets. For more and for an exclusive interview, we're joined by Jeff Sprecher. He's the founder and CEO of Intercontinental Exchange. He joins us here at Bloomberg Headquarters in New York. Jeff, good to see you again. Welcome.
We're going to get to everything that you guys are doing at ICE with perpetual futures. But before we do that, I just want you to weigh in on the markets today because the Nasdaq 100 down more than 4%, the S&P is down more than 2.2%. Worst days in months. What's your view there?
Um, you know, markets climb a wall of worry. And, uh, and so it feels like we've had an unbelievable year. And the eye trade, uh, um, says apocalypse, uh, and, you know, a lot of inputs into the market. It feels like this is something that has to happen, you know, retrenchment, uh, before it can continue to go up. But, um, you know, it's just part of, part of being a long-term investor is tolerating it.
Oh, you're joking about running the casino. Whenever you're speaking with clients, how do they feel right now? What are their questions towards you? Which are top questions? Top concerns.
Yeah. Well, we focus a lot on new companies trying to go public. And, um, um, and we've had, I think, 73 companies go public on the New York Stock Exchange so far this year, more than all of last year. Um, but now there's a retrenchment. Um, uh, what you're talking about is, is, uh, has bankers and others saying, let's let things settle down before we take new companies public.
Yeah, we'll see how long this, this goes on. I mean, what do you think?
Hard to know, but, uh, I don't have to know.
Well, let's talk a little bit about the way you're diversifying things over at Intercontinental Exchange. Uh, ICE and TradeXYZ are planning a new market for trading, uh, perps. Uh, as part of this, you're taking a stake in TradeXYZ. As part of the agreement, billionaire Stan Druckenmiller also investing in TradeXYZ. It's a big push into retail for you. Why do you want to bring perpetual futures products into U.S. regulated markets?
Well, you know, I was invited, uh, when the president was trying to push the crypto bill through Congress. I was invited to a press conference he did, and he actually asked me to stand next to him.
And, uh, uh, you guys have a relationship that goes back years, which, you know, your wife is also part of the wife of this administration. This administration is a cabinet member.
And, uh, and so, uh, and I'm a Mar-a-Lago member. So, uh, anyway, I've actually paid him money. The, um, I was standing next to him, and, uh, you guys probably are used to this, but there was a gaggle of reporters that were staring us down and microphones and people jostling. Um, other than your Tyler Kendall, who was, who is lovely, but, uh, it's kind of this crazy thing. And so I didn't know what to do. I took a half a step away from him so that I wouldn't be in the shot, and I just stared at the script as he was weaving around, and I looked over there and I saw, uh, that it said, we're going to bring Hyperliquid to the United States and regulate them. And I walked out of there, said, okay, um, we should do that. You know, like, uh, so just as an entrepreneur, I just saw an opportunity. Uh, I befriended the founders of these companies and, uh, and went to them and said, you know, we can help.
So talk a little bit more about that because, like you said, the deal has been in the works. You began speaking with Hyperliquid and TradeXYZ some months ago. TradeXYZ's founder is known only by Shoku to most people. Right? Um, take us there. How did you get comfortable partnering with and investing in an organization whose leadership team is entirely anonymous?
Yeah. And, and I would also tell you that Hyperliquid, there's two founders and one, uh, who I know is also has a similar pseudonym. Um, I don't, you know, it's part of the ethos of this crypto community. And, and what the government's saying, starting with the president on down, is, um, and, you know, what you're seeing in Binance yesterday is, hey, we have to get these platforms into the United States, get some regulatory oversight, get some accountability and sustainability into these businesses. And so, um, you know, it is a bit of the Wild West, and, and I'm an old guy that's been in the industry for a long time. And I was like, okay, I can, I can, I understand the, the guardrails, I can help you guys.
Talk to us more about that to you, because you've said these products can be addictive, but then at the same time won't cannibalize your existing product, saying their current clients are mostly institutional, whereas when it comes to perpetual futures, those are more on the retail side of that. So make the case for investors who might be concerned that this could cannibalize some of your existing products. Why won't it?
Um, it's a great question, and I think investors are asking us that question honestly. We run the world's largest energy exchange, and, um, uh, the average hold in our energy exchange is six months or longer. If you look at perpetual futures, oil on, um, on these, uh, platforms, the average hold is 12 hours. Okay. It's not even a day. So these are, these are people that are just, you know, saying, I think oil's going to go up or down, or I think there could be a conflict in the Middle East or something that would, that would be an input to the market. Um, that just won't work for, for utilities and oil companies and people that are trying to lay off risk to make long-term investments. So I do think the two are separate. They're highly correlated. Um, but, uh, I don't think, you know, the average, uh, perp investor really wants to, uh, to deal, uh, crossing with a, you know, one-year or ten-year contract with a large oil company, and a large oil company isn't going to be in there for 12.
You see the audiences as totally distinct.
I do. I mean, they may merge together, and that's partly why we want to be involved in this. But at this point in time, it's just so different trading behavior.
I feel like we can't talk about this in a vacuum because Kalshi just announced this, uh, new round yesterday. $1 billion raise, $80 billion. So eight, $40 billion valuation.
Um, maybe it's hard to keep track at this point. Um, it launched perpetual futures just a few months ago. The business has hit over $80 billion in volume, over 500,000 traders. Is this partnership ICE's effort to catch up?
Well, we're, we're a major investor in Polymarket, which is also a direct competitor to Kalshi. But, uh, no, I was really, um, uh, you know, there's a technology shift going on. There's a, there's a, there's a trading behavior shift, and we just want to be a part of it. Um, um, it's not in our DNA. I mean, you know, we're dealing with at the New York Stock Exchange, everybody who's there is a major broker-dealer, all the brand names that you would know. And in the oil industry, it's all, you know, you and I, I'll never buy in a barrel of oil. Um, but here you have this new cohort that's, that's, you know, rabidly, uh, trading, and, uh, and we just didn't want to ignore it.
Terry Duffy over at CME had said he's been very concerned when it comes to the rise of perpetual futures, uh, because giving retail access to what he said could potentially be excessive levels of risk. Is he wrong? Would you agree with that?
Um, I partly agree with Terry, which is that these, uh, products need to be regulated. And I think, um, the CME Group, where that he, uh, leads, has said we think the CFTC should be the regulator. The CFTC itself has said we think we should be the regulator. So, um, the CME and the, and the government agree that these should be regulated. There's a disagreement about the actual details of that regulation. My own view is it will sort itself out. Um, you know, these are new markets. They, some things will go wrong. Some, some challenges will appear. Regulators are going to have to deal with it. Um, but I've seen that time and time again having started the business. And so, uh, you know, we're voice of reason, I think, in terms of being one of the most highly regulated, uh, exchanges in the world.
Ah, Howard, how are the talks with regulators and your team going right now on this?
I think they're happy that, uh, that we have been able to attract, uh, TradeXYZ and hype to come to the, uh, U.S. to set themselves up. We're also an investor in OKX, yeah, which I would say to you is probably the second largest exchange after Binance. Uh, we're also working with them to bring them into the US. The nice thing about these crypto entrepreneurs is they do have a mindset that if you really want to be global, you can't ignore the United States. These are the deepest, biggest capital markets. And so, um, and so, you know, they're working with us to help them navigate how to come over and get regulated.
Is this all about making it one step closer to 24/7 equity trading?
It is, yeah. Um, the, you know, the, the thing that the crypto guys have done, and it's what Binance is dealing with right now, is they figured out how to move capital over the internet. Um, whereas traditional finance moves capital on private networks, but it's closed on the weekend. So, um, you know, the stablecoins and the crypto, uh, tokenized deposits have, have sort of taken the place, the banking system, but it is vulnerable, as we see. So, um, we are working with the big banks to, to work on how we can move money when the banking system would otherwise be closed, because there is a demand around the world.
Can you give us a prediction on when you think we will see 24/7 equity trading?