Good morning or afternoon if you're in New York. Welcome to Market Hang. My name is Ross Gerber. I am the president and CEO of Gerber Kawasaki Wealth and Investment Management. I manage over $5 billion for investors. I'm a real stock trader, actually one of the biggest on here in Santa Monica. And basically what we're doing today is we get a great group of people together.
We kind of mash through the news of the day and we're mostly trying to give you some information to really help you make more intelligent investments, better financial planning, understand what's happening in the world a little bit better. And that's what we're all here to try to do is try to make sense of this crazy world we live in. Because let's be real, when you look at the news today, there's nothing more distressing. It's almost like everything you see is so sad and negative. And yet when you walk outside it's not so bad. And so we're trying to just bring a little levity into the world for everybody because I do think, you know, the news can be awful negative. So we try to, you know, have more of a spin on things that I think brings a little bit more reality into what's happening in the world.
So let's start with what we have. Oh, let me bring in our guests. We have some great guests today. Very happy. And one special guest will be coming in later who I'm really excited about. But first we have Christine, who's also an expert, I guess, in corporate events in Wall Street. We have Drew from Roundhill, and you know, I'm kind of an old fan of Roundhill, being somebody who was involved with them at the founding. Really amazing success story that Roundhill has, and their very insightful research department in the areas that we like to invest in as well, in AI and technology and other areas. We have Shai from Futurum, who is not as fit as Daniel, but is working very hard.
So, I've now heard that this is a tough thing at your firm. Maybe you guys have a gym downstairs. And then later on we're going to bring in Gary Black to just hash through the Tesla event because let's be real, behind all this is the Tesla Roadster event tonight. And if you're like me, who's been an EV investor, a Tesla investor for 14 years, I've owned every Tesla that's been made, I'm very excited about this tonight because I've been waiting for this car for it seems like maybe six to eight years. And you know, I don't think it needs to fly to make me happy or make me buy it. But I'm ready to trade in my Cybertruck for a Roadster. But I'm excited for the event tonight and we'll get into that when Gary jumps in.
But why don't we start right off the top and we'll get into the economy. And there was sort of this talk of like if we didn't have AI then maybe the economy would be in a recession. And you know, I want to get your take on this because the way I look at the economy now is we're seeing a serious deterioration in the small and medium-sized businesses and sort of the mom and pop part of the economy as high inflation starts to grip and hurt consumers. But then on the other side of the coin, we have this massive AI buildout, massive investment, you know, just tons of things happening, whether it be in construction, healthcare, technology. We have more liquidity than ever with like the SpaceX IPO. So yet there's more wealth, higher wages. The average American's earning more money, but it's also being offset by the highest inflation we've seen since the pandemic. So, are we on the verge of a recession? So, let's jump in. Why don't we start with Christine? I don't know if this is your thing, but why don't we jump into that?
Yeah, sure. I mean, I think Fed Chair's point was if you remove the AI buildout, would there be a recession? And some have said, and you know, we might get to Larry Fink's comments as well, if you remove the, if there's a moratorium on the data center buildout, then we're going to go straight to a recession. And I think Goolsbee's point was no, because there's money there that would filter into other parts of the economy. Obviously it's been very concentrated to AI, but what was happening before the AI buildout, and I don't know where you kind of mark the AI buildout, but for me it's the public launch of ChatGPT in November of 2022. What was happening before then? Well, you know, besides the COVID blip of 2020, we were in an over decade-long bull run. Labor market was still strong and so things were going pretty well.
2% inflation, remember those days?
Oh god, who can forget? Yeah. So I agree like there's other areas for money. Corporations still have a ton of money, right? And they'd figure out where to deploy it. We recently did an article that looked at dividends and buybacks. Remember when you know buybacks were hitting record levels and maybe on a dollar level they do again this year. But we found that the number of buyback announcements in Q3 was the lowest we've seen in 10 years. Dividend announcements, the percentage that were decreases. So the number of announcements that companies made on dividends, 19% were decreasing dividends in Q3 and that was the highest level since Q2 2020 when we were in lockdown. So companies have been pulling back on those things because they've been investing in the AI buildout.
Yeah. Because I would also... I want to have some fun with this one because you said one thing, that they have money, right? What about small and medium-sized businesses? Not as much money. You got a whole bunch of PPP money and like here, sure, flood the system back then, but they spent it. The big guys, they still have access to it, so yeah, mom and pop...
That's part of the problem right now is there's access to capital if you have a lot of money, but if you don't have a lot of money as a business you're getting squeezed from capital because banks don't really lend to small businesses anymore.
So I think it's really tough for small businesses right now and here in my neighborhood in Santa Monica it's like a restaurant closes every day that used to be very successful. We have many like pretty good small and medium-sized businesses struggling right now. And then on top of now higher rates coming in with the Fed. But I think going back, if we didn't have the AI data center buildout, we would have a lot more capital in the markets and we'd have a lot lower rates. So it doesn't necessarily mean that we would have a recession just because there wouldn't be so much investment. In fact, we'd have lower inflation too, right? So, and then more buybacks. So I don't think one can say like if we didn't have this, we'd have that because there's all these other things that would happen. What are your thoughts on this? Do you have any thoughts on this? Shai, don't be shy.
Okay. No, I won't be shy. I will say the rates is purely because we just entered a war that we really didn't have to before. So I think that's primarily the case on why the rates are so high. But we are also in such a strange environment where like the AI buildout can be great for economic growth and corporate earnings clearly via buybacks. But it's creating some of the most inflationary and financing pressure. The markets are kind of a bit uncomfortable. So the next phase of the AI trade like we're seeing it right now in real time is becoming a lot more complicated because the question isn't anymore of who benefits from this enormous reallocation of capital and resources because clearly 10 stocks are lifting the indices to all-time highs while the individual stocks are getting buried in some kind... that's been the case for a long time, you know. I mean truthfully the IWM has underperformed the S&P over the last 5 years by a substantial amount.
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's funny you bring... I want to touch on that because I've been probably the biggest small cap bear for a while and I used to be a small cap specialist. So, I guess I'm not good at talking my old book, but yeah, it's just funny. It's back to the money. It's not about where the money goes, it's how much money you make with that money. And if you took it out of AI and put it into other things like Goolsbee was talking about, it's not going to earn as much in profits. So, like I'm going to spin this from a markets guy perspective here.
If we didn't have AI, we might not actually have an economic recession, but we're going to have an earnings recession, and we've already gone through a bunch of those in the past four or five years.
That's true. Yeah, I agree with you. I think that AI is also driving efficiency at a lot of businesses, which has increased margins on the S&P by several percentage points. And so, you know, I really don't like the counterfactual like if we didn't have this, we'd have that because we just don't know how all, you know, the economy in America is so complex with so many inputs and outputs like to just say if we didn't have this, then this would happen. It doesn't work that way. It just doesn't. And so I think when you what you talked about with the small caps, you know, is a very real thing and something that if it's not addressed will ultimately lead to a recession because we can't have an economy where 10 companies make all the money and everybody else in the economy is struggling. That just doesn't work forever at some point.
You know, I brought this up a couple shows ago about, you know, real estate used to drive the economy. You know, like you would like build stuff, you know, and now we're building data centers, fine, but like the rest of the real estate economy is like horrible right now, you know.
Well, maybe because they're losing labor to the data center buildout and they...
Well, it's not labor, it's rates to be honest. It's just rates, you know.
It's not just rates. Like AI isn't just a tech sector issue anymore. It's competing with housing, manufacturing, other industries for a lot of the same components like you're just talking about. So I think a lot of the weakness right now outside AI is actually by the result of this buildout crowding those industries out which effectively affects SMBs. So I don't think this is going to go away anytime soon. That's the issue because the AI buildout is the beginning of this massive S-curve. So if AI demand does gradually cool off from those resources, I do believe that it's going to move somewhere else which means housing construction or manufacturing could recover and then the economy could rebalance itself. I don't know, losing the entire amount of AI spending all of a sudden in recessionary environments...
But I agree with Drew's point about earnings, which I cover very closely. Look how those have just catapulted over the last couple of years because of this AI buildout. And every season we say can we continue to see growth. We're about to see the third quarter of S&P 500 EPS growth above 25% and the question is how can it continue. And we know that's a low bar, right? Companies always beat that bar and so can continue into Q4.
I think earnings are going to be up 35% this quarter.
Yeah. I mean, you know, and it doesn't matter up, right?
Well, it does matter. So funny. If it's up 35% this quarter, great, cool, awesome. But the market's already priced that there's a lot of embedded growth. But Drew, you got to factor in PE ratios of the market. Like, so like if you go back to the beginning of the year, we were running at 21, 22 times forward, right? And that's historically... Well, now we're under 19 and now we're about to report earnings of up 30% and let's say the market doesn't go up over the next month or so. Now we're going to be looking at a historical PE where I like it at 18 and a half where I'm a buyer of markets when the PE is under...
You guys aren't going to like me.
Well, I don't like... you can bear... you're allowing bears on the show that you know... I typically don't but I will for you, Drew. It's funny because I'm not a PE person because the problem is...
You don't have to be. I am.
I'm a DCF person so I'm old school.
Yeah. For someone who... DCF then looks real bad with rates going up, right?
It doesn't look terrible. But let's how I frame it. It's not about what the DCF tells me the value should be. It's how much growth do I need to justify the price today. That's how I kind of frame the world and right...
And look, like that growth bar is still really high even though PE's come down. But the reason I'm bullish is because of the E. It's to me it's the reason to be bullish is not that the market's gotten like literally got to put the dad mug down right here. Like hasn't gotten cheaper. The growth expectations are high. That's why when companies report huge growth like don't go up. They have to report good growth and better forward commentary has to come with it. Growth expectations are high, but I think we can get there. That's why I'm bullish. So, I'm all about...
Well, I do think that TSM is a perfect example. Well, TSMC is a perfect example of how fickle the market is right now because clearly that was an exceptional earnings report, but the market is looking for renewed excitement essentially where the quarter told us there's nothing wrong with the actual AI demand while it also showed us that fantastic demand no longer guarantees a stock immediately rerates. And I think right now we're in this environment where rates are destroying the cost of capital. Until that changes, doesn't matter what your business does. Doesn't matter because the bond vigilantes are in control of the narrative right now.
Well, and also I think there's a new paradigm of what we're going to have to accept for rates like that. So that I just think the market's rerating its entire PE lower now because we're looking at 5% as the new norm, you know, and so if 5% is the new norm instead of 4%, then the entire market PE is basically just moving down. So I fundamentally think like nothing has actually changed in the AI trade. I mean CoreWeave has been as risky as it was a year ago as it is today. I think what it is is that now they're saying, 'Hey, if I can get 6% pretty safely, why would I pay 8% for CoreWeave? Now you got to pay me 15,' you know, and honestly, buying a CoreWeave bond yielding 15 doesn't seem like a bad idea to me. I don't know. 15 is a real yield, right? Like I don't know. I haven't bought any. I haven't done it. I don't know if you guys have, but...
No, but first off, like Daddy Jensen will save CoreWeave. Okay. So, like I think that 50%, you're absolutely accurate. Like it's almost like free money, but...
I don't know. I just think that the chips are worth something any way you look at it. So, if I own the debt and they don't pay me, I get a bunch of Nvidia chips, you know, am I going to lose, you know? I don't know.
How much would Apple be selling chips for your new job?
Well, that's all Elon wants them.
Apple would easily acquire CoreWeave's assets at any kind of distressed amount. Like there's going to be buyers for CoreWeave no matter what for sure. But also like you just highlighted like CoreWeave's cost of capital is 9%. You can buy the bonds at 15%. Their ROI right now on their actual capital is 1%. There's a massive delta right now on why CoreWeave isn't working. You have to believe the buildout's going to last through 2030 essentially to make CoreWeave work. But end of the day we're all talking about like Jensen prints cash. He will save CoreWeave, brute force their way into profitability, but right now the market's not caring, but clearly there's going to be buyers like it's not going to be...
Compute is still just off the charts so I mean they have, you know, ability to provide compute so people want the compute, you know, it's like so whether they financially blow themselves up because of bad management has nothing to do with the assets. You know, I'm not a big believer in taking a lot of debt. You know, like my firm, we don't have any debt. I'm a pure equity company. I can put debt on my company and probably lever up and all this and that's why I don't let private equity do that to me because it puts a lot of stress on your business. You know, I'd rather be like Drew said and be cash flow positive and, you know, have this free cash flow really growing over time than, you know, trying to lever up to make bets like what CoreWeave did. So, you have fundamentally a good business with a bad financing package, you know, and I think that's part of the problem.
So let me lead that into the next topic about AI because we, god forbid, don't talk about AI for plenty of time. We would not be a real finance show, right? So let's go into policing AI. Okay, I was watching Zuckerberg and Alexander Wang on this podcast last night and I was like, dude, these are like two kids with unlimited money who have no ethics and will build anything to make money. And I was like, as much as they think they're cool and funny, I think they're extremely scary. Okay.
Is it the Guinness that made you the most scared? Because that's what I was re-watching.
The sip of Guinness he took where he didn't, he like very awkwardly...
Yeah. If you can't drink a beer, right, you're... I sometimes think Zuckerberg is actually an alien who came to Earth to destroy it. So, you know, that's just my opinion. It may be factual. We'll see in the next 10 years. But I think that Zuckerberg is the least ethical person that has ever been dropped on the earth next to Sam Altman and Elon Musk and they control all this AI. We need an AI police. What do you think we should do about this? Somebody like in my business, we have the SEC, we have FINRA, we have the broker-dealer compliance departments, I have my own compliance department, I got Miranda watching every word I say. But yet I can build an AI system that'll blow up the earth and nobody checks. There's no system.
I feel like all of us have to say hi to our compliance folks. Hi. Hi Aaron.
Well, I always shout out Miranda because she's forced to listen to everything I say. I feel bad for her, but she volunteered for this job. So that said, how do we do this? We cannot just let these people build whatever. At some point it will go bad and we'll have like a technology crisis. Okay. So, like how do we stop this from happening? We know from the financial crisis we can't trust bankers. We know we can't trust Zuckerberg and these guys from the elections in the past and the manipulation and the Cambridge Analytica and the lawsuits and the destruction of young people's minds. Who's going to do this? I vote Shai. Shai, you should be in charge of compliance of AI. How do we set up a system to protect society from these people?
I'm not worried about AI. I'm worried about the humans. I'm worried about the humans.
Jensen is doing that already. They're trying to become the global regulator of AI already.
The regulator, he created this whole AI ecosystem themselves. Like if it wasn't for Nvidia, there would be no AI at this stage. So I think...
So he's like the Moses of AI and he'll just keep everybody in line.
I think so. And also people don't want to anger Jensen because guess what? They need their chips. So I think that's why... angered Moses once and you know what happened to them, 40 years in the desert.
It's also if there's not the safety issue to me too is you can't expect widespread adoption if there's no safety controls, right? So they have to figure it out and I don't know who should be doing it.
I know that's a tough question because do we trust them to do it? Self-imposed safety measures. Jensen Huang maybe, but some others you might question about, you know, what their rigor and standards of safety are. But, you know, I think there's also this big question about is safety a tax on innovation and do we slow down growth? Can safety and fastness exist together? And my thoughts on that are just you can have the fastest engine in a car in the world, but if the brakes don't work, no one's going to adopt it. So to continue this AI buildout, the public needs to feel and enterprises need to feel that it's safe. Who? I don't know. Do we create an FDA-type AI regulatory body? That I just don't know.
Should it be the government, right? And I was waiting for someone to say, 'Oh, the government should do this. Oh, that'll be good.'
I don't think the government should do it. I don't know how they can, like this is moving too fast.
Well, they're dumb. They're really dumb. So, they don't know the technology. They don't get it. You know, they can't even police themselves, these people.
Even if we put that aside, how are they going to like literally manage something that can move? Like where compute is fungible. Like where you have your office set up, whose money you take, like that's a little bit more physical even. But even then, like you know, you could set up satellite offices and people can kind of do business across countries. Like when we're talking about compute and software and stuff like this, not a single government can really do it because I can just go access something else. I guess you can shut off my access, but then other people can go get it. Like it is kind of...
They can just arrest you too, you know. They can arrest you.
There's an industry that exists for this problem already. It's cybersecurity. And I think that's why you're seeing cybersecurity just be the sector to buy the past six months and the opportunity is expanding way faster than a lot of people expected because guess what? Enterprises are never going to trust the children of AI via Dario and Sam to protect their own enterprise data because guess what? These AI models will not grade their own homework. They won't. They're in a prisoner's dilemma. They're trying to disrupt, disrupt, disrupt. So, I do believe that cybersecurity is going to morph into an area where we are going to have guardrails. I think that right now there is no malicious attacks as much as people thought there was going to be as generative AI took off. Like right now, it's just AI oopsies from Anthropic and OpenAI, but there's really been no big attacks yet. So I think that...
I think OpenAI was testing what they could attack and then they got caught and it was sort of like, oh, we hacked a bunch of people because I did read that some companies were reviewing their cybersecurity because of OpenAI, you know. And so going backwards, one of the things that's bothering me is they're demonizing AI but it's not really AI, it's the people who are in charge of AI that we need to monitor, not necessarily the concept of it, and that's really my issue. I don't think Jensen should be the regulator because he's kind of like super biased to see it succeed. So, you know, a regulator might come in and say these companies need to slow down or these companies need to change policies and that will take time and he would have an incentive not to have that happen. You know, I've said it in previous shows that I think it should just be the Pope. I think the Vatican should get involved and, you know, I don't know.
But I think in our industry we have FINRA which is like a self-regulatory organization where you create these regulatory organizations, but in our case I don't think it works very well. So, you know, I don't know how we solve this problem but it's something we need to solve and I think there needs to be some body of people or a board of directors of AI that looks at what's best for society and I don't know who those people should be.
I mean even Jensen Huang said that the industry itself is doing a horrible job at communicating the benefits, right? And we see Gallup poll after Gallup poll, Americans are saying 39%, I think the most recent Gallup poll said that they believe that AI does more harm than good and that's up from 31%. That's what they're telling our kids, but to your point it's not necessarily the technology, it's maybe more the people running it or the parameters around it.
It's also on purpose. That's like Dario and Sam are doing on purpose because guess what? They don't want the open model narrative to continue momentum. And how do you stop that? You have the government intervening themselves and all of a sudden they are funding this duopoly and now Sam and Dario feel safe with their pricing power because they create this fear themselves. So it's all self-inflicted for their own personal benefits as part of their IPO roadshow. So I do think it's purely narrative but unfortunately they're the children of AI and they are worth $4 trillion essentially between both companies.
I'll tell you, Shai, there's nothing that bothers me more when my kids come home and they say that AI is using up all the water because that's what they're teaching our kids in school. And I was like, AI is using all the water? I was like, how about the golf courses?
Our country club down the street uses more water.
Out of this era in a drought, it's never not green and they got 400 people playing this course. Okay, it's absurd that we're talking about AI and water, but yet at Riviera, they're using tons of water every day for 400 people. Okay, it's ridiculous. So, it...
That gets me outside. AI keeps me inside, Ross.
Okay. Well, listen, I want to move on because I want to move to a topic that I enjoy. And we have an expert here, a Tesla expert, a wonderful investor, somebody who I have known for a long time. We've done the Tesla dance for a long time together. I want to bring in Gary Black. Gary Black manages The Future Fund. You know, great to see you, Gary. It's been a while. I know Gary's been working hard. Full disclosure, I'm also an investor in Gary's company and, you know, he's doing a great job managing funds. But we got a big event tonight. Gary and I are two of the Tesla investors that I think are most controversial in that we are Tesla bulls longer term, but we also have an opinion that changes, which in the Tesla community you're not allowed to have. Actually, you're either...
How dare you guys? How dare you guys?
I know. I know. But we got the Roadster event tonight. I don't know what you're expecting, Gary. We haven't talked about this yet. What are you expecting out of this event? Then why are we even worried about a Roadster when it's not even going to move the needle?
The Roadster is just going to disappoint. It's not, as you say, it's going to be a niche product. Maybe it'll sell a couple thousand units. Yeah, it'll go 0 to 60 in one second, but that's not what wows people anymore. Maybe it's going to hover up and down, but I think...
You think it's going to hover.
I don't know. I don't care. It's not going to move the needle. So, it's going to be an overhyped event and, you know, the stock will fall tomorrow because people are expecting, you know, Elon to walk on water or something during the event and he's not going to do that. So...
You think he's going to show up? He didn't show up for Cyber...
Yeah, who knows. I mean, he may for this, he's been touting it. You know, I've never seen a guy pump an event like he's pumping this event. So, he may show up. But look, the bigger issue with Tesla is, is it going to move the needle? No. And, you know, the controversy that Ross, you and I engage in, it's not that we don't like Tesla. We think it's a great company. It's got great fundamentals and, you know, it's got products that are really breakthrough, but it's an overpriced stock and you can't fall in love with the stock just because you love the company. And that's, you know, something I always try to impart on people.
Well, Gary, I think with the valuation, you know, I have my opinion about the valuation, which is I assign a 10 times revenue multiple, and then the rest is what I call the Elon premium, which averages about a trillion dollars per company. So, if Elon works at your company, you immediately get a trillion dollar valuation plus a regular valuation. And so, that's Tesla and SpaceX to me. And so, you know, why this guy gets a $2 trillion valuation is because he's probably one of the more innovative inventors of our time, for sure. He has executed and been successful on several of his initiatives, but not all of them. And I have to say, as a long-term Tesla investor, it's incredible to see how many Teslas are in Los Angeles today. And the EV business is massive. And I'm so happy about it. In a time where American consumers are getting just destroyed by gas prices, at least there are options for people and there weren't those options before Tesla. So, I do give him credit for what he has done.
But it doesn't change the fact that it's what we're doing in the future that matters. And so, in my mind, Tesla has become second fiddle to SpaceX. Like, it's all SpaceX now from Elon's perspective and the market's perspective to some degree. When do these companies merge? It seems to me like it's a foregone conclusion at this point. What do you think?
No, I was going to say I think that's the whole narrative tonight isn't Tesla. It's SpaceX-related technology being implemented into these Roadsters and now all of a sudden the boundaries across the Musk ecosystem are beginning to blur. And I think that's what probably people are going to talk about tonight. It's not going to be about some kind of reignite excitement around, wow, this product is super quick. It's going to be a massive...
Do you think it's going to... Shai? No, no.
I think it's going to be a dud. I agree with Gary. It's going to be a dud. But I think the narrative behind Tesla and SpaceX almost is like it's going to be a combined entity where Tesla's going to move deeper into robotics, autonomy, semi, whatnot, and SpaceX will all just be together. And I think that...
Roadster is another symbol of that tech convergence rather than some car events, is my takeaway.
Hey Ross, you can ask Gary two questions.
Yeah, I was gonna say go ahead Drew.
Like I got one technical one and one more from a stock perspective. Number one, can I get the car seats for my three and four-year-old in the back of the Roadster? Will they go over that? And then on stock,
My kids already have noticed that there's only two seats and they're already fighting for who gets to go with dad.
So, they're upset already. And then the stock.
Well, Jimmy, my kid Jimmy has reserved it. He's like, "Dad, it's got to be me."
Just say 0 to 60 second kid. You know, just shut up and buckle up.
Yeah. The stock question though to me is we're talking about the car and we've all said it in different ways that doesn't matter. I think like about humanoid robotics, like where's the value coming from Tesla right now?
Yeah. Look, they sell a hundred billion dollars worth of EVs which nobody seems to care about except me, you know, like.
I still think it's impressive.
We both own Teslas. I've had a Model Y performance. I know Ross, you had a Model S, I think from years ago.
They're great cars, but again, you have to be able to put a valuation relative to the growth rate. And so, one of the things that I always say to people is, look, every single innovation that Tesla has come up with has been copied. And if you tell me that all of a sudden nobody's going to be able to copy FSD, even though they're driving around, you know, at 15 different markets and they've got 10 times the amount of vehicles and we know that Nvidia is working with the OEMs to come up with something, then you might start thinking about putting, to your point, Ross, some sort of proprietary type multiple on the stock. But when you got a stock that's going to grow at, let's say, 45% a year, which is what we're forecasting, what is the right multiple that you should be putting on that? And right now the market's putting 220 times on it. You know, in my history,
Do you get 45% a year? I mean, I don't even see Tesla growing next year. Like, you're assuming they're going to sell more cars. I guess.
If you think about energy,
No. Uh, earnings growth. The earnings growth.