If I were representing KJ Biermann, the 15-year-old son of Kim Zolciak and Kroy Biermann, I would say, "I want to show you body cams of Kim and Kroy fighting and just watch fight after fight after fight to understand how KJ Biermann became who he became."
KJ Biermann, the 15-year-old son of Kim Zolciak and Kroy Biermann, is in big trouble. He is facing sexual assault, sodomy, and other charges, and prosecutors want to try him as an adult. They say that he took a 15-year-old girl into a gym, took her into the locker room, and sexually assaulted her in a very violent way. The prosecutors want to try him as an adult. He has a prior with juvenile court where they claim they said there was probable cause he committed incest and he went through a treatment program, and the prosecutors say juvenile court is going to do him no good because he's been through that treatment program and he did it again.
So Mark, I want you to hear what Dr. Drew said because this is essentially saying just here's the only thing you can do with this kid: lock him up and throw away the key.
This is a meltdown situation. And unfortunately, this is not a part-time preoccupation. This may or may not have a treatment associated with it other than keeping him away from people. So, keeping him away from people, Mark, means prison and means prison in a way indefinitely.
Well, I wouldn't go so far. In full disclosure, I've known Drew since high school and consider him one of my close friends, but I wouldn't go so far as to say it's irredeemable, and I know that's going to repel people. But I think the first kind of battleground is precisely what you started off with: do we stay in or does he stay in juvenile court? Right now they have said we're going to direct file basically in adult court.
They did file in adult court. They did file in adult court. It's the defense that's trying to move it to juvie and the prosecutor saying, you know, this kid's 15. If you're between 13 and 17 and you commit an egregious act like aggravated sexual assault, we have a right to have you tried as an adult. And that's where the dog fight is right now.
Correct. And 25 years ago in California, we had what was called then Prop 21. I actually took that to the Court of Appeal and had it invalidated, where there was a proposition that was passed in order to direct file certain crimes in adult court. So people understand, if you're in juvenile court, normally what would happen if you're under the age of 18, the juvenile judge will make a decision: does this person remain under juvenile jurisdiction? Generally, you start off there and you let the judge make the decision, not the DA. I think that's the better way to do it. And I'll tell you why. The DA is always, in any kind of an inflammatory crime or any kind of a high-profile crime, always going to kind of reflexively want to file in adult court. I think that the better process, and it was one of the things we argued in California, was let the judge make the decision. Let the defense put forth what they think are the issues.
Okay. But well, hold on. The judge is going to make the decision, but you have a situation here where a year before this latest charge, a year before he allegedly committed incest. Now, his lawyer denies it, but they found probable cause sufficient that this kid went to a treatment program in juvenile court. He went through the treatment program for essentially another sexual assault case and then he allegedly commits it again. So, the prosecutors are saying, it's not that we just want to be draconian. The prosecutors are saying we tried this with this kid and it didn't work as a juvenile. Isn't that a compelling argument?
Well, it could be a compelling argument except without knowing more. This is what we know. We know that in juvenile court there is no jury. In juvenile court, a judge makes a decision. They aren't really looking for conviction. They look for what's called an adjudication. You said it yourself. There is a probable cause finding. You know, I often jokingly say, but joking on the kidding on the square, probable cause means, is my client breathing? That means basically you could have been in juvenile court. There could have been an allegation in juvenile court.
I know, but Mark, you can't diminish it that way by saying...
I don't want to. Hold on. I'm not diminishing and saying it didn't happen. What I'm saying is if a judge was the one who said or made the determination, I don't know, where there's smoke, there's fire, clearly there's something untoward here, or this is somebody who's troubled, I'm going to give him a program. Maybe it was an outpatient program. Do you automatically go because when you kind of tease this story, it was that Drew was saying irredeemable, put him in prison.
That's right, because he allegedly did this before, went through treatment, did it again. And Drew is saying somebody that young who was so inculcated with this kind of behavior, he's saying the reality is, and you know, he's the psychologist. He's saying we can't really do anything with him. I mean, you can...
He'd get very angry if you said psychologist, but...
Yes. And he, I do not think, I wish I had him here to question him, but I don't think he would say at that age that somebody is irredeemable. I don't know the facts. Obviously, nobody wants to put somebody back out in society who is a sexual predator. However, if the facts turn out to not be as inflammatory or over-the-top as they sound, and I agree, if it's somebody who has had incest at age 12 and then at age 15 is in a public place and is forcing himself on another minor, that is somebody who needs more than a timeout. But we don't know the facts yet, and to start them in the adult court before you get to at least understanding what the situation is and what the facts are, that to me sounds very draconian.
So he could face up to 25 years in prison as an adult. Does a judge consider, you know, even if it would warrant something like that, how much does a judge look at his age? And, you know, when you sentence somebody for the exact same conduct, does it matter that he's 15 or 35?
I think it matters a whole lot. You know, part of the argument is, and part of the biology and studies have been, that a male brain does not fully develop until 24, 25. My father used to have this saying: if you want to solve crime, the way to solve crime is to incarcerate all males between the ages of 16 and 25. That would solve crime because that is the large part of the demographic that commits crime. In this case, and I don't know specifically, but I was talking with Ashley Merchant, who is the lawyer who gained fame in the Fani Willis proceedings. Ashley practices in Georgia, and we were talking about the idea of the various factors that a judge goes through. Age is clearly one of them. A 13-year-old, a 14-year-old, a 15-year-old get treated differently. Also, how long do you have to arguably rehabilitate somebody? Part of the whole reason for the juvenile system is that you actually take them or you have jurisdiction over them until they get to 25. So, you've got the ability to at least monitor them. You can also take them out of society. They don't have to be in an outpatient kind of a setting. They could be inpatient. They could be in custody, so to speak, as a juvenile hall or something like that. A lot of...
They can't be in juvenile hall after 20... what's...
22, and I mean, it depends.
That's not going to work, youth authority and everything, that's not going to work.
Yeah. But you could also, there are various ways to fashion certain kinds of things. Do you believe people are irredeemable at some point?
So yes. Do I? Yes. I've seen people who, it's not as common as you might think, but yes, at a certain point, people are irredeemable. Do you think that a 15-year-old is so broken that there is no hope and that you're just going to basically throw him into prison? By the way...
By the way, I can answer that. No.
Yeah. He would never last 25 years in prison. Period. End of story. He wouldn't make it, be lucky to make 25 weeks. So, let me ask you about his family because this is something we at TMZ have covered now for years. This may be...
Speaking of TMZ, do you have the video of his dad with the body cam?
Oh, I'm about to show you that. But I will say that in all the years that we've done TMZ, this I think ranks as the nastiest divorce. The cops were called so many times that they didn't even have to tell them when they called 911 who they were. The cops knew they had been out to the house so much. And I want to just play a little bit of this now, and then I want to know from you. I'm really interested whether this comes into play. I know it would in sentencing, but could this come into play with the judge's decision on whether to even try this guy as an adult because of what he went through as a kid with this family?
And then I left. I finally got out of the gate and I was walking in my robe down the street and I was like yelling for help to my neighbors, like, please somebody help me. He's screaming, screaming in my ear, grabbing my robe like the back hoodie of my... to be in my home.
You're going to give Kroy... Let's listen.
I did not give you authorization. I know my rights.
I know my rights.
Okay, then stop talking if you know your rights. I'm going to tell you your rights. I'm going to inform you of your rights.
We're here for a lawful reason to investigate a domestic violence situation where the person is outside.
Our kids are the ones that called. I need to talk to them.
I can bring them outside, but you do not have the authority to be in my home.
You were going to go stand outside.
You do not have the authority to be in my home.
Well, first off, I'll tell you this is why most officers, if you ask them, this is their biggest nightmare is responding to one of these situations. Number one. Number two, if I were defending, and by the way, I think Brian Steel just substituted in.
He did. He's the Diddy lawyer.
Yeah. And I think he just subbed in on this case. And my guess is that Brian is going to put this front and center. I would want a judge to see this. But is it relevant in a case like this if the kid allegedly did what he did? Do you try that on the merits and then just look at this maybe for sentencing as some mitigating factor?
No, I think you frontload this. I think part of your argument is in trying to get this back to juvenile court is you need to take this kid out of this situation. This situation was the petri dish for why this kid is where he is.
Okay. And then the prosecutor says, "Hey, listen, that egg has already scrambled, it is what it is with the family, but everybody in that family doesn't go out there, take a girl into a locker room and sodomize her." So, that's what they're going to say. They're going to say, "Look, sorry about his upbringing, but it's no excuse. And again, we gave him one bite of the apple. We tried him in juvenile court for incest. He went through a treatment program." And the prosecutors are going to say, "And then he did not only the same thing again, he was more brazen because he did it in a public place." And they say it was premeditated.
And that's where I would push back on a couple of spots. First of all, I don't know that it was proven as much as it was an allegation, the probable cause allegation, and they tried to fashion some kind of a therapeutic remedy for it. That's what I think happened before. Now, what happened in this instant case? Obviously, it's an escalation. It's from something that's inside the house to something that's outside the house. That in and of itself is a major step. But you would probably want, if you're the judge when you're making this decision, you'd want to know certain things. You'd want to know what happened when he was treated the time before. What were the true facts surrounding that? Was he in fact given the kind of treatment that was intended? And was it onerous enough? Was it engaging enough? I just don't know without more facts whether or not I'm ready to say some 15-year-old is irredeemable and I can't fashion, if I'm the judge, I can't fashion something within the next 10 years when you have jurisdiction over a juvenile, some kind of a treatment that would give this person a second chance to lead a productive life. It's very tough. Do you believe there are people who are irredeemable at age 15? I think it would be very rare. I think it would be very, very rare.
I agree with you on that. So, let's say he is tried as an adult, and that's very possible that's going to happen. If he's tried as an adult, I would imagine prosecutors would want to show the jury evidence that he engaged in incest a year before, as a modus operandi to what he allegedly did this time, that they would try to get in prior bad acts, that bad act before a jury, which by the way could be devastating to the case, but I would assume prosecutors would try that, right?
I don't think there's a prosecutor born who's not going to make an attempt to try to get that into evidence. They will find some signature or similarity or motive or opportunity in which they will try to get that in to say this is exactly why you need to take this person out of society and never let them back in. It's prosecutorial 101.
So does a judge allow it in?