Please welcome to the forum Elon Musk. For a conversation with Bloomberg's Michelle Hussein.
Hello, everyone. And Elon Musk, welcome to Qatar Economic Forum. How are you?
Thank you for having me. I'm fine. How are you?
Very well, thank you. And very pleased to have you with us. You know, among those here in the audience in Doha are some you will know, people who have backed you financially over the years since you last spoke here in 2022. A lot has changed in your life. You're not only running multiple companies, you were doing that then, but now you also have a role in government. So first of all, I hope you won't mind if from time to time I have to move you from one topic to another, because we have a lot to cover in the time we have.
Okay. Well, let's start then with exactly the fact that you now have this combination of being a CEO and having a role as a government adviser. Tell me about your week. How does it work? What's the split of your time?
Well, I travel a lot, so I was in Silicon Valley yesterday morning. I was in LA yesterday evening. I'm in Boston right now. I'll be in D.C. tomorrow. I'll be there after having dinner with the president tomorrow night, I believe. And then oversight of Cabinet secretary meetings and then back to Silicon Valley on Thursday night.
But the balance of your time. Is it... Well, clearly it's a lot. But is it still the case, as you said a while ago, that it's about one to two days a week on your government work?
And what does that mean for your corporate life? Because if we start with Tesla, the company has suffered in recent months what you've called blowback. So what is your plan for turning that around, the declining sales picture? And by what stage do you think you're going to be able to turn it around?
Now. It's already turned around.
Give me some evidence for that. I've just been looking at the sales figures for Europe in April, which showed very significant declines in the big markets.
Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. So our sales are doing well at this point. I don't anticipate any meaningful sales shortfall. And the stock market recognizes that since we're now back over one trillion dollars in market cap. So clearly the market is aware of the situation. So it's already turned around.
But sales are still down compared to this time last year in Europe.
In Europe. Okay. And guess what? That's true of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions.
Does that mean that you're quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. They saw it being at the forefront of the climate crisis. And now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying, 'I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy.' And there are also people who are buying it because of how they may view it.
So, yes, we've lost some sales perhaps on the left, but we've gained them on the right. The sales numbers at this point are strong and we see no problem with demand. So if you want the best insider information, the stock market analysts have that. And a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry about it.
I was citing sales figures rather than share price. Well, tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief executive of Tesla in five years time?
Yes, no doubt about that at all. Well, short of that, let me see if I'm dead.
So this slide does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision?
Well, that's not really a subject of discussion in this forum. I think obviously there should be compensation if something incredible is done, that compensation should match it. But I'm confident that whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do, it will not affect the future of the company.
This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis of the current value of stock options.
Not a judge. The activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume.
That's your characterization? I think the value of the current value of stock options, I think the actual justice according to the law, on the current value of stock options, I think the value of that pay package stands at about $100 billion. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package, your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next five years, as long as you are still with us on this planet is completely independent of pay?
It's not independent. Sufficient voting control such that I cannot be ousted by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. But let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of my pay. It's a reasonable control thing over the future of the company, especially for building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there and wondering if I'll get tossed out for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable. That's all that matters. Now let's move on.
Okay. Well, just one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally? And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political endeavors?
I did what needed to be done. The violent reaction. I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. And yet massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do, to go and damage some innocent person's car. To threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So something needs to be done about them. And a number of them are going to prison and they deserve it.
You're referring to the attacks on Tesla's showrooms. But I think...
Burning down cars. Unacceptable. Those people will go to prison, and the people that funded them and organized them will also go to prison. Don't worry.
But wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were upset at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way? They just objected to what they saw you say or do politically.
Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. That's obviously not okay. That is in no way justifiable at all. And some of the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it, which is unconscionable. Shame on them.
Okay, let's talk about your other companies then. Another business area, SpaceX. I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point Military Academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones. And obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
You certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. So SpaceX is the launch leader. SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX launches rockets, satellites and internet terminals. So SpaceX has a very dominant position in space launch. Of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90% of the world's payload. The rest of the world, including the rest of the US, will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about ten times as much as the rest of the world combined, or 20 times as much as China, which is doing a very impressive job. The reason for this is that we are putting into orbit the largest satellite constellation ever seen by far. At this point, about approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX, and they're providing global high bandwidth mobile connectivity throughout the world. In fact, this connection is on a Starlink connection. This is a very good thing because it means we can provide low cost, high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or it's very expensive. And I think the single biggest thing you can do to lift people out of poverty is giving them an internet connection. Once you have the internet connection, you can learn anything for free and you can sell your goods and services to the global market. This is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world. And I don't think anyone in the audience who may have been helpful with Starlink and getting it approved in the country. I think it's doing a lot of good in the countries that have approved it, which is at this point 230 countries. I don't currently anticipate SpaceX is going to be getting into the weapons business. That's not an aspiration. We're frequently asked to do weapons programs, but we have thus far declined.
Do you envisage SpaceX or indeed Starlink, as a separate entity publicly listing in the near future or at all?
It's possible that Starlink may go public at some point in the future.
And what would be the timeframe? What kind of timeframe would you consider?
I'm in no rush. Going public is a way to make more money, but at the expense of a lot of public company overhead and inevitably many lawsuits, which are very annoying. Something needs to be done about shareholder derivative lawsuits in the US because it allows plaintiffs law firms who don't represent the shareholders to pretend that they represent the shareholders by getting a public plaintiff with a few shares to initiate a massive lawsuit against the company. The irony is that even if the class they purport to represent were to vote that they don't want the lawsuit, the lawsuit will continue. So how can it be a class action representing a class if the class is against it? That's the bizarre situation in the US. It's in dire need of reform. And anyone running a public company experiences this absurd situation.
Well, do you think Donald Trump might change it? You've certainly got his ear. I imagine that you've put this to him. Is this something you're trying to change before any Starlink IPO?
Well, it would need a law to be passed. But the trouble is you need 60 Senate votes and the Democrats will vote against it. The plaintiff's bar is, I believe, the second largest contributor to the Democratic Party. At the state level, this can be solved. Texas recently passed a law that at the state level made it much more reasonable because you have to get at least one in 33 shareholders to agree that they are part of a class. 3%. This doesn't really help with frivolous lawsuits.
Okay. Let's talk about AI, which is in so many of your businesses and in all our worlds in different ways. It's one of the big changes, the development of generative AI. Since you last spoke to this forum three years ago, you're in the space, of course, with Grok, which almost everyone will know. You co-founded OpenAI and then left, and you've obviously got a legal battle with OpenAI. But I wonder if you could say something about the status of that because you were together in Saudi Arabia with the President last week with Sam Altman, but in the same place at the same time. Does that mean you are pushing ahead with the lawsuit against OpenAI?
Yes. I came up with the name OpenAI as an open source and as a non-profit, and I funded it for the first roughly $50 million. It was intended to be a non-profit open source company, and now it is trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed source. This would be like if you funded a non-profit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest and sold the wood. You'd be like, 'Wait a second, that's not what I funded.' That's OpenAI.
They've made some changes to their corporate structure, though, haven't they, since? In recognition of what you've said.
That's just what they told the media. They have partly walked back their plan to restructure the business. That's made no difference to how I feel about it.
So you're determined to see them in court.
Okay. Well, that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation, because when you were here last talking to John Micklethwait, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses. And you said that you really felt what the US was missing was a federal regulator, something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?
Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. Think of regulators like referees on the field in sports. There should be some number of referees, but you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. In most US fields, the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than players on the field. This is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. When you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no cleansing function for unnecessary laws and regulations. So every year more laws and more regulations are passed because legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate. And you get a steady pile of more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. Let me give you an example. Under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for not hiring asylum seekers in the US. The problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under its international trafficking arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States, because the premise is that they will take advanced rocket technology and return to their home country. So we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers, and it is also illegal to hire asylum seekers. Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
But my question was specifically about a regulator for AI, which you said three years ago was needed, and you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that?
No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field, a few referees, but you shouldn't have a field jam packed with referees such that you could not kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. The fields that have been around for a long time, such as automotive, aerospace, food and drug industries, are overregulated. But the new fields like artificial intelligence are under-regulated. In fact, there is no regulator at all. So there should be.