Good morning. The Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation will come to order. Today, we will consider the nominations of Jared Isaacman to serve as administrator of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, which I have to say for a moment feels a bit like Groundhog Day, and also Steven Haynes to serve as an assistant secretary of commerce. NASA is at the forefront of American leadership in science and technology. It is critical to our national security amid what I have called the second space race. But the agency finds itself at an inflection point. Its next leader must be both disciplined and purposeful. Candidly assessing what is working and what is not while recognizing that each policy decision has trade-offs. NASA can't do everything it wants to. The agency must prioritize if we are to beat China back to the moon and then to Mars. If confirmed, Mr. Isaacman will be taking the helm just as NASA is set to launch Artemis 2, the agency's first crewed use of the Space Launch System rocket and the first crewed mission on the Orion spacecraft, which will bring American astronauts closer to the lunar surface than at any point since 1972. I know Mr. Isaacman will be a strong leader who sees that Artemis 2 launches safely, successfully, and without delay. He must then turn to Artemis 3, landing Americans on the moon before China, which is aimed at sending its own taikonauts there by 2030. NASA cannot take its eyes off the ball. Fortunately, Congress has given clear direction and substantial funding to achieve this goal. In the One Big Beautiful Bill, President Trump and a Republican Congress committed nearly $10 billion to specific parts of the space program, including the Space Launch System and future lunar missions of Artemis 4 and 5, the Gateway Space Station at the moon, and the International Space Station. The vision for NASA enshrined in the One Big Beautiful Bill is unambiguous and Congress expects that it will be executed faithfully. And I will note that our friend and colleague Senator Katie Britt from Alabama has come to join us. Alabama obviously has intense interest in NASA and space. And Senator Britt, we welcome you to the committee this morning. Investments in hardware alone won't guarantee mission success. Equally indispensable is NASA's workforce. Houston's Johnson Space Center is home to one of the most capable, experienced, and mission-driven workforces in the world. JSC is home to our astronaut corps, America's spacefaring heroes who represent the best of our nation. Preserving that talent is essential, and I trust that JSC will continue to thrive under Mr. Isaacman's leadership. Mr. Isaacman, I believe, will prioritize stability, accountability, and respect for the men and women who make the agency's missions possible. As the commander of Inspiration4, the first all-civilian space flight, and the first private citizen to walk in space, he knows that every successful mission depends on the skills and the dedication of its crew, as well as the countless professionals supporting them from the ground. Mr. Isaacman, I know that you are as committed to American supremacy in the final frontier as is this committee and the entire Senate. The United States must remain the unquestioned leader in space exploration. And this imperative is why we need to confirm your nomination as expeditiously as possible. My hope is that you will be confirmed and in this role before the end of this year. Finally, a word about our nominee to lead industry and analysis within the International Trade Administration at the Department of Commerce. If confirmed, Steven Haynes will also help us compete with China. He will support US companies with actionable market intelligence, help them navigate trade barriers, and identify opportunities for expansion into foreign markets. He brings experience as a foreign service officer and from across multiple federal agencies. Both our nominees before us will advance American interests whether in outer space or here at home. I now turn to Ranking Member Cantwell for her opening remarks.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for this hearing. Congratulations, Mr. Isaacman, on being renominated to lead NASA and Mr. Haynes on your nomination to be assistant secretary of commerce. I too would like to welcome our colleague Senator Britt from a state that has a very robust aerospace community and look forward to continuing to work with her. And I'd like to say a special welcome to two Washingtonians who are here. Bill Nye the Science Guy from Washington and Mr. Dietrich who is Mr. Haynes's father-in-law. Great to have you here as well in support of him. Mr. Isaacman, I supported your nomination the first time you came before the committee and I hope to do so again. As the chairman mentioned, I hope to get you in this position before the end of the year. But there is no secret that a lot of NASA changes have been made since the last time you were before this committee, including the NASA decision to recompete for the lunar lander, the release of the president's proposed NASA budget, which calls for cutting the agency's budget by nearly a quarter in the workforce, and nearly a third of the science funding cut in half. So given all that, I'm glad you're here. I'm glad you're here to answer questions about NASA's future. And I hope that today's hearing will show that there is bipartisan agreement, strong bipartisan agreement, that we must redouble our efforts to get American astronauts back to the surface of the moon as soon as possible. At our committee hearing in November, we heard concerning testimony from several expert witnesses who left little room for doubt that the current SpaceX lunar lander would not be ready to put Americans back on the moon either in 2027 or 2028. And this almost certainly would lose the race to China and I know that you are going to have robust competition. In response, the acting administrator Duffy reopened the contract and its competition for the lunar lander that can be ready sooner by the end of 2028 and I think this was the correct decision and I expect you to continue executing on this plan if confirmed. To be clear, winning the race to the moon is not just about short-term token victories. It is the first step in accomplishing a very long-term presence on the lunar surface which is strategic, economically, and a national security imperative. Mr. Isaacman, I expect to hear from you today about how you will ensure we achieve these goals. NASA is also much more than just a moon exploration program. The agency leads in a number of other vital strategic missions, including aeronautic research, space technology, and of course, the agency's critical science mission. NASA is one of the world's leading research and development organizations. I think that's why we have I don't know about 50 people waiting outside to get in this hearing room. I think they really believe you're going to get confirmed and they all want to be first in line to talk about all these developments. NASA is one of the leading research and development organizations and agencies that feeds multiple sectors of innovation including AI, quantum, advanced aerospace materials and manufacturing, and aviation safety. You and I have had a chance to talk about this issue as it relates to my home state, which has around 1,500 companies from a robust aerospace supply chain including 40 Artemis program suppliers and this issue of a tech hub working on next-generation thermoplastics that is so critical to all space and aerospace manufacturing to get a high-rate piece manufacturing production. Nevertheless, as we've discussed these issues, OMB Director Vought has been working to gut NASA's budget, especially in science. Earlier this year, multiple NASA whistleblowers provided evidence showing that OMB was pushing NASA to implement the dangerous cuts requested in the president's budget for fiscal year 2026, disregarding the law and the impacts that this would leave on NASA. This is just unacceptable. Mr. Isaacman, if confirmed, I expect you will push back on these dangerous ideas and advocate for NASA's budget. Oh, I also invite you to visit Washington State. We'd love to continue this discussion on how to generate the next aviation innovation. It's clear that there's a lot going on that will help us on the moon to Mars mission, not just the 40 Artemis suppliers but a lot of other issues in how to guarantee our satellite communication for the future and how to make sure that is secure. So thank you again for your willingness to step up to these challenges. Turning to you Mr. Haynes, if confirmed the assistant secretary of commerce for industry and analysis, you will be responsible for strengthening the globe's competitiveness in US industry and overseeing key trade analysis. You would lead a team charged with value-added analysis and tools to support economic policy decisions. No doubt there's been a big sea change since COVID about supply chain issues and supply chain vulnerabilities and the interest that commerce play a larger role in identifying those risk sectors. Myself and Senator Risch have been leading a charge on fusion technology and hoping that we could be very aggressive on supply chain issues if in fact fusion technology gets to the actual point of manufacturing in the United States. So I look forward to working with you on those supply chain issues and I want us to continue to know that we have to reduce tariffs. In my mind, tariffs are causing Americans to be challenged on affordability issues. And I look forward to working with you and asking you questions about that agenda as well. And welcome to our colleague from Tennessee, Senator Hagerty.
Thank you. I will now turn to our colleague from the great state of Tennessee, Senator Hagerty, to introduce Mr. Haynes. Senator Hagerty, welcome to the committee.
Thank you, Chairman Cruz and Ranking Member Cantwell. Thank you for holding this important hearing. Mr. Isaacman, I want to congratulate you on your nomination and look forward to your confirmation. The reason I'm here today though is to introduce a former staffer, a good friend, and a fellow Tennessean, Steven Haynes. Steven Haynes is President Trump's nominee to serve as assistant secretary of commerce for industry and analysis. But before I get into his introduction, I'd like to actually address all of the staff sitting along the walls here today. I hope you'll take a lesson from Steven Haynes. He did a remarkable job serving on my team, a great member of my national security team and frankly touched many aspects of our office. He's taking that knowledge and moving it into the administrative branch and the executive branch into this administration. And he's going to go on to do great things. And I just think it's testament to the fact that the hard work that all of you put in on both sides of the aisle to support our nation and to generate the type of opportunities that we want to see for our children and grandchildren can manifest itself in a career like Steven's. And I hope Steven that you'll continue to advance your career. It's one of the greatest honors I have to represent my to be here and speak on behalf of my former staffers. And to all of you, thank you for your hard work that you do every day. And I hope that someday I'll be seeing you sitting in a seat just like Steven. Steven was one of my national security advisers for two years. His counsel was critical covering nearly every issue that came to my office from supporting my role as ranking member of the banking national security subcommittee that covers export controls and CFIUS work to State Department reauthorization and consular issues on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee to the important work of funding the government through the appropriations process. Frankly, there wasn't much that Steven didn't touch in my office. Before his time in the Senate, Steven served as a presidential management fellow, then as a foreign affairs officer at the Department of State's Bureau of East Asian and Pacific Affairs. Steve is a graduate of the University of Nevada and holds a master's in Asian Studies from the George Washington University Elliott School of International Affairs. Steven's understanding of how federal agencies operate and his deep knowledge of foreign policy and national security were evident from the first day he joined my team. His expertise served the constituents of Tennessee remarkably well. And his love for this country and serving the American people is palpable. He's a man of conviction, a man of loyalty and integrity, and precisely the caliber of person we need serving in government. I thank you for considering Steve's nomination, and I encourage my colleagues to support his nomination as he advances his call to public service. Congratulations, Steve.
Thank you, Senator Hagerty. I will now turn to our colleague, Senator Sheehy, to introduce Mr. Isaacman. Senator Sheehy, the floor is yours.
Thank you, Chairman. Welcome back, Jared. I'd say this is a once in a lifetime experience, but I think we're on number two now. So, Monica, great to see you. Thanks for bringing the girls. Before I introduce Jared, Chairman, I'd like to enter in 40, I think 40 letters of support for Mr. Isaacman's nomination, please.
Without objection. Thank you.
For nearly 70 years, the United States has been at the forefront of space exploration. President Trump knows how critical it is for our country to lead the way yet again as our space program aims to reach new heights. And that's why he chose exactly the right man for the job, Jared Isaacman. I've personally known Jared for several years, sharing an aviation community in Montana and cooperating with him on improving the education experience for our next generation of explorers, astronauts, engineers, NASA administrators at Space Camp in Huntsville, Alabama. Of note, both Jared and I attended Space Camp and although I would say it lit a spark in both of us to chase the dream of aviation and aerospace, he's been far more successful than I have. We both dreamed of being astronauts as children, the difference is Jared actually is one, whereas I had settled for the title of senator. America has been the leader of the global space trail for generations, pushing the boundaries of space and testing the limits of human endurance and intellect. All Americans should be deeply proud of the incredible accomplishments of heroes like Alan Shepard, John Glenn, Neil Armstrong, Jim Lovell, and many others. The sacrifice and leadership of these brave astronauts is what most Americans know. What they usually don't know is that behind each and every one of these explorers is a massive team of dedicated engineers, program managers, innovators, test pilots, welders, electricians, truck drivers, and families who are the true heroes of our space program. To lead this incredible team requires a leader who not only understands and believes in the mission, but has the interdisciplinary skill set to coordinate these cross-functional teams to achieve critical outcomes. Since the tragedy of the Columbia disaster in 2003, NASA's been an organization of great people searching for revival. And after the cancellation of the shuttle program, for 10 years, it's important to remember, for 10 years, the United States was paying Russia taxi fare to send our own astronauts into space. This would make John F. Kennedy, Ronald Reagan, and dozens of others American leaders turn in their grave. In light of the recent Starliner mission to the ISS that left astronauts stuck in space for almost nine months, we're reminded that much work remains. President Trump knew it was time for a change and he chose the right man for the job. Despite Jared's desire to be an Air Force fighter pilot and astronaut as a child, he found out that he was smarter than most and started a disruptive software company in his garage as a teenager. That company grew to be a tremendous multi-billion dollar success. And that success fueled his ascension in the Hall of Fame as a record-setting jet pilot, an aggressor pilot for Air Force fighter pilots, and most recently the first civilian ever to conduct a spacewalk. On top of all that, Jared and I share another passion, pediatric philanthropy. Jared has personally donated millions to improve health care for at-risk children all over America. Yet again, underlining his commitment to this great nation, NASA is a point of great pride for our nation. It has carved out new frontiers for mankind and shown the world the power of freedom. China's progressing at a breakneck pace to overtake our space infrastructure and beat us back to the moon. And they fully intend to win. If we don't focus our efforts and commit to victory now, we will find ourselves going to bed under the glow of a red moon. We have a moral obligation to continue to lead on the greatest frontier ever known, and it requires strong leadership. Jared is an articulate leader, a great father and husband, and one of the smartest people in America. Jared understands not only how to manage a complex multi-billion dollar organization, but how to design and engineer critical systems. And to top it off, he knows how to fly spaceships. NASA's in need of spiritual rejuvenation, and that will take fresh leadership. Jared is a perfect man for the job, and I look forward to adding NASA administrator to his already remarkable resume. Thank you, Chairman.
Thank you, Senator Sheehy. I will now recognize Mr. Isaacman for his opening statement.
Thank you, Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, Senator Sheehy for that very generous introduction, and distinguished members of the committee. I'm honored and grateful to be here before you again as President Donald Trump's nominee to lead the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. To begin, I'd like to acknowledge my family. So, my parents, Sandy and Don Isaacman, behind me, my wife, Monica, my two wonderful daughters, Mila and Liv. So over the years, I've found many ways to challenge their patience, and politics is certainly no exception. We are also joined today by seven astronauts, some of my closest friends and crewmates together with NASA astronauts that have come to this hearing in support. Thank you very much. I also want to acknowledge and appreciate that Senator Britt from the state of Alabama is here today. So, not only home to Marshall Space Flight Center, but also to Space Camp, which is where my journey began. As mentioned before, I have lived the American dream. I've been fortunate to have an amazing business and aeronautics career, to have led two notable missions to space, to help charitable causes that matter deeply to my family, and now I'm beyond thankful for a chance to repay my debt to this nation by serving alongside the brilliant minds at the world's most accomplished space agency. The last time I sat before you, I introduced myself, my qualifications, and the challenges and opportunities ahead. This time, I'm here with a message of urgency. After more than a half century, America is set to launch NASA astronauts around the moon in just a matter of months. This is a challenging endeavor to say the least, and one that requires full-time leadership. Secretary Duffy in his letter to this committee endorsing my nomination emphasized this point. The message is shared by more than four dozen other letters of support, including an online petition started by members of the NASA workforce and a letter from 36 NASA astronauts who, like me, have sat through anomaly investigations, launched and flight readiness reviews, and have accepted the risks of going to space and understand what is at stake. And I know it's not lost on anyone in this room that we are in a great competition with a rival that has the will and the means to challenge American exceptionalism across multiple domains, including in the high ground of space. This is not the time for delay, but a time for action. Because if we fall behind, if we make a mistake, we may never catch up and the consequences could shift the balance of power here on Earth. This Congress and specifically this committee understand the urgency of the moment, placing a historic investment in human space exploration that President Trump signed into the One Big Beautiful Bill. It's now time for NASA and its partners to deliver. To that end, I want to assure you senators, I'm not here for personal gain, to favor or enrich contractors, to close centers, or disrupt programs that are essential to completing America's objectives in space. If confirmed, I'm here to bring urgency and extreme focus to the mission to do all I can working with the best and brightest at NASA to lead humanity's efforts to unlock the secrets of the universe and ensure American leadership across the last great frontier. In concert with that grand endeavor, we will ensure the following: The success of the Artemis program that President Trump began during his first term. America will return to the moon before our great rival. And we will establish an enduring presence to understand and realize the scientific, economic, and national security value on the lunar surface. Along the way, we will pioneer the next giant leap in capabilities to extend America's reach even further into space, including expanding and accelerating investments into nuclear propulsion, both nuclear electric and nuclear thermal, and surface power programs. These efforts, in addition to industry partners building reusable launch vehicles, will set the stage for future missions to Mars and beyond. We will never accept a gap in capabilities again. Not with our space station presence in low Earth orbit or our ability to send American astronauts to the moon. We will strive to build an orbital and lunar economy that can fund the future we all want to see in space someday and not rely exclusively on the taxpayer. We will begin making the investments now for the inevitable spacefaring future that is just on the horizon. We'll make the most efficient use of every dollar allocated, pushing for more X-planes, more rovers and telescopes, more exciting missions like Hubble, James Webb, and Dragonfly with the aim of enlightening the world through breakthrough scientific discoveries, knowing that if NASA doesn't do it, no one else will. Some of the most talented people in America show up to work at NASA alongside a reinvigorated culture and an intense focus on achieving the near impossible when no other organization is capable of or even dares to accomplish. We will achieve these objectives. And when, not if, we get the job done, it will be because of the professionals at NASA, our international and our commercial partners, this committee in Congress, and President Trump's administration that will have succeeded in ushering in a new golden age of science and discovery. We'll do it for America, for humankind, and in doing so, we will inspire the world and generations to follow to take us even farther. We are just getting started on the greatest adventure in human history. And with urgency and purpose and extreme focus on the mission, NASA will lead the way. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Isaacman. And now I recognize Mr. Haynes for his opening statement.
Thank you, Mr. Cruz. And here I was thinking that all the fanfare outside was for industry and analysis, but not the first time I've had my bubble burst. Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, distinguished members of the committee. It's an honor to be with you here today. I'd like to thank President Trump, Secretary Lutnick, and Under Secretary William Kmet for putting their confidence in me to serve as the assistant secretary of commerce for industry and analysis. I'd also like to extend my deepest gratitude to Senator Hagerty for introducing me today. I feel incredibly fortunate to have his mentorship and support. It's also an honor to have several of my family members here with me. Starting with my incredible wife, Erica Haynes, who's sitting behind me. Our first year of marriage, she asked me what I wanted to do with my life career-wise. And I thought I gave her the right answer, which was to be a good dad, to be a good husband. And she gently reminded me that that was the bare minimum and challenged me to aim higher. And her continual love and support of the past 10 years of marriage has challenged me to do just that. Our first son Henry is here as well. It's the honor of my life to be his dad and to have him by my side. His little brother Oscar has been on the planet for a total of 10 weeks and so he decided to forego the hearing, stay home with his grandmother, probably taking a nap right now. My father-in-law, Guy Dietrich, is here from Washington State. Thank you for being here. As well as one of my three older sisters, Heather Prey, and her husband and my best friend, Charlie Prey. My parents, Paul and Christy, were unable to make the trip to Washington DC today. But they're proudly watching from home in Franklin, Tennessee. I inherited a tenacious work ethic and a drive for excellence from my father and a sense of faith and conviction from my mother. They shaped me into the man I am today and there's no way I could ever repay them for that. I grew up in Franklin, Tennessee in the 90s at the height of Pax Americana. I distinctly remember driving home from school with my mom and her telling me that we lived in the greatest country in the world. And even at a young age, I was filled with a sense of pride and excitement and expectation for the future. I truly felt lucky to be an American and I carried that pride with me as I left America to study abroad and then start a career in the oil and gas industry in Asia. No matter where I went, who I met, what I did, I always carried that sense that there was no place like home. My home, the United States of America. Then in the early 2010s, I started to notice a shift like a lot of people in the global geopolitical and economic landscape. But for the first time in my life, America's future felt uncertain and not guaranteed. And so through the loving encouragement of my wife who's from the area, decided to move to Washington DC, leave the private sector and pursue a career in foreign policy and national security via public service. And that journey has led me to multiple roles at the Department of State, Pentagon, here in the United States Senate, and now for the second time at the Department of Commerce. The colleagues that I've worked with along with the experiences that I have gained have all somehow culminated in the necessary preparation for this specific nomination. For six months prior to this nomination, I had the privilege of performing the duties of the assistant secretary for industry and analysis, learning its policies, its people, portfolios, budget, contracts, learning every facet of the organization. And it's because of that I feel a sense of pride and excitement to have the opportunity to lead the organization in an official capacity. And if confirmed, my singular focus will be supporting American industry's competitiveness through robust understanding and analysis of sectors and supply chains, improving and growing INA's analytical capabilities to better respond to trade questions facing US policy makers, and empowering the professionals, the people who work at INA to approach their work with a sense of subject matter expertise, mastery, autonomy, and purpose. And to that end, I look forward to working constructively with this committee. Thank you for your time and look forward to your questions.
Thank you, gentlemen. Congratulations on both your nominations. And I will say, Mr. Haynes, your 10-week-old son would have certainly been welcome here this morning. With some frequency, senators have been known to cry and sleep fitfully and so he would have fit well in this body. Mr. Isaacman, welcome back. As you know, NASA's human space flight program and its Artemis in particular is critical to maintaining US leadership in space. But as I think you can appreciate, space flight comes at a significant cost. Its success requires program stability. The United States can't dominate in space if our commitments change wildly from one administration to the next or from one appropriation process to the next. That's why the NASA section of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act which I authored outlines a stable path forward for the agency. It gives clear guidance on the Artemis moon mission. It paves the way for commercial space stations in low Earth orbit and it invests in NASA's infrastructure to be able to execute its exploration missions. Will you commit to this committee and to the Senate to full and timely compliance with the law's requirements if you're confirmed?
Let's dive into those requirements. Congress wrote into the One Big Beautiful Bill that there shall be a stable fully funded path for Artemis at least through Artemis 5. Congress also dedicated money for the Gateway lunar orbit space station and the Orion crew capsule. Artemis is the key, I believe, to both beating China to the lunar surface and to maintaining a US presence at the moon. What concrete steps will you take to maintain the Artemis program's long-term stability?
Senator, I appreciate the question and similar to my previous hearing, I absolutely believe that the current architecture with SLS is the fastest path to achieving our near-term lunar objectives, which should be to return to the moon before our great rival and establish the infrastructure so that we can realize the scientific, economic, and national security value. Now we have the first mission which is approaching in just a matter of months which is Artemis 2 where we will fly around the moon. The next mission Artemis 3 we're going to land astronauts on the moon. There's a lot that has to happen in between Artemis 2 and 3. So in that respect I am grateful that the One Big Beautiful Bill affords us the opportunity of additional heavy launch vehicles through Artemis 4 and 5. Now in order for us to actually land the astronauts on the moon it will mean that one or ideally two commercial partners will have pioneered reusable heavy launch lift capabilities and orbital propellant transfer to get the lander to the lunar environment. And when we see American astronauts walk on the moon again it means one or both of them were successful. So in doing so after completing the Artemis 5 mission which is already contemplated in the One Big Beautiful Bill we should have numerous options available to us to have routine and affordable missions to the lunar surface for continuity beyond Artemis 5.
It's also part of US law that it is American policy to have sustained human habitation either on the moon or in cislunar orbit. Do you agree with that objective and do you commit to doing everything humanly possible to achieving it?
I do, Senator. I think the President of the United States would be very excited to see a lunar base.
And I will say just a minute ago, you talked about competing providers. I want to be very clear. I have no particular interest in one provider versus another. My interest is in making sure the objective is achieved. And at times some have suggested that the objective of going to the moon and the objective of going to Mars are in tension. I don't believe they're in tension. I believe both are critical. America will be the first to land on Mars. That is critically important. That is written into law. And I was proud to author that provision in law. But I also think at the same time we cannot lose the moon and lose the race to the moon to China. Do you agree that both are critical priorities?
I do, Senator. And again, consistent with my prior testimony before this committee, there actually are parallel efforts underway. Now, I know there is no question the overwhelming near-term priority is to return American astronauts to the moon and again establish an enduring presence on what is a very scarce piece of real estate that we're interested in at this time. But as I mentioned before, in order for those American astronauts to step foot off a lander onto the lunar surface, it means one or both and actually potentially many more commercial providers will have pioneered reusable heavy lift launch capabilities and on-orbit prop transfer which is the same capability really the next giant leap capability that America needs for missions to the moon, Mars, and beyond.
The International Space Station, which is managed from Texas's Johnson Space Center, is scheduled to be retired by 2030. It will be replaced by one or more commercially developed stations, partially funded by NASA and partially by private partners. Congress has been clear that a gap in our presence in low Earth orbit would jeopardize US strategic interests. Will you commit to guaranteeing a continuous human presence in low Earth orbit and a continuous American presence during your tenure and to ensure that there is no gap between the retirement of the ISS and the transition to commercial LEO destinations?
I absolutely commit to that, Senator. As I mentioned in my opening remarks, we can never accept a gap in our capabilities again. Not in low Earth orbit or our ability to reach the moon. I like a lot of space enthusiasts dream of the day where we have multiple commercial space stations in low Earth orbit. But I think in order for that to be a financially viable model we have to absolutely maximize the remaining life of the International Space Station, get the highest potential science and research to the space station to crack the code on the orbital economy to give all these commercial space stations a fighting chance.
Thank you, Senator Cantwell.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Sorry, I had to step out for a minute and take a call from another member, but I just want to make sure I heard everything you just said correctly on this. So, when Secretary Duffy as the acting administrator announced NASA would reopen to compete Artemis 3 human lander to ensure America would reach the lunar surface in 2028. You agree with that decision and will you fully commit to this recompetition?
Well, Senator, both SpaceX and Blue Origin were already awarded contracts through a competitive process to build the lander. And I don't think it was lost on either one of those organizations that the first company that is capable of delivering a lander to take American astronauts to the lunar surface and back is the one that this nation is going to go with. I think that competition is fantastic. I think the best thing for SpaceX is a Blue Origin right on their heels and vice versa.
Great. Well, we're glad they recompeted and when I first became ranking member of the committee, we argued for the redundancy of competition. There's nothing like competition to get the product that we need and I think the decision that was made was based on the urgency to return by 2028. So, you believe in that process?
Senator, I absolutely agree with competition. I think we need competition for the vendors that support NASA's critical mission. I think competition among world powers is actually a really good thing just as long as we don't lose.
Okay. The R&D issue about high-rate composites, I mentioned in my opening statement the High CAM project which does have NASA's support in trying to generate more composites. We have with Idaho established a tech hub in thermoplastics and really believe that the United States should not lose this race for high-rate composite manufacturing. Will you fight NASA's fight to keep for NASA's aeronautic budget to sufficiently fund such High CAM operations and support the technology development that is needed for aerospace materials?
Senator, I think it's squarely in the responsibility of the aeronautics portion of NASA to work on the absolute cutting-edge materials that will ensure the competitiveness of our aeronautics industry well into the future.
Okay. And then how can you further leverage NASA's university work for development and research?
Well, I think there's a couple parts to that, Senator. First, I think in general it's part of NASA's responsibility towards inspiration in STEM education to award grants to academic institutions that give students hands-on opportunities with hardware, ideally inspire them to want to graduate and either work at NASA or contribute to industry. Also, I just think it's a great way to crack the code on important research that's going to bubble up towards NASA achieving its important objectives.
Great. Thank you. And Mr. Haynes, how do we get this supply chain onshoring or supply chain materials similar to this same subject? One of the reasons I became interested in the tech hub is actually an Idaho employer came to me and said, 'Do you understand the Europeans are trying to buy us?' And I was like, 'No, I didn't understand that.' He said, 'Yes, they're looking, everybody's looking for the best technology and they see it in our country and they want to buy it and we're not doing it and creating the supply chain.' So, how do you think this job and role you can help improve supply chain identifications for America's competitiveness particularly in manufacturing?
Thank you, Senator. One word simply is mapping. We're doing this across a wide variety of sectors. Critical minerals, one mine to market is a term that we use often. We have to understand the supply chain, understand where their choke points are if any. There's two components within industry analysis that do supply chain analysis. The trade policy analysis or TPNA division as well as the supply chain center. There's a good amount of overlap there. If confirmed, one of my sole focuses is going to be to supercharge our analytic capabilities. Bring some in-house, currently out-of-house tools in-house to be able to answer specific questions just like that. And be able to have a little bit more ball control in terms of mapping and analyzing supply chains.
And do you look at this issue as a true competition issue with China and other countries to make sure that we are mapping these supply chains?
It absolutely is. It's a competitive issue across the board. I would say yes, Senator.
Okay. And then there is legislation sponsored by myself, Blackburn, Blunt, Braun, and Young on promoting resilient supply chains. Will you look at that and tell us whether you can support that legislation?
I have looked at it. We provided initial technical assistance and if passed, I'd be happy to implement it to the fullest extent and work with the committee to do so.
Do you see any problems with it now?
I would have to read the bill over again. The current text is...
Chairman, thank you. Thank you and Senator Cantwell for exhibiting greater speed than the normal Senate process in having this hearing in hopes that...
I'm pretty sure glaciers move at greater speed.
We share that view, Mr. Chairman, and nice to see that this committee is moving forward in regard to confirmation consideration of a new NASA administrator. I look forward to his confirmation and the Senate considering it, his approval in this committee, and the Senate approving it presumably next week. Mr. Isaacman, let me start with you. My intended questions changed a bit because I received a letter this week from a Kansas farmer. It captured my attention because I certainly share the views of Senator Cantwell and Senator Cruz in regard to the moon and Mars, and that's I suppose what nationally the public thinks about NASA, that we're on our way to some object in space and we're exploring space. But NASA has lots of roles. You've talked about STEM education being one of them. I want to mention for a moment the mission directive of science. The letter that captured me is from a Kansas farmer named Mr. Roth, and he indicates to me that NASA's earth science investments, I'm reading from his letter now directly, support US farmers in ways that were unimaginable even a decade ago. Tools based on NASA's data and science like OpenET, NISAR, and the range analysis platform provide real-time field-level insight into soil moisture, biomass, drought stress, water use, and yield sustainability. These aren't future technologies. He says they are already built, functional, and being used in states like mine. Today he mentions FIA is a national farmer-science partnership that brings early development producers together with NASA researchers to co-develop practical on-farm tools using satellite data. This mission is to unite farmers with NASA to turn earth observation technology into real-world decisions that support profitability, water efficiency, and risk reduction. Kansas farmers found value in NASA. It's something that we don't always talk about and think about when we think about space. I'm looking for your thoughts in response to what this farmer is reminding me of. How do you see NASA supporting or operationally developing the satellites that support precision agriculture? Tell me your response to this idea that NASA has a role to play in the everyday lives of Kansas and American agriculture.
Thank you for the question, Senator. At the present time, we only inhabit one planet, and earth science is pretty vitally important. It's a role that NASA has had since the agency was established. We have Landsat satellites up there that are looking down, understanding droughts and flooding and wildfires, natural disasters almost essentially in real time that obviously play a direct role on the agriculture community. There's obviously our GPS constellations that are going to go hand-in-hand with agriculture equipment for next-generation farming. So, I do see this as a vital role that NASA continues to fulfill.
I thank you for that statement, that commitment. I'm pleased to be a member of this committee and I chair the subcommittee on aviation and space, but I also serve as the chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee that funds NASA as well as the Department of Commerce. Mr. Isaacman, have you had a chance to look at our appropriations bill and any response to what our committee has approved and what we expect to be on the Senate floor in the next two weeks?
Well, Senator, I don't think I can really comment on any pending legislation other than to say that we will absolutely maximize every dollar Congress affords to the agency.
Would you expand that commitment to say that you will execute the funding that we provide to NASA in this legislation as it's intended to be spent?
Senator, I will always follow the law.
Thank you. I would also use this opportunity to indicate that upon our success in bringing the Commerce, Justice, Science bill to the Senate floor, I encourage all my colleagues who are so excited about space exploration and going to the moon and going to Mars and maybe who have an interest in agriculture and earth sciences, I would encourage them to actually vote for the appropriation bill so that we can, in addition to authorizing and confirming personnel, we can actually accomplish the goals that this committee is spending time this morning highlighting. Let me ask about another aspect. I have 14 seconds. Let me ask a question in fairness so that the gentleman from Tennessee is not ignored. It a bit follows the question of Senator Cantwell, and that is making sure that you use ITA not only as a trade remedy and for export promotion but to be a proactive partner in shaping industrial policy, improving supply chain resiliency, and strengthening US competitiveness. Tell me that you believe that's a significant component of what your job is and will be.
Thank you, Senator. That is the core component of the job.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Senator Moran. And Senator Kim has very kindly agreed to allow Senator Marino to skip in front of him in line since Senator Marino has to preside on the Senate floor. So, thank you, Senator Kim. And I recognize Senator Marino.
Thank you, Senator Kim. And that doesn't mean I'm going to be less harsh on you in the pickleball court. But thank you for doing that. I appreciate that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, Mrs. Isaacman, for putting up with this double-take process. I'm sure having a great supportive spouse has been critical in your life like it's been for mine. Mr. Isaacman, as the administration looks to accelerate Golden Dome and strengthen national security space capabilities, how do you see NASA and the US Space Force better coordinating their work in power propulsion, communications, and hypersonic missile testing, especially given the unique test environments at places like Armstrong Test Facility to avoid duplication and move faster?
Thank you for the question, Senator. Clearly, NASA's job is the peaceful exploration of air and space. It's also not lost on us that this is a domain that is of great strategic importance. And I do think in a fiscally constrained environment it is important that we are not having duplicate infrastructure or various bespoke programs when we could have a more unified approach to it. So, for example, a lot of the work that is done both at Glenn and Marshall Spaceflight Center with nuclear has applications for peaceful exploration of space, surface power programs, but also Department of War implications. And I'd hope that we could collaborate at least with some of our counterparts in other agencies again to avoid any duplicative spending or inefficient allocation of resources.
That's right. Speaking of nuclear, at NASA Glenn Research Center, we're leading the development of a 100-kilowatt lunar fission reactor. How should NASA build on this leadership in nuclear power and propulsion to ensure that the US stays ahead in returning to the moon and reaching Mars?
Well, Senator, I love that question. I think NASA is funded by the taxpayers to do the near impossible. As I mentioned in my opening remarks, what no other agency or organization or even company is capable of doing or dares to do. I think NASA should be evolving to work on grand, almost Manhattan Project-level nuclear programs that have the benefit for surface power applications, especially when you're out of sunlight or you're undertaking discovery missions, let's say past Mars for example, or even actually on the surface of Mars for manufacturing propellant. So I think there is this working, whether it's on nuclear electric propulsion, nuclear thermal propulsion, surface power programs, there is a ton of applications that NASA should be working on in that regard. And when NASA does work on the near impossible, what no one else is doing, it attracts the kind of talent that wants to participate in those programs and achieve these kind of, I guess, world-changing breakthroughs.
I appreciate that and look forward to having you and hosting you in Cleveland at NASA Glenn. Very easy trip from home. So, I won't keep him long. He'll be home for dinner if he comes and visits as opposed to Texas, really far away. It's a very out-of-your-way trip to go down there. But Cleveland, right around the corner. Mr. Haynes, the US depends on specialized aerospace supply chains. What is your plan to strengthen domestic component manufacturing, reduce reliance on Chinese suppliers?
Thanks for that question, Senator, and thank you again for meeting with me yesterday. I appreciated the time and hearing what your priorities are. I would say three things. One is the role of industry analysis is to support a wide variety of trade policies. We are currently conducting a number of different investigations, supporting a number of different investigations like Section 232s, 301s at USITC. And as a part of that, we are understanding what these supply chains are, where they head, and how to create the incentives to bring those back here to the United States. We're meeting with industry regularly. Our Deputy Assistant Secretary for Manufacturing was just at the Dubai Air Show. He's met with Boeing, met with a number of different aviation companies, understanding what their needs are and coming up with creative solutions to bring that back here to America.
Perfect. And last question, you do obviously a lot of data. I mean your job is to really make certain that people understand what the set of circumstances are, others opine and make decisions, etc. Would it be possible without President Trump's policies for us to have gone from 51% of the cars sold in America being made in America at the beginning of this calendar year to where we are right now, which is at 57% and climbing of the cars sold in America being made in America? Without President Trump's policies, would that six-point swing in less than a year have been possible?
Thank you. No questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you. And now I recognize Senator Kim.
Thank you, Chairman. Mr. Isaacman, good to see you again. Last time around, we had a lot of opportunities to be able to talk between the two of us. We both stress how important NASA is and space exploration is to our country, to our science. And while we didn't see eye to eye on everything, I was willing to support you. Now you come before us again, and one thing that has come up that is on my mind right now is having seen a document named Project Athena. So I guess I just want to ask you, what is Project Athena, and do you stand by what is in that document?
Thanks for the question, Senator. So at the time of my previous nomination, moving into a new environment such as government service at a responsibility as great as the leadership of NASA, I had called a draft document that I continued to update based on my interactions with, well, the briefing leadership at NASA's agency, my interactions with various senators and their staff, basically ideas, thoughts on the direction of the agency, research requests. It was always something that was meant to be refined with actual data should I have been confirmed in it. But I do stand behind everything in the document even though it was written seven months ago. I think it was all directionally correct, consistent with prior testimony and my interactions with various senators.
So you're the author of the document?
Are you the sole author of the document?
So, I guess the challenge that I have is when you came before this committee a couple months ago, actually in response to the chairman, you said to him, quote, 'Senator, I have no intention as of now to say that I would cancel any program. I need to if I'm confirmed to be getting a job, understand where things are at.' And what we had talked about is that if you were confirmed that you would go in, you would allow yourself to be in the job before you make these decisions. You would engage with the NASA employees and others. So when I see in Project Athena comments like calling for a re-evaluation of sustained lunar presence, I mean you said to the chairman today that you're committed to Artemis, committed to an enduring presence on the lunar surface, but then you just tell me right now that you stand behind the document and stand behind, I assume, this statement about re-evaluating the sustained lunar presence. So, I'm just having trouble understanding what to believe. So, do you stand by that comment in that line in Project Athena about re-evaluating a sustained lunar presence?
Well, Senator, it was 62 pages worth of material. So, I imagine any one sentence or so can be taken out of context, but in my prior testimony before this committee, I said it was imperative for us to realize our near-term lunar objectives. I think at the time I said and determine the scientific, economic, and national security value of being on the lunar surface. I think today I come before you because there's overwhelming clarity within the administration of not only to return the moon before our arrival but also establish the infrastructure for an enduring presence. So that naturally, six, seven months is an awful lot of time. But I would say, Senator, there's probably 10 pages within that plan that call for research requests to make sure that you gather the accurate information to inform a definitive plan. But I certainly do stand behind the idea that if anyone's going into a position of great responsibility, it's better to go in with a plan than none at all, sir.
But isn't it better also to have humility in the job and to be able to go and engage the experts and the scientists who have been doing this work? I mean I don't mind people having a vision and having priorities but you had told this committee that you would hold off on making up your mind but the document very much came and I wasn't trying to take anything out of context. I'm giving you the opportunity to explain it. So like for instance you responded to a colleague of mine about the importance of climate science and the role that NASA is playing in that way. But in Project Athena you say, quote, well you say NASA should be, quote, 'taken out of taxpayer-funded climate science business and leave it for academia to determine.' That stands in contrast I feel like with things that we've heard you say before. So, I guess I wanted to ask you, do you stand by that statement of taking NASA out of climate science business?
Well, and Senator, first of all, I completely agree with you. By the way, I think humility is an important quality of leadership. And that's why again, I would say if it's not 10 pages, it could be 20 pages of the 62 that specifically call for research requests from across the associate administrators, the various subject matter experts to inform a definitive plan. That's throughout the entire document.
But here it did not seek a request. It was determinative in saying that it should take out and also in terms of laying out cutting of thousands of civil servant positions. So look, I'm out of time. We will follow up. But as I said, I'm trying to be someone who can work together. I think this needs to be bipartisan going forward. But some of what I saw in that document, in contrast to things that I heard you say before, at least what you had assured me about, it's okay to say that you changed your mind or that you don't agree with everything that you said in that document. I had expected you to say that but instead when you come here before us today and say that you stand behind what's in that document, that causes us to have further follow-up here to understand what your positions are.
And Senator, I would welcome any opportunity to get together and I would happily talk through anything in that plan or that document and give you the rationale behind it and I'd welcome your feedback. To do this job is going to absolutely take the collaboration and cooperation with this committee and Congress.
Thank you for that. And with that, I yield back.
Thank you. Mr. Isaacman, I wanted to ask you, so let's just pretend you're in Missouri among a group of students, constituents, just a good cross-section of my state. If you were to answer the question, why is it important that the United States of America gets to the moon first or gets to Mars first ahead of the Chinese? What would be your answer?
Well, Senator, I think there's a couple reasons. One of which is fulfilling a promise that's been made by every president since 1989 and over a hundred billion dollars that's been funded by taxpayers on our grand return to the moon. I think it's imperative that we do so and failing to do so calls into question American exceptionalism beyond just our expertise in the high ground of space. Second, I do believe as I mentioned in my opening remarks that when we return, we will have an opportunity to determine and realize the scientific, economic, and national security value on the lunar surface. Now an example I used in my previous hearing is that there is helium-3 on the moon. Not a lot of it but certainly more than there is here on earth and that is predicted to be a more efficient source of fusion power. Now, I mean, our foreign policy and wars have been fought for a century over sources of power. To get that wrong could have implications here on Earth that could change the balance of power.
We have in this country, I think, a pretty robust ecosystem of new companies, small businesses, sort of disruptors that have entered the fray here as relates to whether it's commercial space exploration or travel or what have you. How can NASA in your role help sort of cultivate that, work with them? Because I do think that's one of the advantages we have over China in this race. What can you do in this potentially new role?
Senator, it's a great question and a lot of people do believe generally these are new developments but in reality going back to the 1960s in the space race, NASA worked alongside some of our great aerospace companies. I mean, whether it was Boeing or McDonnell Douglas or Northrop for sure. So a lot of those names are still very relevant within the space program today and then there's also a lot of new names that is referred to sometimes as new space or commercial space. I think it's going to take the contributions of many to do the near impossible. Now where NASA can play a role is consistent in the past, which is sharing its expertise and talent to help these new companies. When NASA does tend to figure out the near impossible and it's mature enough technology to hand it off to industry where innovation can improve upon the capability and lower cost. That's a great outcome. I also think NASA can do a very good job expressing the need. What is the requirement because there are lots and lots of commercial space companies now. I think ranking member Cantwell mentioned I think she said over a thousand in her state alone. That's fantastic. We just want to make sure they're all working on things that bubble up to our most important objectives. So, I think NASA can do an even better job of working with industry to outline the problems that need to be solved and ensure we're kind of concentrating American ingenuity in the right direction.
Well, I think that to put on the parochial hat for a moment, I think St. Louis is a defense tech hub with former McDonnell Douglas and Boeing with their defense side. The NGA West, which is completing their new facilities, there's a lot of opportunities. And which leads sort of to the next question on quantum. Washington University in St. Louis is doing a lot of really important work here. How do you see NASA's role in furthering that mission, to be on the cutting edge? Because I think what I was getting at with the first question, all of this, civilizations come and go, right? And in many ways, whoever has the most advanced technology, whether it's warfare or on the more commercial side, they tend to thrive and win out, win this great competition. And NASA is going to play a, is playing a very important role, continue to play an important role. How do you see on the quantum side NASA working with research institutions and the private sector?
It's an excellent question, Senator. So, thank you by the way. I mentioned earlier about the importance of determining the orbital economy. So for 60 years other than a few exceptions the space economy has still come down to launch, observation, and communication which is largely funded by the government. And if we do want a very exciting space-faring civilization in the future with lots of space stations and orbital, you know, lunar outposts and Mars bases, we're going to actually have to figure out that economy. There's a lot of prospect when it comes to quantum computing, quantum communications. And what I would like to do is ensure that the highest potential science and research has an expeditious path to the International Space Station so we can maximize that remaining life and then hopefully crack the code on the orbital economy that gives all the commercial space stations a fighting chance. So quantum has a number of applications that can take advantage of the unique environment of microgravity.
Well, thank you for your service and I wish you all the best in this new position. Good luck.
Welcome, gentlemen. Welcome to the committee and congratulations on your nominations. Mr. Isaacman, welcome back to the committee. You were here before for this position and as we all know, President Trump withdrew your nomination earlier citing concerns with your, I believe, political donations to Democratic candidates. And in a July 6th post on Truth Social, the president also stated that it would be absolutely inappropriate for you to head NASA given your close relationship with SpaceX CEO Elon Musk. Since that time there have been additional reports that in the time between your nomination being pulled and now being renominated by the president, I think you've donated roughly $2 million to President Trump's super PAC. So based off this information I'm concerned that the decision-making around this position may not have been about ensuring NASA has strong leadership to carry out its mandate. So, could you please explain what happened to make President Trump reconsider the decision to pull your nomination and what assurances you may have provided, if any, that your relationship with Elon Musk and SpaceX would not create a significant conflict of interest for you in this role?
Well, Senator, there's a lot there. So, I will try and hit it all. If I miss anything, please ask me to correct. So first and foremost, I wouldn't even begin to want to speculate why the president nominated me, withdrew it, and renominated me other than to say I was grateful for the opportunity in the first place. It was an incredible experience. When the president pulled my nomination, he gifted me an extended summer vacation where I could take my kids on some adventures before they lose interest in me. And then I understand that he ran a competitive process and interviewed several candidates. I was grateful for consideration at the time and happy to be here. Now, in terms of donations, I think it was covered over the summer. I actually felt I had enough exposure to Washington and got over maybe some of the initial intimidation factors, so much so that I thought perhaps I would have a political career. Maybe be able to contribute for all the right reasons. So it shouldn't be surprising that I supported the Republican party. I mean at the same time period I probably made 30 times that amount in donations to charitable causes. And with respect to Elon Musk, that question comes up. In fact every story I see that writes about my nomination refers to the Musk ally or the Musk friend. It's funny that in a world where everybody has a phone with a camera on it, there are no pictures of us at dinner, at a bar, on an airplane, or on a yacht because they don't exist. My relationship with Mr. Musk is the fact that I led two missions to space at SpaceX because it's the only organization that can send astronauts to and from space since the shuttle was retired. And in that respect, my relationship is no different than that of NASA.
Mr. Haynes, congratulations on your nomination to such a critical role as well. If confirmed as the assistant secretary, you will oversee the Office of Industry and Analysis which is housed under the International Trade Administration. As part of the office's responsibilities, INA produces trade data that is responsible for informing trade policies and decisions across the federal government. It's, I think it's safe to say, and I'd hope you agree, that without accurate data, the federal government and this administration risk making short-sighted and ill-informed decisions that could impact domestic industries and workforces, as well as alienate some of our closest international allies. As you may be aware, earlier this year, the president fired the commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which is responsible for compiling critical economic data like employment numbers as well as the inflation rate. Not only was this firing clearly political in nature because the president didn't like what the data said, it also calls into question the accuracy of data produced going forward from the BLS. So, my fear is that this firing and other offices throughout the federal government, including INA, which you'll oversee, will face political pressures from the president to produce certain figures, certain metrics that align with his policy goals rather than actually publishing what the country needs, which is unbiased data and statistics. So my question for you, do you believe that there is any political influence in the data currently being produced by the Office of Industry and Analysis and how do you plan, if confirmed, in ensuring that INA continues to produce the unbiased data which is absolutely essential to policymaking?
Thank you for that question, Senator Peters. The short answer is no. There is no political bias in the data that we produce and if confirmed, it will be one of my highest priorities to ensure that the data we receive both from industry partners, American companies, and from unbiased data sources, both private proprietary, will remain of the highest integrity.
Thank you, Senator Sheehy.
Thank you, Chairman. Mr. Haynes, we've heard a lot about the politicization of job numbers and economic statistics over the past year since President Trump's taken office, but isn't it accurate that Gina Raimondo had an 800,000 job revision when she was Secretary of Commerce under the Biden administration?
That's possible, Senator. I'm not sure the exact statistics, but...
No, no, that's what happened. That's the fact. So we're routinely told that this administration and the Republican party has politicized numbers. We've warped data and we've lied to the American people. And the truth is we saw manufacturing flee this country. 97% of rare earths and critical minerals are processed in China. That data didn't seem to move the needle at all despite us watching for decades as manufacturing of critical industries fled this country under overburdensome regulation and incentivization that sent those industries to other countries. And every administration whether they had politicized data, non-politicized, they chose to either ignore the data or lie about the data and sent those industries overseas. And now we are paying for that every single day. And Jared's job is going to be exponentially harder because so much of the critical materials he's going to need to send our astronauts back to the moon and maintain space dominance doesn't come from America. And some of our most sensitive technology is built with components that are made in China, the very country that is working every single day to undermine our supremacy. So, I'd like to hear your plan on making sure that not just that we have the data, but you are ensuring that data is shared in a timely manner so that we can make sure we're making policy decisions in this body as well as in the executive branch to ensure that we're bringing those industries back and ensuring we have dominance for the next century.