Welcome back to Hardware Unboxed November Q&A part two. If you missed part one, watch it after this one. Obviously, watch this first now that you've clicked on the video. It'll destroy our stats if you go on part one now. So, don't do that. Watch this video is what I'm saying. Lock in. We've got some great questions. We're going to give some even greater answers. So, we're one-upping the questions.
Yep. Okay. Sure. A lot of pressure on us now, but sure.
Yep. So, we'll do that straight after this. Today's sponsor spot is brought to you by Thermal Grizzly and their Wire View Pro 2. The best way to safeguard your 12-volt high-powered connector from melting. This little device plugs in between your graphics card's power connector and the power supply's cable to measure current, voltage, temperatures, and the power of each individual pin. It has a built-in display with configurable views for per-pin current, total power, and temperature, plus audible and visual alarms if thresholds are exceeded. The CNC machined aluminium body includes a semi-passive fan for cooling, automatic data logging, and optional automatic system shutdown via the included splitter cable for extra safety. Thermal Grizzly are so confident that the Wire View Pro 2 will keep your graphics card safe that they're backing the product with an extended warranty covering the GPU connector for 2 years. That is a crazy level of support. So, for more information, please check the link in the video description. All right.
Actually, Tim, this one is for me. It says VRAM. Yeah. No, no, no, no. All right. VRAM-wise, do you think the 3070 with 8 GB or the 3080 with 10 GB was worse considering the launch price? Um, how about how well they've aged? So, I will lead with this cuz I tried to push you off your chair. I think that's only fair.
Um, I'm going to go with the 3070 cuz that was $500 US. Uh, the 3080 was meant to be $700. Now, I'm aware that this happened during the cryptocurrency boom, so the prices were all a mess. But I do think 8 gigabytes of VRAM on a 3070 aged worse than the 10 GB on the 3080 despite the fact that 3080, you know, more expensive, more capable GPU. But you could do more with 10 GB that you could have higher quality textures, you could do more ray tracing and frame generation if that's your thing. You could do those things. Whereas with 8 GB, you're just struggling to do the game at say 1440p or 4K or whatever it is you're aiming for, 4K upscaled. I know you might do on the 3070.
But yeah, when you go and enable the RTX features that the 3070 was advertised to utilize like ray tracing, 8 GB becomes a struggle even upscaled 1440p. So I think that's probably of the two the card I would have been most disappointed in if I purchased it. There's a lot of games that use more than 8 GB but not more than 10 GB. Like they're just over that limit or because you know you can slightly exceed the VRAM capacity on some models and it doesn't completely tank the experience for you. So there are certainly games where that is the case which makes the 3080 still usable today. Again, like yeah, 8 GB of VRAM, lot of problematic situations today uh with with games. So yeah, I I'd agree with you. I think the 3070 with the 8 GB has aged worse. The 3080 though really did need more than 10 as well. We got the 12 GB version eventually um which was launched during the crypto period and was too expensive. Didn't make a lot of sense. But that was that it probably should have just been the 3080 12 GB model from the start.
I think there was even rumors at the time, right, that they were they were going to like have double the capacity, right? Like there was a there there was like a 3080 20 GB version. Well, they were they did make them and we saw the box art for them. They were ready to go and they cancelled them last minute.
So, yeah, 3070 and it is a nuance discussion. So, if you had an entry level or a more affordable card with 8 GB of VRAM, it's like, you know, ideally we would like to see more VRAM on cards, especially at this point in time, but we are talking about the 30 series, but the 3070 was really your upper sort of mid tier. It was your your everyman's card that could do all the RTX stuff, all the ray tracing, all of the things this card supported and could do with a higher degree of competence. Or at least that was the intention, but it was very quickly hamstrung by that 8 GB VRAM buffer and competing parts or parts that weren't too much more expensive like an RX 6800 had 16 GB and although it didn't have the feature set, it has aged better because of it. In a lot of the modern games, you can use the 4K texture packs and it looks better because of it. So, yeah, I think they just oversold and underdelivered with both of those products, but in particular the 3070.
All right, as usual, another crystal ball type question, which we have on hand thankfully. What are the chances that these 6000 series cards, so I think this is the GeForce RTX 6000 or 60 series, whatever you want to call it, that we are talking about the GeForce cuz I think when you say 6000, my mind immediately goes to Radeon series rather than GeForce.
Yeah, for some reason RTX like 50 series, but it's the RX 6000 series. That's the normal way, I guess.
Yeah. Don't know why, but it is. Anyway, um won't exist in the customer space or consumer space, and that will be dealing with barely existing or existent 5000 series for another four plus years. So another four years of the 5 I think so and AMD still won't have competition. So yeah, don't think that's going to happen. It again it's crystal ball stuff.
I won't even begin to pretend I know what this time next year is going to look like. I there's so many wildly different possibilities that I could see being possible, which is why I consider them possibilities, I suppose. But you know what I'm saying, right? It could just be any number of things could play out. So to answer this question, I just I simply can't. Um I don't think I I certainly don't think the situation is going to continue for four years. Uh I we would definitely get a 6000 series, but what that will look like uh and in four years I would expect that we'd have another GeForce generation for sure. And I think regardless of what happens by that point, we will have established a new norm.
So yeah, I mean if pricing does continue forever in in the sort of position that we'll be in right now, um it's not a great wouldn't be great, but people will adjust. You know, it's I mean, obviously a certain percentage of people will just drop off from PC gaming entirely, which is fair enough because the prices will be too high for some people. Um, but then, you know, products are still available even today, like while prices are high, you can still buy stuff. And we do hear from people that you some people are buying stuff at the current prices because either you they've waited around long enough and they they absolutely love PC gaming is their primary hobby and so they're they're willing to invest the current money into the current situation or whatever the case is.
So yeah, I think if we're talking about like the next four years, I don't know whether we were talking about this in a previous Q&A or some other thing. Um you know, these companies put in a lot of research and development into upcoming series and it's difficult to just make that go to waste. We've even seen that with product series that I think were not really worth releasing. Like remember the 11th gen series processors from Intel, forget which is like they were just worse products overall and not just that but they replaced them in such a short I mean I know they probably had to accelerate the other release but they could only release that at a certain point. So they couldn't accelerate by a year but um it what was it like 6 months or something absurd like that?
6 or 9 months or something like that. They probably hoping for a year anyway.
Yeah. So, we've seen product series like that where they've clearly put in all this work to design, engineer, develop these products. They turn out to not be very good or not worth buying for a variety of reasons. With the 11th gen, it was technical reasons. Um, just not a good architecture. Didn't work out, but they still release it anyway because it's kind of like a it's almost a sunk cost at that point. You know, they're sort of they're just trying to salvage something from the situation. So, even with GPUs, I think in a previous question, we were talking about like the 6090 and how, you know, that might just become a Pro Series GPU, but they're still putting in work to the entire architecture to lower-end models, cut down SKUs, what the different die sizes and allocations are going to be, and all of that has worked out quite a fair fair way.
So, it's hard to just be like 6000 series not happening anymore. Well, it's it it's not because if gamers can't buy it and they're all pro RTX cards that it didn't happen. But what you're saying is it is going to be released in some form like it's been designed, it's coming out, but whether or not it's a gaming focused product is really what the question's asking. And the answer is no idea. Impossible to say. We all we can tell you is the RTX 6090 is coming. Whether it's a GeForce RTX 6090 or it's rebranded as a Pro RTX type GPU, we have no idea. Is that that's the answer in the question, right?
I think it would be pretty misguided from these companies to just assume that if pricing stabilizes to some high level, whether it's current pricing that we see today, maybe it drops off a bit, or maybe it's even worse. I think it'd be pretty misguided to to look at everything happening in PC gaming right now where PC gaming is actually more popular than ever despite the current situation. You know, the all the storefronts and marketplaces are hitting like record highs of concurrent users. If you're looking at that and then going, well, in a year from now there's going to be zero interest in a gaming product, I think that's pretty misguided. I think even at prices may be bad, but I still think there would be interest in a new series of products e like even if they launch a new series of products right now, knowing everything we know right now about how bad pricing is, where they'd have to price the products, how unappealing they would be to a lot of people, I still think they would sell. They a 6070 would sell right now and they would sell for more more than what like because you're saying there's more gamers than ever, right? But really from Nvidia's perspective, there's more peasants than ever.
Well, yes. I mean, it might not make economic sense for them, but I think, you know, if you're talking about like making future plans and you're sort of looking at what's happening right now, I think it would be just a very silly decision to completely just be like, "No, pricing is going to be ridiculous in here because there's still going to be competition from various different things and um that they have to contend with."
Yeah. I I just I find it hard to get on board with your train of thought and your logic there because again if you if you had have said to me or if I had have said to you that before 2026 plays out the 5090 be pulled from shelves will end production and there'll be no replacement. I mean, Asus did tell us that they were doing that with the 5070 Ti to be fair, but it'd be pretty hard to believe the flagship product would be ending with no replacement.
Um, I mean, I would have been surprised if you're talking about like the prices of products getting up to the point where it doesn't make sense to purchase.
Well, I mean, I just mean that it gets to the point where they don't even bother making it because they can make way more, right? I mean, but I mean with the 5090 situation, it's not that that product. I mean, the product itself isn't being made, but they are making a very similar product.
Yes, that's what I'm saying. If but they wouldn't release the 6090 into the current market. It'd be a pro RTX card and you'd get whatever they were willing to sell to gamers.
Yeah, maybe. Um, I still think they would probably release the lower tier products, which I think in a previous question. But we've seen pro we've seen cycles before where pricing has been extremely high and there's been all this it's just repeating discussion that we've had in previous times right in cryptocurrency booms people have had the exact same question they're like is pricing going to be high forever what what's going to happen to new products they're just going to make them all mining GPUs and the answer was well they actually during those times they did make a few new gaming products again that we saw the 3080 12 GB during that time they did a few things and then eventually over time there is a new normal at some point. It turns out for that new normal there was a massive oversupply of GPUs which meant that they maybe made some decisions and we discussed all this in Q&A at the time right where you know maybe the pricing wasn't as aggressive because they started to sell out all their old products and stuff like that so you know things adjust but I think it's difficult to sit here and say things in the current time right now because we're kind of talking about the worst times right and so people get well maybe but I mean people people are buying stuff right now so this pretty much is the worst time right So people get into this like I guess negative mindset where they sort of think that this is just this is it, right? Like this is forever now. Gaming GPUs are dead. And again, like I said, we've seen that happen in all other times that pricing has gone crazy.
Yeah. Well, I mean, I've said before, I don't think this is sustainable. I think this thing plays out and I think we'll see it unravel within the next 12 months. But I guess that's a guess.
Anyway, move on. Next one. Well, Tim, these questions all seem to be following a theme, believe it or not. The next one is, with the RTX 5090 discontinued and the RTX 5080 basically gone as well, about to be replaced, is the RTX 5070 Ti next?
Don't go and say the RTX 5070 Ti is canceled again because we'll um we're going to cop it. Um, is the RTX 5070 Ti next? Um, I don't think so. Just looking at the sort of availability of that product at the moment is still available. It's very expensive. It's like over $1,250, I think, at the moment. $1,300.
Yep. It was definitely end of life anywhere near the MSRP for a long time.
Yeah. Yeah. So, I think the issue that we're seeing with the 5080 is not so much that it's being discontinued to be sold as a pro GPU like the 5090 is, is that Nvidia's planning to replace this with the with the basically the same product. Sorry, my we've just been recording a lot today. Um, they basically have been they're trying to replace it with basically the same product with more VRAM. And so, they're planning on discontinuing it basically so that by the time the 24 gig model is available, it's not competing in the market with the 16 gig card. Now, whether or not the product is going to launch, whether those two things are going to align at the same time, because there has been reports that the 24 gig card may not be being released in like January of next year, it might be getting delayed. There's there's talk of the board partners don't have the designs yet to make that card. But it does seem like at least Nvidia's current plans are let's get rid of the 5080 from the market, make them very expensive, discontinue them, make sure there's nothing in the channel so then they can bring in the 24 gig model. So, it's a bit different to what we saw with the 5090. And also that it's not like they're just go, at least my interpretation of what's happening right now. It's not like they're going down the stack and just being like 5090 dead, next up, you know, it's like a shooting gallery, right? Like they're going to, oh, 5080, boom, it's dead now. And then, you know, moving to the next one. Oh, 5070 Ti, you know, it's dead. Going down.
Then you hear next minute the the 5080 24 GB's been cancelled. And then the 5070 Ti is finally on the chopping block and Tim's like, "Ah, I can't win no matter which way I go."
Yeah. I mean, I think part of it with those type of products, once we start getting like 5070 Ti level and even with the 5080 is that even though AMD, how competitive you think they are, you know, market share and stuff, they're not Nvidia still dominates a lot of those type of things. It's always seemed like Nvidia is still reacting to AMD. You know, if there's a product that AMD makes that's a bit more competitive than they were expecting, they change a few things even though they still outsell them by, you know, a significant margin. You know, you see products I if when we've seen this with the 50 series, right? The most competitive products from Nvidia's GeForce series are the products that AMD has competition for from and then the products that are not competitive like their 5090 AMD has doesn't have a version of. And so I think if it came down to it and the 9070 XT was still available, I think that would make the Nvidia gaming division, which still exists, you know, there's still a lot of people employed in Nvidia's gaming division, GeForce, right? The GeForce team, uh, they would be pretty nervous about discontinuing a product that would effectively make AMD have the fastest GPU on the market.
So, I don't think they will do that. I think even if even if there's pressures from, you know, workstation cards and servers and all that sort of thing, the people that in charge of the gaming team based on how they've operated historically, they they're not going to they're not going to do that. There's going to be something available that shows GeForce is still the best. Even if people aren't buying it, even if it's super expensive, they've always wanted to be in the leadership position in some way. I think they will do anything they can to continue that happening.
Mhm. I've recently seen a CS:GO video where a 1080 Ti actually outperformed a 4090 in the game by a notable margin, suggesting that the newer card was hampering the CPU to a notable degree. Have you done any testing to find out if the older Nvidia cards suffered less from driver overhead? I don't know if I've I've definitely did and I didn't even know I was probably doing at the time scaling stuff that looked at CPU GPU scaling between I think it was like Vega 56 or 64 versus the Pascal GPUs and there were definitely hints that Pascal in some well with some APIs let's say like namely DirectX 12 maybe Vulkan had less overhead uh and GeForce did better with DirectX 11.
As for a 1080 Ti beating a 4090 when CPU limited, I wouldn't expect that necessarily, though maybe it does depend on the API that's used. So, I'm not saying it's impossible. I haven't seen this video, so I don't I'd have to look at the video and see the testing to draw more conclusions. But yeah, I I I'm not really sure what else to say. Like the the initial testing I did was with the GeForce RTX series, so the 20 series and 30 series. And I'm not even 100% sure if the overhead issues stayed the same from the 20 series to the 50 series. Uh I don't sus I don't think based on the testing I have done it's gotten any worse, but yeah, I don't know if it's improved or it's just stayed much the same. And I have to do additional testing on that. And it's not it's good scientific type testing, I suppose, but it's not really that relevant for consumer advice, which is what we've been trying to give, which is like, you know, if you'd have a lower-end CPU like a Ryzen 5 5500 in the example we gave, I would urge you to buy a 9060 XT over an RTX 5060 or 5060 Ti because in a lot of in quite a few instances, you could be gaining an additional 30 uh 20 to 30% more performance, which is and it's pretty common to be getting around 10% more performance which a lot of people especially on a lower end system would deem.
So that was more the why we went about it the way we did because that's relevant information for those of you upgrading your older PCs to a modern GPU. So yep um Pascal probably not something I'm going to go revisit. You know, the the 1080 Ti was the GOAT, but you know, not super relevant anymore. Um, yeah, I wouldn't probably wouldn't recommend buying a 1080 Ti in 2026. Um, I don't know how much that would cost.
Well, must be pretty cheap now. Yeah, I don't think stuff like ray tracing support's at all relevant for lower-end cards, but I think you'd probably be better off buying a modern GPU that's better supported and offers more modern features. Um, even like an ARC B570 maybe. Though, having said that, on slower CPUs, they can also be problematic cuz the driver overhead issue still pops up in certain games. Intel, I think, has to do quite a bit of work there to avoid it. We know they can fix it because we saw them do so in Spider-Man. Anyway, um interesting stuff, but yeah, probably not something I'm going to bother looking into because it's not really relevant.
Pascal drivers as well, they're end of life, aren't they? At this point,
I believe so. No more driver.
That's what I'm saying. Like driver support, why why I would invest in a more modern product because it's 10 years old now. It's
Yeah, it's it's a good card for its time. Um it's run it. I think people look back on Pascal, myself included, so fondly, because it was, in my opinion, the last time the industry was truly great. I mean, probably on a GeForce side of things, I think Radeon certainly got substantially better since then, especially with their latest generation, which I would say is their best ever. Um, back then they weren't super competitive with their GCN stuff, but anyway, it was a golden era, I would say, for for GeForce GPUs.
Do you think Nvidia's heavy feature push this decade with GeForce was because they had realized they could no longer meet their previous generational performance improvements?
Pretty much. Yeah. I mean, I made a whole video about this showing the decline in generational improvements as physics caught up with them. I guess it just becomes much harder to shrink things and get the kind of gains that they were once able to get. So that being the case, you have to try and convince people they need to upgrade or they should upgrade. You have to give them some sort of incentive, right? And if you can't do that through 50 60% performance gains every 12 to 18 months when those lead times get pushed out to I think for the start of those series, you're looking at what two years, two and a half years between generations. Um cuz I think we're already like 18 months into the current generation or something like that. So time flies I guess when you can't buy GPUs. Um but yeah, it's just they have to find a way to sell people and convince people to upgrade. So if it's taking longer to produce a new generation and that generation offers less performance, it means you guys will be holding on to your GPUs for longer. Which means although the market segment is increasing as in each year there seems to be more people interested in building PCs and buying gaming hardware, if the the le if if basically people have gone from upgrading every say 2 years to every five or six then you know that kind of offsets the growth rate and it makes it harder for them to sell products. So that's what they've come up against. So, if you have some sort of killer software feature that uh renders everyone's existing products somewhat obsolete, that is of great benefit to these companies. And so, they did try that for a while. It's starting to backfire a bit now. And also, the advent of AI, humorously enough, has made those sort of lockout features uh more accessible. So, you're able to get things like frame generation on older GPUs and upscaling technologies and all that sort of stuff. And admittedly, I think Nvidia has done probably a better job of backporting those features to support older architectures. AMD is now sort of catching up.
Yeah. I mean, I think with with, you know, the the software features side of things, obviously they've invested a lot in the software side of stuff, Nvidia specifically, but also a lot of those features have required hardware advancements. So things like ray tracing for example, they did need to make architectural changes to enable real-time ray tracing with the RTX 20 series and as well with features like DLSS upscaling with AI models and even what you see now with neural rendering that's been enabled by the tensor cores which again weren't available on something like a Pascal GPU. So it's kind of there's some things where you could sort of look at a feature like frame generation which seems largely just a software feature like yes you could claim oh they're put in some optical flow accelerators and hardware flip metering as supporting that feature but it's largely just software and they've used that to try and claim better performance on these products. You know the classic 5070 beating a 4090 stuff based on frame generation. Um, so they've used software features like that to I think masquerade a bit of the the lack of advancement in the actual hardware.
They're just sort of going even even the hard the things they've had to physically integrate into the hardware. So the architectural shifts, those still in my opinion have only come about because of the brick wall problem like coming up against physics. If they were still just offering 60 to 80% rasterized performance gains every 12 to 18 months, they wouldn't have gone down that path just yet of trying to offer real-time ray tracing. I think they'd probably look at it and go, "Yeah, we can't do that to a satisfactory degree yet." And people are still rapidly upgrading and we can, you know what I mean?
Whereas when that side slows down like we've got to come with something new, we've got to try and create buzz and excitement here. Although they're going to be able to do this to very limited degrees, where they knew ahead of time, it's going to have lots of noise. It's going to be very few truly transformative examples. It's going to be more of a tech demo thing. But like what we're saying with this AI stuff, we can use it to create hype, you know, drum up all this investment, which is gamers handing over cash because who doesn't want their games without all these glorious rays? So that was the plan, right?
Yeah. I think you can see that in a lot of the charts that Nvidia uses whenever they talk about like generational improvements. They talk about things like ray tracing and now neural rendering as being like these big breakthroughs quote unquote. So I think they've shown some charts. I don't know whether we can show an example but just from memory they've had you know like there's the rasterized era and then starts tapering off but then they overlay that with like the ray tracing era and it continues the exponential curve. Then that tapers off and now they're adding in like the neural rendering exponential curve and they sort of they just make up some sort of y-axis thing where they're like gains and so they're like oh well now now we're not seeing any more raster gains but we're seeing huge ray tracing performance gains with each generation so we can continue the upward curve. I think if you adjusted that chart to actually show like the end product like how good games have gotten in terms of visual output or features or whatever over that time you would see that be a significantly compressed with like what does ray tracing actually enable versus rasterization in a lot of cases it's diminishing returns now some people are going to get annoyed about saying that but it depends on the game and how you sort of look at it there's still some really good examples that use minimal or no ray tracing to achieve brilliant visual effects so you know to to claim that it's produced this exponential increase in visual quality I don't think that is true we're in diminishing returns eras with these things.