One week from tonight, the voters of Iowa will decide who will be the next governor. We're going to be hearing from the two candidates asking for your vote. I'm Beth Malicki with KCRG-TV9 alongside Aaron Murphy with the Gazette, and we will be co-moderating tonight's debate between Democrat Rob Sand and Republican Zach Lahn. We also want to extend our gratitude to the College Community School District in Cedar Rapids for hosting tonight's debate in this auditorium right here at Prairie High School.
Tonight's debate will be 90 minutes with one three-minute commercial break. We will begin with a one-minute opening statement from each candidate. A random drawing moments ago determined that Rob Sand will go first. So now to Rob Sand for your one-minute opening statement.
Sure. Thank you, Beth. Thank you, Aaron. Thank you, Zach. Folks, our political system too often feels like two private clubs beating up on each other. There's a lot of people in leadership of both the Democratic and the Republican parties who are more interested in beating each other than they are in solving the problems that ordinary people face. And so, we get a lot of lies and demonization because they know if they're the lesser of two evils, they can make us feel trapped into voting for them. I'm sick and tired of that. I've been going after public corruption for 15 years in Iowa. Seven years as the chief public corruption prosecutor, two terms as your state auditor. Both of those jobs, we went after the facts and we went after accountability for people in positions of trust and power. And too often we are simply seeing them not be focused on actually addressing the issues that we face. For example, right now in Iowa, we have a cancer crisis, a crisis of high costs, and a crisis of corruption. Our public school system is now in the bottom half. But the big priority as we began my second term in the state auditor's office was to make it harder for us to find your misspent tax dollars. I think it's time for change. I think it's time for real reform. And I'd love to have your vote for governor.
Thank you, Rob, for being here. Thank you, the moderators, for hosting. My name is Zach Lahn. This is my first time running for office. I've never been a politician. I've never been elected. You know, first I just want to say this experience has been one that I'll never forget. It's been an honor to meet with the voters across the state, to travel to all the counties, to meet with all the people at diners and at town halls. You know, I got in this race because I see what you see. I see that we're losing our kids faster than 46 other states. I see that family farms are dying off. We've lost 10,000 in the past 20 years. I see public education, which was once number one in the nation when I was a kid in northwest Iowa, is now in the bottom half, and we have the fastest rate of new cancer anywhere in the country. I think a lot of times you're going to hear people talk about what's at stake, and no doubt there is a lot at stake. But I also believe that we have a tremendous amount of opportunity in the state. Opportunity to make Iowa the best place to raise a family, to build a farm, to start a business, and to pass something down to the next generation. I got in this race to solve those problems and advocate for you. And I'd be honored to have your support.
These questions are not timed for each of the candidates. We just hope that we can have a spirited conversation and keep things moving forward while also going a little bit deeper on the questions because we do have a full 90 minutes for this debate. Zach Lahn, if I could please direct the first question to you. Should schools that receive public funding through the ESA program, should they have to accept all students who come to them so long as they have the room, even those who have special needs, such as what public schools do today?
Hey, thank you for the question. I think, you know, one of the biggest issues I've been discussing on this campaign has been education. And my belief is that the educational savings accounts are a foundational freedom. Parents should have more say over where their kids go to school and more say over where their tax dollars are spent. I spend the most amount of time talking about our public schools because I believe the governor has to be the number one advocate for public schools in the state. I've talked about the situation we're in. Since 1992, when I was in elementary school, we have increased per-pupil spending by 50% inflation-adjusted and dropped 27 points. I think there's amazing things we can do in our public schools through innovation as well as through cultural changes where we understand that teachers are there to teach and not be behavioral therapists.
But I think in my experience starting and opening schools for nearly a decade, you learn about the different types of schools that are out there. And to answer the question, I really believe that the best model is to have many different options for children. Not every school is the best fit for every child. You can see that as you travel the country and visit these schools. Some schools are schools that allow children to have more agency, you know, less adult intervention to have them set more goals on their own. Other schools are schools that you have children that need more one-on-one help. And I believe that when we're talking about private schools, we're talking about education savings accounts. I believe we're giving parents the option to find the school that fits their child the best. And if you put these restrictions on schools, many of them, especially the smallest ones, will be burdened to a great degree, a degree that most people don't understand unless you've been in this seeing what's going on. But there's also great schools out there, private schools that also serve students with greater needs. And I believe we should have those in the state as well. I believe that educational choice is paramount and foundational and parents should have more choice where their kids go to school, more say over where their tax dollars are spent. But I also believe that our public schools have to be number one in the nation. Again, that's my biggest ad, that's what I'll fight for the most as governor.
Rob Sand, doesn't enrollment in Iowa's education savings account program indicate a strong desire for that program? And so why constrain it by implementing income restrictions as you've proposed?
Well, so the program has no income restrictions. You're right. It started that way in year one and year two. You were restricted. If you were incredibly high income, good for you, but you didn't get school vouchers. Right now, we have a $1.3 billion budget deficit. Went down a little bit this year. It's still over a billion dollars. For reference, our entire state budget every single year is about nine billion. That is a big hole. We are putting hundreds of millions of dollars every single year into the pockets of people who have plenty of money, good for them, and are already going to send their kids to private school. Fine by me. But your tax dollars don't need to go pay for that. It doesn't make sense, especially when we have that budget deficit. I think there's a number of reforms that we should be making into the school vouchers program. One of them is we should put those income limits back on because we have this massive budget deficit. Another one is yes, private schools that are taking public money should have to take whichever students say they want to attend there. That fact that they don't have to right now exposes the gulf between the rhetoric around this program and what it actually does. Because right now, private schools can pick and choose which students can come in the front door. Public schools don't do that. So Beth, in your original question, you said, should they continue to take students until they're full? But you know, public schools don't get to say sorry that we're full and you can't come here. I think it's a pretty simple rule. If we're going to have school choice, then private schools have to allow public students that are coming in with public money to come in and to be a part of that school. That's what the rhetoric around school choice means. Here's the other couple of changes that we need to make. They need to have audits. Right now, they're not required to have audits. And they need to have rules for how that money gets spent. Right now, private schools only have one thing they can't spend our tax dollars on. They can't pay a rebate to a parent. Now, that's a good rule, but there's plenty of other things I'm sure we can all agree that they shouldn't spend our money on. I think this is simple common sense stuff. Same things that would get you in trouble as a public school should get you in trouble as a private school. If you're taking public money, if you don't want to abide by those rules, then you can continue to not take public money.
One quick follow for each of you on that. Rob Sand, so public schools that take special needs students receive extra weighted funding for those students. If you're going to require private schools to also take those students, would they also receive that funding?
Okay. And Zach Lahn, to Mr. Sand's point, why should taxpayers subsidize scholarships for families that already were able to afford private school?
Well, the families where the tax dollars are coming from is also from the families that can afford it. And so, look, this is, I've said this from the beginning, this is not a welfare program. This is an opportunity fund for Iowa's kids. I believe that, you know, the wrong answer when your public school system goes from number one to number 27, the wrong answer is to delete your competition or make it harder for kids to go to other schools. I think that there's no such thing as government money. There's the people's money. This is their money. And so my belief is that there are reforms we can make to this education savings account program. And I believe actually I agree with my opponent on some of this. You know, I think better auditing, I think third-party auditing is where it should go. You know, I think personally I believe that there's so much political rhetoric around this that we want to take this out of politics. You know, publicly traded companies have third-party auditors audit their books. I think we could do something very similar which allows these schools to still have their privacy but make sure that the funds are being spent properly. I think that's something that's common sense. I think private schools would agree with this. They would agree to say, 'Hey, we want to make sure that everything's up to snuff,' and they would be happy to do that. But I don't believe that the answer is to say that every single school, however you're set up, needs to accept every single type of student because other students that come into these schools, it might not be the right fit for them. You know, I've traveled the country visiting private schools. I spent two years visiting schools across the world. And you see schools that are set up for specific students and that wouldn't fit other students the best. And these smaller schools, that's where the largest burden would be created because there is a tremendous amount that goes into creating these programs that our public schools do have right now. And that is why they have a higher dollar figure attached to it. But I would just say that, you know, some of the schools that allow more agency for children that have less adult intervention, you might need the opposite thing for a child that needs more. And that's the beauty of having school choice is you have the best models rising to the top. But one thing we didn't talk about with this, and I'll just end with this, is that I think through innovation and education in our public schools is where we can really make huge strides by creating school choice within our public schools. You know, the state board of education right now can issue innovation waivers. There's a way to streamline this so it's easier to do. But what this would allow is school choice within our public schools and different models to crop up and the earliest adopting superintendent and teachers who would like to do it can adopt it. If you want to see who would like this the most, just look at the teachers. Look at how many young teachers are leaving the profession at year one, two, and three. There's so much bureaucracy, so much red tape, so much teaching to the test. They come in with big hearts wanting to serve the next generation, but they quickly find that the system will not allow it. And the system doesn't wait for anybody either. And so I think we can make reforms on both sides, but the idea is to have a marketplace of great options.
Zach Lahn, on that same topic, Iowa City Public Schools is in the midst of a financial crisis fueled in part by increasing spending on what you describe as offramps, special education support for students with high behaviors. How would you fund such a strategy for high-need students on the behavior front when you have not committed to more than 3% supplemental aid and you're talking about eliminating the state income tax?
Well, there's a couple things that we need to correct, but I'll just go right into your question. You know, number one, I think there's a large discussion about funding in public schools. And just to be very clear, I do think there's a need for greater funding in public schools. But my belief as somebody who's been in business and even anybody that runs a family budget is when you see the trajectory of increasing spending adjusted for inflation and decreasing quality, the wrong thing to do is just say, you know what, that needs more money. What you need to do is find where the issues really lie and then target better funding there. And so I've talked about two of these issues in a major way. Number one is innovation. I just talked about that, but there are amazing opportunities. There's superintendents across the state I've talked to that would love to do this. You know, they tell me, I met with the superintendent in North Central Iowa. He said, 'You know, I'm not concerned with the education savings accounts. I welcome the competition. The difference is these private schools are free to innovate and I'm not. I just want the ability to meet the needs of my students.' That's one area we can increase funding in education. Number two is on these offramps. So, instead of looking at the blanket increase in funding, we have to understand that 95% of a teacher's time is spent with 5% of the students. These are students who are truly crying out for help. You know, I've worked with students like this and they might have malnutrition. They might have problems at home. They might be sleeping in a car, but a teacher is not a behavioral therapist. And so, what we need to do is have a new type of off-ramp that provides one-on-one and small group help that is tied directly into working with their parents as well because government and schools can only solve part of the problem. It really comes back to working with parents. This is where the education funding increase goes to. You have to target it directly at the problems we're facing that's causing the quality to decrease. The wrong answer is just to say, you know what, we're going to do 3% or 5% across the board without addressing the quality issues first. This is what's so important in education because oftentimes a question like this will come up about how would you fund or how much would you fund? The question is what's the problem? What's the foundational issue? And if you've been in business, you understand you don't just address the symptoms. You have to address the foundational issues that we're facing. And quality and innovation and cultural issues I believe are two of the biggest issues we're facing.
Wanted to ask both of you this. Rob Sand, we'll start with you. What type of leader would you be looking for as director of your Department of Education?
Sure. Well, foundationally, I think it's always important that you want to have people who are attached to the facts. I spent seven years as the chief public corruption prosecutor, two terms as state auditor. These are jobs where you have to know what happened. You have to drill down, and you have to interview every single witness. In my time in the Attorney General's office, we uncovered the largest lottery rigging scheme in American history. I prosecuted that. I prosecuted the Iowa Film Office tax credit fraud. I have framed in my office in the auditor's office a contract related actually to one of those film projects. This was a case where I said, 'You know what? I know I need to talk to this witness one more time.' I got up at 4 a.m., made sure we had an opportunity to have one last conversation before they were testifying at trial. And as it turns out, it was a second contract with that person's name on it, and they only had ever signed one contract. So, you want to have someone who's going to get up early and do the extra work to make sure that they know what's going on. That is far more important to me than having either a Democrat or a Republican. Ideology is not more important than reality. In the auditor's office, I appointed an independent and a Republican to the most senior positions in the office. These were two people who had actually made campaign contributions to my opponent. They were qualified to do the job. And I actually think that we tend to make better decisions when people who think differently from each other cooperate and think together. So that's another piece of this. Whether it's the Department of Education or it's other departments, I want to have not just bipartisan but tripartisan cabinet. I want to have Republicans and independents because when people who don't necessarily look at everything the same way think together, you tend to get to better outcomes. So for me, I'd love to have somebody, I think it's important to have somebody who has experience in the classroom in the Department of Education specifically. But if I couldn't find someone like that and I found someone else that I trusted, was attached to reality, was focused on doing good work, and was interested in actually doing public service instead of politics, then those three things are also important as well. Zach, what would you look for in your Department of Education director?
Yeah, I think this is a great question and ultimately comes back to leadership. How do you find good leaders in organizations? And you know, in business there's a few things I've done well. One of them was put together good teams. I don't do everything the best, but one of them was good to put together good teams. And the way I always looked at this was, you know, I think there's this idea in leadership that what you want to do is just find the expert and trust the expert. But when you're talking about reforming a system, when you're talking about building something new, you need to find people that are on the ground that actually understand the vision that you want to put forward. And the vision for public education in the state of Iowa for me is one in which Iowa is the most innovative place in the country for education. And so with that, this is a very special type of skill set. But I believe that where you can find a lot of this is on the ground. The first place I go to anytime I'm trying to learn more about these issues is not to the leadership. It's to the people on the ground to understand what's actually happening here. What are you seeing are the foundational issues? What relief would help you? You know, and this is where you're talking to teachers. You're talking to people who have been in this for a long time. And also, you're talking to former educators who are in it for 20 or 30 years who have retired to say, 'What did you see change over the time you were there?' And from there you develop out what is the type of person we're looking for that understands the innovation that you're trying to do, that understands how to get something done within the system because these systems are so bureaucratic very often that you have to have somebody that believes in the mission and understands how to navigate it. And so I think those are a couple of the points that you have to look at. You have to find people that understand the vision, have the talent to get it done. And the other thing I would say is you want to find people that have the right virtues, that are working very hard, that are not going to give up on the system, that understand that ultimately there's no such thing as a Republican kid or Democrat kid. There's just Iowa kids. There's no such thing as a public school kid or private school kid. There's just Iowa kids. And we want the best for all of these kids. And so if you have the right virtue and you have the right vision, we can train on a lot of the talents as well. But we want somebody who is going to be willing to stand up to the groups, the special interest groups, who may not want to see change. Many of these organizations don't want to see a lot of the change that we might want to see. But I believe the people on the ground, especially the teachers on the ground, want to see these changes in the classroom, want to see the schools be more innovative and want to see different models crop up that they can take part in, especially the younger teachers.
Thank you. We want to move on to another block of questions on healthcare. Rob Sand, we'll start with you on this one. Medicaid work requirements begin in December. Would your administration implement those as planned, delay them or change them anyway? And how would you handle people who lose coverage because of paperwork rather than because they fail to qualify?