It's debate night in Iowa. Hear from the two candidates battling for your vote: Republican Congresswoman Ashley Hinson.
We want to make sure that Iowans have access to affordable health care, and frankly, it is too expensive.
And Democratic State Representative Josh Turek.
There's a lot of Iowans hurting. They're struggling right now just to keep food on the table.
Where they stand on the issues that matter most to you.
Going to be much more money for continued research.
I would just say across-the-board health care.
And the stakes are high not only for Iowa, but the country as the balance of power in the Senate takes center stage.
The elections this November are truly the future of our country.
And I think this is a once-in-a-generation opportunity.
Tonight, you get to decide which candidate will earn your trust. Now, from your local election headquarters at the WHO 13 studios, this is debate night in Iowa.
Welcome to debate night in Iowa. I'm Amanda Krenz with WHO 13. For the first time in more than a decade, our state has an open seat in the US Senate.
Thanks for joining us tonight. I'm Tim Seaman from KCAU 9. The debate comes at a critical time. Iowa is just one of seven toss-up states, and the race could determine who controls the US Senate. Tonight's debate is airing statewide and will stream online. But before we get to the questions, here are tonight's debate rules.
Congresswoman Hinson and Representative Turek, you will have 60 seconds to answer a question. For a follow-up question or rebuttal, you will have 30 seconds to respond. If a clarification is needed, you will get 15 seconds. When time is up, you will hear this bell.
[bell and music] Each of you will have 30 seconds for a closing statement.
Welcome. And now that we have the debate rules, it is time for us to get started. Based on a card draw, Ms. Hinson, you will go first tonight, and we are going to begin with the topic of cancer in Iowa. Iowans need to know everything possible is being done to protect them.
Iowa has the second highest rate of new cancer cases in the United States. A University of Iowa study recently found 22,000 Iowans will be diagnosed and 6,000 more will die yet this year. Nitrate levels, of course, play a large part in that. Farmers get $14 billion a year in subsidies. Ms. Hinson, the question is: should those subsidies be tied to reducing fertilizer runoff and lowering the amount of nitrates in order to keep Iowans safe? You have 60 seconds.
Well, Tim and Amanda, thank you for the questions tonight and for being here to host the debate. And Josh, thank you as well for being here. You know, it is important that we get to the bottom of our cancer rates here in Iowa. Cancer does not discriminate who it affects. It's not a Republican or Democrat that it's affecting. It's an American problem and it's an Iowa problem. And we need to solve it. I think farmers are a part of the conversation, absolutely. Farmers are the environmentalists. They know what they need to do to help make sure we have clean drinking water. And all of us need to be able to turn on our faucet and know the water that we're drinking is safe to drink. Just last week I had the opportunity to tour a water treatment facility right here in the Des Moines area to learn about the process and what they're doing to take out these contaminants that are in there, whether it's nitrates or PFAS or anything else that might be concerning in our water. We need to obviously have the investments and the infrastructure to be able to clean our water. That's something I'm proud to have been able to deliver as a member of the US House. Millions of dollars in investment in water infrastructure as well. So, farmers I think should have a part in this as well. But we also need to make sure we're investing in the infrastructure to keep our water clean.
Thank you for that. Mr. Turek, the same question: should those subsidies be tied to reducing fertilizer runoff and lowering the amount of nitrates, all in an effort to keep our Iowans healthy? You have 60 seconds.
No, but I can tell you that we certainly have a cancer crisis that is being driven by the water quality crisis, and certainly it's something that has touched my life very deeply and personally. I lost my grandmother to pancreatic cancer. My father, due to his exposure to Agent Orange, has dealt with cancer. And nearly the day I launched my campaign, my sister was diagnosed with stage two breast cancer. I worked very hard in the Iowa legislature to expand cancer coverage to firefighters, to provide some state appropriation to cancer coverage. The reality is that Representative Hinson has pulled $33 million in research due to the DOGE cuts, four times voted in favor of reducing the Clean Water Act, and taken thousands of dollars from Chinese companies and tried to provide them immunity. I think the way that we go about this is we need more funding to infrastructure for nitrate removal plants, but also to our farmers. Our farmers want to do the right thing. And I think incentives to them for cover crops and land barriers and to not put down fertilizer in the winter months is the best way to address this.
Thank you. And I have a quick follow-up for both of you. Mr. Turek first: should the federal government in heavy ag states like Iowa require home water filtration systems to be built into every home, perhaps? Or have homes retrofitted? 30 seconds.
I'm not in favor of the government mandating anything in this area, but I will tell you, especially as our farmers are legitimately struggling. I mean, we are looking at a second farm crisis. We're looking at a farm again. We lead the nation in farm foreclosures and seeing farm suicide rates skyrocketing. Our farmers need the help, and I think that the best way is to provide them genuine incentives to address this water quality crisis.
Ms. Hinson, I'll give you the same chance. Or should the government in these heavy ag states require home filtration systems or possibly retrofit homes, all in an effort to keep Iowans healthy? 30 seconds.
Well, if we're looking at any program, we would need to get to the bottom of the data, right? Does it actually do what we need it to do? And that would be the question I would ask about the funding that would go with any of those programs. The most important part about this is making sure that the funding streams go where they need to go, whether that's to our farmers to help support the conservation practices and techniques. We know investment in fertilizer equipment and making sure we're using less is really critical. We have great investments in R&D happening right here in Iowa to make sure that our farmers are doing more with less. But you have to show up to vote for things like pediatric cancer research, and I've invested in legislation to make sure that we're redirecting those resources to get to where it needs to go to help get to the bottom of this cancer crisis.
Thank you. Let's pause for just a second. You mentioned the votes, it's been very prominent during the campaign. Mr. Turek, I'll just ask: you missed those votes, and I guess my question is, why did you miss them? Were you campaigning?
Yeah, look, something I'm proud of in my time in the Iowa legislature: one of the most bipartisan, one of the most effective members of the Iowa legislature. More than 700 times voted with Republicans. I think you take that in contrast with Representative Hinson, the least bipartisan member of the Iowa delegation. I have gone out there, and I have met with Iowans all over the state, all 99 counties. Hundreds of public forums. Meanwhile, Ashley Hinson, since she's decided to run for U.S. Senate, has not done one in-person town forum. Also, in my first three years in the legislature, more than a 90% attendance record.
I want to ask again, though: why did you miss those votes?
I'm out campaigning. I'm out meeting Iowans all over, all 99 counties. I've done hundreds of in-person town halls. Meanwhile, Ashley Hinson, since she's running for the U.S. Senate, has not done a single in-person town hall.
I'll give you 30 seconds to respond.
Absolutely. I've done more town halls than the percentage of time he showed up to work this year. 42% of the time is all Representative Turek showed up to work this year, and that's two out of every five days of work. And I think Iowans, if you're watching tonight, you should know: if you don't show up to work two out of five days, you're not getting a promotion, you're getting fired. I am proud of my bipartisan record working with both parties to get things across the finish line. I rank in the top 20% of bipartisan lawmakers in Congress, and I have a 99% attendance record even while running a statewide campaign.
Thank you both for those comments. We're going to move ahead.
We're going to move ahead. Thank you both.
On September 28th, President Trump announced the largest steel plant in US history would be coming to Southeast Iowa. This reminds us of 2017 when President Trump announced Foxconn's plan for a $10 million Wisconsin factory and up to 13,000 jobs. The project was scaled back after taxpayers spent hundreds of millions on infrastructure. And now Iowa is promised this $15 billion steel plant with Mesabi Metallics, but Radio Iowa just reported on October 5th that Mesabi had not acquired land, had not obtained construction permits, or finalized financing. Wisconsin had performance-based tax incentives, too. But tonight, I am asking about the roads and utilities that are built before the jobs arrive. Mr. Turek, if this Mesabi steel plant is canceled or scaled back, who pays for that infrastructure, the company or Iowans? You have 60 seconds.
Well, I was proud to vote for the bill, honestly. I think that a project like this could absolutely be transformative for the state of Iowa and certainly for Southeastern Iowa. We're one of three states seeing our economy contract. We certainly need the jobs. This project is looking at providing 1,700 full-time good-paying jobs and somewhere between 6,000 and 7,000 construction workers. I think that we have good protections in place to taxpayers. There's no upfront state money. The incentives are only there if they provide the actual jobs and metrics achieved. But I would say on the infrastructure, that should be covered by the company themselves.
Ms. Hinson, same question. If this Mesabi steel plant is canceled or scaled back, who pays for that infrastructure? The company or Iowans? You have 60 seconds.
Thank you, Amanda, for that question. I think it's really critical that we have this kind of investment coming to Iowa. You look at what this means for our national security and our local economy. We are going to now be a part of this supply chain for steel right here in the United States, so we can be competitive with countries that are not looking out for our best interests like the Chinese Communist Party. We're not going to be able to produce steel right here at home to supercharge our defense manufacturing base and make sure we have what we need here in the United States. So, this is a critical investment in Iowa, and yeah, taxpayers should not be on the hook for this kind of investment if it goes awry. I think to Representative Turek's point, I think we would agree on that, that taxpayers should not be on the hook. We need definite accountability measures built in, and I think what's important about the policies we've put into place is that they are going to supercharge potential future investments just like this one. Hopefully, we can make sure everything has those protections in place, but thanks to the Working Families Tax Cut Bill, we have the long-term tax certainty, so people are willing to make huge capital investments like the $15 billion one that's coming to Iowa.
Ms. Hinson, I have a follow-up about this. The federal government is loaning Mesabi $770 million to get the project off the ground. Does it concern you at all that this company has filed for bankruptcy before? You have 30 seconds.
Of course, anytime there's any concern about a past business dealing, I want to know that full transparency of a project and what's happening with the company involved. I think it's important to look at the situation in the context for what happened before. They were dealing with Minnesota that did not want to have any mining happen. It was a completely different time, a different administration. We are now unleashing American energy and American independence, which means we're going to be mining that ore in Minnesota and then bringing it right down here to Iowa. So, full accountability is important and full transparency about the context of what happened is also important.
Mr. Turek, same follow-up question to you. The federal government is loaning Mesabi $770 million to get the project off the ground. Does it concern you that the company has filed for bankruptcy before? You have 30 seconds.
Yeah, certainly there is a concern, but again, I was proud to vote for this project because I think that this is something that can be genuinely transformative to the state of Iowa and to Southeast Iowa. I think that we have put good guardrails in place on this. Again, no upfront state money. We've got guardrails that the incentives only come in if the jobs and metrics are achieved, and these tax incentives come in over a 10-year period of time. And I'm really, really hopeful that this comes in. It would be transformative for the state of Iowa. We need the jobs.
Tim has our next question about diesel prices.
Thank you, Amanda. President Trump has struck a deal with Vladimir Putin to bring Russian diesel to the US, aiming to lower costs for farmers and truckers, but that deal also eases sanctions designed to restrict the energy revenue that helps fund Russia's war against Ukraine. Ms. Hinson, do you support buying Russian diesel to lower costs for Iowans even if those purchases help Putin finance his war against Ukraine? Yes or no, and please explain. You have 60 seconds.
We need to lower gas prices in this country. We need to lower diesel prices, but I don't think we need to be making a deal with Russia to do it. I think we should be doing it by lowering the gas tax temporarily, making sure we're actually looking at potentially a diesel rebate program for our producers, investing in America's biofuels, which is the homegrown answer that we have right here in Iowa. So, E15, and then I've advocated for putting into place the biodiesel tax credit, which would be an immediate $1 off to provide that relief. But again, I am proud to have voted for sanctions against Russia. I'm banned from Russia because of my stance on being tough on them and supporting Ukraine, and we cannot allow Vladimir Putin to win that war.
Mr. Turek, the same question to you. Do you support buying Russian diesel to lower the cost for Iowans even if those purchases help Putin finance his war against Ukraine? Again, you have 60 seconds. Yes or no, and please explain.
We actually agree on this. I want to do everything that I can because everywhere I'm going all across Iowa, I'm hearing from Iowans talking about gas prices and diesel prices, but I don't think it should be at the expense of benefiting the economy of someone like a Vladimir Putin who we clearly cannot trust. I put forth a program to temporarily suspend the federal and state gas tax. I think that we should open the strategic oil reserves, and I think that we should suspend exports of diesel. I think that would really move the needle in a serious way. But let's remember exactly why we're in this situation. We are in this situation because of this unnecessary war in Iran that Ashley Hinson voted in favor of continuing seven times. This has led to gas prices going up in Iowa more than almost any other state, diesel prices being at an all-time high as our farmers are going into harvest. And it's leading into an increase in fertilizer and input prices to our farmers. It has disproportionately hurt Iowa. We need to end this war in Iran.
Thank you. I have a follow-up for both of you. First, Mr. Turek: should Putin have to agree to a ceasefire before getting that sanction relief, before letting that happen? You have 30 seconds.
I think that there are other ways that we can go about this without benefiting the economy or trusting someone like Vladimir Putin. And so again, I put forth a policy that I think can really move the needle on this, and let's temporarily suspend the federal and state gas tax. Let's open up the strategic reserves, and let's suspend exports of diesel. But I am laser-focused on this.
Ms. Hinson, the same follow-up there. Would you agree to that ceasefire? Should Putin have to agree to a ceasefire before getting the sanctions relief? 30 seconds.
Absolutely. I think we need to bring an end to the war in Ukraine, and we need to bring an end to the war in Iran. It's why I called for an immediate and successful end. I do not think Iran should be allowed to get a nuclear weapon. So, I think we do need to bring it to an end as quickly as possible, and I've been working directly with farmers to figure out ways where we can provide them relief. You know, you talk about fertilizer costs. We've been hearing about that for a long time before the Iran war, but I advocated directly to the administration and USDA to get the countervailing duties removed so we could lower those fertilizer prices. And we're working on making sure we're holding the big companies accountable so that we have less market fluctuation problems as well for our farmers.
Thank you. And Amanda has our next question, and it is about the Iran war.
It is indeed. This is personal to Iowans, the Iran war is. To date, two of our soldiers have died. And tonight, we would like to take a moment to honor them and their sacrifice: Sergeant Declan Cody of West Des Moines and Major Jeffrey O'Brien of Waukee. You both are calling for an end to the war. Mr. Turek, what is an acceptable end, and would you accept Iran being in control of the Strait of Hormuz? You have 60 seconds.
Well, this issue is personal to me as well. I come from a family of veterans. Both of my grandfathers served in World War II in the Navy. My father, the day he turned 18, enlisted to serve his country to go to Vietnam. Because of his exposure to Agent Orange is the reason why I ended up with my disability of spina bifida. I am an example of the generational consequences of these forever wars. We spent, you know, a trillion dollars in Afghanistan and in Iraq. Why? For what? I served with these brave men and women missing arms, missing legs. Here we find ourselves yet again in another forever conflict. We're spending more than a billion dollars a day over in Iran while we're being told we don't have money for schools and roads and hospitals, and we're leading the nation in farm foreclosures. No one wants to see Iran have a nuclear weapon, but we have to end this war, and we have to end this war immediately.
A 30-second follow-up for you. What would you consider to be an acceptable end to the war?
As soon as possible. I think that we need to end this war as quickly as possible. I think that this war in Iran has hurt Iowans more than any other state. You're looking at the two Iowans that we've already lost. You've got gas prices that have gone up more in Iowa than any other state. You've got diesel prices at an all-time high and fertilizer prices. I'm talking to farmers, century farmers, that are telling me they're looking at their input prices because of this conflict and saying, 'I'm not going to be able to afford this. I'm going to go into foreclosure.' We need to end this war immediately.
Ms. Hinson, again, you are both calling for an end to the war. You used the word immediate and successful end. What is an acceptable end, and would you accept Iran being in control of the Strait of Hormuz? You have 60 seconds.
First of all, I don't think we can trust Iran. That needs to be very clear. We need to go into every negotiation eyes wide open. We saw the disastrous deal that happened where our pallets of cash went to Iran to help them fund what was the makings of a huge nuclear program and the ballistic missiles that they're now using to attack our allies in the Middle East. So, that's wrong. We cannot have that kind of an outcome ever again. So, successful end to me means we have to have assurances that there will never be a nuclear program in Iran. I trust the US military to achieve that objective, whatever that looks like. I've met with our generals, had those conversations, but I've also met with the families. You put the pictures up of our soldiers who have passed away. I've been to those funerals. I went to four funerals in the last eight, nine months. I hope I never have to go to another one. I think it's so challenging to sit with a family and grieve alongside of them. So I don't want to see that happen to another family, and nobody wants a forever war. My boys are 15 and 13, and it would be them fighting in that next generation of fighters. So I want it to come to a close as soon as possible.
Ms. Hinson, 30-second follow-up: would you accept Iran being in control of the Strait of Hormuz? 30 seconds.
Again, I don't think you can trust Iran. We've seen how they've behaved. You have to take them at how they're acting, not what they're saying. And I think at this point, making sure we have protections for our allies in the Middle East. I don't want to see the United States get stuck there for decades, but I think we need to make sure that, again, the successful end of this war is that Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon and that we are protecting our allies in the region long-term, because that's good. Every dollar spent abroad needs to advance American interests, and I think it's in everybody's interest that we support our allies in the Middle East.
One more follow-up for you, Ms. Hinson. Would you switch your vote today on the War Powers Act in order to end the conflict in Iran? Yes or no? 30 seconds.
I don't think we need another resolution on the House floor. I think the president and the US military can bring it to the end. So at this point, I take every vote at the time it comes, but I think it does need to come to a resolute and successful end as quickly as possible.
Okay, Tim is next with more on data centers now.
Yeah, let's turn to data centers. There's a controversy in Iowa. Communities across the state right now, like Woodward here in Central Iowa, Salix over in Western Iowa, folks living there have plenty of questions as well as mounting concerns. Ms. Hinson, do you support a federal temporary moratorium on the construction of data centers? Yes or no, and please explain. You've got 60 seconds.
Well, thank you for that question, Tim. As I'm traveling through all 99 counties, I certainly am hearing a lot of concerns, a lot of community feedback around data centers and where they're going in our communities. And I do think that conversation needs to happen at the local level. Local communities know best what is going to fit in their community. If they want to use it as an economic development opportunity, they should be having those conversations, but I'm hearing concerns about utility rates. What are we doing to make sure we're keeping people's utility rates protected? I was proud to vote for the ratepayer protection package on the House floor a few weeks ago, which would make sure we're not passing that cost on to taxpayers and ratepayers. I think that's absolutely critical. And then people want to also know their water is not only safe, but that it's going to be there as a consumer as well. So, those are the concerns that I continue to hear. I don't think we need to interfere on the federal level. There are some basic things that we can do, again, to control costs that are being passed on to ratepayers.
So, you would not support a federal temporary moratorium?
I think those conversations are best had at the local level.
Okay. Mr. Turek, the same question to you. Do you support a federal temporary moratorium on the construction of data centers? Yes or no? Please explain. You have 60 seconds as well.
No, but I can tell you this: in traveling the state for the last 400 days and going to all 99 counties, I certainly have heard over and over and over the concerns from Iowans. And I think that the concerns are primarily through three lenses. The first is no more tax breaks to these large multinational tech companies, and we certainly can't trust Ashley Hinson on this issue. She has voted for $50 billion in tax incentives to these tech companies. I think that they should be paying their fair share. Secondly, I've heard over and over from Iowans concerned about their energy rates going up. I think we need lock-solid guardrails in place to ensure that these companies are not driving up the energy rates to the end user. And thirdly, and arguably most importantly, especially in a state with a water quality crisis that's leading to a cancer crisis, is making sure that these companies are not using and abusing our natural resources like water. I think they should be required to have a closed-loop circuit which can reduce water consumption somewhere between 70 and 90%.
Ms. Hinson, I'll give you a quick 15 seconds to make a response if you'd like.
Absolutely. A data center should not get big federal tax breaks, and that's not what I supported. I actually supported making sure we're investing in opportunity zones, which are places where we need definite economic development. The only reason the ratepayer protection bill is not law is because Democrats in the Senate blocked it. And so, I'm pretty sure that my colleague over here would have aligned with Chuck Schumer, his boss in the US Senate, to have to vote no on that.
And Mr. Turek, I do have another follow-up. Should federal law require data center developers to cover all infrastructure costs, including those left behind if a project doesn't happen, if it closes? You have 30 seconds.
Yes, absolutely. Again, we should not be looking out and giving tax breaks to these large multinational tech corporations. We should be doing what we can to protect Iowa and to protect the tax rates here. The same thing that I said on the infrastructure when it comes to the steel plant: let's protect Iowans. No more tax breaks to these large multinational tech companies.
Ms. Hinson, you get 30 seconds as well. Should federal law require data center developers to cover all the infrastructure costs, including those that are left behind if it doesn't happen? Again, you have 30 seconds.
Well, I think similarly to the moratorium conversation, I think that it should be on the local level to make those decisions. Who's on the hook? That should be a conversation that they're having at the local level. If it's local taxpayer driven, they should decide what the mechanisms are. But I do think that is a serious concern that our taxpayers would demand on the local level. I know I certainly would want to make sure that I, as a taxpayer myself, wouldn't be on the hook. But I think it's really important, again, we continue to try to find ways to incentivize good development and stop bad development in our communities.
All right, let's move to another question.
The Department of Energy is investing nearly $2 billion to reopen the Duane Arnold Nuclear Plant in Linn County. The plant already has a contract with Google to supply its AI energy needs for the next 25 years. Mr. Turek, why are taxpayers on the hook for a private company's project like this one with Google? You have 60 seconds.