I think this market has become much more of a gambling institution, and you see everybody lined up on one way, and then, you know, being a contrarian and going against consensus has become much more, I think, profitable.
From Morgan Stanley, this is Hard Lessons, where iconic investors reveal the critical moments that have shaped who they are today. You'll hear about two out-of-consensus calls, one that was on the money and one that wasn't.
Today on the show, Rick Rieder, BlackRock's Chief Investment Officer of Global Fixed Income, in conversation with Seth Carpenter, Morgan Stanley's Global Chief Economist and Head of Macro Research.
At BlackRock, Rieder helps to oversee $2.7 trillion in assets under management across global bond and multi-asset markets. He's an influential voice on interest rates, inflation, and market structure, and chairman of BlackRock's firm-wide Investment Council.
It actually has been a while since you and I sat down and talked together.
Good to be here. Thanks for having me on it.
You've been at BlackRock now for 17 years.
Yeah, that's a long time. 17 years. Hard to believe. It's hard to believe.
What's it been like, that journey at BlackRock?
I remember in '09, like I had, I had a hedge fund, and all my partners were discussing should we go to BlackRock or not? And, and I remember saying, this place, you know, could be the epicenter of finance, but not thinking that the firm would grow to the scale it did. We were right before the acquisition of BGI and iShares, and which has transformed part of the transformation of the ETF industry. And to think about, you know, over $14 trillion in assets. And when I joined, we were a tiny fraction of that. And it's become like a pretty, pretty amazing place. So it's been, uh, it's been fun.
You did say epicenter, which I think is a useful word, because how many billions of dollars of assets under management? Did you think you'd be able to talk about trillions of dollars of assets under management?
I chair the board of our charter schools in Newark, New Jersey, and I did a talk about how much we managed. And I said, does anybody know how many zeros in trillions? And then somebody gave the answer, and I really didn't know. And I had to actually do, I actually had to think about it and say, oh, hold on. I gotta actually think about how many zeros. And it was actually a funny thing. But when you think about, you know, the sheer scale of it, and, you know, it is pretty extraordinary. You know, certainly in the portfolios I run, we're like maniacal about precision in each of them. So it doesn't feel, like, untenable. It feels very manageable in terms of that scale.
Trillion dollars, trillions of dollars. That's a lot. Do you think the sheer size of it is part of the secret to success? What is it that's the secret?
There, there are some benefits that come alongside of it in terms of the amount of flow we see across different asset classes, seeing thousands of situations. The odds statistically are just better that we can look at so many different things. And by the way, not that I make all the right decisions or many of them, but it is the ability to actually look and say, okay, that makes sense, and see relative value in places you wouldn't even think. Like, being able to put the pieces together. It gives you an ability to actually try and build the puzzle effectively.
So I'm gonna shift to try to draw wisdom out of you and dissect a little bit that process that you go through when you think about your career. There are places where you have been out-of-consensus, and it turned out you were right.
Maybe I'll start with describing, like when you say the wisdom. I actually don't think, like I don't, I don't feel like I, I should be characterized as having wisdom because I don't, like, I think everything is like you have to do immense amounts of work. And I don't think there, for me at least, there's no innate, distinctive skill set. I just think you try and put all the pieces together and then have conviction about it. And some people are like, you're in it, you have conviction, and then you double down. If people don't believe in it, you're not very good at that. I think, though, what I've been able to do is look at things like technology. I am a huge fan geek in terms of technology. When a new technology comes out, I have to be the first in line. And every new technology that comes out, my wife laughs at me. I got to go to the store. I got to stand in line. I got to be with my peeps. And I got, I got to learn what this is. And I just love tech. And I never forgot when EV cars came out. And there was this, you know, they're not going to, it's not going to work. The battery's too expensive. It can't compete. You have these huge players that are entrenched in gas-powered vehicles, and like it can't, can't work. And I don't remember doing all the work and looking at that it wasn't really an auto business. It was an energy business. So anything about is, it efficient? Can you create real scale around it? And I remember doing all the work. I can remember sitting in rooms, and I was the only dope in the room. And you start to think, by the way, there are times I'm, you know, I have no problem describing my conviction. But I'll tell you. Just getting in early on these things. I remember first driving when I was like, oh my God, it's fast, it's clean, it's quiet. I'm like, this is a better product. And I do it with it with like everything. The same thing when, I remember when the Mac first came out, and I remember when the AirPod came out, and like, this works and this is just distinctive, but to me it's like, okay. And then you, then you understand what's the time of the market? What's the, the size of the market? How can you bring costs down over time? What's your cash flow on the back side of it?
So there's a really disciplined, humble process that you just described. But there's also a bit of a lonely process being sort of all by yourself sometimes, and everybody else saying that maybe you're crazy. What do you do in those moments?
So I would say 99% of the time, it's all about collaboration team, because everybody tends to move with the consensus, myself included, most of the time, virtually all the time. And there are some people who are different, who maybe have your view that are also out-of-consensus. And you check yourself a lot with those people, and you say, okay, what are we missing? What do we have wrong? And then I like to read a lot of people with a different perspective, and like, why do they think this makes no sense or what have you. So I tend to go with people that are aligned on the view, and then the people who aren't, really trying to study it and trying to get confident. But like I say, I've learned over time that we're not in the business of being right. We're in the business of generating return for clients. And what happens is the market perception can stay wrong longer. And I remember studying, as you did in school, the efficient markets thesis. I actually think they should throw that out because that is so far from the truth. You know, I think markets are wrong a ton. But you got, you got to survive, and you could be out of capital by the time the markets get it, get it in theory, right. So I try and stay in it. I'm not very good at doubling down when people go against me because, you know, your confidence goes. But I try and stay in what I have, and then try and develop the thought deeper. And like this, this is going to work.
Oh, that's, that's fascinating. It's funny. I think it was, uh, Keynes who, who was at least attributed for saying the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay liquid. Do you find it, and this is very self-serving as a sell-side analyst, but do you find it more helpful for you to read people who have sort of the same general view so you can corroborate what you're thinking? Or is it more helpful to find people who disagree with you so you can pressure test and find out where you might be wrong?
I'd say the most sophisticated answer was to challenge yourself with the people of a different view, and I, I just don't as much as I should. You know, there are people who I respect and I trust, and I like to look at, you know, whether they're right or wrong. I like to go with that. But a situation when you're very against consensus, and I try and read a lot about the people who are aligned on the view. And the one thing you learn is everybody tends to move together and then goes. And I think social media has, has made this even more intense. Everybody moves in the same direction. And, you know, I found maybe just being old or doing this for a long time, there is a time when you see, like, everybody's moving and prices moved, and then now like, okay, now it's done, and now it's time to, to go the other way. And I think this market has become much more of a gambling institution. And you see everybody lined up on one way. And then, you know, being a contrarian and going against consensus has become much more, I think, profitable. And particularly when the news flow is so intense, like, it's been a pretty good trade. Market goes one way and you just fade it, then it goes the other way. When you fade it and you realize you're staying on the line of a trend.
And I'd say, though, if basically the whole market is in one place, it is harder to make money that way because it's all already in the price. And so where are you going to be there? There are probably some times where you have gone through, dotted your Is, crossed your Ts, and still ended up not having the trade work out. Maybe the consensus was right for a reason. When you think through those experiences where it hasn't panned out, what, what comes to mind?
The ones where I didn't get it right come right to the fore, and the, and it's, you know, because I think you learn much more from when you got things wrong. You tend to forget or hope that part of what you train for your whole life, you're going to get more right than wrong, hopefully. But I remember, like with bonds, the coupon, the maturity of something 20 years ago, it was early in my career. I was right out of school, and I figured I must be right on this, and I could buy more. And it was an incredible lesson that, like, the world thinks I'm wrong. You got to get out, or you've got to reduce your size to the point that it doesn't ruin, or one security ruin your whole career. But that was lesson one that was like, you got to manage your risk, you got to manage your size. And then, you know, it's a small industry, and everybody gets a sense you're in a bad spot. Not a good place to be, not a good place. And it's a pretty vicious industry. Like when people think you're on the wrong side.
Sort of taste the blood in the water.
Oh my God. And they can press you. But I'll remember Peloton. I was one of the original owners of it. I remember it was more personal, and I got in. It was incredible. And I watched the technology, and then Covid hit, which was a fortunate situation for it. And then the thing exploded to the upside. And then, you know, you get more bought into the ecosystem. And it's one of those things like it's very hard when you think like you had the right perspective on it, and then all of a sudden it starts to go the other way. And there are a lot of people who say why it went the other way. Listen, I think there were a few things that I learned during that in terms of how do you manage cash flow? You grow too fast. People say Covid, you know, maybe there's a little bit of that, but stop loss is a pretty healthy thing to do. And, you know, you hold your conviction. I really believe in this, that I have this theory that you believe three out of four times, you're right, you're right, you're right. And then, okay, time to move on. But you know, this industry in one situation can hurt you in such an extreme way that I believe in this, particularly on the bond side. Diversify. Make sure you've got liquid assets. Get it right 60%, 65% or 60% of the time. And illiquid if you get it right 70% of the time on the fixing. Like I really feel like doing it more times than not. Just do it like a casino.