Yeah, all the gangsters are here. Mike, you wouldn't believe what's going on in the live chat right now. People are going ballistic.
What about... I mean, the markets are like literally, I don't want to say in free fall, but I...
No, no, no. Tech, tech stocks are basically in a free fall. People are, people are excited. I don't know if because they're dip buyers or because they've been in cash, they've been waiting for this. I don't know. People seem more upbeat about the selloff than I've seen in a long time.
Not on the internet. Not away from our chat, though.
Away from our chat, people are doing like, you know, the thing in the conspiracy movies where there's a corkboard and they're...
...using yarn like Verizon outage, Apple outage, Schwab outage, FAA grounds, 10,000 flights.
Banks, what's the big deal?
Yeah, but there's opportunity in the stock market. This is the key thing. The stock market, no disruption. We're open 24/7. All right, ladies and gentlemen, welcome to What Are Your Thoughts, America's favorite investing live stream. My name is Downtown Josh Brown. If this is your first time here, you are in for a treat. Michael Batnick is my co-host. Michael is here. Say hello, Mike.
We got a full house behind the scenes. Duncan, John, Daniel controlling the ones and twos. I think Nicole is in the chat. I haven't seen her yet, pretty sure. And all the pounders are here. Cool. Mandate is in the chat saying adding to short position in CoreWeave right now. Yeah, it's, it's rallying after hours on these Nvidia news.
Trey Hammer 6509: Jensen threw a water bottle at me. Jensen, I run a business. Sometimes I have to kick ass to make it run right. I straightened him out. Oh, we're doing, we're doing Jensen stick talk. I guess these are things that may or may not have happened in corporate meetings. Let me give, let me give you one more. C Paul Breezy: what up chat? I'm trying to multitask with the Nvidia call and What Are Your Thoughts. Let's go. All right, let's go. We have a sponsor tonight. Who's sponsoring the show?
It's Betterment Advisor Solutions. Thinking about going independent? It's a big decision...
...and Betterment Advisor Solutions. What are you, Tom Brady? Knock it off. And Betterment Advisor Solutions can help make that decision a little easier by turning hard work into less complexity in your day-to-day operations. Because what's the point of leaving? Just to fight with a new platform. Every hour lost to clunky tech is an hour less with your clients. Betterment can help you build a better experience on your terms with a single custodial and wealth management platform, not a patchwork of legacy systems. Plus, you'll have a transition support team by your side to help every step of the way. The move can be simple, low risk, and fast for you and your clients. It's your expertise that clients will follow, and Betterment makes sure the platform and the transition don't get in your way. Build the independent firm you want. Break away better with the right partner in Betterment Advisor Solutions. Visit betterment.com/breakaway to get started. Damn it, I almost stuck the landing. Oh well.
...usually, usually you get through the whole thing. You're better at this than anyone I know, but that's not a 10. It's not a 10 this time.
All right. You guys, we have so much to get through tonight. I know people want to hear our takes on the news of the day and there is just an endless amount of news. I don't even know if we'll get to everything. But of course we have to start with...
...all right. Nvidia earnings about after the close. Michael, why don't you narrate for the people what we have just learned? And I know we have a whole run of charts. Thank you to Sean and Chart Kid Matt and...
...and me. I got my, I got my hands dirty. We are all hands on deck right now for the compounders.
Been doing this for a minute, Josh.
All right, so it was a monster beat and a raise. Let's start just with a straight vanilla. Just show me the revenue up and to the right. They report their fiscal year 27 third quarter. I don't know. How does it even happen? Like whatever. It doesn't matter.
Wait, how does what, how does what happen?
That they're off calendar on their fiscal quarters.
Q3 2027. These guys are playing in the future. It's unbelievable.
These things date back to like the founding of these companies and it just sticks.
You can't, you can't make it make sense. All right. Data center revenue is up 30 times since 2023. Up.
How big was the revenue beat? Six billion.
It was like a big beat. Not just like, oh, we're a penny ahead.
Year-to-date fiscal year 2027 is already just three quarters ahead of the entire 2026 fiscal year. And last year was a monster. Like it was not, you know, high base. And to me, the one of the bigger numbers that stood out was the authorized share repurchase. They're like, 'All right, 11 times forward earnings, we'll take it all.' $150 billion additional authorized share repurchase.
This is... they did this in September.
Yeah. Two things on this share repurchase. It made very little sense when the stock was selling 220 to 240 at record highs with a 5-something trillion market cap on its way to 6 trillion. Now we're at 3.5 trillion and selling at maybe the lowest multiple in the company's history. And I'm all ears for whether or not they're actually going to follow through and complete this authorized buyback. And I think if they think it's survivable, they're going to pay some fines and have their Asian revenue under suspicion for a few quarters. Okay. But still, this company's generating way too much money to not take advantage of this share slide. Everybody's selling. So if you're serious about an authorized buyback, pull the trigger. This is where you pull the trigger. What do you think about that?
Yeah, it would certainly send a lot of confidence in the market.
Can I have the annual revenue chart back up, year or year-to-date revenue? Sorry. Nvidia's fiscal 2027 year-to-date revenue, not this one.
Yep. Can we just talk about the... So, at 293 billion in, and we don't have the fourth quarter yet, but just like look at this progression from 2020, fiscal year 2023, which presumably is the year before ChatGPT. Okay, so Nvidia did $27 billion that year and is now knocking on over 300 billion for this year. Let's just like, okay, yeah, the stock has gone up a lot, but I sort of think the fundamentals have outrun the share price, especially baking in this latest 36% drawdown from the high. It's not an expensive stock. Has not been an expensive stock for a while.
What the shorts are seizing on here is that this is as good as it gets and everything is about to deteriorate, which we're going to talk about in a second. But nobody would say this stock didn't deserve to have gone up as much as it did. Obviously prior to everything we learned last week. I think that's an obvious take, but an important reminder for people. Why was this stock over 200 in the first place?
So margins look great. Everything looks great in the numbers. And Josh, for the last year and a half, we've been not wondering, but talking around the fact that like why is there, why is this trading at a discount to the market? Never in the history of the stock market have you had the dominant player with the dominant personality of a world-changing technology growing at 100% margins at 70%. And it's trading at a severe discount to the market. Well, turns out maybe the market's not so stupid like bubble...
...because at $6 trillion, and we shared a chart a couple months ago, it can't possibly trade at a premium to the market. It would swallow the market whole. And also, the bigger, the bigger a stock gets, the riskier it becomes. Just the fact that when obviously the market didn't sniff this out, right? It didn't know that there was espionage and affairs and all that sort of [__]. But it just said, you know what, there's just at this size and this scale, there's just a lot of things that can go wrong. And we're...
...it becomes asymmetric. Like more good news probably doesn't do as much as the sudden emergence of bad news. That's, that's, that's what happens at 6 trillion. And none of us have that roadmap because it's never happened before. We've never had a stock this big. And I think we've talked about this over the year, over the past year or two a lot. So we don't have to get into like the details, but some of the reasons for that discount. The first one that you just cited, at a certain point it can't be half the S&P, which is where it would be if this was a situation where people were actually pricing it based on its current growth. The second reason is Nvidia didn't really have any competition two years ago and that's not true anymore. They compete with their own customers who are making their own chips. Meta, Amazon, Alphabet, everybody's making chips.
Wait, on this, on this, on this, this is important. So, we have a chart later in the show, but just to that point, in 24/25, this is from Michael Semblat, Nvidia had 80 to 90%...
...revenue share of the market...
...and now it has only 28% share of announced Frontier Lab compute agreements.
Yeah, Chris, Chris Hayes is in the chat talking about Broadcom. So Broadcom is making custom chips for all of Nvidia's top customers. The customers themselves are producing things like tensor processing units and all sorts of ASICs, and you get to a, you get into a space where yes, it's still true that the CUDA software platform locks in a lot of demand for GPU clusters for the foreseeable future. However, the conversations do ultimately get toward the price per unit of compute, and these other companies have not spent the last two years like sitting around.
So, that is, that is, and we're going to talk, I see people talking about AMD in the chat. We're going to get there in a minute.
We got to talk about the man himself. The key man risk here. I saw a headline hit right after the close as the company was disclosing earnings that the SEC is now going to look at the departure of Jensen Huang, and I'm assuming all of the related incidents. I guess what took them so long? Everyone knew this would be inevitable. Is anything else jump out at you about this idea?
No. I just want, we'll talk about...
You were worried about the Justice Department and the SEC if I was Jens, if I were Jensen Huang. Back to this, the stock, and the stock was up after hours and great. It had an amazing quarter. I just don't know how you say that the stock is out of the weeds, like out of the penalty box.
...you can't. It could rally 10%, but that wouldn't get it anywhere near where it was, and even...
...and even if you see momentum come into this thing, which I mean, it's, I think it's had nine red days in a row. I don't know how anybody could definitively say, I feel confident. I heard, I heard Gene Munster say earlier this morning he's buying more Nvidia post the resignation because all of the lingering issues are like 90-day problems and the growth...
I don't know, that's what he said. The growth will be so strong that this will end up being the best performing stock in the tech space over the next year. And I said that's like brazen. I mean, he's a fellow bald, so you guys must, you guys must have some affinity for each other.
He looks like Jarvis. That guy is like, he looks like a robot. He's very fit.
I would love for him to be right. But I just don't get, like how could you even be thinking that way? Like, like think about what... First of all, he's going to testify on December 1st for Congress. That's not going to be a walk in the park for shareholders. It's unlikely that he's going to be so good that nothing more is going to come out. The second thing is the day after his lawyer is going to come testify. Now we are sitting here in waiting mode. The board's got to go through its own process and discover how bad was what he was doing, and there's a law firm involved, and it's, you know, that thing takes forever. Then the Democrats take office in January. They're going to bring them back, or because, because we're talk, we're literally talking about evading controls around selling in jurisdictions where you're not supposed to. So there are really cynical takes out there where, oh no, you don't understand, this is a quid pro quo. The Trump administration actually wants him to sell these chips for China, and in exchange China is selling us rare earths, but nobody knows. It's like a secret deal. I've seen that. I've seen... I'm going to tell you the funniest take I heard. I've also seen people say, 'You know what? Actually, this guy's so arrogant, he actually just unilaterally decided that there's no reason we shouldn't be selling chips to China. We should want China to standardize on US AI hardware.' And therefore, he just said, 'These people are too dumb. I'll figure out a way to do it.' And he did it anyway.
So, that story is sort of...
...and then here's my favorite take. I spoke to one of the smartest people I know over the weekend. He sells ovens to pizzerias. He's from Staten Island. He thinks, he thinks Jensen's coming back. And he said something that nobody on Wall Street has said, including the signatories of the bring Jensen back letter. He said, I'm going to do my best to, I'm paraphrasing, I can't remember the exact wording, some of the exact wording. I remember. He said, 'No, you don't understand. It's, it's, it's okay now.' It's what? Why? Because like Trump's in office and you could just do, do stuff. He's...
...like, 'Wait, is this like young Henry when he get, when he gets pinched?' Sounds serious.
He goes, he goes, 'No, it's okay.' He said, 'What do you mean it's okay?' He said, 'Well, let me get this straight. Before everybody was saying he's involved with a Chinese spy and maybe like getting blackmailed or whatever, like helping her sneak chips into China or whatever, but then there's another girl and then another girl and maybe there'll be another girl. So, all he has to do is make it obvious this is not about chips. It's about sex.'
I'm a sex maniac. It's not that she was a Chinese spy. Fine, but the secretary is not a spy. The head of Nvidia Health is not a... So I go, I never really thought about it that way. And nobody's saying that's actually his best defense of like...
So your friend, your friend sells data centers to pizzerias.
No, literally baking ovens. Baker's Pride ovens. And he goes, 'Yeah, just think about it. It's the best defense in the world.' Yeah. I said, I said, 'Nobody on Wall Street or on CNBC is saying this.' He goes, 'My friend, he [__] his way into this situation. He's got to [__] his way out.' And that was the end of the conversation. But I do think that they're going to use that as the defense. They're going to say, 'Look at this guy.'
It doesn't matter that it's a possible spy. He's sleeping with everybody.
Jensen Huang is Ronnie Mund with $150 billion. Same thing. I thought that anyway, I thought that was, I thought that was insane yet insightful.
Some of the character assassination stuff to me strikes me as very stupid, nonsensical. Some of these anecdotes about his character...
Oh, the Wall Street Journal had an article yesterday, according to people, he was erased...
...he erased $2 trillion from this company's value. He hurt the entire country that's invested in Nvidia through retirement accounts, index funds, actively managed mutual funds, ETF, individual shareholders, retail. A lot of people are invested in this. And he lied. Then he covered it up and now he's coming clean. But a lot of money has been lost. And when that happens, the press, it's open season. This happens to everybody.
No, there's, there's fire. No, my, my point was some of the anecdotes you hear. Oh, he yelled at his employees. Okay.
Oh god, don't ever, don't ever investigate me then.
Seriously, people were afraid of him.
Yeah. Well, okay. I mean, that's the boss.
Yeah, it's pretty common in corporate America. I don't know.
People yell at their employees at a car wash like...
Yeah. By, by the way, I mean, for the avoidance of doubt...
...for the avoidance of doubt, yes, he has done, he did, he did very, very, very, very shitty things. What do you think about, what do you think about the All-In guys and Brad Gerstner, who I like, and Gavin, who I don't know, like publicly prostrating themselves, the board must take him back? So I know they're friends with him, and I was thinking, you know, the Train song Drops of Jupiter.
So it was stuck in my head because I just watched the Matthew Perry documentary on Netflix.
That was [__] depressing, huh? Jeez.
It was too much. I watched it. We were going out to dinner and I was pre-gaming before dinner. I was having a drink and it made me want to push the drink away. I didn't, but it made me want to. But you know the song Drops of Jupiter, there's a line in that song, 'your best friend always sticking up for you, even when I know you're wrong.' Like that's like a good thing. And I sort of feel like I get it. Like these guys are friends with Jensen. Like they hang out. They like, they go to each other's houses for barbecues. So, I sort of understand it. Also, things have a habit of boomeranging back around. And if you're one of the people who's like, knows him in real life and publicly backing him, maybe that's like not the worst position to be in for that boomerang.
It has nothing to do with friendship. It's all dollars. Come on. Don't be naive.
So, all right. So, they're shareholders like, what's Gavin's fund? I don't, I don't, I don't know enough about this, but he has a hedge fund.
A trades is a hedge fund.
Yes. Yeah. It's all about the dollars. Jensen is very, very powerful. The ultimate AI influencer. You don't want to lose him.
You know what? I honestly think you're sleeping with your employees. That's it. Like in other words, let's say, let's say Congress does this, these hearings and there's an investigation. The Commerce Department investigates and they look at this and they say, 'All right, it's gross, but it's not outright treason.' Like, he just had bad judgment. Let's say like all of that plays out. And maybe that takes six months. I have no idea. The thing that doesn't change is that we have corporate governance for a reason, and if, and if within the corporation you can't, you can't have romantic relationships with direct reports, like how does the board just say, yeah, you can't, but we give you two chances...
...or it doesn't, it doesn't apply to Jensen Huang, or enough money has been lost that we're willing to change our governance standards.
That's where I was going. Throw up this chart from Kalshi. So, who will be the next CEO of Nvidia? And as of 3:00 this afternoon, Jensen had a 12.5% chance, and I don't know, oh, there was no time date. Okay. Polymarket had a similar thing and it was like by the end of 2026, by the end of 2027, and it was like similarish numbers. I think the only way that they bring him back is if the business and the stock price rapidly, rapidly...
...goes to [__]. So if the stock, if the stock falls 70%, if the, if the, if the revenue is down 20%, they say, listen, okay, he slept with his employees. Yeah, he's, he's a bad guy. He did bad things, but like we also have a fiduciary duty to shareholders and he is the only person that can fill his own vacuum. So, I'll do you one better. I was reminded over the weekend, I was listening to Alex Kozak on his podcast talking about this, and he was making the point like it's not 2025 anymore. So, like there's a universe where all of this comes out before the midterm elections when Trump is still ascendant and basically like willing, manifesting things into existence. I think he's taken 60 government stakes in publicly traded companies. Like he just decides it's in the best interest of national security and I hereby demand the Nvidia board retain Jensen as CEO. And what do you mean? They took a stake in Intel and started shot-calling on where they're going to build, where they're going to build fabs. Like it is a thing. Not now. Before the election, it was very much a thing. The president was shot-calling at publicly traded companies that the government was investing in and declaring these are national security assets, these businesses. And I think Alex is onto something like that logic in a 2024-2025 world. There is a universe where Trump just decides, how dare you fire the CEO of the most important American technology company in the world and put this country at risk.
I thought you meant, I thought you meant going forward. I agree with you. 20... I agree with you now.
Well, that's the point. So that, like what I think, what Alex and his guest or his co-host were saying is like...
...post-midterms that world no longer exists...
...now there are checks, there are checks and balances again.
I thought, I thought Ben Thompson described it best, and he knows what's up.
He said Nvidia's most important moat was the degree to which it was not a normal company. Huang organized Nvidia as an exoskeleton around one man himself. There is very little management at Nvidia. Huang famously has 60 direct reports for the same reason that there was no succession plan. Nvidia can move so quickly and so aggressively because the company still behaved as if it were a startup. Blah blah blah blah. He said, he goes on to say it also created an environment where there were no checks on Huang, and now that he is gone, the exoskeleton is much more poised to collapse than you might expect. Those are strong words. Right?
So I said this on TV today. I actually don't think you can bring somebody in internally and get the result that you want if you're the board. Because think about it, it's like the head of household leaves home, right? And then it's just the kids left, like the show Party of Five. It's like the siblings have to raise each other.
So if you watch that show, nobody listens to anyone.
There's, there's an older brother, an older sister, a middle brother.
That show, that show is very old. We're old. You're old.
But I'm old. But like you can't expect any of the siblings to listen to each other in the absence of dad. And dad is gone maybe forever. I sort of, and the problem with that governance structure is none of the internal candidates are strong enough to wield the gauntlet.
...you, you could raise this guy Ian Buck and it's like, okay, you're in charge of your brothers and sisters now.
LOL. I'm going to Anthropic. I'm going to OpenAI. I'm going to Nvidia to Intel.
So there's that problem. So, I sort of think you have to put in a G, like a certified G who can actually build a governance structure. Well, everyone's talking about Nikesh Arora from Palo Alto Networks. I don't know why. I have, I have no insight, but that's, that's the name that continues to come up. The Tim Apple thing got shot to [__]. Apple hates Nvidia. Nvidia hates Apple. They literally hate each other. There's no universe where Tim would leave one of the top two largest companies in the world to run the other one. That's a [__] shambles. And I sort of, John Gruber said that, who's a big-time Apple watcher, and I sort of think that that's the right take.
You saw Jensen, Jensen's tweet today.
He basically said, I love, put America...
Yeah, I don't want to read the whole thing, but he said, 'If the board of directors decides my return is in the best interest of our shareholders and our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO.' I mean, obviously...
I can't believe he did this. He resigned less than a week ago. He resigned on Wednesday or Thursday night. I literally can't believe he just put this out.
'I own my mistakes completely, and I am committed to cooperating with the board's independent investigation.' Why don't you get through the congressional investigation before you start applying for jobs? It seems, it just seems like, is he...
...the degree, the degree to which his, his boys are demanding he comes back, I think has to make you a little bit nervous as an investor in this space...
...because why do they feel like it's so necessary?
So, somebody said it's not even about the stock price. They're all invested in all these startups that have handshake deals for compute.
Yeah, of course. It's the whole thing. He's the Fed for AI.
Yeah, it's... Well, yeah, I think I was the first person to say that he's the AI Fed chairman. All right. Last July, we did a show called 'I give you permission to sell Nvidia' because I was watching him check into hotels with various employees. And no, I had no, I had no idea that a year and a half later we'd be dealing with what we're dealing with right now. And I didn't sell myself because I had sold the stock on the way up over the course of years and I'm just, I'm left with my position now. I'm not selling anymore. But I did try to make the case, the stock had just gone up, I don't know, three or four fold and split. And I just tried to make the case that if this thing has taken over your portfolio and like maybe even like took over your whole personality, like maybe that's a good reason to sell. And if you're in that situation, I give you permission. And I think we have a clip. John, do we have a clip?
Off the table or just ride this rally going into earnings.
I think for every individual person watching this and for every portfolio manager, unfortunately, I don't have advice that would cover the gamut of what everyone's trying to do. But one of the things that I think is very obvious is now is not the time to be getting more bullish than you were a month ago or six weeks ago. Now is the time to maybe say, 'Okay, I've had a good run of a bunch of stocks that are up double digits in a very short period of time.' And do I still want to have as much exposure as I did when valuations were lower and there was less enthusiasm priced into these names? And for some of you, you'll say, 'You know what? Actually, I haven't thought about that in a while, but maybe I don't want to have a 5% position that just went to 8%.' And it's not a, it's not the same as saying, oh, we're about to have a correction and I predict that it starts in 27 hours. It's just a recognition that this has been an amazing market to be involved with and a lot of stocks have probably outgrown the original size that you put them on in your portfolio, and you might want to make some decisions right now about if today were the starting point, how do I want to be allocated going forward?
So, thank you. Thank you so much. It cost me nothing to say that, by the way. So, two things. I don't... that was a really short haircut. Like that was, that was like literally buzz cut. So I just want to point out how much things have progressed since then. But more importantly, so we did a show on YouTube. We said the same thing. 'I give you permission to sell Nvidia.' People got pissed off about that. Like there was a time where selling it, you almost were like the antichrist to even suggest like to get out of any AI whatsoever, but especially Nvidia. And it's just, it's, I think it gets back to your earlier point. You don't know what the curveball is going to be. You don't know who's going to throw it or what direction it's going to come from. But like that's why you don't just let individual positions completely take over your portfolio. No matter how good the news is, the thing that happens is going to shock everybody and it's almost inevitable. It's going to happen. You don't know when or what it is. You just...
Let me ask you this while you're hot. While you're hot. So the stock, let's just say that yesterday, or was it the other day? Let's assume that that panic open is a short-term low. Okay.