We couldn't be spies because within five minutes we tell everyone the plan. >> Here's [laughter] the >> and this is why we're right.
Hi everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott, are you in San Francisco and you didn't tell me I'm in San Francisco?
I get there late tonight.
Oh, I'm here. You want to go to an AI dinner with me?
Oh my god. You know me. I just love people, especially those people in tech.
Oh, yeah. I love how you couldn't even get through that ask without laughing. [laughter]
As if you've invited me. I've turned down [__] from you that's about a billion times cooler.
Scott called me this week cuz he was like, "What in the [__] Kara, is going on here with these stupid tech people?" Let me read what's happening. Jensen Huang is reportedly considering a comeback as Nvidia's CEO less than a week after resigning. I'm not sure if he's considering one or if people are pushing it or whatever. Though CNBC is now reporting that Nvidia's board is not considering bringing Jensen back. Jensen allies told the Financial Times that a war room of Silicon Valley executives is being assembled. It is not a war room. It's a sad rogues gallery of the angry people of tech. There's also a petition to bring Jensen back with more than 180,000 signatures as of this recording, including Elon Musk, though some people said they didn't sign it. Their names are on it at Nvidia. So, who knows what's going on there. And the petition says, quote, "Jensen deserves due process, not mob justice." I'm not sure what mob justice means. It was the board of directors. One person who's not on board with Jensen's return: Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Let's listen to what he told Fox News on Sunday.
Makes me think that, you know, as the board conducts a search for a new leader, that they need to go outside the company. That just what was going on inside the company, they needed a dramatic shakeup. Because, Larry, I can tell you that if we were to look at — and Nvidia is a wonderful company, Jensen Huang is an incredible innovator — but that does not abrogate their duties of compliance. And I can tell you that if this were a bank and they hadn't complied like this, the OCC would be in there right now and a lot of the executives would be removed.
That was very strong. Bessent is also pointing fingers at Howard Lutnick's Commerce Department for not blacklisting Mega Speed, the company suspected of sending Nvidia chips to China where Alice Hong was an executive. Let's listen to what Bessent told CNBC late last week.
There have been reports that there was some tension between you and Secretary Lutnick about why Mega Speed was not placed on the entity list, and I'm just wondering about the interagency coordination. Could Treasury have done that? Was it only Lutnick, that could have — Commerce that could have done that? What about the coordination?
Uh, yes. Well, I can tell you there was coordination. Treasury, DOD, USTR, and State, they were in favor of putting Mega Speed on the entity list for months. But Commerce has the pen. Commerce BIS has the pen, and you will have to ask them about their internal process.
Boy, the great coupon man can really deliver a shift. Howard Lutnick and Jensen have both been called to testify with Congress next month. Trump appears to be sticking with Lutnick and Huang right now. He's bringing him — not Jensen — to China, but Lutnick's going to China for the summit with Xi and Putin, this along with Bessent, Marco Rubio, Stephen Miller and others. The Commerce Department also just closed very significantly a loophole that allowed China to get Nvidia compute power from data centers in other countries. There was this workaround where they would give the chips to these companies just outside of China who would then have Chinese customers. Anyway, it was ridiculous, essentially. And whether some of these chips were smuggled into China, that's not clear. Scott, there's so many things going on here. It's moved to a White House national security story. And of course, as usual, Trump's on the wrong side of the trade here. But what are your overall thoughts, and we can get to each piece of it.
Let's start with the White House part and the chips. The tell here over just how serious this is, and how the briefings have only freaked people out even more from our security apparatus, is that Secretary Rubio wrote a memo outlining his alarm and sent it to the president. When the secretary of state, who has direct, fluid, unfettered access to the president, feels the need to put in writing his concern — that means Secretary Rubio, who, whatever you think about him, he's a very smart man, who has access to the deepest intel on this situation, is totally [__] freaked out, right?
He was also a former China hawk, just for people to understand. But go ahead.
But for him, he can go into the president and say, "This is bigger than you think. We need to get rid of Lutnick." But when he decided this is so serious, he needs to cover his ass with a written memo. So that to me — and then when one cabinet member throws another cabinet member under the bus, which we just saw, that means it's coordinated with the president. And I think what's happened is the administration has been briefed by their security apparatus that this is really bad and you're going to need to cauterize it and distance yourself from it. And they've decided the blood barrier or the firebreak here is the Commerce Department and Lutnick.
But he's going, and he also just backed Huang today on the tarmac, and he might ask about this problem. Of course, he'll take G's in. Well, all of a sudden there's this new movement, this what I call the indispensable CEO. We're subject to a different set of norms and laws because we're tech billionaires crew. You made a really — I mean, it's a different issue. So the White House, I believe they saw this and Rubio, and they're like, we got to cauterize it. The blood offering is going to be Lutnick and we're going to blame it on the Commerce Department. This wasn't an errant message from the Treasury Secretary. This was cooked.
What's happened since then is there has been what I would argue is the greatest evidence of how far our society has fallen into the idolatry of innovators. And there's actually a movement that I think has been spun up by certain people controlling certain algorithms on certain platforms and bots.
I do too. I think there's a lot of bots happening.
Because they have a vested interest. What I'll call — what's called the techno-narcissists. They have a vested interest in normalizing the notion that you can violate norms of national defense and it's okay as long as you've created billions of dollars in shareholder value.
Which must look like he's done in Ukraine, but go ahead. He's already down that road, but go ahead.
Oh, nobody wants Jensen forgiven and reinstalled more than Musk right now, right? Because he has to. It's existential. If you're an innovator, you get to skirt national defense protocols and norms, right? That's what they're trying to do here. And then I think maybe Trump sees an opportunity with this kind of what he sees as a populist uprising to kind of have it just be a do-over and keep on cooking. And the argument amongst the quote-unquote tech — what do we call these guys? The techno-narcissists — is that the pace and dynamism that Jensen Huang brings to this very important sector is worth or vastly greater than his errors in judgment. And that argument is insanely ridiculous and stupid and only indicates that these individuals, one, want a different set of standards for all of them because they have a Jesus complex where they think that they are singular to a sector, and two, that they are no longer what I would call invested in the health and well-being of the United States.
Not at all. They're post-national. Thiel has said that where the democracy doesn't matter anymore. You know that.
And that's the problem, is they have their own security. They have their own transportation. They have homes in New Zealand and Milan and Dubai. They can buy access to whatever they need — healthcare, government security. And the other 99.99% of us who are not only stuck on Earth, but stuck in America, we get left. Let's look at this economically. We spend $1.5 trillion a year on defense. 1.5 trillion. There's 150 million households. So the average household has been spending $10,000 a year on defense. And so if you're 45, it's logical to think you've spent a quarter of a million dollars on our national defense. And these errors in judgment basically mean that that quarter of a million dollars meant to provide kinetic and technological advantage such that you and your children are safer and that democracy continues to fight on — if somebody basically says, "Oh, okay, it might be one month, it might be 10 years of advantage has been lost because of indiscretion here" — this is just insane.
It is. It's a waste of our money. Can I just — this movement, I think it's cooked by Musk, absolutely. I think it's a bunch of cooked people. The people involved — Travis Kalanick. Let me — Musk obviously has an existential issue here, right? He's got to push for this because it's about him. It's all about them, not about Jensen Huang. I feel bad in a weird way for Jensen Huang, but one particular person, Travis Kalanick — guess who was shoved out of Uber for bad behavior, and Uber did much better without him.
Well, and guess who's going to get called in front of congressional committees around Ukraine?
Yes, Elon. But Travis Kalanick, you know, as if he is an important figure. He's a fine entrepreneur, but the fact of the matter is Uber has done so much better under a better CEO, Dara Khosrowshahi, who wasn't so pugnacious and in-your-face and battle-ready. And you know, they use all these dumb war and war room. And by the way, at Uber, guess who cooked that up? It's got to be Travis. Because at Uber back in the day, that was the name of their boardroom, was war room. And the minute I walked in there, I'm like, what a bunch of [__] toddlers these people are that they have to name rooms after man things, none of whom have served in the military, but that's another issue. And it's like people like that, or Tim Sweeney was always a cranky person. He's CEO of Epic Games. He said Nvidia's board had serious corporate governance issues. They were hand-placed by Jensen Huang. They're friends of his and they had to take him out and was gaslit into pushing a once-in-a-generation visionary. Let me just say last thing. Steve Jobs — comparing him to Steve Jobs, get his name out of your mouth is how I say it. Stop saying the word Steve Jobs. First of all, Steve Jobs didn't sleep with a Chinese agent. And secondly, would never have tolerated this kind of thing. You know, it's just grotesque that they are trying to pull from this idea. And by the way, I'm sorry Steve Jobs died, but Apple also did well after he died. There's nobody that's indispensable. And he would have done great, too. And I think as our friend Stephanie Ruhle put it, genius doesn't buy a pass on national security. And the fact that they're doing this and saying shareholders should decide is grotesque. They haven't gotten the memo about the election. You lost the election. We hate you and you're still going. How do you explain that? Why they're still going? I don't understand it anymore.
When you say why they're still going, what —
Why they still think they won? They're acting like they won this whole thing, that people like them and that we should take their word for it.
I think that — well, first off, it's a tell because, as you remind me over the weekend, a lot of tech executives are not on board with this indispensable save Jensen [__].
No, you haven't heard from the big ones.
We've heard this about Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Reed Hastings, Jeff Bezos, and most if not all of those companies have gone on to quintuple or increase their market cap by 15x. And I understand the calls around. All right, most companies have protocols where if the CEO is caught in an undisclosed relationship and it's public policy, they're out. And I can understand to a certain extent the calls that this is a private matter between Jensen and his wife and his girlfriend and his other girlfriend and his other other girlfriend. [laughter]
That's a lot of girlfriends. Oh, by the way, I don't know if you heard, but the Senate Banking Committee has subpoenaed the five women at Nvidia who weren't [__] Jensen. [laughter] One died in 1997. One started yesterday. One is a female security dog who's up for it if it involves peanut butter. [clears throat] Oh my god, this is the daily joke on the internet. Daily Show. Yeah.
God, it's gross. Look, the —
This is first off, Kalshi says there's a 10% chance he goes back on the board. I think it's 1%. And this is why, and I say this, I've been on seven public company boards. I've been on 25 private company boards. This is what I believe happened. And I want to be clear, I've never been on a board of this size, magnitude, or even what I'll call importance. But I have been on boards where quote-unquote [__] gets real. And it is a very intense couple weeks.
Including when the New York Times almost went out of business in '08, by the way. This is what happened. They tried to minimize this.
They lied first that nothing was to see here.
Yeah. That it had been quote-unquote — the fact that chips had been shipped violating export controls to a place in Singapore which all of a sudden was like 18% of all sales of Nvidia. They said those rumors had been debunked.
When the [__] got real, the board members basically, I would imagine, all sought personal counsel. They said, "Okay, I probably should check in with my personal lawyer." And I can't imagine a personal lawyer saying to a director, "Oh, my brother, you need to distance yourself from it and show that you are on the side of national security." The downside here — you want to get hauled in front of Congress and maybe someday be testifying in court — you need to distance. And summarily they all told him to resign. The idea that they would take the risk of bringing him back as maybe more negative information unfurls.
These people are now — I don't care if you got $80 million from Jensen. Congressional testimony under oath and the threat of violating import and export controls knowingly and then bringing back the CEO. This is — I just don't see. Now granted, I would have never thought that anyone would have the nads to say, "Oh, let's just forget about this. Let's just not worry about it." But the board there is, in my view, there is no way this board is going to take the personal risk of bringing him back in. Also, I don't think he wants to come back in. Have you heard how he feels about this?
I don't know. I'm not sure. I don't know if it's him speaking through them or whatever, or he's mad now because initially Bloomberg had a really good report about him calling himself — I'm a real [__]. I don't know why he's not focused on his family. I don't know how you could be that egomaniacal after behaving this way and getting found out and there's all these national security implications. You are this arrogant. Although now reports are people seem to like him, but now there's tons of reports of him being an [__] too, like yelling and screaming and throwing things and everything. So, a lot of that other stuff is coming out. I'm sure a lot of the company likes him because he made them a lot of money. But it's not even close to what happened with Sam Altman either. I mean, again, Sam Altman just got mad, got crosswise with a board that was overly stacked against him at that moment. It used to be equal and that was different. And so, again, you haven't really heard from him on this, have you? You haven't heard from — you know, maybe behind the scenes there's some like idea that he might return in a non-CEO role.
Well, there's a group called Kalshi that does a lot of these sort of probability things, and they said if Huang publicly says he would accept a non-CEO role, the probability he returns to Nvidia rises to 63%. If major institutional investors join the push to reinstate him — that could happen. And if he returns, you know, I just don't — it's so ridiculous that this is what we're focusing in on. We don't know what he did here. And a lot of people feel that maybe there was much more to it than that. You know, even Bill Kristol, he wrote there was no — on the China chip scandal there was no honeypot. There was no entrapment of an unwitting innocent. There was collusion. Jensen Huang and Alice Wong to work together to evade export controls and get chips to China. And they worked with Lutnick and Trump. It was a conspiracy. We don't know what happened here. And so putting him back in place is disastrous for this company. The best thing they could do is, as Bessent said, let's get a new CEO in here. Let's get a Dara Khosrowshahi type person in here, you know, and there's, you know, Brett Taylor's a good choice. I've heard that, you know, there's a bunch of them. There's a guy who ran ARM who looks like a good choice. There's a couple internal people, this guy named Ian Buck. There's a number of people. They cannot bring him back right now, especially now that Trump is backing him, and Trump is such a loser.
Be bad for him. Oh, be the whole — if he does this, what a toxic person he is.
Now, one of the bigger things is the bigger picture here. The Wall Street Journal, which was reporting all this — these chips suddenly appearing in China. Amazing reporting by the Journal and the New York Times, I have to say, and the Washington Post, too. The Wall Street Journal is reporting that in recent months, Jensen Huang was laying the groundwork for Nvidia to pull back on financing the AI industry. This is why I think Bessent and his folk — they were a bank. Jensen Huang was a banker. Last month at a conference in Berlin, Jensen signaled that Nvidia's days as an open checkbook were coming to an end. He reportedly told a group of cloud company executives, quote, "I don't even need you guys. I could just give all this capacity to Elon. Elon wants it." Interim CEO Colette Kress, who's also CFO, had been pushing back against these big deals which were sort of cooked up by Jensen's son-in-law. Like, it seems all so odd. You know, this is — they're going to pull back on these what Scott and I consider Ponzi schemes, and this guy had made himself indispensable in the most unfortunate of ways. So, what do you think's going to happen here?
Well, so kind of vendor financing is nothing new. This takes it to a new level because they're taking equity stakes. And what this just reminds her has echoes of is Sam Bankman-Fried, who was investing in anything trying to prop up the sector. And you could argue, I mean, to a certain extent these guys spending their money to try and, you know, fund the pioneer of innovation and spend the money on plant, property and equipment. I actually think it's a good thing, this massive capex, because if it doesn't work, okay, a lot of shareholders get hurt, but that money goes into the economy. So, it's like people get angry at these companies when they just do share buybacks, and now they're, you know, people are saying, "All right, maybe it's not sustainable." Fine. So, a bunch of investors get hurt. I like the fact that these guys, these hyperscalers are making huge capex. I think it's good for the economy. The last time this happened with Sam Bankman-Fried, kind of the interesting thing about Sam Bankman is that he's probably in prison because of — well, for a lot of reasons, but tactically his lawyers told him to declare bankruptcy. If he'd held on for another few months, Sam right now, because of some of the investments he made, would arguably be one of the most successful VCs in history. He owned a ton of Anthropic. The reason why I bought claims in FTX is because I saw in their bankruptcy filings they owned a bunch of shares in Anthropic. I personally think that two things can be true at the same time. I think this is such extraordinarily poor judgment. I think the technonarcissism and an attempt to normalize risking national defense because you are a quote-unquote tech innovator, this Jesus messiah-like complex — I think that's going to be quelled pretty fast. And then also, but at the same time, the underlying business model of Nvidia has not been threatened here. They still have a massive moat. It might be less than we thought because you can bet Chinese engineers, if they got the most advanced chips, are doing everything they can to reverse engineer these things. But I believe Nvidia — this is not financial advice, I'm just speculating — I think it's a buy right now. Nvidia, as a price-earnings multiple, is trading at the same valuation as a low-growth manufacturing stock, and it's growing like a venture. It's going 60% a year, but it's trading at the same multiple as P&G and Walmart. The thing that is so insulting, in my view, to Nvidia employees — they have outstanding people up and down this company. And even if they decided to follow Bessent's advice, and it's a decent view that if there's a lot of people say, you know, I'd rather just keep it to myself what happened there, right? If that's the culture there, they probably should go outside. I think that's a decent argument. I would probably try and find someone internally that could just keep running at the same pace. But okay, if they put together a list of the hundred most talented executives in the world, from, you know, from Brett Taylor to Tim Cook to Lisa, whoever it is, right? And they called them and said, "Do you want to play shortstop for the Yankees of the digital age?" 98 returned that call. They can get anyone.
Although it's messy. It's going to be messy because you got him. Although, can I just say at the time when Dara took over Uber, there was a lot of shadow of Travis and he kept sticking around making trouble, right? He kept doing it and it was very problematic. And I remember talking to Dara. I'm like, "How do you deal with him?" And he was like, "I'll just be nice to him and like pretend to be interested." Essentially, he's a very polite and close to the best person, but that's what it seemed like he was doing was he wasn't zeroing him out, but he just was going to run the place himself, and he did a great job doing it, right? And I think that — but he definitely removed him and his people out, like all the people went. All the Travis acolytes went. And it just was like the fact that this particular person is doing it really irks me because it's only about his own trauma from being hosed. And he put up this stupid thing on Twitter about like it's a scoping — people are trying to get — look, anyone who wants to know how crazy someone is, read that thing of like how to deal with scops against you, never taking an ounce of responsibility for his bad behavior and saying that the reason I'm out is because people were out to get me. Like if Jensen Huang, which I can't believe he would fall for this [__] — he's a little bit older, right? He should feel bad because of his family. Can't fall for this nonsense. And that's the issue, is that every single one of these people pushing this got hosed in some way or are about to get hosed in some way. Don't trust what they're saying at all. And that the sickness of Silicon Valley in thinking shareholders should decide everything has come to an end. And the voters, by the way, said it very clearly among the many things they said — affordability — they are sick of you people, and you are doubling down on the thing they hate about you, which is that you deserve every single break and nobody else does. That to me, that's a real problem. And then there's the national security implications. If you're a CEO taking this, there's usually going to be a lot of cleanup on aisle three on this. And it's very — it's as serious as a heart attack, as they say.
In 30 or 50 years, I don't think Jensen Huang will be remembered for AI or GPUs. I think he'll be remembered as the definition of a useful idiot.
He is now — he will now in history become the most famous useful idiot, surpassing the French official who fell in love with what he thought was a woman and was a man. That was the story behind the play M. Butterfly. He is now the definition. When they talk about in history and espionage cases, when they talk about useful idiots, he'll be case study number one.
Unless he knew, right? Unless they knew they were subverting these things. We need to find out, folks of Silicon Valley. Yeah. Allegedly.
The first thing I thought was maybe Jensen's too smart for this and our government's too smart. Maybe they knew she was a spy and he was feeding her false information. But that doesn't appear to be the case here. But this is the thing that is just so striking to me is that, I mean, what's going on is twofold. There's a group of people who want to be exonerated from the laws and norms around national defense in exchange for creating shareholder value. There's a messiah complex where we just get to play by a different set of rules. But at the same time, I just think as it gets unfurled, I mean, this — we use these chips now to simulate weapons for autonomous drones. This is how we gather our intelligence information and to distill what needs attention and what doesn't. This is bad.
We need to protect this stuff. We need this. You know, it's so funny that they just — the worst one of all was the person I think who engineered this wild west, which is David Sacks, who was the AI guru. You know what his reaction was? Let's investigate who leaked to the New York Times. That is his focus. Like literally, sir, like you lost the election because people hate you. You can't possibly try to distract people by focusing on the press who is doing its very best.
Or let's go after the Congress people calling for hearings.
Right? I mean, and by the way, it's a bunch of Republicans, too. So, anyway, we got to move on. This is just — if he comes back, it's —
Tech has completely lost the narrative if that happens. I have to say.
It's a group of people who are no longer invested in the well-being of America.
And we've had 43 million people serve in uniform. We've had one and a half million people die in uniform. Every month a household spends more on defense than they spend on their car, sometimes as much as groceries given how much we're spending. And you think, well, my taxes, that's not true. Well, your kids are going to pay for it because we have a $2 trillion deficit every year. And American citizens deserve to know that when someone compromises national security, puts people in harm's way, that there is consequences here. And the consequences shouldn't be that, oh, he's such a hero, we're going to bring him back in. That is to me, this is literally unthinkable. And just pragmatically, there is no way these board members, when they call their lawyer and say, "Well, what if we bring them back in?" They're like, "Oh my gosh, if this ends up being a quarter as bad as we think it might be, just get ready to raise your right arm. You're going to be one of the most famous board members in history for not good reasons."
Yep. Yep. And the Republicans are breaking on this one the right way. So is Bessent. And by the way, you're not going to like what the Democrats are going to bring you. Anyway, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, the FAA's national meltdown. Another incompetent situation.
Support for the show comes from Base 44. Every great business starts somewhere. Sometimes it starts in a spreadsheet, [music] a nice organized spreadsheet. But as the business grows, the spreadsheet gets messier. The workarounds multiply and the tool that once helped you run your business is actually making it harder. That's where Base 44 comes in. Base 44 is an AI platform that turns your ideal company setup into software you can actually use. From the first essential tools you need to get things off the ground to systems that run the entire operation, you can build it with Base 44. You can even customize the tools that you need, ditch the ones you don't, and keep building as your business grows. Whether it's a client portal, a dashboard, or a tool for managing your audience, or anything in between, Base 44 has you covered because your business shouldn't work around your software. Your software should work around your business. Go to base44.com/pivot for 30% off the builder plan for your first year. That's base44.com/pivot for 30% off your first year. Thanks to Base 44 sponsoring this episode.
Support for the show comes from Framer. When a new landing page turns into a pile of tickets and handoffs, Framer can help your team move faster. Teams can collaborate in real time, iterate on the same page, and publish instantly. Agents help you go beyond the vibe-coded site and that first draft look to bring you a production-ready site faster than ever. That's because agents and humans work in tandem. Agents bring speed and scale. People bring taste, judgment, and control. Agents and Framer work alongside teams to streamline collaboration on the same canvas, build custom code components, create and manage CMS content, optimize SEO settings, audit for issues, and ship everything all in one place. Bottom line, Framer is the AI website builder that helps creators, teams, and businesses ship production-ready sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. Prompt, inspect, edit, and publish in one place at a whole new pace. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a Framer specialist, or get started building for free today at framer.com/pivot for 30% off a Framer Pro annual plan. That's framer.com/pivot. Rules and restrictions may apply.
Scott, we're back. Air traffic is returning to normal after a rare nationwide FAA ground stop halted US flight departures for over four hours on Friday, leading to more than 9,000 cancellations and days of travel disruptions. Officials say the outage began during work to replace old copper wires with fiber optic cables. It seems — I don't believe them. The FAA's new $875 million AI-powered air traffic system was rolled out just three days before Friday's ground stop, though officials insist the two are unrelated. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy blamed underfunding by Congress and called for billions more to modernize the system. Trump waited until Sunday to publicly address the crisis, blaming the Biden administration. Huh, whatever. Let's listen to a clip how he explained the issue a little while ago.
Essentially, what you saw on Friday was very, very old equipment that had a heart attack.
Oh my god, he's such a [__]. Meanwhile, a separate Microsoft outage disrupted Outlook, Teams, and Copilot worldwide for 36 hours for users last week. This is critical infrastructure, and there's lots going on here. I mean, first of all, Trump — they authorized $12.5 billion. Sean Duffy decided to go on a tour of the United States with his family for a reality show instead. But they had 12 billion dollars. He spent just a billion of it and he wanted 50 million more. He did correctly blame both Democrats and Republicans for this, and at the same time wouldn't take any responsibility himself. So just thoughts on this whole thing and the critical infrastructure situation.
Yeah, there was a lot of conspiracy theories around the timing and maybe it was an attack and they're hiding the attack because they don't want to cause chaos. I actually think most likely it is what they say it is and that is —
You know, something — a piece of equipment broke. They modeled out potential danger and they decided to shut it down. What this reflects is a bipartisan issue and it's a bipartisan failure, and that is generally speaking our laws and our budget, which is a reflection of our values. Our values are that we want to create a superclass of billionaires and that comes at the expense and has come at the expense, in my view, of the middle class. It's not that the middle class has done that poorly the last 30 years, but relative to how the economy has done the last 30 years, they have not kept pace. And one of the ways you do that, and when it reflects those values, is investments in infrastructure are investments in the middle class. The rich have their own infrastructure. They have their own airports, their own schools, their own hospitals. Europe — they make life better for the Spanish because they give them high-speed trains so they can see their friends. They make it such that they can live 30 minutes outside of the city in an affordable home with a high-speed rail network that runs quickly, and so they can spend more time with their family. In addition, infrastructure spending usually creates what are largely middle-class, shovel-ready and also predominantly male jobs. When we've decided we have underinvested in our infrastructure for 30 or 40 years, because the general viewpoint from American politicians has been, I know we can cut taxes and go to war. How are we going to do that with deficits? By underinvesting in our infrastructure, because the people who benefit from good infrastructure aren't the ones funding campaigns or putting $400 million into Senate campaigns in Texas. So, a lack of infrastructure investment, which I believe the secretaries here has been a bipartisan issue, is simply a decision to not reinvest in the middle class. And we have not. We have been underinvesting in our infrastructure for decades. Just go to Europe and go to the parks. I know it's —
Get on the subway, get on trains,
And you're going to see —
New. It's fresh. As non-innovative as they are,
There's a lot of happy people going to their less expensive house because they can get there in 17 minutes and the train is really nice. It's just — or the bridges don't break down.
I was on Amtrak the other day and I thought, Jesus Christ, we can't afford better trains. Like this is insane. Like even just riding it. But you know, I flew here to San Francisco and I did not get caught and was lucky. But like a lot of people I know just got — like the time and money spent by average citizens being sucked out of the economy. The amount of time — both things, the Microsoft outage, everything was so astonishing. The productive value of US citizens was brought down by this, and not just having to hang out in an airport with a toddler all night long kind of thing, which sucks, but it's this idea that our time is not valuable and their time is. And I do think their messaging was terrible. I thought him and Markwayne Mullin — I mean, dumb and dumber essentially. The messaging was terrible. It blamed you. It put all the onus on the poor airlines and also people like travelers, and it's just they just don't care. And that was the message, is like, we don't care. And this blame game —
and instantly blaming Biden or someone else was like, "Just do your [__] job, Sean." Like, and by the way, you're barely competent to do so, essentially. And I feel more unsafe with people like you. And even when there's people that were competent, like a Pete Buttigieg, he didn't do enough, right? Like it's hard for competent people to fix this stuff, and incompetent people in these critical infrastructure jobs feels very troubling, as anyone who travels as much as I do. But just to piss off everybody, this is bipartisan, and there's bipartisan responsibility. The far right says we don't want to invest in infrastructure. We want to cut taxes on corporations and the wealthy. The far left has engaged in so much special interest group regulatory capture that every mile of subway in New York costs 12 times what it costs to build in France, the most unioned-up nation in the world. Democrats make it so expensive and special interest groups to build infrastructure that we can't afford it. And the Republicans don't want to spend the money because they want tax cuts and wars.
So this really is, there's a lot of blame to go around here.
But if you, the whole point of infrastructure is we love our middle class. We want you to be... I took the RTD to the beach when I was a kid. This should be an election issue for whoever is running on the 'I'm going to make everything work' like a mom-and-dad thing, right? I'm going to make it work. I'm going to fill your potholes. That should be the... We're going to do pothole filling now. We're going to be doing new trains. We're going to be doing this. And I know the Democrats have done themselves. The whole high-speed transit thing in California is at the foot of the Democrats. Why they haven't been able to get that through, and other lobbyists who don't want it. I mean, there's always that, but it's really something they got to focus on.
Speaking of people who have changed their minds, by the way, because everyone is very aware and everyone gets affected by travel, so everybody knows what the problem is. Joe Rogan is speaking out about the Republicans' massive midterm loss, saying Trump had indeed lost the podcast bros, as David Sacks recently put it, but the problem went way beyond that. Let's listen.
They didn't just lose the podcast bros, they lost most of the country. Like when you get into a war that no one wants to be in, when you got militarized police in the streets wearing masks and no American citizens... They did some good things. They closed the border and then crime dropped significantly. Those are good things. It's not a good thing to have the [__] border wide open where anyone, including terrorists, can come in. Also, not a good thing to snatch people out of their [__] taco stand that have been in the country for 20 years and are nice, good people that are loved by the community, but they just don't have the right paperwork.
I love when a penny drops at someone who doesn't have very many pennies in his brain. He also questions the role that he and his fellow podcasters have played in politics in recent years, saying, quote, 'It's a sickness of our society that people take our opinions so importantly.' I would agree, Joe, that is absolutely true. The realization is really quite something. What happens here? Because I don't think these people will have the same influence going forward. I think they had their moment in the sun. I doubt they'll ever regain it. He also was saying some things that aren't accurate. The crime has been dropping significantly for a long time, and very, very few of the people that they arrested were actual criminals. But one terrorist in is bad, it doesn't matter, one is bad. So any thoughts on where the manosphere goes now, or if it exists anymore in the same way?