When we have anxiety, firstly, a preamble: when you have anxiety, not if, because you will. When you have anxiety, the goal is not to get rid of it, it's to use it in a constructive way. Welcome to the TheoTherapist podcast, where theologically trained, licensed therapists share health and healing conversations. Join our host, Dr. Ca Trice Glenn, for conversations about real life issues from both theological and therapeutic perspectives.
Hello and welcome to the TheoTherapist podcast. I'm Dr. Ca Trice Glenn, your host, and I'm so glad that you're joining us. We are now in season five of the TheoTherapist podcast, and so I'm so glad that you have taken the time to watch or listen wherever you are to our podcast. So far, we just keep elevating every season. The TheoTherapist podcast is expanding and growing, and this season is definitely going to hit the mark as far as expansion. My guest today does work at this intersection right where we start and we begin at the meeting place of spirituality and mental health. Dr. David Rosmarin is an associate professor at Harvard Medical School. He's the director of the Spirituality and Mental Health Program at McLean Hospital. He's built his career doing something that many said couldn't be done, which is bringing spirituality into serious evidence-based mental health care. He's one of the most cited researchers in our field with more than 100 peer-reviewed publications. He's also the founder of the Center for Anxiety, where his practice has served more than 10,000 clients with a staff of over 75 clinicians. He's the author of Thriving with Anxiety: Nine Tools to Make Your Anxiety Work for You, and you may have seen him on Good Morning America, in the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal, or even on a TED Talk stage. So I'm so glad and thankful he took the time out to come for our podcast today. Please help me welcome Dr. David Rosmarin.
Thank you very much. I really do appreciate the opportunity to speak with you today. I've been looking forward to it all week.
Thank you so much. I'm so glad. I was really looking forward to this because we have so many intersection points that you may not know and parallel points in our journey. A lot of my work and research has been focused on the integration of spirituality and mental health, and we have researched and used some of the same methods to try to understand how this bridge and this connection point helps others to cope with life and to overcome and to heal in some ways. And so I'm curious, you know, what would you tell our listeners? That's a little bit about your work and what drew you to this place of looking at spirituality and mental health together.
Sure. So a couple of things drew me to it. I'll tell you about my story, how I started off at Harvard Medical School within McLean Hospital. I came as an intern to do psychology, to learn how to do cognitive and dialectical behavior therapy with acute psychiatric patients. And the hospital knew about my interest in spirituality and being an Orthodox Jew — I proudly wear my yarmulke on my head — so they knew about my faith and my affiliation and my interest, from a, I suppose, a diversity standpoint. But beyond that, it was really not intended to be a foray into spirituality and mental health; it was intended to be a clinical experience to further my secular clinical knowledge. But lo and behold, within a couple of days of being on campus and walking around and seeing the patients, people would come over to me and say, 'Excuse me, sir. Can I talk to you about God? Can I speak to you about my faith? Why is God doing this to me? Why am I feeling depressed? Is there a purpose in the universe? Will you pray for me?' All sorts of questions that I was not equipped to answer. Fortunately, I had gone to graduate school at Bowling Green State University. Ken Pargament is one of my mentors, and when I reached out to him, he promptly told me, 'Well, nobody has done this before in acute psychiatry at scale anyway, and you're going to have to figure this out.' So over time, I did, and created a number of clinical programs which at this point have been used by several thousand individuals within the McLean Hospital and Harvard Medical School system. We have a flagship spiritual integrated therapy that we've created called SPIRIT, which is an acronym for Spiritual Psychotherapy for Inpatient, Residential, and Intensive Treatment, and that at this point is being disseminated all over the globe on three continents — four continents, in fact. So, you know, I'm very proud of the work that's happened, but honestly, it's been organic. It's been something that's, I would say, divinely led. I've only, you know, been positioned here and doing the service that I can, and I really mean that, and I can speak up frankly with this audience about the truth. And I was just ready to do it and willing, and the rest was not in my hands.
You know, I think sometimes, you know, our journey finds us, right? We end up finding where our niche is because it found us. We were headed there anyway. I'm curious. You have a unique lens toward anxiety and working with anxiety. How did you head in that direction?
Oh, my own anxiety. I think that, you know, a lot of folks in the mental health field, we have our own concerns, whatever it is, leaning towards whatever areas, and anxiety certainly mine. And it's motivated me in my life, you know, it got me to push beyond my limits and to be nervous about things and to do extra work and publish papers and to face all that adversity. And yeah, I think that that's what sort of drew me in clinically. And then I realized that actually the world of spirituality has much to offer beyond the walls of the clinic and the hospital and the clinical work that's being done, and that's been some recent work I've done. You mentioned the TEDx stage. That was my foray into that.
Well, you did good regardless of the anxiety. I saw them both. [laughter]
So, appreciate that.
And I do appreciate your view. You know, as a practicing clinician, I talk about anxiety every day simply because I'm with people who are at the life transition situation or some particular chaos situation where their anxiety is heightened. And so I'm interested in the fact that you talk more about harnessing anxiety rather than the combating or the fighting. Where did that emerge for you?
It came from my spiritual tradition. If you look at the Bible, if you look at, you know, throughout scriptures, the greatest human beings who ever walked planet Earth struggled. Moses himself, you know, asked at one point to be killed. He said, 'Please take me. I can't take this anymore.' You know, King David, he also, 'My God, my God, why have you abandoned me?' I mean, you just see this, and certainly throughout Jewish history and throughout, I think, the history of all religious traditions, it's not one of feeling good all the time. It's not a story of relationships without challenge, of faith without dark days. It's always one of overcoming a struggle. It's always one of persevering through that difficulty and using faith, using connection, using relationships to navigate the complexity and the challenges of life. And that is in many ways at odds with the secular conceptualization of anxiety, which is that all forms are a disease, all forms are a disorder. And it's not true. And that's really a departure, I would say, that my spiritual lens has led me through, in terms of framing anxiety and helping people to work with it as opposed to against it.
That reminds me so much of, what is it? Eustress, right? It's the stress that motivates us to do things. So that we use it in a way that's productive rather than run from it. And I think that's what many people struggle with. It's that thin line between excitement and anxiety, where some anxiety is helpful to help motivate us to move past something that we might be a little bit afraid of or a little bit timid around.
Well, sometimes it's even significant anxiety. I mean, I don't know about you, but as a clinician seeing people who are starting a new relationship and they're really nervous — well, yeah, you should be, this is important — and people who are having a baby, or people starting a new job, or they're starting a new field of work, or they're taking a big risk. You know, those are moments where it might not just be a little bit of anxiety, but it doesn't mean something's wrong from a spiritual perspective. That actually could be the tip of the spear for moving forward in the way that you need to, in the way that your journey is required. And I think we need to reframe anxiety as a society, and the spiritual lens that many traditions have is so helpful.
Well, and that brings up an interesting challenge sometimes, is that spiritual communities and faith communities sometimes won't acknowledge anxiety as a reality. Some see it as a moral failure or faith failure or some way of being out of alignment with spirituality. And I'm curious, you know, you talk about how in your Thriving with Anxiety book, you talk about how anxiety can actually work for us. You know, how do you speak to that challenge that some face?
Yeah, I think a lot of it is linguistic and language. I think when anxiety is getting the better of somebody and they feel that there is no hope and they feel that there is no future light and they feel stuck in that place, there are spiritual dimensions to that, and those are very challenging. Now, I think used correctly, those spiritual challenges can lead to growth. They can lead to greater faith. But in those dark moments, it is a challenge. I would say maybe a moral and a spiritual and an existential challenge. But that doesn't mean that all anxiety is bad. I mean, show me a pastor in this whole country who does not feel stressed by their community. The reason is because they care. They're working 24/7, and their families are inviting people in, and they're caring for people during difficult times and showing up at the hospital and dealing with marriages falling apart and people's financial crisis in addition to running a congregation. You're going to feel stressed, and that doesn't mean it's a failing. I think there's a knowledge of that across many faith traditions, and certainly for the audience.
And that's one of the things that I tend to draw on is meaning making — kind of what meaning do you have of what's happening to you, because it's that meaning making that's going to either help you cope or it's going to create more distress for you. And so, you know, that's one of the things that I often tell people to lean into, particularly in faith communities, because, you know, is this purposeful? Is this something that's meant to be a part of your process to get you to where you're supposed to be heading? So let's talk about uncertainty, though, because sometimes sitting in that space of uncertainty and ambiguity, it feels so disorienting and it feels so threatening to us. How is it that you speak to that?
Well, let's be clear. We are sitting in uncertainty. We are sitting in uncontrollability. We're human. And if you look at, especially in this day and age — here we are on August the 14th, 2026 — with global uncertainty, with economic uncertainty, with AI, with technological uncertainty, I mean, you name it, we have no clue what tomorrow will bring, let alone a week or a month or a year, 10 years from now. I mean, you've got to be kidding yourself if you think you can predict the future at this point in human history. It's just not true that you can. So the question is, are you aware of it or not? And then if you are tuned into the reality, how can you let go of that and continue to do what really matters?
And that is that's the part, right? That's the leaning into it. It's letting go of the fact that there will not be a time in your life where some uncertainty might not happen, right? We do not have everything in control. We don't know the full direction of where we're heading. And so that uncertainty is inevitable. It's going to happen. And rather than try to avoid it from happening, find a way to work through it, as you say, which we often talk about, and to continue to focus on what you can do and what you need to do, even though there is no certainty that it will come to fruition.
I remember publishing, trying to publish papers earlier on in my career, and I wasn't focusing on religion journals or psychology of religion journals or specialty journals. I was going for mainstream impact within the world of clinical psychology, within the world of mainstream psychiatry, in order to show that spiritual and religious life have some clinical statistical relevance to the domains of life that we study. And that was my whole goal. And every time I submitted a paper, I had no certainty. In fact, I was quite certain that I would not have that paper see the light of day, that it would not be published, that I would be laughed at by my peers. And sometimes that happened. But I stuck with the process and did it anyway. And it's not a matter of the certainty and the control. That's not my domain. My domain is, my job is to simply do the work and to let go of the rest. That's been my mo.
And I think that's the way to go. That's the direct path. The challenge is always how does the letting go happen? Right. [laughter] That's usually the thing that my clients come up with is, you say let go. What does letting go look like? How do we get letting go?
When you let go, you work harder, not less, because when it really doesn't matter and you don't have control, might as well put in your maximum effort. What do you have to lose? So I think that faith — I do think that faith and letting go can actually enhance the effort that you put in to bringing your dreams to fruition in this world. And both of those, to me, are a divine service that to me has spiritual benefit on both sides. It's the expression of your identity in this world coupled with the understanding and acceptance that God is in control and I'm not.
Absolutely. I also think, you know, we're getting deep into spirituality here most of the podcast. I don't know why you like got me open up about all this stuff. Normally like I'm — I guess it's a Friday, I'm like a little casual, like we're chilling. Normally like I'm a little more...
We're spiritual practitioners. Yeah. Let's bring it on. Let's be real.
And absolutely, that's what the whole podcast is about. It's about, you know, real talk at the intersection of theology and therapy. So it's right here. And so one of the things that I think about — so here's a challenge that I find is that sometimes we use spiritual language or spiritual bypassing, and I'm not sure how familiar you are with that language, but spiritual bypassing as a way of getting around things versus going through them. And I'm curious with you, you know, looking at spirituality, looking at clinical resources, you know, how do we keep it from being coercive or too simplistic in the journey?
I wouldn't call — I think coercive is a different thing. I think what you're talking about means bypassing. What I understand is when people focus on spiritual dimensions to the exclusion of interpersonal dimensions or intrapersonal dimensions — when you're not familiar with how you feel, you're just going to faith. And when you're not aware of how you're hurting other people and you run into the church or wherever your proverbial place of worship is, and that's not okay. That is a bypassing when we seek refuge without actually dealing with our package, without dealing with our relationships with others. But I think if you're again, if you're seeking a spiritual lift without having an interpersonal base or an intrapersonal relationship with self foundation, yeah, that's bypassing. And I'm very sensitive to that.
Mhm. And I think the ways that I've seen it used and operationalized is as a way of denying kind of the realities that I'm facing and using it as a shield to say, well, you know, I'll just pray about it or, you know, God's just doing a thing, and choosing not to sit with it and get grounded in what's happening and do the intrapersonal work so that we can understand it better. It's a way of kind of just glossing over what's happening in reality.