of introducing our first speaker for our event. He has contributed to price transparency policy since the first Trump administration and he now serves as deputy administrator of CMS and director of Societio. Please welcome Peter Nelson.
Thank you so much, Jack. And good morning to everyone else here. And as Jack noted, I am the director of Societio, which stands for the Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight. This part of CMS leads the ongoing implementation of the Affordable Care Act and the No Surprises Act. And the price transparency rule that we're talking about today evolved from the Affordable Care Act. So, on behalf of HHS, I would like to enthusiastically welcome you all to the Humphrey Building today. I am beyond thrilled to be here with you today. Today's event on price transparency and healthcare is the product of years and years of hard work for HHS, the departments of labor and the treasury and all of you, our public and private sector partners.
We'll soon be hearing from top officials in the Trump administration who are leading this work. HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., my immediate boss, CMS administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz, Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling, Treasury Deputy Secretary Francis Brooke, and FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson. We'll then hear from the people and businesses in the private sector who are making price transparency data accessible and actionable for all of us because we'll all eventually be a patient needing care at a price we can afford and understand.
So, people have talked about the need for price transparency for decades. It's just common sense that patients should know the price before they receive care. Without transparency, there are little to no market forces to drive competition, the competition we need to control rising healthcare costs. Common sense, however, repeatedly ran up against the strong special interests that profit from hidden pricing and rising health care costs.
Then in 2016, America elected Donald Trump to lead this country. President Trump put patients first and issued an executive order requiring true price transparency. Price transparency in the first Trump administration started with rules requiring hospitals to post their negotiated rates with health plans. Then in November 2020, the administration released the transparency in coverage final rule which required health plans to reveal their negotiated prices. These historic rules transformed the landscape of healthcare pricing, making hidden costs available for the first time and allowing employers, researchers, and the public to learn critical details about healthcare costs. For me, price transparency has become a passion. And I expect if you're in the room, you share my passion.
I had the privilege to lead the transparency help lead I should say. There was a crew of us and I so I had the privilege to help lead the transparency in coverage rulemaking in the first Trump administration alongside several people here in the room. When that job ended, I immediately moved on to nonprofit and advised state lawmakers on how they could build on our work. And we saw several states pass laws to enforce the federal rules and beyond our federal rules, expand price transparency to more care settings. I also lent some advice to Congress on how they could possibly codify our rules. Today, as the director of Societio, it's an honor to be back working alongside so many people that share a passion for price transparency and ultimately a passion for patients. In this second Trump administration, Societio has taken several important steps to further the administration's price transparency goals by building upon the 2020 transparency in coverage final rules and by delivering on President Trump's executive order, making America healthy again by empowering patients with clear, accurate, and actionable healthcare pricing information.
We don't work alone here in this building. Everything we do is in partnership with the departments of labor and the treasury and of course the white house.
Together, we proposed a rule in December 2025 to amend the transparency in coverage 2020 final rules to improve the standardization, accuracy, and accessibility of the public pricing disclosures and increase access to pricing information for people enrolled in private coverage and anyone else looking to better understand and make sense of our health care system. As discussed, the 2020 price transparency in coverage final rules were historic and they transformed the landscape of healthcare pricing. However, these final rules were not perfect. No rule ever is. The pricing information the rules unleashed has turned out to be difficult to access and navigate. Oversized files, duplicative data, and information that could not be easily compared across the healthcare landscape has limited the data's use and reliability.
Simply put, you basically need a supercomputer to process the data, which has limited who can work with the data. The December 2025 proposed rule was proposed directly to confront these barriers. And I am thrilled to announce that HHS and the departments of labor and the Treasury released the final transparency in coverage rule this morning. That's when you're supposed to clap. Thank you very much.
The final rules respond directly to the invaluable feedback from you, our stakeholders. And the final rules are designed to make pricing information easier to analyze, compare, and use while reducing the burden.
The improvements in this final rule largely involve addressing issues with the structure of the data files which we call the schema. Earlier this year, we implemented schema 2.0 which took major steps to improve the files outside of rulemaking. This rulemaking will take the final next steps and eventually start enforcing schema 3.0. Key improvements in this final rule include simplifying how the data is organized to make it easier to locate and access. Improving the quality of the data by reducing file complexity and size. Eliminating unnecessary information. And this is a big one. Some of you may have heard about zombie rates. Zombie provider rates. There is a fact about the data files that allowed basically providers to include all basically force providers information across every price in the system. So if you were a podiatrist and you would have data on heart surgery in your system, it duplicated data non-stop. It was unnecessary. This rule will solve that problem.
We're also modifying reporting of out of network pricing information to provide a more complete picture of healthcare costs. We're also requiring health plans and issuers to attest that their public pricing is complete and accurate. We're reducing reporting requirements from monthly to quarterly. And finally, we're making consumer-facing tools more accessible to more consumers.
The departments intend for these improvements to open the door for more organizations, including those with fewer technical and financial resources to analyze pricing data, build consumer-friendly tools, and drive competition across the healthcare industry.
Enforcement will be a top priority moving forward. This rule does three things to strengthen enforcement. It makes the data files easier to find by providing an easy link on a website to where the data files are located. The data files will also include a new utilization data file to cross-check the full data set. And every plan, as I just noted, must provide an attestation.
In addition to the final rule released this morning, I'm also thrilled to announce that we will begin developing the prescription drug schema file next month. Thank you. This has been long awaited and we expect to publish the drug schema next May and begin enforcing by the end of next year.
I want to emphasize how the departments work together. This happens because each of us has jurisdiction over different types of health coverage. Congress actually drafts legislation in triplicate for each of us. This might appear inefficient, but it is a unique check and balance in our system governing an important area of policy. By working together, we build on each other's strengths, which gives me great confidence in the quality of the price transparency rulemaking we finalize today. I also want to emphasize that while this is tri-department work, the final rules released today are products of the combined concerted efforts of everyone in this room. The final rules illustrate what can be accomplished when the federal government, researchers, developers, employers, health plans, and consumer advocates unite around a common goal. Creating a more transparent healthcare market where Americans can more confidently shop for the care they need. Where employers can make more informed decisions, where researchers can better understand healthcare markets, and where innovators can build better tools.
Thank you all for your contribution to these momentous final rules. It is now my great honor to welcome to the stage the Secretary of HHS, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
Thank you very much, Peter. And thank you to CMS administrator Mehmet Oz who's gonna speak right after me, Deputy Secretary of the Treasury Francis Brooke, FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson, Peter Nelson who you just met who's director of CMS's center for consumer information and insurance oversight and assistant secretary of labor for employee benefits security Daniel Aronowitz. I also want to thank the teams across HHS, CMS, Labor, Treasury, and the FTC who did the hard work leading up to today's announcement. And I want to recognize James Sternsburg, my policy advisor at CMS who helped shepherd this effort through all of the interagency processes.
Today, HHS, Department of Labor, the Department of Treasury are finalizing new transparency in coverage rules that strengthen what health insurers must disclose about prices that they negotiate with doctors and hospitals. And I just to summarize this for people who are not sort of familiar with this sort of Byzantine procedures around this. When I was during transition, I was staying with Dr. Oz at his home in Palm Beach and working on the transition team every day. And while we were there, we were visited by the former prime minister of Australia, Prime Minister Rudd. And after he finished his tenure, his administration as prime minister, he had chaired a health commission to do healthcare reform across Australia. And they faced many of the cost and accessibility issues that we face in this country.
And his commission succeeded brilliantly. And he said the principal change that they recommended that reduced prices more than anything else that they did. Of the many many reforms that they implemented, the most effective one was price transparency of giving people individual consumers and also employers who are paying for the plan real transparency as to what they were actually paying for. And the ability to compare prices across a city or an MRI for hip replacements, etc. So, President Trump tried to do this during his first term and he succeeded in doing it and he demanded that everybody publish their prices. The industry, the payers and in some case the providers took evasive action. And this is what is important to understand. The evasive action was just to flood the zone with so much information that instead of enlightening the process, it actually obscured it further.
The information was impossible to decipher and even the employers who have hundreds of attorneys working for them could not figure out the differentiation in prices and they, as Peter said, included all kinds of information that nobody needs. How much does a podiatrist charge for heart surgery? He's never going to do heart surgery. Why do we need to know that? It was put in there simply to create volume to obscure the two lines that we really want to know is what is the procedure and how much does it cost? And that's what everybody wants to know. And that's what this new procedure is going to do. It's going to force the industry to stop obscuring the answer and require them to actually publish it so that we can compare and that we create a marketplace for the first time, a real marketplace where people can choose based on quality and price.
Today we're announcing those rules. These new rules make sure that information is accurate, standardized, easier to use, simplified, and free of all the extraneous information that was being used to obscure the answer. We forced the payers, the providers to cut out duplicative and meaningless data. We are requiring insurers to stand behind the information they publish and that they give to patients the American businesses a clearer view of what health care actually costs.
That matters because Americans have spent decades paying into a system whose prices bear little relationship with each other because there's no market. It was completely arbitrary. We see this in the data. A hip replacement in Boston cost $17,900 at one hospital and at a nearby hospital it cost $74,000 for the exact same surgery with the same Yelp reviews. Researchers have found MRI prices varying as much as ninefold within a single city. And one analysis found that 60% of insurer negotiated hospital rates were higher than the hospital's own cash price. And so think about that. The insurance company who is supposed to be negotiating for all of its members and beating down the price is actually negotiating a price that is higher than if you just walked into that hospital off the street and asked for that procedure. So you know the whole system was corrupt. It was crooked and there was no marketplace because that was by design. There was no marketplace and those are not signals of a functioning market. Markets cannot discipline prices that they cannot see.
President Trump understood that and during his first term he established the most significant healthcare price transparency requirement in American history requiring hospitals and health plans to disclose prices that had previously remained completely hidden. And the evidence shows that these reforms are beginning to work despite all the noise that was injected into the system to make it difficult for us to work. Recent data show that prices among the most expensive quarter of health care services fell by 6.3% per year following the implementation of the initial transparency requirements. When President Trump returned to office, he saw these evasive tactics that the industry had taken and he directed us to build on that foundation. And the administration has already issued warnings or corrective action requests to more than 500 hospitals that failed to meet federal price transparency requirements. And today we are strengthening the rules for health insurers.
One lesson from the first generation of transparency requirements is that publishing enormous quantities of data does not necessarily produce useful information. Some existing insurers' files contain vast amounts, literally thousands of pages of duplicative data. They can even include negotiated rates for services like I mentioned for providers that are never going to provide that service like a podiatrist performing heart transplant surgery. Today's rule eliminates that kind of noise. The department estimates these reforms could reduce the size of our pricing files by up to 70% while making information much easier to analyze and compare. We are also requiring health plans and insurers to attest that pricing data they publish is true, accurate and complete and to identify the senior official at that company who is responsible for that data and for those statements.
We are making it easier to find the data. We're expanding access to useful out of network pricing information and we're requiring consumers to be able to obtain personalized cost sharing information by phone in addition to the tools already available online. The results will be better information for the people who need it. Patients will be better able to compare what care costs before they receive it. Employers will be better able to judge whether the insurers that they hire are negotiating the best prices for their workers and researchers will be able to identify price disparities and study where the market is failing and where the system is failing and innovators will be able to build better tools that turn this data into information that ordinary Americans can use. The American people pay for this health care system and they have the right to know the prices.
If you go into a restaurant and you order a meal, you know what the price is on the menu. If you went to a car dealer and you said to the car dealer, "How much does that cost?" And they said, "Well, we're not going to tell you that till after you make the purchase." You wouldn't do it. But that is how the health care system in this country works every day. It literally is insane. It has nothing to do with free markets. The American people pay for this care system and they have the right to know the prices. The prices do not belong to the hospitals. They don't belong to the insurance companies. They belong to the American people and the consumers.
President Trump gave us a clear mandate to bring real price transparency in American healthcare. We're exposing the prices. We're making the information usable. We're holding hospitals and insurance companies accountable. And we are punishing them when they refuse to comply. Administrator Oz has led this work at CMS and will explain what these new rules mean for the healthcare marketplace. Matt, the floor is yours.
I want to thank Secretary Kennedy for being such a passionate advocate for just doing the right thing. These rules are hard to write. Peter's worked on this with his team for almost a year and it happened because when the Secretary of Health and Human Services thinks that quality is the most important thing, the defining element of this organization, people act accordingly. The importance of this endeavor is also reflected by the power hitters who are going to follow me today. Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling, the newly confirmed labor secretary, Treasury Deputy Secretary Francis Brooke, FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson. Peter also brought Jack Hollerin who started this endeavor and other members of the Societio Group and there are many others. But President Trump has clearly defined what quality means and he's using it to unite our government in the 21st century behind a couple major initiatives. This is one of them. So, we are accelerating the accomplishments. We're not slowing down.
And I want to call to attention what happened last week with the National Design Studios effort to bring technology to bear on the reality. We have 29,000 websites in America. And a lot of Americans don't understand how to interact with their own government. America.gov uses technology to bring us together. Effectively, we are hosting a dialogue. People can ask us questions. They can talk to us. We can talk back to them. This is the kind of innovation using technology that should define us. Now, part of it is the reality that technology is ready for it. But part of it because we prioritized these endeavors at America.gov's launch, we recognize, and I hope you will do as well, that we can use an all of government approach to bring a different, seemingly disconnected, sometimes discombobulated elements of government together in a uniform way to serve the American people. So, no longer are we working against the tide with so many of the questions Americans have. We're actually working for you. I think when you see what America.gov was able to do to bring multiple agencies together, you see why these kinds of events today are so critical because what we're announcing is based on that same basic conviction, which is we have the ability to do things never thought imaginable before and today we're delivering.
So, let me tell the brief story of what this looks like for the average person, but I'm going to go back a tiny bit. When I was in medical school, I actually went to business school. I was at Wharton and I went to my first day of classes and they told me, "Here are the options that I could pick from." And interestingly, there was no accounting class offered. And I asked why not. And they said, "Well, we don't really do accounting in healthcare." And the reason, this is a true story, by the way. They said, "We don't do accounting in healthcare because how do you measure the value of a gauze?" It really is just sort of made up to add up to the right number for the entire procedure. And this was a while back, but it hasn't actually changed as much as it should have. Now we have accounting classes obviously, but we don't have a lot of the infrastructure insights because to have accounting, you have to have data. Today the costs are largely invisible to patients and the companies as you all know pricing data hidden in files as described by Secretary Kennedy and by Peter Nelson in ways that is scattered across individual plan websites seemingly on purpose.
When really smart people don't do things that are obviously important to do, it's because they didn't want to do them. We have found that at CMS again and again that toll takers get involved. Narrowing of the information flow happens on purpose because someone can lift the toll, collect a little tithe, dip their beak in the flow of information and money and get paid accordingly. So the grocery store analogy that Secretary Kennedy used and others I think will speak to which is at the heart of the problem is you never go shopping for a plane ticket, a car, groceries without having some idea of the prices you're going to pay. And to solve this problem, this new rule that releases today is going to allow healthcare plans' pricing data to get packaged and presented to you in a way that's intelligible. We're going to make the cost of care visible to everyone, especially to the American people who seem to get left behind in many of these discussions. The changes are going to weed out redundancies, provide essential context, standardize how the data is going to get presented in ways that actually could be used by other parties. Now, all this may seem pretty technocratic, but here's what's going to unleash very concretely.
There's going to be an explosion of independent, innovative price transparency applications. There's going to be conversations with super intelligence and cost comparison tools. We're going to give companies and patients the clearest picture yet of what they're actually paying for and is it the right value for them based on what their desires are. Now, some health tech companies are already doing some of this on their own. They were doing it before we started, but it was hard for them. Just take what Secretary Kennedy told you about the difference in the cost of hip replacements in Boston. We know these numbers because of the transparency sites that have already been out there. Turquoise Health, I want to applaud who's also helping lead the tech ecosystem, which I'll speak to in a second. Garner Health, Helm Health, Serif Health, all these are great members of the health tech ecosystem that is out there trying to get ahead by allowing companies to get the tech sector off the sidelines and into the main flow of information to help the American people. But when you actually look at the numbers, it's stunning. The city that I practiced medicine in for much of my life in New York City. The difference between an MRI scan across United Healthcare insured policies, by the way. So, just in one insurance company, one procedure, $350 to $3,000 on the same island if you're insured by the same company. The bottom line is our rule is going to empower all these transparency sites in the room today to sync up and deliver a one-stop shop for cost comparison using data that is out there, has always been out there, but has purposefully been obfuscated. Denials can be clearer and cleaner with the CMS rule. It's a big step towards a future where you don't have to shop around on individual health websites paging through lots of literature put there in part to block what the truth really shows. It's actionable data. That's the goal.
Now, to get there, here's what we did and this is the key part. First off, we reorganized all that data that's out there around provider networks. So, it's built around how people actually search for what something might cost. And that's going to make it not just easier, but also practical for plans to put numbers into a file. We're going to cut out a lot of the redundant and frankly unreliable information and add context to the numbers that people see actually mean something to them. We're going to require plans and insurers to attest that what they publish is complete and accurate because otherwise the system breaks down because people cannot trust the numbers. And we got insurance companies who don't comply. They're out there. The reason Andrew Ferguson is going to speak today is this rule is going to make it a lot easier to find and verify who's cutting corners. I'm guaranteeing you we will find you and when we find you, we will find you because this is not something that any of us can tolerate anymore. You should applaud to that because Chairman Ferguson is going to detail specific actions to comply with that.
And by the way, the way we have done successfully with fraud in this country is get the good guys to tell us what the bad guys are doing. So if you see people defrauding the system, purposely hiding their numbers, tell us. We will take action. We are open for business in that regard for sure. So, we're taking a lot of the red tape that's in the way, getting rid of that as well. We realize we have not made it easier for industry to do the right thing at times. So, we're going to take responsibility and deal with that. We're also expanding how people can get personalized cost information. So, you can just call up if necessary through not just through online tools. Call up over the phone, call your plan, and be able to get data on what your specific procedure costs. So, yes, find out what all the MRIs might cost in New York City. But if you know what you're going to have and where it's going to be done, we'll tell you what it's going to cost roughly so you have an idea of what you're going to have to come up with.
The health tech ecosystem that I've mentioned, Amy Gleason who's here leads that endeavor, has 85 companies out there. They have joined this price transparency pledge and you have providers and payers and clearing houses and app developers all working together seamlessly in order to take on two goals. First, what is the price transparency data that hospitals and health plans already publish and how do we make it easier for patients to use it in whatever app they choose so that people can compare and provide the best information out there and it's going to put some pressure to compete for the patients' business because once you have transparency and you know quality, you can calculate value. Second big issue is we're going to get patients real estimates before a major procedure from their own provider on their health plan. So, it's not theoretical. You're going to know what that operation is going to cost. So, your part of it is clear to you. So, you can go into this endeavor because these procedures cost as much as buying a car. You're entitled to know what you have to pay out of pocket.
Now, we're testing all this now. We expect to be in production in December with the drug element as well that was mentioned briefly and Peter acknowledged this because we think drug prices should have the same transparency rules as health services. And for the very first time, you're going to be seeing that rolling out very quickly. Next month, Peter's going to begin developing the price schema for prescription drugs. That's the file blueprint that health plans must use to follow to disclose negotiated drug rates. We're going to test these files over the coming months with a hopeful publication of that rule by May of 2027. And this builds on what TrumpRx has already crafted. TrumpRx, one of the most successful endeavors. We've already saved the American people about a billion dollars just by putting all those most-favored-nation drug prices out there on a website. So everyone can get access to what those prices are if they're paying cash. And now we're seeing employers and pharmacies and others rely on that basic set of information that covers about 80 to 90% of all the drugs sold in America in pharmacies and about 90% of the branded products you can know what the best price would have been out there if you were desiring of it.
CMS is taking transparency to a whole new level. We got the entire industry working with us with visibility in the health plans' negotiated rates accessible and when we're done you should be able to know like in every other sector what it's going to cost you. I want to thank the different members of this administration who are here today and I want to appreciate the fact and you should as well that healthcare price tags will no longer be written in invisible ink. It's there to be seen. It's designed to be read. We're going to make sure that it's legible and available. We're putting out the pen, pulling that thing off the shelves and writing them in bold print with large serif, no pun, to make sure that it's available. And finally, I want to welcome Secretary Sonderling, who has just got through his Senate confirmation for the Senate broke, which is a wonderful thing for America. It's a wonderful spirited leader of the Department of Labor with whom we work very closely on these endeavors. Keith.
Thank you, Administrator Oz. This is my first speech not as acting secretary but as the labor secretary. And how exciting is this to talk about price transparency and I first want to thank everyone here today, my counterparts at HHS, CMS, Treasury, and the FTC. And this really just shows how President Trump has wanted all his agencies to come together to help the American people. So from the Department of Labor's perspective, think about it. Most Americans get their health insurance through their employer. And the Department of Labor, we protect the health benefits workers receive through their employers. And that is a lot of Americans. 2.6 million group health plans covering 136 million workers and their families. President Trump has made it a priority to give Americans clear, accurate, and actionable information about what their health care actually costs. During his first term, President Trump brought previously hidden health care prices into the open. And he has directed us to build on those reforms. And today, we are doing exactly that. Making health care prices more transparent, helping drive competition and lower costs for the American people.
And the idea behind this is simple. Americans should know prices and compare their options. When it comes to nearly everything else you buy, groceries, home appliances, back to school supplies, you can compare prices. And you can decide what gives your family the best value for the lowest price. That is how choice and competition are supposed to work. But not when it comes to health care. You work hard to earn your health care benefits. You shouldn't guess what it's going to cost. Especially for your employers, and this is a really important part, Department of Labor, employers, they invest significantly in providing health care benefits to their workers. They also deserve to know too what they are paying for their employees. And while President Trump's first rule brought health care pricing into the open, there was still a lot of work to do. As you've heard, the amount of raw pricing data was enormous. It could be difficult to access, difficult to understand, and difficult to compare.
In some cases, you practically needed to be a data scientist to make sense of it. And today, our new transparency and coverage rule solves that problem. For workers and their families, that means better information to understand and compare health care costs. And for employers, it means better information about health care benefits they offer to their workers. Because when workers and employers can compare prices, providers have to compete for their business. This is competition that will lower costs, putting more money back in your pocket. And together with our partners at HHS and Treasury, we are doing exactly that. And like I said, it's been a team effort. I want to thank Secretary Kennedy, Administrator Oz, and Secretary Besson, who have been incredible partners with the Department of Labor in carrying out President Trump's vision for greater health care transparency. And I want to thank my incredible team at the Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration. I see a lot of them are in the front row for their hard work today. So getting to it, what does this all mean for workers and their families? It means better information to make informed health care decisions. And for employers, it means greater transparency for health care benefits that they are ultimately paying for. So whether you are going in for an MRI, scheduling a routine procedure, preparing to have a major surgery, or having a baby, you will know what your care will cost before you receive it. And this is more than just price comparison. It's about the American people giving them the information to make better decisions about health care and, more importantly, where their hard-earned money goes. And when you have that information, it creates more choice, more competition, and more opportunity for lower costs. It's actually the opposite of socialism. It's the American way.
President Trump took historic action on health care price transparency during his first term. And now in his second term, all of us are finishing the job. Because when Americans know what health care actually costs, they can compare and they can choose. And thanks to President Trump, Americans can save and keep more of their hard-earned money. It's now my honor to introduce the Deputy Secretary of Treasury, Francis Brooke.
Well, thank you, Keith. Good morning, everyone. It's wonderful to be here. I want to start by thanking my colleagues at the Department of Health and Human Services and the Department of Labor, as well as the dedicated teams across all three departments who've worked together to finalize and publish this health care cost transparency final regulation. At its core, this regulation will put Americans in a position to better understand the cost of their health care coverage. That should not be a controversial idea. When families are making important decisions about their health care and their finances, the cost of health care coverage should not be a mystery. People should be able to understand what they're being asked to pay, compare their options, and make informed decisions. This is how markets should work. President Trump has made it clear that health care price transparency is a priority for this administration. He directed the Treasury, HHS, and Labor to build on the cost transparency reforms he began during his first term and to ensure that pricing information is clear and accurate. Today, we are continuing that work. This rule will improve standardization, accuracy, and accessibility of public pricing disclosures of in-network and out-of-network health care costs. When patients and families can see and understand the price of health care services, they can make more informed decisions about their own care. When employers have clear information, they can better assess the value they are purchasing for their workers and employees. And when researchers can make use of reliable pricing information, they can build tools that help make an extraordinarily complicated health care system easier for Americans to navigate. These are the central objectives at the heart of the transparency and coverage regulation. But transparency only works well when the information is actually usable. We are strengthening the existing transparency framework so that health care pricing information is more reliable and easier to use. At the same time, we have worked hard to avoid unnecessary burdens that do not advance those goals. For example, Americans will have another way to get information about what their care may cost. In addition to the online tools already available, individuals will be able to request cost-sharing information by phone. For years, consumers have had far less information about prices in health care than they typically have when making basically any other purchase in their life. President Trump's price transparency initiative is aimed at changing that by making actual pricing information more visible and comparable and by strengthening accountability for information that is reported. We appreciate the Department of Health and Human Services' leadership on this rule, and Treasury is proud to be part of the effort. We look forward to continuing this work with Secretary Kennedy, Dr. Oz, Secretary Sonderling, and our other colleagues across the administration as we implement these reforms and make health care prices more transparent for the American people. And now, it is my privilege to introduce our next speaker, my friend, FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson. Thank you all.
Thank you, Mr. Deputy Secretary. Good morning. I'm not here to talk about the transparency and coverage rule specifically. I'm taking a moment from fighting fraud to come here and talk about something the FTC is going to begin doing today that is aimed at fixing the same policy problems that the rule is aimed at fixing. Anyone who's ever been through the nightmare of hospital billing knows that there has to be a better way than the way it currently works: confusing charges, surprising costs, and a final number that often bears very little resemblance to the number you were given up front, if you were given one at all. It should never be a mystery how much money a standard procedure is going to cost you or your children. No family should have to wonder what the bill is going to be at the end of the process and whether, when it arrives in the mail, it's going to wipe out your savings. Despite health care being among the largest and most consequential expenditures that American families make, Americans are routinely asked to commit to care without knowing how much they're going to pay before the service is rendered. Prices for the same service often differ dramatically from one provider to another. But when patients aren't told in advance the price of health care, they are unable to compare prices like they do in every other market. And like in every other market, patients in the health care markets deserve to know the price of the services they're being offered before they receive care. The solution is straightforward. We've heard a lot about it today. It's price transparency. That's why President Trump has championed empowering patients with clear, accurate, and actionable health care pricing information. It's a key part of his Make America Healthy Again agenda and demands nothing less than radical transparency. Secretary Kennedy, Dr. Oz, and Secretary Sonderling have all embraced this goal because they know that price transparency is not just good policy. It's critical to health care affordability and fairness for every American and every American family. The FTC has been at the tip of the spear in promoting price transparency throughout our entire economy. We've brought lawsuits to enforce price transparency against major landlords, against car dealerships, live ticketing events, pharmacy benefit managers, and grocery delivery platforms. We have two pending rulemakings that would require price transparency for grocery and food delivery apps and for long-term housing rental. We're holding these industries accountable for hiding and obscuring their true costs and making it impossible for Americans to compare prices across providers and merchants. Those actions were straightforward applications of a bedrock legal standard that the agency has been enforcing for 90 years. Businesses can't mislead consumers about price. Across industry after industry, the FTC has enforced the standard. And today, we are applying that well-established standard to the hospital industry. This morning, I wrote the largest for-profit hospital groups in the country, collectively representing over a thousand service provider locations, to inform them of their legal obligation under the FTC Act to provide truthful and accurate pricing information to customers. Consumers have a right to be told of the price of health care in advance before purchasing it. And no hospital is exempt from the principle that every other industry is expected to follow every single day. CMS under Dr. Oz has done an incredible job advancing the cause of accountability and price transparency. It has implemented the No Surprises Act, which requires hospitals to provide good-faith estimates upfront. And we heard today that they, along with the Department of Labor under newly confirmed Secretary Sonderling, are allowing patients and U.S. businesses to better understand and hold payers accountable for deals that they may not have had any part in negotiating with providers on their behalf. These are huge leaps in the right direction, and those men deserve tremendous credit for them. But these rules only provide a baseline for what hospitals have to do. The Federal Trade Commission has additional authority to deal with unfair or deceptive practices. And today, I'm warning hospitals that we will exercise that authority to stop the following types of conduct. Hospitals cannot conceal the true cost of a procedure to prevent patients from shopping for better deals at competing facilities. And hospital price disclosures must be complete, accurate, and offered in advance of scheduled services. Arming consumers with the knowledge they need to shop around will foster competition and drive down health care costs. Knowing the true price means that consumers, before they undergo procedures, consumers will be able to better decide for themselves whether it's worthwhile to undergo an elective procedure and where to have it done. Competition like this is critical because nearly one out of every five dollars that consumers spend goes to health care. Let me be clear. These letters are a warning. Health care providers must disclose their prices to consumers and must do so starting today. If they do not, then the FTC will take them to court. The FTC has already opened price transparency enforcement investigations against hospitals, and we will not rest until pricing transparency in health care is the universal norm. Today, like President Trump, we demand nothing less than radical transparency. Thank you very much.
Thank you to the secretaries, Administrator Oz, and Chairman Ferguson for these momentous remarks and for sharing the Trump administration's commitment to price transparency. Today's event celebrates the administration's continued achievement of making health care prices accessible to every American. And this next panel demonstrates how price transparency is already making care more affordable for employees across the nation. Now, it is my pleasure to introduce Assistant Secretary Dan Aronowitz, the leader of the Employee Benefits Security Administration at the Department of Labor, who will be leading our first panel, Turning Transparency into Health Affordability for American Businesses.
Well, good morning, and thank you for being here. Secretary Sonderling told you that more Americans get their health care from employer-sponsored health care than any other health care in America. And so if you take that by logic, if you change employer-sponsored health care, you change all health care. And that's what we're going to talk about today. For most employers, health care is the second biggest operating expense beyond their wages. Employers who sponsor health care have fiduciary duties to act in the best interest of their employees. But you can't do that if you don't know what the rates are. And that's the promise of this rule. You've heard it over and over. Employers now, with the TEF files, can benchmark rates, press vendors for better deals, and pass those savings on to their workers. Every dollar in excess health care is a dollar that can go into wages for American workers. This is an American worker issue. What I want you to think about when you're thinking employer-sponsored health care and the promise of this rule is to much is given, much is expected, and that's what we're going to talk about today with respect to fiduciary liability. We have four leading thought leaders, and I want to introduce them, and then we'll talk to each of them individually on how we can take the TEF rule and turn it into actionable savings for all Americans. First, we have James Gelfand. He is the president and CEO of the ERISA Industry Committee, and he's going to give you the voice of large self-funded plans. Then we're going to talk to Elizabeth Mitchell. She's the president and CEO of the Purchasers Business Group on Health. She's done a very interesting data project with current TEF data comparing to some of the claim expenses of five of her employer members, and we're going to learn from her. Then we're going to meet Chris Doup. He is the director of health benefits at Amazon. He leads the benefit strategy for one of the largest companies in America. He's going to give you a real-world example of how a large company can use the TEF data. And then we're going to meet Chris Deacon. She is a fiduciary guru, sort of an evangelist of how fiduciaries can hold insurance companies accountable. She did it when she led New Jersey's health plan. And I want you to make sure you have her book, The Great American Health Care Heist. To start the panel, even though she's going to talk last, let me read from her book, page 23. If we want a future that prioritizes innovation, prosperity, and health, not just for individuals but for the entire nation, we must demand accountability from an industry that has taken too much for too long. So, with that, let's start with the leader of ERIC, who represents self-funded employers, and you have championed this issue for years and years. Can you describe how ERIC members are using the TEF files and how they can use it even better with improved TEF files?
Absolutely. Thank you, Mr. Assistant Secretary. Right now, it's really the most sophisticated employers that are using the TEF data, and those who have specialized consultants who know how to use big data. That shouldn't be super surprising if you've heard the speakers who have already spoken today. The information that's out there right now is very hard to use, and it's not by accident because some carriers and TPAs have gone out of their way to make it tough to work with. But for those companies, and you'll hear from some today that are making use of the data, they are harnessing it. They're starting to look for anomalies. They can, for the first time, compare prices in any given market. And they can start to shape networks based on actual value instead of what we've used before, you know, ethereal concepts like reputation of a given provider or institution. And providers and systems that are outliers, they're going to warrant further examination and questions. Why are your prices so high? It doesn't seem to match the outcomes that we're seeing. Employers can also compare their TEF data to the hospital transparency data. For the first time, they can evaluate whether their TPA is actually getting a good deal using real and meaningful comparisons. So this might cause some employers to demand that their TPAs do a better job or maybe to go shopping. I think that it was a wake-up call for many employers when it first emerged that carriers might be agreeing to higher rates for self-insured employers in exchange for lower rates in their fully insured business. And that's a revelation that we just simply never would have known without being able to compare that data. And it likely provided hard evidence needed to ask bigger questions and explore new vendor options. But ultimately, the TEF data gives us the opportunity to ask one simple question: Is the design of our plan operating in the best interests of our workers and their families? If the answer is no, then we have to change it.
You submitted a comment on the rule, and you recommended to avoid duplicative files. We should organize TEF data on a provider level as opposed to a plan level. You would hopefully be happy to know when you read the rule this afternoon that we took your comment to heart and we did that. Can you explain how that will make a difference in all practicality?
If you want an employer to do a good job of managing the money that they set aside on behalf of their employees, you have to arm them with several specific pieces of information, right? They need to know the negotiated rate. That's what the TEF file provides. They need to know the bill charge from the provider. And then they need to know the actual amount of money the TPA took out of their bank account. And if you have all of that information, then you have total vision into your health plan, and you can start to work to make it better for your employees. But there's a reason why this has been almost impossible to achieve up until now, and that's because the health care industrial complex absolutely thrives on opacity, right? There are literally tens of billions of dollars at stake. The arguments against it, of course, are kind of ludicrous. They say, "Hey, I'm going to take money out of your bank account. I'm not going to tell you the exact amount that I take out or what I do with it because they're proprietary." And the reasons for that are like privacy or, you know, trade secrets, something. And as this sounds crazy, but it's actually the current situation today, even for the largest employers. And the Trump administration has actually opened the door by demanding that negotiated rates be disclosed. Although it may take another act of Congress to get us that second piece of information, which is how much money they're taking out of our bank account. But once you know how much was supposed to go to the provider and how much was actually taken out of the account, the game's over, right? You know exactly how much vendors are paying themselves with your money. And you're going to find some uncomfortable stuff, right? So many in this room, I'm sure, read the New York Times expose that found that a now disgraced vendor was settling out-of-network claims and sometimes paying itself more than it paid the provider that the claim went to. Sometimes this even meant that the patient was being left with a huge balance bill. And unfortunately, when the data comes to light, I think a lot of us are going to find that our current TPAs have similar practices in their shared savings programs. And I know that Chris has spoken about secret hidden contracts that are actually underneath the employer's contract. Maybe it locks the employer into spending a certain raw amount of dollars on a hospital in a given year. Or maybe it says to the employees, you're going to get gouged if you get health care in a certain state. But these are the kinds of things that we can find out once we have access to this information, and we can stop it.
Thank you very much. Let's keep digging in a little bit more. Elizabeth, you've been an innovator, and your association has been an innovator in driving lower cost in employer-sponsored insurance. Your health care data demonstration project worked with five large employers, taking claims data, comparing it. Can you tell us about your project and what you learned?
I would love to. And first and foremost, thank you for making this possible because employers and employees have been asking for pricing information for decades, and unfortunately the industry was not responsive. Now we think that they will take this more seriously, and employers, self-insured employers in particular, are ready to put this data to work. We were out of the gate. We said now that we have this information, we need to use it because self-insured employers, like the employees they're representing, have every incentive for affordable, high-quality care. Unfortunately, it is very hard to find when you cannot get that data. Once we had the data, five of our members, five of our PBGH members, ran it. And one example, one of our members up in the Puget Sound area thought that they were getting the absolute best deal. They were told that by their plan and their consultant. Turned out they were paying 30% more for one facility. They were then able to use that information to negotiate lower rates on behalf of their employees. Another public member of ours, City and County of Denver, learned in the data they were paying twice as much for emergency care in one facility than the others. No difference in outcomes. Once they had that information, they could change their contracts. They could change where their employees were getting the right care. Those are two examples of many. This data is eminently usable. More and more of our members are seeking to use it to evaluate their health plans. Are they getting the best deal? Is it the right partner? Where should they send their employees? We learned that one of the most expensive hospitals in California actually had the lowest quality scores. That makes a huge difference not just for the employer but for employees where they are getting the right care. So this data arms them to go and be effective advocates on behalf of their employees and their families and also to reduce costs. Affordability in the commercial market is at a crisis level. This will give self-insured employers the information they need to reduce costs on behalf of American workers.
Thank you for that powerful message and showing us how the promise of this rule is so profound. Let's move to Chris. You are a large benefit leader at a large company. You've shown that lowering costs for workers is possible at scale. I'm told that in 2026 you cut the cost of the basic health plan to $5 a week with $5 co-pays. You can't even get a $5 footlong anymore at Subway. Tell us how you did this and how it relates to TEF data.
100%. Amazon Health Benefits is striving every day to deliver the most trusted and effective health benefits on Earth. And a huge part of that is working backwards from customers every day. For us, our customers are employees and their families. And so the $5 plan, which is $5 per week contribution, $5 co-pay to see mental health, primary care, other office visits, we call it now the essential plan. That was working backwards from our employees saying, "Hey, if someone is thinking about this the way a consumer thinks about anything, it's how much do I pay? How much does it cost to see the doctor? How do I have health care that's accessible for me?" And so we did do the $5 health plan that you're mentioning. Amazon offers day-one health benefits for all regular full and reduced-time employees. We have a whole bunch of clinically excellent, evidence-based programs that we've launched to make sure that the most important priority conditions, mental health treatment, virtual doula support for people who are pregnant, any kind of need you have, we're trying to make it as accessible as possible. And a foundation of that is being able to get after cost and quality information. And so we try to marshal all available data resources to make sure we deliver health care that is safe, timely, effective, efficient, accessible, and patient-centered. And so where the transparency data fits in is it allows us to say what is going to be the financially sustainable version of this. How do we appreciate what the costs actually are, make apples-to-apples comparisons, make effective comparisons both at sourcing, but also on an ongoing basis. And so it's being relentlessly focused on our customers and their families, relentlessly focused on doing the right thing for our people every day, and then having the backup and the background of things like TEF files, transparency, and quality data to make sure we do that in a financially sustainable and customer-centric way over the long term.
Thank you for sharing your experience. So Chris, we're going to end with you, and I told everyone to think of this rule: to much is given, much is expected. As a leading fiduciary thought leader and someone that fought in her job to take on the system and a large insurance company, tell us how plan fiduciaries can now exercise their responsibilities to act in the best interest of their plan members and beneficiaries.
Thank you. So I think, you know, first to set the stage, what does it mean to be a health plan fiduciary acting in the sole and exclusive interest of the plan and plan participants, acting prudently, paying only reasonable expenses, following plan documents, and finally having a prudent process to select and monitor service providers. With the TEF data, right, what we are able to do is really move from buying a network as a product to looking behind the network and seeing the prices, you know, in that product. I think self-funded employers for a long time have been buying services based on network size, network disruption, network discounts, right, and admin costs because they haven't been able to look behind that. But with this TEF data, you can actually see the prices within that network, and we can stop thinking about the network as the product and actually think about what we're buying, right? We are buying health care services for our members and their families. The network is really just a mechanism through which we access those providers and that service. And it is important, obviously, because they're who sets the price. So what we're able to do now with this TEF data from a fiduciary perspective is move beyond size, you know, size of the network and this elusive discount, right, to actually see what would my health plan spend have been last year with network A, right? Is that $30 million? Had I been with network B, I could see perhaps that's $25 million. Now without the TEF data, the network size might be comparable, the discounts might be comparable, and the admin fees might actually push me towards the more expensive net cost. But today we can get behind that and we can look at the prices and we can again select in a prudent manner. We can monitor in a prudent manner. And we can actually, with this TEF data and this enriched amount of information, we can begin to execute on the promise of what it means to be a fiduciary.
And you have to do it. Thank you, Chris. Now, we've heard from a large employer, and they have more resources. Help us for those that are smaller employers: how can they meet their fiduciary obligations as well?
Great. I love this question because I think, you know, so much of the focus has been on large employers that have the resources to crunch the numbers and hire the actuaries and the economists and data analysts. But I think the promise of transparency data and this increasing availability of it is really most valuable to the smaller employer market. You know, they might not be able to use their own claims data, right, to look at network price, but that absolutely doesn't mean that they can't, you know, in their own geographic region, look at network prices for a basket of services: labor and delivery, musculoskeletal, imaging, and say, you know, what are these prices for this network? And they can actually compare networks and evaluate and monitor that process and document the process. But I think the biggest fundamental shift, especially again in the small employer community, is a shift in power dynamics. Today, small employers have a dependency on consultants and brokers and third-party vendors to be their source of truth for everything and make recommendations. In the future, when we have access to more of this transparency data, today when we have more access, that power dynamic begins to shift, and the small employers of the world begin to act not from a dependency relationship on other third parties but actually an informed oversight relationship. Right? They can do evaluations themselves. They can ask smarter questions. They can ask better questions, and they can begin to fulfill those fiduciary duties that they need to execute upon.
Thank you, Chris. I'm going to let you take a break. We're going to close with a lightning round. Starting with you, James. In 30 seconds each, what is the one thing every employer should do with TEF data? Now.
I would recommend demanding complete and total transparency from all of your vendors. And if they don't comply, then tell them what the president would say: You're fired.
It's going to be hard to beat that, Chris. But you are now up.
As the saying goes, reality remains undefeated. And so all of this is such good news for employers, for their plan members, that they will be able to understand the more valid and reliable version of their cost and quality data. And so I encourage every employer: go beyond using that to negotiate excellent agreements in procurement and bring it to the customer experience. Find a way that it's not just valuable to you in procuring health benefits, but becomes a vector for people to feel that their benefits are better and easier to use, that they have better and easier access to their health care services that you're buying on their behalf.
Thank you, Chris. Elizabeth.
Well, we're going to be scaling our project with the Peterson Foundation. We are making it available to more employers. The more employers that use this data, the more pressure to bring prices down. So we think that's going to make a huge difference. And we will include small and midsize employers. That power change that you're talking about, I think, has a lot to do with why it's so hard to get the data. You making it available will enable us to create a market.
Thank you, Elizabeth. And Chris, finish us off.
Yeah, I would say use the data to validate and audit, right? So validate what is coming out of your bank account for a claim and match it to that network price that is being published. You know, is the network price that is being published of $30,000, is that actually what you paid for that claim? And if it's not, right, if there is a variance or an exception, you absolutely, I'm not saying it's necessarily paid erroneously or wrongly, but it is cause to investigate and look at that exception, understand those variances, and that variance itself can begin to become a component of your evaluation of your network and vendors.
Well, thank you to all four of you. I think you gave practical guidance on how this is going to execute lower prices for all Americans. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Assistant Secretary Aronowitz, and to our panelists. My name is Caitlyn Sodto, and I'm a senior policy adviser at the Employee Benefits Security Administration at the Department of Labor. Labor is proud to partner with HHS and Treasury today to advance meaningful health care price transparency, which is helping employers deliver more affordable health care to the American worker. That's what drives our work at EBSA every single day. But transparency isn't just about employers. It's also about the patients and families that are on the other side of each and every health care claim. So with that, I'm proud to introduce our second panel, Leveraging Data to Make Health Care More Affordable for the American Patient, moderated by our own Jack Collarong with CMS. Jack.
We were joking on the way up here who would be stuck with the yellow microphone. And so Dr. Michael over here is our contestant for today. Thank you for the introduction, Caitlyn, and thank you everyone for your time and attention today. Like Caitlyn mentioned, my name is Jack Colin, and I'm joined on stage by the industry's leading price transparency innovators. And in a moment, they're going to help us understand how millions of Americans are already benefiting from price transparency through innovative products and services. But before I do, I want to address any remaining skeptics in the room. If anyone out there thinks that this data isn't practical, then this panel is for you. I want everyone to walk away excited about the future that price transparency unlocks for every single American. And I'm relying on my panelists to help convince you all that that's the case. So now that the pressure is on, panelists, are you ready? All right. Ready? Ready.
Let's do it. All right. So this question is for the whole panel. If you could please introduce yourself and your company and tell us why the work your company is doing should get people excited about the future of a transparent health care system. So Michael, why don't you start us off?
Thanks, Jack. Michael Mogan, senior medical director at Garner Health. I want to tell you a little bit about Garner Health. We're a health data analytics company. We offer a provider and an employer solution to help decrease health care costs. So we do this by navigating an employer's employees to the best doctors, the highest quality and the least expensive doctors. And how do we identify the best doctors? First, we have 600, actually over 600 clinical quality metrics. This is measuring things like does a primary care doctor keep his heart failure patients out of the hospital, and what's a spine surgeon's complication rate after spinal fusion.
We layer on the transparency data, facility negotiated rates and professional negotiated rates and site of service data. Is a gastroenterologist doing endoscopy in an ambulatory surgical center or a hospital outpatient facility? We run these metrics through our massive claims data set and layer on this transparency data to identify the top quarter of doctors by quality and cost. If employees go to see a top doctor, they have no out-of-pocket expenses. That's the incentive to them. We take on risk in these relationships with employers. If we don't save them money, we lose our fees. We put our money where our mouth is. We're one of the fastest growing startups in the country. We have 800 employers with 1.5 million employees. And the transparency data really allows us to drive employees to the best doctors, highest quality, and lowest cost.