CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
David Solomon
Chairman & CEO, Goldman Sachs Group Inc

LIVE: Global Banking Leaders Gather In Hong Kong For Annual Financial Leaders Summit | AF1D

📅 Nov 02, 2026 DRM News 420 MIN 1355 VIEWS 431 SEGMENTS · 36 SPEAKERS
Global banking leaders gather in Hong Kong for the city's annual Global Financial Leaders Summit. Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon and UBS CEO Sergio Ermotti are among the executives attending as Hong Kong seeks to reinforce its position as an international financial hub amid geopolitical and technological uncertainties. Watch live coverage from Hong Kong. For more details, watch our story and subscribe to our channel, DRM News. LIVE: Global Banking Leaders Gather In Hong Kong For Annual Financial Leaders Summit | AF1D Hong Kong financial summit, Global Financial Leaders Summit, Hong Kong fi...

What David Solomon said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

David Solomon, Chairman and CEO of Goldman Sachs, discussed the current market dynamics, noting the US economy's resilience despite headwinds from the Middle East war and narrow earnings growth, with 65% of S&P earnings growth coming from 10 companies. He expressed optimism about the technology supercycle and its potential for productivity gains, while acknowledging uncertainties and potential bumps. On mega IPOs, he highlighted a top-quartile environment for equity capital raising, with $160 trillion in public equity markets providing ample capital for good companies. Regarding AI, he described it as an extraordinary technology with near-term demand vastly exceeding supply, but cautioned that nobody knows how it will play out over 3-10 years, with winners and losers expected. He emphasized Goldman Sachs' role as an advisor and capital raiser, with over $4 trillion under supervision. On competition from non-bank market makers like Citadel Securities, he framed them as both partners and competitors, predicting both will do well.

Key takeaways

  1. 65% of S&P earnings growth has come from just 10 companies, indicating narrow market breadth.
  2. Goldman Sachs has over $4 trillion under supervision in its asset management business.
  3. The US economy is 'incredibly resilient' despite headwinds from the Middle East war.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
65% Share of S&P earnings growth from 10 companies metric 1:33:13
$160 trillion Size of public equity markets worldwide metric 1:35:22
over $4 trillion Assets under supervision in Goldman Sachs asset management metric 1:43:39
65% Share of US job growth from small businesses metric 1:43:39

Chapters

  1. 0:00Market dynamics and US economy
  2. 1:35:22Mega IPO pipeline and capital markets
  3. 1:43:18AI financing and technology supercycle
  4. 1:46:43Competition from non-bank market makers

Questions asked in this interview

4
  1. 1:34:56David, how do you see the general mega IPO pipeline developing in the coming months?
  2. 1:36:23Where is the capital coming from?
  3. 1:42:25So what do we have, an AI bubble, guppy hunger games, or parabolic growth in AI?
  4. 1:45:50How do you see this play out over the next decade?
Unknown 0:00 ↗
discovery, clearing and physical delivery. Our gold central clearing and settlement system, which entered trial operation in July to strong market feedback, is scheduled to launch in the first quarter of next year, with delivery connect linking to the Shanghai Gold Exchange and alignment with the London Bullion Market Association standards underway. Hong Kong is emerging as a trusted hub where Asia's gold flow meets global standards.
Turning to fintech, Hong Kong continues to rank first globally for fintech offerings in the Global Financial Centers Index. We are home to more than 1,400 fintech companies, including eight digital banks, four virtual insurers, and 12 licensed virtual assets trading platforms. They create a vibrant ecosystem rooted in innovation.
Sustainable finance is another core strength. Last year, green and sustainable debts issued in Hong Kong exceeded 76 billion US dollars, and green and sustainable bonds arranged here amounted to about 38 billion US dollars, ranking first in Asia for the eighth consecutive year. In September, we issued close to 2.66 billion US dollars equivalent in digital green bonds, that I'm pleased to say is the world's largest digital bond issuance.
Then there is the northern metropolis. It takes up one-third of Hong Kong's land area and is located right next to the enterprising mainland city of Shenzhen. The northern metropolis will rise as a strategic hub integrating education, technology, industry, talent, and a quality living environment. It will be home to three university towns as well as dedicated land for I&T development. I invite you to partner with Hong Kong in developing the northern metropolis into an innovation, technology, and talent hub.
Ladies and gentlemen, while the global financial playbook is being rewritten, one timeless investor imperative endures: the search for certainty, clarity, and confidence. Hong Kong delivers on all three. That confidence is reflected in our international engagement. Just two weeks ago, the APEC finance ministers' meeting was held in Hong Kong for the first time as part of APEC China 2026, underscoring our super connector status.
Later this month, I will attend the APEC economic leaders' meeting in Shenzhen representing Hong Kong, China. I'll be working with economies representing some three billion people and more than 60% of global GDP. Our goal is clear: to advance open trade, investment, and regional economic cooperation. Cooperation creates collaboration and the rewards of mutual opportunities.
I invite you to rethink the playbook with us. Leverage our world-beating fintech offerings to try next-generation financial products. Take advantage of our gold and commodity infrastructure. Join our growing green finance marketplace. Launch new financing products for the innovative creations in the northern metropolis, and do it all in the stability and certainty of Hong Kong, where East meets West, where global finance thrives in dynamism and security.
Ladies and gentlemen, at the inaugural edition of this summit, five years ago in 2022, we were reopening Hong Kong's doors after the pandemic, putting Hong Kong back on the global stage again. Now five years later in 2026 at this fifth summit, Hong Kong is resplendent on stage with renewed ambitions. We will rethink and rewrite the playbook with all of you. We will show the world how we could pair market agility with governmental foresight. On that note, I wish you all a productive summit and time too to enjoy the many pleasures of Hong Kong, Asia's world city. Thank you.
Host 5:18 ↗
Thank you very much, Chief Executive, for your keynote and for sharing with us your vision for Hong Kong. Ladies and gentlemen, Hong Kong is widely recognized for its role as a unique gateway connecting the Chinese mainland with international markets, serving as a critical bridge that facilitates the flow of capital, talent, and innovation between the East and the West. Today, we are very honored to have Mr. He Lifeng, Vice Premier of the State Council of the People's Republic of China, to deliver an opening keynote for us through video. Let us now welcome Vice Premier He Lifeng.
He Lifeng 5:59 ↗
Distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, it is my great pleasure to join the fifth Global Financial Leaders' Investment Summit by video entrusted by Premier Li Qiang. On behalf of the central government, I extend warm congratulations on the convening of this summit and also sincere welcome to all guests.
President Xi Jinping always cares deeply about Hong Kong's development. He has given earnest instructions and high hopes for Hong Kong to sustain long-term prosperity and stability and better integrate into and serve overall national development.
With steadfast central government support, the Hong Kong SAR government has united all sectors of Hong Kong in hard work, reform, and innovation. The practice of one country, two systems has deepened, and Hong Kong's transition from stability to prosperity has steadily consolidated, yielding notable new progress in economic and social development. In the first three quarters of this year, Hong Kong posted its highest economic growth in nearly five years. Three key growth drivers — exports, investment, and consumption — worked in tandem.
Cargo and trade volumes rose steadily. Global talents kept flowing in. Sci-tech innovation advanced on the fast track. Overall social stability held firm, and Hong Kong residents lived and worked in peace and contentment.
Hong Kong's capital market has grown more competitive and attractive, with IPO fundraising ranking among the world's top. Its offshore RMB market expanded steadily, further cementing its status as the world's largest offshore RMB hub and underscoring its strengths as an international financial center. Hong Kong brims with robust development momentum, and its transition from stability to prosperity is more evident than ever.
Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, this year marks the launch of China's 15th five-year plan. Officially released in March, the national 15th five-year plan delivers top-level design and a strategic blueprint for China's high-quality development over the next five years and beyond.
Faced with a complex and challenging external environment this year, we have stayed focused on our own priorities and solidly advanced high-quality development. China's GDP rose 4.6% year-on-year in the first three quarters, remaining among the top major global economies.
China's economic momentum is shifting towards new drivers and its structure toward optimization, with this trend further entrenched. The economy demonstrates strong resilience and stamina. In finance, we balance development and security, making solid, orderly progress in risk prevention, enhanced regulation, and high-quality development, achieving remarkable new results in financial work.
We have implemented a moderately accommodative monetary policy with liquidity remaining ample. Social financing costs have fallen to historic lows, and financial institutions have improved their risk resilience and capacity to serve the real economy. Financial markets stayed generally stable, with growing support for sci-tech innovation. Central-local regulatory coordination has been strengthened, and risks in key sectors have been resolved in an orderly, prudent manner.
We have accelerated financial rule-of-law building. The financial law has been submitted to the Standing Committee of the NPC for deliberation. We have also formulated the 15-year plan for building a strong financial powerhouse, rolling out comprehensive arrangements for high-quality financial development over the next five years, steering China's financial sector steadily towards the grand goal of a strong financial powerhouse along a path of financial development with Chinese characteristics.
Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, Hong Kong's development has always moved in tandem with the nation, resonating with its progress. Building and developing Hong Kong well remains a key strategic consideration for the central government.
Promoting Hong Kong's long-term prosperity and stability forms an important part of the national 15th five-year plan. Building on the 14th five-year plan, it sets concrete arrangements to help Hong Kong consolidate and sharpen its competitive edges and better integrate into and serve overall national development. For the first time, major Hong Kong-related projects are included in the national five-year plan, enriching the connotation of Hong Kong's high-quality development and entrusting it with greater historic missions.
This year marks Hong Kong SAR's proactive alignment with the national 15th five-year plan. Hong Kong has rolled out its first five-year plan to set the goals, map out the priorities, and define the path over the next five years. This will surely consolidate social consensus in Hong Kong, unlock innovation vitality, boost growth momentum, and help Hong Kong sustain its competitive strength. We view Hong Kong's implementation of its five-year plan with utmost confidence and high expectations. We will continue to offer full support and safeguards for Hong Kong's long-term prosperity and stability.
Here, I would like to put forward four suggestions. First, fully leverage the advantages of one country, two systems to upgrade and advance a free and open economic environment. Facts have fully proven that one country, two systems is Hong Kong's greatest strength and source of confidence for long-term prosperity and stability.
Under the solid safeguards of one country, two systems, Hong Kong has long maintained world-class business conditions, ranking high globally in economic freedom, talent appeal, and international competitiveness.
We hope Hong Kong will uphold the foundation of one country, harness the benefits of two systems, leverage its unique strengths of backing on the motherland and connecting to the world, further highlight its international character, deepen global exchanges and cooperation in economy, technology, and people-to-people fields, and create greater convenience and opportunities for international capital, institutions, and talents to start and grow businesses here in Hong Kong.
We will continue to fully support Hong Kong in preserving its unique status and strength, build a more competitive, free and open economic environment, and create broader room for future development.
Second, further consolidate financial development. Consolidate and enhance Hong Kong's status as an international financial center. Hong Kong boasts deep-rooted financial strengths. Building an international financial center tops the four centers and one highland agenda. It plays an irreplaceable role in Hong Kong's high-quality development and represents shared expectations of the central government and all sectors in Hong Kong.
We hope Hong Kong will consolidate its traditional financial strengths, guard against risks and strengthen regulation, improve capital market inclusiveness and competitiveness, reinforce its role as a global offshore RMB business hub, grow high-quality banking, securities and insurance services, and strengthen its functions as an asset, wealth and risk management center.
Meanwhile, it should expand the scope of financial services, pursue innovation in commodities, fintech, and green finance, and build a more complete and efficient financial system.
Under the central government's overall arrangements, since the start of this year, national financial regulators have rolled out a package of measures to support Hong Kong's international financial center, including deepening cross-border financial market connectivity, supporting mainland enterprises to list in Hong Kong, boosting liquidity in Hong Kong's offshore RMB markets, backing Hong Kong to launch RMB China government bond futures, and scaling up RMB bond issuance in Hong Kong.
We will continue to guide relevant authorities to faithfully implement these policies and introduce additional measures as needed, inject fresh impetus into Hong Kong's financial development, help Hong Kong tackle various risks and challenges, and safeguard financial security.
Third, continue to strengthen financial capacity, supporting high-quality development of Hong Kong's society and economy. Finance constitutes Hong Kong's core competitiveness and key growth driver, as well as a vital pillar for its economic and social high-quality development. The financial sector has long provided strong backing for Hong Kong's industrial growth, sci-tech innovation, and livelihood improvement.
We hope Hong Kong will stay focused on the four centers, one highland goals. Leverage its abundant financial resources, sound systems, mature business environment, and efficient services. Fully implement the finance-plus initiative. Deepen integration between finance and sci-tech innovation, trade and shipping, green development, and intellectual property rights. Accelerate northern metropolis building. Foster emerging industries and plan ahead for future industries. Allow financial capital to fully empower various sectors. Optimize economic structure and strengthen economic resilience.
We will keep supporting mainland and Hong Kong financial institutions and stakeholders to enhance experience sharing and exchange mechanisms for better economic and social high-quality development. We support Chinese-funded institutions in Hong Kong to take part in local economic and social development based on realities and help Hong Kong make new strides in high-quality growth.
Fourth, to solidly implement the five-year plan, thereby better integrating into and serving overall national development. The 15th five-year plan period is critical for China to lay solid foundations and forge ahead toward basically realizing socialist modernization. It is also a key phase for Hong Kong to strengthen its competitiveness and advance from stability to prosperity.
The motherland is Hong Kong's firmest foundation. Steady progress in Chinese-style modernization brings broad opportunities and solid guarantees for Hong Kong's sustained prosperity, and Hong Kong has huge potential to further integrate into and serve overall national development. We hope Hong Kong will seize these opportunities brought by national reform and development, deeply align with the national 15th five-year plan, especially the GBA and the Belt and Road Initiative.
Further act as a bridge, a link, and a window, contribute its strengths to meet national needs, sustain its prosperity rooted in national development, and tell well China's reform and opening-up stories to showcase the fruitful outcomes of China's deepening reform and high-level opening up, to sail and forge ahead through wind and waves together with the motherland on the great vessel of the Chinese nation's rejuvenation.
We will continue to guide relevant central and local authorities to strengthen coordination with Hong Kong, advance alignment of rules and mechanisms between the mainland, Hong Kong, and Macau, and create a sound policy and institutional environment for Hong Kong to integrate into and serve overall national development.
Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, today major changes unseen in a century are accelerating. Amid shifting global landscapes, peace, development, cooperation, and win-win results remain an irresistible historical trend and shared aspiration of visionary people across the international community.
This year, President Xi Jinping and US President Trump completed historic mutual visits within six months. They build a constructive, strategically stable China-US relationship, advancing mutual respect, peaceful coexistence, and win-win cooperation between the two nations, injecting strong certainty and positive energy into global stability and development.
International friends present today are supporters, defenders, and promoters of economic globalization, as well as witnesses, participants, and contributors to China's reform and opening up and Hong Kong's prosperity. On behalf of the Chinese government, I express sincere gratitude for your long-term care and support.
China will unswervingly expand high-standard opening up. We hope you will keep supporting China's reform and opening up and Hong Kong's development, share new opportunities from Chinese-style modernization, and jointly make greater contributions to global economic prosperity and stability. In closing, I wish this Global Financial Leaders' Investment Summit a complete success. Thank you.
Host 20:31 ↗
Thank you, Vice Premier He Lifeng, for the insightful address. Ladies and gentlemen, please remain seated while we set the stage for the next session. Let me take this opportunity to thank our Chief Executive, Mr. Lee, for his valuable time and for his remarks today. Due to prior commitments, Mr. Lee will now be departing the venue. Please put our hands together again for Mr. Lee to thank him for joining us today.
Ladies and gentlemen, please be seated. For four consecutive years, this very summit has been recognized by many participants as a critical lens through which to view the evolving economic and financial landscape of the Chinese mainland. With that in mind, we are pleased to welcome senior representatives from the Chinese mainland's financial regulators to this session. They will share with us their insights into China's current economic and financial landscape as well as future policy direction. This session will be moderated by Mr. Eddie Yue and conducted in Putonghua. Please use the headsets in front of you for English simultaneous interpretation in channel 2.
Ladies and gentlemen, let's put our hands together to welcome Mr. Yue along with our speakers: Mr. Zou Lan, Deputy Governor of the People's Bank of China; Mr. Xiao Yuanqi, Vice Minister of the National Financial Regulatory Administration; Mr. Li Chao, Vice Chairman of the China Securities Regulatory Commission; and Ms. Li Hong, Deputy Administrator of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange. Please be seated. Eddie, the floor is yours, Eddie.
Eddie Yue 22:56 ↗
Yes. For this session, the topic of interest to all of you is about the macroeconomic situation and the financial reform and opening up in the Chinese mainland. We are very honored to have with us four special guests from Chinese mainland financial regulatory agencies, and I will not take up too much time.
First, I would like to invite Mr. Zou Lan, Deputy Governor of the PBOC, to share with us the overall progress of the monetary policy at the PBOC, and also how to promote the connectivity with Hong Kong and how to support Hong Kong as the largest offshore RMB hub. The floor is yours.
Zou Lan 23:51 ↗
Respected Mr. Paul Chan, Mr. Eddie Yue, good morning. I'm very honored to attend the Global Financial Leaders' Investment Summit. Hong Kong is an important international financial center, and in the 15th five-year plan it is very clear that Hong Kong's IFC status must be strengthened and to enhance the international appeal of the city and its influence. Vice Premier He Lifeng's speech has pointed out a direction to support Hong Kong's development, and the PBOC will earnestly implement the relevant requirements.
And today, according to the arrangement of this conference, I will be talking about how to drive the force of China's economic development and the structural changes in the financial system. Firstly, we are seeing a high-quality trend for China's economic development since the beginning of this year. We have seen a very good trend for China's macro economy. Behind this strong momentum is the accelerated growth of the new driving force. We are seeing a strong support from first the cultivation and development of the new productive forces.
Science and technology innovation is a strategic choice for China. For years we have been implementing this innovation-driven development strategy with original innovation, and we have strengthened basic research and our R&D strengths, and investment has reached 2.8%, and China's global innovation index ranked number 10 globally in 2026.
At the same time, China actively cultivated and expanded emerging and future industries. We have 25 innovation clusters ranking top 100 in the world, and we are also actively promoting the green and low-carbon transformation.
We are the advocate and protocol contributor to global green development, and we have the world's largest renewable energy system. By the end of 2025, the installed capacity of renewable energy accounts for more than 40% of the world, reaching 2.34 billion kilowatts, and the newly installed renewable energy capacity accounts for half of the world. At the same time, we have constructed a complete renewable energy ecosystem which includes EVs, PVs, and power batteries.
We have taken the lead for these industries. And secondly, we have been implementing the strategy of expanding domestic demand since the 2008 financial crisis. We have established a national strategy to expand our domestic demand, especially to stimulate our consumer demand, and the contribution rate of consumption to economic growth rose from 37% in 2010 to 50% in 2025.
The 14th five-year plan has further clarified the strategic position of expanding domestic demand. And in terms of consumption, the Chinese overall structure has shifted from being dominated by commodity consumption to a balance between commodity and service consumption. And in April, we had the national conference on services. The central government emphasized the expansion and quality improvement of the service industry.
For the first three quarters, the added value of China's service industry increased by 5.2% year-on-year, contributing to economic growth by over 60%. China will continue to tap into the consumption potential in areas such as service consumption, smart and green consumption, and we will also expand quality supply and stimulate consumption demand.
In terms of investment, we are seeing a decline in traditional infrastructure investment. But at the same time, we are seeing new infrastructure represented by what we call the six networks. And in the coming years, the six networks investment would reach about 25 to 30 trillion yuan to expand effective investment. It would provide very, very strong support for our further reform and opening up, and such kind of opening up will also help us to stabilize the exchange rate and reduce the uncertainty for cross-border economic and trade activities.
And for the import for the first three quarters, it grew by 22.3%, 5.9 percentage points faster than the exports.
Thirdly, we are seeing changes in China's financial system structure. With the economic structure transformation and upgrading in China, we are seeing enterprises' asset forms shift from land and factories to technology, data, and brands. We are seeing also long-term and trend changes in adjustment for the financing structure in China. The direct financing proportion steadily climbed up, and in 2025 we're seeing incremental amounts of social financing for bonds and stocks, and for the first nine months it further rose to 49.5%.
And we are seeing more and more loans directed to technology and green development and other high-quality development areas instead of the traditional infrastructure and real estate industry.
The PBOC implemented the 14th five-year plan for building a stronger financial nation and responded to the changing trend of the financial structure. We have created a favorable financial environment for high-quality economic development. Firstly, we have been based on a supportive monetary policy stance and continue to advance the transformation of the monetary policy framework.
It gives more play to the role of interest rate regulation and improves the market-based interest rate formation, regulation, and transmission mechanism. We have further optimized the short-term interest rate regulation mechanism, enhanced the accuracy of interest rate regulation, and promoted a reform of the loan prime rate from a relatively single reference to the loan prime rate to a more diverse pricing benchmark.
Secondly, we have responded to the enhancement based on the different financing types, and we have improved the technological innovation board of the bond market and cultivated patient capital, enhanced the ability of financial support for technological innovation. We have deepened market-oriented reform and better leveraged the functions of the financial market in terms of pricing discovery and resource allocation.
And thirdly, we have deepened the high-level opening up of the financial market. We have raised the level of RMB internationalization, optimized the layout of RMB clearing banks, and we have also provided stable and multi-tier RMB liquidity support to offshore markets.
We have optimized the Bond Connect and Swap Connect program and mechanism and enriched the supply of high-quality RMB assets worldwide, so that global investors can also share the fruit of China's economic development and bring more returns to the investors.
As the world's biggest offshore RMB center, Hong Kong will continue to play a very big role against the backdrop of uncertainties and RMB internationalization. We will consolidate Hong Kong's position as an offshore RMB hub and support Hong Kong in developing a deeper pool of RMB assets.
And Hong Kong, as a very important part of the Greater Bay Area and international scientific innovation, Hong Kong can leverage its advantage in technology, talents, and finance to provide impetus for its development.
Ladies and gentlemen, the PBOC, together with all authorities, will continue to show support to Hong Kong to build Hong Kong as an international financial center. And we welcome all the global financial leaders to come to the Chinese mainland and Hong Kong to invest and to share the benefits of China's economic growth. In closing, I wish this summit a complete success. Thank you.
Eddie Yue 34:44 ↗
Thank you so much, Governor Mr. Zou, for your sharing, and also thank you, Mr. Zou, and the PBOC for your great support to Hong Kong. Now we will have Mr. Xiao Yuanqi, Vice Minister from the National Financial Regulatory Administration, to share with us his view on global risks and also the Chinese mainland financial regulation.
Xiao Yuanqi 35:13 ↗
Distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, it's a great pleasure to meet you here in today's summit. I know that many of you complain about the compliance cost of regulation, so I will not talk about financial regulation today. Instead, I will share with you some of my thoughts about the global economy and finance.
First, global debt, interest rates, and growth risks may spiral into a negative feedback loop. The International Monetary Fund, IMF, recently released its report forecasting global economic growth at 3.1% in 2026 and 3.4% in 2027.
If we look at the long-term historical average, the world's economy retains some growth momentum, but it remains stuck in a low-growth range. Overall, growth is highly concentrated in a small number of economies and sectors, which warrants close attention to its balance and sustainability.
Although the global debt ratio has retreated from its pandemic peak, government debt levels continue climbing. Global government debt stood at 94% of GDP in 2025 and is projected to approach 100% this year. Public debt in major economies is the main driver of debt growth, with leverage ratios rising rather than falling. Yields on the 10-year US Treasury note hover around 5%, with the European average at 4%.
Since the Federal Reserve embarked on its rate-hiking cycle in 2022, global nominal interest rates have remained elevated. When economic growth is generally weak and evenly distributed and interest rates stay high, governments, corporations, and households alike face dual pressures of sluggish income growth and heavier debt servicing costs.
This erodes the foundation of debt repayment capacity and willingness, further lifting debt risk premiums and pushing up financing rates. It also dampens investment and consumption, weighing on economic growth. If fiscal, monetary, and other structural policies fail to be effectively coordinated, these three policy areas are likely to fall into a negative feedback loop, exacerbating existing problems. Breaking out of this loop will come at a higher cost and take far longer.
China generally features low interest rates, moderate to low leverage ratios, and medium-high growth. Its average GDP growth rate for the first three quarters of this year stands at 4.6%. The LPR for 10-year loans is below 3%. Household and government leverage ratios at 60%, and also we understand that the corporate leverage ratio is around 170%.
I will go a bit faster in the interest of time, but I've already submitted my script to the organizer, so our interpreter has the script in front of them.
Second, monetary policy stances among major economies have been volatile, making economic rebalancing far more challenging. Traditionally, monetary policy is primarily tasked with maintaining price stability and fostering economic and employment growth. In practice, central banks generally prioritize inflation targets.
To curb the rapid rise in global inflation, central banks of major economies reversed the two-decade-long low and zero interest rate environment and entered a rate-hiking cycle in 2022, aiming to bring inflation back within policy target ranges. Yet, this goal has not been achieved over the past five years.
Sticky inflation has emerged, and core inflation in major economies still runs above 3%. Weak economic growth persists. In the meantime, if high interest rates remain in place for an extended period, elevated market borrowing costs will further undermine investment and consumption capacity and willingness, potentially contracting economic activity.
If the current momentum in tech investment fades, global economic growth is likely to fall short of the IMF's projections. Trapped in this dilemma, global central banks often send ambiguous, erratic, and sometimes contradictory policy signals. Unstable market expectations in turn amplify economic volatility. Divergent global economic and financial cycles make international policy coordination more difficult.
While global trade is fragmenting amid geopolitical shifts, cross-border and cross-regional capital flows have not weakened materially. Such divergence generates strong spillover effects through interest rates, exchange rates, capital flows, and asset pricing, partially weakening the effectiveness of monetary policy.
Furthermore, monetary policy has inherent limitations. Capital flow divergence has become more prominent, with greater concentration across regions, industries, enterprises, and markets. Market capital flows follow the principles of return and safety, driven by financial institutions' risk appetite, corporate investment intentions, and household spending capacity. As an aggregate regulatory tool, monetary policy cannot precisely guide capital allocation at the micro level.
Similarly, deep-seated structural issues, including global industrial and supply chain restructuring, energy supply-demand imbalances, population aging, slowing productivity growth, income disparities, and social welfare gaps, cannot be resolved directly by monetary policy. As a tool for aggregate demand management, monetary policy can only create a sound liquidity environment with limited direct regulatory effect.
And third, the spillover effects of artificial intelligence development are becoming increasingly diversified and complex. AI development has sparked extensive public discussions. I would like to share three key observations.
First, how long will the economic cycle driven by the AI technological revolution last? Human history has witnessed multiple major technological revolutions, each spurring economic boom cycles of different durations, including the Kitchin cycle, the Juglar cycle, the Kuznets cycle, and the Kondratieff wave. And the AI technological revolution is undoubtedly another landmark and probably the most transformative technological revolution in human history, bringing fundamental and disruptive changes to economic and social development.
It remains difficult for us to accurately judge the development trend, evolutionary path, and the duration of the upcoming economic prosperity driven by AI. Short-term fluctuations within this long-term cycle may interfere with current assessments and trigger doubts. Even so, we must actively adapt to these changes and make adequate preparations in macroeconomic policy production, investment arrangements, asset price pricing, as well as economic and financial risk prevention and control.
Second, the impacts of AI on major macroeconomic indicators such as GDP growth, inflation, and employment remain to be fully observed. Before the industrial revolution, the global economy was trapped in the Malthusian trap. For a long time, global economic output grew at an annual average rate of merely 0.06% before 1500 AD and rose slightly to 0.53% in the century prior to industrialization. In the 100 years following the industrial revolution, global annual economic growth surged to 2.1%.
So the first 1,700 years, the global economic growth on average is less than 0.5%, which means that in the past 200 years there has been explosive expansion of global economic output.
Since the rise of artificial intelligence, data shows that AI contributes 0.5 to 1% to annual economic growth in the United States and 0.1 to 0.3% in Europe. Its contribution to growth will rise substantially upon large-scale industrial application, beyond boosting productivity. We also need to analyze AI's structural impact on GDP growth to capture marginal changes in microeconomic operations.
AI's overall impact on inflation is neutral. On one hand, it generates massive investment demand and pushes up prices of production factors. On the other hand, it crowds out investment in traditional sectors, offsetting inflationary pressures. The final impact depends on the balance of these two forces.
Employment is another core macro indicator. AI's labor substitution effect has sparked a widespread debate, yet solid empirical evidence remains insufficient. Current employment data across economies shows no obvious structural changes. So the employment data from different economies haven't shown significant changes, and this may be because the long-term impacts have not fully materialized and the new jobs created by technological progress have offset labor displacement.
Meanwhile, AI replaces current labor, and also it requires new labor skills, which we need to pay close attention to.
And third, whether an AI bubble exists has become a heated debate topic recently. Looking back at human history, almost every major technological revolution has been accompanied by bubbles of varying magnitude. Typical examples include the railway bubble in the 1840s, followed by the telegraph and telephone bubble, and in the 60s of the last century the computer bubble, and the dotcom bubble around 2000.
If an AI bubble does emerge, is this a recurring historical phenomenon? And is it inevitable that it will burst?
Judging from previous technological revolutions, some bubbles didn't burst while others did. Yet bursting didn't necessarily lead to economic recession, let alone a great depression. This is because major technological revolutions greatly boost productivity and underpin long-term economic growth. However, productivity improvement is a gradual process before achieving critical breakthroughs.
Karl Marx once said that there will probably be critical breakthroughs and productivity growth slowly, with economic dividends realized only in the long run. Maybe a few years or even dozens of years later you will see that.
So short-term localized asset bubble bursts have occurred throughout history, but over the long term such market shocks can be digested and translated into new value growth.
Fourth, global financial fragility is on the rise. A host of financial regulatory reforms were introduced after the 2008 global financial crisis, strengthening the overall resilience of the international financial system.
Nevertheless, against the backdrop of geopolitical turmoil, transforming economic growth models, stagnating trade globalization, and the prolonged coexistence of high interest rates, high inflation, and low growth, the foundation of global financial stability has been weakened.
To begin with, financing from non-bank financial intermediaries has increased significantly. According to the FSB, the scale of global private credit stands at around 1.5 to 2 trillion US dollars. In some economies, financing provided by non-bank financial intermediaries has exceeded that of the traditional banking industry.
Non-bank financial intermediaries feature high leverage, opaque financing structures, and insufficient rigorous supervision, making their potential risk difficult to assess. In addition, their client bases and funding sources overlap and intertwine with the traditional banking industry, leading to potential risk spillover to the banking industry.
Furthermore, global capital flows are excessively concentrated. On one hand, massive capital has flooded into the technology industry and leading industries, driving up leverage in these sectors, fueling excessive expansion, and pushing asset prices higher. On the other hand, over-concentrated capital crowds out traditional industries and small and medium-sized enterprises, raising their financing costs and increasing financial burdens.
And secondly, we are seeing the effectiveness of the global financial governance system is gradually weakening. Thirdly, China's financial systems remain dominated by indirect financing via banks, and I will skip those figures. But what I want to say is that we will bring non-bank financial activities under regulation as well.
Apply the identical regulatory standards to similar institutions and similar financing activities. Preserve the overall resilience of the financial systems in sustaining operations, preventing and mitigating risk, and enabling self-adjustment and adaptation, and achieve a dynamic balance between financial stability and efficiency. And that's my remarks for today. Thank you.
Eddie Yue 51:05 ↗
Thank you, Mr. Xiao. Now let's welcome Li Chao, Vice Chairman of CSRC, to share with us the development of the capital market in the Chinese mainland. The floor is yours, Mr. Li.
Li Chao 51:25 ↗
Respected Mr. Zou Lan, Mr. Paul Chan, Mr. Eddie Yue, distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, good morning. I'm very honored to attend the fifth Global Financial Leaders' Investment Summit on behalf of CSRC. I would like to congratulate on the successful opening of the summit.
With the acceleration of changes unseen in the century, we are seeing new challenges and new opportunities for this summit. Our theme is rethinking the playbook, and it is of very practical significance. And Vice Premier He Lifeng's important speech, we are seeing the very important guidance for the capital market, and we will implement the spirit of his speech by taking this opportunity.
I would like to talk about the capital market in the Chinese mainland and also the regulation. First, we will do our utmost to maintain the stable operation of the capital market. Since this year we are seeing a lot of imported risks and challenges, and we are committed to focus on the foundation of market stability.
We have further improved the system and ecosystem for long-term capital and investment, and we have promoted the reform of the public offering funds.
And secondly, we have continued to improve the quality and investment value of the A-share listed companies. For the first three quarters, we are seeing more than 2,000 M&A cases, and the transaction amount was nearly 1.5 trillion RMB. We're seeing a batch of high-quality enterprises from this accelerated transformation and M&A.
Since the beginning of this year, the A-share listed companies have shown a good growth trend, and we have seen a very strong increase in terms of dividends and buybacks, far exceeding the amount of IPO and refinancing. And we are also seeing better awareness for the listed companies to give back to the investors.
And thirdly, we continue to deepen the inclusive reform of the A-share capital market. We focus on the new productive forces development, and a series of companies that focus on new productive forces have been listed. They will optimize the overall structure of the A-share market.
And fourthly, we enhance the efficiency of supervision and law enforcement. For three consecutive years, we have launched special campaigns to combat financial fraud, and we have also promoted stronger regulations and risk control for public funds. And fifth,
Zou Lan 54:47 ↗
We have expanded high-level opening up. For the first three quarters of 2026, more than 130 companies completed the record filing work of overseas listing. We support the companies to make good use of the two markets and two resources in the Chinese mainland and in Hong Kong. QFI is allowed to participate in the domestic treasury bond futures trading, and we have approved the establishment of Citigroup Securities China, and the number of foreign-owned securities companies has increased to seven.
The CSRC will continue to implement the requirements of the 15th Five-Year Plan, further promote the nine proposals and the capital market package system. We will continue to deepen the reform of investment and financing as our guide. Ladies and gentlemen, to strengthen Hong Kong's IFC status is a national strategy. It is also a requirement for building China into a strong financial power. We're very happy to see the first five-year plan from Hong Kong, and Hong Kong is integrating itself into the overall development of the country, and we are seeing the series of policy measures being issued as well. CSRC will continue to implement the arrangement from the central government. According to Chairman Wu's arrangement about the five coordinations in August, we will continue to consolidate the practical cooperation in Hong Kong's capital market.
First, we will further accelerate the inclusion of RMB stock trading counters into the Shanghai-Hong Kong Stock Connect, implement the optimization plan for the Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor system, and will provide an efficient and convenient institutional environment to support the listing of domestic companies in Hong Kong. Secondly, we will deepen the opening up of market products and institutions, and will remain highly open in terms of stocks, bonds, and futures products, and strengthen the cooperation of the two markets.
We'll further develop more ETF products linked to China's assets and those that are part of China's modern industry system, and in this way we can better meet the diverse asset allocation needs of global investors. And thirdly, we will strengthen cross-border regulatory cooperation and coordinate the openness and security requirements, and we will deepen the cross-border regulatory cooperation with Hong Kong's regulators, and we will crack down on frauds for cross-border capitals and illegal business operations. And fourthly, we will take a deep participation into global financial governance, and we will work closely with Hong Kong's financial regulators in the formulation of international rules and researching global capital markets.
Recently we are seeing an upward trend for China's economy, and we are seeing more and more attention and recognition for China's new economic trend. And I believe that China's capital market is drawing more attention. And by taking this opportunity, I would like to invite all of you to come to China to invest and share the fruits of the high-quality development of China. In closing, I would like to wish this summit a complete success.
Host 59:00 ↗
Thank you, Mr. Zou, for the speech. And lastly, I would like to give the floor to Madame Li Hong, Deputy Administrator, State Administration of Foreign Exchange, to talk about the policy of foreign exchange management in China.
Li Chao 59:19 ↗
Respected Mr. Paul Chan, Mr. Zhang Yong, Mr. Eddie Yue, I'm very honored to join the 2026 Global Financial Leaders' Investment Summit. Vice Premier He's video address just now is of great significance for us to grasp the situation and tasks, and it will provide guidance for us and for Hong Kong to better serve the overall development. We will earnestly implement it. Hong Kong is a globally important IFC and a bridge connecting the mainland and overseas markets, playing a special role of super connector and super value add. Supporting the development of Hong Kong as an IFC is an important task of SAFE.
In recent years, we have adhered to market-oriented, law-based, and international principles, firmly advanced foreign exchange reform, and focused on energizing market entities, improving the ecosystem, expanding opening up, and enhancing governance, taking measures to support Hong Kong's high-quality development. Firstly, it is about foreign exchange use being more convenient for enterprises. We have strengthened the alignment and integration of various foreign exchange policies on trade, investment, and financing, supporting companies in allocating domestic and overseas funds and unleashing development vitality and momentum. Taking the form of banks' foreign exchange business practices as a key initiative and drawing on international best practice of whole-process business conduct, we have improved the foreign exchange facilitation policy system featuring the more trustworthy, more convenient, the compliant, and the first, supporting mainland banks in handling foreign exchange business between enterprises with good credit standing and Hong Kong without the need for document review, directly improving efficiency. The average processing time has been shortened by more than half. In the first three quarters of this year, import-export between mainland and Hong Kong exceeded 400 billion US dollars, up 55.6% year on year.
And secondly, we have advanced the connectivity of financial markets between mainland and Hong Kong, supporting Hong Kong in strengthening its function as the global offshore RMB business hub, international asset and wealth management center, and international risk management center. We cooperated with authorities in advancing mechanisms such as Bond Connect, supported the optimization and expansion of Bond Connect, raising the annual net investment quota from 500 billion to 800 billion RMB. We have advanced the issuance of QDII quotas, granting new investment quotas of 124.4 billion US dollars since 2026; the accumulated quotas exceeded 183 billion, one-third allocated to the Hong Kong market.
And thirdly, we have strengthened the reform of cross-border investment and financing for enterprises, supporting Hong Kong in its role as a platform for enterprises' international operations. We have introduced multiple policies, including cross-border financing facilitation and green-to-foreign-debt, facilitating high-tech, specialized, refined, distinctive, and innovative enterprises and green low-carbon transition projects in conducting cross-border financing in Hong Kong and other overseas markets. Together with PBOC, we have explored building a framework for multinational companies' cash pool and expanded the pilot of centralized cross-border RMB and foreign currency cash management for multinational companies.
And fourthly, we have created a dual evaluation mechanism for foreign exchange policy and ecosystem, improving policy implementation effects. We have strengthened coordination with financial institutions and local governments to improve incentives and constraints and enhance the overall ability of the whole ecosystem. At the same time, we carry out closed-loop management and effect evaluation from policy introduction to policy implementation.
Distinguished guests and friends, at the gathering marking the 25th anniversary of Hong Kong's return to the motherland, President Xi Jinping pointed out that the central government fully supports Hong Kong in sustaining its unique status and strengths, consolidating its position as an IFC. This year marks the 30th anniversary of China's achievement of current account convertibility. Over the past three decades, amid shifting global circumstances, we have honored our commitment, and this has strongly underpinned China's deeper integration into the global economy as well as Hong Kong's openness, prosperity, and stability. Going forward, we will fully implement the decisions and arrangements of the PBOC Central Committee and the State Council to deliver on the requirements of the 15th Five-Year Plan, balancing development with security and capital account opening with RMB internationalization, and working with the Hong Kong SAR government and its financial regulators. We will further consolidate and advance Hong Kong's status as an IFC.
Recently we have introduced two sets of package facilitation policies. The first is a package of current account facilitation policies to better meet diverse settlement needs of foreign trade enterprises and support new forms of trade. The second is a package to further optimize cross-border investment and financing facilitation. It covers 11 specific measures across three areas, and these two documents will be officially released and implemented. And these policies will facilitate enterprises to better engage in international economic trade cooperation and also inject fresh momentum into Hong Kong's development. We believe that with the steadfast support of the central government and joint efforts from all sectors, Hong Kong will attain new and greater progress in the future. And lastly, I wish every success to the summit. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Madame Lee. Thank you so much to all the four speakers for giving us a very comprehensive sharing on the situations in the Chinese mainland and also the financial opening-up policies, the connector between the Chinese mainland and Hong Kong, and how to support Hong Kong to reinforce its IFC status. So a warm round of applause to all the four guests. Thank you.
Thank you again to our speakers for their valuable perspectives on the mainland economy and financial markets. Ladies and gentlemen, for those of you who were with us last year, we had highlighted a key trend: the blurring lines between public and private markets. We had debated how a hybrid approach offers the best of both worlds, optimizing yield while maintaining liquidity. Now, one year later, with corrections in the private credit market, that conversation has taken on a new dimension. And so, here we are returning to the core question: is the hybrid portfolio still the optimal strategy? And more importantly, what does the right mix look like for different investors? There is certainly no easy answer to these questions, but our two speakers from last year's panel are now returning to the stage to share their thoughts with us. Let's hear how their views have evolved. Please join me in welcoming our moderator Gokul Narayan from Morgan Stanley, together with our panelists Jonathan Gray from Blackstone and Manny Roman from PIMCO.
Thank you, Gokul. Over to you now.
Gokul Narayan 1:07:57 ↗
Good morning. It's a real privilege to be moderating this session. John, Manny, welcome back to Hong Kong. It's always great to have you here.
Jonathan Gray 1:08:08 ↗
Thank you.
Gokul Narayan 1:08:09 ↗
Yeah, of course. Great to be in Hong Kong. It was a year ago you were on a similar panel, and a lot has happened since then, and we'll get into all of that. But I thought, in the interest of time, we'll sort of dive into the deep end, so to speak, and perhaps start with a question that might be on everyone's mind in this room and in many rooms outside of this room. Both Blackstone and PIMCO have been at the core, and in fact the most influential participants and critical participants to the financing of AI infrastructure. Now, AI is a revolutionary technology. I think everyone agrees that the impact on productivity, efficiency is real. But history suggests that in the financing of revolutionary technologies in the past, there's been misallocation, overinvestment, some disappointment. So, how do you guys feel now? And when you answer how you feel, do you not sleep at night because you're excited, or do you not sleep at night because you're nervous, or a bit of both?
Jonathan Gray 1:09:18 ↗
So, I guess I'd start with when you have an investment boom like we're seeing today, there's no surprise that there will be some misallocations of capital. There will be folks who commit to things who may not have the resources execution-wise or financially. So there will be some things that go awry, but when I think about what we do in AI infrastructure, I have a tremendous amount of conviction and confidence. And I'd say it starts with sort of Econ 101, which is supply and demand. And so if you think about the demand for compute we're seeing, it's pretty extraordinary today. At our companies, we've seen a 20-fold increase in model spending over the last year, and they're doing it because content creation, customer engagement, coding, all of these things are giving them financial benefits. So, we see this very sharp upward move in demand. And then on the supply side, it's getting harder every day to build. So getting a site, getting entitlements, getting chips, getting power, aggregating the capital, that's getting harder.
So you go back to the telecom build of the 90s. Back then you built supply and hoped for demand. Now you're in an environment where the demand's running well ahead of supply. So that gives me a lot of comfort. And then the other thing I'd say about it is almost everything we do in AI infrastructure is tied to the biggest companies in the world. You know, the hyperscalers with average market caps of two and a half trillion dollars signing long-term contracts, 15, 20 years. So you have the support of supply and demand, and then you have very strong financial contracts, and that to me seems like a sound setup. But yes, the market is looking at things today and saying, is everybody doing this on a sound basis? And there will be some people who may not get it right.
Manny Roman 1:11:31 ↗
I think we were sitting here in California, sort of looking at the sea, and then all of a sudden this huge tidal wave of capex comes, and with it comes a lot of borrowing. And at the same time, it's incredibly exciting because the size is very big, and I think you can get an excellent spread. But the flip side is the amount is like nothing we have ever seen, and I think companies have been very upfront about the amount of capex they're going to have to do. And so we're all busy trying to do transactions, make sure we're going to get our money back, because at the end of the day, we bond investors, whether it's private or public, we want our money back, but we want to make sure that we've thought carefully about the risk and we aggregate the risk and we think about portfolio and say, you know, what risk do we exactly want and how much can we take and what's the right time to do it and how does it compare to other types of risk in the bond market. And the bond market is like this biodiversity where you have everything from mortgages to private credit to infrastructure and so on and so forth, and so you constantly think about the opportunity and what's attractive. But we've been both super busy, hence why we're here, and I think we're more excited than worried at this stage. A year from now, if you still invite us, we may feel differently.
Gokul Narayan 1:12:52 ↗
I don't make the invitations, Eddie does. But the interesting dynamic there is that AI and AI infrastructure is obviously a big piece of this, but you know, we're in an environment where there's high nominal GDP growth, capex outside of AI, the deregulation is getting embedded in the ecosystem, so M&A activity is high. So the amount of credit, private, public, or capital that's being raised in the ecosystem broadly is actually higher than it's ever been before. In fact, this year, all included, the number could be five trillion dollars or more. How do you think about capacity? And that's for good reasons. But at some point, does the demand-supply dynamic get trickier?
Manny Roman 1:13:32 ↗
Oh, so let me borrow some numbers from my friend Bill Ford who's sitting here. For the next five years, the amount of capex is like 10 trillion. Year to date, there's $550 billion of AI debt in various shapes and forms. So you think about 10 trillion dollars over five years, that's $2 trillion per year. You know how big the bond market is in the US? 12 trillion. Let me just repeat that. So you need $10 trillion over five years. The US bond market is $12 trillion. The global bond market, corporates, 20 trillion dollars. So the amount, even if you think of one unit of equity and one unit of debt, is gigantic, gigantic, and at some point in time it's going to be too much. And so I would just say one difference on this, which is the five big hyperscalers by next year will have about a trillion dollars of EBITDA. So not everything's going to be financed. Some of it will be done through... No, no, I say one unit of equity and one unit of retained earnings and one unit.
Jonathan Gray 1:14:47 ↗
But I would say to Manny's point, which I think is really important, is the way the equity market looks at this versus the debt market is very different. If you think about the S&P 500, 10 companies today have 40% of the market cap. That is very concentrated. And equity investors are okay with that because they say these are great companies and I get the upside. But if you're a debt investor and you see this huge concentration of borrowing, you don't have upside. You're playing for repayment and coupons. And so what you're beginning to run into, to Manny's point, is concentration issues both to this overall trend, but also to some of the individual companies. So what I think that's going to lead to, and you're beginning to see this, is a need for more equity, right? You guys know this, and so Meta and Google and Oracle raising equity, obviously SpaceX going public, Anthropic going public, there's going to be more equity needed across this space to keep up with these enormous demands. And on top of it, of course, we're just talking, you know, the data centers, but the energy needs are enormous. We're seeing a huge buildout in defense. So yes, there's more need for capital. I think the biggest challenge is the concentration risk in fixed income, and that's got to be countered with free cash flow that's produced to pay for this. It may mean this becomes even more concentrated who builds it, and it certainly means more equity.
Manny Roman 1:16:27 ↗
I'm in awe of the hyperscalers, but someone is going to lose. It's not a win-win situation for everybody, right? So, I think when we think of risk, you sort of say, okay, how much AI can I have, and then what's the value destruction, and where am I going to lose money on old business models where all of a sudden life becomes a lot more complicated, whether it's in the private or the public side. I think people have talked quite a bit about software and what would happen to B2C in the software space, but there's many other industries where you sort of say agentic AI is fantastic, who's going to be affected? And I think we want to think about this from the offensive but also very defensive side, away from our AI risk.
Gokul Narayan 1:17:12 ↗
That is actually an interesting lead into the next question, which is, you know, we spoke about, and I think we were introduced as the blurring alliance between private and public. Just listening to both of you, I mean, to me, that's almost less relevant an issue because just given the amount of capital that's going to be needed, you're going to need all sources of capital to finance it. And in fact, one of the things that we've certainly seen over this past year, as particularly in AI infrastructure transactions get more complex, the relationship is in fact symbiotic. I mean, there's complementarity to private and public to sort of make sure this infrastructure build happens. Do you guys see it the same way, and do you see it continue?
Jonathan Gray 1:17:50 ↗
I think it's all hands on deck, right? I mean, when you need this kind of capital, you need our robust public markets, we need the banks globally, and you need these private markets. And the solutions to finance a $50 billion AI factory may be in some cases some junior private debt, but then something that gets rated and is sold in the public markets. And Manny and the team at PIMCO have been very creative in doing this. This has become part and parcel of a lot of what we're seeing. Big corporations today are doing more of these corporate solutions because they've got to be mindful of how much debt they take on. So, you're seeing big structured transactions. We announced one today with Mitsubishi on LNG Canada. I think this is going to continue. The creativity is needed because the scale of capital is enormous. I do think for growth this is very positive. The fact that we're investing large amounts of money in the future will enhance growth. I think we're going to get this big productivity boom. But there is a question of cost of capital. So there is a bit of a crowding out effect. Cost of capital's going up. That will have a tendency probably to slow some of this. And some of the skepticism today is probably healthy too, which is slowing things as well. But the overall trend is towards greater investment and therefore more needs for multiple forms of capital.
Manny Roman 1:19:18 ↗
I mean, the thing I would say from a financing standpoint is these deals are attractive. I mean, they, you know, if you rate them on a one to 10 basis, they're not the issue. The issue is, the good news is it's an eight. The bad news is there's a lot more coming, and I think no one is shy about it. I mean, you know, SpaceX, you know, we just did a deal with our friend from Apollo on SpaceX, and there's going to be plenty more coming, and I think we all know that. And so you hope that you caught the right time in the financing, and you know that you want to have space to do the next one, and all of these things. And so it is just a lot, and you know, I think everyone in this room is going to be involved one way or the other. Some are going to put equity in data centers, and some are going to finance it, and there's going to be some real estate, and it's just like literally the industrial revolution in England in 1760. I mean, we've never seen anything like this.
Gokul Narayan 1:20:17 ↗
And obviously we've had a pretty constructive environment, you know, more uncertainties beginning to emerge. And as these uncertainties get more real and more alive, and people sort of start questioning the available pool of capital, the returns on capital, the cost of capital, is that an opportunity? Because to me, particularly for private, but to the extent that private and public are coming together, the ability to sort of deal with complexity is within the wheelhouse, right?
Jonathan Gray 1:20:45 ↗
Well, it definitely creates opportunity. If you can aggregate capital at scale and people need large-scale solutions, then that means your capital gets treated well. So, if you look at the size of the deals now, multi-billion dollar deals, chip financing, data financings, energy, and other infrastructure, you're able to earn very attractive returns. And I think Manny's totally right about this. It's really about can you pull this capital together? And do you understand the risks you're taking? And today, this feels pretty good. I mean, most of this stuff I go back to is contracted by parties who have very healthy balance sheets. So it's about do you have the capabilities and scale to deliver for them.
Manny Roman 1:21:34 ↗
You know, I would say when you think of your portfolio and you said, okay, I have long equity, I have private equity, I have venture, and I have fixed income, I'm willing to bet that everyone in this room is very exposed. That's good. The AI trade, and the question is, what's the anti-AI trade? And it's not simple because investment grade is super tight. High yield is tight except for the triple-C market that you probably don't want to touch too much and is not scalable. So what's left? What's left is basically mortgages in the US, which are AAA and attractive. But you need to go outside the corporate world to be able to find some degree of decorrelation, what I call loosely the anti-AI trade, because everything's going to move together. And I've advised, I would have, and you know what we were talking with John before we came on stage is, you know, you need to think about your exposure and how much do you want and how much across all asset classes you want. And it's incredibly exciting. There's a reason why 40% of the S&P is seven companies.
Gokul Narayan 1:22:44 ↗
John, switching gears a little bit. Earlier this year, we did see some turbulence in private credit.
Jonathan Gray 1:22:51 ↗
Retail for, I noticed that.
Gokul Narayan 1:22:52 ↗
Yeah. But I was actually speaking to a large sovereign wealth fund who said private credit performance as an asset class has probably been better than most of what they have. So institutional participation in private credit continues to grow. Equally, we've had a pretty good environment, nominal GDP, etc. To the extent that the credit cycle would return, how resilient do you think this asset class is to that?
Jonathan Gray 1:23:16 ↗
I think it's very resilient. If you went back earlier in the year, had the critics come out and said private credit returns will come down because base rates were lower, spreads had gotten tighter, and there was going to be a little bit of a normalization of defaults, that would have been, I think, a very credible criticism. Instead, you heard that it was somehow putting the financial system at risk. And these were in most cases direct lending, senior loans. The entities were leveraged less than one to one, a tiny fraction of what financial institutions are leveraged. And we have not seen anything like what was predicted. In fact, if you looked in the third quarter at our borrowers and our non-traded BDC, they had the best cash flow growth that they've had in some time. And yes, there are some legacy deals from 21-22, but overall the fundamentals look very good. So, I think that sector will outperform certainly all that doom.
And then I think you'll continue to see this growth in investment-grade private credit because again, to do this huge buildout, you need capital at scale. And private credit is pretty uniquely set up for non-income-producing assets. So if you're building one of these AI factories or you're building an LNG facility or a power plant, something that's not cash flowing, I think being able to amass that capital at scale, both senior and junior on a private basis, is very helpful. So the trend overall in private credit grows because it's a direct-to-customer model and it's more efficient both for the borrowers in many cases as well as for the lenders in terms of generating higher returns without incremental risk. So that stress test, I think the industry will prove to have passed it well, and I think you'll continue to see growth.
Manny Roman 1:25:12 ↗
I'd say, you know, the one elephant in the room is I was at Goldman Sachs for the '91 and '98 crisis, the 2001 telco bubble. I was unfortunately in a hedge fund in 2008. Every time I lost more money than I thought I could lose. And you know, if you were alive on the back of it, there was a lot of things to buy and make a lot of money, but you had to be alive. A lot of people haven't seen a recession, and the economy has been incredibly stable. We had the COVID blip for a couple of weeks, and none of us could buy much because the Fed came and the Fed sort of moved everything up. At some point in time, there's going to be a downturn, and then things are going to break. And they can break because rates in the US go back up quite a bit because of a war in the Middle East. There could be a Eurozone crisis, name it. But we really haven't been tested, and I think a word of caution would be that, you know, sometimes problems arise, and I think you want to be anti-fragile and think about your portfolio and think about how things can go wrong.
Gokul Narayan 1:26:19 ↗
So one final question because we're running out of time here. As you just say that, when people think about portfolio construction, particularly in uncertain times, and the desire to sort of balance risk and alpha generation, is the bigger mistake today being too cautious, or is the bigger mistake today taking on too much risk?
Manny Roman 1:26:44 ↗
I would say people are risk... I mean, so the mistake has to be that people take too much risk. But I, you know, I got to be honest. If you're a fixed income manager, you're a miserable human being. The glass is always half empty.
Gokul Narayan 1:26:58 ↗
You have no choice.
Manny Roman 1:26:58 ↗
You wake up in a bad mood. You have no choice.
Jonathan Gray 1:27:01 ↗
I would say it's a bit of both. I think you have to recognize when you're in a moment of this much technological change, what that means for existing assets you own that may be corrupted, trying to forecast the future, and then looking overall at your portfolio so you're balanced, you're not caught up in any of these frenzies. That is super important. So our job is to generate returns but also keep our eyes on risk. But I do think what is happening is very powerful, and I think underestimating the productivity gains that are coming and the change in consumers and businesses, that's a mistake. The question is how can you invest in it in the most downside-protected way.
Gokul Narayan 1:27:50 ↗
John and Manny, thank you.
Manny Roman 1:27:52 ↗
I was going to add one thing, Eddie, on behalf of John and I, thank you for having us.
Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Have a great trip to Hong Kong.
Thank you very much, John, Manny, and Gokul for enlightening us on recent dynamics in public and private markets. Ladies and gentlemen, now let's address the persistent challenge of volatility. For months, the narrative has been one of caution with warnings of an imminent downturn, but the reality on the ground tells a different story. Markets have generally been resilient, earnings have been strong, and we are witnessing the world's largest IPOs. So, have the forecasts simply missed the mark, or are we witnessing a moment of greed before the storm? Ladies and gentlemen, to help us navigate this, please welcome our moderator, Albert Go from the Exchange Fund Investment Office of the HKMA, together with our panelists, Ted Pick from Morgan Stanley and David Solomon from Goldman Sachs.
Albert, over to you.
Albert Go 1:28:59 ↗
Good morning and welcome, David and Ted.
David Solomon 1:29:03 ↗
Morning. Good morning.
Albert Go 1:29:06 ↗
So when I found out that I'm moderating the CEOs of Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, I naturally asked AI for help. Surprisingly, the first output is: it is impossible for two masters of the universe to be in the same fireside chat. Now media really got it wrong because having worked with these two gentlemen, I think they really get on really well together. Now, by the way, I'm quite sure I typed in HKMA, not MMA. So, thank you, David and Ted, for doing this. It is a real honor, and thank you for making the impossible happen in Hong Kong. Let's kick off straight into macro. So last year both of you warned that potentially there could be a downturn, but look, both Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley had wonderful years. So the HKMA, despite long-term interest rates staying higher for longer, other than some recent wobbles in AI stocks, the broader equity market has held up really well. How do you see the current market dynamics? Maybe over to you, Ted, first. Could there be a broader market correction, you think?
Ted Pick 1:30:29 ↗
Well, first of all, thank you and Eddie for having us, and it's great to be sharing the stage with David. You're right, the markets have been resilient in the US. The indices are up about 10% year to date. The two themes of the year clearly have been the democratization of AI at the enterprise level as well as the ongoing geopolitical struggles in the Middle East and Eastern Europe. And against that backdrop of these two themes, it's clear that you could make the case that the glass is very much more than half full. US GDP is working at an extraordinary 7% plus nominal rate. The economy is operating at full employment with largely inflation ex-energy under control. The Fed is vigilant in that regard, and consumer confidence, while it's been tougher, is not reflected in the large-cap corporate suite where earnings continue to be extraordinary, and these great companies are accessing, as we're seeing actively, the debt, the equity, and the M&A markets. So if you put that all together, the glass half full is more than halfway full.
Now the case against it at this moment is clearly led by the energy shock as a result of these two ongoing conflicts. There's an element of NIMBYism with respect to data center AI build. I want the cash in my local coffers, but I don't want the data center in my backyard. And then the third element of the negative side of the coin is, at some level, the politics of populism seem to have gone global. We've seen it in Brazil, we've seen it in Israel, and it's anyone's call whether the GOP gets 50 or 45 seats in the Senate tomorrow. So the populism is real. If you put the glass more than half full together with the glass somewhat emptier on the other side, it's fair to say that the tails are fatter. Maybe there'll be a clearing event in the near term, in which case we could see a Santa Claus rally into year end, or maybe the glass half full doesn't have that clearing event, and then that'll weigh on the large-cap piece of the indices, and we could drift lower.
The last comment I'd make though is that there has been an element of a correction already. Something that David and I talked about a little bit last year, which was there are at least 60-65% of the Russell 3000 are down 20%, 85% of the S&P is down 10%. These are from their highs. So there's already been an element of correction going into this moment.
Albert Go 1:33:11 ↗
David, any follow-up?
David Solomon 1:33:13 ↗
Well, first I'll echo Ted's comments. It's great to be with Ted and Eddie, thank you for what's always a terrific event, and I'm pleased to be here. You know, I think Ted has framed it well, the glass is half full, but it's our job as risk managers to always be thinking about things, you know, in the tails. US economy is in solid shape. There are greater headwinds in other parts of the global economy. I think the war in the Middle East has been a real kind of sand in the gears or headwind to what might have been, you know, broader growth. We obviously are in the middle of a very, very strong tech supercycle, and one of the things that has kept equity markets strong is just earnings growth, you know, broadly across equity markets, particularly in the US. But a lot of that earnings growth is narrow, so if you look at, you know, the earnings growth in the S&P, 65% of it has come from 10 companies.
You know, despite all that, my biggest high-level comment is the US economy, which is such an important force in global economic activity, is just very resilient. It's incredibly resilient. And you know, the one thing that I know is that it's an exciting time. I don't know what's going to happen tomorrow, next month, next week. You know, we worry about speed bumps or things that can go wrong and can recalibrate, you know, some of the momentum that has existed in markets. But when I look out five, ten years, I'm really excited about the evolution of this technology supercycle, the deployment of the technology into enterprises, the ability for it to drive productivity. And you know, I think that's something we all have to be excited about. I think there'll be bumps in the road. I think we've got to figure out how to manage it and govern it. There'll be winners, there'll be losers. I think the path of all that is unclear, but it's certainly a pretty exciting time when you look at the change that's coming.
Albert Go 1:34:56 ↗
Thank you very much. Let's dive straight into mega IPOs. So 2026 is a breakout year for mega IPOs. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley seem to have cornered the mega IPO market. So congratulations to you two for SpaceX and also for winning the Anthropic mandate. David, how do you see the general mega IPO pipeline developing in the coming months?
David Solomon 1:35:22 ↗
Well, the mega IPO pipeline, I mean, there are a handful of mega companies, but the IPO activity broadly this year has been up meaningfully from where it had been the previous year. But I think one of the things that's interesting that people look at, if you look at the IPO volumes, and obviously the IPO volumes in terms of the amount of equity raised and the amount of equity raised in the equity markets broadly kind of look like a 10-year average. So the activity is good. You know, I would say the environment for equity capital raising over the course of the last year has been a top-quartile environment. That doesn't mean there aren't periods of time where there's a little bit more tailwinds or a little bit more headwinds, but there's, you know, $160 trillion in the public equity markets in the world, and there's a lot of capital looking for interesting businesses to back. And I'd say, you know, the market continues to be receptive to good stories, good companies. That's an important part of the functioning capital markets.
Albert Go 1:36:23 ↗
Good. So Anthropic is potentially the largest IPO in history. Anthropic also wins the prize for having the most interesting IPO disclosure ever, saying that their products may pose an existential threat to humanity. But you know something, I think humanity is going to double down. I think humanity will double down and oversubscribe to this IPO many times over. So why is there so much depth in the capital markets for these mega IPOs? Where is the capital coming from? Maybe David.
David Solomon 1:37:04 ↗
Well, I just make no comment specifically about Anthropic or what's coming there, but there's $160 trillion in the public equity markets. There's more than that in government debt and fixed income markets. There's tens of trillions of dollars of cash in, you know, cash and equivalent type, you know, money market accounts around the world. There's a lot of capital in the world. And so, once again, good companies come to market with good stories, there's plenty of capital to support those stories at reasonable valuations.
Ted Pick 1:37:38 ↗
Agree with that. What I'd add as well is that we're now in an era of the institutionalization of the retail product. Equitization of companies around the world has brought institutionalized retail that is more sophisticated, tends to be longer in ownership and duration, tends to be obviously more savvy about how transactions trade over time, index inclusion. So I think index participation and the knowledge of banking winners long-term by being part of these IPOs is something that retail now has really thought about in a more sophisticated way, and they can be anywhere between 10 and 25% of the long-term ownership of these great companies, and that serves, of course, as a ballast for price clearing and the dampening of volatility over time. So I think the emergence of retail as a vibrant component of the post-IPO ownership structure is here to stay, and that's very strong.
Albert Go 1:38:43 ↗
Let's move on to AI financing. So AI financing will hit three to four trillion dollars over the next few years, and much of this financing is based on a web of interdependence between frontier labs, builders, chip makers, and energy providers. So Ted, are you worried about this? How do you see the role of financial institutions evolve over this cycle?
Ted Pick 1:39:12 ↗
Well, I think the reality of AI development as being one of the great technology advances in history, and certainly the biggest since the internet, a year hence from our last get-together, is now incontrovertible. If we think about roughly a trillion a year of capex among the hyperscalers, it could be 800 billion in a year, it could be a trillion three or a trillion five. You think about that over the course of seven, ten, twelve years, we're somewhere in the second inning of a nine-inning game. We would think that 10 to 15 trillion, that's a very large range, but that's not an unreasonable sum to be thinking about to build that which will push the product forward, and then on a sustainable basis an ROI that can drive real GDP growth of 50 to 70 basis points in the US on a real basis running, and then of course something that feels like that over the long duration globally.
So two to three trillion in the ground to build, 10 to 15 trillion over time against a US S&P market cap of around 70 trillion. 10 to 15 trillion is not inconsequential, of course, but if it generates 50 to 70 basis points over time in the crystallization of intelligence, efficiency, and then eventually long-run effectiveness, this at the large-cap company level and then throughout the real economy. These are extraordinary numbers, and I think they'll come to pass. Now, of course, we'll hear throughout the '99, 2000 period, '01, '03, '06, '08, those of us that all experienced that. I think that's very healthy. That creates a wall of worry that reminds us that sometimes the technology will be ahead of the plan or vice versa. And some of the projects will have poor capital structures, and they will eventually not pass the test of time. But this is all part of the innovator's dilemma as we go along.
And we're not talking about whether AI, especially at the enterprise, but certainly for us as individuals as well, and we're not even debating whether there'll be a long-term net ROI that is 50 to 100 basis points real running. It's just a question of which particular instances will be part of success or failure. And that's part of the fun of what we get to do. And I would just sort of throw in that Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley are very fortunate because we're in the epicenter of these developments where we can act as an advisor, as a financier, an underwriter in bringing the different components together. So it's a very exciting time to be teaming and working with these important players and something that is obviously world-changing.
Albert Go 1:42:25 ↗
Yeah, that's great. So Bridgewater says that we are in an AI bubble. Elon Musk says that the 200-plus new clouds will experience guppy-level death and consolidation. But by the way, I'm not sure if Elon has guppies, but I do. And yes, some will die, but you usually end up with a lot more guppies than you started with. I digress. Jensen Huang says that we have parabolic growth in AI demand, utterly parabolic. So what do we have, an AI bubble, guppy hunger games, or parabolic growth in AI?
David Solomon 1:43:18 ↗
We have an extraordinary technology that's accelerating very, very quickly. You know, Ted outlined broadly the capital needs. I think there's no question at the moment that the demand for compute, certainly in the near term, the next couple of years, vastly exceeds the supply. You're therefore looking at lots of projects given the people that...
are taking up that compute, largely the hyperscalers that are very, very attractive to finance. You know, I think that nobody knows how this will all play out when you start looking out three, five, seven, 10 years. There will be winners and losers, and a lot of the value will come from an application layer and changes in technology that are very, very hard for us to even identify or understand at this point in time. But I think that's super exciting. You know, I'd echo Ted's comments. We feel very privileged at Goldman Sachs to sit in the middle as an advisor, capital raiser, huge asset manager. We have over four trillion dollars under supervision in our asset management business. And so, you know, we sit in the middle of trying to form capital back companies and, you know, try to make bets as to where this will go. But as with any technology acceleration, the technology tends to move faster than the enterprises and the people do. It takes time for the technology ultimately to be deployed. I think one of the things we all have to remember is at the moment the hyperscalers are buying the compute, but ultimately governments, enterprises and individuals have to buy the ultimate offtake of products and services that come out of this. But I'm hugely optimistic that the opportunity to use this technology to create productivity and efficiency and invest in scale in businesses is very exciting. And by the way, not just for big businesses. You think about what this technology can do for small businesses. As you look at the United States, small businesses generate 65% of the job growth in the United States. And you've just brought the cost of starting a business down and the ability to accelerate the infrastructure of a new business to a much more attractive place. So these are enormous opportunities. Won't be a straight line. Will things go right? Absolutely. Things will go way right. And I think one of the things people can miss as investors is for the opportunity for things to go better than we all expect. But things will go wrong too. And we'll get things wrong. And investors will find situations where they pick wrong or they lose money. And you know, the mix of that though over time, I think is going to be productivity, good investment returns. And you know, it's important to have a balanced, diversified view as you look at this because none of us know, none of us know where this is going.
So quickly, moving on to Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley being the best-known Wall Street banks for a very, very long time. So the question is, are non-bank market makers like Citadel Securities and Jane Street just sitting over there disrupting the Wall Street broker-dealer model? I mean, scale and efficiency is paramount in global markets, but Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley continue to lead in relationship-driven sectors such as M&A, underwriting, prime brokerage. These are super high-margin sectors that require high-touch human talent. How do you see this play out over the next decade? Whoever wants to start.
David Solomon 1:46:43 ↗
Citadel is a great partner to Goldman Sachs. We do a lot with Citadel. Citadel, like some other partners, also competes in certain areas of our business. I mean, there are lots of people in the room that in certain parts of the business compete but are great partners. That's the ecosystem we live in. My bet is Citadel is going to do very well in the years ahead, and Goldman Sachs is going to do very well as their partner, and there'll be places where we compete. That's the nature of the business. I think that's one of the things that all of us in this business understand. We collaborate with each other in places where we collaborate, we compete in places where we need to compete, and that's the way the markets work.
Unknown 1:47:18 ↗
Very good. Yeah, I would echo that. Of course, there's been now regulatory normalizations. Some of the businesses that our firms and our typical competitors, our traditional competitors were effectively regulated out of, we're back in those businesses. And technology matters, but so does access and the ability to access corporate relationships and to act truly globally and to be able to have the balance sheet behind that. And then ultimately this is about intellectual capital and trust. Who has the intellectual capital? Who has the trust of clients? And we feel good about where our positions are with these great firms that are now new players. Sometimes they're clients, sometimes they're counterparties, sometimes they're frenemies, and we make it work. And it's an exciting time to be working together against the context of all that is going to come with AI.
Yeah, it's been a real honor to have you two on stage and to see you two on this panel. So, thank you so much for having us. A big thank you very much, Ted, David, and Albert for packing so much insight into 20 minutes. Ladies and gentlemen, we will now take a 10-minute break. Coffee and refreshments will be served outside in the foyer area. Please be back here by 10:40 a.m. 10:40 a.m. Thank you.
Ladies and gentlemen, the next session is about to begin. Please return to your seats as quickly as possible.
Ladies and gentlemen, the next session is about to begin. Please return to your seats as quickly as possible.
Hello everyone, welcome back. The next session will begin very shortly. Please be seated as soon as possible.
Ladies and gentlemen, the next session will begin very shortly. Please be seated.
Welcome back everyone. I hope you enjoyed your coffee break and were able to connect with other participants. We will now move on to our next panel on how to operate under uncertainties. The macro landscape we face today is undeniably complex. Geopolitical conflicts are driving sticky inflation and higher rates, while the rapid expansion of AI and technological fragmentation are bringing with them heightened cyber risks. And so, how do global banks recalibrate their priorities to maintain stability? And in this era of uncertainty, what will emerge as the new economic drivers? Ladies and gentlemen, please join me in welcoming our moderator Arthur Yun from the HKMA. Together with our speakers, Sergio Hermati from UBS, Jean Lumiere from BNP Pariba, Ronald O'Henley from State Street, and Benet from Barclays.
Arthur Yun 1:51:30 ↗
Welcome back everyone from the break. I hope you are fully energized after your coffee break. I see that the clock has already started ticking and we are two minutes short because the MC took two minutes to introduce us. I hope it will be compensated towards the end. So welcome back everyone. This panel is about macro trends. In the previous two panels, we have talked about the public-private dynamics and also how the market has avoided a slowdown because of the continued investment in AI. Now we are looking in this panel, we're looking more closely at macro forces that would be reshaping some of the basic parameters that the market is operating in. And I'm glad to be joined by four very great panelists. I don't think they need any introduction, but Sergio, group CEO of UBS, Jean Lumier, chairman of BNP Pariba, I have Ron O'Henley from State Street, chairman and CEO, and Benet, good friend. I always say that I started off my career as a Barclays banker. He's from Barclays. So...
Unknown 1:52:45 ↗
And you've done well in spite of it. Thank you.
Arthur Yun 1:52:49 ↗
So we are going to focus on three macro trends. If we talk of macro trends, there are many to talk about, but we are focusing on three issues in particular. First, geopolitics, and geopolitics is such a wide issue. So we're focusing our attention on supply chain reconfiguration, which I think Eddie alluded to in his earlier remarks. And then we'll focus a bit on fiscal pressure. And then finally, I don't think any discussions of macro factors will be complete without a talk about cyber security. So let's start with the first issue about geopolitical tensions, in particular global supply chain reconfiguration, in particular because increasingly there are concerns about strategic supplies. And as a result of these strategic considerations, there are issues about reconfiguring the supply chain at the expense of efficiency, but more about diversification in this kind of environment. I would like to discuss the various implications of that trend. So let me start off with Benet. With these kind of changes in supply chain reconfiguration, how, in particular with governments seeking to reduce their dependencies on strategic imports, how are you seeing that impacting the macro trends of, for example, trade, investments, industrial policies, capital flows, etc.?
Unknown 1:54:27 ↗
Well, thank you, Arthur, for having us here, and thank you, Eddie, for inviting us on behalf of all of us here on stage. We're very grateful, and it's good to be here. So you know, the trend you've spoken about, about supply chains and dependencies, obviously one of the defining features of the last decade post-COVID of what's happening. I think there are two ways in which we look at it. One is what countries and industries do, which is what are critical dependencies, and people will try to spend as much as they can to overcome weaknesses or to ensure themselves against critical dependencies. And then there is what is general interdependence, where if you try to reduce that a lot, then it can be expensive without giving you resilience, and different countries and different economies will make those choices. The bigger countries in the world have greater choices to make, the smaller countries in the world have to rely on others, and you can see that configuration taking place. And then the question comes really is when you operate globally, A, you have to adapt your own business to the needs that you see in different countries. And then an interesting question comes as to global financial centers like Hong Kong, where finance is playing a role along with a domestic financial center in helping a country manage these dependencies. And so the link of Hong Kong to China that we saw earlier today is very important. But great financial centers have hinterlands. New York has the United States. London has Europe in some shape or form. And those links are important because it's the link between domestic finance and international finance. And I think in order for international finance not to get caught up in the strategic breakdown of dependence, it's important for the international financial centers like Hong Kong to do what you're doing, which is to have fair and transparent regulation to promote growth and to make it easy for people to operate.
Arthur Yun 1:56:47 ↗
Now, thank you, Benet. You talk about how financing or international finance can continue to support these corporate needs. So let me next turn to Jean. In terms of the corporate views of things, as your corporate customers are diversifying their sourcing and production across different regional hubs, what changes are you seeing in terms of their liquidity, capital, working capital needs? Are you seeing any major shifts in those parameters?
Unknown 1:57:24 ↗
Yeah, I think the first question, at least from a European point of view, I agree with you, over the five or seven last years, is dependency, and this is a broad, very broad question: dependency on energy sources, dependency on markets, dependency on funding, technology. And I think the Europeans have discovered that they had a business model which may be too dependent on some regional links. So there has been a lot of work addressing this. That's the broad picture, and the EU, to a certain extent, is part of this, rare earth, for instance. On your question, what we see, I would say, is more a localization of the approach. It's clear that we see in Asia from European companies a demand for domestic funding, much more than before, hedging capabilities to face volatility of Asian currencies. So you have a lot of questions, treasury management in the region. You see a lot of questions being put together and increasing, not the fragmentation, but a better management of funding and treasury questions. And of course, Hong Kong is key there. But may I add one comment? What you say is true for the Chinese companies moving to Europe. Chinese companies moving to Europe need new kind of services. They need to understand better the market. They need access to the euro, which they don't have, and they need to understand what I would call the complexity of the European system. Regulations, ESG reports, you have a lot of questions, and of course it creates the need for a hub. To that extent, Hong Kong is key. Hong Kong is becoming more and more, for the funding in RMB, a key bridge between China and Europe. For me, this is very crucial when we see the activity, it's raising for the corporate sector, but raising for banks. So yes, we see more localization, more local skills, the need for hubs. Hong Kong is a very good place where to do it.
Arthur Yun 2:00:16 ↗
Yeah, thank you very much for raising that point. We're doing a lot of work in terms of how to make sure that Hong Kong can continue to service supply chain needs, whether they are going for reconfiguration or not. So thanks, Jean, for raising that. Let me turn to Ron as a global custodian and asset servicer. How are you seeing all those trends that Benet and Jean talked about changing the servicing, investment servicing models? Are you seeing any major trends there?
Unknown 2:00:48 ↗
Well, yeah, you are seeing major changes because if you think about what the financial sector does, us included, either as an asset manager or as an asset servicer, right, we're here to support what's going on. And as these supply chains have changed, starting with COVID, the Ukraine war, the conflict in the Middle East, and all the consequences of that, you're seeing the world move from a... you're not seeing deglobalization, you're actually seeing reglobalization, right? Trade patterns are changing, and therefore payment patterns need to change, and financing patterns need to change. So that is what you're seeing here, and you're also seeing, particularly amongst clients, whether it's borrowers, capital raisers, it's the same mindset. It's moving from what was in vogue 10, 15 years ago, which is just-in-time, to just-in-case, right? And building in that resiliency not just into your supply chain, but into your financing model. And as several of the panelists have noted, remember the biggest player and where we're seeing the most change is around the role of China, and Hong Kong is the gateway to that. And it's this kind of movement of money north and south and movement of capital north and south that Hong Kong's playing that role in. For us as an asset servicer, with things like Bond Connect and those kinds of things, it's to support that. But again, the financial system is here to both respond to what we're seeing but also to support that, and I think that's what you're seeing in the behavior of each of the institutions on the stage here.
Arthur Yun 2:02:31 ↗
Thanks, Ron. Let's also look at the investors' perspective. Sergio, are you seeing your clients treating strategic sectors as a long-term structural change in the allocation model for assets? Are you seeing your clients changing the needs?
Unknown 2:02:52 ↗
Well, first of all, we don't really see clients derisking massively, but it's quite interesting to see that for many, many years, we had a fairly stable asset allocation framework, and now 60% of the global family offices we serve have an intention to change their asset allocation within the next 12 months. And the focus is not really in terms of exiting any major sectors that are driving the economy or are the future, but rather going more through a diversification, which is, you know, currency diversification, regional diversification, and in a sense, you know, the way they look at this phenomenon is really looking through, first of all, the overlay, how they look at exposures across different markets, listed markets, private markets, credit, equities. And while, for example, high-net-worth individuals, you know, have a more limited tools to play around with, that, you know, you see them playing more into the listed market and through structured products, a potential asset reallocation. But when you look at fundamentally the exposure to these sectors that are impacted by the geopolitical events, you know, we don't really see this as being a tactical response of resilience, but rather a play for a durable situation. So no matter if you look at infrastructure play, if you look at also the investment in commodities, you know, for example, gold stays a fairly, still a very important role to play in terms of giving diversification, safe haven status, but also liquidity, while, for example, copper is more seen as a play towards electrification. And so I would say that we are probably going to see in the next 12 months some changes that are a response to the geopolitical and supply chain environments, but no major derisking for the time being.
Arthur Yun 2:05:23 ↗
Yeah. Thanks for that. It's a convenient point for me to move to the next issue about fiscal pressure. You mentioned there's no major shifts in asset allocation because of supply chain. But how about fiscal pressure? And the corresponding high interest rate environments that we're seeing, high inflation, high interest rate environments that we're seeing, are investors increasing their real asset allocation or changing the real asset allocation? Are you seeing any trends there?
Unknown 2:05:50 ↗
Well, there is definitely a desire to play into the infrastructure segment. We start to see a little bit of reduced appetite for real estate. As I mentioned in commodities, you know, there is a different dynamics, you know, as I mentioned, gold stays as a quite important play. But broadly speaking, I would say infrastructure investments are favored to real estate, and this is likely to continue.
Arthur Yun 2:06:27 ↗
Okay. And how about turning to Ron? Given the steepening of the sovereign yield curve, are you seeing any shifts in sovereign bond allocations or changes in duration strategies amongst your clients?
Unknown 2:06:41 ↗
I think what investors are most worried about now is just the whole changing environment as it relates to debt servicing cost to GDP, right? And that really is the critical question, and we're in a very different point than we were coming out of the financial crisis where sovereign balance sheets were in quite good shape. In fact, the criticism at the time was they should have done more from a fiscal stimulus, borrowing, etc. And that's obviously not the case now. So there's a lot of focus on that and questions about whether sovereigns can, or maybe the better question is, will respond. I mean, will they change entitlements? There's nothing they can do about interest rates, but will they change entitlements? Will they change spending on that? And this is happening at a time when for most of our career here, we've talked about a savings glut and we've been the beneficiary of that. And for lots of reasons, that savings glut is turning into a savings deficit. So just at the time when you'd like to see a little bit more demand for these bonds, you're seeing less demand. And the savings deficit has to do with a lot of things. Some of it's demography, some of it's, you know, you had, for example, regions like the Middle East, which were extraordinary exporters of capital. They're still exporting capital, but they're also importing capital, and they've got lots of needs inside and lots of good needs to diversify their economies, make their own economies resilient. So that's just one example here. So with all of that going on, yes, investors are actually pausing on this and deciding what am I going to do and what do I want to get paid for taking this risk.
Arthur Yun 2:08:32 ↗
Yeah, thanks, Ron. And let me turn to Jean. Can't help to ask you the question about Europe. The European situation, are you seeing, do you expect sovereign bonds to rise in Europe more generally? And are you seeing any contingent potential contagion risk across other asset classes then there?
Unknown 2:08:53 ↗
Well, yes, sovereign bonds, I don't know if it is enjoy or suffer interest rate increases, but this is for reasons you have mentioned, the rule everywhere, may be slightly different for some countries in which the increase may be slightly higher. Now, what is the story behind this? I think most of governments have been taken by surprise. The shift from cheap money to more expensive money. And some of them have had significant spendings in the past for various reasons, from COVID to transformation, adaptation, whatever it is, and they begin to understand that they have to manage in a different way their debt. So it requires some time and political will to do it. It's not easy in the corporate sector and it's not easy in a government. We have to be much aware of this. Now, do they do it? Yes, they begin to do it. If I look at my country, you don't know, and we shall not mention, budget will be voted, I would say on deficit, with the deficit agreed on the presentation. But the most striking part of this is the fact that the cost of debt, not the debt, cost of debt is now very high on the political agenda. It wasn't the case before. Let's be clear. Cheap. When it becomes expensive, suddenly it pops up as a key priority for various reasons. One of them being sovereignty, let's be clear, not to be dependent. So I'm very confident the adjustments are being made step by step, like in the corporate sector. It's the same, you know, but it takes time. And even if in many countries in Europe, and including mine, there are elections, political leaders begin to understand very well the necessity to do it. Because you speak about Europe, I would like to add one sentence, which is maybe a concern for many of us. It's what I see in Europe, in many countries in Europe today, in my Europe, including in Switzerland, which is demonstrations. No, but look, it's a serious question. Demonstrations, suddenly we have seen some level of social, I wouldn't say unrest, that would be wrong, but uneasiness, questions, what about, formally about cost of living. It's the impact of the price of oil, and we know where it comes from. Two wars, cost of housing in Spain, Italy, France, Germany, Belgium. We see it, probably questions like AI, like all these questions are popping up, and these questions are quite important, and they have to be addressed, listening to people, especially young people, and trying to build up solutions which are not always budget solutions, but they are very important questions, and that's what we see. Probably we see the same elsewhere, but it's more invisible, but that's exactly what you see across Europe today.
Arthur Yun 2:13:22 ↗
Yeah, thank you, Jean. Let me quickly turn to Benet. With all these remarks, are there any financial stability concerns that we should pay more attention to?
Unknown 2:13:31 ↗
So I don't think higher for longer in itself leads to stress. It adds pressure. It increases vulnerabilities to stress. The stress itself, if it comes, may likely come from events, either a rapid move in interest rates or some events in the corporate sector or the government sector. And as was said in an earlier panel, then the vulnerability will depend on how quickly can people respond. I don't see the vulnerability in the banking system or among the large institutions represented here, but it'll be among those who either lack the experience or are too leveraged or too exposed to something.
Arthur Yun 2:14:12 ↗
Yeah, thank you, Benet, for that remark. We are actually running out of time, but I do think we need to very quickly go into cyber security or cyber resilience. I think resilience is the key word there. So I don't think I need to explain the landscape. But let me quickly turn to Jean. In Europe, the regulators now have the power to go into critical third-party service providers directly. How are banks responding to that power? I'm not even sure whether the power has been used. Are banks actually turning more to internal solutions, technology solutions rather than external ones, given their concerns?
Unknown 2:14:52 ↗
Well, I'm sure you don't ask me to respond here about the request of the supervisor.
Arthur Yun 2:14:58 ↗
No, no, no. Of course not. I won't put you on the spot.
Unknown 2:15:00 ↗
Supervisor always right.
Arthur Yun 2:15:05 ↗
No, that's not the question. I think the question you raise is probably different.
Unknown 2:15:12 ↗
Well, it's easy for me, you know, do we need external sub providers? Yes, of course we need for many reasons, from innovation to scale. We need, and we need many, not only one. But we need to keep control. So the answer to your question is a delicate balance, quite difficult to organize, between the need for external suppliers and the need to control the system. And we need to keep control. We need to be much aware about the concentration risk, and we need to be able to move to substitute a provider to another provider, and it means a lot. It means that you need to have very strong skills in the bank. You need to have the capability to transition from one system to another systems, and you need to engage with critical suppliers in a profound way. This is what, on the last point, this is what we have seen over the last month. We have been in deep contact and trust with suppliers to understand what was happening. So that's the way we have to manage, and the EU is willing us to do this, and they will scrutinize very carefully what we do to deliver this. I would add one point I would like to see more is more cooperation among us and with the official sector, because these questions are becoming more and more challenging, notably cyber, and cooperating, working together, notably with the official sector in Europe and elsewhere, would be a great, great help.
Arthur Yun 2:17:15 ↗
Yeah, thank you, Jean. Let me turn to Sergio. I'm sure UBS has done all that Jean has mentioned in this long list of issues that needs to be done. How is UBS dealing with the overall enhancement to cyber resilience?
Unknown 2:17:28 ↗
Well, first of all, let me tell you that, and it's quite clear to all of us here in the room, that, you know, operational risk, cyber, and I would add also when we talk about what's going on in financial markets, suitability, is becoming as important, if not more important, than managing market and credit risk as a bank. So from our standpoint of view, basically having a good governance and identifying accountability and the ability to really react and prepare and react fast is very, very important. So one of the topics that Jean just mentioned, in my point of view, is very important, is, you know, the collaboration, the broad collaboration between the industry, regulators, I would say the society at large, in making sure that we don't stigmatize too much when somebody is going through a cyber event. So I think this is probably one of the biggest issues that we need to address if we want to gain momentum in creating resilience in the system. We have to accept the fact that cyber is a topic that is here to stay, by the way, is increasing exponentially. It's nothing new, but it's the price to be paid for all this innovation and digitalization we have. So it's pretty much at the center of risk management in a bank today, and I think that for everybody is the same, no matter if you talk about direct connection to your clients or counterparties or the larger numbers of service providers we face.
Arthur Yun 2:19:16 ↗
Yeah, thank you to the two comments about enhancing the collaborations between public sectors, the regulators, and the banks. Benet, anything you want to add there? How can we work closely together to collaborate on that?
Unknown 2:19:33 ↗
So I agree with everything Jean and Sergio have said. It is the overriding risk for large institutions. And I think the other thing is, which we have to all understand, is we're all electronic. We prioritize being up and being reliable, but increasingly we're going to make trade-offs between that stability and the requirement to make rapid changes to your systems, putting in patches so that you reduce the vulnerability. So that trade-off is a very important thing that a lot of institutions are going to have to make.
Arthur Yun 2:20:08 ↗
Thank you. Finally to Ron, how are your institutional clients demanding in the face of cyber security risks? Are they demanding new ways of enhancing that, and are they requiring things like insurance coverage for service providers?
Unknown 2:20:26 ↗
I think what clients expect from institutions like ours is the benefit of what we're doing. And this was the lesson out of Glasswing, and initially the real frustration from clients because they knew this work was going on. They knew the institutions were working together, collaborating, collaborating with the suppliers, but what they wanted is answers. And I think the theme that you're hearing from all of us here is there needs to be collaboration, there needs to be collaboration at speed. That collaboration, by the way, needs to recognize that, you know, this whole room is a network, and the network is only as strong as the weakest link. And it's in all of our interests, whether it's a supplier, a client, a counterparty, to actually work on that behalf. So we've got to take a very different way of working on these problems here. Glass was useful. There was a divide and conquer approach in terms of how we worked with the open source providers, how we worked with third-party providers. But we have to recognize this is going to be the way of doing business. And this idea that you can kind of keep it secret and, you know, do the work amongst a small group doesn't make sense. You've got to be sharing these answers pretty quickly, or else you're just going to... you may have displaced the problem from your own institution, you're still going to own the problem.
Arthur Yun 2:21:44 ↗
So, point well taken, collaboration together, we actually stand stronger against these cyber security risks, but also the importance about resilience. The need to educate the public that resilience is not meaning nothing would fail, is that when we fail, we can actually bring things back to normal quicker, and that needs a lot of work ahead of time. So we run out of time, and so thank you very much to the generous sharing by the panelists. Let's give them a big round of applause. Thank you.
Thank you very much to our panelists and Arthur for sharing your insights on building resilience. Please be seated, ladies and gentlemen. And up next, we will examine the evolving marketplace where the traditional landscape is being rewritten by the rise of non-bank financial institutions, namely proprietary trading firms and market makers. This prompts the question, do these developments bring new risks that could crack the system? Or are they catalysts for new opportunities? And perhaps more importantly, how must traditional financial institutions reinvent themselves in response? Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome our moderator for the next session, Ernesto Torres Kantu from Citi, and also Daniel Pinto from JP Morgan and Jaoong from Citadel Securities. Ernesto, I'll hand the stage to you. Thank you.
Ernesto Torres Kantu 2:23:28 ↗
Good morning. Yeah, it does work. No, Daniel Pinto. No, it's great to be here with you to talk about a topic that pretty much was introduced by Ted and David earlier today. And, you know, for ages banks were the primary, if not only, providers of market liquidity. That changed, that has changed significantly. And let me start with you, Pinto. What was behind that change? You know, the technology, the operating model, the regulation, the lack of regulation, what was behind it?
Unknown 2:24:00 ↗
First of all, thank you for HKMA inviting us again and organizing this fantastic event. And we have many of our most important clients and partners from around the world in this room, so always appreciate Albert giving us a shout out in front of our clients and partners. Now, it's not a secret that we built our firm on the vision that as the market becomes increasingly electronic, information becomes increasingly openly available, automation and technology was going to profoundly change how financial markets operate. And we had that idea 20 years ago, before now that idea, and then underpinning how AI is going to change the entire world. And what technology has allowed us to do is to provide, to build a liquidity solution that is robust, efficient and scalable, right? Especially when we look through the various different episodes of volatility and market turmoil. The scalability and the resiliency part of what the technology and the scale of the technology has brought us has really played a profound role. This year, on an average day, we traded $800 billion. On the peak day, on the back of the Iran crisis, we traded $1.36 trillion dollars, largely on a principal basis, with 1,900 employees around the world and lots and lots of computers, accelerators, hard drives, flash memories around the world. And that ability to flex up and down as the market challenges, flex up and down, opportunity flex up and down, has fundamentally brought a new era of markets and a new level of efficiency to the investors all around this room.
Ernesto Torres Kantu 2:26:08 ↗
So with that comment from Pinto, Daniel, how do you see this continuing to evolve?
Unknown 2:26:17 ↗
I think that the participants and the balance of the market have changed. So some is driven by regulation. So as a bank, for a unit of risk after the financial crisis, you have to have more units of capital. So the capital available to facilitate the intermediation process in the banking system is more than it was. Technology has evolved, and the kind of increase in private market activity is the other leg of this situation. So overall, I think that what we want is a market that is as liquid as possible, that is as continuous as possible, and it creates lower spreads that facilitate the intermediation process in every market environment. I think that in that sense, companies like Citadel Securities, they help the market to provide liquidity, and companies like JP Morgan and others, that we are providing the full services, not just execution, we are all kinds of pre-trade services, including research, including the way that, improving the way that clients consume research, execution, financing, and post-trade services, and all that. And as the technology evolves, we have to continue investing in how smart our algorithms are to improve the way that we execute transactions for clients. So how we move from low latency to super low latency by using different technologies. So JP Morgan spends close to $20 billion in technology, a substantial portion goes to markets, and that substantial portion makes us more and more competitive. The market business of JP Morgan is huge, it's around $40 billion a year. But I see the non-banks really adding to the pie. I don't think that they are subtracting anything and creating a lot of value together with the traditional players.
Ernesto Torres Kantu 2:28:40 ↗
Yeah. And what is more relevant is the way more than the, you know, non-bank financials or banking institutions, that the ecosystem works well, that is where more relevant. So for that ecosystem, what is the main risk? And this question is for each one of you, that you see that is most, you know, underpriced or underappreciated. We've been, I mean, all morning, we've been talking about risks, Daniel.
Unknown 2:29:14 ↗
So I think that the previous panel mentioned cyber, and I think that cyber was always a risk. I think that at the moment it's by far a higher risk than it was pre-Mythos. I think that Mythos has exposed vulnerabilities that can be exploited. That, in conjunction with agentic AI, allows the bad actors to really have a technology that can be really harmful. Obviously, companies like JP Morgan and most of you will use the same technology to protect ourselves, but when you think about it, we are not exactly in a level playing field because if you are a bad actor, you don't care if your agents are doing illegal things, whereas if you're a JP Morgan or Citadel or any of the other companies, you need to control your agents to do what they have to do. So I think that even though I believe that the new AI technology is going to make, in the long term, the business stability more resilient, in this process of adjustment that is quite challenging, it's risky. And the second thing that I would say is we talk a lot this morning about all the trillions of dollars going into the AI space, valuations that are still elevated. There has been some recent correction, but it's still the case. So in the long term, I do believe in the boom of productivity and the impact of AI. So I would caution everyone to think about the speed of growth, because all these things that are being developed, someone has to consume it. Trillions of dollars that the non-AI sector and everyone else have to pay to these companies to justify the investments. So when you think about what has to happen, the top-line growth of these companies, AI companies, that is needed to justify the level of investment and the current valuations, it may be a bit too fast. So I do believe that it's a positive slope curve. It may not be as steep as the market is pricing. So therefore, I think that there could be a correction in the AI sector, but by definition it will correct all the sectors, because if someone is believing in those valuations, it's also assuming that they are going to pay for those services and get the productivity in the time that the market is pricing. So I think that I'm bullish on AI. I think that it may be a bit too steep of growth of revenues and earnings of these companies to the current market price that can produce a re-rate of the whole sectors.
Well, first of all, I just want to echo what Daniel just said. You know, JP Morgan and Citadel Securities have one of the biggest partnerships in all financial markets. JP Morgan runs our primary credit facility that finances our activities around the world. And here in Asia, for example, Hong Kong and other countries in Asia, JP Morgan has been one of the primary enablers and supporters of our trading activities in the region. You know, also this concept of non-bank institutions is obviously a relatively amorphous definition, and it catches a lot of different firms, but that segment has been one of the fastest, if not the fastest-growing segment as a client base for traditional banks as well. And I think as technology and market structure continue to evolve, these lines keep on getting moved around. In the face of such tremendous amount of opportunity and challenges, large firms like ourselves are very much focused on finding ways to work together so we can capture the opportunity together. So just, you know, very much want to echo what Daniel just said, and thanks to JP Morgan and many of the other audiences in the room for all the partnership and support we received over the years that allowed us to grow and develop the way that we have. In terms of the risk, there's a lot of talk about increasing volatility. Now, if you look at the realized volatility in US equities, September, October, it's around 10 to 11%. Not high at all. So I think there's a critical concept that we're confusing, which is the difference between volatility and uncertainty. Right now, both the market and the world are very uncertain. It doesn't mean it's volatile. In fact, from a volume perspective, right now in many markets around the world, many main markets around the world, volume is down 40% from earlier in the year. Investors are anxious, they're uncertain, and they're not acting. Price may be drifting in one direction or another, but not in a particularly volatile manner. That's not there. In my view, the risk really comes from that uncertainty. It's not that some excess volatility or volume is going to break the market. It's rather that in the era of AI, the disruptive nature of that technology is creating an unprecedented challenge to the market's investment community due to that uncertainty. The market has incredible capacity and funding ambitions, but only on the basis of credible expectations. As many of the audience, including Daniel, has pointed out, right now we're in this game where, first of all, the technology itself is developing at a rate that's much faster than the investment cycle. So this is challenge number one. Challenge number two, the numbers are huge, right? So you have a lot of revenue and a lot of capital commitment. So it's a huge number minus another huge number. So if you're off by a little bit in terms of your ability to extrapolate and predict either one of the numbers, your net result can be tremendously off, right? And our ability to really know what this technology will do and its revenue potential is very, very limited due to the fact that we've never seen anything like this before. So we lack historical analog to be able to predict and project to any degree that we feel comfortable with. So you put that all together, we have this risk of uncertainty, right? Because we no longer have those credible expectations we can count on to commit the level of capital we would need to allow this technology to develop at its fastest rate. Because as...
investors, as a market, we're not passive in this technology either. What we decide to assign to the value of this thing self-funds and affects the rate by which it actually realizes. So that's another kind of square effect on top of it all. So you put that all together, that to me is what's causing a lot of the recent price actions and anxiety in the marketplace. It's not so much that people all of a sudden develop a bearish view of what the technology can accomplish, but it's rather this sudden realization that we can't know or we can only know so much about this thing and the numbers involved are so huge. So we don't know what to do about that. And that uncertainty is for sure going to lead to a lot of errors and companies that we think are going to do well may not have a business, and then companies that we think may be rich, we may all of a sudden realize, oh, there's so much additional profitability that this company will be able to realize that may actually be enterprise, and we're going through this period of risk management, in fact.
Yeah, yeah, I agree with that. In a previous panel there was a comment made about the strength of the ecosystem is as strong as its weakest link. And that's true for cyber, by the way, in third-party providers, that's true for every one of the risks we run at banks. In that sense, what is the, how do we banks make that ecosystem stronger? And that's the same question for you.
The ecosystem is quite strong and I think that sometimes we confuse systemic risk with people losing some money. So as John Gray mentioned this morning, the correction was what happened in private credit markets. I think that is a good thing. So expose the vulnerabilities that were there at a size that it wasn't systemic. So it would have been worse if you have these type of things when the asset class is 15 trillion. It's a trillion plus. So, and I think that there are a few of those things. Beyond that, I think that the amount of capital in the system, the amount of liquidity in the system, the resilience of the infrastructure. So clearly for me what could create a problem is cyber mainly or some very, very deep geopolitical development, but overall I think that the system is in a good place and functioning properly, is quite disciplined, and where there is no discipline you have the wakeup call in the market as we have seen this, I have seen this, the recent correction in the AI sector. So I think that as long as the market continues to do that and doesn't create these bubbles, it may correct over time, hopefully in a constructive way without a big problem.
Or the pricing of sovereign debt, for example. Right. Right. Yes. That now has become a lot wider, which is a good thing. No, and the markets have absorbed, etc.
So for us, we think about two things, right? We think about the risks that come from the operational scale. There's quite a bit of analogy between our market makers like ourselves that can operate with scale with firms that can no longer, that become increasingly challenged for them to keep up with what's required to operate at scale. It's a bit like hyperscalers where if you have the capital base, you have scale, the market's rewarding that right now. On some of the busiest days, we actually provision for multiples of what the amount of hardware and computing resources we normally need, just because in case our clients need it. And unless you're operating at the scale that we're operating, it'd be hard to provision that much technology resources just for the few days a year that you would need and your client would need. So thinking a lot about that scalability and the resiliency during times of volatility, that's one of the key things we think about as a market maker. The other thing is we fully expect the market to continue to go through stress periods. A combination of the uncertainty around AI as well as the geopolitical uncertainty would mean, well, what's guaranteed is for some segments of market or another going through these stress periods, and some of our clients will need more liquidity help than others during these periods. So we are privileged to be able to focus on facilitating our clients every day, including those periods, and we really stay away from having same-way risk as our clients, right? We're fortunate that our bigger brother Citadel, the hedge fund, is one of the most successful investment firms in history, and our partner Sequoia, who's an investor in ours, is one of the most successful venture capital firms in history. So being associated with them allows us to really focus on market making. So during times when the clients of ours are navigating difficult periods, we are fully available and ready to work with them to accommodate the capacity they need and facilitate their liquidity and risk needs in the marketplace.
Very good. Thank you very much, Pang Daniel. No, fascinating conversation. Thank you very much, everybody. Thank you very much, Ernesto, and our speakers for sharing the insights on the new market-making landscape.
Ladies and gentlemen, while diversification remains a cornerstone of modern finance, its implementation is becoming more complex. As investment themes and products converge, achieving true diversification is more challenging than ever. Our next panel brings together leaders from global banks and asset managers to offer insights into navigating this complexity and uncovering new opportunities to expand the investment frontier. Their expertise will guide us in building resilient portfolios capable of withstanding structural changes while at the same time continuing to capture growth. This session will be partially conducted in Putonghua. Please use the headsets in front of you for English simultaneous interpretation in channel 2. And with that, ladies and gentlemen, let us welcome our moderator, Kevin Sneer from Goldman Sachs, together with our speakers Balahi Bots from Amundi, George Alhedri from HSBC, Savo Mia Kupa from Societe Generale, and Jang Hi from Bank of China. Kevin, over to you now.
Kevin Sneer 2:44:08 ↗
Good morning. There we go. Right. Okay. We have three French speakers, one Chinese, and a Scot. What could possibly go wrong? We're going to try and speak English together. So, please be patient. It's a foreign language for all of us, so this is not easy. All right, diversification. We have a lot to cover. This is a dialogue, a subject that's been on the agenda last year and this year. One can question whether or not progress has been made. It's certainly a hot topic. And of course at a time with heightened uncertainties perhaps the pressure for diversification has also risen. So I'm delighted that we have such a terrific panel who literally need no introduction, which is just as well because they are getting no introduction. But I think you all know who they are. So we're going to make the most of that because we're under some pressure on the time front. But I am going to start with George from HSBC. Gor, terrific to have you with us today. Now you have been doing a lot of work on focusing your investments and one area which I know you have spoken of, you may even have spoken of this in this environment before, is the Asia-Middle East corridor. Can you talk to us a little bit on the subject of geographic diversification and that corridor in particular, how that's playing from a global perspective and what do you see it and how's it playing into your strategy for delivering diversification for your clients?
George Alhedri 2:45:34 ↗
Sure, Kevin. And I'll take the opportunity also to thank Eddie and the HKMA for receiving us today. Five points I would like to share about the geographic diversification relating to Asia and the Middle East in particular. The first one is what we're calling out is Asia buys Asia. Trade and investment flows in Asia have picked up in a way that for instance ASEAN now is the first partner to China in trade ahead of the US and Europe, and that's demonstrating much bigger consumer market, much bigger investments flow for manufacturing, and we believe Asia buys Asia will add 1.8% to the Asian GDP over the next five years. The second point is this region has plenty of capital. So we have nine of the 10 largest sovereign wealth funds on the planet in this Asia-Middle East region. There is plenty of capital accumulated also in private wealth through entrepreneurship that we're seeing growing across Asia and the Middle East. And that capital has historically been naturally invested in the very attractive markets of say the US or Europe. But more and more that capital is looking for opportunities now within Asia and the Middle East. And the demand for resilience, built infrastructure investments across the board is basically driving that capital to reinvest back onshore into the Asian-Middle East region. The third thing to call out is this region remains very much open for business, in particular very much open for trade. So the UAE in particular has signed 40 trade agreements, CEPA agreements in five years. Now that's a record. But it demonstrates the speed at which this region, the wider Asian-Middle East region, is opening up for partnering, you know, selling goods and buying goods. And it's not just the kind of Middle East sells oil and buys manufactured goods from Asia. It's become much more sophisticated, much more nuanced, and is growing at a fast pace. And more recently India-GCC trade agreement is also a demonstration of this trade integration, trade for integration of the wider region. And of course the ASEAN and the GCC are in negotiation of a free trade agreement which we hope they can achieve soon, and then we see that trade flow also growing. The fourth point I wanted to bring about is the cultural affinity of these two regions. There are various parts of Asia. If you go to India, they wouldn't call the Middle East Middle East Asia. They would say this is West Asia. And they see this as therefore part of the Asian continent. Geographically it is. But there's West Asia, there's South Asia, Southeast Asia, East Asia. They're looking at this in a way that is much more connected. And if you look at the diasporas, I mean certainly the Indian diaspora in the Middle East, we're counting more than 10 million. That's a big cultural affinity. But the growing Chinese diaspora across Southeast Asia and the Middle East is also very visible, and that's creating also this cultural affinity to be open and trading with each other. And then the last point I want to say is Asia buys Asia, Asia-Middle East, but that kind of concept is growing into these markets that are open for trade, and clearly South America, who claim for a number of them including Mexico, Colombia, that they are Asia-Pacific because they have a Pacific border and they want to be part of that trade flow, are going to be part of this global trade and investment flows increasingly so, and we see this as the next kind of frontier for these investment flows and trade flows. Thank you.
Kevin Sneer 2:49:24 ↗
Thank you, George. And a good reminder how the world looks really differently depending where you sit, including how you call things. I think this point about West Asia certainly resonates. But to go to President Jang from the Bank of China, last year and in other fora you have talked about the importance and the relevance of Hong Kong. So bring it closer to home, the relevance of Hong Kong as a base from which to expand into Southeast Asia, the Middle East or West Asia as well as the European Union. So maybe if you could just take a moment or two to share with us how do you think about the advantages or what Hong Kong offers when it comes to diversifying products for your clients?
Jang Hi 2:50:13 ↗
Please allow me to answer in Mandarin. You will have to wear the headsets. The moderator asked me to talk about how we think about the advantages of Hong Kong. Bank of China always looked at Hong Kong as a key strategic base for our globalization strategy because of the IFC status of Hong Kong, and also Hong Kong connects China's dividend together with global funds and clients, and Hong Kong plays an irreplaceable role, and there are four areas in particular. The first one is Hong Kong's super connector role. So the financial industry can cross-border allocate the asset in a diversified manner. We all know that Hong Kong has become the first choice for Chinese enterprises to go overseas, and also it is the first stop for foreign enterprises to invest in China, and a lot of emerging market enterprises also see Hong Kong as a new investment highland. And the second advantage for Hong Kong, it is an offshore RMB hub. It enjoys unique strengths. The investment currency can be diversified. Hong Kong accounts for more than 75% of the payment of offshore RMB transaction. Actually, the PBOC representatives have already mentioned about the policies to support Hong Kong as an offshore RMB center, and for the qualified mortgage position for the RMB denominated bonds will also play a very big role for Hong Kong. And certainly Hong Kong has always been an innovation center for finance, and for this year, for the commodities transaction capabilities building in Hong Kong, of course, will play a bigger role in the future. The finance innovation capabilities in Hong Kong will also provide more choices for investors. And the fourth point is another point, which is a highland for international finance talents. Hong Kong provides a variety of financial services for investors, and in Hong Kong there are several top universities, and in recent years Hong Kong continued to promote different supporting policies for high quality talents, including finance talents, cross-border talents and legal talents, and all these policies will be very useful for Hong Kong's development and for the Bank of China. Next year it will be our 110th anniversary. This is a very important milestone for us, and we will also continue to invest our resources in Hong Kong, and we will continue to play a very big role to help contribute to the IFC positioning of Hong Kong. Thank you.
Kevin Sneer 2:53:39 ↗
110th birthday. I know everyone would sing, but we don't have time. So, Suvamir, maybe turning to yourself, you've been busy quite a bit of restructuring, refocusing, disposals and strategic exits. How does that shape your approach to delivering for your clients diversification and how you manage the implications of a reshaped portfolio?
Savo Mia Kupa 2:54:03 ↗
Thank you. Thank you. Indeed, we've been very busy streamlining the portfolio, and I want to say two things to start with. One, diversification is obviously a number one concern and objective for a bank executive to make sure that risks are managed properly before even considering strategic diversification from a business standpoint. But the other thing I want to say is that when I was young I attended a function, a closing dinner with a lot of people, and there were, you know, screens and all the banks were advertising themselves, and we were advertising the fact that we were in 74 countries and that we had, whatever at the time, 130,000 employees. So it seemed like the more the better, and I think, you know, time has proven that it's probably a little more complex than that on both ends. So our journey in the last few years was one where we indeed divested more or less like 14 businesses and among these basically 13 countries. Because with diversification you need to pay attention to value creation, and value creation is in tension with diversification, both in terms of obviously averaging returns, but more importantly for a bank and a bank executive, it's the idea that the more you reduce focus in terms of business, in terms of capital allocation, in terms of risk-adjusted returns, in terms of risk management also eventually, in terms of what is the portfolio of tail risk that you also embed by being over-diversified and overstretched in terms of geographies, you end up in an equation in terms of value creation which destroys the theoretical benefits of the diversification. So our journey was exactly that, not so much let's reduce the number of countries, but much more let's look at the deeper level, the various dimensions of value creation, again from capital returns, capital allocation, risk management, and how can we recompose the portfolio in ways where value creation comes first. And so after the process of streamlining, we have basically, including at these portfolio levels, basically doubled the returns, 80 basis points of CET1 freed up, I think a much more consistent risk management and much better, much more stable risk-adjusted returns. And so I think that's very important to always pay attention to value creation when thinking about diversification.
Kevin Sneer 2:56:58 ↗
Thanks. So let's go from Societe Generale to Amundi and Valeri. Clearly you are one of the world's leading asset managers. Not a lot of Europeans in the list of the top 10. What are the implications of that for your clients who are seeking to diversify? And do you feel a responsibility or a burden as Europe's leader in this regard?
Valeri Bots 2:57:22 ↗
Well, I don't know if it's a responsibility. I think it's probably easy, but it's above all an opportunity for our clients. We manage 2.6 trillion, among which 500 billion for Asian clients. We have, of course, strong European DNA, but strong anchoring in Asia as well. What our clients want is, as for all big asset managers, some of them are in the room, scale, the capacity to bring a lot of expertise, performance of course, but above all what our clients want is advice, most of the time, especially in the current times, and it's for that reason that we're here today in Hong Kong. Thank you again Eddie for that meeting which is very precious for all of us. And what they want, advice, they want to have the different lenses of the advice. And I think that all the more in the world we're living today, which is a bit more fragmented unfortunately, you need to have all the lenses, the American one, the Asian one, the southern one, the European one. Of course it's incredibly important to understand properly the world and the strengths and especially the consequences of the geopolitics towards economy. So that's what we're bringing to our clients, and probably one last thing, which is also the capacity to diversify the risks and to make sure that they are able to trust partners all over the world.
Kevin Sneer 2:59:12 ↗
Thank you. Let's shift from the geographic side to the broader set of trends and diversification, and we're going to do this as a sort of one-minute each round, just in order to respect the time that we have. And maybe we'll start with you, Valeri. Societe Generale has been doing work on your sustainable finance framework. Just in a minute, how do you think about the role of green and sustainability products in supporting diversification?
Savo Mia Kupa 2:59:41 ↗
It's again about the business opportunities, the resilience and so on. So our starting point, say at the end of the past decade, by 2019, we were one of the leading banks in the world in terms of, let's say, traditional energy financing. We were doing things all over the place. We have kind of put coal to the side, but we were doing everything else. And the challenge that we have at the time, under obviously some policy pressure, but not only, you know, client demand, our own vision for the future, right? You know, you need to diversify away from the past and into the future. That's always a decent approach. And so we have very firmly then, and have been consistent since, decided to flip the business. So say the green ratio, the component that we have in terms of, let's say, traditional energies was 80% in 2019. It's now less than 40. And obviously you have the opposite in terms of the low-carbon energy financing that we do and advisory all over the world. And the idea here is again not being the last person standing with that piece of coal when it's over. All right. And this is something that we were running the risk of to some extent. And two, well, the business opportunity across the entire value chain. First basically moving from one source of energy to another, but then building an entire business ecosystem for us working on the new challenges like adaptation, risk mitigation, which are huge new opportunities unfortunately as the climate challenge continues to be a big one for everybody. But also around these themes, all the value chains, electrification, battery storage, all the new emerging leaders, right? We are very big bank to one of the leaders in China in terms of battery storage, battery production, renewable energy technology and so on and so forth. This is a non-existent client 10 years ago. Today a very big client of the bank because it is very active in the value chain of the climate topic. So it's really building diversification over time and into new businesses which, and that's going to be my final point, are also critical in nature. So you're repositioning from something that I'm oversimplifying, right? It's not that simple, but that something that's basically dying over time and over the next decades will die into something which is not only rising but also critical. So that demand for the financing and for the products and for the advisory that we can provide clients with is on a critical need which we like obviously to be active on a critical need.
Kevin Sneer 3:02:38 ↗
Thank you, Valerie. ETFs have been a part of Amundi, clearly a place where you have a leading role, but how are you thinking about the shift in client demand and the balance between traditional benchmark exposure that ETFs bring versus the growing demand for alternatives?
Valeri Bots 3:02:57 ↗
Well, in less than one minute, our first priority above all is to answer all our client needs everywhere, especially here in Asia. So we do active, passive, ETFs, indexing, money market, treasury solutions, technology solutions as well. So we offer everything. But you're completely right, ETFs has become, it's not only used as a liquid useful tool. It has become core in the allocation of our clients. All types of clients from the most, from central banks, the most largest institutional clients to the pure retail clients. So they are really core in the allocation now and they're part of the picture and we're really happy to manage 400 billion in ETFs today. Private assets are more and more growing for the time being. They've been especially used by institutional clients. They are not liquid or less liquid according to which one they are, but they have a good risk return. So that's why they're growing in the portfolios, in the portfolio constructions of our clients. And we definitely use them more and more, introducing them step by step, being careful with retail clients as well because they deserve the profitability that they bring.
Kevin Sneer 3:04:24 ↗
Thank you. President Jang, what role, from your seat at the Bank of China, what role do you see Chinese products playing in product diversification?
Jang Hi 3:04:44 ↗
For the investment value of the Chinese product, it is becoming more and more evident in terms of diversification. I would say that China is playing a bigger and bigger role. First of all, what we need to pay attention is to RMB denominated assets, especially the treasury bonds. We are seeing a lot of volatility. I believe that a lot of investors would pay more attention to the safety and security of the assets, and I believe everybody is very confident about the Chinese economy, and then you will have confidence in the treasury bonds of China. And another thing is about the independence of the RMB products. The relevance or connectivity with the European assets is relatively low, and the return rate is very different from the European or American assets. And thirdly is about liquidity. We are seeing more and more recognition from the global investors, and it is also becoming more liquid. And another thing is about the stability of the RMB assets. The RMB exchange rate continues to maintain in a very stable range, and it provides more confidence to our investors. And fifthly, I think that is also the most important point. The RMB exchange rate is very low, so the financing capability for RMB products is very strong. For example, you can issue the dim sum bond in Hong Kong. It can cater to the needs of a lot of investors in terms of its low cost. In terms of industries, you can pay attention to two points. First is about the application of AI in different areas. As you know, China is leading in AI development. But what needs more attention is the actual application of AI in different sectors in China. As you know, China is the biggest manufacturing power in the world, and we have the most comprehensive manufacturing system, and smart manufacturing is one of the key priorities for China, which means that AI will have a bigger role to play in manufacturing. We also need to pay attention to the green industry, and the president from Societe Generale also mentioned this point. With geopolitics tensions, we think that energy security is becoming more important, and the green industry plays a very good supporting role. China's PV manufacturing, wind turbine manufacturing and energy storage, these are all the big advantages we have, and these will play a very important role to support energy security. That's all for me. Thank you.
Kevin Sneer 3:07:57 ↗
We heard the chief executive talk about commodities, gold for example. If you think about it from your vantage point and the role that HSBC, as it expands its commodities business here in Hong Kong, what role do you see commodities playing? Can they play a more central role in diversified portfolios?
George Alhedri 3:08:15 ↗
So we believe commodities among all the other points actually are an important diversification point, and in particular precious metals, and within that in particular gold. There are three reasons I'd call out, Kevin. Number one, they do, gold for instance does provide diversification. Gold is a risk-off asset unlike many risk-on, and therefore is providing diversification to a risk-on portfolio. Second, gold over time has proven to be a good hedge to long-term inflation. Maybe not short term, but over long term gold has been a good protector against inflation. And then thirdly, there is intrinsic value in gold. I mean it could be used in industrial uses or ornament or other kind of jewelry uses. So there's intrinsic value. So this is why we like it. I mean I compare that to crypto for instance, doesn't have intrinsic value. It doesn't have the test of time and the inflationary impact. And it's a risk-on asset. So therefore clearly gold provides something. Precious metal provides something other assets don't provide. HSBC has been heavily involved in that. In Hong Kong, we launched gold tokens. It is now top three gold token in the world. And we're now, you know, rolling out to other international markets beyond Hong Kong because it's been so successful, multi-billion dollar. We launched from Hang Seng Bank our first gold ETF in the market. Within a week, it was more than a billion Hong Kong dollar. So, it's a demonstration of the strong appetite for gold as a diversification asset. And more recently, we announced that we'll be launching our vault. So, of course, we're involved in trading, financing, clearing, but we announced our vault storage capability here in Hong Kong to the tune of 150 tons of gold. That's adding to our London vault of 200 and the New York vault as well. So, that gives us now also physical presence of that asset here for investors across Asia.
Kevin Sneer 3:10:14 ↗
Terrific. Well, thank you. Thank you, Valerie. Thank you, George. Thank you, Spamir. Thank you, President Jang. Please thank our panelists, and we appreciate Eddie your invitation.
Thank you very much to all panelists and Kevin for your insights on diversifying in a concentrated world. Ladies and gentlemen, up next we will look at the escalating global race for computing power. As high-end hardware and data infrastructure remain critical bottlenecks, geoeconomic tensions have driven up the cost of energy, which in turn inflates the cost of compute. This raises the following questions. Are we seeing an infrastructure bubble in AI? How does the energy equation fit into this picture? And are there any risks lying underneath the surface? Ladies and gentlemen, for this panel, let's welcome our moderator Bal Khan from UBS, together with our speakers Jim Culture from TPG, Bruce Flatt from Brookfield, and Bob Prince from Bridgewater. I'll hand the stage to you now. Thank you.
Bal Khan 3:11:29 ↗
Thank you very much. Thank you Eddie and HKMA for hosting yet again a fantastic event. Thank you gentlemen for being here. We've heard a lot this morning. I'm just going to sort of like summarize what I've heard and then we'll just get into this because we only have like 19, 20 minutes. Glass half full, partially empty, but not that empty. The empty bits maybe fatter tails, no end to demand. There's supply, retail will participate. My boss talked about suitability. I do feel I represent the retail side here as the head of wealth management. But let's get into data centers, power, capital, and all of that. Bruce, starting with you, you all have been investing in power, data centers probably the longest. Where are we really? What are the challenges you're seeing? Or is it blue sky from here?

120 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Solomon, D. (2026, November 2). LIVE: Global Banking Leaders Gather In Hong Kong For Annual Financial Leaders Summit | AF1D [Interview transcript]. DRM News. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3190731/

MLA

David Solomon. "LIVE: Global Banking Leaders Gather In Hong Kong For Annual Financial Leaders Summit | AF1D." DRM News, 2 Nov. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3190731/.

BibTeX
@misc{solomon2026_3190731,
  author       = {David Solomon},
  title        = {LIVE: Global Banking Leaders Gather In Hong Kong For Annual Financial Leaders Summit | AF1D},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, DRM News. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {nov},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3190731/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}