RFK Jr. at the helm of HHS is really worst case scenario for any pediatrician. There is a desperate need for scientifically literate people to run for office, for people who have real frontline experience working in America's health care system to run for office. We have to lean in.
This is Unmoderated. I'm Sarah McCammon. When Dr. Annie Andrews launched her Senate campaign in a solid Republican state last year, she knew she was the underdog. No Democrat has won a Senate race in South Carolina for close to three decades, and the state has voted for Donald Trump by double-digit margins in every election that he's run. Andrews is running against Darline Graham, the sister of the late longtime Republican Senator Lindsey Graham. She's a pediatrician who spends her days caring for children, and as a doctor, she has ideas about what leaders can do to care for their constituents.
Dr. Annie Andrews, thanks for joining me.
Well, thank you so much for having me today.
You know, your race has been full of ups and downs. It was just weeks, I believe, after you won your primary that your opponent at the time, the longtime Senator Lindsey Graham, passed away unexpectedly. What was it like for you to sort of walk through that moment and recalibrate the way that you were thinking about this race?
Yeah, I mean, that day, that moment was shocking for everyone here in South Carolina. Lindsey Graham had been a member of Congress for three decades and it was so unexpected. But quite frankly, Lindsey Graham's unexpected passing didn't change the problems South Carolinians are facing. It didn't change the reasons I decided to pivot from pediatrics into politics. So, you know, the messaging switch was pretty easy because I'm still talking about the same issues I was talking about on day one of this campaign. It was an unusual situation to go through the summer without an opponent. But now, you know, the field is set. I know who my opponent is, and we are laser focused on winning so that we can return this Senate seat to the people of South Carolina.
You know, about your opponent. Graham's sister, Darline Graham, is now your opponent. She's gotten a lot of attention, frankly, for what she doesn't know. Uh, there was that viral moment in which she struggled to answer a foreign policy question, you know, which was an area where her brother was an expert. Uh, and that moment got a lot of attention online. How did that land with people you're talking to in South Carolina?
You know, it went viral, not just in South Carolina, of course, all across the country. And it to me was just a glaring example, a glaring illustration of the fact that she is unprepared and unqualified for this job. Being a US senator is an incredibly serious job. War and peace are not electives for a US senator. And it just really put on full display the fact that she was thrust into this role. I don't know what her decision-making process was to decide to run for the full term, but being new to this is not an excuse to show up unprepared. You know, I've spent my entire career working in children's hospitals. If I were to show up one day unprepared, a child could die. You could argue being a US senator is equally as serious of a job. And these really are life and death decisions our senators are making, sending service members into war zones. And you know, it was just inexcusable. And what I'm hearing on the ground is everybody saw and heard that, and it confirmed what people feared: that just because your brother was a senator, it doesn't make you qualified to be a senator. And it's allowing a lot of these independents and center-right Republicans to feel like they have a pretty reasonable off-ramp to try something different this election cycle.
You've said that what you witnessed while caring for people who were struggling to get treatment within the current system is part of why you decided to go into politics. As someone who's devoted your career to taking care of children's health, what do you hear when you hear Trump administration officials like RFK Jr. expressing skepticism about vaccines?
I mean, it's really a five-alarm fire as far as children's health care in America goes, and it's a two-pronged problem. It's the dismantling of our routine childhood immunization schedule. It's further, you know, diluting our public health system with disinformation. In addition to the fact that this administration has gutted our nation's largest insurer for children, the Medicaid program. You know, the routine childhood immunization schedule, the one that's currently supported by the American Academy of Pediatrics, that's the one that's based in science and evidence. The changes that have been proposed and supported by this administration are not based on an evolution of evidence or science. It's not like they figured out something new and so we have to change what we recommend. And it's really difficult to watch because, you know, here in South Carolina we had a measles outbreak in Spartanburg County where there were nearly a thousand documented cases of the measles earlier this year. We've seen deaths from the measles in Pennsylvania. And I think it's really important that people understand this is a direct result of the anti-vaccine conspiracy theories that grifter RFK Jr. has been peddling for decades while simultaneously enriching himself. And it has to stop. RFK Jr. cannot have two more years of leadership at HHS because he's already done such grave damage to trust in our public health system, to the public health infrastructure in this country, through dismantling of the CDC as well, through on-again, off-again NIH funding, and it's got to stop because real people are suffering. And of course, I'm most concerned about America's children. The diseases we vaccinate for are not just, you know, polio and measles, which get a lot of headlines, but it's diseases like RSV and flu that every single year in this country, children are hospitalized and some children die from these preventable infectious diseases. It's also diseases like bacterial meningitis. We currently vaccinate infants for two of the leading causes of bacterial meningitis. And as more parents refuse vaccines or hesitate to vaccinate their children because of these conspiracy theories, we're going to see increased rates of deadly bacterial meningitis. And it just didn't have to be this way. It is deeply distressing to me and all of my pediatrician colleagues all across this country. And we've got to do something about it. That's why I believe it is so urgent that we elect America's first ever pediatrician senator on November 3rd.
My kids are in their teens now, but I remember even when they were babies hearing some of this skepticism about vaccines from, you know, other moms, mom groups, and just kind of as a new mom going, 'Okay, what do I believe? Who do I trust?' And talking to my kids' pediatricians about that. Um, you know, and I remember them walking me through some of the science and being very helpful. I'm curious what you say as a doctor when you must have moms and dads come into your office with some of these questions. How do you talk to them about how they should think about this as parents?
Yeah, and I think that's a really important point. I absolutely do not blame parents for the decisions they're making around vaccines. They are victims in this sort of disinformation ecosystem that RFK Jr. has been leading for decades. Parents don't know where to turn or who to trust. I really recommend that parents go talk to their individual healthcare providers, to their own child's pediatrician. That's what the pediatrician is there for. My entire career has been spent working in children's hospitals where I do spend time counseling families whose children have been admitted to the hospital about vaccines in particular, you know, seasonal flu vaccines and RSV vaccines. But now more than ever, when I ask my intake questions of these patients and their parents, 'Is your child's immunizations up to date?' The answer is some version of no. And 20 years ago, at the beginning of my career, I would write the answer yes before the parent even opened their mouth because it was 99.99 times out of 100 the answer was yes. And now there's been such a rise in vaccine hesitancy and vaccine refusal. And it is no easy job to combat that disinformation that they've been receiving passively and actively oftentimes on their social media feeds in one doctor's visit or one hospitalization, one interaction. That's why it's so urgent that we get RFK Jr. out of there, because the longer we allow this to go on, the longer we have disinformation about vaccines being spread from the highest levels of our federal government, the harder it's going to be for pediatricians to claw back at this relationship they have with their patients and their patients' parents, and to be able to, you know, provide that evidence-based recommendation to convince parents why it's so critical that we protect young infants in those earliest months of their lives. There's a reason we give vaccines at two months and four months and six months. And yes, it seems like a lot of vaccines, but those are medical miracles. It's amazing that we can vaccinate and prevent so many previously non-preventable infectious diseases. And we have to protect infants in those first months of their lives because their immune systems are not strong enough to fight against these infections. That's why we concentrate vaccinations in the first year of life. And it's just so critical that we do everything we can to protect as many young children in this country as we can.
Now, people have a hard time getting those vaccines or having those conversations with the doctor if they don't have access to health care. There's some debate within the Democratic coalition about what is the best way to get everybody covered. Now, you've opposed Medicare for all. That's one idea. You've called it an idea from decades ago. As a doctor, what do you see from the inside? And what insight do you have into not only what's broken, but how to fix it?
So, I absolutely believe that health care is a human right, but I am a painfully pragmatic person. I think most physicians I know are incredibly pragmatic. You never have a perfect treatment plan for a patient, but that doesn't mean you just walk away and say, 'Oh, well, I can't help that kid today.' I understand that we need to take big steps to shift America's profit-motivated health care system to a patient-centered health care system, but we're not going to get from point A to point B in one election cycle or one legislative session. And that's why I'm a huge proponent of a public option, because if we offer a public option from the federal government, something that was supposed to be a part of the original Affordable Care Act but it didn't have enough support in the US Senate, people will be able to choose to purchase a plan from the federal government. And when they do that, that removes the profit motivation from that transaction. And over time, those people will start to understand that they're getting a better deal. More of the money they're putting into their monthly premium is actually going to the provision of health care rather than padding insurance company shareholders' pockets, and that will force over time private insurance companies to compete and to offer more comprehensive benefit plans at lower premium rates. And then there will be a domino effect as more and more Americans recognize the public option is actually meeting their needs in a way that their private insurance wasn't. And then and only then do I believe we will be able to have a true, productive, bipartisan conversation about how we can ultimately build a health care system that truly meets the needs of everyone in this country.
What does that look like as a doctor, you know, when somebody's uninsured or underinsured and they have a health need?
I mean, it's heartbreaking. You know, as I said, when I work in the hospital setting, thankfully there's still federal law that requires emergency departments to provide care to anyone who shows up at their doorstep, regardless of their ability to pay. So it is not uncommon for a child to come to the emergency department uninsured. They receive the treatment that they need. They require hospitalization, so they get hospitalized. We don't send them to the curb. And then they're under my care as the hospital-based pediatrician. And then we have to spend many, many phone calls and hours with our case managers and our social workers trying to figure out if we can find an insurance that this family can qualify for and that they can afford. It's heartbreaking when you're ready to discharge a patient from their hospitalization, but you can't make a follow-up appointment with either a primary care doctor or a subspecialist that they need because they don't have insurance and these offices can't take appointments with uninsured patients. I mean, these are sick children in America, and oftentimes they don't receive the care that they need because we've built a health insurance system that really does prioritize padding the profits of big insurance companies rather than prioritizing the provision of health care to everyone in this country. And enough is enough. And it's, you know, it's bad enough when it's an adult, but in my view, it's so much worse when it's a sick child. And we just, we can do better. We must do better. I am heartened that I think the politics around this issue are changing because of this unprecedented coordinated attack we've seen under this administration on every aspect of our health care system. Not only the Medicaid budget cuts, but the ACA tax subsidies expiring, the Medicare Part D subsidies expiring. And, you know, people are starting to ask questions, you know, why is our health care system built the way it is? And can't we do better?
One of the challenges in South Carolina is, you know, your state is among the states that never expanded Medicaid, and I know you've drawn a line from that decision by Republicans in South Carolina not to expand Medicaid to the child care crisis. Connect those dots for me.
Yeah, I mean, clearly, you know, a nation's budget reflects a nation's values. A state's budget and a state's policies reflect a state's values. Um, you know, we like to say that we're, you know, we're a pro-family state, um, but we don't build policies that actually support families. You know, if you don't expand Medicaid, then you're going to have a lot more children who are uninsured, and that doesn't feel very pro-family to me. If you allow daycare vouchers, child care vouchers to expire, so that hardworking, you know, particularly single moms in South Carolina cannot afford child care, they can't contribute to the workforce and the tax base. That doesn't feel very pro-family or pro-child to me. All of these issues are interrelated. If your child cannot access health care, then you can't give them their preventative asthma inhaler. Then they're more likely to have asthma symptoms. They're more likely to miss school, to not be able to go to daycare, and then the parents can't go to work. All of these issues are interrelated. That's why the health care piece is part of our affordability plan, because if you can't afford to stay healthy or to see a doctor when you're sick, then you're going to struggle in all other aspects of your life.
How do these kinds of conversations land with people in South Carolina who have always voted Republican? And how do you try to persuade them to consider a Democrat like you?
You have to push back against these, you know, sort of false narratives that the Republican Party has claimed of being the pro-family party or the pro-child party, because as a pediatrician and a public school mom, I can tell you objectively they are wrong. They are not the party that supports policy that actually uplifts every child in this state. And so you have to name the problem, and the problem is that they're being dishonest about what their policies do and don't do to support hardworking families. And then you have to be really clear about the policies that you envision that can actually help these families. And that includes things like, you know, subsidizing child care centers so that the child care business can actually stay afloat, and that families who want to get into the workforce, moms who want to go back to work, can find affordable child care in their communities. It looks like making sure we do in fact expand Medicaid, which a recent poll just showed the majority of South Carolinians want us to expand Medicaid so that every child can access a doctor and see a doctor when they need to see a doctor. It looks like investing in our public education system so that every child in South Carolina can access a high-quality free public education regardless of the zip code into which they were born. You know, I think for a while I've, you know, been frustrated by the messaging coming from the Democratic Party because it's been very clear for a long time that our policies actually do prioritize kids and families, but people don't know that because we don't message effectively around that. That's one of the reasons I think it's so important that more pediatricians get involved in politics so that we can have these conversations with voters. And once I'm able to sit down and sort of explain where I stand and why I stand there, I have found it's, you know, it's not as hard as you might think to win over some of these moderate Republicans who feel left behind by their own party. And it's certainly not hard to win over independents when you can convince them that you're going to make informed decisions, that you're going to work hard on everyone's behalf in South Carolina when you get the job.
In addition to your background as a pediatrician pushing you into politics, you've also said that the Parkland school shooting in Florida back in 2018, you said that moment pushed you into politics as well. What was that?