across the entire social spectrum. And until we get political leadership that can explain to the American people why sacrifices for defense are important, we're going to be in trouble.
Thank you very much to both of you. It was really fascinating. Thank you all. Appreciate it.
For a conversation on national security and the road ahead, please welcome Atlantic staff writers Missy Ryan, Eric Slavin, and Nancy Youssef. Here to lead the conversation is Atlantic staff writer Vivian Salama.
Hello. Everyone can hear me. Oh, it's so great to be here and to be home for a change at these events. I'm so glad to be here with three friends. It's a nice opportunity to be on stage and get to talk to people who I work with day in and day out. We cover national security and the Trump administration together, but we are also friends as well. So that's always a treat.
And I'm going to start with Eric. For those of you who don't know, Eric just joined The Atlantic. In fact, you haven't even started yet. And so naturally, we thrust you out on stage to address the masses in an episode of hazing. And so Eric joined us from Stars and Stripes, where he had been editor in chief. Now, for those who don't know, Stars and Stripes is a federal entity operating inside the Department of Defense, but its journalism operates separately from the military, and the administration went after the senior leadership, Eric included. And so, you know, I want to start there because you just heard some of the policymakers who are very well known in this town talk about, you know, the big picture issues that we are dealing with that we cover on a day-to-day basis. But I want you to get an idea of sort of behind the scenes and what we deal with as journalists, and especially in this current challenging environment, to say the least. And so, Eric, let's just start with kind of the road that brought you to The Atlantic, and just talk even about why accountability matters for the future of national security, and what happens when the public, when Congress, and even military families have less access to independent information about what the military is doing.
Well, Stars and Stripes does have a very unique role. There really is nothing like it on Earth, and I think it's the best representation of American values that I can really think of, in that the United States is willing to authorize a media organization that will hold it to account on behalf of the United States service member. I think it's a really special thing. And that really has been the case since World War II. Stars and Stripes has run continuously since then. And at the time, General Patton was unhappy about some cartoons that were running in Stars and Stripes. They showed service members as dirty, as grumpy, kind of angry about doing their jobs. Really exactly how it was. And Patton went to General Eisenhower, says, 'This got to stop. We can't have this. They don't—they got to look all spit and polished.' And Eisenhower said, 'No. No, this is the soldiers' newspaper. We will not interfere.' And that has been the norm ever since. Stars and Stripes ran as a First Amendment news organization, really until now. Really, I look at what Stars and Stripes is doing, and the reporters there are still trying to do their best, but the leadership now is effectively run by Pentagon Public Affairs. And so I think it's a concern, and really it's a microcosm of what we're seeing throughout the media and throughout the Pentagon's conception of what media should be. Media has always been a useful tool for the Pentagon in a lot of ways. It's allowed them to see information come up that normally wouldn't come up through officers and others who might be concerned about their jobs. It's been able to inform them, even when the relationships haven't necessarily been that cozy. They certainly weren't during the...
The Atlantic promotes and protects the free exchange of ideas through prohibiting the physical or virtual disruption, shouting down, blocking or suppressing an invited speaker's right to speak. Please note, disruptions of this nature will result in removal from the venue. Thank you for your support of this event.
Please take a moment to silence your cell phones. The program is about to begin.
Please welcome The Atlantic's managing director for events, Evan Smith.
What a year to be here.
Good morning. I'm Evan Smith, managing director for events at The Atlantic. I am so happy to be here with all of you. At The Atlantic Summit, Power Politics and What's Next, this is our roll forward from last week's extraordinary midterm elections. If you did not follow along at theatlantic.com or on social media, a lot happened last Tuesday, even in my home state of Texas. Fortunately, we'll get to that in a little while. Fortunately, we are here to break it down for all of you. We have a series of terrific conversations with political and policy leaders examining the midterms and what the results tell us about the state of the country and the state of the world in a pivotal moment for the economy, democracy, and global security.
To kick us off, we have three great conversations. In a few moments, Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan will sit down with Atlantic staff writer Jonathan Lemire to talk about his successful race for that august office and his priorities once sworn in this January, as well as what we can expect from the new majority in the upper chamber of Congress. Following that, Michele Flournoy, former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, and John Bolton, former US National Security Advisor, former US Ambassador to the United Nations, will reflect on the future of warfare with The Atlantic's Editor in Chief Jeffrey Goldberg. Then, Atlantic staff writers Missy Ryan, Nancy A. Youssef, and Eric Slavin will discuss Pete Hegseth, the world's hot spots, and the national security news of the day with their fellow staff writer Vivian Salama. Following those sessions, we'll break for coffee and networking.
Before we get started, I want to thank today's underwriter, Rubrik, for supporting The Atlantic's journalism. And off these cards, I want to thank all of you. If you are readers, if you are subscribers, if you are simply fans or stans of The Atlantic, thank you for making the work that we do, never more important than now, possible in this extraordinary moment. So, please silence your phones as we begin our program by welcoming our first guests. Thanks very much.
Please welcome Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan. Leading the conversation is Atlantic staff writer Jonathan Lemire.
Good morning. Thank you all for being here. Mr. Senator-elect, thank you for being...
Thank you. They're not doing much for my height here on this couch.
You're right. 5'8", a tall 5'8", but jeez.
You should have read the rider a little more carefully.
But we appreciate you being here and starting off. It'll be a great day here at The Atlantic Summit. We appreciate all of you being here. So, welcome to Washington.
Thank you. How's the weather up there?
Well, at the moment it's all right. So, you're already, of course, faced with some decisions here before you're even sworn in. And one is who to support for Senate majority leader. And you have said that you will not be supporting Senator Schumer, who is the minority leader now. Explain that decision for us.
So, no one take anything away from Senator Schumer. He's been doing this for a long time. I personally really like him, got to know him well. And he's very pragmatic. He understands the way the Senate works. But the question I think we have to ask ourselves is two things. Number one, do we want the Senate to work the way the Senate has worked? Number one. And number two, what is it that the American public is asking for? What have they pushed for? What is it that they want? Let's talk about the way the Senate has worked. I've been very clear. I want money out of politics, money in your pocket, Medicare for all. The money in your pocket part and the Medicare for all part, they don't come without the money out of politics part. And the way that too often the Senate works is a conversation between special interests, corporations, and people in leadership on both sides of the aisle that tend to drive the legislative agenda.
I think what the public is telling us is that they are sick and tired of not being able to afford very basic things. And now obviously the blinking red light is the war in Iran that's driving up our gas prices and our groceries. It is the tariff policy, tariff war with Canada that's costing people in my state $5,600 a year. But it's also the way that a few large corporations are able to use their power to consolidate markets, to suppress our wages and raise our prices. It's also the way that we've had nearly a century of union busting in our country in ways that have left people without access to unions. It's those things too. And so we need a Senate majority that is going to take on both the immediate challenges to affordability and also the long-range challenges to affordability.
What I see in Senator Van Hollen is really what it's about. It's not against Senator Schumer, it's more about being for Senator Van Hollen. He is unique in the Senate caucus around two things he brings together. Number one, he understands how this place works. He does. He's been in the United States Senate. He's run the DSCC. He understands how this thing works. But he also has a willingness to take risk. And we need people who are willing to take legislative risk. Most senators don't fly down to El Salvador for proof of life for somebody like Kilmar Abrego Garcia. Most senators don't go stand on the rough Gaza border. So those two things are what we need right now, and we need to rethink the way we legislate. It just should not be the process where you make one or two omnibus pieces of legislation that nobody really knows what's in them. You end up getting caught up in every snag because some senator from somewhere has an issue with some piece of the bill that's not even the most important piece of the bill. Instead, what we need to be doing is identifying problems, creating legislation that solves those problems, passing that legislation, and the whole time narrating to the American public that we see you, we understand the challenge that you face. Here is a piece of legislation that would solve it, and then we're going to move on to the next problem and solve that one too.
So Senator Schumer's supporters would say, well, he too knows Washington, and they will point to the scoreboard, if you will, about how many Senate seats the Democrats just won. But he, of course, initially backed your primary opponent. You have said now you are supporting Senator Van Hollen instead. But if Senator Schumer is elected leader, can you work with him? What's an area or two of common ground?
So let's just sort of step back. What was it that the American public told us? I think as Democrats we would do well not to overread what happened as a mandate. We have the opportunity to earn a mandate over the next two years. But this was more about slapping down Trump and Trumpism than it was a mandate for Democrats. People didn't go to the ballot box thinking, man, those Democrats, I cannot wait. I think they went to the ballot box thinking, I cannot continue to live under this, the chaos, the corruption. I cannot continue to have to pay $5 in gas. So the question for us is, where do we go from here? I've worked very well with Senator Schumer over the last three months. He's a very pragmatic guy. I like him personally. He's really funny. He is. He's actually hilarious if you actually sat down with him. He do great jokes. The truth is, I've been talking about Senator Van Hollen since April. Go check the record. People ask me, you know, do you oppose or support Senator Schumer? And a vote is a choice between two or more things. So it's disingenuous when you say, yeah, I oppose one person not knowing what the alternative is. If somebody told me it was going to be John Fetterman or Chuck Schumer, I'd be like, well, there we go. So I wanted to offer an alternative. And it is because I believe in the leadership opportunity of Senator Van Hollen that I'm so excited that he is interested in leading. Now look, obviously he's starting as an underdog. Obviously we've had electoral success, and obviously Senator Schumer has been the leader for a very long time. But what I hope is not obvious about this scenario is the recognition that we actually can change. We have not seen an open Senate fight for leadership for a very long time. This is healthy. It's good. It's good to have these conversations as a caucus out in public because we are all democratically elected. And democracy should have its say. The people should have their say. And so it's not just that the ballot box around do you pick the Democrat or the Republican, you name the state. It's also how do we want the Democratic caucus to look? How do we want it to fight? How do we want it to legislate? What do we want leadership to do? This is good, and we should embrace it. And so to that point, should Senator Schumer come out victorious, I am looking forward to working alongside him. He is going to be the captain of our team. I am excited to get legislation done. I do hope that I can have a voice in a large caucus, all of whom have their voices. But this is not about opposition to something. It is about embracing the democratic ethos that should dictate what we do in a democratic society.
So let's talk a little bit about legislation and how things could get done here with Democrats now in the majority in the House and the Senate. We'll take a flashback for a moment. In 1994, as Bill Clinton was preparing to address Congress on healthcare reform, his aide, Paul Begala, advised him to wave a pen in the air and tell Congress that if they didn't send him a bill that covered every American, he'd veto it. Begala later said it was one of the worst pieces of advice he'd ever given, because it drew such sharp lines, prevented compromise and progress, and there was a 15-year gap before they could revisit healthcare. So it's not necessarily about healthcare, it's about the process. So how do you see your role as a legislator? Are you willing to make compromises on some of your values to make incremental progress, even if it's not the full goal?
So let's say you want to climb Mount Everest. There are several ways to climb Mount Everest. I've never done this, but...
You need to get to base camp, so I'm told. And then you need to climb a series of other heights until you finally have gotten to the top of Mount Everest. I think the mistake we sometimes make is that we try to cast this false choice around, well, if you can't leap Mount Everest in one big leap, then you're not serious about climbing Mount Everest. Well, yes, we are. We just got to climb Mount Everest the way you climb Mount Everest. The other side of it, though, is we say, well, if we can't climb Mount Everest in one single leap, and we got to get to base camp first, then we should pretend that we got to the top of Mount Everest because we got to base camp. No. You can climb to base camp, take a rest at base camp, and climb the rest of Mount Everest. I would love if we can get to Mount Everest in one single leap, Donald, I'm giving you the ultimate Trump card. Okay? All right, gold, then we can like gold plate it, say Trump on the top of it. You literally like, oh, I can't pay for my healthcare, Trump card, boom, there it is. So maybe we can, but maybe we can't. And so I don't want to make the mistake of pretending that base camp is Mount Everest, and I don't want to make the mistake of thinking that somehow the only way to do this is to make a leap. And that I think is the opportunity we have here.
If we were to put together a bill that dropped the Medicare eligibility age to 55, covered all children, did away with all of the different parts and made it one Medicare with no copay, premium, and deductible, that thing would have 95% support. Can we pass it? Right? And I want to put that down, and I want to force the president to make a decision. Does he want to provide more people health care, or does he want to continue to ally with Big Pharma and Big Insurance? That's the opportunity I think we have in front of us, and that is saying, listen, this is base camp, and we build from there. And if we can get all of Medicare for all done, let's say, you know, in 2028 we have another big election, I'm sure you're about to ask me about. And when we elect the president who is ready to get money out of politics, put money in pockets, pass Medicare for all, let's pass the whole thing, get to the top of Mount Everest, and the whole country can celebrate with us.
Well, we will close with the 2028 question now. We're going to have to. The one flaw in this plan, of course, is the president Trump doesn't like to put his name on things, so he's not going to go for the Trump...
This whole city is about to have his name on it by the time it's over.
So a real quick follow-up before we move to something else. Do you think there are areas that you could work with President Trump? Do you think he talks occasionally about making deals and then his actions speak very much otherwise? He's not someone who has much of a history of working across the aisle. Are there places where Democrats could work with him?
I mean, I've seen him. It seems like he has a thing for successful brown Muslim elected officials, like so, like...
He's also commenting on handsome men, so I mean...
I wasn't going to go there.
That's my job to set you up for that.
And look, I'm a professional. I'm interested in working with whomever is interested in getting money out of politics, putting money in pockets, passing Medicare for all. Every once in a while Donald Trump surprises you because at the end of the day the man does not have a fealty to any particular ideological position, if that's not clear. He is interested in advancing his own positions based on what he thinks is popular. And the American public just told him that his entire other policy was not very popular and just elected a lot of folks who are running on other policies. So if that is what he is interested in advancing, I am happy to put his name on whatever he wants to put his name on if it means that people in my state get the health care that they need and deserve and stop having to worry about going to see a doctor because it's going to cost them too much. And so the ball's in his court. He is the president of the United States. He has real power in this position. And I just think it behooves us to get out of our own way. Politics, if I've learned anything in the last 18 months, people are sick and tired of Democrats versus Republicans, blue versus red, the show of it all. They want people who are willing to show up and make change that they are going to see every month either in their paycheck or in the bills that they have to pay. That's it. That's the goal. That's the job. That's what we're here to do.
So furthering the idea of relationships, and particularly relationships that might have to be across the aisle, your primary campaign obviously ended the Democratic side sort of an ugly note and certainly right for election day. Your former competitor Haley Stevens surprised a lot of people by endorsing your Republican opponent. She said she was hurt, you know, she and her team spread word that she was hurt, that she wasn't included, more events and the like, and certainly, you know, there was not just quite a display of Democratic unity there at the end. So not assigning blame one way or the other, but are there things you could do, you feel like you could learn from what happened with Haley Stevens that you could apply to your new job here in Washington where you are going to have to work with people you have sharp disagreements with, some in your own party to be sure, but also Republicans across the aisle? You have said you have an appetite for trying to do bipartisan bills. What lessons can you take from the campaign you just concluded in order to take on your new job governing?
So there's a really interesting case study. I had thought that the difference between me and my primary opponent was on substance. It was not. It was on process. And I ran on getting money out of politics, putting money in pockets, passing Medicare for all. We got outspent 11 to one in my primary campaign. $70 million spent against us. It is a record for the amount of outside spending in a primary any race in American history. One would have thought based on the campaign that the opponent ran that they were committed to things like reproductive rights, union rights, clean air, clean water. But really what showed itself is that the people who were funding that campaign and funding Mike Rogers' campaign were really the same. And the commitment was to those people and their interests. So it's not surprising to me that she ended up siding with the people who are funding both campaigns. That's not surprising to me. And what that teaches all of us, I hope, is that that money out of politics point really has to be where we start. We cannot continue to watch as these insanely large, insanely powerful special interests wield this much power in our politics and think that the things that politicians say are real if they're funded by people whose interests are on the other side of what they're saying. So all that Haley Stevens did was take the mask off.
So on your general election night you won by eight points, about. Clear victory.
Oh, that's right. Famously you predicted it was seven. I understand. I was giving you extra credit. I said you won by eight, but you'd rather get the prediction right. Okay, seven it is. A clear victory, clear victory, decisive victory in a state that Trump won narrowly in 2024. But it is a closer margin than we saw some other places. Roy Cooper won in North Carolina by 20 in a state that Trump won by three. Senator Ossoff won by 18 in Georgia. Senator won by 12 in Texas, a state that Trump had won by 14. I believe the overall electorate was D plus 13. So your victory certainly decisive, but under those margins, what does that tell you about Michigan? What can you learn from that?
We won a race running on money out of politics, money in your pocket, Medicare for all. Michiganders want money out of politics, money in their pocket, Medicare for all. I don't spend much time thinking about what other state electorates want and need. My focus has been on the state of Michigan. You know, I said back in May that I was going to win by seven points, and in November I won by seven points. So, you know, we feel pretty good about the outcome. Now you're asking me to play pundit, and just because, you know, I spent a lot of my career as an epidemiologist, let me offer a couple of different perspectives to be thinking about here. We got outspent by $110 million. And it wasn't just the $110 million being spent on 30-second ads on television. It was that Donald Trump and JD Vance and all of their surrogates decided to make me the main character of the entire midterms. Donald Trump would come to Michigan and talk about me. Then he'd go to South Carolina and talk about me. Then he'd go to Texas and talk about me. Then he'd go to Mississippi and talk about me. And he talked about all those other folks, but the one person he talked about everywhere he went was me. And so, in some respects, it's very difficult to fully capture the extent of the opposition that was marshaled by way of networks to then try and compare across different races. That's number one.
Number two, I came out of a deeply bruising primary in August, and we only had three months. So, there was a residual cost of the campaign run against us in the primary that you have to factor into the general as well. So, when you think about it, it's not just the $110 million outside spending difference in the general. If you just think about election season, add that to the $60 million spending difference in the primary, and you got a $170 million gap that we had to overcome. Third, the state of Michigan is used to tough general elections. And so, in a lot of ways, a lot of the electorate tends to be baked because of the residual consequences of other races around who are Democrats and who are Republicans. The kind of spending that we saw in some of these other new battleground states is different. And so you don't have the same kind of ossification of an electorate that you would have in a state like Michigan that is consistently a battleground. So comparing consistent battleground states to other states that are not consistent battlegrounds also may violate. Then finally, if you didn't notice, my name is Abdul El-Sayed. I'm brown and I'm Muslim. And so that has—I mean, look, we won the race, and I'm so grateful for the support I was given. But we won the race having to show people what a senator could look like independent of what a senator has looked like that they've ever seen before. So is that going to have some cost? Probably. Right? So all that I'll say is this.
I'm so grateful that James Talarico won by the incredible gap he won by. I'm so grateful that Annie Andrews won by an incredible gap that she won by. I'm so grateful that Adam Hamilton won by his gap. I'm grateful that Scott Colomé won. I'm really grateful that Mary Peltola won because these are going to be amazing colleagues. Josh Turek, amazing future colleague. I am so grateful to be able to come here in a class like this. Why? Because these folks are all incredible. They bring regional perspectives that I'm already learning from. They are going to allow us to be able to govern in some really new and interesting ways. And it's not just—I know from where folks sit, everybody focuses on the gap, right? We focus on the advantage, the majority advantage. Folks are not just a vote. These are people who bring lived experience and life perspective and perspectives from their state that are going to shape the color of the legislation that we drive so that we can pass. And what a gift to be able to work with these incredible legislators who ran incredible races in a moment when people gave us the opportunity to govern. So I just think it's a bit of a fool's errand to be able to say, well, you know, how do we measure these races against each other? Because all politics is local. Every candidate and campaign is going to be different. The hue of these things is different. But what I wish more folks in the press paid attention to is what is the mixture? You know, you ever had like a boring salad? You like, this is a lettuce and tomato salad. Didn't even bother to put onions in the salad. Didn't even bother to like think about like something. But then you have a salad where it's like you got some sunflower seeds and it's like a, you know, a honey mustard vinaigrette. And it's a shallot. It's not even an onion. Right? Like, and you're like, wow, that shallot just changes the flavor of the lettuce. We are making the best salad. And you know, just in case he goes after us for using vegetables and not meat, we put flank steak on the salad, Donald. All right? For Talarico. Like, we got it from Texas, Angus, high-quality beef. Anyway, we are making a far better mixture because of who is coming to the US Senate. And I hope that those of you in the press who are covering this get to cover the different flourishes and the different understandings that come to the legislation, how much richer it's going to be because it reflects experiences from those states.
This is The Atlantic Summit brought to you by Chopped and Sweetgreen.
Pretty good punditry after saying you didn't want to necessarily delve into that. But I didn't want to—I wanted to make sure we didn't gloss over one thing. You mentioned your name, you mentioned your faith, your identity.
Now it's your turn to say it.
I would need to consult my notes. I could do, yeah. So let me ask you how much, you know, are you carrying that with you? And like, it's who you are. But when you think of yourself in this new role, do you think of yourself like, I'm a role model now? Like I have some people can look up to me? Or is it also like, well, I'm more than this because I want to get this task done, this piece of legislation done and more.
You know, the people of the state of Michigan didn't elect me to be the first of anything. They elected me as their next senator. I take very seriously that the most important word on my name plate is Michigan. That is Michigan's Senate seat. And my job every day is to take that with me inside that office and ask, what can I do to advance the well-being of people in my state? Now, there's a lot that gets attached to you when you look different than anyone who's ever sat in that chair or any chair before. And the thing that I keep saying is the best I can do is to do that job really well so that the next person who might look a little different, whether it's because they share a faith or have no faith at all, or different skin color, or love different, or have different ability, that that person will be asked about how they want to do the job rather than about their identity in doing the job.
And I think a lot about the incredible gift that President Obama gave me. You know, and I got to share this with him, but there is no world—I mean, I had mentors telling me my whole life, someday you're going to run for office. I was like, you're insane. My name has 11 letters in it. Nobody can pronounce or... These are not things that people can say. Like, I don't get to do this. And then I got to watch Barack Hussein Obama run for the presidency and showed me something in myself I never would have seen. And so he made it possible for me to do this and to run with my full, like, very complicated personality. Right? A lot of folks were like, you don't get to get away calling out the president with your name. I'm like, watch me do it. Because I am who I am. I'm not going to pretend to be somebody else. And so my hope is that I get to do this job and people will look and say, yeah, yeah, his name was whatever whatever, but look at what, look at the legislation he led on. Look at the way that he was able to uplift his caucus and the Senate. Look at the way he led. That's what I'm interested in. And my hope is that that makes it easier for the next person to be able to do this job and not to have to think so much about who they are and how they are and how they show up.
Let's move briefly to Israel. Their election is concluded there.
We're in Washington, D.C., my friend.
Not interested in moving to Israel.
No. There you go. See, we got jokes here today, guys. We got jokes, both of us. And Jeff later. Jeff loves his jokes. Let's—there's just an election there. There's a chance for a coalition to be formed. There's a chance that Prime Minister Netanyahu will leave office. If that happens, if Prime Minister Netanyahu loses, would you work—would you want to work with his successor? And would that change your position at all on US funding to Israel?
So I've been very clear about my principles. I believe in equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike. I will work with anyone who is interested in advancing those principles. But moreover, I am more focused on what's going on in Michigan. And right now, I've got communities in Michigan with a median income of $14,000 whose kids go to schools that look like they did 50 years ago, whose boilers will break. I do not believe that we should be in the business of unconditional foreign military aid to any country, that is Egypt, that is Saudi Arabia, that is Jordan, that is Pakistan, and that is Israel. Those principles don't change regardless of who the leadership in Israel is.
What will be the condition that would need to change?
Those are just principles of mine, and I think we should move forward on that. I also think it's important for whoever becomes the leader of the Israeli government to reckon with the past and what has been done. I believe that Netanyahu is a war criminal. I think he should be held accountable for his war crimes. I think the people who have aided and abetted his war crimes need to be held accountable for their crimes. I think these are just principle-based approaches. So, if the next Prime Minister of the government of Israel is interested in saying what does it look like to create equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians, I'm really looking forward to the conversation. If not, I will continue to advocate for those equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination. It's not about not working with somebody, but it is about identifying what our principles ought to be and holding all of ourselves accountable to that, including our own government. I mean, we aided, armed, and abetted a genocide. Like, full stop. And then every time we have a conversation, it's like that part of history you just kind of don't want to talk about. That's insane. Like, insane that this is not where the subject of the conversation goes. 70,000 people, that's the minimal estimate. At least half of them children. If any other country in the world did that, we would be having a very different conversation. Very, very different conversation. But I'll also tell you this, this is going to be an important test case because it's very difficult to see a government form without an Arab party in coalition. And for a long time, we've been told that Israel is Jewish and democratic. And so this is going to be a really interesting test case.
What should Israel be? What should Israel be?
I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, equal rights for all its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws. That's again the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination. And let's step back from here because we always start from the premise of what is Israel now and what should it be versus the premise of what should be the juxtaposition of states or state that upholds equal rights for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike. That to me is where we ought to start. And then there needs to be a free, open Palestinian movement that can, on equal footing, negotiate with Jewish Israelis to think about what the ultimate peace should look like. Should it be two states? Should it be one state? Should it be 25 states? I don't really know. That is not my decision to make. But that should be a decision that is made with these two peoples with equal claims to self-determination on that land together, in a way that addresses their claims to self-determination in a peaceful and just way.
So you're very clear you're speaking about that you're talking about Israel here. But what is your response to someone who comes up to you and says, well, I find that your critiques of Israel fuel my fears of antisemitism? I feel I'm afraid now because of some of what you or others are saying. When someone comes to you and expresses that belief, what would you say to them?
I'm sorry for your fear. Obviously I don't want to do anything that drives your fear. At the end of the day, there's a difference between safety or lack of safety and comfort. If what I'm saying is making you uncomfortable, you should be uncomfortable with injustice perpetrated on other people. You should be uncomfortable with that. I don't want anything we do to make anybody unsafe, to put them in harm's way. But addressing the safety question and the discomfort question are two different things, because if it is your sense of your discomfort and/or fear of safety that has to keep me quiet while I watch 70,000 people get killed, their homes annihilated, their hospitals destroyed, their universities decimated, and I can't critique that, then I think what you're telling me is that their humanity matters less than yours. And I'm not going to be okay with that.
Let's move on with our last few minutes here, a couple other topics we'll hit briefly. You of course are a doctor. If Medicaid for all were to pass tomorrow, that would put RFK Jr. in charge of that program, American Self Care. Is that what you want or is there another way forward?
So, you know, at the end of the day, when we think about healthcare, like, you know, it is an interesting thing to think through. But let's say we did — let's just imagine this magical scenario, okay? Where Donald Trump hears me out. He's like, I like that Trump card. I want to give it to everyone.
He — whatever it might be. RFK should just grow a beard. Let's say we had that scenario. The American public would demand a level of accountability around what that offered. And there would need to be a system of governance set up around the short-term decision making about coverage, etc., etc., right? We do this often in government. You think about the Fed, right? The Fed is not governed directly by the executive branch. We set up a system of governors with longer-range appointments so that they are a step removed from political interference. That's something we would set up.
Now, I also think that the existence of something like this would very much change the way that the public thinks about who it wants to be elected over leadership over that. And I think that would probably be a good thing. So where RFK Jr. is out here playing games with things like vaccines, talking about doing certain things, and you know that he's about to be HHS Secretary if Donald Trump gets elected, I think people would think twice about being like, do I really want that man running my healthcare?
And I say because I think it's important for us to realize that too often the way that we cover politics is designed for people who think about politics like sports. I'm never going to forget the moment that I saw Steve Kornacki, God bless his soul, lovely man, but I saw him covering the big board like on the Super Bowl. And I was like, oh, the crossover is finally over. Like these are just the same things. And that's a real problem because look, I bleed blue.
But when Michigan beats Ohio State, like it makes a lot of us feel really good in Michigan, makes a lot of people in Ohio feel very bad. One man who lives at the Naval Observatory, he feels bad. But at the end of the day, nobody lives or dies because of it. But when blue beats red in politics, lives and livelihoods hang in the balance, and we have to start acting like it. And so we say these things because what we've basically — the question has assented to this idea that politics is a sport.
Now, what do you think about this funny scenario where RFK Jr. governs all of healthcare? Well, at the end of the day, RFK Jr. does govern a lot of parts of healthcare, and look, how many measles cases have we had because of it? How many people got sick because of lettuce that they ate that nobody should have been eating because of it? Like lives hang in the balance, and I just think it's important for us to cover these things in the depths of the ways that political decisions really do shape people's lives. So yeah, I'd be fine with that, but I also think it would create a level of accountability and a level of discipline that would not have allowed for a lot of the shenanigans that got away because most people aren't paying attention to what he's doing to destroy our healthcare system.
Let me ask you this. This is, and upfront conceding that these things do not have to be mutually exclusive. What is more important to you? The Democrats elect more progressive members, or grow perhaps a more diverse ideology, but with not as many progressives per se, but build a broader electoral map? What would you prioritize?
What's the point of having an electoral map if you can't use it to drive legislation? Like the point of winning elections is that you change public policy. So I don't need everybody in my caucus to agree with me on everything, but I do need us to get into the business of legislating in ways that protect our rights and provide better, more durable public goods and protect us from the exceeding power of a few very, very large financially oriented organizations in our lives. So how we get there is a secondary question to getting there. See what I mean? So I don't need people to, like, you know, agree with me on the words. I need them to be coming to DC to get into the business of making people's lives better. But it does not matter that you win elections if you don't do anything with the seat. It doesn't matter. Again, like this just goes back to this sort of like, ah, but Team Blue won.
To do what? Like I don't, you know, to do what? This is the point. Everybody's like, oh, well, you'd work with Donald Trump to get Medicare for all. I'm like, hell yeah. Because the point for me is Medicare for all. I don't care who puts their name on it. I need to go back and talk to Michiganders and I need to know that our service made their lives easier. That is the point. So to the point, I would rather us create governing majorities that govern well and solve problems in people's lives.
Two last questions, lightning round. Secretary Hillary Clinton, when she was — well, before that, but she was elected first lady, then elected senator from New York. She was — we proposed the question and frequently said that she wanted to be a workhorse and not a show horse. That's sort of Senate terminology, and others have been asked that question too. It sounds like workhorse is what you're looking for.
Have you ever seen a Clydesdale that is actually set up for a show? They're beautiful horses. The idea that there's a workhorse or a show horse is kind of ridiculous.
I want to be a workhorse who shows well. I mean —
Both. The answer is both.
I appreciate — I gave you that as a layup and you said no, I'll take it the other way and went —
But let me actually just — I do want to say something about this.
Then we have one last after this. Go ahead.
The nature of politics has also changed.
We have the ability to communicate directly to the public in a way that was not possible 20 years ago. So the ability to move a conversation in the public and then deliver that in terms of legislation, that has changed over time. So you cannot do the job only on the inside. You have to also be able to engage the conversation on the outside, which of course is why I'm here.
And to that point, I'm just looking — you have 716,000 followers on X, the Everything App, Twitter. I mean, there is an element obviously of showmanship there. So last question for you. In the '28 — and we're certainly very grateful, you have been generous with your time this morning.
But is that what you think? Michigan will be, you know, have a play an early prominent role in 2028 in a way that has not previously. States are very proud of their spot early in the process. Jim Clyburn famously has his fish fry for the candidates in South Carolina. Tom Harkin in Iowa has a steak fry. What are you going to fry in Michigan?
I don't know. I'm thinking maybe like we could do like the shawarma show.
There it is. We want to thank all of you, and let's please thank Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, Dr. El-Sayed.
For a conversation on the future of war, please welcome John Bolton, former US National Security Advisor and former US Ambassador to the United Nations, and Michele Flournoy, former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy and co-founder and managing partner of WestExec Advisors, with The Atlantic's Editor in Chief Jeffrey Goldberg.
This is a good day. We have a lot of good people for you, including and especially the two people here. Michele Flournoy, former — I mean, the generally recognized defense genius, former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, done a million things in Washington, knows everything. John Bolton, of course, Ambassador John Bolton, former National Security Advisor to President Trump, until that ceased to work. We could talk about that a little bit. It only works until it doesn't work. Let's just jump in and talk. I want to ask you both about NVIDIA and Chinese spying. We could leave the lurid stuff out unless you want to go there. But I want to hear both of your analyses on what this means, and specifically what the fight between Lutnick and Bessent means. They both got on Air Force One together. Apparently, it landed safely, which is a little bit surprising given that they're on polar opposite ends of this question. Maybe I'll frame it with Michele first. I'll frame it just by asking, you know, define the threat, and did Jensen Huang and Howard Lutnick, among others, downplay the threat?
Well, I think this whole — first of all, it's great to be here and thanks for hosting us. I think this is a real wake-up call for all of us in terms of the extent to which China is going to go to try to compete effectively on AI and particularly access the most advanced chips, which they have not been able to replicate themselves. And so, you know, classic move by an intelligence service to sort of create a honeypot and lure someone that they thought they could either compromise or get information from or get compliant behavior from.
And I think, you know, we are in a very deep competition with China over AI. I think we are way ahead in the frontier model competition. They are running a different race, which is about distillation into smaller models that require less compute, are cheaper, and they want to win the diffusion race, meaning let's get the world to adopt cheaper Chinese models as opposed to the American frontier models. So this has national security implications, economic implications. This is a very serious issue. I think that the right course of action here is a serious investigation into whether or not this woman was an actual Chinese spy, if she was, what kind of information was shared, were any laws broken or norms transgressed in terms of actually enabling her company to export chips against US law to entities in China. So I think this is worthy of a very serious, deliberate investigation because there are very real national security concerns here.
Right. Ambassador Bolton, does Donald Trump understand AI?
Did you ever have conversations about this, or did you predate this —
You predated the AI. Well, tell me, where do you stand on the Lutnick-Bessent dispute?
Look, I think this is a wake-up call, but remember the Chinese business model since the mid-1980s, when Deng Xiaoping first broke from Marxist principles, is steal everybody's intellectual property. And it's been an incredibly successful business model for China. They have resisted every attempt we have made over multiple administrations, Democrat and Republican, to stop it. And what I think is going on here — I think it's more than just the Chinese ran a swallow against Jensen Huang and he fell for it. I think it wasn't so she could fiddle with his phone while he was out of the room. I think it's so she could say, you know, we need help with our next chip question. Could we talk to some of your designers? So that instead of just her talking to Jensen Huang, you've got a dozen mega-speed technicians picking Nvidia's brain. And I don't think it's limited to Nvidia. I think we need to think again — not that we should have to, but we need to think again about the whole-of-society approach that the Chinese are throwing at us in the realm of stealing intellectual property.
Let's talk about the implications at the highest level. Yes, the Chinese want the world to adopt their cheaper models. From a national security perspective, what does it mean if China gets our best technology? What does it mean for Taiwan? What does it mean for US power in Asia? What does it mean for the future of warfare?
So if done responsibly and well, the adoption of AI or the integration of AI into our intelligence and decision-making networks should give the adopter the advantage of better quality decisions at faster speeds. And, you know, one of the tenets of warfare is you can get inside the other guy's decision loop, meaning you can make better decisions faster than the other guy. That tends to, you know, certainly enhance deterrence if not win wars. Now, there are a lot of caveats to that in terms of doing it responsibly, well, having the AI behave as it should, and so forth. So we can get into that.
But so on decision-making, it has huge implications. It also has implications in terms of autonomy. You know, we are seeing a preview of the future of warfare in Ukraine right now, where swarms of unmanned systems, autonomous systems on the battlefield are having extremely lethal effects. And that is enabled by AI. The human-machine teaming that allows for drone swarms is key. So I think it has lots of implications for national security that we're only starting to understand. But it is an area where we absolutely need to keep our edge.
Can we talk a bit about the future of warfare? Ambassador Bolton, what are the lessons that we are learning from Ukraine right now? And what are the lessons that the Trump administration is not learning?
Well, I think the speed with which drone technology and counter-drone technology are occurring on the battlefield in Ukraine is something that's important not just in terms of drones in the air, but drones on the ground, drones on the surface of the sea, drones under sea. I think, as Michele was saying, I think we're moving closer and closer to almost totally unmanned warfare on the battlefield. A little bit science fictiony, but it's in the future. Donald Trump wants an F-47 fighter plane. I'm not sure we need manned fighter planes anymore if we have the right drone technology. But what it also says is that the boundaries that Western civilization at least tried to draw between war and civilian life are disintegrating. And I think that as we talk about gray zone warfare, hybrid warfare, these are all areas where artificial intelligence and cyber warfare become very important.
Just look at what's been happening in the United States. Let's assume it's all purely technological failures. Let's assume there's no foreign actor at all in the collapse of the air traffic control system, but there could be. And in fact, you could see use of AI in cyber warfare against water and sewer systems. Last week, France accused Iran of cyber warfare against their cold storage food chain. Supermarkets all over France lost the ability to keep meat and other products frozen. So you're talking about things that have a direct impact on civilian life. And it's not just the hybrid warfare Russia has been running by putting drones armed with explosives in the Leipzig airport, but in many, many other ways, they're trying to destroy the morale of civilian populations. They're testing how far they can go. And I think AI is a perfect enabler for broadening the scope of warfare, really to make it whole of society almost from the outset.
Are we in World War III and we just don't know it yet?
I don't know that we're in World War III, but I do think that with regard to Russia in particular, Russia is waging a form of conflict across Europe right now with sabotage, with assassinations, with drone incursions, with these cyber attacks and so forth. And so in some ways, when you think about the future of warfare, we're being pulled in two different directions. The very high-end transformation of how things will be fought on the battlefield, military force against military force. And then below the zone, below the level of sort of overt conflict, the gray zone where you're going to have a lot of activity disrupting societies, creating dissension and division to try to break the will and the cohesion of a country to respond. And it really pulls you in very different directions in terms of preparedness.
The reason I asked that World War III question is because we see again this week North Korea sending more troops to aid the Russian effort, Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which of course is supported by NATO, by European NATO, and intermittently by the United States. Definition of a world war is when you have many different parties and many different continents coming together to fight each other. I mean, that's one way of looking at it, but I mean something larger, which is that are we — our writer Josh Tyrangiel yesterday, a couple of days ago, used a great expression. He should trademark it. He said we're entering a period of history that's going to be remembered as kind of a software Beirut, where every day, every week, there's another kind of attack on a system that we need, whether it's United Airlines' reservation system or refrigeration or so on. Are we ready for what's coming? That's a question for both of you.
I don't think we're ready. I think on the cyber dimension, you know, you had the revelation of the Mythos model and holding back its release so that we could use the model to understand our own vulnerabilities, patch as many of those as possible. But with the advent of agentic AI, and you put that together with cyber attacks, it's going to identify vulnerabilities, exploit those vulnerabilities much more quickly and at a larger scale. And it sort of democratizes the best practices — you take average Joe hacker and give them these models, and now he has state-level cyber at his disposal. So I think there's a lot of effort to work on agentic defense to try to combat that, but right now there's a window of vulnerability that is very real.
But we are not ready for the gray zone tactics that we're experiencing now, and certainly not for the escalation. But rather than call this World War III, I would say it's something different. What we're seeing is what, you know, my colleague Richard Fontaine from CNAS has called the Axis of Upheaval. It's the alignment of China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea, first starting to cooperate in Ukraine. Now we're seeing it cooperating in support of Iran in the Middle East. This is a coalition that is offering very meaningful support to one another as a counter to our alliances and coalitions and our interests.