CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Mira Murati gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Mira Murati
Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer, Thinking Machines Lab

Jensen Huang, Zach Snyder, Mira Murati & More - The Big Interview Live 2024 | WIRED

📅 Dec 11, 2024 WIRED 312 MIN 29525 VIEWS 341 SEGMENTS · 19 SPEAKERS
For the first time, WIRED’s iconic "The Big Interview" series comes to life on stage with a series of unforgettable, in-depth live conversations. WIRED's The Big Interview will showcase the people, platforms, technologies, and ideas that are shaping our shared future—and feature WIRED journalists in one-to-one discussions with some of the most influential leaders across tech, business, science, entertainment, and beyond. 0:00 The Big Interview Live 0:15 Opening Remarks With Katie Drummond 4:09 Meredith Whittaker: President, Signal Foundation 30:50 Anders Bell: Chief Engineering and Technology...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 3:49:00Prior to joining OpenAI, she managed the product and engineering teams at Leap Motion and led the design, development, and launch of vehicle products at Tesla, including the Model X. Is that all correct?
  2. 3:52:28You did share that view, and I guess do share that we're approaching the point where we can accomplish that. Is that correct?
  3. 3:57:26Is there something you still believe in, that AR and VR will be super important technologies?
  4. 4:03:14Do you think we're overrunning safety? Are we paying enough attention?
  5. 4:07:23Can you explain to me, you've been working on these products, why we haven't been able to get rid of the hallucinations?
  6. 4:11:37Where are we going to be if we get this AGI which can match and exceed some human capabilities and then learn to go beyond us? What's that world look like?
  7. 4:21:52We're on a timeframe here, okay?
  8. 4:24:18But is it actually doing your work for you at this stage?
  9. 4:24:48How are you thinking about this?
  10. 4:27:49When you hear remarks like that, how concerned are you about what that could mean for your relationship with TSMC?
  11. 4:29:38Do you anticipate having extended conversations about your business with him?
  12. 4:31:57I mean, it's assumed that it's faster, right, but what are the downstream effects of that?
Katie Drummond 0:07 ↗
Please welcome Katie Drummond. Oh yeah. Hello, hello, hello. Good morning everybody and welcome to Wired's inaugural Big Interview event. I am Katie Drummond, I am Wired's Global Editorial Director. I am thrilled to be here in San Francisco with all of you today. I'm going to tell you a little bit about what we're doing today, a little bit about the Big Interview, go through some housekeeping, and then get out of your way. We have been putting out the Big Interview in print and online since 2022, and we have talked to a ton of incredible people in those two years. We've talked to Saa Adella, Anthony Blinken, Grimes, Javier B.M., Yan Laon, and several of the people that you are actually going to hear from today. This year we made the Big Interview series bigger and more ambitious, so we took it to video. We started releasing the Big Interview on YouTube and across platforms like Instagram and TikTok, and we are now bringing the Big Interview to life at this event, which I am thrilled about. If you're wondering what a Big Interview is, on the surface it's the Wired version of an interview or a Q&A. We like to talk to people who are creating the future, whether that's a tech executive, a filmmaker, an activist, an athlete. We want to talk to people with forward-looking ideas, people who are doing novel or interesting things, people who are taking big risks. Our ideal version of a Big Interview goes beyond that surface level. You should walk away from reading or watching a Big Interview feeling like you know this person on a deeper level, like you learned something, like you were surprised by something, maybe upset by something, maybe amused by something, maybe completely weirded out by something, which being Wired, that would be just fine with us. I hope you feel at least some of those things today, maybe not all at once. But ultimately, above all of that, I truly hope you all walk out of this event today feeling like you got a dose of optimism. I hope you walk out of this event feeling hope, which I think we can all use a little bit of right now. Thank you. Now we have an amazing lineup of speakers throughout the day. Offstage, we also have some great stuff for you to check out. In the main hallway, we have an incredible photo installation of Wired's most iconic portraits from the Big Interview series. Our photo team goes above and beyond every time, but they certainly do for the Big Interview series. Our editors have also reimagined the classic idea of the science fair, so we have more than 10 exhibits throughout the main space. Just follow signs for the science fair and go check those out during the breaks. Of course, we hope you stick around at the end of the day. We're going to be doing some drinking, and I hope you join us for a little bit of that too. Throughout the day, we want to hear from all of you on the social media platform of your choice. You can hashtag Big Interview to share what you're hearing, share your thoughts, share your impressions. Finally, I want to be sure to extend a big and very sincere thank you to our presenting sponsor Volvo, as well as the H-Tech Collaborative from AARP, Omid Network, Shot, and Meta for making this event possible. With that, let's get started. We are going to welcome Brian Barrett, Wired's Executive Editor, and Meredith Whitaker, the President of the Signal Foundation. Thank you all so much for being here. Enjoy the day.
Brian Barrett 4:10 ↗
Hi, thank you all for being here today. To echo what Katie said, I'm so excited to be talking with Meredith Whitaker. Meredith is the President of the Signal Foundation, which for those who don't know, oversees and runs and maintains the Signal messenger, which is an encrypted messaging app and platform that is used by hundreds of millions of people globally. As far as why it's concerned, the gold standard in encrypted messaging. We all use it, recommend that you do too. But Meredith also co-founded the AI Now Institute at NYU, which focuses on the social implications of AI and tech, and spent over a decade at Google, which I think is also especially relevant given what we're talking about today, which is the idea of surveillance capitalism. The name of the talk is about surveillance capitalism, if you check your program. But I think we want to draw a little bit of distinction there about what we're really talking about today, Meredith, which is more of a surveillance business model that has kind of defined the last couple of decades of tech.
Meredith Whitaker 5:12 ↗
Yeah, well, it's great to be here with you, Brian, and thank you everyone. I think, you know, as someone with a bit of an academic background who really pays attention to definitions, this is just a clarification I often make. Surveillance capitalism as an academic term is very freighted with disciplinary histories. When we at Signal, when I talk about the surveillance business model, we're being a bit more diagnostic and a bit more schematic about what we're talking about. Ultimately, Signal exists in an industry where the profit incentive is defined by surveillance. That's not a scary term in this case. We're talking about data collection. You collect as much data as you can about whatever your domain is, your customers, your environment, what have you. You use that to create models to target ads, perhaps, or to train AI models, or what have you. Or if you don't do that, you provide goods and services, tool chains and libraries to those who do. So there's a flywheel, a center of this industry that is defined economically by the collection and creation of data with a 'the more the better' paradigm. In Signal's case, we reject that out of hand because we are motivated and dedicated to preserving privacy, to creating technology that maintains the hundreds of thousands of years of private communications as a norm into an age where privacy is vanishingly scarce in our daily lives, communities, and activities. So when we talk about the surveillance business model, we are talking about a paradigm within which Signal both exists and which it rejects. I think what we see here is Signal almost as the acid test for what's wrong with the current incentive structure in tech. When something as valuable as Signal can't figure out how to make a profit, when we can be core infrastructure for human rights work, for journalism, for every military in the world, for governments, for boardrooms, when it's clear we are the gold standard for a value that everyone cares about, the Apple billboards proclaiming privacy, Meta sort of turned to privacy, this is something it is clear there is a market for and people want. And yet we have to squeeze ourselves into a nonprofit shape that is not quite conducive for the high availability, real-time tech we are maintaining and developing, simply because there's no real way to make a profit in the tech industry given the surveillance incentives. So I think that introduces why we focus on that paradigm so much and the distinction practically speaking between how we use it and how it might be used in different academic discourses.
Brian Barrett 8:19 ↗
Well, I think that is the central question. You are presenting a model of how to do things differently, and beyond just messaging, you are providing a messaging model and then maybe other people can follow that. But I think what's interesting and why I'm glad to talk to you is that it's not just hypothetical. You are currently making it work, and you genuinely have this sense that things are changing. You wrote for Wired in an essay that we published a couple weeks ago, 'Next year will be big tech's finale.' Do you feel like we are at a sea change? Do you feel like we are that close to things unwinding for big tech, or is that a little more hyperbolic and it takes a few more steps to get there?
Meredith Whitaker 9:05 ↗
Yeah, well, look, you all asked me in the middle of 2024 to write a prediction for 2025. Past data does not necessarily predict a volatile future. What I really wanted to write was, I sat down and thought, well, what is there to be optimistic about right now? How do I actually sincerely communicate optimism? What I came to is, let's write something that is half manifestation and half optimism as invitation. That's not a prediction where we say, 'Oh, it looks like probability approaching one, we can all sit back and let the gears of the world take shape.' No, this is an invitation to action and to marshal the forces that I do truly see fomenting. I've never seen a broader and more heterogeneous coalition looking at concentration of power in tech, looking at the deep dangers of pooling vast dossiers of surveillance data on every person on Earth in the hands of a few companies, looking at these choke points and single points of failure where one bug in a kernel driver can take down core infrastructure globally across medicine, transportation, governments, what have you. None of those things are chill or nice. No one is championing them, certainly not in the way they were 10 years ago or even 5 years ago. The first step to a strategy for change is an honest map, and that's what I think we have now. No one is pretending this is okay, and so that is the opportunity and the invitation for change. To take things like Signal, we're existing as a nonprofit, we exist on donations, we persevere at being the keystone species in the tech ecosystem around privacy and tech that is rights-preserving and works with integrity. But we're not looking to be alone. We don't want to be the outlier that proves the rule. We want to be a new set of rules leading the way to a much more open and diverse tech ecosystem that again isn't reliant on five companies and 15 guys in a paradigm that is very, very stale and ultimately not healthy for the world or the future.
Brian Barrett 11:29 ↗
Well, I want to talk about Signal and how it is ubiquitous, especially among the privacy conscious. But that ubiquity is expensive. Signal cost about $36 million to run last year and about $50 million to run now, which is a pretty big jump. About two-thirds of that, by my understanding, at least in 2023, came from contributions. Is that it all came from? Okay, fully donor supported. So as you grow, things get more expensive. You need more donor support to fund all of this, these features, these servers. How sustainable is that? Do you feel like you're on a flywheel right now where as you grow, the donations grow in kind, or does there need to be another model that steps in that makes you sustainable for the long term?
Meredith Whitaker 12:18 ↗
Well, it's a bit of a tricky question because it's sustainable right now because there are a lot of people who value privacy and who get why what we're doing is so critical. One thing to take home: we couldn't make Signal again if the heartbeat stopped. If Signal went away for a year, you can't just restart a globally interconnected communications network where you can pick up your phone and your friend also has it installed on their app. That network effect is huge, it is not replicable. When Signal came up over 10 years ago, when it emerged as two apps, then one app, and the history of Signal and the masterful work of its founder, Moxie Marlinspike, who basically carried this thing through for a decade, it was coming up in an environment where its competition was web clients like Jabber and Google Chat. It was coming up in an environment where less than 30% of human beings had a smartphone, most people left their desktop at their work when they went home. A vastly dramatically different ecosystem than what we have today, where we have incumbent monopolies who have saturated the market. So we're talking about preserving something that grew through the cracks into a mighty tree, let's use that metaphor, and needs to continue to be fed and watered because without that, we can't just snap our fingers and introduce tech that will actually serve the purpose of Signal. Everyone has to use Signal for you to use it. You can be the most virtuosic cryptographer who created the most elegant and beautiful private communications technology, you go out there and say, 'Hey, use it,' but if your friend doesn't use it, it doesn't matter to you. So that network effect is hugely important, and the reputation that Signal has developed because of the care and attention and sometimes agitation of the hacker and infosec community is equally important. We develop all in the open, our cryptographic implementations and our core technologies are open source. Every change to our repo gets scrutinized by communities of dudes who are train spotters for Signal code pushes, and we love them for it because they will find a little bug and they will report it. It's really making good on the promise that many eyes make more secure code. That's similar to CUDA or some of the other standards and infrastructures you might hear about in other sectors like AI. What we're talking about is a community of practice, a community of labor norms, and a standardized understanding of tech that has come through Signal as infrastructure over about 10 years, and again can't just be recreated. I can publish anything on GitHub, but I can't force anyone to read it or care about it. So these things are very, very precious and they need to be maintained, they need to be supported. Right now we do have support, we're looking to diversify that. Now is a very critical moment for privacy-preserving communications. The more geopolitically volatile the world is, the more it's important for us to be able to have real talk that is not interrupted by surveillance. So we're working on growing the base of supporters and thinking through are there models that can marshal the type of money we need. It's absurd that we are core infrastructure from everything to human rights and defense, and then you see these companies that are basically white-labeling some AI API getting billion-dollar valuations, and we can't figure out how to make money on that to sustain a thing that if it went away would literally change the fates of nations.
Brian Barrett 16:13 ↗
Well, and you also wrote about this idea of a nonprofit critical infrastructure ecosystem, not just Signal but other aspects where we are too relying on private companies. Where's the nonprofit version of that? As part of that, you mentioned a need for state capital to get involved at some point. Is that when you talk about alternative and diversifying funding, is that something that Signal is looking at? And are there any concerns with that too about taking money from governments that you're also protecting people from? None of this is simple.
Meredith Whitaker 16:48 ↗
Friend, this is simple. What I'm looking at is the type of capital we need, how do we get it? Not how do we partner with states, absolutely not. Not how do we enter into shady agreements. The issue here is not nonprofit or for-profit. Nonprofit is a tax status, it's not actually comfortable or amenable. We are constantly, I feel like we're fitting inside a dollhouse. We are a massive tech not massive in size, but we have to maintain, we have to act and function like a tech company. We are for all intents and purposes a tech company with a nonprofit tax structure because again, that means that my board isn't going to go to Davos or be pushed to have a profit motive come back to me and be like, 'I love you Meredith, I love this privacy thing, real cool, real nice, but ultimately I have a fiduciary duty.' Just as the board sold Twitter, our board is going to have to strip some privacy protections because you have to be making some revenue. That's the risk that we are warding against with the nonprofit structure. We are not celebrating nonprofit as some sort of alternative to private enterprise. Those are the two cage matches there. This is a structure that we have to have if we're going to preserve our obsessive mission on privacy, because otherwise it would be whittled away because those dudes on my board ultimately have no choice, or they want an AI strategy, or whatever. There are a lot of ways we could make money that we simply are not going to make money doing because we're privacy preserving. So the call here is not everyone come be a nonprofit. Nonprofit is not the perfect form, it is a prophylactic from the perverse incentives that define the industry we're in. How do we create better incentives? How do we marshal things like state capital, which is going to tech all day every day? If you look at the subsidies, if you look at the research history, if you look at the massive cloud contracts that are now ultimately the pipeline of revenue for most of these companies, there's no state capital involved here? I mean, you look at their government sales departments in any one of these large companies, they are orders of magnitude bigger than Signal's team. So we also have to stop with these bright lines as if there's some clear difference between private industry with state control. The question then is how do we marshal that state capital without state control? How do you get long-term commitments, guarantees? How do you do things like the Sovereign Tech Agency in Germany, which was set up ultimately to take government appropriations but then has a lot of clear boundaries where they independently allocate those outside of state control? So we're interested there, but I had to go into a long digression to explain what we're actually talking about, which is not a clean schematic, not a clean divide between for-profit and non. Clean is boring.
Brian Barrett 20:14 ↗
Clean is boring, yeah. While we're on the topic of governments, we obviously had an election here in the US recently. Donald Trump is coming. It's true, it's true. Read about it on Wired.com. Is that a website? It is. But I want to talk to you about it. The Trump administration the last go round was hostile to encryption. Not you know, several governments worldwide are. You've got Kash Patel coming in potentially as FBI director. How does this affect Signal, its users? What is Signal's role in this moment? How are you feeling about the incoming administration, both for your users and for Signal itself?
Meredith Whitaker 21:00 ↗
I mean, look, Signal knows who we are. Signal will continue being Signal. Signal has one thing we do and we do it really well and we do it pretty obsessively, and that is provide truly private communications infrastructure to everyone everywhere globally, full stop. We're not changing. That's how I feel.
Brian Barrett 21:29 ↗
Is Signal going to stay in the United States no matter what, in terms of where it's based?
Meredith Whitaker 21:35 ↗
I mean, we're a global operation. People use Signal everywhere around the world across the globe. We're an open source project. We have people who, we don't routinely take third-party commits, and when we do we scrutinize them really closely. But we do have people who contribute to Signal globally. We're jurisdiction in the US, and we don't have plans to share on that, but we are a globally interconnected communication network that has to touch as many people as possible so you can make that call from Bangkok to Kingston, Jamaica, and then from Kingston to London, and then London to New York. So we don't have any plans to move. We are focused on markets around the globe, and we are of course aware of the way that geopolitical volatility informs our ability to function in one or another market. We've been fighting things like the Online Safety Bill, now Act, in the UK, which threatens to mandate backdoors in end-to-end encrypted communication, a disastrous cybersecurity vulnerability that would ultimately undermine Signal anywhere it's used irrespective of jurisdiction. We're fighting Chat Control, which is the European version of that law. It's this zombie that honestly, since 1976 when Diffie and Hellman tried to publish their paper introducing public key cryptography and the US government freaked out and tried to suppress publication of that paper, has been this ever-present specter behind the idea that there could be private communication networks or other privacy-preserving technology that would protect interpersonal communications and activities, not simply government or corporate activities. This is a tension that threads through the crypto wars in the 90s with the specter of evil that encryption is said to be protecting changing over time. It's terrorists, it's people who harm children, it's what have you, but with the goal remaining steadfastly focused ultimately on destroying the only technology we have to preserve the human right of privacy in an age of unprecedented mass surveillance. So we fight that wherever it emerges.
Brian Barrett 24:08 ↗
With the time we had left, I want to talk a little bit about the future for Signal on a product level, which feels less grand than global fights, but is fundamentally what it is. Signal itself, what I want to ask is, as you grow out features, it feels more complicated because you have to build them out in a secure way whereas your competitors do not. So it's more expensive, more timely, harder to keep parity in certain ways. What do you see as Signal's future as a product? What's next on the roadmap? What do you care about parity about? What do you not care about? Which is really a way to ask about AI, because no one has yet, I get to be the first person today. Everyone's going to do it, so I just get to do it here. What does Signal need to do to keep up with and expand and get to a billion users that it's not doing right now?
Meredith Whitaker 25:10 ↗
Well, we have to provide a product that when anyone picks it up looks and feels normal, that works. When you want to send a cat dancing on a birthday cake to your auntie thread, you can go to search and type in 'cat birthday cake dance' and the right little thing will pop up and you send it to your aunties. It has to do that. That is as fundamental as ensuring that our crypto systems are robust and not susceptible to attack. Because again, if your friends don't use Signal, it doesn't matter how ideologically committed to privacy you are, you don't use Signal either, unless you open it to send a note to self, but note to self is a great feature by the way. So what we are aiming for is a product that just works, because no one picks up their phone to use Signal, they pick up their phone to talk to their partner or talk to their dad. The actual imperative of messaging is human relationships and connection, and honoring those as a first order is what Signal has to do on the same level as ensuring privacy preservation. This is where the early Signal team, Moxie, Tyler, some of the people who were really at the founding of this product, got it right where very few people did. There was a whole crop of privacy-preserving, command-line-looking, PGP-looking technology that no one used. I was a person trying as hard as I could to get anyone I know to email me back with PGP, and crickets. Not because people didn't care, but because ultimately when they wanted to talk to me, they didn't want to do that. So from its inception, Signal has really focused on usability, on design, and on being extremely stringent about making an app that looked and felt normative. We will continue doing that. You should see in the next months or so encrypted backups, which is a gap. You can back things up, and if your phone falls in a river, everything isn't on device and lost. It's obviously much harder to do in a privacy-preserving way where we have full deniability around our ability to see people's data. Backups are tricky there, so we're looking at improving some of those gaps. AI, what I see across a lot of these apps right now is a glassy-eyed company imperative coming down from the top to integrate AI into everything. I can imagine how the OKRs get written: 'It's the year of AI.' Then your little VP is like, 'Okay guys, it's the year of AI, integrate this into your group level or your product level.' Then there's somebody here who has to take on integrating an AI feature into this, but that's not how good innovation happens. That's why we have these little prompters, these little 'Hey, let me write your mom for you,' and I'm like, 'You don't need to write my mom, I like stop it.' So what we're seeing is annoying at this point. It is cluttered, it is swirly and swoopy and unclear, and it doesn't actually solve a problem for me. The problem it solves is AI takes vast amounts of capital in the bigger-is-better form we have, and there is a need for a consumer market fit. They're trying, they have people who are like, 'Well, they said it's the year of AI, let's try to shoehorn this into an interface that ultimately would serve us better if it were cleaner, would serve us better if it weren't cluttering up with suggestions and little prompts.' That's the thing Signal is not going to do. Signal doesn't have to because we didn't go out and invest a trillion dollars in data centers on a bet that this stuff was going to return as a good product feature, which is another benefit of our model. So we are laser focused on doing one thing and doing it very, very, very, very well. When something comes along that doesn't serve that, we don't have to pick up that mantle because we're not chasing quarterly returns, we're not chasing investor approval to make sure that we continue with the valuation that will keep our C-suite employed. We do use a little bit of AI, it's an on-device face detection model. If you go to the face blur feature, it works kind of half the time, it's fine. But when we talk about AI right now, we're talking about these bigger-is-better Transformer models, everything is generative, and ultimately I think a lot of that is going to fade away because it's not proving useful in a consumer context.
Brian Barrett 30:20 ↗
Meredith, thank you so much. That's all we have time for. I really enjoyed talking with you. I really appreciate it. Thank you.
Greg Williams 30:50 ↗
Wow, what a great way to open the Big Interview event. Really, really terrific. Hope you enjoyed the conversation. We're going to move now from secure communication to connected mobility. The connected, software-defined vehicle is propelling the automotive industry to probably its most significant phase since the creation of the automobile itself. Our cars now constantly update themselves, they're effectively an OS on wheels. Our next speaker, Anders, these things have a truly transformational power for you because we are talking about the ability to raise the bar on safety and what connected vehicles are able to do in that way. As you are Chief Engineering and Technology Officer of Volvo Cars, I'm really excited to understand how real-time, software-defined vehicles are learning on the road, how they're accelerating the future of safety, and also how fundamentally a company rooted in physical engineering and vehicle safety reimagines itself in the age of AI. When I grew up, frankly, Volvos were a car that everyone associated with safety. I remember my uncle had one, and it was this incredibly reliable car that really did have a sense of that factor being associated with the brand. Can you just maybe kick off the conversation by exploring that a little bit and give us a sense of how technology is going to expand that proposition moving forward?
Anders Bell 32:30 ↗
Absolutely. As you point out, safety is really in our DNA. We're approaching our 100th anniversary soon, 97 this year. Already since the start of the company, the founders said that the cars are designed to be driven by people, so therefore everything we do must be based on safety first and foremost. It's very much in the DNA of the company. There's always been a curiosity in the company to understand the real world, what's actually going on out there. You see some of the examples out here on the walls of technologies or gadgets or functions and features that we launched, but the approach is much more comprehensive than that. The technologies and improvements that we launch are part of a relentless progress and relentlessness of always trying to do better and also being constantly curious about what goes on in the world out there. For instance, since the 1970s, we started to go out to actual accidents on the road, collecting field data in the early days with measuring tapes, checking skid marks, inspecting the scene, looking at police reports, medical reports, insurance data to truly understand the world, and then bringing that back to the lab for continuous development. In that process, we created our own safety standard which is above and beyond regulatory and rating requirements. Occasionally that results in technologies that we launch. In many ways, it's the whole comprehensive approach to how you design every little piece of the whole machine, the millions of engineering hours we spend obsessing how the front end of a car crumbles in a wide range of different accidents. It's our fundamental core value as a company. Now, also as you point out, the last 20 years of automotive technology transformation, if you zoom out and look at it from a high level, when I started in automotive in 1998 compared to the products we do now, it's a massive difference, a massive transformation. Going back to the 90s when GPS was a new thing, we had AM and FM radio, that's about it, to where we are now. Look at the EX90 that we have parked outside here, which is a product that is fully integrated to itself, meaning all sensors and actuators are interconnected to one compute network, and through high-speed 5G, endlessly integratable into general society. There's no end to the things we can do today compared to 20 years ago.
Greg Williams 35:32 ↗
You mentioned earlier that you used to collect data physically from skid marks, those kinds of things. Now obviously you're able to collect data in real time. I'm interested in how that translates into safety improvements and also what mechanisms you have in place to translate that into something that's actionable in terms of vehicle design.
Anders Bell 35:56 ↗
Yes, a good question. The whole process, the engineering, the data analytics, the comprehension, the simulation capabilities that we have already now, with the introduction of the software-defined vehicle or the computer on wheels, with real-world, real-time insight into what goes on out there in real traffic situations, we're going to equip ourselves with a superpower of insight. Not only fully understanding and comprehending what happens in the world, but also the ability to, with over-the-air updates, write back new instructions to respond even better next time, be more granular in the response. This applies very much to the active safety and self-driving capabilities, but also into the passive safety, which is in the case of a crash. Even no matter how good your active systems are, you might be hit by somebody else. So being able to understand and have better instructions on how to deploy the airbags, in what timing, what frequency, to better respond, more granular response in different types of collisions, for example. It's really creating a closed loop of having the product informing you what goes on in the world, being able to design for it both as a software update but also as informing our next hardware revision, and always feeding back to the product on the road continuously making it safer and safer.
Greg Williams 37:21 ↗
Obviously historically you're a company that's rooted in physical engineering. What needs to happen in terms of the infrastructure to become software-defined? What fundamental shifts in the electrical architecture are necessary to support that transition from the mechanical to software-defined?
Anders Bell 37:43 ↗
I think first we need to understand where we're coming from. The car of today or yesterday is based on what we call domain-based architectures, where pretty much one function, one system, one ECU, to call it. That served us extremely well in the automotive industry for many years, being able to develop functionalities in parallel, disconnected from each other, and then put them back together again in the complete vehicle and have a predictable outcome. But adding more and more functionalities and more and more complex functionalities on top of that architecture adds more and more complexity, adds more wiring, more ECUs, and slows you down. The step over to a core compute system, flat topology, interconnected system in the car is a massive one because we are dealing with two and a half ton moving objects that are roaming around the streets among people. This is not to be taken lightly. But what we are creating is a product where you can endlessly combine the different hardware compute capabilities in your car to create new functionalities. So it's an absolutely necessary step as a car maker to make this step over to a state-of-the-art core compute architecture. It's a very hard one. Again, this is not consumer-grade electronics, this is automotive, it's kind of one step down from military grade. The level of safety mechanisms that you need to have built into this is nothing. We do all the other stuff still as well. We still make fantastic cars designed with beautiful Scandinavian design, and we're adding a significant piece of software on top of that. As an organization, it kind of changes your mindset a lot. We need to change the culture fundamentally, and you need to put software on top of the considerations in this business of making the world's most complex consumer product. Bringing all the software in-house and making all the products from one software master is a massive step, which has been a very tough journey. But now we're here. The EX90 outside in the front is the first car out on our new superset tech stack, where all the technologies, all the cars will be built on this tech stack going forward. So it's been a very interesting journey so far.
Greg Williams 40:13 ↗
Obviously because it's 2024, I'm legally obliged to ask you about artificial intelligence. I'd love to get your sense of what the role of AI and machine learning play here, particularly around safety. Can machine learning and AI algorithms help us in predictive ways? Can they help us to actually prevent bad things from happening?
Anders Bell 40:33 ↗
Absolutely. We see more and more, we're using more and more in the teams AI to increase productivity in simulation, in coding, etc. But from a product perspective in the car, where we are primarily investing in AI is where it matters the most, which is to save lives. From that perspective, we are working with extremely valuable partners. The EX90 outside is equipped with two Nvidia SoCs and a Qualcomm Snapdragon platform, which are both hardware ready for future AI applications in the vehicle. It's in the self-driving realm or the automation of driving, because our ambition is to accelerate towards zero. We cannot have any other target than zero accidents and zero deaths. We can't morally have any other target. So we are using AI to accelerate faster towards zero. It's all about having the hardware platform that you can gradually over time profill with better and better instructions. In this, we have our fully owned subsidiary, Sense Act, which is probably Scandinavia's best AI outfit, working full-time on developing our vision perception stack to run on all our future cars.
Greg Williams 41:55 ↗
You mentioned autonomous vehicles, semi-autonomous vehicles. How is the software-defined vehicle getting us closer to that? We were promised these things quite a long time ago. Is that going to be a step change?
Anders Bell 42:12 ↗
Absolutely, it's the only credible step change towards zero, or a big incremental step, because cars are driven by people currently, and people are imperfect. We're all humans. So our approach is not to be a dash to get the first to level X, Y, Z, or level three plus plus, however many pluses you put after it. Our approach is really through safe automation, continuously work towards zero. Zero implies automation absolutely, because you cannot have zero when there are humans involved because humans are imperfect. For us, it's most important to create systems that are convenient to use, that you love activating your Pilot Assist when you're driving, so you do it every time, because that's the best way we can further reduce accidents and keep on improving that stack again through the closed loop systems. We already have today, on the vision perception stack, we drive from code to car every day in the development phase. We release every single day back to cars on the road to test the latest and greatest algorithms. That process is already up and running, and soon as we get the cars out on the road, we can start connecting, getting that software into the customers' vehicles.
Greg Williams 43:29 ↗
Sure. We just had Meredith on the stage, and she wouldn't forgive me if I didn't ask you about privacy. How do you balance what you're describing, the need for data collection in order to improve safety and improve the experience of drivers, with driver and passenger privacy concerns?
Anders Bell 43:50 ↗
I really appreciated listening to Meredith. I think first we need to acknowledge and accept that there's a duality here. Data privacy is super important. I usually say data safety is also safety, and we're safety. The protection of data, the topic of cybersecurity, etc., are extremely important. We need regulations, we need to handle it very, very carefully. At the same time, data and data insight, especially in the automotive world, is our best path to getting to ever more safer, ever more sustainable products. So we need to be able to do both. It's up to us as a company to earn the trust from our customers to press yes on that consent button, so that you trust that we will use your data anonymized, of course, to make the world a better place. Ultimately, we want to make safer cars, we want to reduce our CO2 footprint on the world, and we want to do good things with your data. But it's our job to make sure you trust us and press that consent, and that we can also tell you later on what we did with the aggregated data that we see. We need to show results coming from your data.
Greg Williams 45:10 ↗
Sometimes when we talk about software-defined vehicles, it can seem a little bit like an abstract concept. I'd love to get into some specific, real-world examples. Can you give us an example of how you've used real-world data to influence something very specific in terms of a feature or a design modification?
Anders Bell 45:30 ↗
Absolutely. Real world, I mean, all the examples you see out there on the wall are all examples of safety technology we developed as a result of real-world data. It's just real-world data we had to go out and grab, we had to go out physically to the scenes of accidents. There are other examples as well, smaller ones, that go into the millions of engineering hours we pour into designing obsessively the front structure, how to behave in a crash. But also smaller things, like we see a lot of run-off-road accidents where you drive into the ditch, you have a lot of spine compression. This is data we have to go actively look for in medical reports, etc. So when you run off the road and you land hard, there's quite a lot of people who get problems with their back after having a spine compression. So we integrate into the seats energy absorption mechanisms, so when if you run off the road, the seat will slightly collapse and absorb energy and hopefully save your spine. These are examples of small steps, things that we do all around the car. Not everything results in a fantastic patent or something that is worth doing an ad campaign about, but it's important. They are all a result of collecting real-world data and understanding the real world. Again, the software-defined vehicle for us is that real-world, real-time insight, which is almost like, wow, this is going to be sometimes called the Hubble Telescope moment when we look at the field data collected. No human eyes have ever seen this before, fully understanding the world. It's massive. It's exciting times.
Greg Williams 47:10 ↗
It's a Wired event, so obviously we have to look forward. I'd love to get a sense from you of what emerging technologies you believe are going to be really transformative in enhancing the experience for drivers and passengers and also enhancing safety moving forward. You said humans are fallible, so we're never going to get to zero accidents, but are there technologies that you really are optimistic can help us get much closer?
Anders Bell 47:39 ↗
I think, I sometimes get the question and continue there in the same theme: what's the biggest innovation in automotive over the last say 20 years? Number one, automotive generally doesn't invent things. We're kind of high up making the world's most complex consumer product, we apply technologies, we don't typically invent things, except maybe in the world of airbags and combustion engine technology. The biggest step, the biggest game changer in automotive has been the telematics, the introduction of telematics in the car and continuous high-speed, low-latency connection, because that is the lifeline to understanding the world. I think keep on building on that and designing the whole system around both the cloud side, how we compute, how we analyze, and how we can connect back to the vehicle again. This is a vehicle now which is a flat topology where all the hardware capabilities can be combined in new ways. So it's really on that system level where the big innovations will continue to happen. The ability to connect endlessly the car, which used to be this isolated object roaming around the world taking up 20-25% of public space, into something which is actually useful and can better our cities and the planet as such. It's a resource we have, both compute and energy on board, which again connected with the ability to communicate, turn on and off, give back energy to the grid. You can theoretically use the onboard computing to do meaningful stuff when you're parked as well. There are so many things we can do which are untapped with the so-called software-defined vehicle.
Greg Williams 49:17 ↗
Okay, one final question for you then. Let's zoom out and think about a societal level. What do you think the impact of a software-defined vehicle really can be, broadly when we're looking at the mobility ecosystem? What's the bigger picture?
Anders Bell 49:35 ↗
Let's see if my crystal ball is enough here. We're at a Wired event, so we need a very, very accurate crystal ball. For me, I stay focused on primarily the case of safety. I think different car makers will have different interests, they will go different avenues.
to explore different business opportunities, etc. We do this mostly for the contribution to how we can take this next level up in safety performance. But all your car sharing, I mean all those discussions have been around for quite some time. The next few years again will be super interesting to see how the robo taxi environment develops. Some of my colleagues here took the Waymo car to come to the venue today. That whole urban mobility, is there room for the car? I mean if you look at Europe for instance, the car is getting banned from many city centers, yes, and it's becoming more of a rural product, and the cities are moving more towards micromobility and public transport sectors. I think this is going to develop very differently across different regions. And I think the key point here is being able to have a product which can adapt quickly by activating different functionalities or use modes through software is key, because then you're quick to respond to whatever the world needs. But thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, absolutely fascinating Anders, thank you so much.
Greg Williams 51:03 ↗
And I'm now delighted to welcome the mighty Steven Levy from Wired with the equally mighty co-founder and CEO of Figma, Dylan Field. Welcome.
Okay, hi everyone, having a good time? Great. So I'm really delighted to welcome Dylan Field to the Big Interview stage. He's the co-founder and CEO of Figma. As a student of Brown University, he and his co-founder Evan Wallace began experimenting with design tools built on and for the web, and with funding from a Thiel Fellowship, maybe we'll talk about that, they began Figma. His previous jobs were internships including at LinkedIn. Figma has millions of users, they run a big developer conference called Config, and lately they've been very creative in integrating AI into their product, like you had a choice, right? And welcome Dylan Field.
Dylan Field 52:26 ↗
Steven, thank you for having me. And also really great to be back here. Config, our first Config, which was just weeks before the pandemic, was actually here at the Midway, and so it's very exciting to be back and good energy.
Greg Williams 52:42 ↗
Great to have you back. Though I have to say, I've got a comment on what you're wearing. You are the CEO of a multi-billion dollar company, why are you wearing an Enron hoodie?
Dylan Field 52:58 ↗
All right, well first of all, one thing that people don't know enough of is that the Enron logo was designed by Paul Rand, which I'm sure some of us know. Paul Rand was an amazing brand designer responsible for many different corporate entities, including IBM, the NeXT cube, and his last one actually was the Enron logo. And it was the final project he worked on, it was released after his death. And you might say it had a short shelf life. It went from what I think actually is a quite timeless logo to being called the Crooked E. And one thing that happened yesterday which I got a real kick out of was somebody actually acquired the rights to the Enron brand and they did a relaunch on the anniversary of the bankruptcy. And to me, I think this is fascinating because it brings up all sorts of questions for a new generation that didn't necessarily have all the associations with Enron as others did. Can you actually make a new company out of that material? For me, I was 9 years old when Enron went bankrupt in 2001. I was reading the newspaper, aware that there was really bad stuff happening, aware that there were brownouts, but I definitely don't have those same associations as a lot of others do. So that's why I'm wearing the sweatshirt.
Greg Williams 54:50 ↗
So in other words, you're not getting the negative implications, of which there are some, of Enron, but it's just like a cool, gangster aspect of it attached to a logo which you bonded to. Is this always an appreciation of that stuff? You had, because you were in college doing math and science, then you get this Fellowship that basically tells people to get out of college and build something, and you gravitate towards design. Is this something you were always interested in, or did you just see it as a gap, an opportunity?
Dylan Field 55:30 ↗
Yeah, I was always interested in design, not always very good at design. Those are two different things, your taste versus your ability. There are a lot of good famous quotes about that. But for me, I was always fascinated with how things worked, the experience of things, and also graphics and how you could use interfaces online and the web as well as desktop software. I grew up playing things like Incredible Machine, then eventually things like Neopets were big influences for me in my childhood, and the design aspects of those and how they worked were endlessly fascinating. But it took a while to get to Figma. I started the company because my co-founder and I were excited about WebGL and we thought that was definitely an opportunity, the ability to use the GPU in your computer in the browser. If we could start to do that, what could you make? We thought there were really two things that could be interesting: one is games and the other might be tools. We thought games is a hit-based business that is incredibly hard to do the right way, so we're not going to go there. Instead, we said let's go explore the space of tools. I'd actually just been a design intern at Flipboard and they had an incredible design team there, really ahead of their time in terms of the premium they put on design. They thought about design as something that everyone in the company contributed to and was the reason they stood out as a business. Despite that, it still took a while for us to get back to design because we thought it was a tiny market. It turned out that the more we learned about it, the more we looked into it, we started to realize that this was an exponential trend of not only how much software is created in the world but also the importance of design in that context. Design was the way you'd stand out. What's interesting now in this age of AI is that it feels like that's even more true than ever, both the exponential trend of software, it's going straight vertical now, but also this idea that the craft of design being the way that companies will stand out in this age of software is more important than it's ever been. When we started Figma, the ratio of designers to engineers was off the charts, much better than it had been 10 years prior. We started to see improvements in those ratios even over the first five years of Figma. If you look to the future, it might be that the ratio flips, that there are more people doing things that look like design than people actually building the code. I'm fascinated to see what that'll look like in the future.
Greg Williams 58:44 ↗
One of the pillars of Figma is this paradigm of collaboration in design. Now Paul Rand, who you idolize, he didn't have to collaborate with anyone. When Steve Jobs tried to stick his nose into the process when he was doing the NeXT design, he said get out of here, it's either take it or leave it, if you don't like it I'll take my $100,000 and go home. Did you have trouble pitching that to generations of designers who were used to that kind of diva attitude?
Dylan Field 59:25 ↗
Absolutely. There's this mindset that agencies had where there's a grand reveal and a black box that the process is in. When we launched Figma, I remember the comments were something like, if this is the future of design I'm changing careers. Another comment that always stuck with me was, a camel is a horse designed by committee. What we found is because design is so central to how a business works and whether you win or lose, not only does everyone have an opinion, and you could say the more opinions the worse it gets, but I actually find that if you're able to make it so that everyone can come together and see the best ideas and you can visualize them quickly, which I think becomes more possible in the age of AI, then you're able to create a playing field. For brand marks like Paul Rand created, you have to be so strongly opinionated, that's a different sort of beast altogether. But when it comes to thinking through user flows, thinking through how a product experience should work and how a business should win, oftentimes that really helps the strategy.
Greg Williams 1:00:54 ↗
So what you said before links to something else that you've said, because creativity is the new productivity, right? Can you explain that?
Dylan Field 1:01:06 ↗
My sense is that people are trying to visually express themselves much more than before, and also that there's a new paradigm possible when you've got an infinite visual canvas. With an infinite visual canvas, whether it's in a whiteboard tool like FigJam or even in a slide deck, and we have Figma Slides now too, being able to show great visual work can really help bring people along. I think that the more creative you can be, the more you can stand out, whether it's inside of an organization or on the outside in your marketing and product, the ways that you'll stand out to customers.
Greg Williams 1:01:54 ↗
So millions of people are using Figma, which they are, right? You're not telling me how many millions, but it's fair to say millions. Then if everything looks good, how do you stand out? It makes it on you, raising the bar and making it actually tougher to be distinct.
Dylan Field 1:02:12 ↗
Yeah, I think that it's not just about how it looks but also how it works, of course. But I believe that there are things that the best designers are doing today in terms of interactivity, dynamism, motion, and just unique experiences that they're creating which very few people are able to do. I hope that we can do two things. I hope that we can, partially with our tools but also partially with AI, and really they're the same thing, lower the floor, make it so that more people can participate in the process of design, but also raise the ceiling, make it so that more people, whether they're new to design or outside the world of design, can raise the ceiling on their work and match the work of some of the best designers in the world. They're limited more by their ideas than by the tools in front of them.
Greg Williams 1:03:17 ↗
So Dylan, the first time we spoke, I know we had a great meeting and you went out for coffee, and you were telling me how you're never going to sell out, sell this company, we're going to go it alone, we're going to build on that. And it was like maybe two months later, Adobe is going to buy your company for $20 billion. I felt so bad when I told you that.
Dylan Field 1:03:47 ↗
If you've ever had a one-on-one conversation with Steven, you'll know how he stares into your soul. I had just gotten off a call with Adobe literally minutes before. What a poker player, unbelievable. No, I was petrified. I was like, did he hear? Anyway, I'm still sorry.
Greg Williams 1:04:15 ↗
Okay, well don't drop the subject. What I mean, why just feel bad? That's all I mean. Did you feel it was an offer you couldn't refuse, or is it something you felt was genuinely going to be better for your customers and to grow what you want to do?
Dylan Field 1:04:33 ↗
I was honestly quite excited. I think it was something that, to me, especially as we explored it further, and that was still early in the process, we were going back and forth, but I was excited about the possibilities we could have inside of Adobe. What we could do there in terms of taking the multiplayer tech, the way that we brought our product to the web, and doing that for more of the Adobe ecosystem, and the change we could create there. I thought it was a good outcome not only for our customers, which honestly most of the negotiation was about how to make sure our customers would end up in a great place and be beneficial for them, but also for all the stakeholders around the company. So yeah, I was excited and that's why we went after it. Obviously, because regulators here and abroad said they were not going to look kindly on this, that went fizzle and you're left with a company on your own again. You have an extra billion dollars for a breakup fee, but I'm sure you had your plans and distraction, but then you get to concentrate on AI. So walk me through a little bit of your journey about how you're building, it's available now, open betas and things, AI into what you do.
Absolutely. So yeah, we're wildly excited about all the opportunities ahead. As we think about the future of Figma and what it can become, we started off as a design tool where a third of our weekly active users are designers, a third are developers, and a third are in the other category. We found these folks were coming into the product and then we started to build out from there. We created FigJam, we created Figma Slides, now Dev Mode, and we're really trying to make this platform where you can go and create products end to end. As I think about what AI enables through that, I get excited about these different transitions between abstractions. How can you go from a brainstorm file to a slide deck, or a slide deck to a design file, a design file to working code? That becomes more possible in a world of AI. But also the ability to improve the way that you explore this idea maze. We're all kind of in the design process thinking about all these different possibilities that could exist. How do you rapidly navigate that, think about the things that could be, evaluate them quickly, and then see if you want to go down that path and really refine it and bring all the craft to it, or if you can discard that possibility? If you could do that across that entire process quickly and bring those two things together, it's super powerful. That's where I think you can both lower the floor and raise the ceiling, and make it that in the end state, even though there's so much more software in the world, the software we have that stands out can be so much better.
Greg Williams 1:08:01 ↗
It seems to me, correct me if I'm wrong, there are sort of two paths that you're pursuing on AI. One is just to improve the flow, to use AI the way some of us use ChatGPT to fill in things and automate certain kinds of things, make edits all at once, search through things you already have, things that make it go smoother and take drudgery away. The second is almost to build a collaborator to the creative process, and that's where things get interesting and a little questionable, like where did this stuff come from? You had one experience, a product that, maybe you explain it briefly, but ultimately someone used something that wound up looking a lot like Apple's weather app and you had to make an adjustment. So rather than dive into that, there is this gray area of whether people should contribute to the training sets. You're transparent about that, but some people want to contribute to the community, other people are very protective, there are lawsuits. So where do you stand on that? Do you feel that we're going to be a blend of the creativity that comes from this cloud of what comes from training sets and us, or will people draw firmer lines as this goes along?
Dylan Field 1:09:41 ↗
It's interesting because when we launched this make design feature, which we later called First Draft because we thought that was more representative of the actual value we were creating, the first draft that you're going to iterate on, we did it in a way that was more generic. What we found in the feedback we received was that design companies have a design system already. They have a system that they rely on, a kit of parts of all their styles and components that they want to use. They don't want an arbitrary thing. What they do want from us is the ability to quickly explore and make variations using their own design system. So first of all, most likely a lot of those outputs on the generative side are more unique to companies and organizations than they are matching the general universe of design. But it is important to be able to do all sorts of other functionality as well. I think where training comes in is making it that we're able to explore things like, if you're in Gmail for example and you start typing and you see autosuggested text and you can press tab to complete it, what's the design tool equivalent of that? What makes it so that you can remove drudgery, the things that people don't want to do, and put people into more of a flow state, make them more creative, and make it so that they can explore even more options faster? If we can do that, then I think that is really exciting.
Greg Williams 1:11:21 ↗
That's great, but I guess my fear is you're doing great work in democratizing design, so you add AI to the mix. There are people who are going to lower the floor, raise the floor, to make things look good, but we've already seen what good enough does in ChatGPT and we're inundated with AI slop. I guess it's sort of my nightmare that this stuff looks better and draws this in even more.
Dylan Field 1:11:53 ↗
Yeah, I think it's interesting. When I looked back at the history of Figma, there was a moment in 2014, 2015 where I realized some of the negative effects of the power of design. I remember later on reading about the time ISIS was a really important challenge that we were facing globally, and there was a magazine they put out which was really horrific and it was incredibly well designed. Design has the power to lift bad actors as well. That's an extreme case, obviously, as well as stuff that might just be not as interesting. I think that is the reality of all tools. They have the power, if they're made correctly, to lift people up. That's a debate you can have about any tool. But what I think is most important is that we find ways to recognize that most of the AI tools right now are about lowering the floor. They're about democratization. Democratization is great in many ways, and new use cases and markets are unlocked. You talk to the people that do image generation with diffusion models, not all of them are doing the things that you expect. Some of them are doing art therapy, which was never possible before. But I also think it's so critical for us to really invest in raising the ceiling and making these new possibilities for designers. That's where a lot of our thinking is right now and that's where I hope we can drive towards.
Greg Williams 1:13:47 ↗
I love to go on that's a great place to stop. Thank you, Dylan. Thank you so much.
So we're going to take a 30 minute break. Talk amongst yourselves, but don't go too far because when we come back in 30 minutes we'll have an exciting performance from 2024 Olympic gold medalist Phil Wizard. Thank you, thanks all.
Dexter Thomas 1:14:27 ↗
Please welcome Dexter Thomas. Check, check, check, check, hello, hello. Don't get too excited, I am not the main event. I am just here to introduce the main event. So welcome back from the short break. What I would like to do, or what we're going to do during this session, is bring a little bit of extra culture into the mix over here. So without a whole lot of further ado, because y'all aren't here to watch me talk, you're here to watch somebody dance, actually to somebody's dance. So I would love to bring to the stage, if we're ready, Phil Wizard.
We can definitely do better than that. Come on, big round of applause, let's go, let's go. That's closer, that's closer, there we go.
Give it up one more time, one more time, bro. Yo, bro, once again, Phil Wizard, who we'll be bringing back on in just a moment. So I just want to set the table a little bit for y'all. There is a word that you will probably not hear us using very often on the stage, probably not at all actually, and it is the word that you probably might use yourselves and it's okay. Break dancing. Break dancing is a phrase that we actually don't use all that often. It is something that, no offense, outsiders use a lot, but actually people in the scene don't say break dancing. People will say b-boying, people say b-girling, or if you would like to say breaking. So what you just saw was breaking. Now if you have to explain it to somebody, you say break dancing, that's okay. I'm not going to say anything, I don't know how Phil feels about it, but most people seem to not be too offended about it, that's all right. But that is just one thing. The next thing is you might be wondering what in the heck is a couple of b-boys, what is some hip-hop doing here at what is a sensibly Wired Big Interview like this, a bunch of tech stuff, what are y'all doing here? Well, if we're talking about creating the future, I will humbly posit to you that the guest that I'm about to bring out is part of creating the future. We are talking about somebody, once again Phil Wizard, who saw some breakers in 2009 when he was in middle school, went home, he thought it looked really cool, went home and got on YouTube, looked it up, and 15 years later he won an Olympic gold medal. So I would humbly posit to you that the stuff that we are about to speak about and the stuff that you just saw, that is what a lot of this stuff is about. That is what the technology is moving. This is the stuff that goes into the phones, goes into the computers, this is the stuff that we're doing. So I would love to bring out once again, top ranked b-boy before the Olympics even happened, and now the first ever gold medalist, b-boy Philip Kim, AKA Phil Wizard.
Man, good to talk again, good to talk to you again. So I just first off, I want to thank you for just silencing the haters. First off, man, if you have not seen this person's Instagram, look at it, it is incredible. I mean cookies, cakes, biscuits, baguettes, this dude, and you will see him posting himself eating all of this, I'm not going to say junk food, but very tasty looking treats. And you got people in the comments saying bro stop, we need you good for the Olympics.
Phil Wizard 1:21:18 ↗
I literally had people, because you could bet at the Olympics on who's going to win, and I had people in my DMs being like yo, I put money on you, can you fix your diet? You need to eat healthy. And then one of my other friends messaged me because his friend had messaged him being like, this is how he really eats. And one of my best friends knows, he's like yo, when he eats like this, you know he's ready. I think the day before you posted yourself eating like cookies or something like that. I just like to enjoy life. Those things, obviously health and nutrition is extremely important in anything physical, but I think people don't understand that those aren't all I eat. My meals are extremely healthy. I like sweets, I've always liked sweets, and it's not like I'm suddenly doing this for the Olympics. Every competition leading up to a competition, I'm eating sweets the day before. It's my version of carbo-loading. I don't know if it's actually scientifically proven, but it works for me.
Dexter Thomas 1:22:06 ↗
Clearly it worked. So man, there are so many moments from, if we're just going to talk about the Olympics, one of my favorite moments, if you could break this down for me, it's not even the finals actually. The finals is amazing, but it's actually the semi-finals, you versus Shigekix. It's the semi-finals. And just picture this, by the way, who watched the Olympics? Who watched? Okay, about half, okay, we're doing good. A little bit, that's all right. Your homework is going to be to watch more, we'll talk about this later. All right, but this, I think the end of round three, Shigekix is doing his thing, and I mean just imagine this guy just power move after power move, just, you know, every when you think of breaking, he's doing all that stuff times 10, it's amazing, he's so good. And then right near the end of his last set, he starts stepping and he's doing a few things, and he starts spinning and he goes into this rotation, and I see you looking at him, and the camera picks it up, and he looks at him and he goes from like fan mode just enjoying what's happening and backing up, he says hold on, and then all of a sudden you do a handstand and like go in kind of a V type thing just as he does the same thing. So basically you predicted his move, which is incredible. Talk about that.
Phil Wizard 1:23:32 ↗
It's funny because I think from an outside perspective, and I didn't know, I think this went a bit viral, I saw it on TikTok after a bunch of times, but it's funny because for us it's not that weird. I've done it to him specifically a bunch of times in other competitions, but I guess it was a bit different because it was on the Olympic platform and from that angle in which it was shot too, it was like, I will give myself credit, it was exactly the same move, the exact same freeze, symmetrical. But the thing in breaking is, first for those who don't know, it's a freestyle dance, so we don't know what the music being played is going to be, so we just kind of go up there and you have to adjust to what you're doing. But a lot of breakers will still pre-choreograph their movements and so they'll just time it to the music. Shigekix is one of those people. The breaking community is quite small and Shigekix and myself are on the same team, we're both sponsored by Red Bull, so I've competed with him and against him so many times that I know his moves. I know all of his moves. So I knew what he was going to do. And I think it's like as a friend, I probably shouldn't have done that to him on the Olympic stage, but in the heat of the moment you're just like, I know what he's going to do, so I'm going to do it myself. Personally, I have a bit of a different approach. Everyone has their moves, but the way I put my moves together are very different every single time, and I don't even know what I'm going to do when I show up on that stage. Based on the music, based on the crowd, based on how I feel, I change my plan all the time. So someone couldn't do that to me as easily.
Dexter Thomas 1:24:52 ↗
It's unpredictable. You go up and you'll do stuff where it's like, is this that breaking? Do y'all do that like the weird rubber band legs thing? It's amazing. So I mean, again, just to put into context, imagine Simone Biles, somebody says hey those flips are amazing, too many of those points off, nobody would ever do that, right? It's completely different if you're talking about it as a sport.
Phil Wizard 1:25:11 ↗
Yes.
Dexter Thomas 1:25:16 ↗
Which brings me into something else which makes me think that, you know, before we were talking, we spoke before the Olympics, and I remember one of the big conversations was within the community, is breaking being at the Olympics even a good thing? Now I'm curious, has that conversation changed? Before, has it changed since? What's the vibe been like?
Phil Wizard 1:25:39 ↗
Yeah, I mean, again, for people that don't know, breaking derives from hip-hop culture. It's been part of the culture since its inception. Breaking traditionally within the world of breaking has been seen as an art and a culture first. It's a dance, it's about self-expression. It's difficult to go into something like the Olympics because it's so subjective. It still is, it's based on opinion. For example, figure skating in the Olympics, it can be very subjective, it is very artistic, but there are certain criteria they have to hit. In breaking, there's no criteria that we have to hit. You can go up and do whatever you want. That makes it very, very subjective. That's why that debate is so big. Is it sport? Is it art? For myself, I do think the beauty of it is that it doesn't really matter. These are just labels to me at the end of the day. I think the beauty of it is that it can transcend these things. It's extremely athletic. We see ourselves as athletes and we've always seen ourselves as athletes prior to the Olympics, but at the same time we see ourselves as artists too. It's about self-expression, it's about finding your style, finding your individuality, and those are the people that are celebrated within the dance. We have a common saying within the world of breaking that I have adopted as well and that I kind of live by: train like an athlete but think like an artist. I think the beauty of breaking is that it can transcend those labels and it can live within those two parallels.
Dexter Thomas 1:26:52 ↗
I remember you were saying, because some of the worry about breaking being at the Olympics was that, okay, is mainstreaming this going to dilute it? Is a bunch of outsiders going to basically, we're talking about selling out here. So the Olympics have come and gone. How do people feel? Was it, because we were talking about this is going to provide opportunities for people. Has it definitely?
Phil Wizard 1:27:18 ↗
I can only speak from my own experience and those that are kind of close around me, but it definitely has opened up a lot of doors for people. It's opened up a lot of narratives and opportunities, like speaking here, that we never could have done prior. So we can speak about breaking on a bigger platform. There are opinions on breaking after the Olympic Games for many reasons, and we can have the opportunities to speak on that and to talk about the culture, to talk about the fact that for us it's not just a sport. So yes, and I will say there are messy parts to it too, of course. Going into the Olympics, coming out of the Olympics, there are things that when I looked back I was like, that could have been done way better, this could have been done way better. But that's with anything, nothing's ever going to be perfect. At the end of the day, I can only speak from my personal experience, I do think it is a net positive.
Dexter Thomas 1:27:58 ↗
But you never know. Okay, you open that window. Could have been done better. What do you mean?
Phil Wizard 1:28:03 ↗
There are a lot of things that were a bit disorganized in the process. When you're an athlete competing in it too, you don't really look too deeply into it because you're so focused on your competition and what you're competing at. I know the people that have been running the Olympics, they're friends of mine, they're great people, but there are things that maybe shouldn't have been done, certain judges that shouldn't have been there, whatever. But I also understand that I don't understand the whole political and geopolitical environment surrounding that, so I can't fully judge because I don't know the full picture. But there are things for myself as a competitor that I think could have probably been done better.
Dexter Thomas 1:28:43 ↗
So you kind of danced around this a little bit, and I want to address the kangaroo-shaped elephant in the room. Unfortunately, I felt this when I tell people I talked to this guy who I think is going to get gold, and then the conversation immediately spins over to, if you're not familiar, Australian breaker Raygun, who a lot of people had a lot of feelings about. How has that conversation been within the scene?
Phil Wizard 1:29:12 ↗
Yeah, I mean, it's hard because I get this question a lot now, I bet you do, but it's okay, honestly I don't mind talking about it. First and foremost, I don't think anyone deserves the amount of hate that she got. No one deserves to be bullied. That's just internet culture, that's meme culture. No one deserves that kind of hate. But this is probably one of the problems that isn't necessarily just for breaking. I know it's inherent in other sports as well, it was just more inherent in breaking because it was the debut of breaking and again we're going in as a sport that no one really understands going into it. There's a lot of negativity already being like, why is this even there? But it happens in other sports. Essentially, why she qualified was because there are continental qualifiers and they had to do continental qualifiers, so she won the Oceania qualifier. Traditionally in breaking, there aren't a lot of breakers in Oceania in general. The scene is very small and there's no one that's really high level. From my understanding too, because of the nature of things, it was put together very last minute, and so the opportunity for other people around Oceania to even go to the qualifier, which happened in Australia, was quite low. So she was the best of the bunch that were there, but the amount of people that were there I think was quite low. So she rightfully earned her spot, but she was not at the level of the other competitors at all. The unfortunate thing is when you look at the B-girl category specifically, I was there live, it was some of the top level B-girls especially in the second half when you go from top eight onwards, the level was incredible and it was beautiful to watch. It's unfortunate that the narrative was all focused on her. When I say it's happened in other sports, from my understanding in things like swimming this happens where there are certain people that shouldn't be there, but because of how qualifications work, certain countries get kind of like byes, right? But in something like swimming, you can see the gap, you can see the distance, you can see like oh this person is significantly worse than the other people, but that's a little bit more difficult to understand in breaking. But because of that meme culture, a lot of things kind of came out of it.
Dexter Thomas 1:31:00 ↗
Yeah, well I guess that takes me to kind of wrap this question then. You said that the Olympics has been a net positive, right? What I've seen is a lot of people, if you ask them about breaking in the Olympics, the one thing they know about is, and it's not even her full set, it's like a supercut, it's all the bad parts. Because yo, there's some parts, and I challenge anybody in this room to do some of the moves she was doing. You cannot do them unless you actually b-boy or b-girl, at which point come on up and show us your thing. But it's this really concentrated viral moment when there was so much else. Is there any concern, I guess, that that will be what people have taken away from breaking?
Phil Wizard 1:31:46 ↗
Yeah, I mean, again, that's just the reality of meme culture on the internet nowadays. Like you said, it's a supercut. No one, it's the same thing with interviews, people will take things out of context. It's the exact same thing that happened with the Raygun thing. They just took the supercut of her bad parts and put it on the internet. Do I think it's bad? Yes, I do. I personally think it's a bit embarrassing for breaking because people will kind of walk away from the Olympics thinking this is what breaking was at the Olympics moving forward. So I don't think that that is the best for us. But again, I think there are opportunities like this to kind of change the narrative and talk about it. Hopefully that happens moving forward, and hopefully Raygun honestly stops getting bullied and has the opportunity to talk about it more as well. So we'll see what happens.
Dexter Thomas 1:32:29 ↗
Yeah, so you know, and another thing to be cleared up, it was already set before the Olympics even happened that breaking would not be an event in 2028. It was not because of her performance. So there, but to be real, there's a lot of misinformation out here.
Phil Wizard 1:32:42 ↗
Exactly.
Dexter Thomas 1:32:45 ↗
So let's say that you could wave a wand and breaking would be in 2028. Would you want that?
Phil Wizard 1:32:54 ↗
The 2028 Olympics in LA. It's a good question. Yes, the simple answer is yes. But I think within those four years, a lot would have to change. Just the way qualifications work, and again, coming in as a new sport and it coming in pretty quickly, there are adaptations that are difficult to make in a short amount of time. I think after having experienced it once, I would be an advocate for things needing to change for the next one. There has to be a lot more transparency. We can even just talk about problems within breaking that have been around for a long time but are now pushed to the spotlight more with a platform like this. In the sense that when you go to a breaking competition, the judging panel and the judging system for the Olympics is just red or blue. It just says who the judge voted for. That needs to be more transparent, especially for people who don't understand breaking. Not just this person won, why did they win, by what margin, but by what reason? I think those kind of things need to change. There are a lot of technical details. But I think again, if it were to come back in the future, I think it would be a cool thing, but it would just mean that we would have to put in a lot more work to make that more transparent and more easily understandable for people. I think that's almost a blessing in disguise because there are a lot of problems that have been spotlighted for us within breaking that we never thought about before. For us as breakers, we understand all of this already. I know why this person lost or won, I can see it. But when someone else who doesn't watch breaking, it doesn't happen often that there are a lot of people who don't watch breaking, especially at the scale of the Olympics, recognizing like oh right, these people don't know this. Even the idea, people came up to me and be like oh you know what music is going to be played, right? When someone first asked me that, I was like what are you talking about? Breaking is a freestyle dance. And it made me realize like oh right, people don't know about this, people don't understand this. So it just addresses a lot of things that myself included, I didn't know as problems until it's put on such a big stage like this.
Dexter Thomas 1:34:39 ↗
It's really interesting to me that you have not only truly at the top of the game, top level of this, but also that we're still needing to explain this to everybody. I mean, imagine LeBron James just doing what he does and then jumping in the announcers box and saying okay everybody, what I just did, this is why it was cool, right? It's amazing.
Phil Wizard 1:35:00 ↗
Yeah, but I think that's okay too because I understand that people don't understand this and it takes a lot to understand. To the naked eye watching breaking, you will be impressed by the things that are of course physically impressive, people spinning on their heads, people doing these crazy movements. But there are so many details and layers to breaking that myself included only understand after years of being into it and actually learning the dance and understanding why other things are actually significant, more difficult creatively as well. But to the naked eye they won't understand. I'm happy to talk about that. I'm a nerd about breaking. I love breaking. I still watch it to this day. The people I compete with and against, I still fanboy over. Some of my best friends I grew up watching now. For me it's still surreal to me and I'm happy to open that door for other people if I can.
Dexter Thomas 1:35:41 ↗
This will be my last question then, because we could talk about this all day. You already know me. So being that breaking is a part of hip-hop culture, and I think the older the person is, the more connection to that they feel. I think the younger we get, we feel like rap is something different, breaking is something different, DJing is something different. Do you feel like in the future, because you're at the point now where you still have, if Olympics come back you still have two, three, four Olympics left in you, definitely, but you're at the point now where there are kids who are looking up to you, where maybe you're the first YouTube video that they see, and they're looking at you like how could I be like Phil? Is there a way for you, looking at the next generation, that breaking, that rap, that everything else comes together and we stop being distant cousins and we start being more like hip-hop as a culture again? Is that on the horizon for you?
Phil Wizard 1:36:42 ↗
I mean, I think that would be cool. I will be completely honest, even for myself, I know I'm way more just joined into hip-hop than I probably should be. And again, like you said, as the generations get younger, those things tend to separate a lot more. But I think that's not just the job of breaking. That's the job of the rappers, that's the job of the MCs, the DJs, and the graffiti writers to bring that all together. But it's hard because it does get disjointed and history gets blurred as the generations kind of move on. Even within the context of breaking, there were some hip-hop artists and rappers that came out and were like yo, breaking is in the Olympics, this is cool, but then there are other people being like yo, that's whack. So yeah, it does, I don't think it's just our job. I think it's something that we should push because history is extremely important. To recognize where this comes from is to understand where that energy comes from. What you were saying even before, the context of break dancing and breaking, why it's so important is because of history. The reason it's called breaking is because they would dance on the break of a record. The DJ would loop the break, so they had two records of the same song and they would loop the break. On that break was the hypest part, it was when the drums were played, and so the dancers would start dancing. They would dance on the break of the song. That's why we're called breakers. Because of that, the reason it's so important, for some people you might see it as just a name, but the reason is because it's a context. It's why this dance started. That gets diluted further down you go. The reason it's called break dancing is because the media saw it and they were like you're just break dancing, you're breaking your bones and you're doing this crazy stuff, so we're going to call it break dancing. That's why it's called break dancing. But as generations keep moving forward, that history gets diluted. So it's important to understand that, to understand where it comes from, to understand that that's where the energy came from, that's why it's called what it's called. That's why history is important. I know myself, I have to do a better job of looking back and understanding that even more than I do now. And I know for future generations, it's my job then to teach that because if you don't teach it, then you start losing it. So I do think that's a responsibility of anyone who has a platform like myself for any high level breaker. But I also understand that I can do a better job of it as well.
Dexter Thomas 1:38:49 ↗
Thank you so much, my man. Thank you very much. Thank you so much. Thank you for having me.
A little bit louder, we can do better than that. Come on, that's an Olympian over there, gold medal, come on. Man, truly an honor. Thank y'all so much. So that is it for us. We're going to keep the energy going. Coming up next, I would like you all to welcome to the stage Wired Global Editorial Director Katie Drummond and the Senior Vice President of AARP Innovation Labs Andy Miller.
Katie Drummond 1:39:47 ↗
Hello. Oh, that was amazing. From breaking to aging. Whoever planned this transition, kudos to you. It's breaking as well, brilliant. Fabulous. So Andy, thank you so much for being here. I'm going to start with a really, really simple question that I think is relevant to everyone here. If you're a Wired reader, if you're in the Wired demographic, when they hear aging or age tech specifically, the term age tech, what I would think about, and I think what many in the Wired audience would think about, is blood transfusion, or supplement protocols, or cryopreservation, or all of these really fascinating, wild, maybe a little out there approaches to extending our lives, to living to 120, 130.
Forever, that's not quite it though in terms of the way you think about it and AARP thinks about it. So tell us a little bit about sort of what you mean when you say age tech.
Greg Williams 1:40:52 ↗
Yeah, so this is an interesting one. I'm going to step back. All those things you said are true, that's all happening. Scientific breakthroughs are letting us live much longer, and that curve is just decade over decade getting steeper. We think about age tech, it's really anything that's going to help you age well. We often get this question: would you want to live an extra 20 years? A little bit of an ethical dilemma. Certainly if you didn't live well, you probably wouldn't. So at AARP, our mission is to empower people to choose how they live as they age. The most important word there is 'choose,' because you and I may have different definitions of what living a longer, happier, healthier life would be. We are focused on finding innovation, finding technology solutions, products, and services that help us all age well in however we define 'well.' So someone may be into cryogenic freezing and want to go down that path, and that's great. Others just want to be able to be active and play pickleball until they're 90. No matter where you are in that continuum, that's what age tech is to us, and we're trying to find those solutions. It's really important because we often talk about this shift in the demographic. We see it, but I don't know that you all really understand what's happening. This is a very disturbing statistic, prepare yourselves. There's a few statistics I'll share that are disturbing but also good. 12,000 people turn 65 every single day in the United States. That's fairly mind-blowing to me. The interesting side of this, and I think in the description it talked about the economic possibilities here, in the US today, people over the age of 50 contribute 8.3 trillion dollars of economic impact into our economy. When you think out to 2030, that's a really significant time, and that's because 2030 is when the first Millennials, the oldest Millennials, turn 50. Projecting out, that number goes from 8 trillion to 12 trillion. If you think of that in terms of GDP, it would be the third largest GDP in the world, and that's just the US. Then if you think about this globally, today worldwide that number is 35 trillion. If you project out to 2050, it goes to almost a hundred trillion dollars of economic impact. So while the demographic shifts are happening, the money is flowing with it, and we've never encountered anything like this in the history of the world.
Katie Drummond 1:43:59 ↗
Yes, I would say this statistic, this fact that I'm a millennial on the elder side of millennial age, but that 2030 number really stood out to me. It felt too soon. And speaking of too soon, I'm going to be really candid with you that I think a lot of people, myself included, when they think of AARP, they think about the mail. You get mail from you. I get mail from you, and when I get the mail and I see it's from AARP, I think 'No, it's too soon. Why are you sending me this?' We will talk more about the mail in a little bit maybe if we have time. But what they may not associate you with is technology and innovation, when in fact you are actually doing a tremendous amount of work in the technology space. Just tell us more about that, because I think it will be surprising for people here to hear a bit about it.
Greg Williams 1:45:00 ↗
Yeah, so we are really good at mail. AARP, just to level set and make sure people understand who we are and what we do, at its core we are the largest nonprofit, nonpartisan advocacy association in the United States. We advocate for people over the age of 50 in the United States, and we do that at levels nationally in DC, at state and local levels. We have offices in every single state, Puerto Rico, the US Virgin Islands. We're known for that, and we're also known for deals and coupons and discounts. Great discounts. We have 38 million members that represent roughly 22 million households in the United States, and yes, they get member benefits, a lot of them in the form of deals at a restaurant or travel deals. One of the things we looked at about eight years ago was we are a great advocate for things like healthcare, but what are we doing for technology? What are we doing for this idea of age tech, which didn't really exist eight years ago? We had a lengthy conversation, the CEO and I, and if somebody was going to have the right to plant the flag in the ground and sort of galvanize the tech space around the concept of aging, it had to be us. There was really no discussion about it. The idea really is, let me step back. We had been working with startups for about the last seven years, and I think we had a portfolio of maybe 50. We started making small investments. One of the challenges we have is in the nonprofit structure, we cannot help those startups sell into the 38 million members, and it's unfortunate because it would be great for everybody. So we started thinking about how do we help these companies get in front of all of you? How do you get distribution, how do you get scale, how do you get money, how do you get pilots? No one really knew we were doing this. In 2019, we decided to have a 400 square foot footprint on the CES show floor. The idea was a little bit of shock and awe. We wanted people from the tech space to go to CES, come in and be like 'What in the world are you doing here and why?' What happens is when we tell them the story, and I'm sure many of you are product tech folks here, if I asked you how do you build your product, you'd probably say we put the consumer at the center of everything we do. We are representing the consumer, the 50-plus consumer, and in some cases even intergenerational interaction occurs, and we'll represent people that are under 50. We wanted that voice to be heard in the tech space. We wanted to tell that story that there's a huge need for people to use technology because there's two things that are certain for everyone sitting here: you're all going to be a caregiver, and you're all going to need care. There are not enough people in the US or the world, and technology has to fill the void. That was really the impetus of this: how do we start to spark innovation in industry, how do we bring together and convene the right people that care about aging and that can help us all age well? To give you some sense, fast forward from 2019, in about a month from now, AARP's booth at CES will be the largest booth on the Venetian side. We have almost 13,000 square feet, and we bring, I think, 30-something companies with us. Every year we're excited to go because we can continue to tell that story. The thing we did to galvanize this ecosystem was to build something called the AgeTech Collaborative, which is our effort to bring everyone together.
Katie Drummond 1:49:08 ↗
It's fantastic. And 13,000 square feet is a lot of real estate. That's a big space to fill. When you think about all of the startups and the companies and the innovators that you have worked with in these last seven, eight years, are there specific examples that stand out to you that you feel like have really made a dent in the way we age, that have grown and are now in households, affecting lives, that you can point us to?
Greg Williams 1:49:34 ↗
Yeah, this is a question I get a lot, and I hate answering it. Sorry, no, for the pure fact that if you're a parent out there, you're not supposed to have a favorite child. So pick a few, we would love to hear. We have about 200 in our portfolio today. I'll start by just saying there are some categories that we really think are important that we focus on. As you can imagine, a large number of people, our data suggested 77% of people want to age in their home. That number went up as a result of COVID and everything that happened with different nursing facilities. So smart home technology we think is one of the biggest areas, and that's not just what you think. It's this convergence of health tech with fintech, with lifestyle tech, with femtech, with all these different things coming together. We think that's one area that's really interesting. Mobility is a huge concern for us. I'll give you a stat that I think is my favorite stat and the most mind-blowing: when someone becomes socially isolated, the impact on their health is the equivalent of smoking 15 cigarettes a day. Wow. So we need to make sure that as we age, we can stay active. 10 years ago, if you asked someone that was approaching, let's say, 70, 'What's your biggest fear?' they would say unequivocally it was somebody taking my car keys away because they didn't want to lose that independence and that mobility. If you ask someone today, that's not the answer. The answer is my cognitive decline. They want to maintain their brain health, their sharpness. That's one of their biggest fears. So brain health is a huge focus for us. Along that social engagement path, it's entertainment. Everything can't be a downer. We get that a lot. 'Oh, the cryogenic freezing and I don't want to die and all this stuff.' But we want to live life, we want to live our best life, we want to be active and excited. I was telling Katie beforehand, at CES we're going to have a pickleball court. We want people to play pickleball. That's just one example. We do have a presence in the science fair here. I'm going to just pick on those three companies because they're here. We have a company, Biomotum. The single largest or most frequent surgery that happens for older adults is knee replacement or knee surgery, and behind that is hip surgery. If you lose mobility, you become more isolated. Biomotum has an exoskeleton for your legs that can actually help you walk and help you move around. Staying on that accessibility angle, there is a company called SEPH, and they are AI accessibility. Imagine you have dexterity issues in your hands and you can't really use your hands well. You could use your eyes, for example, if you were looking at a web page and you want to flip a screen, you can use your eyes or you can nod or use a gesture. The last company over there, and some of you may have been over there and seen it a few minutes ago, it's called Proto. Proto does live streaming in a 3D holographic form. Back in the day, you may have remembered the Whitney Houston concert or the Tupac concert. These are the guys that were behind that way back in the day. That's really for us an entertainment, a social isolation or social engagement tool. I could send one of these boxes to my mom in Florida, and I can from my iPhone stream my kids to my mother. It's pretty powerful. Those are the kind of things we're looking for. It's not just the 'hey, blood transfusion' or 'here's the new walker.' We do have a really cool walker company from LA, but it's not what you'd think. When we tell that story, it really resonates. So much so that the AgeTech Collaborative, we launched it in 2021 about exactly this time three years ago. It's now the largest age tech ecosystem in the world. We're approaching 600 companies, some of the largest companies in the world, Fortune 10 kind of companies, all the way down to assisted living. We have over 90 venture capitalists that have joined. The movement's working. We're getting people's attention. They all understand one thing, and hopefully this is if you take nothing else away today: no matter what industry you're in, no matter what job you have, aging is going to disrupt it. We're seeing the momentum, and it's just been incredible to watch.
Katie Drummond 1:54:28 ↗
What is your white whale? What is sort of the challenge in aging that you feel like technology has yet to conquer? What sort of stands out there for you?
Greg Williams 1:54:41 ↗
So there's no shortage of products, services, or solutions. I'll just pick on a smart house for a minute. You could have 50 different gadgets in your house. You could have a smart fridge, a smart washing machine, you could have a robot that's bringing you things around, you can have a smart toilet seat, a smart TV, all these things. In and of themselves, they all create incremental value. But what's missing today, and there's probably only a handful of companies that can actually solve this, is the creation of a ubiquitous data layer. If I have 50 devices in my mom's house, and that's another interesting point by the way, often the user is not the buyer. My mom lives in Florida, she's been recently diagnosed with Alzheimer's. My sister lives in Virginia, I live in Boston. We are concerned. Being the tech guy that I am, I want to go buy a bunch of gadgets and throw them in her house. While that sounds great, what do I do with the data? I'm getting this one-size-fits-all data. Imagine if you had 50 devices in a home and all that data was going to one data layer. Then you start thinking about AI. I just was reading an article about how good AI is at diagnosing illness from things like scans. Imagine if you could feed it data from my mom's day from 50 different devices and how well it could create contextual insight and intelligence that could then develop a feedback loop back to me so I could have great conversation with my mom and sort of prod her, but could also help my mom live her best life as she's dealing with this new illness she has. I think that's the next big thing: how do you aggregate data from a highly fragmented system, apply some level of AI to get contextual insight and intelligence that will let each person live their best life?
Katie Drummond 1:56:46 ↗
Makes total sense. The reason I was going to come back to the mail thing is that when we talked before we sat down to do this session, I told you that I get mail from AARP and I'm 38 years old and candidly feel that I am simply too young to be getting mail from you guys. But the point that you made is sort of what you just alluded to, which is yeah, I have parents who are in their 70s. The idea of me being exposed to AARP, aware of its existence, thinking of myself as someone who may potentially be in a caretaking role, that then made complete sense. I understood why the mail was coming. But I think my question then would be for someone sort of in my demographic, or someone who's, I'm sure there are many of us in the audience who are sort of in that caretaker or potentially will soon be a caretaker cohort, what guidance do you have? What advice do you have for us as we're looking at this landscape of products and apps and walkers? It can feel very overwhelming if you're thinking about how to take care of an aging parent, how to help them age well. Any sort of advice or guidance that you would have on the caretaker side of things?
Greg Williams 1:58:01 ↗
Yeah, I think the challenge with this is it usually smacks you in the face. You're just going about your daily life, and in the case of my mom, I just continue to pick up my mom for a minute. She suffered a stroke, we didn't know. We noticed something was off with her memory and her engagement. Then you go through this battery of tests, and then you find out you get this diagnosis. When you get that diagnosis, that's that moment in time. It's almost like an 'oh' moment: what do I do? The first thing I would suggest is educate yourself. There are a lot of places. AARP.org is a treasure trove of information on this, but there are other places as well. In the case of something like diabetes, go to the American Diabetes Association, they have tons of information, or the American Heart Association. Just educate yourself. The other thing I'll say, and we're working on this or trying to work on this, is it's such a fragmented market. You try to find a product or a service, and there are a bazillion. Where do you go? How do you know that they're good? AARP and others are actively working on trying to come up with curated marketplaces where it's not just products and services, but it's education that's wrapped around those products and services. Even as you're going through an illness, you have different stages, so it's a never-ending thing. To make matters worse, there are a whole lot of people that become caregivers to their parents but also have children themselves. The big thing I would caution all of you, if you become a caregiver, is caregiver burnout is a real thing. You've got to make sure you take time for yourself, otherwise you will run yourself into the ground, and that's not a good situation because now you're going to end up needing care yourself. Just educate yourself, and know that you're not alone.
Katie Drummond 2:00:05 ↗
Last question, unfortunately we're nearly out of time. But you talked about pickleball, you talked about wanting aging to not feel all doom and gloom. There's a lot that we need to be prepared for and thinking about in the context of aging and technology around illness, a fall, all sorts of potentially dark scenarios to be confronting. Are there other examples of where you come in to provide some of that fun and that joy and that levity to the aging process that you can leave us all with?
Greg Williams 2:00:39 ↗
Sure. I will say yes, pickleball is, I've yet to play, I guess I will play at CES. I will say there's a common misunderstanding about older folks that they don't use technology. The single largest cohort that spends money on tech are 50 to 60 year olds. 66% of older adults believe technology is a necessity to living their best life. I think you can't underestimate this category in their desire to use technology for the fun stuff. I think Zuckerberg said not too long ago he wasn't thrilled with Facebook because it was all old people or something like that. There are a lot of folks that are using technology for fun. Dating has become a big deal. We're seeing a lot of that. VR, interestingly enough, is a huge deal with older folks, taking trips like walking the streets of Barcelona in virtual reality. Music as medicine is another really big one. We have a company, it's actually based here in San Francisco in our portfolio, called Freestyle Plus, that is a derivative of a Broadway show from an improv rap group called Freestyle Love Supreme. It's amazing to watch people rap. Imagine going to an assisted living facility and seeing a bunch of people beatboxing and rapping. There's a lot of fun to be had here. We're seeing more and more of that, not the doom and gloom.
Katie Drummond 2:02:22 ↗
Wonderful. I love to hear that. Andy, thank you so much for being here.
Greg Williams 2:02:26 ↗
Thank you.
Katie Drummond 2:02:29 ↗
All right. Well, up next, I am thrilled to welcome HL Javer, Wired's managing editor, and the acclaimed director, writer, producer, and director of photography, no big deal, Zack Snyder. Enjoy.
Hey guys, hi everyone. Hello. Thank you all very much for being here. Very excited to have you here, and I'm very excited to welcome my guest, as noted, writer, director, producer, director of photography Zack Snyder. Great movies such as Watchmen, Rebel Moon most recently. We're here to talk to you a little bit today about tech and entertainment. Hi, Zack.
Zack Snyder 2:03:27 ↗
Hey, thanks for having me.
Katie Drummond 2:03:28 ↗
No, thank you for being here.
Zack Snyder 2:03:32 ↗
Everybody nice. I appreciate the woos. I appreciate the woos. Where is that fire? Isn't this a fireside chat? Oh, we were having... no, sorry. It's just a little... just you and I. We can make it intimate.
Katie Drummond 2:03:49 ↗
Very good. Okay. So you have a really specific vision. I feel like in your work, highly stylized, and I don't mean that as a criticism. But how do you see, let's start with the big elephant in the room, how do you see the advancing AI systems like LLMs, visual models influencing the industry? I know it's a broad question.
Zack Snyder 2:04:14 ↗
No, it's a cool question because obviously it's an exciting time, and obviously that technology, which is also still slightly ambiguous about what exactly and how exactly it will land in entertainment. I think it's an exciting frontier, and it's a cool thing to speculate about and have fun thinking about workflows and stuff. I've spent some time thinking about what an AI workflow might look like. But I do think that, for instance, when you have someone like myself, or anyone who's interested in making specific imagery, very, very specific imagery, I feel like we're still evolving toward that with AI. I've thought about it this way: I think that in the not too distant future, I like to think about the potential for an AI interaction to be like if the AI can create a 3D world like a game engine, but an instantaneous 3D world, which is not outrageous. I think we're not far from that. So say I film you with my phone or some other capture device, you're the actor, and you did your awesome performance, and it was great by the way. Thank you so much, so good. Then we've got the performance. Now, I can see a world where the production designer has created all the sets and everything that we needed, those have all been loaded into an aesthetic bank. That is to say, this bank, the AI understands what the movie aesthetic core will be, and that hopefully is a thing that I'm interested in. I like this kind of lensing, this kind of motes of dust, this kind of backlight, this kind of whatever, and also this kind of set design. For instance, we're doing our movie in France, so it's going to be a French landscape, and we're very specific about the French farmhouse and the way it looks with patina walls and all that. We did it so that exists. I can imagine that now when we make a shot, if that 3D world, if the AI understands if I'm saying 'Okay, I want the camera 10 feet away, I want it this high, you're by the window so you're lit by the window, I want the sun out the window,' and if that can happen in real time, because you know, I converse with my... you were just conversing with your AI backstage. I find that because I think that also this idea of right now, this sort of the prompting gatekeepers of AI have this kind of prompting, what I would call, which is cool in a way because AI is like 'Oh no, it's available to everyone,' unless you don't know how to do it, and then you can't do it. So it's a cool...
Katie Drummond 2:07:53 ↗
Do you see it enhancing your filmmaking, or do you see it replacing?
Zack Snyder 2:07:58 ↗
Well, this is where I was going with this. In this world where I'm making that shot of you, the question really becomes, unless there's something about this shot that requires it to be made only on the computer or only in an AI universe, then I think you have to say, 'Okay, well what's the why of it then?' What does that keep me from flying to France? Is that all that I saved? If it's a handheld shot of you sitting in a chair by a window, why would you use it other than that you can? And look, there's not to say that that's not a reason. If it democratizes in some way the ability to not have to travel to France, and if I'm just at home, a filmmaker at home, and I captured my actor friend and I want to make a movie in France, can I just do it? Maybe. I think there is a potential for it making things accessible because obviously that same AI doesn't care whether the house is on fire or whether it's on Mars or whether it's underwater. That's all the same conversation. All the things that might cost a lot of money about what I just described are to the AI no different. But to you as a filmmaker, is it going to be different? Do you need the experience of being in the actual location?
Katie Drummond 2:09:28 ↗
I don't know. That's a thing I don't know because it's theoretical. I see a when I can have a conversation with an image-making device that is natural, that is to say, if I say in real time, 'Wouldn't it be cool if that back wall was another 10 feet away and the sun was just nicking the horizon so that during the take the sun just goes down and now this ambient light takes over?' If that's happening as we speak, that's an interesting way to understand visual language. But is it a replacement for? I don't know that's a thing I don't know. But it is a fun conversation. I can see, it's the thing that's weird is that people think 'Oh, that's a great way to make storyboards or to make pre-visualized shots that then you could take the set and use that to shoot with.' Yes, that's true, but there's very little difference then between that and the actual shot.
But you also, we've spoken in the past, and you've done all your physical storyboards. You hand-drew everything for Watchmen. Is AI going to take a lot of the creative process out for you if you're just talking to the chatbot and saying 'Draw this frame for me, draw the sun setting'?
Zack Snyder 2:10:57 ↗
Yeah, that's where I think the problem is for me personally. I don't think that the drawing of it is so specific, and I'm not interested in the AI's interpretation of what I'm saying. That's where the rubber hits the road, I think, for me, and where I think the technology is really kind of quickly changing. Because it is quickly changing from a suggestion, like 'Hey, I want to see 1920s LA, a woman walking with a suitcase down Hollywood Boulevard.' It'll give you its concept of that, and it'll be pretty awesome, but it's not necessarily... if I drew it over here and then went like this, I'd be like 'Oh, it's close,' but it's not your vision. That's its own take. I think that's where the tool will become, and it's happening this moment. All the AI video generators and image generators, the few holy grails that came up immediately are like staying on model. That's a big deal. Can I do two shots of you that are like, okay, a close-up and a wide shot where you look the same? That was a bit of a problem, but now they're starting to work that out.
Katie Drummond 2:12:26 ↗
Well, let me ask you. Are you overall... I'm not going to ask you because I think I already will say, we've talked a little bit before, but you are generally very optimistic about the use of artificial intelligence in filmmaking, in the creative process. You do not come to it from a perspective of that technology shouldn't be involved in artistic endeavors.
Zack Snyder 2:12:44 ↗
Well, I've... yeah, I mean, I'm not definitely not a gloom and doom AI person at all. I think that I've done so many movies with so much visual effects and so much technology, and I've lived in a very virtual world when it comes to filmmaking and also very organic handheld world, and those two worlds have mixed a lot for me too. So I think for me personally, I sort of put performance at the front, at the head of it. I think if you're capturing an incredible performance, everything else around the actors, that's context, and that's all it is. I don't know that anyone's interested in the AI's story or its point of view. Maybe they are, that's cool, that's another subgenre. But I think that for me, it seems eager to get at what the stories are that people are trying to tell. In the same way that when we all, because look, every single person has a pretty good camera on their phone, a pretty good movie camera, and yet we don't have, right this second anyway, maybe that'll change, I hope it does, but we don't have millions of awesome movies just being uploaded out of people's pockets. I feel like the AI represents another tool that will help us make movies awesome, I hope. It's been my experience that certainly as a research tool and a little bit as an image-making tool, I found it really interesting.
Katie Drummond 2:14:56 ↗
I'm curious to see how you're using it, because like I said, you have it on your phone, talking to it, asking it questions. Is it becoming a person to you, your AI chatbot person? That sounds weird. But is it developing a personality?
Zack Snyder 2:15:11 ↗
You know what it does say, which I find really interesting. When it's explaining something, it'll go 'um,' you know, 'the Golden Gate Bridge is...' and I'm like 'Oh, that's cool.' Or it'll breathe, you know, it inhales, which I think that's all in the programming. It's a ChatGPT for the language model, and it does that. It goes, you can hear the... they program that inhale and they program the, obviously, to make it more natural. It's way better than, like, I have the ElevenLabs reader, do you know that company? Amazing. I find that the voice on the ChatGPT is a scale more natural than that even, just really. I don't know how it works, but it's awesome.
Katie Drummond 2:16:12 ↗
So you were talking about how performance is actually really important to your filmmaking process and how you've already used tools before. Do you think filmmakers should be required to disclose that they used AI generators?
Zack Snyder 2:16:27 ↗
It's an interesting question. Does the audience want that? I think is a better question, only because certainly we don't ask when you go see a movie about, like, a Marvel film or a superhero movie that has a lot of visual effects, are people interested in knowing when that was a digital double, that was really the person? Or is it the moment or afterward? Maybe that's a conversation after you've seen the film: 'Oh, we used AI in these little sections.' Or is the question whether it is an entirely AI-generated movie? I feel like if that happened, we would know about it first of all. Everyone would love it or hate it or whatever. I don't know that's still up to debate about how we feel about it.
Katie Drummond 2:17:24 ↗
About images being created that way. I mean, you've seen that Coke commercial. Did you see that Coke commercial, the polar bear spot?
Zack Snyder 2:17:33 ↗
I mean, was the point for it not to fool us? I couldn't... I'm not even going to talk about it. I wouldn't speculate on that. The Coca-Cola one, I was like 'Okay, obviously this is an AI-generated...' Maybe they wanted to make it really obviously AI, so deliberately make a lot of people angry.
Katie Drummond 2:17:54 ↗
Yeah, but what made it angry? So it sounds like you're advocating for a really specific use of AI in your filmmaking, or leaving the door open for it, but not replacing anything.
Zack Snyder 2:18:05 ↗
I don't think it's replacing anything, and I don't know why you would want it to right now, because it's really quite... I mean, I think it's great. Again, like I say, you can imagine costume designers, production designers, editors, everyone having a central hub that the AI kind of manages, as a way of creating an overall aesthetic that is consistent, where everyone can constantly sort of be reaffirmed in the aesthetic of the project. You can imagine that could be really efficiently and seamlessly curated by an AI point of view. That is to say, every time in this project, every time we ask it a question, it's answering it from the point of view of the aesthetic of the film, which I think could be really awesome for some immersive kind of movie-making experience, whether it be an animated film, Avatar, something that really requires that kind of focus and technology.
Katie Drummond 2:19:23 ↗
So you're talking about it in terms of efficiency. How do you see it changing the industry?
Zack Snyder 2:19:34 ↗
Yeah, I mean, I see it changing the industry. It would be interesting, its impact on visual effects obviously that's happening right now, but like motion capture, voiceover artists, animators... I mean, voiceover is going to be very disruptive. That makes me nervous. You probably don't want it voicing things. I mean, it can obviously, as I just said, it does pretty well. But I feel like if there's an author and an artist at its base, then I think it's cool. But it's not going to take away that. But it is going to streamline the industry. It is going to send ripples all the way through. I think it's doing that right now. It absolutely is doing it right now. I think that educating yourself and understanding what it can do and what it can't do is important right now, especially at this point where it exists in image making and storytelling. Because I think if you're in now and understand it and what it's not capable of as well, I think that's important. I think that you can really use it as a tool, as opposed to fighting it or standing on the sidelines with your hands on your hips. It's going to... look, six months ago is different from now, and six months from now will be much different from where we are. I think it's important to stay with it basically. If you don't, you're going to be left behind.
Katie Drummond 2:21:27 ↗
I did put words in your mouth? No, no. But I'm worried... yeah, if you don't... and I think you used the analogy of putting toothpaste back in the tube. The toothpaste is not going back in.
Zack Snyder 2:21:39 ↗
No.
Katie Drummond 2:21:41 ↗
All right, well, shifting gears away from AI for a little bit. We've got a few minutes left. I wanted to talk to you. You've done a lot about streaming. Are you still invested in theatrical releases?
Zack Snyder 2:21:51 ↗
Yeah, I look, I think that movies absolutely can and should be experienced in the theater. I never really... when I made the Netflix films that I've made, the two I've made, well three really, but the four, five... there were a lot of cuts, you know how I am. But the process of working in the format of a streamer for me, I was really very clear about 'Okay, I'm making a movie for TV. That's fine. I'm not under any kind of misconception that I'm making a movie for the theater.' I'm happy to do that if that's the assignment and that's the way it's going to be shown. But we know that so much of the material, when you make a movie that's going to play on Netflix, chances are if your movie ever is shown on Netflix, more people will see it on Netflix than ever saw it in the theater. That's just a fact. Even a big blockbuster, you make a blockbuster, it's in the theaters and then it gets licensed by Netflix, more people will see it probably on Netflix than also saw your blockbuster. You're just going after the eyeballs. But I'm not necessarily a pure eyeball guy, because I don't... a lot of the movies that I've made have a very particular audience and they're made in a very particular way, and they're not necessarily pure mass audience. That's not the way I think it happens. It can happen, that's fine. But what I'm saying is that the assignments are different. I'm fine if you're asking me to make a movie for your streaming, you're not precious about it. I'm not going to say 'Hey, I'm not an artist if it's not in a theater.' That feels rude, only because you're the streamer, you're paying for the movie. You're like 'This is our format. We have a giant streaming service, 250 million people are going to look at it on their phone probably.' Unless at the very beginning of our conversation I have to know that's the reality. If I do, then I should be fine with everything that happens after it.
Katie Drummond 2:24:32 ↗
But are you fine with that though? With Netflix?
Zack Snyder 2:24:36 ↗
Well, I have an amazing relationship with Netflix. I think they're incredible. The pipe that delivers your ideas to people who are enjoying it is pretty efficient. At the same time, I would say that if the assignment was, if you were Universal Studios and you came to me and said 'Hey, we want to make a movie that's like a big theatrical release,' I'd be like 'That sounds amazing. I love it. IMAX, why not?'
Katie Drummond 2:25:09 ↗
One last final question for you in the few minutes that we have left here. With technology, with streaming being the primary way people consume movies right now, what is the story that you are most excited to tell?
Zack Snyder 2:25:23 ↗
You mean just for me personally with this technology, like with AI technology? I think you mentioned that AI was going to let you do things that you hadn't really figured out how to do yet. Yeah, it's an interesting... I mean, I feel like that's it. The way I see it working right now is really as an incubator in the most efficient way possible. I can experiment, I can work on things that normally would require a big amount of effort from everybody, and that I can have ready on the day when now we have the crew standing by. But I think that there's no substitute for walking down a gritty street with an actor and me with the camera. I don't know that anyone would ever want the AI version of that. I don't know that that's... I mean, it could be done, but I just don't know that... it can be done, but there isn't a need for it. And also, you're saying that it would strip the personal vision out of it.
Katie Drummond 2:26:46 ↗
Yes.
Zack Snyder 2:26:47 ↗
I'm not even saying that. I'm just saying that there is a texture and a point of view. I always say this about filmmakers: the only thing you have as a filmmaker is your point of view. That's it. You're not right, you're not wrong, you're not morally correct, you're not morally wrong. You are like a prism. The way you see kind of shines through you. My favorite movies are movies where I can kind of feel the director's hand a little bit. They're guiding me, they're showing me things I wouldn't have thought of. In the end, that's what it comes back to. I want that point of view, that human point of view, to really be moving me in a narrative way through a story that I wouldn't have thought of or that I couldn't imagine what's going to happen next. I think that's really what we as audiences pay for, what we hunger for. How that's gotten to, what tools are used to get to that very human thing, that could change.
Katie Drummond 2:27:57 ↗
You're not precious about the tools that you're using.
Zack Snyder 2:28:00 ↗
I'm precious about that voice, the vision and the voice.
Katie Drummond 2:28:05 ↗
All right, well, I think that's a great way for us to end it off. Zack, thank you so much for being here.
Zack Snyder 2:28:11 ↗
Awesome, thanks guys.
Katie Drummond 2:28:14 ↗
Thank you all so much. Next up, we're going to take a break for lunch. Short break, short break, and we'll see you guys back here at two. Thank you.
Hi everyone. Is this on? Yes, it is. How's everyone feeling after lunch? Good, okay, hopefully a little warmer. Thank you so much for being here. I don't think our next guest needs much of an introduction, but I've been given one. I'm excited to welcome entrepreneur, co-founder of Cost Plus Drugs, Mark Cuban, to the Big Interview stage. From selling garbage bags door to door at age 12 to founding a lot of groundbreaking tech companies, Mark has always been ahead of the curve. It's really no surprise that with his latest venture, Cost Plus Drugs, he's also ahead of the curve. He is working to demolish and rebuild the prescription drug industry, and that's what we're going to talk about today. Everyone, please welcome Mark Cuban.
Thanks so much for being here, Mark.
Mark Cuban 2:30:25 ↗
Thank you so much for being here. I liked how you changed up to 'demolish.' You know, it's a family-friendly event. Oh, I should leave right now. This is just like Shark Tank.
Katie Drummond 2:30:40 ↗
So I asked a friend here, actually Sean, earlier today, I said 'What should I kick off with Mark Cuban? What should I say?' And he said 'Why don't you give him a belated congratulations for Klay Thompson?' There you go. Klay is killing it. We thank everybody here for... yeah, you're lucky that you're welcome in the Bay after that one. I look over my shoulder.
Mark Cuban 2:31:00 ↗
All right, so let's talk about Cost Plus. When our issue came out in which you're prominently featured, one thing I heard from people was 'I didn't know Mark Cuban was in the pharmaceutical business.' You've been doing this for a while though. Why did you get into pharma?
Does anybody here like their healthcare? Does anybody here think the healthcare industry works well? That's why. I literally got a cold email from a Dr. Alex Oshmyansky who wanted to start up a compounding pharmacy, which actually makes drugs that are on the shortage list. I'm like 'You're thinking too small.' That was right around the time Martin Shkreli was going to jail, so he was in the news. I was like 'How can this one guy take control of this drug and jack up the price that dramatically?' So I'm like 'Let me just take a look.' When you look at the pharmaceutical industry back then, it was very obvious that it was opaque. There was no transparency at all. Think about it: if you get a prescription from your doctor, what's the first thing they ask you? Not 'Can you afford it?' It's 'What pharmacy do you use?' And that's it. Then you've got to deal with the fear of can you afford it, what's the impact, what's the co-pay, what's the deductible, all those things. So we said 'Okay, let's start a company called Cost Plus Drugs, and let's make it transparent.' It seems so simple, but the impact has been so dramatic. If you go to costplusdrugs.com and you put in the name of the medication, and we've grown from 111 to 2500 and we have more to go, if we carry it, the medication pops up and you'll see our actual cost. We show you what we pay for it. We mark it up 15%. If you want it delivered, there's a $5 pharmacist fee because you have to have a pharmacist review it, then $5 to ship it to you. Or you can now, we have an affiliate network where you can pick it up at a local pharmacy. Just by showing our price, our cost, and only marking up 15%, we were able to take down the price of drugs like imatinib, a chemotherapy drug, from like $2,000 plus a month to $21 a month, $35 a month. The impact has been insane.
Katie Drummond 2:33:15 ↗
What are some of the common drugs people might recognize that you're manufacturing and selling?
Mark Cuban 2:33:21 ↗
I mean, imatinib is probably the most dramatic example. I'm not the pharmacist to remember all the funky names. But people with MS, as an example, we're able to take... there's a drug called droxidopa. I'll give you a scenario. A friend of mine was in this horrific car accident and he needed to take this drug and lost his insurance. He emailed me and said 'They're telling me it's going to be $10,000 every three months.' I'm like 'Okay, Landon, I'll check into it.' Turns out we carried it, and when we carried it back then, it was $64 a month. From $10,000 to $64 times three. And now it's in the $20s because as our volumes go up, because we do everything on a straight markup, our costs go down. We have literally lowered the price of a medication every single weekday for the past almost 18 months.
Think about it, but the most dramatic thing we did was unintentional. We published our entire price list. So there are places, if you really looked hard, you can go and find a price for a medication that you might need, but there's no place where the company published their entire price list. And we did that for all 2,500 drugs. And what's happened now is that researchers are able to use that price list to compare to what the government is paying for things, to compare to what states are paying, and if you have a company that self-insures, to start the process of allowing you to compare what the company pays for the medications that their employees and the people that they cover, the population they cover, what they pay. And that has just been a game changer. I mean, we've had researchers from Vanderbilt, Harvard, all these different places say, you know, if Medicare bought these nine drugs from Cost Plus Drugs, just nine drugs would save $36 billion a year. If they bought these 11 drugs, it's $6.3 billion a year. I mean, it's insane. And literally, for so many folks out here in the valley, probably the easiest way to raise money and put cash in your own pocket is to change your health care plan, and in particular your pharmacy benefit manager, because the crux of this problem and the opacity of the industry: there are three pharmacy benefit managers that control, give or take, 80% of the market. So these are basically the middlemen. And literally they don't want you to know what you pay. If you work with a self-insured company and they're working with one of the big three, let's just say the biggest PBM, you're getting ripped off guaranteed. The quickest way to raise money if you have over a hundred employees and self-insure is to change your health care program, and in particular pharmacy benefit management. That's immediate cash in the bank. And companies don't really realize that, and that's why it's been so successful. The next question always is, how did this happen? And the reality is, there's 155 million people covered by self-insured employers, and it's not the core competency of a CEO to understand all their health care benefits. You just don't. I mean, you could ask a couple of them here on stage today if you want. Happy to. You, Brian Chesky, let's talk about health. You know, Jensen Huang, I'm sure he wants to talk about health plans. Just say, would you? No, seriously, ask them why are you dealing with one of the big pharmacy benefit managers, and ask them, is that because... Here's what's happening, that's crazy. They're starting to understand. There's a law called ERISA that requires the employer now to take on their fiduciary responsibility for the cost and care of all the lives they cover. And J&J and Wells Fargo just got sued, and they're going to lose, which effectively means that every single major self-insured employer is going to get sued in a class action suit. So if any of you fall into that trap, get ready, they're coming. But the bigger point again is, now there's transparency for medications, and you can cut the cost whether you're a little company or a big company. And if you have a high deductible, or you're uninsured, always check the pricing, because otherwise you're going to get ripped off.
Katie Drummond 2:37:47 ↗
So you've made it pretty clear you're not doing this for altruistic reasons. You're running a business, you want this to be a profitable business. I think people hear about what you're doing and they think, oh, it's altruistic, it's because you're doing something good. Well, I could make more money, right? But what you said, in all seriousness, we're a public benefit corporation. But how much money do I need? You know, I'm not trying to land on Mars. It's just... And not to take anything away from him for trying, more power to him. But the reality is, at this point in my life, it's just like, more money up the healthcare industry. That was the word I left out of the intro, you guys. The healthcare industry. But how did you... I guess what I'm getting at is, how did you decide on that being the industry you wanted to go after?
Mark Cuban 2:38:46 ↗
Because it was so obvious that it would be easy to change, that it was insane. What had happened in the past is, I dug in more. We've been in business now, we started shipping two and a half years ago, and now we have millions of people whose lives we've changed. But you start to realize that what the incumbents would do is they'd go in and just buy companies. So anybody that was a threat, they just buy them. And one after another, we'd go into situations where we're talking to employers or whatever, and they're saying, yeah, we were going to do business with this company and they were trying to cut the cost, but then so-and-so bought them. And like I said, that's just not in the cards for us.
Katie Drummond 2:39:25 ↗
Let's talk about tariffs. Tariffs. Okay. So President-elect Donald Trump is... I know who he is. Yeah. Okay. So he said that he's planning to impose tariffs on Canada, Mexico, China day one. We don't know exactly how that's going to shake out yet, but we do know that this could affect the drug industry. I mean, he's referring often to the illegal drug industry, but also this could affect the pharmaceutical business. How is this potentially going to affect Cost Plus?
Mark Cuban 2:39:54 ↗
I mean, if it's just China, it won't impact us at all. Why? Because we had... I checked, we had 16 drugs that we bought that were shipped from China, and we're changing that to a different manufacturer. So the Chinese tariffs won't impact us at all. Okay. And now we do get drugs from India, so we'll see what happens there. But if there are tariffs, we only have 15%, so we'd have to pass them through.
Katie Drummond 2:40:18 ↗
Pass them through meaning the cost goes to... The cost would go up because our cost would go up. Okay. Have you talked to Donald Trump about this?
Mark Cuban 2:40:27 ↗
Sure. I was like, yo, what's up, bro? Yeah, no, I have not.
Katie Drummond 2:40:34 ↗
You have not. If the conversation were to occur, if you were invited to, what's your priority? What's the first thing you would say?
Mark Cuban 2:40:40 ↗
I would say, don't screw it up. It's working. You know, I mean, I don't look, there's no point in trying to guess what he's going to do and speculate because we don't know. I don't think he knows yet. I think he's trying to, you know, he plays it by feel, and it'll go where he goes, and we'll react accordingly. But I think, you know, he's obviously very cognizant of PR and the idea that medication from the cheapest provider going up means more people aren't able to afford it. I really don't think he's going in that direction. I really think he'd make an exception.
Katie Drummond 2:41:13 ↗
You were clearly a vocal supporter of Kamala Harris for president. When you look back... You see how good a job I did. When you look at this election season, is there anything that you think you would have done differently or taken a different approach in terms of how you were communicating?
Mark Cuban 2:41:35 ↗
Not really. I mean, I'm not the candidate. I did the best I could to try to convey what she was doing for business people, small business, you know. And I think the message was good, but they weren't voting or not voting for me.
Katie Drummond 2:41:52 ↗
One of the things that we talked about when we did the big interview in the magazine was crypto. And you feel pretty strongly, and you're in favor of crypto, and you're in favor of it not being villainized, and you felt as though that's what Gary Gensler and the SEC had been doing.
Mark Cuban 2:42:05 ↗
Yeah, and I think it really hurt her. So it's interesting because my response to you was, isn't that sort of a fringe issue? And you said no. But how many people here own crypto? Yeah. And so when the price goes up, when crypto goes up, everybody smiles. And if you're particularly a young male and you're not part of the traditional banking system, when I was a kid, open up a bank account, open up a savings account. Now download an app, Robinhood or Coinbase, buy crypto because your friends are buying crypto. You understand it more. Maybe you buy stocks, but more kids were getting into crypto, and that was their net worth. And when 40% according to Pew Research of young men own crypto or have owned crypto, and the guy you're connected to, Gary Gensler, is basically telling you to roll over and let me stick a bike pump in your ass. That just... Yeah, I was going to say worse, but I just... That was stupid, sorry. But basically, you say a bike pump? Yeah, forget it. I'm sure that's something Elon will tweet about at me. But in any event, Gary Gensler did not make it good for people who own crypto, and I think that truly hurt Kamala. And I even said it, I said it to her, I said it to her team, I said it publicly, that Gary Gensler could lose the election for her. And when there's 240,000 votes across seven swing states, and the number of young men voted against her was much higher than expected, I don't think it's a stretch to connect the two.
Katie Drummond 2:43:56 ↗
What happens to crypto now?
Mark Cuban 2:43:59 ↗
I think it's, you know, it's whatever comes comes. But it was interesting when he talked about putting, if any of the BRICS countries stopped using the dollar as the de facto reserve currency, that he was going to put tariffs on them, which is the antithesis of what people who gave him a lot of money and support Bitcoin think. They think a big part of the value of Bitcoin is the fact that fiat currency is weakened, the Federal Reserve weakens it, and it doesn't have a great future. So here's Bitcoin to save the day. So it'll be interesting to see if he follows through on that, and what the Bitcoin maxis think about it.
Katie Drummond 2:44:39 ↗
Does this mean Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies actually become more legitimate or less?
Mark Cuban 2:44:46 ↗
It's not about legitimacy. It's like gold. Gold's not based off of supply and demand on jewelry. People see it as an option in the event of the economy going down or something bad happening. But people aren't going to walk around with gold bars. Oh look, he owns gold, bam. Now I own gold, bam. What are you gonna do, let me slice you off a little piece of gold? But no, people look at it. Fort Knox has a ton of gold, the United States owns it, and it's supposed to be an underlying asset or commodity for the dollar in some respects. And people look at Bitcoin as a better version of gold, and I agree with that. I think it's a great store of value. It's easier to buy and sell, you can fractionalize it, you can buy things, you can transfer it internationally. So I think it has more value than gold. So I don't think you have to legitimize it. But in terms of the price, I own enough that I really want it to go up, but it's just supply and demand.
Katie Drummond 2:45:51 ↗
How much do you own?
Mark Cuban 2:45:52 ↗
A lot.
Katie Drummond 2:45:53 ↗
Okay, glad we got that out of the way. We have 10 minutes left and there's so much I want to ask you about. I feel like we could talk about crypto the whole time. I also wanted to ask you about AI, but I think we... One thing I'll say about AI and then we should move on from it to the platforms is that when we spoke for the big interview, you asked me what would you trust more in an environment if you weren't able to see, you said, what is it, self-driving car or a seeing eye dog? And I said AI, and you said I trust the dog. And I just want to say, while you're here in San Francisco, you should take a Waymo. No, I want to actually... If anyone would like to pull up their app and get a Waymo ride for Mark, I do that. I know how to download the app. He'll pay for it. But the difference is a dog will recognize adversarial situations better than AI can. When you were talking about training the video and all that. But let's talk about the platforms, because you were a very active Twitter user. Now you're not using it quite as much anymore, you moved on to Blue Sky. How would you describe this moment for... I'm just going to call it Twitter. How would you describe this moment for Twitter?
Mark Cuban 2:47:05 ↗
I think it's an existential moment for Twitter. I really do. I go over to Blue Sky and I can engage like it's 2015 or 2016 like we did on Twitter. And literally I can talk about the Mavs and people aren't going to come in and say, the Mavs, you look like you took Klay Thompson. Yeah, you took Klay Thompson. I get some of those, but that's okay. Or you look like Rachel Maddow when you wear glasses. You know, just dumb. That's the tame stuff. It's crazy. I count... So whenever Elon would talk to me, I would just bookmark it on Twitter. And somebody said that he said something, and I would just check and he hadn't. But I just decided to count how many times he has posted about me or replied about me in the last 12 months. More than 40 times. I stopped at 40. And it's just like, what the... I mean, I don't mind going back and forth with him, but whoever controls the algorithm controls the platform. And when you have an algorithm that defines what happens on the platform and what you see, you get one type of engagement. When you go to Blue Sky, where you completely control the experience, you get a completely different type of engagement. And so I can talk about Cost Plus Drugs and really engage. I can talk about other discussions and jump in and ask questions. And it's been great. I mean, literally, and when some idiot comes along, somebody who comes over from Twitter who likes to give me... There comes on, not only can you block them and it's a real block, but you can do this thing if you started the thread where you can say, hide reply for everyone. That's like the best thing in the world ever, because I want to talk about the Mavs or Cost Plus or whatever, and a troll comes in, troll gone. And the one thing about a troll is a troll wants to be seen. If within 15 minutes you're gone and nobody's going to see what you posted, there's no point in continuing to fight it, particularly since you truly can't see my post. And even if they create burner accounts or whatever to try to get in, it just takes two seconds to do it. And so as a result, I forget the topic I was talking about, but I counted that there were over 526 responses to something and only five trolls posted, and that took me just a minute to clean them out. And it was a great conversation.
Katie Drummond 2:49:42 ↗
Do you feel that Blue Sky is in any way just becoming an echo chamber of the people who decided that Twitter was too toxic or too for them, and now they've just moved over to Blue Sky? In a sense, how does that fix anything?
Mark Cuban 2:49:56 ↗
But it doesn't matter, because if I want to talk about the Mavs, I went to a bunch of sports writers and there's these things called sport starter packs on Blue Sky, and they were all in there. And I said, you have a Wired one, follow it. Thank you. The Wired starter pack. And you see what happens. I can engage with them and talk Mavs and see where it goes. And Ben Shapiro, he has an account there, and I can engage with him. I may agree or disagree, but if I start the thread, I have control of it. And if it turns out to be a legitimate argument or discussion, that's great. And the point being that whoever controls the thread controls the conversation and can open it up to anybody they want. And there's no for you page. So it's not like it's dominated by everything Elon says. It's dominated by the people you follow or the list that you create or the feeds that you follow. And so you get to really engage. And that's cool. I mean, it's just like all that intellectual engagement that we kind of miss from Twitter, where it was like, oh, this is a great topic, I want to learn more, or I'm just watching these people have this conversation. It's amazing. And there's one or two idiots in there, not even talking about people I disagree with, but people who just say stupid stuff, hateful stuff. It's so de minimis that the engagement is amazing. And I think that's why it's growing. And you even saw the New York Times come on there, and someone told me they referenced one of their posts on Blue Sky as, whereas in the past they would do that on Twitter. And to see them move over to escape what's going on over there is great. And here they are, I don't know their latest numbers, but they have more than 22 million users. And I can get an update on those numbers shortly. Actually, yeah, come stage, Jay comes on. But you got to try it. And like I said, I'm @mcuban on Blue Sky. Try it. I mean, bring your friends on there. It is truly a social network. Hey, was that the Mavs game? I was there too. I mean, that's insane to be able to have that conversation on a social network.
Katie Drummond 2:52:09 ↗
I think that there's been this idea for a long time, and certainly probably when you were starting out as an internet entrepreneur, that the internet was a little bit downstream from culture. And now we've come around to this idea that the internet is culture. And we certainly saw that play out a lot in this election too. And there were some reactions, responses to the outcome of this election saying that on the left, people don't have the same kind of audience that people are gaining on the right. There's no podcast for the left. That was something that I don't agree with at all. So talk about this, because if everyone who just doesn't like Twitter anymore moves to Blue Sky or moves to Threads or moves to something like it, but Twitter remains small relatively in numbers to some social networks but sort of outsized influence...
Mark Cuban 2:52:58 ↗
I don't think Twitter... I mean, if you want to know what Elon thinks, Twitter's amazing. And that's great. So how do we distinguish reality on social media? What's really happening? I've been on the Nelk Boys, I've been on all those podcasts and everything. But Joe Rogan, he won't have me on for whatever reason. And so when you go on there, they just want to have a conversation. And from that conversation, there's a ton of clips. Andrew Schulz, I had a great conversation with them, they're still posting clips. And so when you go on those, it's not that they're right or left, it's that they create clips that feed the algorithm on Twitter. And so if you happen to be a fan of theirs and comparable things, the algorithm is going to find you. The algorithm always finds you with things that you've shown interest in. And so that's great. But the way to deal with that isn't trying to get more Andrew Schultzes to counter that. The way to deal with that is to flood the zone.
Katie Drummond 2:53:58 ↗
What does that mean? What does that look like?

162 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Murati, M. (2024, December 11). Jensen Huang, Zach Snyder, Mira Murati & More - The Big Interview Live 2024 | WIRED [Interview transcript]. WIRED. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/616413/

MLA

Mira Murati. "Jensen Huang, Zach Snyder, Mira Murati & More - The Big Interview Live 2024 | WIRED." WIRED, 11 Dec. 2024. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/616413/.

BibTeX
@misc{murati2024_616413,
  author       = {Mira Murati},
  title        = {Jensen Huang, Zach Snyder, Mira Murati \& More - The Big Interview Live 2024 | WIRED},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, WIRED. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2024},
  month        = {dec},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/616413/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}