Sometimes politics feels like it's a hobby only some can afford, and I don't want it to be that way.
I'm Lulu Garcia-Navarro, and today I'm interviewing New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. In his first six months in office, Mayor Mamdani's been riding high and has started delivering on the issue that defined his campaign: affordability. He's frozen the rent on nearly a million apartments.
We're so excited that the Rent Guidelines Board decided to freeze the rent for the first time in New York City history for two years.
And he's made progress on universal child care.
We're going to make child care free for 2,000 kids this fall, 12,000 kids next fall, every single two-year-old by the end of four years.
What's more, he's recently endorsed a slate of progressive congressional candidates who swept their New York primaries to the dismay of the Democratic political establishment.
You can't fulfill an affordability agenda for the most expensive city in the country without partners at every level of government.
Of course, Mamdani has many, many critics.
Mamdani is telling everybody he's going to give everything away for free. He's a psychopath. He's a communist, too, by the way. He kind of reminds me of a young Fidel.
But he's now undeniably a national political force. So, just how does he plan on using all this power? Here's my conversation with New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Welcome to The Interview. Thank you so much for being here. I really appreciate you coming here.
Thank you so much for having me on a day of the World Cup. I don't know if you heard some of my colleagues cheering in.
Yes. I think there's about 20 minutes left in the France-Spain game.
Yeah, yeah. So sorry that we're interrupting perhaps your viewing of this, but not at all. But yeah, appreciate the time.
I was going to do this whole interview without mentioning President Trump, but as often happens, he tends to enter the chat regardless of one's intentions. And President Trump recently shared a video by Michael Savage, who's a pro-Trump pundit, calling for you to be criminalized and deported. And my question is, what does it mean when the president of the United States shares a sentiment like that? And how do you deal with it?
I think that it's part of the corrosion of political and public life that this is frankly something that I don't even blink at anymore because it's become, in many ways, a norm of the last few years. And I also think that Americans are hungry for a very different kind of politics, one where disagreement is a part of it. Deportation and demonization is not.
Does it worry you that it is normal, and that by not reacting it normalizes it more? Or do you worry that he's trying to goad you into reacting? I don't want to be part of the sort of cycle of that. I'm just wondering how you calculate it.
I think that for all of the fear-mongering around democratic socialism, the best response is to show what it actually means. And what we've shown over the last six months is exactly that. We've shown that a city with a democratic socialist vision is one that paves more than 170,000 potholes, 50,000 more than the prior administration by this point. It's a city that has delivered the lowest recorded number of shootings and shooting victims and murders in New York City's history. It is a city that is on a pathway to universal child care, saving thousands of parents more than $20,000 a year. And it's a city that is doing all of these things while fighting for the people who are often left behind. Workers, for whom we've secured more than $10 million; tenants, more than $64 million. These are all indicators of what is so scary to a right wing that has built its entire power and framework on the idea of debating who should be left behind.
One last question on this. When these kinds of attacks against you — and I can hear you deliberately not trying to personalize it, not trying to respond to it — but does it impact you and your security, for example? I mean, we've seen other people who get targeted like this verbally. It has an actual impact. There's more threats. There's more focus. So,
There are threats, the kinds of which sadly became familiar over the course of the campaign. I am lucky in that I'm protected by the best of the best in our NYPD. And I'm also concerned because if these threats have changed my life and have changed the lives of those that I love, I often wonder about the threats to those whose names we don't even know. Because what is so terrifying about the normalization of political violence is not even just those to whom it's directed, but what it makes acceptable towards any other in this city, in this country. And that is a real fear that I have as we try and show what a city can look like where everyone belongs, that there are those firmly invested in a kind of division that is at odds with that.
Did you at some point have to make peace with the fact that you are a target?
I don't know if you can make peace with it. I think you can come to expect it. You can come to rationalize it as if it is part of what it is that you do. And look, I grew up and I would hear politicians say things about their family, how they didn't sign up for it, this, that, and the other. And when you're on the outside and you're hearing that, it sounds at a certain point to be quite cliché. And when you're living it, you realize the depth of that sentiment: that we sign up for public life shouldn't mean that we sign up for threats or violence, but at least we made a choice. And then there are those that we love who did not make a choice other than to love us. And yet somehow those threats, that violence also becomes a part of their life. And it has seeped into the lives of many more people across the city, across the country. And you know, I grew up in New York City. To me, disagreeing is one of the most New York things you can do. Sometimes you'll hear two people and it sounds like they're fighting, but that's just how they say I love you in New York City. And so it's not to say that we shouldn't have that kind of disagreement or dissent or debate, and even that it not be vehement, but what it has become instead — it actually silences that debate out of fear.
We're talking a few weeks after some pretty big political victories for you. You went out on a limb and endorsed several Democratic Socialist candidates who then won their primaries. And after they won, you said you wanted to send a national message, and that it sounded like you want to clearly be heard beyond New York City. Why?
You know, we are in some ways distinct here in New York City. We are the wealthiest city in the wealthiest country in the history of the world. And I also know that the struggles of working people here in this city, a city where one in four are living in poverty, are not unique. I know that working people across this country are facing those same struggles. And for too long it has felt like our party, the Democratic Party, that the only answer we have is to say that we are not the Republican Party. The only answer we have is a response to the cruelty of the federal administration. But we also have to have a vision of what comes after this administration. And I think that at the heart of that has to be a vision for that working person. And that's why I think it is so critical to speak about that not just here in New York City, but frankly anywhere where those people are struggling.
And you feel like because of your position in the party, you are at this point one of the most visible people, that you're the person to impart that?
I think that message, frankly, is coming from New Yorkers themselves, and we should listen to them when they vote for Daria, for Claire, for Brad, when they vote for all five of the state legislative candidates that I endorsed that won their races. So much of what has often been discussed as if it is an intellectual debate is in fact something that can change the material reality of working New Yorkers. And I think that's what's been so incredible about being able to serve as the mayor of the greatest city in the world is it's a chance to show that you can fight for the people that the right has left behind, and you can do it by asking yourself what are the challenges they face, and then asking your team how can we deliver on those things.
Do you see yourself as a Democrat or a Democratic socialist? Because you said our party, and obviously you ran as a Democrat.
I am both. I'm a Democrat and I'm a Democratic socialist. And I think that so much of what makes me proud to be a Democrat is looking at what our party used to stand for. And you think about the Four Freedoms, you think about FDR, you think about the New Deal. Those are at the core of what our party's identity is. And yet it feels like to experience it, you have to read about it. You can't see it around you anymore. And that isn't something that I'm willing to accept. And I know that many feel similarly.
I'm curious how you're planning to use your political capital. I mean, are you planning on getting involved in races outside of New York?
Eventually. My focus right now is on New York City.
I would say that for now, this is where I'm looking because I think that — have you ever seen New York?
Yeah. But you keep on answering this question in this particular way, and I understand why. But you know, you have some momentum, and if you're wanting to sort of send this message beyond New York, the question obviously is how and when.
I am still seeing the world like that cover of The New Yorker where it's New York, it's New Jersey, and then it's the rest of the world. I think that my focus is on doing the work here, but I also think that New Yorkers have sent a message, and we've also seen that it's not specific in that we've seen these kinds of victories in New Jersey, in Colorado, in California. When it comes to my endorsements, I was proud to make those eight endorsements, and I'm excited to see what they do next.
After those endorsements, you said 2028 begins now. I mean, what role would you like to play in 2028?
I think to continue to be honest about the struggles that New Yorkers are facing and the importance of a vision that responds to them. And you know, sometimes politics feels like it's a hobby only some can afford, and I don't want it to be that way. Politics determines what people can afford, and we need to see a recognition of that and an actual platform of how we will deliver that affordability. We in fact have to be able to say, what are you going to do about housing? What are you going to do about child care? What are you going to do about the cost of groceries? I think what's so exciting is that cities have often been discussed as laboratories of democracy, that we can actually show that this isn't a fantasy. I think there's cheers going on. I'm not sure what's happened, but we'll find out later.
We'll find out. I think Spain probably won.
I was thankfully a little unengaged in today's game. A lot of the teams I root for, they tend to lose now, but now is the time for favorites.
I want to stay on this just a little bit longer because one of the people who is rumored to be considering a run for president is obviously Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and there's been reporting that you coordinated with AOC in your New York endorsements. Do you consider that to be a partnership?
Absolutely. I consider it to be a partnership, and I also consider her to be an inspiration. I had the privilege of having been represented by her in Congress. Before I was the mayor, I was an assembly member in an overlapping part of her congressional district in Astoria and Long Island City. And I think she has shown what it looks like to fight for working people.
Do you consider it an alliance sort of going forward, that she would endorse, you know, Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan and elsewhere, and you endorse her in New York?
I think that she makes her own decisions, and I think they're decisions that many of us look to and are inspired by. And I'm excited to continue to work together because for a long time politics has been understood as if it is about individuals, and what's so exciting is that at the heart of that partnership is a belief in the collective. And even if you think about the greatest mayor, I would argue, in New York City's history, he could not have achieved what he did without the partnership of FDR. And that dream of having partners is also what drove me to make the decision to endorse those three congressional candidates, because you can't fulfill an affordability agenda for the most expensive city in the country without partners at every level of government.
So it's interesting that you mentioned that partnership with FDR. Would you endorse AOC for president if she runs? Because that obviously would be a very clear partnership.
I'm excited to see what decision she makes. In terms of endorsements, the ones that I'm focused on are the ones that I've just made.
I mean, there's been some recent disagreement in the DSA, the Democratic Socialists of America, your party —
What is a socialist without disagreement?
Yeah. Surrounding her endorsement. Do you think you would endorse her independently of your party?
Well, first I would say DSA is an organization, and my party is the Democratic Party.
And my organization is DSA.
And I would say that I'm still very much focused in this year, but I do believe that we all have to take a step back and appreciate what it is that she means to so many across this country. And the reason for it is the work that she has done.
You think she'd make a good president?
I think she would make a good anything. I think she's a great congresswoman. And I think no matter what she decides to do, she's going to bring those same qualities to whatever that work is.
So we've talked about your endorsements, and I would like to talk in particular about Daria, Lisa, AOC, who ran successfully against Adriano Espaillat, the head of the Hispanic Caucus. You know, he's a former undocumented immigrant. He has strong progressive credentials: dismantle ICE, supportive of Medicare for All. Did you privately promise him that you were going to support his reelection campaign during your campaign for mayor?
I told him that I appreciated his support when he endorsed me in the general election after I won the Democratic primary. And the promise that I made to New Yorkers was to use any tool that I had to further that affordability agenda. And in Daria, Lisa, I see a congressional candidate, soon to be a congresswoman, who will be someone who really has built a campaign on a vision of babies, not bombs. And I think that that speaks to what it means to invest in affordability and also reckon with the bankruptcy that has typified a lot of our politics, especially when it comes to our foreign policy. And you were asking me earlier about political capital. To me, I think the point of political capital is to spend it to deliver material change. And these are not intellectual arguments. These are the ones that will determine whether or not these districts look different in the years to come. When it comes to Daria's district, this is one of the poorest congressional districts in the United States of America. And as I walked that district with her, we were discussing the amount of money that our federal government sends in the billions of dollars to the Israeli military. And as we were doing so, a man came out of a bodega with his hands full with two packages of Huggies. And you see what the priorities are of people living in the district, and yet you see what the priorities are of federal policy that represents the district. And you see this chasm. And the more that you tolerate that kind of a chasm, the more that you tell people that politics is something that they shouldn't deem as if relevant to their life, something to tune out as opposed to something to be a part of.
I mean, it's interesting that you mention Israel, because is the reason you didn't endorse Espaillat his relationship with AIPAC, the pro-Israel lobby, his longtime support of Israel? Was that like sort of the seminal thing that for you was a differentiator?
I think these are all important factors. I think the need for moral clarity in our politics, to quote Congresswoman Ocasio-Cortez, is something that speaks to a wide variety of policies and also applies to our foreign policy when it comes to the funding of the Israeli military. And you saw in the final weeks of that race, AIPAC spending a significant amount of money to try and stop Daria. And what you see when you speak to the constituents of that district is a very different hope and vision for the place they call home and also the country that they've helped to build. And it's hard to explain to a New Yorker why their needs are not even being discussed, and yet we have billions of dollars to kill civilians halfway across the world.
I mean, earlier we were talking about the World Cup, and you know, we'll be watching the games here, and then you'll look to the news and you'll find that even someone who had gone to Gaza on a relief mission to set up watch parties was then killed by the Israeli military. There is no respite from a genocide, no matter even in a moment of joy for the entire world. I want to understand your point of view on what political weight you give the Israeli issue, because you are very clear about where you stand, but I'm wondering how you apply it to sort of how you look at other political actors. The left-wing streamer Hasan Piker recently said, and I'm quoting here: 'Someone who will not say the truth about Israel's genocide will not stand with you and fight for you for your health care, for your housing. It's that simple.' Do you agree with that statement?
I think what we have seen from New Yorkers, what we have seen from Americans when we talk about this hunger for a new kind of politics, it's a hunger to move beyond the bankruptcy that characterizes a lot of politics today. And it is hard to find a more bankrupt policy approach than what our country has done to Gaza and to Palestine, and how it hasn't been specific to any one party. It's been again and again an insistence to tell New Yorkers and to tell Americans that what they are seeing is not something that they should in fact either be concerned by or believe in. And when you talk about the rupture in trust that comes from that, it is hard to then turn to another issue and say, 'Believe me here.' And what I've found time and again is that that trust, you have to be able to maintain it. It's not to say that you have to agree on everything, but there has to be an honesty. And too often you'll find that there are far more Congress members who will privately tell you that something is a genocide than publicly announce it to be so. And so long as there's an understanding of a difference in what people believe and what they're willing to say, there will be a skepticism and, frankly, a despair amongst those considering whether or not to engage themselves in politics.
So should the litmus test for a politician who wants to be part of your coalition be their views on the Gaza war and their commitment to calling it a genocide?
I think it's an important part. I wouldn't say that there's a specific litmus test as to creating a cookie-cutter of a person that I would endorse in any one seat. What I would say is that you have to have a clear vision of being able to describe things as they are and being able to fight for that which working people have been denied.
But can it include those who support Israel and support America's support of Israel?
I think when you asked me earlier what is my party, I've said the Democratic Party.
Yes, and my point is not what's in the Democratic Party. My point is that the importance of a big tent — it's critical not just in how we describe ourselves as what we belong to, but also that we can work with those with whom we might not have agreement on every single issue. And you can even see in the administration that I've put together, it's not an administration where at every job interview I ask someone, 'What are your thoughts about Israel and Palestine?' Frankly, it has very little to do with most of the things that I'm hiring for. And what we want is to show that you are looking for expertise, you are looking to deliver on the ambition of your policy platform, and to build a team that's able to do so. And when it comes to my endorsements of Congress members or those running for state legislative seats, they have to show a vision of the world that speaks to that despair and also addresses how you would actually deliver something different.
And you felt that Espaillat didn't do that?
One other question on this. Former vice president and presidential candidate Kamala Harris called you recently. She's reportedly reaching out to pro-Palestinian groups or people with pro-Palestinian views. She's, you know, considering another run for president. Reportedly, as Biden's VP, she is closely associated with America's support of Israel during the Gaza war. Do you think she can regain trust on that issue?
I think that the first step for anyone looking to run is to be honest about what we see today and what it would take to change that. And when I say what it would take, one of the common features between all of the people that I endorsed for Congress was that each one of these candidates spoke about how they would sign on to the Block the Bombs legislation. It speaks about an unwillingness to continue to be complicit in a genocide, and we're talking about billions of dollars in material support. So I think the first step for any presidential candidate looking to earn the trust of people across the country is a recognition of what our policy has wrought and what a different policy would deliver.
Did you hear that from her?
I think that everyone is early in their considerations, and you know, I truly appreciated the vice president reaching out, and I think that it is a critical part of this early stage.
You know, pro-Palestinian voices were not allowed to speak at all during her 2024 Democratic convention. I heard a lot from people in the activist community around that. They felt very betrayed by the fact that they were not allowed to engage publicly, that their voices, they felt, were silenced. How damaging do you think that was for her?
You know, I think what people wanted in that moment was to know that their voice too belonged in this party that we call home. And I remember following along here from New York City and just refreshing Twitter as I would see for the updates, and Ruard Man and a number of others who were gathered outside, hopeful that their voice would be heard. And what I'm thankful for is that now today that voice is being heard. And it's being heard not only because there are those who have it that are entering into the halls of Congress, but also because those who have long stood up for the belief in a universality when it comes to human rights are now being treated as core parts of a political conversation, whereas before it wasn't even a conversation that was often permitted to be had.
Do you think the Democratic Party can become the party of Palestinian rights?
I think it can become the party of human rights for all people, and that must also include Palestinians. I think people are tired of exceptions being drawn. And we know that in politics, the more often you draw an exception, the more likely you are to draw another one. And people want consistency. They want to know that when they speak to you, they don't have to call you the next day to see if the wind is blowing differently how you're going to answer them, but that they can trust you that this is something that you in fact do believe in.
Last question on this topic. Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is perhaps planning to visit New York for the UN General Assembly. You pledged during your campaign and after you won to order his arrest to comply with the International Criminal Court warrant. What will happen if he comes in September?
I believe that Prime Minister Netanyahu belongs in The Hague. He's a war criminal who has been charged by the International Criminal Court. And what you will find is that is an opinion that is held by many purely because of what his actions have wrought over these last many years. I've also said that I will follow the laws that we have here in New York City, because I believe that there is an importance in following the law as a leader who presides over our city, and that's something that I plan to do.
Meaning — I'm sorry, I don't understand what that means.
Meaning that whatever the law allows me to do in New York City, that's what we will do. But we won't be writing our own laws to that end.
What does the law allow you to do?
That's an active conversation with our legal department in seeing what the prospects are we have here in our municipality. However, what we've seen at the national level is a desire sometimes to write your own laws, to go outside of the bounds of legality. That's not something we have an interest in.
I mean, normally when people come to a UN General Assembly, they're granted a sort of amnesty because it is the seat of the United Nations. Is that what you're thinking that you'll honor, or you're actively looking to see if you can actually arrest him?
I think we are looking at all of our legal obligations, and one of them is with regards to the United Nations. But the other part of this is we're not talking about a personal assessment of Benjamin Netanyahu. We're talking about the International Criminal Court and the fact that they have a warrant out for this prime minister's arrest. And I think it's important to talk about the weight that that has as a charge, and also that as the mayor of New York City, I'll be following the laws of New York City.
Okay. One of the things that I really wanted to ask you about also was an understanding of your sort of broader vision for your coalition now that you're getting involved in federal races, because Daria, Lisa again avails all deportations, even of violent criminals. She called borders a philosophical concept. How do you view, for example, the issue of border security? What border policy should America have? You know, should immigrants be able to claim asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border? Should they be able to enter the country while their claims are being reviewed?
I think some of what you're describing is answered by the law. And I believe that we should follow the law when it comes to asylum cases. I also believe that we should have a border policy that both is secure and one that is also defined by some humanity. You know, when we talk about immigration, it's often bandied about as just a political subject for debate. ICE is an agency that has terrorized Americans across this country and others that live in this country. Just the other day, a man who wasn't even 30 years old said goodbye to his wife and his child, and moments later was shot by ICE agents in Maine. And this was not even a month after a man was killed in Texas. And so when we're talking about all of this, I often think about it through a prism of legality, consistency, and humanity, and an understanding that immigration policy doesn't just affect those without status. It affects an entire city. You know, I went to a Dominican barber shop in Harlem, and the owner was telling me that everyone in the barber shop had status. They all had status. And yet most of them were terrified to come to work because they know that for so much of ICE's operations, it has little to do with legality. It has to do with profiling, and it has to do with a vision of creating the largest deportation machine this country has ever seen, and of a notion of this country where so many of us who call it home would have no place in it any longer.
I think the issue of deportations is one you've been pretty consistent on. I'm trying to understand what your idea of the border would be, because obviously the people you endorsed in federal races will have an impact on any legislation to do with the border. And the Democratic Party, you know, has struggled gaining support over its border policies, considering what happened under the Biden administration, where you had, you know, the border, as some would describe it, being overrun, millions of people coming in in an unauthorized fashion, and that had impacts here in New York City. You know, a lot of the city was overstretched. Resources were overrun, and it made people very unhappy. So again, I would just like to understand what a humane border policy looks like for you.
I don't believe that secure and humane are at odds. I don't believe that the only way to provide immigration enforcement is through ICE. I think oftentimes we are forced into these false choices.
Would you have asylum seekers be able to, you know, for example, ask for asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border?
What is the law today? What are they legally entitled to do?
I mean, the law today — I mean, under President Trump, the law today is that they're not. But in terms of international obligations, in terms of — and that has meant that the border has seen a dramatic drop in illegal crossings. So I guess that is the tension that a lot of people see.
I think that what we've found from the Republican administration has been a desire to make any and all immigration illegal. And I sit before you as one of the first immigrant mayors of our city in generations. I lead a city where of eight and a half million people, more than three million are immigrants. And so when we're talking about legitimate claims to asylum, I think that those should be honored. When
We're talking about immigration enforcement. I think that it should be humane. I talk about our pride in being a sanctuary city in terms of the policies that we practice. I'll give you an example of those policies. We are willing to work with the federal government on more than 170 serious crimes if someone has been convicted of them. What we are unwilling to do is to participate in civil immigration enforcement with a federal government that has said openly it wants to deport a vast majority of people for crimes that we will never even know.
That is where I think I see the tension. Have you ever been to the U.S.-Mexico border?
You've been in office for half a year. You have very high approval ratings, 58% in New York City, according to the most recent Siena poll, and that is a number that has actually gone up, which I think is unusual in our current political moment. You've made strides on two out of your three central campaign promises: a start on universal child care, the rent freeze. Free buses are not there yet, but you've just launched a whole new project on making the buses action plan.
175 routes, up to six minutes saved per way.
I think people find it heartening that you nerd out on this stuff because it makes a difference. You know, sometimes we treat these like statistics, but think about for an average New Yorker what they could do with 12 more minutes if they're taking a bus to and from.
You know, as I was thinking about your project and the ambitions that you have laid out to the city, I was wondering, and I know this is a little bit of an absurd question, but come on. Let's do it. Let's do absurdity. But if you had a magic wand, no, but really, I know this sounds like a little bit absurd, but I do think it speaks to if money was no object and you could enact anything, what would you do?
I'd be doing the same things I'm doing now.
It would just be a lot easier, I think.
No, but one thing that you could do.
I think one thing I'm very passionate about is universal child care.
So that would be the thing.
That would be the thing. And the reason that would be the thing is right now in our city, to afford child care for a 2-year-old as a family, you need to make $334,000.