Both sides of the aisle, red and blue, Republican and Democrat. Lots of words in politics, but right now voters are demanding results: a lower cost of living, an education plan, answers on data centers, better health care, improved infrastructure. Two candidates with very different ideas to accomplish all of that, but just one will be the next governor of Michigan. Forget the attack ads and the talking points. Tonight, the candidates are face to face. Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson and Congressman John James here to debate the issues. Who will earn your trust and win your vote? Live from the WDIV studios in Detroit, it's Decision 2026, the Michigan Gubernatorial Debate. Now, here is your moderator for the evening, WDIV anchor and host of Flashpoint, Jason Colthorp.
Good evening, everybody, from our WDIV studios here in downtown Detroit. And welcome to those of you watching all over the state of Michigan tonight as we hear from the two major candidates on your ballot for governor. With us tonight: Republican nominee for governor, U.S. Representative for Michigan's 10th Congressional District, John James, and the Democratic nominee for governor, Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson. They know the rules for tonight, but for our viewers, it'll go this way: I'm going to ask a question, they'll each get one minute to answer, and then both get a 30-second rebuttal. I may also jump in with some quick follow-up questions throughout the way. They each get a 90-second opening and closing statement. And by random draw, Congressman, you get to go first tonight.
Thanks, Jason. I'm John James. I'm running to be governor because I hate politics, but I love the state of Michigan. I love you. I'm brokenhearted that our children have to leave to find better opportunities from the state that my parents came to, from the Jim Crow South, for those opportunities. There are areas of Michigan that look worse than the combat zone I flew in in Iraq. And that's wrong. We must demand better. We have to demand change. I'm a military leader who's brought people together from different backgrounds and different political parties together to accomplish tough missions. That is the experience we need in a governor. I'm a business leader who's signed the front and the back of a check, who's had to deal with the red tape that's been created in Lansing. We need that in a governor. And I'm also a congressman who's already delivered for you as the 10th Congressional District's representative, and I will deliver as your governor. Right now we're 42nd out of 50 in infrastructure, 43rd out of 50 in economy, 45th out of 50 in education, 46th overall. That means that 45 states are doing better than Michigan because of failures in Lansing over the past eight years. We must demand better. We must have excellent schools — I have a plan to bring that. Safer streets — I have a plan to bring that. Accountable government — I have a plan to bring that. Healthy families — I have a plan to bring that. Accountable and affordable Michigan — I have a plan to bring that. Experience matters, and having somebody who has experience where it matters, proven, is exactly what we need in our next governor. I'm excited for the opportunity to be here today, and I'm excited to earn your support. Thank you.
Well, thanks for having us tonight. My name's Jocelyn Benson, and our campaign is about three things: cost down, wages up, and ending corruption. Because as governor, I will work for you — not the highest bidder, not Donald Trump. You. I will fight for the veteran who deserves access to the health care benefits they've earned, for the teachers who deserve better pay and more respect, for our kids whose futures depend on what we do today. I know how important that is, as a mom of a 10-year-old little boy that I'm raising right here in Detroit, as a wife of a combat veteran, and as the daughter of special education teachers who taught me that the power of the people must always be greater than the people in power. I, as Secretary of State, have transformed how our office works, saving you time, saving you money, and making your life easier. And as a leader, I have been unafraid to stand up to bullies, including standing up to anyone, anytime, anywhere who would try to interfere with your rights, your freedoms, your privacy, and your vote. In sharp contrast, my opponent is only in this for himself. In just four short years in Congress, he's become a multimillionaire, buying stocks in companies that he regulates while raising our health care premiums, supporting a reckless war in Iran that's driving up our gas prices, as well as tariffs that have cost Michiganders more than any other state. He's not serving the people of Michigan. He's profiting off of you. But I want you to know that even if it means sheltering in my home here in Detroit while people with guns assemble on our front lawn because of lies my opponent and others have spread, I will always fight for you. I've done that as Secretary of State, and I'm ready to do it as your governor.
All right, let's get to the questions. The first one's on affordability. For a lot of Michiganders, the biggest worry is the cost of everyday life — housing, groceries, gas — and that's gotten even worse with news this week that inflation is up to 3.7%, the biggest jump since May. Governors, we know, don't set the prices. So, give us one specific thing you'd do in your first year that would actually lower the cost of living. Congressman, you have one minute.
Energy. There's a reason why Indiana and Ohio are eating our lunch — not my words, but Secretary Benson's. We have some of the highest utility rates in the entire Midwest because of the failed policies of the people in power in Lansing, the Democrats. They put their Green New Deal Public Act 235 through, and they've jacked up our rates. And as a result, in the past couple of weeks, both DTE and Consumers have gone in for rate increases at your expense. We're going to roll back those harmful regulations to lower our energy costs to get back on par. There's no reason that Indiana and Ohio should have double-digit lower energy rates than us, and states like Missouri and Kansas should have 50% lower than us. That makes everything more expensive, from gas to groceries. And she won't do that. She won't hold her climate activist friends accountable for the unaffordability. She's been there for eight years, and she has only started mentioning this, where I actually have voted and pushed forward our Ratepayer Protection Act that will keep your rates low, and I will continue to keep your rates low as governor.
Secretary, one thing you would do in your first year to lower the cost of living.
Well, you know, health care is a defining issue in this race, and it's not lost on me as I talk to my neighbors, who have — including my neighbor Gwen, who shared with me the other day she has stage four cancer, and every month she has to look at her bills and decide whether to cover her chemotherapy bill or her electricity bill. She is faced with that impossible choice because my opponent went to Washington and voted three times to raise health care premiums on the people of Michigan. That is why we have to work to ensure that we have a plan, as I do, to lower the cost of health care in the state. I'll reform DHS to make it as seamless as possible for you to access your health care benefits, drive down medicine costs, ensure we're taking on insurance companies that are not covering your needs, and passing tax credits to support long-term care. I also have a plan to reduce the cost of energy by banning profit-driven rate hikes and investing in clean energy infrastructure and modernizing our grid, which is the data-driven, long-term way to actually reduce the cost of energy. There's two people on the stage tonight: one who went to Washington to raise your health care costs, and the person — myself — who has an affordability plan to lower them. And you can go to jocelynbenson.com to read the entire affordability plan in detail.
Congressman, you have 30 seconds for a rebuttal.
Yeah, that's real cute, but it doesn't pass muster. The fact that I have led the Patients Deserve Price Tag Act to actually increase transparency, increase accountability to lower the cost of health care, holding the insurance companies, the pharmacy benefit managers, and the hospitals accountable for the sick care cartels that are making it worse. But Secretary Benson's taken thousands of dollars from the people who are running Blue Cross Blue Shield, who just got popped for — by the AG — for actually running monopolistic practices in the state driving the cost of your health care up. I've been protecting your health care, and she hasn't.
Yeah. I mean, my opponent's record speaks for itself, as does mine. He went to Washington and not once, not twice, but three times voted to raise your health care premiums. He supported a bill that will try to kick people off health care. It's the basic purpose behind the big beautiful bill — is to make it more difficult for you to get access to the health care benefits that you're entitled to under the law. My plan will actually ensure that we are working with you to drive down the cost of health care and invest in clean energy structures that will reduce the cost of energy. We'll also invest in child care affordability and housing affordability, all of which we need to do to drive down costs for all Michiganders.
Well, let's drill down on one of those other costs — gas prices. And Michigan's average is often running above the national average. What would you do to bring relief to the pump? Secretary, one minute.
Well, you know, we have to recognize why we're in this mess. It's because of a reckless war in Iran that my opponent has voted six times, including just a few weeks ago, to support. We have no exit strategy, but what we do know is that our gas prices are going up exponentially, especially here in Michigan, as a result of that war. That's why I was the first person in this race to take the stage and call on my opponent and others in Washington to end the federal gas tax to ensure we're doing everything we can to drive down the cost and fix the mess that my opponent and others in Washington who support this reckless war have created. I'm also open to reducing our gas tax here in Michigan, and we'll work with our leaders in Lansing to ensure we're doing everything we can and using every tool in our toolbox to move towards energy independence so that we can ensure that we are protecting Michigan from the reckless economic decisions that are happening at the federal level, including a war in Iran that is directly responsible for increasing the cost of gas close to $5 a gallon here in the state.
For her to insinuate me, a combat veteran who's actually been to war, is supporting war — I hate war. I have called for this war to be over. Weeks ago, weeks ago, I've called for this war to be over. We must use every diplomatic and economic resource at our disposal to make sure Iran does not have nukes and we keep us safe. But she's distracting from the fact that she is fighting for the gas tax like I fought for our freedom. I've actually called for the state and the federal gas tax to be repealed. And there's a reason that Indiana and Ohio are eating our lunch — because they have lower gas tax. They repealed — they gave a suspension of their gas tax. I support suspending the gas tax. I would sign it immediately. But she told her running mate not to even take a vote on it. We would have lowered the gas tax for everyone, and right now gas would be in the threes. It's in the threes in Indiana. It's in the threes in Ohio. And you are paying more at the pump literally because your pain is her plan. She wants to run against Donald Trump, and she hates him so much that she's willing for you to pay for it at the pump. We need to focus on what it's going to take to lower energy costs, and supporting the repeal of gas tax is it.
What I hate and what I have no patience for are politicians who are all talk and no action. And that is exactly what my opponent represents. For him to say what he just said when he's voted six times, six separate occasions, including just a few weeks ago, to continue this war in Iran that is driving up gas prices — tells you everything you know about where he truly stands. So, he can throw around all the mud he wants. The reality is this: I was the first person in this race to call for a suspension of the federal gas tax, something he can directly do something about and has not done a thing about. That's the difference in this race. I have a plan to drive down the cost of living in Michigan. You can read all about it at jocelynbenson.com. His work has actually raised taxes on the people of Michigan, and you can read about that at johnjamestax.com.
Well, when you call the truth mud, you know exactly what kind of people you're dealing with. The fact of the matter is I have called for a repeal of both the state gas tax and the federal gas tax. And she does not support a state gas tax repeal. She is keeping 52 cents per gallon away from you. I call that the Jocelyn Benson tax. She's been in Lansing for eight years and has done nothing to lower your energy rates. But right now that she wants your vote, she's going to tell you whatever she wants. Again, I support lowering the tax on gas to make life more affordable for you. And she just doesn't. She hasn't even answered that.
I have a follow-up. Hang on. How would you pay for the revenue that's lost if you suspend the state gas tax? That goes directly to improving roads.
Great question. MEDC has $550 million that's sitting there. That's your money. That's not Lansing's money. She's concerned about blowing a hole in Lansing's budget. I'm concerned about blowing a hole in your budget because of her failures in Lansing. We need to make sure that economic development goes to you and not to the lawyers and lobbyists in Lansing. That is your money. So, it's appropriated. It is unresourced. It's not dedicated to anything. That money should go directly back to people for a suspension of the gas tax.
Secretary, let me ask you quick. You say you're open to the gas tax repeal. How serious is that?
Yeah, I think we need to look at all options for reducing costs for the people of Michigan, including suspending the federal gas tax. Which, just to be clear, I'm the Secretary of State of Michigan — I don't have a vote on the state tax. But he, as a congressman in the United States Congress, could actually go and work to eliminate the federal gas tax. He's all words and no action, and that's the difference between he and I. I actually have a plan to drive down costs for the people of Michigan, including fixing the mess that he and so many other folks at the federal government have created. All he has is words and empty promises to distract us from the fact that he's voted to put us into a war in Iran that has actually driven up these prices and then hasn't done anything to get us out of it.
Let me ask you about SNAP benefits, because as of October 1st, Michigan is now paying 70–75% of the cost of running SNAP, which is up from 50%. The state's also going to have to pay more for the benefits. About one in eight Michiganders live in poverty. So, I want to ask you: if the federal food help shrinks, what are you prepared to do for the families who depend on it? Congressman.
Well, first of all, one in eight Michigan families live in poverty when you've had one party in charge of Lansing for eight years. You have to ask yourself why we're in this position and why we continue voting for people who leave us in this position. I would absolutely make sure that we address the fact that Michigan is spending 50% more than we spent during Rick Snyder's administration and $20 billion per year more than we spent during the height of the pandemic. That's your money. It's being wasted. We have to protect SNAP for those it was meant for. And also, as governor, I would opt in and I would opt into waivers to protect people in opportunity zones, protect people in areas that have high unemployment, and protect people in areas that desperately need it, because these are benefits that are required for our people. These are benefits that should not go for able-bodied adults without dependents who are choosing not to work, and it certainly should not go to illegals. We need to get rid of the fraud in our system and use our money more wisely to take care of people who need SNAP.
So, first, Republicans run the state House of Representatives. If my opponent spent more time in Michigan, he would know that. But secondly, I want to tell you a story. So, I'm a military spouse, and I vividly remember one of the first days on base when I sat down with another military spouse, and she turned to me and explained to me where you could get your food assistance. In that moment, I realized that so many people who are actually receiving SNAP benefits are the very military families who are serving every day and putting their lives on the line to protect this country. So to me, this fight is personal. Ensuring that food is affordable for everyone in our state is necessary, and the next governor has the moral responsibility to make sure that's happened. That's why I've actually spoken with our farmers, corn growers, and others who are supporting this campaign to say, 'How can we ensure a supply chain of food that is grown right here in Michigan?' We have the second most diverse agricultural economy in the nation. That food that is grown here can be used to reduce the cost of food here in Michigan and enable more people to have access to food without having to break the bank. So, I've got a plan to ensure food is affordable while we're also not cutting necessary SNAP benefits that support so many families, including military families like myself.
Can I have a 30-second rebuttal, if you like?
Yeah, sure. I actually voted for SNAP and passed it through Congress. This is something that's extremely important, and not just that, but making sure that we have a higher quality of food, working with our farmers to make sure that we are getting our children better food, higher quality of food in schools, making sure that we have food that we understand is not making us sick. We need to make sure that we are taking care of people and making prevention in the health care system so that we are not having some of these diseases that are caused by harmful foods. So, we must support SNAP, and I will as governor.
Congressman, I think you need to review your voting record because it just does not match the words that you just shared. You voted for bills to cut SNAP benefits and have left us here in Michigan to try to pick up the pieces. But as governor, I'll be ready to pick up those pieces and ensure we're reforming the Department of Health and Human Services to use the data we have to make it as seamless as possible for you to get access to the health care benefits and the SNAP benefits that you're entitled to under the law. As the next governor of Michigan, I know how important that is, as a parent in the state, as I've talked to families trying to make ends meet, and it will be a priority for me to make sure you can afford your food, you can afford your groceries, you can afford everything else in the state.
You need a rebuttal quickly.
I voted for the farm bill, which is where SNAP is. I voted for that. This is the reason we have SNAP. I will continue to protect SNAP for our people.
All right, I'm going to move on to data centers here. When it comes to those, you have each been the target of political attacks. After doing a little fact-checking, we're left with: Congressman, your campaigns have gotten more than $100,000 in donations from data center developers, and you've said yourself that you have some investments in data center companies. Secretary Benson, your husband is a senior VP for the company trying to build the massive data center in Saline Township and even lobbied for it in front of the township board. Yes, you each have talked about a one-year moratorium on data centers, but my question is: why should voters trust either of you to make the decisions on data centers that are in their best interests rather than the best interests of the companies behind them? Secretary.
Well, thank you for the opportunity to set the record straight here. My family has not profited from data centers. We've disclosed our personal finances, and you can see that for yourself at michigan.gov/sos. That's why transparency to me is so important, and also why supporting a moratorium that will put a pause on new data center development until we have guardrails in place to protect our water, to protect our energy costs, to protect our noise, and to above all ensure we're protecting local voices. And that's in sharp contrast to my opponent, who voted four times — not him, he voted, not his spouse — he voted four times to stop local citizens from having a voice in whether data centers could come to your town. And he, not his spouse, he also has bought stock in data center companies and got millions from it. And then he, not his spouse, he passed tax breaks to protect those companies. That's the sharp contrast in this race. I have a plan to ensure that your voices are protected and heard in whether a data center can come to your town. He's voted against that right that you should have.
She's put $370,000 into her pocket. She omitted that in 2025. She's throwing mud to obscure the fact that she's dirty as sin on this. These are the facts. If you want to learn more, go to datacenterdarlings.com to see exactly how deep she is into this. The fact of the matter is she and her husband bulldozed the will of the people of Saline to carpet over the productive green farmland against her commitment. Of course, she's going to come up with a moratorium after they've already made out with $370,000 on these deals in back rooms. Her running mate actually passed Public Act 233 that bulldozes over local control, and frankly, she signed an NDA so you wouldn't know any details about it. Again, she's been called out on it, and she's been there eight years, and she's just now talking about this. Again, my five-part moratorium is: no new data centers until we have a plan to protect our communities. That means local control, our electricity bills can't go up, we need to protect our water, prevent pollution, and prioritize blighted and brownfields over productive green farmland.
Only one person on this stage tonight actually voted themselves to block the ability for local voices to have a say in whether data centers can come to their town, and that's my opponent. He did it four times. Only one person on the stage has actually profited from data center companies, and that is my opponent. He has bought stocks and made millions of dollars in data center companies while he's supposed to be regulating them, and then turned around and gave them tax breaks. That's the difference in this race. I'm committed to protecting your voice and your ability to determine what, if any, company should come to your community. My opponent has voted against protecting that.
Yeah, she can spew lies all she wants to, but the fact of the matter is her party's been in power. They've given tax credits to these billion-dollar companies. She and her husband have been employed by billionaires, bought off, and she now wants to insinuate that somehow campaign donations are tantamount to her putting $370,000 in her personal bank account. The fact of the matter is that they've bulldozed over the will of the people, and we must hold her accountable for continuing to tell stories and yarns about this that have been widely reported. Go to datacenterdarlings.com.
Well, the original question was about trust. Let me just quickly follow up. I'll start with you, Secretary. After your moratoriums are over, what's the plan? It's anything goes, or what?
No, we have to put guardrails in place to protect local voices. We have to ensure that our water is not being used or abused by any company that wants to come to Michigan, let alone a data center company. And we also have to ensure that we are requiring data center companies to pay their own way and shoulder the burden of any energy usage they require and have noise abatement plans in place. Those are just some of the guardrails we need to put in place, while also implementing community benefits agreements that are transparent and enforceable to protect your voice in this process.
Congressman, after your moratorium, what?
That's the point. She's going to bulldoze your will after this so-called moratorium is over. Frankly, my moratorium is: the locals come before Lansing. If you want a data center, fine. If you don't want a data center, fine. But it should be up to you and not the powerful people in Lansing determining this. Your rights will be protected by your governor when I'm elected. Ultimately, this is not up for anybody to decide but your community. If you want this, great. If you don't, great. I will be in your corner, and I will always put you first.
All right, let's talk education. Michigan students, as many of us know, trail much of the country in reading and math. What has the state gotten wrong over the last decade? And what would you do that hasn't been tried yet? Congressman, one minute.
Education is a basic civil right. I believe that we have to have successful public schools, private schools, charter, homeschool — because when you give parents a choice, you give children a chance. Ultimately, the status quo is not working. Michigan is 44th in fourth-grade literacy, 45th overall. My opponent wants to keep the status quo. We talk about the Mississippi miracle. This is from a state that my parents both came to from Mississippi for a better chance. We have to make sure that we change. We have to have mastery for our children before they get to fourth grade, and we need to give them the opportunities before they get to fourth grade to get there, so we're not punishing them, and so they have a skill by the time they leave high school because they've started skilled trades in middle school. We also need accountability — simple A through F — so our parents know exactly what's going on with their schools, and so we can help and train and pay our teachers what they deserve. And finally, we have to get rid of this overhead. 50% of the dollars that we're spending on our declining school-age population, as we're paying more administrators, are not going to classrooms, not going to kids, not going to teachers. We need to change that.
Well, you know, as a mom of a 10-year-old little boy and the daughter of special education teachers, I will take on this issue and treat it with the urgency it requires, because I know every day we don't solve this issue is a day we do not get back for our young people. And you know how to finally reform our public education system and make it, as I hope to do, one of the best states in the nation for public schools? Put a teacher, a former teacher as I am, in the governor's office, and I'm ready to do the job and get things done. In fact, I've released a five-pillar education plan that's rooted in data and best practices and what's worked in other states to turn things around, to ensure our kids are college or career ready when they graduate, with the Michigan Education Guarantee to better pay our educators and ensure they have the wraparound support they need to do the jobs they signed up to do, and to invest in early childhood education so that from zero to age six, our kids are getting prepared to succeed in K through 12. We're also going to do away with the one-size-fits-all funding model and ensure we have a weighted, equitable model to meet the unique needs of every school. You can read our whole plan at jocelynbenson.com. My goal at the end of my first term is for people to be talking about the Michigan miracle and how we've transformed our public schools, as opposed to the Mississippi miracle and everything else.
As you take your rebuttals, let me also ask: do you favor more spending on students and teachers, or accountability, or both?
We need to first look at accountability and make sure the money that we're already spending on the system is used well. We're paying 10,000 on average per pupil, and we have declining performance while our spending is increasing. We need to spend our money more wisely. Right now we have somebody who's running, and when she started at Wayne State she was bragging about it being 50th, and when she left it was 105th. Right now, because of the failed education system while she's been in Lansing, our number one export is our children. We must be focusing on getting skilled trades, literacy, basics, and not make our classrooms a battleground for culture wars.
Yeah, I think my opponent's talking about Wayne State Law School, an educational institution right here in Detroit. When I took over, it was ranked in the fourth tier. Now it's in the top 50 nationwide, and I'm really proud of what we did there. But in addition to that, I believe that funding in this state needs to be efficient, equitable, transparent, and accountable. And you know, when you talk about trust, the trust has to come to who can actually do this job. I have actually run and turned around educational institutions. My opponent — he's taken close to $10 million from the DeVos family. What's their claim to fame? Paying politicians to promote private education and defund public schools. So, I'm the only one on the stage you can trust to actually transform our public schools, and I've got a plan to do it.
Education is important. I want to ask a very quick follow-up. You don't need the full 30 seconds, but when you talk about consequences and accountability, should that be for schools that aren't getting the job done, or students who aren't able to pass their grade yet?
The accountability has to start from the top, which is why I'm going to be working on a constitutional amendment to have the Michigan State Board of Education, the state superintendent, report to the governor, and then the governor report to you. With me, the buck stops here. With her, it's a deer in headlights. She absolutely will change nothing. She will keep the status quo, and we will remain 45th out of 50 or worse.
I think your plan, it sounds like, is to have education run by the DeVos family, not by the people of Michigan. But my plan is actually comprehensive and data-driven that will transform our public schools and ensure that we are investing in accountability for our schools and for our parents and for everyone. I mean, we all have a responsibility, every single one of us — teachers, parents, students — and at the state level, to ensure our public schools are among the best in the nation. I'm ready to take us there. It will be my top priority as governor because we don't grow our economy without it, and I'm ready to get the job done.