We're going to do like 30, 40 minutes of roundtable questions, like you know, you all heard from me in the advisory, and then we'll get started and do our gaggle and shift into the interview.
Okay. Sorry guys. They're all just coming up from the back. So if you guys want to come up, we can get everyone seated and situated. I appreciate all the press patience while we get all this sorted. Our situation is a little challenging with all the cameras. So, just come grab a seat. Amy and Dave are going to be right here, but if you all want to grab on the sides, I think that would be great. And I think just no backs, all that good stuff. And there are some wires down here, too. So, you just want to be careful.
Okay. What side is ABC? Um, let's do her right there. Anybody else want water or anything?
Everyone good? We're going to get started in like, anyone need water or anything? You guys good place? Okay. Does anyone else have anything for sound or anything? Sure. Water. Love water if you don't mind. Local water. Whatever you got. Okay. We have filtered water. It's good water. [laughter] It's all good. You know how that happened.
Okay, we're going to get started in one second. I'm just going to go to the bathroom, get out of everyone's shot. Just give me two seconds. Yeah, that would be embarrassing.
We did the middle school thing. Did you guys have all of the genders on purpose? I was going to say we just did the middle school thing. Yeah. Boys on one side, girls. Hello everybody. Hello. How's it going? Good to see you. Oh my god. Wonderful to meet you. Yeah. Nice to meet you. Nice to meet you, Derek Smith. Oh my goodness. Awkward. Yeah, we've been long time. So, we got a woman's side and a man side. I was going to say it's like up on my... That's right. Small table. It's all the same. This is great. Wow. Well, nothing like having a quiet small conversation with a [laughter] lot of people listening. Yes.
Well, I think to begin, this is an exciting day. Obviously, we've shared some great news about my colleague, Mr. Pepper. And a lot of people are already, I'm getting memes all the time now, Dr. Pepper. So, I see where this is headed. But it's an honor, you know, for us, we've been on the ground for a lot of time now, for me almost two years, listening deeply. And so even with an audience, I just want you to know like this is part of something that matters a lot to us, hearing from folks what is really going on in their life, ideas you have, you know, just I hope you can be open even with the attention. And we might start by just having you introduce yourself and talk a little bit more, maybe even where you grew up, what your background is, what you're doing now.
And if I can add, first of all, it's an honor to join you, Dr. Atkin. This is an exciting day for me. I've admired your leadership for years and I'm tickled that you've asked me to join you. I also though, as we talked about earlier, it's a really serious time. So, it's exciting, campaigns are exciting, but it's also a very serious time for Ohio families, for Ohio businesses. And so we take this very seriously. And so the other thing I'd like to ask to think about is, in addition to your story, talk to us about whether you're a business owner or a family member or just your community, how are, especially around affordability, how are those issues that we see all the time in the news from healthcare to childcare, everything else, how is it impacting sort of whether it's your business or your own life? Because our goal is to get to work solving those issues. So, absolutely. Why don't you get started?
My name is Derek Smith. I'm... I'm going to take notes on my computer. Is that all right? [laughter] Keep track of all this stuff. So, go ahead. Job's not otherwise specified. So, checking Facebook. Yeah. No, I'm not Facebook. [laughter]
My name is Derek Smith. I'm a realtor with Keller Williams here in Columbus. And yeah, I've been born and raised in Columbus my whole life. I do like to travel and get around, but one of the things that I love doing is helping our community find home. And that's a big struggle for a lot of people at this very moment. So, housing affordability, whether you rent or buy, is something that I think is forefront to a lot of people's, you know, it's in the forefront of their mind. So, I'd like to kind of ask some questions on that front and see kind of what an administration would look like in, you know, 2027 and beyond for housing affordability.
Great. Thank you. And can you just a little bit more? Sorry, David. I just, because you're working with so many people, can you describe what you're seeing and what, you know, people are struggling with?
There's probably one out of every three people I work with asks an elder family member for down payment assistance. Yeah. And just to, you know, some easy numbers, there's 179,000 homes that were sold in Ohio or bought in Ohio in 2024. So if you do some math on, you know, the recent $600 million money that we found, if you divided it up with every home buyer, whether they need it or not, that's enough for $3,300 for down.
Are you referring to the surplus? Yeah. Okay, [laughter] perhaps. Yeah. So give that to 179,000 for the whole state in 2024.
Yeah. Yeah. So, obviously a lot of those people are second, third, fourth time buyers and they have a house to leverage. First-time buyers are where we really need the help with the people that are paying $2,500 a month for a three-bedroom home on the east side of town and they're just trying to find ownership. So, there's ways to do it. We have a burden to educate. But also there's, if they don't have that family member or that leverage or that extra bonus to really push them over the edge to get that five, 10, 15, 20,000 to start that process, they'll feel a little hopeless, right?
That's right. That's right. We're hearing that everywhere we go, too. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. And then on the opposite end, we're hearing about trying to age in place with dignity and there's rising, all the other factors are rising, whether it's childcare, whether it's utilities, all those things like that. So that factors into eating away at that margin. So that's right.
Yeah, that's what I'd kind of want to know is what are some things, what are the ways we're going to tackle the affordability.
So we'll talk about housing and I know that the story I'm hearing a lot now is, you know, I live not far from here and our electric bill went up like 150 bucks this summer. And so when you're balancing all that out and the rent is high, everything is high, and healthcare, every one of our healthcare costs is going up right now with these changes. So when people are uninsured, we all do, and it just doesn't add up. So yeah, there's no margin left. Yeah. Thank you.
My name is Chris Crater. I own Harvest Pizzeria. We have a cafe out in Granville. I have a farm in Granville and a bakery in Granville. Served in the Air Force and lifelong Ohio resident. But I know that I do like to travel. It's important to say if you're born in Minnesota, like you have seen outside our borders. Mhm.
But I think my concerns in addition to those are, I mean obviously everybody sees the cost of goods going up, whatever sector you're in. Restaurants operate on a razor-thin margin. Yeah. So you can only raise your menu prices so much before people are, you know, you price pizza out of affordability or a person out of affordability.
Yeah. Those concerns are obvious to my industry, but also just having a farm that borders Granville land that was recently acquired by the New Albany company, and seeing a governor that currently doesn't even hide the fact that it's, if you're a big industry, come and take our resources, quite literally. You know, they're working on a water pipeline that takes water from Granville's aquifer to cool data centers in New Albany. It just, when you put corporations over people, and I don't think that's really breaking news from a federal level, but I think we expect more from our state leadership.
Can you talk about your workers and what you see them dealing with and with the cost problems?
Yeah, I mean, I think shortly after COVID was like a record, we saw like a 25 to 30% increase in labor costs. And I think maybe there's a silver lining there because, you know, we had to react in a lot of different ways to the COVID crisis and the hospitality industry. Yes. But so they're making more than they've ever made in our industry. So, you know, I think that they've been able to tolerate it, but there doesn't seem to be an end in sight. So if you're making 18 to 22 to $24 as a line cook, right? Two years ago you were able to afford a little more, but now groceries, like you fill up a small basket, it's close to $100. Everybody's just feeling the squeeze. And we also provide health care to all of our full-time employees. We pay 95% of the premiums.
So there's another angle where you're just like, all right, do I charge $40 for a pizza so that I can continue to operate as a good business owner and take care of my people? Like, you know, it has to come out of somewhere. Are you getting stuck with high premiums? Ours went up, not as bad as the marketplace saw. I think we saw, typically we had seen a 3% increase year-over-year. This year it's about 5.5%. But I mean, you know, it's a large amount of money still. Yeah. Thank you.
By the way, I could spend an hour with each one of you with these cost of goods and all that, but... When do you want to pencil me in? Yeah, go ahead. You're next. Sorry about that.
My name is Matt Higgins. I am here in a couple of different capacities, I guess. I am a small business owner. That's my partner Lea. We own Preston's, a burger joint which is in Clintonville and also Grandview here recently. We also co-founded a nonprofit. It's service relief for hospitality workers. And our focus right now is really workforce development. So for us, you know, affordable housing is an enormous obstacle for the people that we work with. You know, costs are up across the industry and there's a thousand things I could talk about, right?
You know, having a stable place to live is the beginning of the ability to recover your life when you're returning or making any kind of transition or just living day-to-day, you know, right now. So we see the impacts of that on people, you know, every day. And the way that it gets people off track, you know, the good news when people recover. But that's really, you know, if I was going to talk to you about one thing today, I feel like that's really probably the most fruitful thing that we could discuss. Thank you. Great. Thanks. Thank you.
Are you from here? Ohio, too. I was born in Cleveland. And I've lived in Ohio most of my life. Okay, great. Thank you.
Hi, I'm Janette Birfield. I am a community organizer and girl about town, but mostly I do a little bit of everything. So, I work in the arts. I also work retail in the city. I'm a 1099 employee and I just love to build up the city and the people and the folks around us and help find resources. I also am a co-organizer for an organization where we help find resources for marginalized folks and I'm just trying to see what I can do to make the community better. So that's awesome here in this capacity. So great to be here from here.
I'm good. Your first name again was... Janette. Okay. Two N's. All righty. Thanks for having me. I'm glad that this... Thank you. Thank you for taking the time.
My name is Letha Pew. I'm a small business owner. So Matt and I own Press together. Then my wife and I own a couple locations for Bake Me Happy, which is a gluten-free bakery. And then we have the Workplace Development Project in the county courthouse, but I am also a budding real estate developer. And so I own three apartment buildings. They're all affordable, they were financed through the affordable housing trust, and then I'm building a duplex over on Miller and Livingston Avenue. And I think Chris and I, we just kind of sat through something not too long ago, a roundtable. And I think the one thing that's kind of stuck with me from that roundtable is that with all the issues and things happening in the world, it doesn't trickle up to the federal level. It trickles to us, because we are the people who are here working with people every day. I have roughly 80 people on payroll and so those 80 people are a concern to me every day.
Yes. And when the price of goods increases or the electric increases, they look to us and we have to figure out how to help ourselves when the bottom line shrinks, but then also look out for our staff. And so, you know, I would like to have some discussion around, you know, just what do you envision for this state? And I'll tell you personally, we need compassion in our members. And so here [laughter] we need to bring compassion. Can you bring the business? Yeah. Let's put those two together and try to do something. That's right.
I think like compassion, like it's a broad term that is needed in all facets of the definition. But like, you know, we did food service for the Facebook or for the Intel site and seeing the red carpet rolled out, and I became friends with Jim Evers, the head of Intel Ohio, and he's like, I'm just a scientist. I don't like, I'm getting invited to the president's box of Ohio State, and like seeing how the governor and everybody in this administration has rolled over backwards for people that literally are like taking resources from the state and getting tax abatements and things like that. I'm like, well, who's paying for it? Everyone at this table. Everybody in this room. Yep.
And it's like I think they're going, I mean, I don't know about Intel. Intel might not be fine, but like other corporations, like the, you know, the major activity just using New Albany as an example, they're going to be fine, but we're not sure that we will, you know. Yeah. I didn't mean to jump in.
I literally had a board revision appointment this morning about a property I bought. It's completely affordable. Seven of the nine people that live there are justice-involved and they're working and they're on a great path and now they want to raise more property taxes. So, but when I go to them and say, hey, yes, I understand what the rules are, but let me tell you what this is, and it's frustrating because I tell people all the time, don't let these lights and cameras fool you. When the door shut, we mopping floors and we are taking out trash and we're working, you know, it's, I think people get that there's, we're not in the 2% up here. We are out here like grinding and trying to, you know, lead people and be good citizens ourselves and our families, and you have a 14-year-old and all the things 14-year-olds go through, going through, you know, so it's tough out here. Yeah.
And you don't want to feel alone, right? I think one of the best things about things like this is that we recognize you are... Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you.
Hi, my name is Oliver Bradish and I'm the owner of Wildcat Gift and Party in Columbus, Ohio. And I'm originally from St. Louis. I came here to go to Ohio State and like many people stayed in the fine state of Ohio. And the thing I kind of wanted to talk about is, I mean, in terms of affordability, our healthcare costs skyrocketed the last time we had a renew and they went up 28%.
And it was a shock. And did my profits automatically go up 28% where I can cover that? No. I had to ask myself, where is that going to come from? Is it going to come from raising prices for our customers? Is it going to come from cutting benefits or bonuses for our staff? And it's so disheartening to deal with the stress of this and then look at those same healthcare corporations posting billion-dollar profits, million-dollar bonuses for their executives. And where did that money come from? Well, they found it out of our pockets. And it's so frustrating, that disconnect. And I'd love to be able to look to a state government that has our back in this and that recognizes our struggles and that it's our pockets getting picked by these billionaires.
I think we could introduce ourselves too quickly. I know this is [laughter] okay. We're going to be here a long time. But, you know, one of the reasons I'm running for governor is I just couldn't look the other way anymore while, you know, people are struggling. They're doing everything right. There's no more breathing room. They're definitely not lazy and mediocre or whatever we've heard said. That's not the Ohioans I'm seeing. It's not who we all are. And the state keeps going backwards on every measure. Over my, I'm almost 60 years old, but over the course of my lifetime, I've been watching it slip away. And everybody is ready for a change. And I think what I want to introduce David this way by saying, I got to know David maybe about five years ago. But he actually wrote a book on what's happening in state houses. Because we all pay a lot of attention to, like we are all the noise federally. We pay attention locally, but most of us can't even name who works at the state house. And I mean, I was as guilty as anyone else, even though I'd done work, you know, over the course of my whole life there. Something's very, very broken in Ohio. We are not where we're supposed to be on any of these measures. And what happens when you have a super gerrymandered, you know, situation, corruption takes hold. And that's absolutely what this election is going to be about, is about drawing this door open. Quite frankly, going after gerrymandering again so that we can get good people on both sides of the aisle back in there. Because when I worked there in the '90s, you know, and I've always had to work with people on both sides of the aisle to solve the wicked hard problems. It's always who you're getting around the table, right? And we could still, you know, Joanne Davidson, Betty Montgomery, we might not agree on every issue, but we'd be arguing a little policy, but actual policy would get made and implemented that would change lives. Like, it's broken there. It's stuck. But what's getting through is the special interest stuff, you know, for the wealthiest, but we're not taking care of the needs of everyday Ohioans.
95% of which everyone agrees on. I honest to God don't hear the hate and the chaos and vitriol, it's exhausting everyone, but I'm actually hearing what people are talking about. No one would disagree on 95% of the things, they're all things we want to sit here and go, what is the exact right housing policy or how do we, you know, deal with the effect of, you know, we need energy, but how do we do it in a way that is protective and all these things? That's what they want to see us just hammering out. David's been one of my favorite people to hammer out these ideas with, but maybe you could speak to why you're in this. Sure. So they know you. Yeah.
I mean, you guys just reflected what I said, which is it's a serious time. Like these are all sobering accounts of what people are dealing with. And Amy and I sometimes together, but also separately, have been out all over the state. And it's what we hear everywhere. I mean, I hear teachers, we were, I was in Jackson County and teachers were literally, this was when the SNAP cut deadline was about to hit. Like the entire hallways of our schools are full of kids who are either asking or visibly worried that their family will not have benefits beginning on Saturday. Yeah. I mean, that's alarming. I mean, Toledo is looking at four days a week for school. I mean, alarming. And to your point, I think your point, and not to get too, you know, political, but I guess this is a campaign, like... Yeah. If you see yourself failing in multiple categories, it's not like you're just bad at that category. Something more deeply is going wrong.
And what's going wrong is sort of what you're hinting at. We have a state house that's gerrymandered. You know, as you joke, turn on HBO, you see Ohio corruption is HBO feature documentaries right now. Yeah. And the price that is paid from corruption and pay-to-play that help special interests is what you said, the outcomes for everyday people are what falls, or as you said, or maybe you said we pay for it. So we used to have amazing public schools. We've given away a lot of that to private players. Who pays the price? Students, families, and higher property taxes to make up the difference. Same with child care. In Ohio, you're paying more child care than almost any other state in the country. They've been short funding higher ed, so we have one of the highest tuition rates, unaffordable tuition rates. The pattern is always the same. State House takes public assets, hands it to private interest, and you all, we all pay the difference. And so, you kind of hear, I don't care if you're in urban Ohio, suburban Ohio, rural Ohio, you hear the same story. So one thing Amy's asked me to do in recent months, long before I knew I'd be considered for this, was to test.
Yeah, it was sort of a test. Like, okay, David, that's great. Like, what can we as a state do about the issues you guys are bringing up? And here's the other part. So many other states who aren't corrupt actually sit at tables and hear views and say, okay, let's actually solve the housing problem or try to, or let's come up with something that means we're not all getting bankrupted by the cost of energy bills. And so, I'll just throw out a few things. I'd love to sort of talk more about them, but, you know, the housing issue is clearly generally driven by there's just not enough good affordable housing in a place like Columbus. It's because prices are skyrocketing. In rural, there's just not enough supply. What are states doing? They're doing everything they can to get more on the market. And they're actually trying to work with local communities to incentivize processes, and this might sound like a bipartisan point, that are too slow. And so we can't get the houses built to keep up with the demand. And there are all sorts of ways that governors in other states are saying, hey, we want to work with the city of Columbus or Cincinnati or a rural area to just get more housing out there at all levels so that problem goes away. That's just one example. One of the... He was hinting toward one, I thought, and we're digging deep into subsidies for first-time home buyers and ways to make sure that people can get in that first.
Absolutely. Yeah. And that would be really huge because a lot of times in this market it's kind of gone, it's not 2021 anymore, so it's rebalanced a little bit. So we can ask for some closing cost concessions. We can ask for those things. But we're also finding that the barrier to entry is still a little bit high. So even one grand or two grand to someone buying in the 200s or 300s would push them over the line to stop paying someone else's mortgage and start paying their own. That's right.
Can I brag about something for a second? So when I was on the county commission in Hamilton County, every year we had a budget gap. Our budget people come to me and say, you've got to raise the transfer tax, which is the tax on home buying. And I was like, wait. And this was during the housing crisis of the Great Recession. Said, wait a second. The problem is we have a housing crisis. The last thing we want to do is add more to that process. So despite a lot of grief, I never touched that transfer tax. So we have to think about it in sort of every way possible.
Absolutely. Yeah. And then I was going to say the number of people that are purchasing from out of state, even the wholesaling. I know the assembly has been working on putting safeguards in place to kind of limit wholesaling or allow disclosures to be brought out. I was just on a phone with someone on Monday who was trying to buy a home that my client has on the northeast side of town near London. We're on the market for 150,000. This is her last paycheck. She is going to retire with the proceeds of the sale. Owes about half of it on there. And I told him, you're going to try to buy this for 10, flip it to someone for 140 and you're going to profit that 30 grand. You're not even licensed. And you know, you're just going to, you're taking it from the most at-risk people and then gentrifying neighborhoods with tenants. And I think removing that block. And that's something I can do a sidebar on, of course.
And how is that affecting the valuations of everybody as their taxes go up? Because I've heard about that from folks. Is that impacting everyone else's property taxes as well when you see those purchases?