I just want to begin by saying congratulations, and I just want to get your reaction to this prize, you know, the most prestigious of prizes. And when you were told, what did you think?
Well, of course I was caught unaware completely because I was sitting in courtroom 600 with phones off. And unfortunately, the selection committee was unable to reach me, and when they announced the award, they even said in that call, "If you're listening, Navi Pillay, please phone us back." So it was just a moment, and that's why I learned of it later. It was a complete surprise. But I'm absolutely pleased because I see this as an award respecting the advancement of the rule of law and of justice.
One of the UN commissions that you presided over found that Israel had in fact committed genocide in Gaza. That's according to your commission's findings. Israel categorically rejects the commission's findings of genocide. They say that they were fighting Hamas, not seeking to destroy Palestinians and the Palestinian people. Why do you reject this argument?
There were three commissioners. I was the chair. There is not a single fact that we put in that report that has not been verified by us. Where we couldn't verify a report of an incident as true, we left it out. It was a very court-like process. Anybody who reads the report connects the evidence we heard, the statements that political leaders in Israel made, including the president, the prime minister, and the former minister of defense. So, you connect those, you will come to the same conclusion. So, it's been criticized by Israel and the United States. It's been criticized by lobby groups who promote those views. But I'm very pleased that we've had no criticism from sources that I would pay heed to, such as academics, other lawyers, legal practitioners, including the NGOs who are focusing on these matters. So, I'm very pleased there has not been a challenge to our conclusions in that report.
When these sorts of commissions or courts are either rejected or criticized by those who have been accused of such crimes, how can there be accountability?
I think the reports of the commissions are very important. The Security Council relied on a report it received in respect of the former Yugoslavia and then acted to set up a special tribunal there. Similarly, the Security Council sent a commission to investigate and report to the Security Council. They usually are very careful about the individuals they select as commissioners. They must be independent, impartial, objective, and people of stature. And why is that? Because more recently, courts also rely on the investigations done by commissions and these triple-I mechanisms the UN has set up for the safe collection and safeguarding of evidence. So it's an important tool that governments need when they get together in international circles to make a decision. They need reliable information. We all hear about the great work done by media, but still you have questions about whether that is impartially collected, whether it's true. And therefore commissions have become an important tool. You know that we serve voluntarily. Commissioners don't get paid. Commissioners work for the United Nations, that is. That's an additional factor which guarantees integrity and impartiality. They have no personal agenda in the way they produce those reports.
Yes, your commission found that Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli Prime Minister, incited genocide. Do you believe that he should face prosecution?
That's what we recommend. Our recommendation, our finding is that the president, Prime Minister Netanyahu, and the former Minister of Defense should be put on trial. They should be prosecuted either by national courts or by the International Criminal Court, the most likely international court that would be able to put these individuals on trial. Let me recall that the purpose of the Genocide Convention is to prevent genocide. The world doesn't want to wait for a genocide to happen and then react to it. It's too late. Thousands of people get killed in these genocidal attacks. Therefore, the focus of all states when they adopted the Genocide Convention is: as soon as you hear that there might be genocidal conflict, you have to step in to prevent it. That's a legal obligation that rests on every state, even if the genocide didn't happen in their own territory.
So, Israel in response accuses the commission, accuses you of bias rather than real analysis. You know, I'm just curious to know what is the strongest evidence that you would point to to counter that?
Firstly, my own record. You know, judges are professionally trained to be impartial. Secondly, I was welcomed by the state of Israel. I was the only High Commissioner for Human Rights who received an invitation from them to conduct a mission in Israel. This was around 2012, when I was the High Commissioner. We worked very well together, and the authorities in Israel told me they respected the fact that I brought a balance into the reporting in the Human Rights Council on Israel because I presented their views and their documents as well. It was only when I became chair of this commission that I received these abusive comments that I was anti-Semitic, and now that I'm biased. So, what I say is it's totally incorrect, and anyone can check that situation by reading the report itself.
I just want to point out to you, you know, the reaction from Israel to you receiving the Nobel Peace Prize. The Israeli foreign minister said of your win, he said it's a grotesque weaponization of an award to legitimize anti-Israel hatred and prejudice. He accused you of relentless, politically motivated demonization of Israel. The Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office called you a bigot and accused the Nobel Committee of having lost its moral compass. Your reaction to that?
You know, those are groundless accusations. It's in reaction to a report that should concern them very much. And as I said, the criticism of me only came about when I started investigating in Gaza. It's an unwarranted reaction because I have a record as a judge. So do the other two commissioners who have been impartial in their assessments of the evidence. And I see that they're also critical of the award itself. The award is, as I said earlier, focused on the rule of law and on justice. These are precepts that every member of the public cherishes. And let me say that for the purpose of drawing this report, which concludes that Israel committed genocide, that was supported by evidence from inside Israel. The government had prohibited like eight well-known NGOs inside Israel from sharing information with the commission, from sharing information with the International Criminal Court. Clearly with the goal of making sure that what they are doing is suppressed. They themselves suppressed it, would not allow anyone or any international journalists to come in there to make a record of what is really happening. So I want to emphasize that we held test hearings in Geneva and brought people out of Israel. And we protected the names of some of these people. So we have actual hearings from the victims, from doctors, and from academics and NGOs who are working on these issues. So I began by saying here we verified every fact before we recorded it.