Hello and welcome to the Politics War Room with James Carville, and I'm Al Hunt. This week our guests are the historian and the greatest expert on the Founding Fathers, Joseph Ellis, and the Iowa Democratic Senate candidate, Josh Turek. Remember, we love taking your questions. So write to
[email protected] for next week's show. We'll get to as many as we can, but don't forget to tell us where you're from. You can also get text updates about what's next for Politicon and Politics War Room by signing up at politicon.com. Tell your friends about us. Remind them to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And please check out the link to our sponsor, Hims, and our episode show notes. We thank you for supporting our sponsors. It really helps make this podcast happen.
James, I still think the Democrats are going to score impressive gains in November, but the results in Colorado this week were not very encouraging. A democratic socialist — I think I'm pronouncing her name right, Maiti Kirros — a 29-year-old passionately anti-Israeli democratic socialist knocked off a 15-term incumbent. So it's not just deep urban blue areas where the democratic socialists are scoring some gains, and they are very left-wing. As an aside, I also was sad that Michael Bennet, one of the most thoughtful people in American politics, lost his race for governor to a very aggressive anti-Trump attorney general. That guy is not a socialist. And I'm happy that Colorado's other senator, John Hickenlooper, who defeated a left-winger, will be back.
But, you know, this is an issue that the mainstream of the party is going to have to address. Some of it is ideological. Some of it is simply age. And what progressive Democrats, not socialists, have to do is more aggressively make their case. Emphatically, what they're not for — they're not for defunding ICE, they're not for emptying prisons — but what they are for: reforming ICE, restoring the drastic Trump Medicaid cuts, increasing the minimum wage, making the wealthy pay more taxes. Those are winning issues, and they shouldn't get caught up in a long discussion about whether they agree with the socialists on various things.
There's also the troubling issue of antisemitism, which, you know, unquestionably afflicts some of these democratic socialists. Even some question Israel's right to exist. Look, I think the vast majority of Democrats, James, and you have a better feel for this than I do, I think the vast majority support an Israel that has been a great ally. They see Netanyahu as a disaster and look forward to his fall and defeat sometime in October and a much better prime minister. They're open to investigating war crimes in Gaza and they want a Palestinian state. But it's also imperative to call out antisemitism where it's blatant, which, by the way, is more prevalent in the Republican ranks than it is in the Democratic ranks.
Well, I guess I have multiple thoughts. It probably took me a little bit longer than today to synthesize them. First of all, I think the age thing has played a big, big deal, and there's just young people who think that our generation, a generation even after us, has just failed them. And what's particularly distressing — I guess I don't know if distressing is factual — is this is happening in sub-5% unemployment. I mean, economy costs are terrible. We got all kinds of issues within it, but this is nothing like what a real economic downturn looks like, and you're having this reaction.
I think the very idea of everything that we thought — pluralism being at the core of the philosophy, the idea that a regulated economy with a strong safety net and strong social insurance was the way for the United States to go — and for a long time that proved to be correct. I think it's still correct, but people don't have any faith in it. And it's a very, very, very taxing time. I mean, the only thing on the horizon coming up would be the nomination of a Democratic candidate for president in 2028. I think that's going to be it. But I just think the party may have to splinter.
I just don't — I go back to the same thing. I don't know if — I'm old, so who cares — but there are people younger than me that kind of agree with pluralism and agree with this kind of stuff. And I don't — it may be that people always talked about the end of the two-party system. We might be seeing pretty close to the end of it. There's certainly no place for anything you would think of as a traditional John McCain, Mitt Romney Republican. They got nowhere to go. So I don't know where this is going, but it's hard for me to see that the two parties are going to dominate American politics in the future as they have in the past.
James, I don't think it's possible to be in the same tent with that woman who won in New York with the terrible things she said, or perhaps even the woman who won in Colorado. I do think it's possible to be in the same tent with AOC, with differences. It's possible to be in the same tent with Jayapal, with differences. And I think age is clearly a factor. And I don't believe in age limits, but I think people who are older ought to be encouraged to take their pension and go do something else productive.
But I want to just pick up — and you can pick up on any of that — but I said earlier that some of this hate stuff and some of this antisemitism is greater in Republican ranks, and they don't get hit with it as much. But it's so prevalent. Just look at the House. Just look at someone like Andy Ogles who says all Muslims should be deported and America has no place for gays. Or Paul Gosar in Arizona who said one of his good friends is Nick Fuentes, the Holocaust denier and white nationalist. Or your friend — I say very sarcastically — in Louisiana, Clay Higgins, who went and filmed himself in Auschwitz.
I mean, there are great haters in the administration. There are real antisemites. Paul and Gracia, the leader of the Office of Special Counsel, and a woman named Wilson over at the Pentagon. But they don't get hit with this, James, the way Democrats get hit with it. But their right wing is bigger, more vicious, and more viral than some of what I consider the new Democratic crazies.
So, of course, everything you say is true, but that doesn't — it's horrible. I mean, we could talk about it more, but JD Vance saying Watergate was a parking ticket. Okay, it's not up. It might have been, but whatever. Okay, but the Democratic Party — and I never had a problem being in the same coalition with AOC or Jayapal or, for that matter, Ilhan Omar. I mean, by you, they're probably what I would have considered, you know, out there, in the same coalition I am. But this new crop that's coming in is entirely different. This is not the same thing.
This is some kind of — and I don't — I think people might be voting for it and hadn't thought about it. I don't know what they're doing, but I got to tell you, I don't see this doing anything. That Colorado is Denver, so it's a pretty urban Democratic district, but that's not the case yet. This is the new trend, and it's a very disturbing trend. And you think people are just looking for a quick solution to just do anything that they can to stop the pain they're going through, and I got news for you: there are no quick solutions.
I go back to: I don't know why we don't embrace the Elizabeth Warren, Bernie — bust the cap on Social Security. That's a dream of a lifetime sitting right in front of us. But somehow or another, no one wants to pick up.
Well, there is an agenda to embrace that is, you know, far from tepid. It may seem tepid to that woman in Colorado or that woman in Manhattan, but, you know, it's not tepid. And when people talk about — look, I hear all these democratic socialists say the overwhelming majority of Americans are for Medicare for all. What if you say Medicare for all? Yeah. Elizabeth Warren got savaged in 2019. It almost was the beginning of the end of her campaign, because basically people say, 'I don't want to lose my health insurance.' And you ought to build on the Affordable Care Act. You ought to do away with those Medicaid cuts. And maybe you build to have a public option. Maybe you build towards Medicare for all someday. But we ain't ready for it yet. These people are not into building.
Okay. But understand now they're into anger. You know, we let the Al Hunts and James Carvilles and Obamas and Clintons and Pelosis and the whole goddamn freak show just get run over, and meanwhile wealth inequality just skyrockets, opportunity plummets, and we got to stand up and we got to do something, goddamn it. The same people that are telling us to be incremental and build on things are the same people that got us in this. Okay, that's what they would say.
And now you're only getting me started on four people on the Supreme Court that don't believe in birthright citizenship, which is what I've been talking about. Professor Ellis is as clear as a bell — it's right there in the Constitution. I'm really scared for the United States. I'm really in — and meanwhile we've been talking about all this, we're drowning, we're suffocating in corruption, and I think a lot.
Yeah, I frankly was very depressed by that Supreme Court final couple of days. I mean, then the narrative, which is what they wanted, was, well, they called balls and strikes on the one hand, on the other hand. And I mean, birthright citizenship was enacted by constitutional amendment in 1868, the 14th Amendment, and, you know, suddenly Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh say, hey, you know, we've been wrong for 170 years or whatever it is. And yeah, they denied Trump a few things, but they gave him a lot more. This was a 90% pro-Trump Supreme Court.
And I love — they did a campaign finance thing which was intended to advantage the Republicans. I think it's exaggerated. I don't think it's going to make a huge difference, but I love Brett Kavanaugh saying this will even the playing field for Republicans and Democrats. If it was going to do that, you can rest assured that that Republican operative, Brett Kavanaugh, would have opposed it. So I'm glad they did a couple of things. I'm glad that at least five members said that you can't summarily fire a Federal Reserve governor because you have this absolute henchman, Bill Culty, making a false charge. So I think the court session this year is pretty damn depressing.
James, I think it's — Oh, first of all, it says the people who were born here are citizens thereof. It's not a — see, they didn't do you a favor. All right. They didn't do you a favor. It wasn't some act of objectivity. Don't get Barrett and Roberts. They don't believe in the 14th Amendment. They don't believe in any of the Reconstruction Amendments. They never have. And they have never believed in the First Amendment. And you know what? Look at just what they're doing — the wrecking ball. The whole thing is — meanwhile we can debt like crazy. So, paper Trump — we know Trump made $2 billion since he's been there.
I just — maybe I'm going to be better. Maybe I'm — I've been in Milan, but I've been here for three or four days. I don't think I'm jet-lagged. I'm just really fearful for the United States. I mean, in ways that I don't think I could have ever been. It's just beyond awful. And I'm so glad we got Professor Ellis, because there's a lot that I won't.
We're going to buck you up when you come back, James. It's bad, but it's also correctable, sort of. You know, one of my favorite things in that Lisa Cook case: Clarence Thomas said individuals don't own the offices they occupy. I wish Justice Thomas would explain that to the president of the United States. And I wish he would vote accordingly. But of course, only when it's what he considers to be a Democrat does he say that and feel that way. Lots to talk about, and I hope you're going to be back on our land next week. Are you?
Probably at the end of the week. I'm really trying to help you out, and all my World War II museum people are going to be in Innsbruck. And I got to tell you, I got a grandchild coming, so that motivates me to come home for sure. But I got to say, I am not disturbed at all that I'm not here for the Fourth of July. I'm really not.
I'm not anti anything. I'm just so down on the whole thing. And I'm down on everything that you can imagine. And you know what we're doing is we're facing a staggering, difficult time. And I just think that our primary voters in some areas — I know it's not typical — are going for quick fixes. And there's no quick fix out there. No.
Well, James, I'm going to tell you, I'm not going to pay any attention to any of the charades that Trump has. He's wrecked the Fourth of July, which always has been a great, great holiday. You know, I compare it to what Gerald Ford did for the 200th when he went to Valley Forge and he went to Independence Hall, saw the tall ships come in, and he tried to unify the country. And this guy instead has a cage fight on the White House lawn and says we're going to have the greatest Trump rally of all. So just ignore Trump, and you can ignore him in Washington as well as over in Italy.
But I will tell you, you have a grandchild coming — oh, that's special. My eight-year-old grandchild has become a real soccer fan. So he's kind of — he got me into the world soccer stuff, which I was not into, as you know. And his team — he cheers for — but you know the team he loves? I'm not quite sure why, Norway. He loves the Norwegian team.
That's how they got — he's unbelievable. I mean, I had friends that follow it. I'm into it because everybody else is. Yeah. Yeah. I saw that. I haven't watched it all, but that Paraguay-Germany shootout was really one of the most exciting moments in any sport. I mean, I'm not a huge soccer fan, but that certainly was extraordinary.
Yeah, but I mean, it's obviously — you know — but I'm so relieved. I don't have — the desecration that's going on in Washington, D.C. It's just sickening. It's just desecration. It's just a goddamn sacrilege.
All right. And I don't know. You know, like I say, I'm so glad we have Professor Ellis, but it's coming up soon.
Lose weight with Hims. Well, we love talking about this, and I'll tell you one thing: you'll never see an old folks' home that's a fat person. I don't mean — I could go through reams of — in addition, it's just beneficial, and people should obviously do everything they can to keep their weight in check. I know some people have conditions that they can't, and it's terrible. I know people like that, feel sorry for them, but 95% of the population can affect their weight. You know, if you felt stuck trying to lose weight, join the club. But thanks to science and better understanding of the human body, there are more effective options out there than ever. Enter Weight Loss by Hims. It's designed to support you in reaching your goals.
And Hims now offers access to an affordable range of FDA-approved GLP-1 medications, including the Wegovy pill and the Wegovy pen. Now, the results are incredible, and it's an amazing, effective tool for you or the women in your life that you care about. With Wegovy at Hims, lose up to 20% or more of your body weight combined with diet and exercise. It helps you regulate your appetite, eat less, and keep weight off. Plus, Wegovy is the first-ever GLP-1 pill for weight loss. That means no needles are needed. Everything is 100% online, and Hims connects you with a licensed provider who will determine if treatment is right for you. If prescribed, your medication is delivered right to the door. No insurance necessary.
And it doesn't stop there. Weight Loss by Hims goes beyond medication by offering access to 24/7 messaging with your care team and tons of in-app lifestyle and nutrition tips like recipes, meal plans, fitness videos, sleep content, and more. Even better, with a range of affordable GLP-1 options, Hims makes it simple to find an approach that fits your need and your budget. If eligible, you'll get a treatment plan personalized to you and unlimited dosage changes as needed. It's weight loss designed to work with your life. Are you ready to reach your goals? Visit forhims.com/warroom to get personalized, affordable care that gets you. That's forhims.com/warroom.
Again, forhims.com/warroom. Weight Loss by Hims is not available in all 50 states. Wegovy is the registered trademark of Novo Nordisk. To get started and learn more, including important safety information, Wegovy clinical study information, and restrictions, visit forhims.com, and the link is also in our show notes.
James, this weekend America celebrates our 250th birthday. And our guest is the foremost — I don't use that word lightly — scholar on those Founding Fathers, having written books on Jefferson, Adams, Washington, and others. His latest book was on the contradictions and mistakes that those great men made. Joe, let me start. Sometimes I think people overlook, or they don't know, that what those men in Philadelphia did not only was remarkable in calling for a government with the consent of the governed and breaking away from England — it was an act of courage. It was an act of great courage. There were real risks involved.
Yeah. I'll tell you a quick little story. When they initially — Virginia made a proposal on July 2nd that these colonies are and have every right to be independent states. Adams thought that was the day we were going to celebrate. He told Abigail that, and you got everything right, even to fireworks. But after that vote, the representative from Virginia — whose name I have my Biden-esque moments here — who escaped, went over to the representative from Massachusetts, and he said, 'I am lucky and you are very unlucky, because I am fat, and when they come to hang me I'll die quickly, but you will twist in the wind for many minutes and hours, maybe.' So Jefferson wasn't wrong when he said our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor.
They were being asked to make a commitment to a cause which, if they lost, was — you know, Washington's head would be cut off and placed on stands in London. So yeah, a lot was at stake there. And I think that if you think about it too, how can 13 colonies who have no history of cooperation — quite the opposite — come together and defeat the dominant military and economic power in the world, which they proceeded to do? And so we're celebrating — and the Declaration of Independence itself, written on the 4th or submitted for vote on the 4th, and that's the date the printer put on the edition, and that's why the 4th becomes the date.
If you ever want to question whether it's the right date, 50 years later to the day, Jefferson and Adams both died. And Jefferson's last words were, 'Is it the 4th?' And Adams's last words were, 'Jefferson still lives,' but he didn't.
Joe, let me — most of what I've learned, I've learned from Joe Ellis. But I think there were a number of enormously smart, courageous, and brilliant men back then. But sort of the big four of Philadelphia were Jefferson, Adams, Franklin, and Washington, who wasn't there. Is that a fair summation? And tell us why.
Yeah, I would say there's six. I would put Franklin in that list too.
I did. I did. Oh, you did? Okay.
And you're right, Washington was up in — well, he was in Boston, ready to come down to defend New York, but he's going to almost lose the war in one battle there in the beginning. But I think that — you know, I've got my own — you know, I'm the historian of the founders, so-called. But I think that Washington was the greatest leader, probably the greatest leader in American history. Jefferson was the most skilled writer. Adams was the most honest among them all.
Adams believed, by the way, that human nature was driven by emotion. Jefferson believed it was driven by intelligence. And then there's Madison, who makes the list. Well, the other one is Alexander Hamilton. Hamilton would have got the highest score on the SATs. He's the smartest and the most dangerous in some ways, but Madison was the best at internal politics. If God were in the details, Adams would have been there to greet him upon arrival.
So you've got a collection of talent here. And one of the Ellis points over the years has been: none of these people were divine. All of these people were imperfect human beings. New nations, especially new world powers, seem to require mythological heroes, like, you know, like Romulus and Remus for Rome. And let's say anyway, these were not mythical figures. And in some ways, the strength of the founding generation is the fact that they don't all agree. I mean, they agree on independence — you have to agree on that one. But there's built-in checks and balances, if you will, inside the founders themselves.
Joe, let me pick up on that with two in particular that you've written about. I think it's hard to imagine two people more different than Jefferson and Adams. You already cited one difference. And they later became great adversaries until their post-presidency, but they worked pretty well together that summer in Philadelphia, didn't they?
Oh, yeah. Adams was the guy who had led the way in the Congress on the debate towards independence. He had embraced that position, and he said all those who were waiting were waiting for a messiah that would never come. So he was — and in the play 1776, they do a good job with this, showing him — that Jefferson was pretty close in terms of coming along on the question of independence. And when the committee was created to draft a — and there's a portrait, it hangs in the Congress now, of a group of them, Jefferson, Adams, and Franklin are most visible, and they're standing before the president of Congress, and everybody thinks it's the signing ceremony for the Declaration on the 4th. It's not. It's June 28th, when the committee that drafted the Declaration turned it in.
When they met to draft it, everybody asked Franklin to write it, and Franklin said, 'I have a position: I never write anything that will be edited by a committee.' So the next one up was Adams, and Adams said, 'I shouldn't write it because I've made a lot of enemies in the Congress.' And then the next person was Jefferson, and Jefferson said, 'Okay, I'll do it.' And all the words that are in the Declaration were written by him except for one change made by probably Franklin. 'We hold these truths to be' — he wrote 'sacred and undeniable,' and Franklin changed it to 'self-evident.' Probably didn't want God in there at all.
At any rate, the thing that most of us need to grasp on this celebratory moment — in this celebratory moment, the answer to the question, what made the American Revolution a revolution? It's in the Declaration. All my friends want me to plug my book here, but no, I'm going to plug the primary source. Go home with your families and your friends and sit down, and you can call it up on your cell phone. Read the Declaration of Independence. Those are the most important 56 words in American history. The beginning, the preamble.
Probably in world history. And what do they do that makes the American Revolution a revolution? They reverse the tectonic plates of Western thought. Power does not flow downward from God to kings, but upward from that group called the people to their elected representatives. That's a revolution. Okay, that's the core of the American Revolution right there.
Wow. James Carville, you want to pick up on this with our great guest?
I definitely do, Professor. Of course, Walter Isaacson, my friend and fellow New Orleanian, called it the greatest sentence ever written. I would like to make my nomination for the greatest sentence ever written. And this is by one Joseph Ellis. Well, let me read the sentence. Okay. All right. I think because you — Democrats must finally treat the Republican Party as Republicans treat the Democratic Party, not as a partner in bipartisanship, but as an adversary. An adversary, in the case of the GOP, that will not respect the rules of democracy unless it is forced to by political defeat. That's where we are.
Goddamn it. We're not — we're not celebrating. This country is about to blow a gasket. And as long as you have — all right, people made mistakes. Well, we thought they were legit. We liked them, and we dealt with it. The only thing you can do with these people is defeat them, because they don't give a — I really believe that. It sounds terrible to say this, but if you think I'm wrong, tell me.
No, I'm with you all. We're on the same page, James. And without question, the republic is on the ballot.
And now your most famous phrase, which is justifiably so, is 'It's the economy, stupid,' and people are liable to vote this time on the cost of gas or something like that. But really, something much larger is at stake. And we're going to go forward or backward here. And again, the foreign people I've been talking to over the last week or two — somehow they all think I know something about this. Like the Germans I talked to, they said, 'Is it true that the current president of the United States has several heroes, but his greatest hero is Hitler?' And I said, 'Yeah, it's true.' And it's going to take a while.
And one of the things I also asked them is, to what extent will the rest of the world, after we've recovered from the Trump administration, begin to recognize us again as a world power? And they all said no. They said that, as far as they're concerned, Trump has destroyed our relationship with NATO and with all the other European powers.
But back to the point that James made — and you can be absolutely sure that the Republicans, the recent decision by the Supreme Court is going to allow them to outspend the Democrats two to one in this election or something like that. But we just need turnout, but we need people to recognize this might be the most important election they ever vote on. And most off-term elections only produce, oh, 50% of the normal outcrop. There's one group that seems to get it. That's the No Kings group, and there's several million Americans in that. And, you know, now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of the country.
So, Professor, I thought about that recently about 'It's the economy.' Okay, it's a great catchphrase. It's maybe one of the most oft-repeated things in politics. I now have come to detest the fact I said that. I'll tell you why. I listen to people who say people don't care about corruption, they care about the economy. As long as their incomes are up, they really don't care what he does. And I'm afraid that's right. But when I said it in 1992, you can say what you want about George H. W. Bush — he was not corrupt.
Okay. He was not a corrupt man at all. A decent man, too. Decent man.
That we have now — the breathtaking, staggering. And I understand people say, 'Hey, you know, you're right, that's all people care about is the economy.' And I won't do it. I don't say anything. I'm nice. I want to punch him in the face. Okay, I'm serious.
I hear you, brother. I hear you, because the phrase actually haunts me today. My wife said, 'Don't mention that to Carville because he's committed to it.' And I realize now you're not committed to it. And I understand completely what you're saying. But the truth is, James, even though you're absolutely right, I do think that the bulk of the American electorate, even in this coming election, is going to be driven by economic considerations.
I agree. And it pains me. And it might — we can get over high egg prices, the high gas prices. We can get over a lot of interest rates. You can't get over systemic, endemic, pervasive corruption. That's really — that's everything. And bounce back from — this is a troubling time. I — before I'm going to turn it back to Al, but very fortunate his history, and I love history. We don't even agree on history anymore. I mean, we're trying to change history. Yeah.
Ivy League — JD Vance says Watergate, which — I was 29 years old. I actually remember Watergate, and it was not a parking ticket. We can't even agree. They don't believe in this court. And I will say this right now, and people listen to me: they have never believed in the 14th Amendment. And my college professor told me that they can't stand the 14th Amendment. They think that the Reconstruction Amendments are illegitimate. And they also think the First Amendment, as it relates to religion, is illegitimate, because they claim — understand this — it only applies within Christianity. So you have to be a Baptist or a Methodist or — I don't know, Catholic, but I am. But that's catching hold, man.
Well, yeah. A lot of that comes out of Project 2025 stuff, you know, and in there is, we should be a Christian nation.
I mean, I don't know what that does to me. I'm an ex-Catholic, and it's a violation of the First Amendment. The First Amendment begins, you know, saying that the freedom to worship wherever you want to is one of the central freedoms of the Constitution. And why — I'll ask both of you this, but mostly James: why is the American electorate so stupid?
Albert, do you want to go? Oh, thanks. I don't know what I'm going to say.
I think I am slightly more of an optimist. I think they get things wrong, and usually they correct them, and you're right, they have to start in this midterm, in this next presidential election. But Joe, I want to go back to your most recent book, The Great Contradiction: The Tragic Side of the American Founding. The phrase 'all men are created equal,' inalienable rights, that lives for the ages, and yet it was really hypocrisy. How did they rationalize this contradiction, and could they have adopted the Declaration and later the Constitution if they had done the right thing and condemned slavery?
Those are all good questions. The book called The Great Contradiction says yes. On the one hand, you've got to be able to do two things. Think — what is it F. Scott Fitzgerald said? 'The sign of an intelligent person is the ability to hold two contradictory ideas in your head at the same time and still function.' Here are the two ideas. On the one hand, the American Revolution was an incredible moment. The leadership at that moment is the greatest collection of political leaders in American history. And they, as I said, reversed the tectonic plates of Western political thought, and they went on to win the war itself, and then only later, 11 years later, create a federal government under the Constitution. Those are all incredible achievements.
However, alongside those great achievements, there are two enormous failures, and they're both tragedies. One is the failure to end slavery. They did end it in the northern states, but not in the southern states, where 80% of the slaves were. And the second failure was a failure to reach a just accommodation with the Native Americans, that eventually led to their extermination over time. Those are two big failures, and they're failures because they both are contradictions of the values we claim we're fighting for in the Declaration.
I would say it depends on which founder you're talking about. Washington comes out looking pretty good on this one. He frees all his slaves. Jefferson doesn't. He never — none of the other prominent Virginians other than Washington freed their slaves. And Washington not only frees his slaves but attempts to avoid Indian removal by passing a law that would grant the Creek Nation a state — the current state of Alabama, as a matter of fact — and be admitted into the Union. It doesn't work.
Who can we blame here? Who can we blame?
Well, some of the founders fail here. I think Jefferson fails, Madison fails, as they become Virginians rather than Americans. Washington looks pretty darn good. But the United States faces this dilemma uniquely that no other European nation faces this dilemma. What do I mean? If you own slaves in Great Britain, France, or Spain, or Portugal, and you decide to free them, where are they? They're across an ocean. They're in Latin America. And if you free your slaves in the United States, where are they? They're right there. And they're 20% of the total American population.
Joe, I just think you just said that those founders were — I believe you said the greatest collection of leaders in American history. You told me once you thought they were the greatest collection of political leaders in the world. You haven't downgraded them, have you?
No. No, but whenever I said that, somebody from Europe would face me with an example of leadership, and I wasn't fully prepared to answer them with information. So I'll just stick with being an American historian here. They might have been the greatest in the world, but that's arguable.
Tell me this. What grade would Professor Ellis give them in percentages? You're looking at them, and you talked about some of the contradictions, you talked about some of the great — what percentage grade would you give them?
Well, you know, I'm an old teacher, and the grading system was A's and B's. I'd give Washington an A minus. He'd get the highest grade, probably. The rest of — well, I don't know. Washington gets slavery right, and he even attempts to avoid Indian removal. As I've written a biography of him, if I could rewrite it, I would give him a little bit more credit than I did in that biography.
The most disappointing of the founders is Jefferson. He is extraordinarily literate, and he's very outspoken on the slavery issue, saying it's wrong. However, he says that we can't free them until we send them elsewhere, because they'll intermarry and they will pollute the Anglo-Saxon purity of our race.
Meanwhile, on his plantation, he is fathering six black children.
Okay. And he is the Mona Lisa of American history. Is he smiling or not? He's like the dirigible above the Super Bowl, flashing information to both sides.
So Joe, would it be fair to — I think you told me, I don't know if you did or not — would it be fair to say they got it about 80% right?
Yeah. I mean, well, winning the war is big, and creating a republic is really big. These failures — I think many of them, including Washington, believed that they had to defer the slavery issue until 1807. Why that date? That was the date when they could end all importation of African-Americans or Africans. And the problem is that — and this is where my historical friends go nuts when I tell them this — that you have to be — well, if they had attempted to end slavery during the war, they might have lost the war, because the blacks would have gone over to the British side, and they would have lost the South.
But more importantly, during the Constitutional Convention, if they had insisted upon ending slavery, the Constitution would have never passed. It certainly would have never been affirmed. So you have to — a lot of my historian friends are presentists, and I think presentism is — if racism is the mortal sin of America, presentism is the mortal sin for historians. You've got to recover them on their own terms before you can make judgment. And in that moment, then, they faced a tough choice: namely, do we try to end slavery now, or do we defer it for a while? And that was Washington's position and most of the people in the Congress's position.
Joe, one final question. I turn it back to James to close this out. I think you believe that they would be very — they might be very proud of what they created today if they looked at it today. They would be very down on some of the things going on. I saw conservative historian Harvey Mansfield say the other day that the founders would probably be Republicans today. Do you believe that?
He's dead wrong on that. The one thing you can know if you read the correspondence of all the founders and you read the debates in the Congress over the Constitution, the one thing that they all agreed on is that we do not want to have a king, that we do not want to have a person who stands above the law. That was one thing they all agreed on. And so the Trump presidency is a violation of the values of the American Revolution as they understood them. And Republicans who try to claim the founders are as illiterate historically as anybody I've ever seen.
James, I think he's pretty clear on that. You have a final thought or two?
Yeah. You ask why people believe this stuff, and this is what I think, and this is my answer: myth is easy. History is hard.
Okay. I can't tell you — undergraduate, you sit there and you take a course on the American Revolution or whatever, and then you're talking about the Magna Carta and the Roundheads and the Cavaliers and the Restoration and John Locke, but you can't just pick up history at the revolution, right? It's — well, these guys got together in Philadelphia and they wrote this document, and they were very brave and were great Americans. It's more complicated, man. It is.
James, I am very impressed with your own thought process, and you're especially on the issue of, you know, what's at stake in this particular election, but that the history enrollments are down throughout the United States. These colleges have given their money to the sciences. When I left Mount Holyoke, there were 22 people in the history department. There are now three.
And if you gave a civics test to the American people, the civics tests that...
are required of all immigrants for citizenship, according to the most recent study, only 18% of them would pass. So we've got one of the most ignorant electorates in the Western world, and that's one of the major sources of the problem.
Well, I think it is. And I was fortunate, you know, even growing up in Louisiana, I had a very good undergraduate history education. And I'm always reminded, you know, Napoleon's definition of history. What is it? But an agreed-upon fable. And you're always fighting that.
You're always fighting that because fables are easy.
Yeah, slavery is complicated, and yeah, they did this and...
But I so agree with you on present... he can't... you know, Lincoln didn't then in 1960, he didn't run on freeing the slaves.
Right, right. During his presidency, he sent a committee to Central America to look for a place to send all the blacks once they were freed. And so he was thinking that they would all have to be removed. What Lincoln would have done if he hadn't been shot is an unanswerable question. He certainly opposed slavery, but he was also a person — he would have never won an election in Illinois if he hadn't said that he didn't believe in blacks living together with whites.
Yeah. And of course, now we got Miss Shiva, who doesn't believe in interracial dating. That's where the progressive movement is. Okay, we have some bad things going on, but the best thing we had going on today was Joe Ellis.
Joe, you know, and please thank Ellen. We couldn't have pulled this... Well, thank that woman that you're married to, too, because she's doing God's work out there as we speak, you know, and she's trying to help us understand why people are making the decisions, political decisions they are. I've enjoyed this. I hope I've made sense. James, welcome to the — I welcome you as a fellow historian.
Okay, we'll call him now historian. Dr. Carville.
All right. The only thing you have to be to be a historian is you got to love history. And if you're there, you're 80% away. You're not going to be Joseph Ellis. You're not going to, you know, go to original text. But if you love history and...
Question it all the time and just...
Well, what too many historians, however, are only writing books for other historians. They're difficult to read.