Back
Mohammed El-erian
Chief Economic Advisor, Allianz

The Fed's September minutes fail to address challenges to financial stability, says Mohamed El-Erian

🎥 Oct 12, 2022 📺 CNBC Television ⏱ 5m 👁 107667 views
Mohamed El-Erian, Allianz and Gramercy advisor and president of Queens' College, Cambridge, joins 'Closing Bell' to discuss problematic market outlook for economic growth, the potential need for the market to price in liquidity risk, and general remarks following the September Fed meeting minutes.
Watch on YouTube

About Mohammed El-erian

Mohamed El-Erian, chief economic advisor at Allianz and a professor at the Wharton School, has appeared on CNBC multiple times in recent months to discuss the economic impact of geopolitical conflicts, inflation, and Federal Reserve policy. He stated that the U.S. economy has so far avoided "demand destruction" from the Middle East war, but warned that the next phase of the shock would involve affordability issues severe enough to reduce consumer spending. He described the current economic environment as having four phases: higher energy prices, broader inflation, demand destruction, and potential financial instability. El-Erian said he is "really worried" about the UK, noting that the 10-year yield above 5% is "crippling for mortgages and for businesses" and makes government debt more explosive. Regarding the Federal Reserve, El-Erian said he expects the Fed to "sit on their hands" and not cut rates for most of the year, and that a rate hike is more likely than a cut. He suggested the Fed is tolerating a 3% inflation target rather than 2%, as long as inflation expectations remain stable. On Fed Chair nominee Kevin Warsh, El-Erian said he believes Warsh will "err on the side of lowering rates earlier" than the current Fed would, citing Warsh's belief in the productivity enhancement of AI. El-Erian also expressed concern about the volume of funding needed from capital markets, citing large IPOs, government deficits, and corporate borrowing for AI investment, and said he cannot identify where all the money will come from, predicting it will push borrowing costs higher.

Source: AI-verified profile updated from Mohammed El-erian's recent appearances. Browse all interviews →

Transcript (10 segments)
✨ AI-enhanced transcript with speaker attribution
S
Sara0:00
For more on the Fed and markets, let's bring in Mohamed El-Erian. The biggest headline: they weighed the cost of doing too little or too much and decided it would be too risky to overdo it.
M
Mohamed El-Erian0:17
That's absolutely right, Sara. These minutes are as expected – somewhat more hawkish, but they don't want to overdo it. What the minutes do well is balance the inflation battle with the growth and job challenge. What they don't do well, and what the Bank of England has reminded us we have to keep an eye on, is bring in the financial stability challenge. That's what's missing in these minutes. There's a passing reference to liquidity in the Treasury market and that's about it.
S
Sara0:52
Keep in mind, and our viewers should keep in mind, these are the minutes from the last Fed meeting, which was, you remember, a very hawkish Fed meeting. The market tanked afterwards, fell 5% that week, on this idea that they're not going to be slowing down anytime soon. And things started to get a little more disjointed after that. So how problematic is what you're seeing in the markets at this point?
M
Mohamed El-Erian1:17
Look, it basically points to the fact that the Fed is so late that it will probably break something on the way to reducing inflation. The most likely victim is economic growth. I think the marketplace is starting to recognize that the risk of recession and what that does to earnings is an issue. So think of interest rate risk – we've understood that. Credit risk – we've understood that. There's a third element we don't understand at all, which is liquidity risk. And that is something that I hope we're not going to have to price in. But if the U.K. is telling us anything, it's that markets are quite fragile after such a long period of zero interest rates and massive liquidity.
S
Sara2:09
The other thing we're starting to pick up is that the interventions are not proving that successful. It looked like they were at first with Bank of England, Bank of Japan, but both bonds and currencies are back to pre-intervention levels. So what's it going to take here?
M
Mohamed El-Erian2:26
It's going to take a change in the basic economic measures. So in the case of Japan, at some point they have to exit YCC, yield curve control. Until they do that, they're going to find it very hard to control the currency depreciation. And when they exit, that in itself is going to be a challenge. For the UK, it's very different. There's a short-term challenge of stabilizing the pension system – that's the Bank of England issue. But then there's the underlying problem of a government thinking it has more fiscal space than it does. And I don't see a way out unless the government does a U-turn on its tax cut promises. And that's going to be hard to do, but that's the only way out.
S
Sara3:18
The other thing people are worried about is that the U.S. dollar, which is stronger again right now – just this relentless march higher. I was curious to get your reaction to Janet Yellen's comments. I asked her yesterday if she was okay with it and whether she would consider joining other central banks that are trying to intervene to stop the dollar strength. Listen to what she said on that.
J
Janet Yellen3:44
I've said on many occasions that I think a market-determined value for the dollar is in America's interest, and I continue to feel that way. I do think that the pressures we're seeing reflect fundamentals and policies that are by and large appropriate.
S
Sara4:06
She blessed it. She basically said it makes sense and we want a market value. So is the market going to keep daring her and others to do more, to just buy the dollar?
M
Mohamed El-Erian4:16
There are three things pushing the dollar: a stable interest rate that is going to reassert itself, a favorable growth differential that's going to stay for a while, and of course, a safe haven. So I warn people: don't bet against the dollar too early. I've been saying this for the last three years. The time will come, but it's not just now. But what the U.S. authorities are going to get is all the central bankers and government officials coming from other countries to Washington, D.C. this week for the IMF annual meetings, and they will complain about the Fed. They will complain about the dollar. And they will basically say, 'You are forcing us to tighten too much and the global.'