Welcome to The Long Run. This is a podcast for biotech adventurers. I'm your host, Luke Timberman.
Today's guest is Bob Langer. Langer, an institute professor at MIT, is one of the nation's most accomplished scientists and scientific entrepreneurs. Much of his work over the years has focused on tissue engineering and drug delivery systems.
It would take half of this show to list all of Bob's contributions to biotech, so I won't. But the short version goes something like this: he's the most cited engineer in history and the sixth most cited scientist ever, according to Google Scholar's h-index. He's one of just a handful of people ever elected by peers to all three national academies.
He's won the top awards for science and engineering from the Queen of England and two U.S. presidents, and he's had a hand in founding more than 20 biotech companies.
Langer recently turned 70 years old, and he's still running a lab of 100 people who are thinking big. One recent project: it's a sort of biodegradable needle that can be swallowed and still deliver insulin for diabetics without the need for shots.
I've known Bob for about 10 years, mainly focusing on his startups. Despite his busy schedule, I've always found him to be courteous and responsive, and a pleasure to interview. More than 600 people — former students, colleagues, partners, and the like — showed up for his 70th birthday symposium last fall. That says a lot.
Bob's path to success, like most, didn't always move along in a straight line. In this conversation, he's quite open about some of the tricky junctures he encountered along the way. His resilient character — he would call it stubbornness — has been every bit as important to his success as his intellect.
Now, before we get started, I want to mention a couple of events to mark on your calendars. I'm organizing the cancer summit series this spring to raise money for cancer research at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center. David Shankine of GV and Cindy Peretti of Foundation Medicine are just a few of the industry leaders coming together for the Boston Cancer Summit on April 16th.
A couple of days later, on April 18, you can hear from Hal Barron at GSK and Ira Mellman of Genentech, who will be among the distinguished speakers at the San Francisco Cancer Summit. You don't want to miss these outstanding events. Go to timbermanreport.com and click on Kilimanjaro Climb for all the details.
Now, please join me and Bob Langer on The Long Run.
Bob Langer, thanks for joining me today on The Long Run.
So, Bob, I'll just let the listeners know straight up that I've interviewed you a handful of times over the past 10 years or so, I guess, mostly in your context as a scientific entrepreneur. But recently we crossed paths at this PureTech Health conference at this lovely Caribbean island and had some time to talk, which made me think it's about time that I get you on my show.
Thanks for joining me. Now, the other thing that I was impressed with was that, you know, I know that you recently turned 70, and you know, this is — you've won all these awards, right? But you're not one to rest on your laurels. You seemed really trim and fit and relaxed and busy as always. So I think before we get started, is there any like secret that you have to healthy living or improving your health span to keep doing what you do?
Well, I think I do what you do. I exercise a lot. You climb mountains. I do running, lift weights, and go on the treadmill. But I think, you know, exercise has been a good thing for me, partly because I like to eat too much. But exercise is probably the one thing I do a lot of, other than work and spend time with my family. So that maybe helps a little bit.
Do you get ideas while you're physically active?
Yeah, sometimes. I mean, I think about stuff while I'm exercising. I mean, you know, and I mean, I probably shouldn't say this, but geez, a lot of times I work while I'm — you know, I even have — correct, you know, like if I'm on the recumbent bike, I exercise, I sometimes I go over papers that my students give me and things like that. So I often, you know, work a lot while I'm exercising.
Well, you know, people do have treadmill desks. I know that's a thing.
Yeah. Yeah. Well, I even do it sometimes on the treadmill without a desk, but I sort of do it on a high incline, and I sort of taught myself how to write not too sloppily on things when I'm on a high incline on the treadmill.
Yeah. If you're typing email, you could have a few typos, I suppose, bouncing around.
Okay. Well, so we'll get into some of your habits and your current projects later in the show, but as you know, I like to start out with a bit on the person's origins, where they came from, how they got on their career trajectory. Now, I know you've told this story many times in different contexts, but so I hope it's not too boring for you, but could you just start me off — like I know you're from Albany, New York, upstate New York originally. Can you tell me about that upbringing? What was that like for you growing up there in, say, the '50s?
Yeah. Yeah. So I was born in 1948, and I did grow up in Albany in a small house. My dad ran a liquor store. My mom was a homemaker, and I had a sister — have a sister still. And, you know, I really thought I had a pretty normal childhood. You know, we lived on this small street, Tuthill Road, and we'd end up playing sports with, you know, baseball and football and basketball with the kids in the neighborhood. I went to Public School 27, you know, for my first bunch of years. And, you know, I was pretty good at math. I wasn't very good at English or other things like that. And then I went to high school, and, you know, sort of more of the same. But I really liked Albany. I still have fond memories of it. I think a lot of people haven't thought it's a great city, but I always have had very fond memories of it, and, you know, I felt I had a nice childhood.
Middle class, it sounds like. What kind of community — I know you've got a university there too, but what was your school environment like?
Yeah. Well, my grammar school environment was, you know, just — I mean, it wasn't that big a school, Public School 27, and, you know, the kids were from, you know, the neighborhood. I'd actually walk to school, you know, and that — I'm amazed that my mother let me do that. She worries a lot, but she did. I think it — people — it's probably different then than it was now. So I'd walk to school, and I liked doing that. And, you know, there was a playground in the back of the school, and myself and other kids would, you know, play in the playground. And my neighborhood in Tuthill Road — one of the couple of people across the street from us had some pretty good chunks of land, and, you know, and we'd — you know, then so that was like you could play baseball or football or things like that there. And so we did, and it was just fun. I mean, it was, you know, it was nice. And I had a lot of friends.
And you had a lot of — that was independence from an early time. The grown-ups weren't hovering around and guiding every step.
Yeah. Yeah. I'd say that's true. Though my mother really — like I say, she worried a lot about everything. She still does. My mom's 95. Still worries a lot about me and my sister. But, you know, I think it was a different time. So she didn't worry about me going out and playing sports. But, you know, when I went to camp, if I was going away, you know, like when I was like 11 years old, she'd get very worried. And I remember my sister and I, when they were driving us up to this camp, you know, we'd keep counting the worries. She kept saying, 'Well, what happens if it rains? What will you do?' And well, so, well, it's not that big a deal, but there, you know, so but yeah, so I'd say that it was a pretty nice childhood.
Okay. So you go to public schools. How did you get interested in science or engineering?
Yeah. Well, a couple of things, I guess. I mean, and I'd like to say that it was really systematic, but it wasn't. You know, a couple of things I think that made a difference. When I was a little kid, you know, my parents got me for presents — like there was this company, Gilbert, and they made these erector sets and these chemistry sets and microscope sets. And I liked them. I mean, you could build like a robot with an erector set, and with a chemistry set they had all kinds of chemicals. So I had this little lab I set up in our basement. And I mean, it was a pretty crude lab, but yeah, I liked magic and stuff. So I'd make, you know, different solutions and mix them together, and they'd change color. The microscope set, they had this thing where you could watch shrimp hatch. And so that was probably one thing. And then the other thing about engineering — I really didn't know what engineering was. I actually, it's embarrassing to say, I thought engineering meant like a railroad car, but running a railroad car. But my dad said, you know, if you're good in math and science, you should become an engineer. And there was a guidance counselor at my high school, and he also said, if you're good in math and science, you should be an engineer. And I didn't like English. I didn't like French or things like that. And I wasn't very good at them. So that's why I applied to engineering schools, but it wasn't terribly well thought out.
So it sounds like you did some tinkering by yourself in the basement.
Yeah, I did. I did. I liked that.
Was there a particular teacher or mentor? I mean, you mentioned a guidance counselor, but was there a class that just jumped out at you and made you say, 'Boy, math and science is what I love'?
Yeah. You know, not really. You know what happened was when I was a little boy, my dad and my grandfather played a lot of math games with me, and I liked that. I really liked that in math. And I did like the high school — you know, there were a couple of math classes that I enjoyed, but I don't know that anybody there was great. In fact, it's interesting. The teacher I think I liked the best was the history teacher. But science classes, they at my high school, they were okay, but they were certainly nothing great. So I don't think that those things had that big an influence on me in terms of being positive. You know, the classes, they were okay, but they weren't, you know, spectacular.
Were you the valedictorian?
No, I actually — I was fifth in my class. So there were people who did a good deal better than me.
Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Now this would have been — by the time you graduated high school, this would have been the '60s.
Uh-huh. '66. And so you have to decide where to go to college. You end up going to Cornell, not too far from home. How did you pick Cornell?
Well, I actually — I applied to MIT and I didn't get in. And I, you know, and then the other schools I thought about were Union, because that's where my dad had gone as an undergraduate; RPI, because that was a very good engineering school right near me, and I had, you know, gone to RPI Fieldhouse, you know, ice skating when I was a little boy. Cornell I heard was very good. You know, it's an Ivy League school and a very good school. And also you could get — like if you were in New York State, and a lot of the colleges I applied to are in New York State, you could get what's called a Regents scholarship. So that would pay for part of your education. And so, you know, really at the end of the day, Cornell was the best school that I got into. And so I was excited that they let me in, and I went there.
And did you study chemistry from the get-go?
Yeah. So my first year — well, I was in engineering, but I took chemistry my first year, and chemistry was really the only course I liked and did well in. I did terrible in physics, and a lot of the other classes were hard for me. And so I did study chemistry, and from the get-go in the sense that then after the first year, you had to decide what you were going to major in. And I decided, since I didn't like any of the other engineering things, I'd do chemical engineering. So it's almost by an elimination process that I went through that. Again, not terribly well thought out, but, you know, that's what I — you know, I was a young kid, and I didn't — you know, that was what I decided to do.
Did you have to take a number of these other humanities courses like English and such and kind of struggle your way through them?
Well, you know, you had to take one humanities course, and actually I kind of enjoyed those a little bit, but I was an awfully slow reader. But, you know, you had to take a lot of engineering courses like mechanics and dynamics, and you had to take physics courses, and, you know, all kinds of different chemical engineering courses later. But you take one humanities course a term. And so I did that, but, you know, some of those were kind of interesting like history. The only thing that was hard for me is they — a lot of people were fast readers, and I was a very slow reader. So it, you know, it was hard for me to sometimes keep up with it, but I tried, and I think I managed, I guess, to do it.
Now you ended up graduating with distinction, so I think you did okay at Cornell. But I did notice you graduated there in 1970. This would have been peak of Vietnam War times. What was your story there?
Yeah. Well, first at Cornell, I mean, it was interesting. I mean, not only was it the Vietnam War, I mean, there was — what happened is in 1969, the Black students took over Willard Straight Hall, which was the student union building, and took it over with guns as a protest. I mean, it was a huge deal. It shut the school down. And then the next year, you know, there was the Cambodia invasion. So, and that shut the school down again. There was also the whole Kent State thing. And, you know, for me as well, I remember going to Washington once on a protest, and I certainly wasn't very happy with the whole, you know, Vietnam War, as I don't think very many people were at the time. So it was really disappointing to me that the government was doing what they did. And, you know, but I was still interested in trying to do a good job in school and, you know, trying to think that I hopefully could do something useful with my life.
Okay. But you weren't — were you drafted or?
I wasn't — I wasn't drafted. Yeah. No. So that didn't happen, fortunately. But I basically was deferred, and so yeah, but I wasn't drafted, and then so I went to graduate school after that.
Okay. And that's when you get into MIT, and it's chemical engineering.
And what were you thinking you might do with that? Or did you just go into it because it was interesting and it was something you were good at?
Yeah. Well, that was part of it maybe, but also like I got some job offers when I was graduating Cornell, but there were things like to run a chemical plant. And boy, I wouldn't hire me to run a chemical plant. I'd probably have blown it up. And so I couldn't really decide what I wanted to do. But I could see it wasn't that. And I looked at graduate schools like, you know, like Princeton and Caltech and Wisconsin and MIT. There were a number of really good ones. And, you know, they looked interesting, like they had things like polymers and, you know, combining engineering with biology and advanced chemistry. And so I thought graduate school might be good. Maybe it would give me a clear idea of what I might want to do. And so I did apply to graduate school, and I, you know, I was lucky enough to get into all those places, and, you know, I decided to go to MIT.
So you go there, and it's the 1970s. The oil shocks are occurring. Industry — you know, industry is always patrolling these great schools for chemical engineers, particularly oil. I know this. I went to Wisconsin, and I had friends who studied this major, and I was jealous of how many — the kind of offers they could get, the salaries they could get. Nobody really wants to hire journalists straight out of college. But well, Wisconsin was a great school in chemical engineering too. That in the 1970s was particularly great.
But so the oil industry came calling you, and what was your reply?
Yeah. So I interviewed at different oil companies, and I just wasn't excited about it. Actually, I wasn't — like when I was there, they were okay, and I could sort of see myself doing it, but I wasn't — you know, I'd fly back to Boston, I think, you know, do I want to do this the rest of my life? I mean, there were things like increasing the yield of some petrochemicals by very small percentages, and I felt like I just didn't want to do that. I was trying to think how could I do some kind of research that I felt would make more impact. Not that I really knew what I did want to do, but I could start to see that I didn't want to do that. So I didn't — I got 20 job offers on doing those kinds of things. I mean, it wasn't because I was that good. They just had a lot of openings. You know, Exxon alone, I think, offered me four jobs, and, you know, in different parts of the country. But I wasn't excited about it. I just couldn't — you know, as I started to envision my life, not that I knew where it would go, but I didn't want to be doing — I could see I didn't want to do that.
But as a graduate student at MIT, it sounds like you were thinking that academia suited you. I mean, you mentioned that you were the kind of guy who would probably blow up a chemical plant if you were in charge of it. So that's maybe — you're not the most like detail-oriented P's and Q's kind of guy. Did you see that in — did you have enough self-awareness to see that academia and creativity and, you know, the resiliency that's required to make it in that realm was what suited you?
I don't know that I did. You know what — but what I did do in graduate school, I got involved — I really loved teaching. When I was a senior at Cornell, I was a teaching assistant, and I really liked that. And so when I came to MIT in 1970, I did some tutoring, and I liked that. And then some people were thinking about starting a school, a private school for poor kids in Cambridge in 1971. And Cambridge, even though it's got Harvard and MIT, was very poor. There were like a lot of projects. There were 35% high school dropout rate. So they asked if I would help, and so I did. And I helped start — or I started the math and science departments at this school. And I did a lot of teaching even when I was supposed to be doing my graduate work. I'd go there almost every day, and I'd work with the high school students. And I really liked that again. And so I spent a lot of time when I was at MIT doing my thesis at that school. And that I think really helped shape things that I did want to do, because I could see I got a lot of satisfaction out of the teaching. And so something in my mind made me think, well, gee, how can I do something like that that can impact, you know, kids educationally? And I think maybe that in a part of my mind made me think that being a professor someday might be something I'd enjoy.
Now, this is something that you have in common with your friend Hood, you know, who I wrote the book about. That interest in youth education, science and math. And for him, I know that this was very valuable to him in terms of — I mean, it gave him satisfaction in helping other people, but also sharpened his clarity of thinking. You know, if you force yourself to learn something well enough to teach it and then communicate it effectively to other people, that's really good practice. Also helps polish one's communication skills in front of small groups, which comes in handy later on. Do you look back and think maybe you got some of those kind of benefits from the teaching at such an early time?
I think I got some of those benefits and also others. You know, it's interesting how people today and academics and myself included — you know, one of the big things you end up doing is writing grants and, you know, raising money. And when you start a school like that, that was probably — you know, as hard as it might be to raise money for research, it was far, far harder to raise money for that school. But I also got involved in that because I really wanted it to succeed. I wanted the kids to have a good education. And so I spent time trying to help write grants and trying to help find money. And so I really was involved in everything in this school. You know, grant writing, raising money, governance, teaching, curriculum development. And so I think, you know, I learned so much about a lot of things from that school that was never the reason why I did it. I just felt — but when I look back, the question you're asking is very good. I gained a lot from that experience.
It sounds like your first startup, really.
Yeah. Well, in a way it was, though I had a lot of people working with me on it, and I certainly wasn't the leader of it, but it was a great experience.
So you're making your way through graduate school, and I know that this wasn't just all a charmed life, you know, yellow brick road path for you to become a professor at MIT. You got some rejection. Can you talk a little bit about that experience?
Sure. So well, actually a couple of things. So what happened first — first on jobs. So when I looked at — you know, after I decided I wasn't going to work — I got all those offers at the oil companies, and I decided I wasn't going to do that. I started thinking, because of the school that I helped start, and because I had developed new chemistry curricula and things like that, that maybe what I should — and I saw an ad one day to be assistant professor at City College of New York to develop new chemistry curricula. And I thought to myself, gee, that sounds really interesting. I'd really love to do that. So I wrote them a letter applying for a job, but they didn't write me back. But at least it gave me this idea, this direction. And so I wrote to a lot of colleges then, you know, some not even very good ones, but to be assistant professor to develop new chemistry curriculum, and pretty much none of them wrote me back. So I got a lot of rejection there. And then I started thinking about other ways that I might be able to help people. And I thought about medicine, and I wrote to a lot of hospitals and medical schools, and one after the next never bothered to write me back either, or might say, you know, they're not interested. So I got a lot of rejection there, and I mean, I could go on and, you know, but eventually — well, you just got to the chase to keep telling you about more rejection. So finally one person, Judah Folkman, who was a famous surgeon — you know, but I didn't know who he was, but somebody in my lab said I should write him, so I wrote him, and he offered me a job.
Well, I want to ask you about Judah Folkman in a minute, but let's just pause here for a second on this dealing with rejection, because this is something that you all graduate students have to face. I mean, they're going to have their low moments when that set of experiments doesn't work out for whatever reason, or just things don't go your way. And you hear this a lot with successful people that it's not — the distinguishing characteristic isn't always just the raw intellectual horsepower. I mean, that's there for many, but it's this resilience, this grit, this ability to, you know, dust yourself off, get back up again. Do you know where that came from for you? Did you always have it, or did you have to work on that?
I don't know. You know, I've always been stubborn, you know. So I don't know if I necessarily had a resilience, but I was a very stubborn person. I probably still am a very stubborn person, but so maybe it's that. I don't know. But as I'll go over later, I had a lot more rejection. It didn't stop there. But I don't know what it is. I think just, you know, a type of stubbornness, maybe a belief in oneself. I'm not sure.
Uh-huh. Stubborn. How so? Like you get an idea in your mind and just won't let go. Just fixated on making it work.
Well, like what — like later on in doing research, you — and research, of course, in my opinion, certainly for me, I fail a lot more than I succeed. But of course, finally, if you succeed once on an idea, you're okay because then you can just repeat it. But I — so I guess like if it doesn't work right the first time or even the hundredth time, that's not necessarily going to stop me. I would just keep going for the 200th time until hopefully I got it right.
And then hopefully there's enough judgment to recognize when you're beating your head against the wall and really need to shift gears and try something else.
Well, hopefully there is, but I don't know if — but I'm sure I'm the kind of person that errs on the side of still beating your head against the wall. It's probably too much.
Okay. So you have this fateful encounter with the late legendary Judah Folkman of Harvard Medical School, Children's Hospital, sort of the godfather of angiogenesis. This idea that if you could cut off excessive blood vessel formation to tumors, that might be a way to fight cancer. Now this is very basic medical research at the time. You encountered him — lots and lots of skepticism. I mean, I just to put it that way. How did you enter this lab, this realm?
Yeah. Well, for me, when he went over his ideas, of course, I didn't know any biology, but I thought it was just a fascinating idea. I thought, gee, this would be fantastic if it worked. And I also felt it was so much more important than all the stuff that I'd seen in graduate school. And, you know, and I didn't know that there was all the skepticism. I just thought, boy, if you could do what he's talking about, that would have just such an enormous impact. And I thought, this is great. This is what I want to do. So I was, you know, thrilled to do it. I was actually the only engineer in the hospital, and the only engineer in the surgery department, but I just thought this is a great person and this is a great idea. Later on I would see what you said, that there was so much skepticism about it. But even then I felt like it still was a great idea, and if we could do it and prove it — and that was actually my job, was to prove it and actually isolate the first angiogenesis inhibitors — that I thought was just a wonderful opportunity to do something important for really the first time in my life.
Now why did he want an engineer around the lab?
Well, what he told me is he said, 'Gee, he'd had a lot of other people try to do it who were great biologists or great medical people, and they never solved the problem.' So he thought, you know, he thought when he looked at my resume and talked to me, he said, 'Well, you know, I should get somebody totally different who thinks differently than most people, and maybe if that person thinks differently, he'll be able to solve it.'
If you enjoy listening to these interviews with biotech newsmakers, you'll love reading Timberman Report. You can subscribe to Timberman Report for $149 a year per person. Discounts are available for companies and universities with multiple readers. Ask me about a group license at timbermanreport.com. And have you heard about the cancer summit series of events I'm organizing this spring for the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center? These events are big fundraisers, part of a million-dollar Kilimanjaro Climb to Fight Cancer campaign I'm leading this year. R&D leaders like Hal Barron of GSK, David Shankine of GV and AIOS, and Cindy Peretti of Foundation Medicine will not be climbing with me on the highest peak in Africa, but they are all coming together to speak at these events. Mark your calendars for the Boston Cancer Summit on April 16 and the San Francisco Cancer Summit on April 18. Go to timbermanreport.com and click Kilimanjaro Climb for all the details.
Okay. So what were you trying to do? We're talking about anti-angiogenesis. So stopping that excessive blood vessel formation to the tumors. People were trying to do what at the time, and then what was your different take on it?