CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Matthew Prince gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Matthew Prince
Co-Founder, Co-Chairman & CEO, Cloudflare

Barret is Zo Back, Copper is Metal, Branded Workout Equipment, The BTA Battle, Meta VR Layoffs

📅 Jan 15, 2026 TBPN 191 MIN 3669 VIEWS 872 SEGMENTS · 10 SPEAKERS
Sign up for TBPN’s daily newsletter at TBPN.com 00:06:06 Big Tech Turns to Mining 00:16:45 𝕏 Timeline Reactions 00:26:20 Thinking Machines Loses Top Executives 00:34:00 NYC Sauna Wars 00:43:22 Meta VR Layoffs 01:01:48 Chirantan “CJ” Desai discusses MongoDB’s evolution to support AI-driven applications, its growth to 60,000+ customers, strategic acquisitions to enhance AI capabilities, and confidence in cloud providers meeting future compute demand. 01:12:31 Matthew Prince discusses Italy’s €14M fine against Cloudflare, criticizes rapid takedown mandates as overreaching, and warns about...

Questions asked in this interview

8
  1. 1:12:20Happy New Year. How are you doing?
  2. 1:12:42How did everything lead up to your post which went mega viral?
  3. 1:19:54What has been pulled? How are the discussions going?
  4. 1:21:32How's the rest of the ecosystem reacting to all this?
  5. 1:22:54Did you just pay it or are you debating it?
  6. 1:24:24What are you seeing in AI adoption? What are you feeling internally?
  7. 1:28:55How has it evolved, and then what's the reaction from your customer base been to those defaults?
  8. 1:36:47Like at what point do you just buy the whole thing?
John Coogan 4:36 ↗
You're watching TBPN. Today is Thursday, January 15th, 2026. We are live from the TBPN Ultradome, the Temple of Technology, the fortress of finance, the capital of capital. Jordi has a new set of animations. The soundboard is growing in complexity every day. There's a horse that walks all the way across the screen. And yes, guests can see that when they are calling in to...
Jordi Hays 5:03 ↗
To be clear, to be clear, if we flashbang a guest, their entire screen is going white. Yes. Along with yours, along with ours. We're all in it together.
John Coogan 5:11 ↗
Yes. But it's somebody's birthday. It's Bobby. Bobby's birthday.
Jordi Hays 5:16 ↗
Oh, happy birthday. Happy birthday.
John Coogan 5:18 ↗
Anyone who's thinking about getting a gift for Bobby, get him RAM.
Jordi Hays 5:22 ↗
Get him RAM. I want every single person.
John Coogan 5:25 ↗
Time is money. Save both. Easy use, corporate cards, bill pay, accounting, and a whole lot more all in one place. A little hot on the soundboard today, but that's great. Um, but we're feeling good.
Jordi Hays 5:36 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 5:37 ↗
Uh, we have a massive lineup. Uh, we have six CEOs joining the stream today. Hey, we have MongoDB, Cloudflare, Varda, Skeldham Industries, and Brinc Drones. We're going to talk about the DJI ban on drones. Uh, we got to add Matthew, uh, we got to add Blake Resnick to the lineup today. Linear, of course, meets the system from modern software development. Linear is a purpose-built tool for planning and building products. Um, so, uh, in the news today, Tesla is sharing that they made a ton of progress on their lithium refinery. And then simultaneously, AWS did a deal with Rio Tinto to buy a bunch of copper, not that much copper. We'll get into how much, but uh, they're sort of underwriting a new chemical process for refining copper. Uh, and it's also sort of interesting that uh, you know, Marc Andreessen published the 'software is eating the world' story back in 2011. And I think even the folks in tech who took that seriously were saying, 'Oh, yeah, of course.' Well, that just means that...
Jordi Hays 6:42 ↗
I didn't take it seriously. I took it literally.
John Coogan 6:44 ↗
You took it literally. Yeah.
But the people that took it seriously were thinking, 'Okay, well, you know, you're going past just the first wave of the internet, the newspapers on websites, that type of stuff.' And yes, we're going to get the Ubers. We're going to get uh, you know, more and more tech companies that are consumer-facing or business-facing, and you might see some transformation in legal services, financial services, uh, logistics, uh, airlines will be using apps to let you book. But we're now in the era where the tech companies are starting to vertically integrate so deep that they own the mines and they own the refineries. And it's not just that they're actually building uh, software for the mining...
Jordi Hays 7:29 ↗
Technology eating the world.
John Coogan 7:30 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And it's a new layer of uh, of vertical integration that sort of just crept up on me because it wasn't an issue until the AI boom really necessitated massive industrial scale buildouts, new industrial policy which admittedly can't turn on a dime. But we're now two, three years into the ChatGPT boom, into the AI boom. The data center buildouts are getting bigger. We're seeing bottlenecks all over the place, whether it's chip shortages or energy shortages. And so, you know, companies like Tesla, AWS, a lot of other folks are really looking deep into the supply chain all the way into the ground, into literally eating the world. Uh, because I see mining as sort of terraforming. I see it in some ways as literally eating the world, like you said. Uh, before we move on, let me tell you about Gusto, the unified platform for payroll, benefits, and HR built to evolve with modern small and medium-sized businesses. So, um, Amazon's buying the first new copper produced in America in over a decade. It's a very exciting project, and Tesla now has a Texas facility that can convert raw ore directly into battery-grade lithium hydroxide. It's a more efficient process. We can get into that. Uh, Tesla originally broke ground on this uh, lithium refinery operation in May of 2023. It feels like they were sort of quiet about it, but now they're getting a lot louder. Obviously, the narrative around China controlling 90% of uh, rare earth extraction and rare earth elements has been in the news, and this is sort of their response. Um...
Jordi Hays 9:08 ↗
That shot with the Cybertruck driving by...
John Coogan 9:10 ↗
It's good. It's good. There's a voiceover. We should watch that video um, in a little bit more detail. Can we pull it up with some audio when we have a second? So, this facility, this refinery, is the first spodumene to lithium hydroxide refinery in North America. We're deploying a new technology platform that is inherently uh, much more environmentally friendly and cleaner. It's a simpler process. It's not that big of a facility. And this should be able to create enough lithium for 500,000 vehicles a year, EVs a year, maybe a million a year, I've heard. Now Tesla's shipping 1.65 million. So this won't be 100%, but you copy-paste this two, three times and you got uh, enough coverage for the entire Tesla fleet.
Tesla Video Narrator 9:54 ↗
Take it through a kiln and cooler. From there we take it through an alkaline leach and additional purification steps, take it into crystallization and produce battery-grade lithium hydroxide. Our process is more sustainable than traditional methods and eliminates hazardous byproducts and instead produces a co-product named anhydrite used in concrete mixes.
From breaking ground in 2023 to running rot through the kiln in 2024 to start a full integrated plant startup.
Jordi Hays 10:24 ↗
He looks so tired. He's just like, 'Yeah, it's been great working for Elon.' Hi. Hi. Uh, I love it. I...
Tesla Video Speaker 10:31 ↗
Yeah, it's been relatively relaxed here at the site. The uh, you know, we sleep in the factory. In this case it's just dirt, but sleeping in the dirt, surprisingly comfortable.
Tesla Video Narrator 10:41 ↗
Construction timeline.
Tesla Video Speaker 10:43 ↗
This refinery really enables us to have access to the critical minerals for energy storage, for battery manufacturing, and ultimately for growth.
And it enables us to accelerate Tesla's mission by regionalizing supply chains for battery minerals and materials, by providing jobs, by cutting emissions from the transportation network that's required for those supply chains. It really allows us to usher in energy independence for North America.
John Coogan 11:07 ↗
Who would have thought that Texas would be the home of EV domination.
Jordi Hays 11:13 ↗
I know. Narrative violation.
John Coogan 11:15 ↗
California really dropped the ball. Um, so, uh, Tesla shipping 1.65 million. That was a little lower than the previous year. I think they were up at 1.7 million, but you get a couple of those facilities and it should be enough to cover uh, everything that they need. Um, there's also been a whole bunch of news around uh, rare earth minerals generally. Last year a company called Iconic or Ionic Mineral Technologies made a large discovery of 16 different types of minerals in Utah late last year. This was in December. Um...
Jordi Hays 11:47 ↗
As we do.
John Coogan 11:48 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It has been funny. There have been rumors about this, but uh, they found a huge deposit of all these different uh, minerals. Um, obviously everyone's worried about China controlling 90% of the supply of rare earths, but uh, we need to actually get these minerals out of the ground, refine them, and so that's where projects like that come into play. Uh, Amazon's partnership with Rio Tinto is a little bit different. They're not fully vertically integrated like Tesla is. Uh, but they are partnering with Rio Tinto. Um, and uh, Rio Tinto had been working on a new method of refining low-grade copper deposits. So basically, like, there's a fair amount of copper in the ground, but there's a lot of dirt, a lot of other stuff that you have to process out that can be very expensive. But because of the data center expansion exploding, the price of copper has I think nearly doubled in the past two years. And so uh, copper is not the main ingredient to an AI data center, a token factory, but it is important uh, because the biggest data centers use tens of thousands of metric tons of copper to move electricity around. So you need wires. There's copper in circuit boards. There's copper in the transformers that move electricity around. And there's tons of miscellaneous electrical components all over a data center that need copper. Uh, so this particular AWS Rio Tinto deal is only 1,400 metric tons over four years. I don't even think that's enough for a single AWS data center. Um, but it's allowing Rio Tinto to underwrite this sort of risky new process methodology that if it works and they get the price down on this new process, then they can apply that to tons more copper reserves that's locked up in, you know, messy ore that otherwise would be uneconomical to refine. So uh, 70% of the global supply of copper uh, is currently locked away in ore that's not economical to refine into actual copper right now. So if this new process technology works, you effectively triple the amount of copper. You triple the supply, and so price should fall. It's doubled. You triple the supply, maybe price comes down. Uh, good news for anyone who's in the copper market uh, trying to acquire a...
Jordi Hays 14:06 ↗
Rio Tinto. Some quick backstories. One of the world's oldest uh, largest and oldest mining corporations with a history that spans over 150 years. Uh, the name uh, was uh, inspired by the Rio Tinto in southwestern Spain.
Uh, but uh, the founding again goes back to the mid-19th century. Spanish government was facing financial crisis and they started selling off their older mines. Um, and so crazy story of just like a very old company, you know, continuing to be a key player in an entirely new tech trend.
John Coogan 14:43 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. Rio Tinto's been in the news a ton also for lithium-ion. They do some stuff there. They had one uh, investment that I think they wrote down, then they spun another one up. They've been uh, back and forth. Uh, let's uh, tell you about Fin.ai, the number one AI agent for customer service. If you want AI to handle your customer support, go to fin.ai. So, uh, X-Freeze broke the Texas lithium refinery down a little bit more. It's the first in North America to convert the raw ore into battery-grade lithium hydroxide, skipping intermediate steps. In the long term, probably more economical. It went from groundbreaking to first production in just 19 months, an unheard-of timeline at this scale. The process is cleaner, no hazardous waste, a useful byproduct that can be turned into concrete. Uh, the single refinery can supply lithium for over 500,000 EVs per year and directly challenges China's 60% grip on global lithium refining. Uh, Elon chimed in and said it sounded like... I saw another number that was maybe closer to a million. But either way, you do two or three of these and you're good for Tesla's supply chain. At least maybe they sell it to other folks as well. Uh, and what comes out of this will actually be sent to another company and then back to Tesla. But they are vertically integrating. Um, uh, Chamath Palihapitiya called it, he predicted this. He says, 'As we predicted in our annual predictions episode at the start of the year, unless someone shows up with superconductivity or carbon nanotubes, copper is the only game in town and AI is a huge demand driver for a very underresourced material.' So, he's taking a victory lap with his thesis on copper. Uh, pretty good call. Pretty cool uh, that he has this clip here. Um, so in other news, let's tell you about Graphite.dev, code review for the age of AI. Graphite helps teams on GitHub ship higher quality software faster. And speaking of AI, there is turmoil in the trade wars, in the talent wars in...
Jordi Hays 16:41 ↗
Barrett is back.
John Coogan 16:43 ↗
Barrett is back. Barrett is back.
Uh, so uh, this is from Kylie Robinson over at Core Memory. She says, 'Breaking.' Can we just give it up for Kylie for a second? Potential scoop athlete of the year.
Jordi Hays 16:56 ↗
Huge.
John Coogan 16:56 ↗
Putting up some crazy scoops. Crazy scoop.
Jordi Hays 16:58 ↗
She had the Anthropic xAI drama last week.
John Coogan 17:03 ↗
She's on an absolute tear.
Jordi Hays 17:05 ↗
Absolutely.
John Coogan 17:05 ↗
She's on an absolute tear.
Yes. Uh, so she says breaking: Thinking Machines has terminated its CTO Barrett Zoph due to unethical conduct. According to two sources familiar with the matter, CEO Mira Murati announced the news at an all-hands with employees today. Sumanth Chentala will be taking over as CTO, and Mira posted as well confirming the news. She said, 'We have parted ways with Barrett. Uh, Sum will be taking the new CTO of Thinking Machines role. Uh, he is a brilliant and seasoned leader who has made important contributions to the AI field for over a decade and he has been a major contributor to our team. We could not be more excited to have him take on this new responsibility.'
Jordi Hays 17:48 ↗
And uh, Alex Heath actually has some new news, broke 30 minutes ago. He says more Thinking Machines employees are in the process of joining OpenAI.
John Coogan 17:58 ↗
After three of the startup's co-founders rejoined yesterday. Of course, the Thinking Machines co-founders had previously been at OpenAI. Uh, but anyways, somewhat of a uh, not great. Not great. Um, I think uh, potentially more controversial news was that Thinking Machines has branded uh, squat racks at the office. Yes. Ryan Peterson posted a photo. A lot of people uh, a lot of people took this as somewhat of a red flag, right? People say, you know, the sort of common guidance is don't make merch until you're generating some real revenue, right? And so if you take that further, it's like maybe you shouldn't have...
Jordi Hays 18:39 ↗
What was Ryan doing to get this photo? It seems like...
John Coogan 18:42 ↗
I think he just walked by.
Jordi Hays 18:43 ↗
He's going journalist mode here. You see this? He's like, he's not in...
John Coogan 18:48 ↗
If you zoom in, you can see these things look fantastic. So...
Jordi Hays 18:50 ↗
Well, Ryan, you're outside. You're outside the Thinking Machines branded gym.
John Coogan 18:56 ↗
Yeah. I'm somewhat uh, I'm somewhat envious. Uh, these things look fantastic. I'm kind of mad that we didn't get the branded uh, plates. Uh, but this coming out while losing, you know, half of your family...
Jordi Hays 19:12 ↗
It has to be weird. I mean, how much have they raised? It was two billion at 12 billion, something like that. I mean, it's got to be so weird to start a company and on day one have enough money for a custom gym. That's just like unheard of. Like, you know, like normally you start your company in the garage and maybe there's a weight in the corner you can lift or a kettlebell...
John Coogan 19:33 ↗
One dumbbell.
Jordi Hays 19:34 ↗
Yeah, one kettlebell or something, but to just come in and say, yes, we're taking Class A office on day one, uh, hiring a massive team, uh, bringing on six or seven co-founders...
John Coogan 19:46 ↗
And Atlas was saying uh, like the other red flag is where are the 45s? I think I'm going to assume they're just not in sight. You know, like you can't see them, right? They would be mounted lower.
Jordi Hays 19:59 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 20:00 ↗
Right on the rack. Uh, but uh...
Jordi Hays 20:03 ↗
Alex, never change. Oh...
John Coogan 20:08 ↗
But uh...
Jordi Hays 20:09 ↗
So funny.
John Coogan 20:09 ↗
But yeah, so...
Jordi Hays 20:11 ↗
So rude.
John Coogan 20:12 ↗
But in case you forgot, Andrew Tulloch left Thinking Machines in uh...
Jordi Hays 20:19 ↗
Q4 of last year. Yeah. Zuck had been trying to poach him. Yeah. And offered uh, increasing amounts of money until uh, and Andrew, I...
John Coogan 20:30 ↗
The sense is that Andrew was like, you know, I can't be bought.
Jordi Hays 20:34 ↗
But he needed the money.
John Coogan 20:36 ↗
He needed, he had a shopping cart filled with Chrome Hearts Supreme. And he was like, 'Wow, like my next outfit's going to run me 500 mil. I gotta get a new job. I can't afford it. I can't afford my lifestyle.' Maybe it was a case of lifestyle inflation. They talk about that, you know. He's just like, 'Okay, I got a new SP3 Daytona now. I got the Valkyrie and like...
Jordi Hays 21:02 ↗
And they gave me 80 allocation.
John Coogan 21:05 ↗
I need some cash. I gotta get a new job. It's just not covering the bills over here.'
Jordi Hays 21:12 ↗
Tyler, do you remember the final amount that Meta paid? It was like uh, because I always appreciate a lot of rumors. Like in my head it was like Andrew was like, yeah, like I'm really honored that you would make such a big offer, Zuck, a billion dollars, but like unfortunately like...
John Coogan 21:28 ↗
I'm very mission aligned, you know, I'm mission driven. Uh, there's really no price that I would take to leave the company that I started.
Jordi Hays 21:36 ↗
And Zuck's like...
John Coogan 21:37 ↗
Two billion.
Jordi Hays 21:39 ↗
Well, so I...
I think all the rumors were actually from the summer when there was like all of the talent wars going on. Um, so first there was I think it was just one billion, and then there were rumors of three and a half.
John Coogan 21:51 ↗
Wow.
Jordi Hays 21:52 ↗
And that being turned down.
John Coogan 21:53 ↗
That's a lot.
Jordi Hays 21:54 ↗
Uh, but then later in the year, then he eventually...
John Coogan 21:56 ↗
Okay. So people kind of assume that the rumor is true because uh, because he eventually made the move.
Jordi Hays 22:02 ↗
Yeah. But I mean it's not necessarily higher than three and a half, right? Because now we're seeing more people leave. Like why are they leaving?
John Coogan 22:08 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Jordi Hays 22:08 ↗
You know. So...
John Coogan 22:10 ↗
It's, I mean it's very unclear, right? Yeah, I think the actual estimate was like something like uh, the Journal had reported one and a half billion over six years.
Jordi Hays 22:19 ↗
I mean there is just some risk to starting a company with six co-founders. Like that's just unorthodox.
John Coogan 22:26 ↗
Unorthodox. So some amount of churn.
Jordi Hays 22:29 ↗
And they still got John Schulman, right? Who's an absolute legend, co-founder of OpenAI.
John Coogan 22:33 ↗
Yeah. Like everyone who's still there or everyone who was there, like they're all goated and it's like super hard to... one of my buddies, he's like super smart. He was trying to get a job there. It's like insanely hard. You have to be actual goat to work there.
Jordi Hays 22:43 ↗
Okay.
John Coogan 22:44 ↗
So, but you know, now they're leaving.
Jordi Hays 22:46 ↗
It's a bit of a goat panting.
John Coogan 22:47 ↗
Yeah.
Jordi Hays 22:49 ↗
Goat farm.
John Coogan 22:50 ↗
Yeah. I mean, Dylan Patel was really excited about this. He said, 'Uh, can I invest in Mira's company?' Goddamn. Two more goats going there back in February 6th of 2025. So, a little under a year ago. Uh, there everyone's saying Schulman, but the other is just as arguable, just as if not more goat. And David Hoels says, 'I'm calling it Murati Heavy Industries.' Uh, and...
Jordi Hays 23:15 ↗
Yeah, I mean, at one point, um, one of my buddies who works at a big lab, he was saying at that time, Thinking Machines has like the best team.
John Coogan 23:23 ↗
Yeah.
Jordi Hays 23:24 ↗
Like any of the big labs.
John Coogan 23:25 ↗
Yeah. So, how would you describe what they do? Because uh, we've heard a number of different uh, you know, pitches from them, products from them, and some of them seem like...
Jordi Hays 23:36 ↗
I, you know, this could easily make a couple billion dollars a year. Uh, yes. So uh, they've shipped a bunch of blog posts, but they also I think their only like real product so far has been Tinker.
John Coogan 23:45 ↗
Um, which was basically...
Jordi Hays 23:48 ↗
An API for fine-tuning. It made it very easy. I think it was a super good product. People who've used it like really like it.
John Coogan 23:53 ↗
Yeah. So I mean the general focus has been enterprise and...
Jordi Hays 23:57 ↗
ChatGPT. Uh, everyone at OpenAI has been very obvious like this is the year.
John Coogan 24:02 ↗
Uh, this is the year they're focused on.
Jordi Hays 24:05 ↗
This year. I think the idea was um, like RL environments for specific like businesses.
John Coogan 24:10 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. So you get a really great fine-tune. I know obviously OpenAI has a similar business line that probably competes directly, but you know being a pure-play can work out. We've seen what Anthropic's done. It didn't seem like a crazy crazy strategy.
Jordi Hays 24:23 ↗
Yeah. I mean John Schulman is like one of the OG like main RL guys. The team is like perfectly suited for this.
John Coogan 24:29 ↗
Yeah. So I don't know, maybe smaller team, more focused, um, more, you know, a couple big deals, they start finding their footing. Uh, how AGI-pilled is uh, Thinking Machines? Were they on our chart?
Jordi Hays 24:45 ↗
I don't think they were, right? Um...
John Coogan 24:47 ↗
SSI was on the chart of needs AGI, is AGI-pilled. I don't think Thinking Machines made the chart. I don't know.
Jordi Hays 24:55 ↗
How AGI-pilled is Thinking Machines based on what we... Oh.
John Coogan 25:00 ↗
Yeah. I mean it's hard to say because it's like, okay, compared to like the average person they're obviously way more AGI-pilled, but the idea of like doing, you're doing RL for business, like...
Jordi Hays 25:08 ↗
AGI, it's like G is general. Yeah.
John Coogan 25:10 ↗
So if you're just like focusing on specific like business use cases...
Jordi Hays 25:14 ↗
That's not very general, right? You can imagine um, someone is just like building the massive model, they're just going to everything. That's much more like AGI-pilled.
John Coogan 25:22 ↗
Is anyone doing AI, artificial business intelligence? I think that's what we...
Jordi Hays 25:28 ↗
Yeah. ACI, artificial corporate intelligence. AVI, artificial voice intelligence. ElevenLabs, build intelligent real-time conversational agents. Reimagine human-technology interaction with ElevenLabs.
John Coogan 25:43 ↗
I think the question is there was already an immense amount of pressure and like really really high expectations on Thinking Machines around what they put out first, right? I don't think these people leaving, maybe it makes it harder to deliver on those expectations, but the expectations are still...
Jordi Hays 25:59 ↗
Sky-high. Uh, it did feel like uh, kind of rough messaging, uh, very very rough messaging, right? Unclear coming out, uh, pushing this like unethical conduct angle. Uh, people at OpenAI have obviously their bias, but they've denied it. Uh, Susan Jang, uh, who's at DeepMind said, 'Feels like the type of character assassination leak you put out when you find out one of your co-founders might be splitting off.'
John Coogan 26:31 ↗
Uh, and Rune says 100% snaky PR move.
Jordi Hays 26:36 ↗
Uh, so...
John Coogan 26:38 ↗
Signal says there's more drama in AI than the Real Housewives.
Jordi Hays 26:41 ↗
Uh, that's in the uh, in the Wired article. Um, the quote is a source close to Thinking Machines alleged that Zoph uh, had shared confidential company information with competitors.
John Coogan 26:50 ↗
So there's like that and then there's the like...
Jordi Hays 26:52 ↗
Yeah. And like to me that's just like, okay, it sounds like he had been like in conversations with OpenAI.
John Coogan 27:00 ↗
He could have just been complaining about the lack of 45-pound weights and that is technically confidential.
Jordi Hays 27:04 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 27:05 ↗
He shares it with somebody else. They overhear it at a coffee shop and they're like, you shared confidential information.
Jordi Hays 27:11 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, but that type of allegation is like, you guys talked about AI, that...
John Coogan 27:16 ↗
You shared confidential information.
Jordi Hays 27:18 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 27:18 ↗
So anyways, uh...
Jordi Hays 27:21 ↗
Well, the scoop will continue.
John Coogan 27:23 ↗
It is playing out. I'm sure we'll get more.
Jordi Hays 27:25 ↗
Uh, what did Fleeting Bits say? Fleeting Bits said some quick thoughts on Barrett Zoph and Mira and Schulman. Uh, going back to OpenAI, Barrett was the vice president of post-training at OpenAI before he left for Thinking Machines. He left OpenAI in September of 2024. Barrett would have probably initially had options for about 10 to 30% of Thinking Machines. That's insane. They had six co-founders. How could that be so high? Uh, post-training was one of the more valuable skills at launch, I suppose. Okay. Uh, the seed round was two billion at 12 billion. So this would mean that he would have options now for around 8 to 25% of the current company. This seems all hypothetical here. Uh, there were rumors back in November that Thinking Machines was in talks to raise at 50 to 60 billion. So this puts his equity at four billion to 15 billion valuation. Uh, Thinking Machines could probably exit somewhere between 30 and 60 today. Who has that money? I don't know. Maybe Nvidia buys them or something. Um, at least at some point over the next two years. I think the most likely acquirers would probably be Microsoft, Apple, Meta, Amazon, and Nvidia. Okay. Large-cap company that wants to build a frontier model. Barrett would have been just over his one-year cliff. So assuming he was not fired for cause or Thinking Machines doesn't want to litigate, he still has about one to...
John Coogan 28:42 ↗
Okay, that part's incorrect. How does that math work?
Jordi Hays 28:44 ↗
I don't know.
John Coogan 28:45 ↗
Uh, one quarter of...
Jordi Hays 28:46 ↗
25% vested.
John Coogan 28:48 ↗
Yeah. So one quarter of the equity at a... So this person's assuming that he got 10 to 30% of the company and that the value of the company currently is...
Jordi Hays 28:59 ↗
60.
John Coogan 29:01 ↗
A year. Over a year, and so you're looking at a billion dollars of equity. Uh, would be interesting to know how his OpenAI pay package... The rumor is that OpenAI set aside about 50 billion for the equity pool for the new PBC so they can afford a decent pay package for him. My guess is that it was a personality dispute or disagreement over the commercial direction of the company with Mira, the executive team. And if there is something behind the unethical conduct claim, it could just be a game of telephone over him talking to the other labs and Mira interpreting it as him disclosing trade secrets. Huh, interesting. Well, let me tell you about AppLovin, profitable advertising made easy with Axon.ai. Get access to over one billion daily active users and grow your business today. Uh, it's called Thinking Machine now because there's only one left. No, there are three left. So, it's still plural. Rahul, but that's a funny post. Nevertheless...
Jordi Hays 29:55 ↗
Uh, yeah, I...
John Coogan 30:00 ↗
Reading into this, I mean, uh, there's got to be some real excitement on that, you know, OpenAI has just been outflows, outflows, outflows...
Jordi Hays 30:09 ↗
Getting some of these superstars back. Yeah.
John Coogan 30:11 ↗
On board has got to be good for them.
Jordi Hays 30:13 ↗
So, is this what the elves and Valinor... Do we know what Rune is posting about? Because we learned that Rune posts the elves have left for Valinor every two years apparently.
John Coogan 30:24 ↗
Okay. Well, he posted it once before. Yeah. In um, in 2024 about, I think what was it, January 22nd.
Jordi Hays 30:30 ↗
Yes.
John Coogan 30:31 ↗
So yeah. So now um, he posted this like uh, on the 12th, so three days ago. Um...
Jordi Hays 30:38 ↗
I think most people have now taken it to mean to be about this, right? Uh, people leaving Thinking Machines going back to OpenAI. Um, but I think there's a couple ways you can look at it, right? So, if you look at it in the context of the last time he said this, it was the exact same quote, the elves had left for Valinor. Um...
John Coogan 30:56 ↗
Like, okay, what is Valinor in Lord of the Rings, right? Valinor is where elves go. Um, so they don't like diminish or like they don't like kind of fade away.
Jordi Hays 31:04 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 31:05 ↗
Um...
Jordi Hays 31:06 ↗
So it's okay, what does that mean? Like maybe it's you're just basically securing like massive wealth, right?
John Coogan 31:11 ↗
Yes. You're not going to be diminished by inflation or something slowly, you know, dying.
Jordi Hays 31:17 ↗
Or the other way to read that is like you go to one of these newer labs and you could be a superstar, but your abilities could fade away with time, right? Because you just don't have the scale or the resources. Yes.
John Coogan 31:30 ↗
Yeah. But so I think in the 2024 context...
Jordi Hays 31:34 ↗
Uh, Valinor actually was the new labs, right? Because you can basically go start a company, be the co-founder, you guys raise at 12 billion.
John Coogan 31:42 ↗
You're just like, let's go. Like, yeah, I just secured an insane amount, like massive bag.
Jordi Hays 31:47 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 31:48 ↗
But then now...
Jordi Hays 31:49 ↗
Now OpenAI, now Valinor, right? They're setting aside 50 billion just for pay packages.
John Coogan 31:55 ↗
Sure. Sure. Sure.
Jordi Hays 31:55 ↗
If you go back, I mean, you're doing pretty well.
John Coogan 31:57 ↗
Another battle.
Jordi Hays 31:58 ↗
It's pretty safe, right? You don't have this startup, you know, you're not sure if it's going to work or not. Um, so it's kind of a circular thing going on. Yeah.
John Coogan 32:07 ↗
There's other ways you can even read the most recent one, right? There's like the billionaires leaving California.
Jordi Hays 32:12 ↗
Maybe Texas, Miami, that's Valinor.
John Coogan 32:15 ↗
Yeah.
Jordi Hays 32:16 ↗
Um, you could say the agents are the elves. And...
John Coogan 32:20 ↗
Maybe Barrett was so afraid of the billionaire tax act that he's like, I don't want to be a billionaire.
Jordi Hays 32:25 ↗
I'd rather not be a billionaire than give 5%. Just give me a simple hundred million dollar pay package.
John Coogan 32:35 ↗
I'm a humble guy. That's it.
Jordi Hays 32:38 ↗
Yeah.
John Coogan 32:39 ↗
I don't want to be worried about that. AGI is coming.
Jordi Hays 32:42 ↗
Yeah. The new pay package...
John Coogan 32:42 ↗
Money won't matter.
Jordi Hays 32:43 ↗
Should be 999 million.
John Coogan 32:45 ↗
He's like, I don't want to deal with the headache of, you know, paying out taxes on unrealized cap gains. Yeah.
Jordi Hays 32:51 ↗
I'll be bankrupted.
John Coogan 32:53 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. Uh, yeah. So uh, yeah, Rune is talking about the framing around this. Before cognitive restructuring, important people are leaving. After cognitive restructuring, they're being fired for unethical conduct. Uh, the mom and dad are fighting. Uh, more Thinking Machines employees are in the process of joining OpenAI after three of the startup co-founders, all ex-OpenAI, rejoined yesterday. Three? I thought it was only two that rejoined. Um, but it does seem like...
Jordi Hays 33:23 ↗
It's two. They're counting Andrew. Oh, okay. Rejoined. But he didn't rejoin OpenAI, so I don't know if that would count. Little odd. Yeah.
John Coogan 33:34 ↗
Anyway, it does seem like the talent wars are unending in the AI race. Um...
We got to talk about saunas. We got to talk about the sauna wars because they're heating up and Vanity Fair has a piece on it. So, before we read this, let me tell you about Console. Console builds AI agents that automate 70% of IT, HR, and finance support, giving employees instant resolution for access requests. As we recess...
Jordi Hays 33:58 ↗
Everyone's focused on the AI wars. Not enough attention going to the sauna wars. The real heated rivalry is at the bathhouse.
John Coogan 34:07 ↗
Yes.
Jordi Hays 34:08 ↗
From Bath House to Other Ship to Alter. A wave of bathhouses in New York City are popping up just blocks apart. Okay. Igniting a war of zen. Uh, and this is especially relevant to the TBPN team because we've been in somewhat of a sauna war ourselves, which we'll get into at some point in the story. Uh, the Flatiron District in Manhattan has been a center of nouveau wellness for around 15 years with its many boutique fitness classes, gyms, acupuncturists, and stretching and recovery centers. Now, a wave of bathhouses that offer dry heat and cold plunges face off in a few blocks. There's Bath House on West 22nd with Other Ship two blocks away and Alter set to open this winter. You could walk between all three in mere minutes. Williamsburg has its own cluster, right? Parallels.
John Coogan 34:56 ↗
It's like a supercluster.
Jordi Hays 34:58 ↗
Yeah. Uh, with the original location of Bath House and Other Ship that followed. Welcome to the Sauna Wars where dedicated bathhouses compete with members' clubs like West Village's Continuum, which costs $40,000 per year, that has a bathhouse setup, and the Financial District co-working space WSA's wet lounge as well.
John Coogan 35:18 ↗
Co-working space with a wet lounge. Not something...
Jordi Hays 35:22 ↗
Not something you hear about every day. The fitness chain TMPL has a whole subway ad campaign entirely around their bathhouse facilities featuring women in swimsuits reclining in a suggestive way that one doesn't really find in saunas in real life.
John Coogan 35:36 ↗
Very odd.
Jordi Hays 35:36 ↗
They joined stalwarts like Spa 88 and Air in Manhattan, Citywell and World Spa in Brooklyn, Spa Castle in Queens, and of course the Russian and Turkish baths in the East Village, which is the sort of place newcomers are brought to see a slice of the real New York City. It's usually teeming with people, some getting whacked by bushels of oak leaves in a treatment called Platza, and has two owners who rotate weeks of ownership.
John Coogan 36:01 ↗
That's interesting. It's a funny concept.
Jordi Hays 36:04 ↗
Uh, it's no-frills and even a little gritty. For those who are used to conveniences such as booking ahead, there's none of that to be found. They do have a nod to modernity with an active TikTok account featuring guest endorsements, recently highlighting Uma Thurman wrapped in a pashmina and calling it one of the greatest New York institutions. 'The first time I went to 10th Street Baths was in 2007. I love the authenticity and how it made me feel. I would find my way back there when I felt depleted, underslept, whatever it might be. I would come out feeling great,' says James O'Reilly, who is one of the founders of the co-working space. His latest project is the new Lur bathing club.
John Coogan 36:42 ↗
This is where you go if you want to cultivate lore in your life. Uh, I guess founded alongside restaurateur Adam Elie, Lur takes some inspiration from the Russian and Turkish baths as well as the communal sweat traditions of Europe and Asia and drops it into a 6,200-square-foot space finished in travertine and white oak in NoHo. The bath world is quite a scene. One where skincare brands such as Fenty Williams, Humanrace send out a press release to announce they're temporarily supplying Lur locker rooms with their signature 7D gel sets.
Jordi Hays 37:16 ↗
What is a 7D gel set, Tyler? I...
John Coogan 37:20 ↗
Have no idea.
Jordi Hays 37:21 ↗
Other Ship is hosting comedy nights. Alter will be selling bathing suits that are custom-made in Brazil.
John Coogan 37:26 ↗
And has hired a lighting designer who has worked with Billie Eilish. 'So you're always feeling your best and comfortable and tan,' Jafari says with a laugh while giving a tour of the space. There's already a waitlist of more than 500 people for their membership, which will cost $275 per month upfront for $500 worth of credits to be used towards sauna and cold plunge, but also IVs and shots of vitamins, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, red light, NAD, compression, and PEMF. Lur has an indoor sauna with a list price of $120,000, an outdoor sauna with a list price of $95,000, and even launched a collaboration with the wellness club Remedy Place for an at-home 39-degree ice bath for $20,000. Do...
Jordi Hays 38:08 ↗
you think Brian Johnson will get into IRL experiences, physical locations? I know, was it Dave Asprey did that for a while? There were a series of Bulletproof coffees. Yeah, there's one in Santa Monica.
John Coogan 38:22 ↗
And there's been a few uh, like locations where you can go and they have a hyperbaric chamber. You can get your uh, your blood tested, like a variety of uh, sort of health and wellness like biohacker hubs. Uh, some of them...
Jordi Hays 38:38 ↗
I think Brian would make a nightclub bathhouse.
John Coogan 38:42 ↗
Probably.
Jordi Hays 38:42 ↗
Because he would want to, you know, his new thing is love as the ultimate longevity hack and so...
John Coogan 38:49 ↗
Could see him doing something like that.
Jordi Hays 38:51 ↗
It's such...
John Coogan 38:52 ↗
It is a sauna boom reminiscent of the glut of boutique fitness studios that flooded the market in the wake of the success of SoulCycle. 'It used to be that you would go to a gym and it was outrageous to go to an expensive group class,' says Jafari. 'But now there are 99 boutique fitness concepts in a 4-mile radius.' Still, there are not as many as the peak days pre-pandemic. Not every boutique fitness studio survived, let alone thrived like Solidcore and Tracy Anderson. 'Competition is always something we are aware of,' says Emily Bent, Other Ship's co-founder and director of marketing. 'The saturation in North America for bathhouses is not even close to what it is in Europe. We're starting an industry and rising tides and all that.' I have uh, heard about Other Ship uh, and what an insane business uh, Other Ship is um, from a number of people. Uh, so not surprised to hear they're expanding. While the message from founders blissed out on 180-degree heat is one of bringing together community and good vibes, the reality can be cutthroat. Consider the case of Bath House, probably the most well-known of the businesses in the second wave of New York City sauna culture. Co-founders opened their first location in Williamsburg in 2019 and a second in Flatiron in 2024, both featuring saunas, steam rooms, warm pools, and cold plunges. Goodman, the founder, saw the company's approach through the model of working on large event production. 'You think like an experience designer, so going to Bath House is not a monolithic experience, but more of a choose-your-own-adventure.' When it first opened, Bath House was jokingly called the Bitcoin bathhouse as they used the heat generated from mining to warm the tubs. Uh, which is... I've been to both of the Bath House locations in New York.
Jordi Hays 40:36 ↗
Now they need to do LLM inference.
John Coogan 40:38 ↗
Yes.
Jordi Hays 40:38 ↗
This is a no-brainer. Like everyone who was in crypto mining needed to pivot to AI. They should just do that. They already have all the infrastructure.
John Coogan 40:46 ↗
This is the solution to the political problem. People are mad at data center power use, but if you have a nice bathhouse that you can go to for the public...
Jordi Hays 40:53 ↗
Everyone's at the bathhouse constantly talking to Claude or something. Uh, I imagine that uh, the water use in a bathhouse is actually probably pretty significant. I imagine that they're like draining the pools fairly often. So...
John Coogan 41:04 ↗
I think... I think they're probably draining them less than you would hope.
Jordi Hays 41:09 ↗
Oh, that's not good.
John Coogan 41:12 ↗
Uh...
Jordi Hays 41:12 ↗
Uh...
John Coogan 41:13 ↗
So anyways, the comments originally were like uh...
Jordi Hays 41:15 ↗
There's a bunch of things I want to talk about. First, CrowdStrike. Your business is AI. Their business is securing it. CrowdStrike secures AI and stops breaches. Second, we have a key question. Do you know who Uma Thurman is?
John Coogan 41:26 ↗
No.
Jordi Hays 41:29 ↗
Kill Bill. You've never seen Kill Bill, Tarantino? It's fantastic.
John Coogan 41:33 ↗
Oh, I... Yeah, I...
Jordi Hays 41:35 ↗
Brutal.
John Coogan 41:36 ↗
Also, Pulp Fiction. I've seen Pulp Fiction. Um, anyways, the comments were like, 'Oh, they're laundering money through bitcoins, but it's just a fancy pool heater.' Those jabs did not prepare them for what happened earlier this year when someone posted on Reddit: 'I noticed the hot tub and body temp tub were looking kind of dirty and gross. I thought I'd be fine, but then I ended up with a UTI.'
Jordi Hays 41:58 ↗
Mhm.
John Coogan 41:59 ↗
Uh, not great. 'A UTI doesn't just walk across the river. If it was a problem, it would be a pool at a single location at one given day. There's 24-hour computer monitoring.' So, I'm glad that the uh, Bitcoin heated pools are getting 24-hour monitoring, and they're manually logged five times per day. And we keep the logs. We are adjusting pH and chlorine at all times.
Jordi Hays 42:22 ↗
'Every drop of water at every pool turns over every 30 minutes. All the vessels have their own independent system so they don't mix.'
John Coogan 42:28 ↗
'The water goes through a sand filter that takes out any particles up to two microns, like a receipt in their pocket or a tag that falls off.'
Jordi Hays 42:35 ↗
Interesting.
John Coogan 42:36 ↗
Uh, then it goes through a UV filter, big tank with three-foot-long light bulbs, a pure UV light. So...
Jordi Hays 42:42 ↗
They're sterile.
John Coogan 42:42 ↗
They're going pretty hard.
Jordi Hays 42:43 ↗
Cool.
John Coogan 42:44 ↗
Uh...
Well, Vibe.co, where DTC brands, B2C startups, and AI companies advertise on streaming TV, pick channels, target audiences, and measure sales just like on Meta. Anyway, speaking of Meta, we got to talk about Meta because they just laid off 1,500 people in their Metaverse division. It's 10% of their staff. It affects the company's AI glasses and other wearable products. The stock is up on the news. Obviously, 1,500 people is a ton. That's a lot of people. But they still have 14,000 people working on Reality Labs. So there's a question about like what exactly will they be doing? How much does this represent a shift? The messaging has certainly shifted to augmented reality instead of virtual reality. But it feels like they will be continuing with a lot of stuff. The Wall Street Journal has a report here in December. The Journal reported that Meta was planning to make budget cuts to teams working on the metaverse. A Meta spokesperson said, 'We said last month that we were shifting some of our investment from metaverse towards wearables. This is part of that effort.' And yeah, you see the Reality Labs team work on a bunch of different stuff. And it started as sort of, you know, the Oculus acquisition, a VR headset, then all of a sudden it was Meta Ray-Bans, which is, you know, mostly just a camera, certainly not a VR headset, but it feels like it's sold many more units. I actually don't know the precise number.
Jordi Hays 44:17 ↗
I'm super curious how many of those 1,500 people will end up working in VR or if they're going somewhere else.
John Coogan 44:24 ↗
Yeah. It's just like, can the industry really absorb that many people, right?
Jordi Hays 44:31 ↗
I don't know. I mean, there's projects at Google and Samsung and Apple Vision Pro, obviously, and then there's a couple startups, but yeah, where do you go?
John Coogan 44:38 ↗
I mean, I imagine that a lot of those people are just broad technologists and can work on anything because they're probably working on servers or supply chain or purchasing or marketing. Like, there's so much to do within Reality Labs. It's a massive organization. I mean, they ran like huge TV campaigns for the Oculus and they will probably continue to with the Quest. A year after the name change and pivot, the Journal reported that the company's flagship metaverse product called Horizon Worlds was failing to catch on with users. It had less than 200,000 monthly active users, and most so-called worlds were never visited by anyone at all. The company's presentations attempting to stoke enthusiasm for Horizon Worlds provided fodder for popular mocking internet memes. People were making fun of it. Yeah, the Horizon Worlds product.
Jordi Hays 45:24 ↗
I still believe Meta is a fantastic name for Meta.
John Coogan 45:28 ↗
Yeah. Do you think Salesforce should rename? I wanted to ask Benioff that yesterday if he's ever just going to go Force.
Jordi Hays 45:34 ↗
Meta Force.
John Coogan 45:35 ↗
Force. Meta Force would be a good name. But yeah, I mean, he is moving past sales. He talks about Agentforce and Serviceforce and all the different groups he has. Maybe he's got to change a name at some point. It'd be fun. But Salesforce is kind of a Lindy name. It's been around for so long.
Jordi Hays 45:47 ↗
Who has the ticker AI?
John Coogan 45:50 ↗
C3 or something. I don't know. Meta has been ramping up AI spending, pushing its capital expenditure to $72 billion last year with plans to accelerate that spending this year. It's also doled out offers worth tens and hundreds of millions of dollars to AI researchers and engineers and recently acquired a Singapore-based AI startup called Manis for more than two billion. The company's Ray-Ban smart glasses equipped with AI have also started to take off. The company sold more than 2 million pairs and has delayed the rollout of its newest glasses in Europe as it struggled to keep up with demand in the US. 2 million pairs of smart glasses, the Ray-Ban Metas, versus 200,000 monthly active users in Horizon Worlds. I wonder what the retention is on Meta Ray-Bans because if they're retaining less than 10%, then the actual MAU pool is lower.
Jordi Hays 46:45 ↗
Yeah. But I see people and I've started to see Instagram reels of people using the smart glasses to do first-person videos and often prank videos. So I think that there's actually a flywheel there that's stronger than what's happening in VR.
John Coogan 47:01 ↗
The thing that's interesting about not focusing on Europe is that my initial reaction of using the Ray-Ban Metas was if I was using WhatsApp as my primary messaging app, these would be like way more interesting, right? Because you have the integration, you have the heads-up display, you can get messages, you can read them, you can respond to them. It's super, super integrated. Meanwhile, they don't have an iMessage integration and so they're not that valuable to me from a messaging standpoint, which is like kind of one of the key use cases.
Jordi Hays 47:39 ↗
Yeah. The sort of Ben Thompson takeaway from this was that even though Mark Zuckerberg has effectively complete control over Meta and can rename the company and move very aggressively and acquire big companies, at the end of the day he does respond to shareholders and the shareholders have been watching the Reality Labs losses pile up billions every year. And at some point, if you have a new sort of big money pit initiative that's AI and you're going to spend tens of billions there, you have to sort of make a sacrifice or at least show the shareholders that you're refocusing on the new thing. Even though obviously AI and VR play very well together, part of the biggest problem with VR is that it's very difficult to develop. You have to develop this full game. AI can enable a lot of that, speed up development. And then there's also the sort of longer off-take, maybe not that far in the future, but this idea that if you generate a world model like the Fei-Fei World Labs project or Google has a project as well, Genie, that might be something that actually gets you to put on the headset because it's infinite and endless and requires a whole bunch of upfront cost to train the model, but then once you put it on, you're just in that and you can prompt it yourself. You're kind of designing your own game and that's a unique experience that it seems uniquely suitable for VR.
John Coogan 49:08 ↗
Ben Thompson's take was that the Meta rebrand was like a virtual reality project effectively, even though you didn't put glasses on. It was created.
Jordi Hays 49:19 ↗
Well, that's been my take on the name. It's still a metaverse. It is a metaverse. It just looks like a suite of apps.
John Coogan 49:26 ↗
Yes, yes, yes. And now you access that metaverse through a screen. And how close that screen is to your face might take years to get closer and it might be small when it's close for the first iteration. I'm very interested to see how the Ray-Ban displays are selling. 2 million Ray-Ban smart glasses. I've seen them sell the Ray-Ban displays at Best Buy. And Shyam Srinivasan was talking about sort of his frustrations getting onboarded. Have you run into anyone wearing them in the wild? I've run into people with the Ray-Ban smart glasses all the time with the cameras on them, but I haven't run into any with the new ones, the display.
Jordi Hays 50:10 ↗
Yeah, I haven't seen anyone just rocking them even though they are out.
John Coogan 50:15 ↗
Honestly, I feel like we don't see that many people.
Jordi Hays 50:19 ↗
I never go outside.
John Coogan 50:21 ↗
Well, I mean, on the weekends I do, but I'm like out and about. But I wanted to go back to the thing. I didn't get a chance to give a take. I am extremely bullish on Americans starting to sweat more because the evidence is so clear that if you use this every day, you will probably extend your health span, lifespan. It's heavily, heavily studied just because of how popular it's been in the Nordics for like decades and decades. So very bullish on sweating. One of the things that's interesting though is that New York is like the center of consumption, right? People have tiny apartments so they're just constantly consuming, right? Food, exercise, shopping, etc. But I don't think it's representative of the way that Americans will sweat broadly because you can get a sauna for like a couple grand and so all these bathhouses are like a few hundred. And so I think for some people they want the social experience whereas for me I'm not really that into the like the...
Jordi Hays 51:34 ↗
You don't like talking in the sauna?
John Coogan 51:36 ↗
I do like talking in the sauna. We've obviously had our sauna wars, our sauna wars, or I guess we were talking too loudly in the sauna the other day because this guy just absolutely snapped. He was a bit of an angry elf. But anyways, most consumers are going to be looking at it like, I can go and buy a sauna for $2,000 and I have space for it because I have a two-car garage and a backyard and maybe a pool. And like for the average American that has a little bit...
Jordi Hays 52:07 ↗
Last time I lived in an apartment, this was like six or so years ago, I had a whole cold plunge that I snuck into my apartment and a sauna. I had a two-bedroom loft.
John Coogan 52:19 ↗
You had a sauna, too?
Jordi Hays 52:21 ↗
No, no, I had two. So I had a two-bedroom loft and one of them I just put a cold plunge on a wooden floor.
John Coogan 52:29 ↗
That's insane.
Jordi Hays 52:29 ↗
And I had a sauna.
John Coogan 52:30 ↗
Of course. I don't think you're allowed to bring like a mini swimming pool in. If it leaks, you're going to destroy the whole...
Jordi Hays 52:37 ↗
I actually did. They did eventually tell me I had to get rid of it because there was a leak in the building and they went in to look and they were like, it didn't have anything to do with my cold plunge or whatever.
John Coogan 52:46 ↗
Okay. So if you were talking to Bryan Johnson, you would say, 'Skip the physical institution that is the sauna. Start a line of saunas that can be delivered on a truck to homes.'
Jordi Hays 53:00 ↗
Yeah, maybe. I mean, there's a company called Plunge that scaled insanely quickly. I think over nine figures of revenue off the cold plunge boom. But yeah, the main thing you have to understand is for other ships in these companies, you have to go into dense areas where people don't have a lot of space to have saunas because a lot of people are going to look and say, I either have one in my gym or people can go and just even if they don't have the two grand, you can use a sauna and like you're effectively paying a couple hundred bucks a month for like a private experience.
John Coogan 53:34 ↗
We'll see, we'll see. Gabe says, 'The big sweat lobby is making moves.'
Jordi Hays 53:40 ↗
I like it.
John Coogan 53:40 ↗
But yeah, I've remained so bullish on this trend because it's just passive, right? You don't have to work up the motivation to sweat in a car, right? So you get a lot of the benefits of exercise, but you're not like, I got to force myself to go for a run. It's just like get in the box.
Jordi Hays 53:58 ↗
Get in the box.
John Coogan 53:59 ↗
The Labelbox.
Jordi Hays 54:00 ↗
Yeah. Let's tell you about Labelbox. Labelbox, delivering you the highest quality data for Frontier AI. Get in the box.
John Coogan 54:10 ↗
Get in the box.
Jordi Hays 54:11 ↗
Labelbox. Maybe Labelbox should do a drop of custom saunas for everyone.
John Coogan 54:15 ↗
Daniel Gross says, 'I am building out Meta's compute desk. I'm looking for folks with a background.'
Jordi Hays 54:20 ↗
I like the term desk. It feels like New York. It feels like finance. It's not just a team. It's a desk.
John Coogan 54:27 ↗
Yeah. Deep learning, supply chain, commodities, semiconductor, stacking copper, energy, Excel, prediction markets, monitoring situations, etc. This is amazing. Candidates should have experience in at least one of these domains. Somebody's like, I've monitored a lot of situations. I'm qualified here. And novel ideas on how to apply LLM to their work. If you'd like to help manage $100 billion of compute spend, please DM and include information about why you're a fit. If you're in doubt about being a good fit, please apply.
Jordi Hays 55:00 ↗
Yeah, at least one of these domains. I only know Excel. I don't know anything about any of the others. I'm just an Excel jockey. Good luck.
John Coogan 55:09 ↗
But yeah, I mean, massive compute spend. Very interesting to see where the Meta Superintelligence Labs compute project goes. Obviously, they're spending a ton. Mark Zuckerberg said, 'Today we're establishing a new top-level initiative called Meta Superintelligence Labs. Meta is planning to build tens of gigawatts this decade, hundreds of gigawatts or more over time. How we engineer, invest and partner to build this infrastructure will become a strategic advantage.' It's led by Daniel Gross, of course, and Santosh will continue to lead the technical architecture, software stack, silicon program, developer productivity, and building and operating the global data center fleet and network. Daniel will lead a new group responsible for long-term capacity strategy, supplier partnerships, industry analysis, planning, and business modeling. They'll work closely with Dina Powell McCormick, who just joined Meta as president and vice chairman to work on partnering with governments and sovereigns to build, to invest in and finance Meta's infrastructure. I'm looking forward to working closely with Daniel, Santosh, Dina, and their teams to scale Meta Superintelligence Labs compute. It's a good name. You need a name for a team. What did Ben Thompson have to say about this? He said, 'A narrative seems to be quickly spinning up that this signals that Meta is finally going to get into cloud computing, competing with Amazon, Microsoft, and Google.' And well, Ben Thompson, he doesn't really think that's going to happen. What exactly would be the point? Amazon invented the space and invested heavily to have a structural cost advantage in commodity compute. Microsoft had a natural customer base with enterprise. Google has differentiated infrastructure and an outlet to fully leverage their AI investments without fear of cannibalization. What exactly would Meta bring to the table that other hyperscalers do not have such that they would have the confidence that they could be anything other than second choice competing on nothing but price?' So asking the hard questions about where Meta compute goes. They don't need to sell it if they truly scale. I mean, wasn't their compute budget in the pre-AI era tens of billions of dollars in capex and that was just for Reels, just for ads? Like there's plenty to do if they don't choose to sell it anyway.
Jordi Hays 57:20 ↗
MongoDB, choose a database built for flexibility and scale with best-in-class embedding models and rerankers. MongoDB has what you need to build what's next.
John Coogan 57:30 ↗
We have the CEO of MongoDB coming on in just five minutes. In other news, Beijing has told Chinese firms to stop using CrowdStrike. If you didn't have a reason to start using CrowdStrike, this is a pretty good...
Jordi Hays 57:44 ↗
Is this the TVPN effect? They saw us run a couple ads over in Beijing and they were like, 'Yeah, they're too powerful. Too powerful. They're too powerful. Homegrown.'
John Coogan 57:54 ↗
Apparently, this is already a very tiny business for CrowdStrike, so not super impactful. But in other news, OpenAI's number one hater in the entire world, Nick, is back on the timeline.
Jordi Hays 58:08 ↗
He was the OpenAI hater of the year last year. He's really gunning for it again this year. His camera roll is all just pictures of Sam. It's all his camera roll is just all Sam Altman photos for sure.
John Coogan 58:20 ↗
But the news, OpenAI Broadcom AI chip delayed. And Teo says this is not a delay. It's clearly a 5D chess move where Sam is amassing enough time to release state-of-the-art GPT-6 and put Google and Anthropic out of business. Everyone's having fun with the news trying to find where this was actually reported.
Jordi Hays 58:41 ↗
Yeah. Well, Sam Altman also is putting together... there's an announcement from Ashley Vance about OpenAI and Sam Altman backing a new bold take on fusing humans and machines. It's called Merge Labs. We've heard about this before. We talked to Rob Taves on the show about BCI and brain-computer interfaces potentially being a big trend for this year. Obviously, Neuralink has been cooking for a number of years. Sam Altman also has his bet with Merge Labs and they now have $252 million in the bank and an all-star crew and superpowers.
John Coogan 59:22 ↗
And remember, Sam Altman wrote in 2017 a piece called 'The Merge'. I'll read a few paragraphs from it. He said, 'More important than that, unless we destroy ourselves first, superhuman AI is going to happen. Genetic enhancement is going to happen. Brain-machine interfaces are going to happen. It is a failure of human imagination and human arrogance to assume that we will never build things smarter than ourselves. The merge can take a lot of forms. We could plug electrodes into our brains or we could all just become really close friends with a chatbot.'
Jordi Hays 59:54 ↗
But I think a merge is probably our best case scenario. If two different species both want the same thing and only one can have it, in this case to be the dominant species on the planet and beyond, they're going to have a conflict. Imagine if dolphins... Imagine if Benioff has been working with the dolphins to secretly help them merge and they're like in a crazy dolphin-human race to see who can merge first because dolphins basically... dolphins can just like generate B2B SaaS product ideas constantly. So funny.
John Coogan 1:00:25 ↗
X has this new thing that AI is very good at being funny unintentionally, but a bunch of people were posting about the Benioff story yesterday talking about... and so X summarized it as a headline: 'Mark Benioff recounts dolphin vision behind Salesforce's start.'
Jordi Hays 1:00:45 ↗
Dolphin vision. I love it. Dolphin vision.
John Coogan 1:00:47 ↗
Sam has some crazy old posts. I was looking at this one from February 15, 2023. It says, 'In 2023, it's $30,000 to get a simple iPhone app created and $300 for a plumbing job. I wonder what those relative prices will look like in 2028. The likely coming divergence between changes to cognitive work and changes to physical work could be quite dramatic.' And I mean, I saw Nick was showing us an iPhone app that cost about $100 of credits or something like that, maybe a little bit less in a vibe coding app. You know, you're going to use credits to inference a model that can actually build an iPhone app, but we're definitely closer to 300 bucks than 30,000 at this point. It's remarkable. Sentry shows developers what's broken and helps them fix it fast. That's why 150,000 organizations use it to keep their apps working. Well, we have our first guest of the show, CJ from MongoDB, in the Restream waiting room. We won't keep him waiting any longer. Thank you so much for taking the time.
Chirantan Desai 1:01:50 ↗
What a set.
John Coogan 1:01:51 ↗
Jump on the show. How are you doing?
Chirantan Desai 1:01:54 ↗
I am doing fantastic, man. It's like there are 700 people here. San Francisco is back. I feel like San Francisco is back and we are reintroducing MongoDB in San Francisco today. So, folks, the energy is just amazing.
John Coogan 1:02:10 ↗
Fantastic. Congratulations. Take us through some of the announcements. What does it mean to reintroduce MongoDB? What are the misconceptions where people might think of it as one thing and now you need to reintroduce it?
Chirantan Desai 1:02:22 ↗
I would say, you know, MongoDB, first of all, the database market has been around for a long time, 50-plus years, maybe 60 years. Oracle is going to celebrate its 50th anniversary in a year and a half. That was my first job out of college, I joined Oracle. And MongoDB was a truly disruptive database that got created in 2007 in New York City. I mean, this is one of the few tech companies that got created in New York City and put it on the map.
John Coogan 1:02:56 ↗
I know. I know.
Chirantan Desai 1:02:59 ↗
And then the leaf, you know, people ask me, what is the leaf of MongoDB all about? And the founder said, 'Hey, this is a natural way a software engineer or a builder should interact with a database versus a rigid way of interacting with a database.' So, it's pretty cool. I just became CEO a couple of months ago. Came from Cloudflare and I'm having a great time meeting innovators, customers around the world. On the misconception, here's what I would say: that even though the database was created in 2007, the whole idea behind it was speed, agility, and dealing with a lot of unstructured data like emails, PDFs, images, log files, this and that. So when the founder created this database, it was not with AI in mind. And today when you look at any AI application, your favorite consumer application you may be using on a daily basis, you see there are images in there. You may have created a video in there. Lots of interaction. This database was created for the AI wave and we want builders building on MongoDB as they create agentic AI applications or any applications for that matter that have structured data so that they can move fast and hopefully create the big iconic businesses, legendary businesses in Silicon Valley on top of MongoDB.
John Coogan 1:04:29 ↗
Where are you seeing the most excitement and growth in your business? I can imagine that there's a ton of greenfield projects that are happening in large clients, large enterprises where they want to move even faster. So they're grabbing MongoDB in addition to other modern tools on a new greenfield project. And then there's also a new startup boom of AI-enabled software companies. I'm sure that's growing as well. What have you been seeing? Where's uptake the fastest in the last few years?
Chirantan Desai 1:05:04 ↗
I would say, John, you know what I learned and I can feel it right here on the floor is that you had pretty much customers. We have 60,000 customers. Okay, 62,500. And our customer growth has accelerated in the last 12 months, which is pretty cool because a lot of developers are now building on MongoDB.
John Coogan 1:05:34 ↗
Nice. I like it.
Chirantan Desai 1:05:35 ↗
Every time you say something great, I'm going to hit that. So fair warning.
John Coogan 1:05:38 ↗
All right. I love it.
Chirantan Desai 1:05:38 ↗
So one is our customer base reaccelerated as developers are building on MongoDB. But it's a tale of two cities, right? One is large enterprises, John, as you called out, they are growing still with MongoDB. They have some mission-critical across every industry: financials, healthcare, government. I can tell you many across the globe just building on MongoDB. And you have AI-native companies or digital-native companies, whether they are in San Francisco, Seattle, Tel Aviv, or even New York. They are building on MongoDB. So the customer growth is coming from them. And customer growth accelerated in the last 12 months for us, which is really cool. Many, many companies, you know, when they start decelerating, they do not reaccelerate and we reaccelerated. So that gets me like really fired up and really positive. And the innovation that we announced today, that if you want to truly build an agentic system at scale that doesn't hallucinate, you can build it on your laptop. You always require a great database. You need an awesome agentic RAG or, you know, semantic search that just works, that is accurate. And this is truly a mission-critical app that an insurance company may float it to their customers or a government may float it to their citizens or whatever the case might be. We want to make sure that this is a great data platform. So we announced Vector Search for embeddings. We created a small embedding model called Atlas Vector Search, which is 1/8 the size of large. It shares the embedding space and works pretty much on cloud, on-prem, multicloud. And, you know, Jensen talked about at CES the whole thing around multicloud, multimodal, and multimodels, and we do the same. So very cool, excited. We gave that message this morning to the builders here. We have a full show all day today which was also live and people are fired up.
John Coogan 1:07:43 ↗
How are you thinking about M&A this year? Obviously, the company's doing really well. You're a public company. You have a public currency for acquisition. There's a lot of different pieces in the landscape that could be synergistic, but what's your thought process for partnering with other startups, either in a full acquisition or another partnership? How are you thinking about it this year?
Chirantan Desai 1:08:10 ↗
So, John, I'm a big believer in organic growth. We have a large market that we participate in. We have only penetrated 2.5% of that market. $100 billion, we are at $2.5 billion. So we have a lot of room with our core data platform. Now we are always looking for specialized skills, say maybe in the AI area. So in 2025 we bought Voyage, which was created out of Stanford. Amazing people, you know, the founder teaches a legendary course on machine learning. So we bought that company and he got amazing engineers and researchers and that professor is now chief AI scientist at MongoDB. So we will do those type of acquisitions where they are small, either for technology or people or sometimes both, so that we can truly leverage and accelerate the pace of innovation.
John Coogan 1:09:05 ↗
Has anything in the various compute bottlenecks been a headache or kept you up at night? I mean, we're reading about Amazon Web Services paying for copper refining because they need to go so deep in the supply chain that they need to go to the mining level. Memory prices are through the roof. There's delays on all sorts of custom silicon chips. I know you might not be affected, but how are you thinking about the different bottlenecks in the cloud computing supply chain?
Chirantan Desai 1:09:42 ↗
I would say the bottlenecks, if you remember a couple of years ago, everybody was worried about will they get enough GPUs from Jensen. Everybody's like, 'Oh my god, bro, are you going to get enough GPUs from Jensen?' And that was like a big worry. And now when we speak to customers, that's why they are like, okay, will GCP or Amazon, like you said, AWS and others, will they have enough capacity? Right now it is not something that people are panicking. And Amazon or Google, I would say, they're trying to stay ahead on that curve so that it doesn't become that, 'Hey, CJ, we cannot run MongoDB for your favorite customer X because we are out of capacity.' Man, we just can't do that. So we are trying to definitely work with them, understand how they are dealing with both compute as in CPUs as well as GPUs, and those innovation cycles are also very fast. But right now we are relying on them to solve, but we are not worried about it because they haven't given us the signal that we won't be able to do this.
John Coogan 1:10:47 ↗
Well, congratulations on the event. Jordi, do you have anything else?
Jordi Hays 1:10:50 ↗
And the new role. I know we're out of time, but I'm sure I'd love to dig more into your background and tell the fuller story. But we know you have a busy day today. Congratulations and we will talk to you soon.
John Coogan 1:11:02 ↗
Give our best to everybody at the event.
Chirantan Desai 1:11:04 ↗
Thank you, Jordi and John. Appreciate it.
John Coogan 1:11:06 ↗
Have a great rest of your day. Goodbye.
Chirantan Desai 1:11:08 ↗
Cheers.
John Coogan 1:11:09 ↗
Lambda, Lambda is the superintelligence cloud building AI supercomputers for training and inference that scale from one GPU to hundreds of thousands. We have Matthew Prince from Cloudflare joining in just a few minutes. In the meantime, we will go back to the timeline. There is some massive news.
Jordi Hays 1:11:29 ↗
I did want to say a couple things on Merge. So Male, who's one of the co-founders of Merge, says, TLDR, we are developing a new paradigm for BCI using molecules instead of electrodes.
John Coogan 1:11:42 ↗
Oh, interesting.
Jordi Hays 1:11:43 ↗
If you're excited about this and want to contribute in protein engineering, synthetic bio delivery, immunology, ultrasound devices, neuroscience, or data ML/AI, we'd love to hear from you.
John Coogan 1:11:55 ↗
That sounds extremely sucky.
Jordi Hays 1:11:58 ↗
Merge is pursuing ways to make BCI much higher bandwidth, millions of neurons, and less invasive, no device implants. Instead of electrodes, we're focusing on modalities like ultrasound that can cover large areas of the brain and on proteins that can connect these modalities with neural activities. And so again, quite a different approach than Neuralink.
John Coogan 1:12:20 ↗
Well, let me tell you about Turbopuffer. Serverless vector and full-text search built from first principles on object storage, 10x cheaper and extremely scalable. Our next guest, Matthew Prince, is in the Restream waiting room. Let's bring him in to the TVPN Ultratome. Matthew, good to see you again. Happy New Year. How are you doing?
Matthew Prince 1:12:41 ↗
Good. How are you?
John Coogan 1:12:42 ↗
That's good to hear. It seemed like you weren't doing that well a week ago when you posted about a court in Italy fining you. Can you take us through the process? Was this a surprise? How did everything lead up to your post which went mega viral?
Matthew Prince 1:13:01 ↗
Yeah, first of all, not a court, a quasi-governmental organization. And let me give you a little bit of background. So in Italy, there was concern by a bunch of the football clubs, so the soccer clubs in Italy, about online piracy of the matches that were there. And in response to that, the Italian parliament basically designated a quasi-governmental organization called AGCOM that they would have the ability to essentially allow any media company executive to put any website they didn't like on a list and then initially just the ISPs in Italy had 30 minutes to block access to that website. But they've amended the law to be able to include other companies including Cloudflare but also folks like Amazon, Google, Microsoft, anyone that is doing anything that is cloud-related. They have gotten swept up in this. And so the requirement was that when a website was put on this list that we would have 30 minutes to remove it globally. In other words, this small group of media executives got to choose what you could watch in the United States. And we already saw significant exposure of this beyond just illegal streaming where we saw political content being removed. They accidentally blocked all of Google Drive at one point. They accidentally blocked all of Cloudflare's network at one point which broke the Italian internet. So they turned that off pretty quickly. And so we had been in litigation in Italy to basically say this doesn't make any sense. And what particularly doesn't make sense is we hate the illegal streamers. They cost us money. We don't make any money off of them. They waste our bandwidth. They take up resources that we could have for paying customers. And so we have a huge team that is trying to shut them down. We actually won a court decision right before Christmas that said that we could get all of the internal documents on how this commission was created, what its rules were, everything else. And then, you know, probably just coincidentally, of course, immediately after Christmas, the first meeting they had, they imposed a $17 million fine on us and said that it will continue to escalate if we don't pay it and register for this scheme and commit to let them censor the internet, which obviously we're not going to do. That, by the way, is 2x our revenue in Italy. They have interpreted the law as saying that they can charge up to 2% of global revenue for any company that they fine. So again, the insanity here is pretty high. And yet that's not even what the law says. The law simply says it can be from tens of thousands and in fact there's parts of the law that they relied on that are so old that they were actually quoted in the LRA. So it was back before even the EU existed. To give you some sense of how crazy this is, even the EU has said that they have significant concerns over this law. And so we're in a strange situation where, you know, we're getting a lot of pressure to literally just turn Italy off and not let them connect to Cloudflare's network, which would, you know, unfortunately everyone saw a few months ago when we had an outage how big of an issue that is.
John Coogan 1:16:28 ↗
That doesn't seem right. Putting your tinfoil hat on, do you think there's some local group that wants your Italy business that says like, 'Hey, that's a purely own goal.'
Matthew Prince 1:16:47 ↗
I think there is. So I think first of all it's a bunch of, you know, older football owners who don't understand how the internet works who just are saying, you know, piracy is a problem. And instead of doing what most of the leagues around the rest of the world do with us, which is work with us in order to identify what those illegal streams are and then we not only take them down but we actually put up a page that's an advertisement for the correct stream in its place, instead they were just like, you know, we're going to just make it so that you have to take these things offline. Damn the consequences. I think there are other people inside of Italy that see this as an ability for them to be able to control some political content that they may not like. Obviously Italy is a contentious political state and being able to shut things you don't like off the internet is a very powerful political tool. So I think that's the tinfoil hat side. But I think mostly this is just thuggish behavior by a bunch of people who don't understand how the internet works.
John Coogan 1:17:51 ↗
Then take off the tinfoil hat, put on the steel-man helmet, and try and steel-man for me where the work should be done of fighting piracy on the internet because I have some empathy for a league owner who doesn't want their content streamed illegally and it seems to be like such a hard problem. Like my view is like UFC kind of just threw in the towel and was like, the pay-per-view model is over, we're going to Paramount. And so yeah, it seems like it's a nice thing for you to do to take down these illegal streams. Maybe there's some legal reason that falls on you.
Matthew Prince 1:18:33 ↗
It's a purely financial reason. It's like when the streams come up, they clog our pipes and that shuts down the ability and we have to pay for that bandwidth. So we have all the financial incentives to shut it down. It is a hard problem, right? Because again, the streamers are clever and they're always bouncing around and doing different things. But we shut down hundreds of thousands of illegal streams every single day and we work with most of the leagues around the world. So there doesn't need to be a law in order to create the incentives for us. What I do worry about though is anytime that you create some sort of rule in the name of privacy, in the name of protecting children, in the name of whatever that lets a local government and whether that's a state government or a nation state be able to set how global infrastructure works. That just seems per se bad, right? You shouldn't be able to say Italy decides what you can see and watch in New York or California or Texas or Canada or China frankly, and China shouldn't be able to impact... let China be crazy inside of China and they can have their own rules and regulate their networks however they want. But the fact that this has extraterritorial application, that literally some Italian soccer club owners can dictate what content you watch in California or New York, that's insane and that's something that we have to push back against.
John Coogan 1:19:54 ↗
Yeah. So what's the response been like in Washington, in DC? I imagine that at some point, even just a passing statement from the admin, 'Hey, Italy, back down on this. We'll buy a little bit more wine or something, some trade deal, or not impose a 100% tariff on all your goods.' What are the levers that people are considering pulling? What has been pulled? How are the discussions going?
Matthew Prince 1:20:22 ↗
Yeah. So I spent the beginning part of this week in DC meeting with everyone from senators to the United States State Department, a number of different officials within the administration directly in the White House, USTR, which is the United States Trade Representative, and I didn't come across a single one that wasn't disgusted by this policy. And so I don't think the Italians quite understand the hornet's nest that they've stirred up. This is now sort of the cause célèbre for Europe using US tech companies as their piggy bank where, I mean, the crazy stat is that Europe makes more off fining US tech companies than they do off taxing their own technology companies. That's insane, right? And so something has to change here. And this is the most clear example that again, you know, whistles to all the dogs in Washington right now saying like we can't have again Europeans, let alone this sort of Italian cabal, being able to dictate what is and is not online.
John Coogan 1:21:32 ↗
Yeah. What's the reaction been from, I mean, your competitors, there are other content delivery networks, other hosts. Do they agree with you and they're just less outspoken because they're not in the founder mode that you're in perhaps? Or are there some other companies that are just less affected or less targeted because they aren't as much of a peer play? How's the rest of the ecosystem reacting to all this?
Matthew Prince 1:21:58 ↗
Yeah, I think the hyperscalers are really concerned about this. I think anybody who has a really large business where they have millions and millions, we have tens of millions of customers. You know, I think what's unique about us is we have a free version of our service because we believe that every small business, every developer should be able to have robust cybersecurity tools, robust content delivery tools. And so that gives us a much broader portfolio than some of our competitors that only have, you know, they won't even pick up the phone for less than a million dollars. Like that's a different thing. But if you're an AWS, if you're a Google Cloud, if you're Microsoft Azure, if you're an Oracle, like they are deeply concerned that this is going to impact them because they all have broad sets of customers and it's very difficult for them to just say we're going to let Italy pick who can and cannot be a customer of ours. That's again just insane.
John Coogan 1:22:54 ↗
Okay, last question on the fine for me and then I want to move on to AI. Since we have you here, what's the result of the fine? Did you just pay it or are you debating it?
Matthew Prince 1:23:02 ↗
No, no, no. So we're challenging it. Italian law, because it's Italy, doesn't have any mechanism to stay this. I would imagine that there are going to be some pretty pointed phone calls from senior US officials to senior Italian officials saying like, cut this out. In addition, you know, we're considering various options. So we may shut down our free service in Italy, which again is unfortunate. It'll hurt a bunch of developers there, but we can't do charity for places that again earn rent. The other thing that's coming up is the Milan Cortina Olympics where we provide tens of millions of dollars of free cybersecurity services. I was actually a personal guest of the...
Former president of the IOC to the Paris Games because we provided the information that took the terrorist attack that almost shut down the games and allowed them to arrest 90% of the terrorists beforehand. We helped stop massive denial of service attacks again for free that were launched from Russia, which is trying to completely discredit the Olympics because of the doping scandals and fans that they've faced. And so, you know, again, I really believe in the Olympics. I really want the Olympics to succeed. But again, it seems wrong for us to be providing tens of millions of dollars of free cybersecurity for a showcase event in a country that's just acting completely insane.
John Coogan 1:24:24 ↗
Yeah, that makes a ton of sense. Talk to me about the 2026 App Innovation Report. Talk to me about this idea of a technical glass ceiling. I've been going back and forth with a lot of the AI researchers that come on the show. The models are amazing. And then I'll ask them, like, well, this particular app doesn't seem to be getting better on my phone. What's going on over there? Why isn't this app significantly improved? Why are there still bugs in enterprise software when everyone has access to frontier models? What are you seeing in AI adoption? What are you feeling internally? Just take me through your current thinking.
Matthew Prince 1:25:00 ↗
Well, we are incredibly bullish in AI. We use it internally. We use it across all of our teams. We actually had our companywide kickoff today, and our CTO challenged every one of our teams to say how can they use AI more, and it's really quite incredible what it's done. What I will say though is we're definitely in some places for some AI companies hitting some sort of a limit, it seems, in what they're able to do. And the exception to that, I think, has been Google. Gemini has continued to outperform the rest of the market. And I think that the answer to why that's the case is actually not about the chips. Obviously, they've designed their own GPU chips. I don't think it's about the people. They have incredibly smart people, but so does Anthropic. So does OpenAI. I think it's actually about the data, and we are one of the few companies that actually has a view into this. And so we haven't shared this very publicly, but I guess, you know, no time like the present. And so, how much more of the web would you guess that Google sees and is able to train their AI systems on versus OpenAI?
John Coogan 1:26:09 ↗
Yeah, I would probably say 50% more.
Matthew Prince 1:26:12 ↗
Yeah, the answer is actually 3.2 times more.
John Coogan 1:26:15 ↗
Wow.
Matthew Prince 1:26:16 ↗
Which is insane, right? That means that for every one page that OpenAI sees, Google is seeing, you know, 3.2 pages. So there's just so much more data that's going into it. And again, OpenAI the next closest. After that, Google sees 4.8 times more of the web than Microsoft. They see similar to what they see with Anthropic as well. And it just drops off from there. And so what I worry about is that because Google has this unique access to the web that nobody else has, that the game might just go to them. Because I think that at the end of the day, whoever has the most data wins in the era of AI. And I think what a lot of these companies are seeing is they're hitting kind of a data limitation. And one of the things we're really thinking about is how can we make sure that we level the playing field? Either bring Google back to where everyone else is, don't let them leverage search in order to get a unique advantage in AI, or how do we lift everyone else up to the same place where Google is? Make sure that everybody has access to that same data. If we don't create a level playing field in terms of the data, I do feel like there's a real concern that Google is going to run away with this and no one else will catch them.
John Coogan 1:27:25 ↗
Interesting. Yeah, we've noticed that. I mean, we test all the different LLM apps, and even just from a branding perspective, when you're in the Gemini app and it says doing a Google search, all the other apps will say we're searching the internet, but doing a Google search just gives it the brand is like, oh, it's doing what I would do if I were on the computer. And it's interesting to hear that there's actually more data being accessed. It's not just the brand.
Jordi Hays 1:27:50 ↗
That's also one of the only things that Elon and Sam can really agree on, or sort of a shared motivation, is like making sure the AI race is competitive with
Matthew Prince 1:27:59 ↗
Google. I mean, people forget that OpenAI was started because Elon and Sam got together because they were so concerned about what was happening with Google. And I think that that concern is rightly placed, and Google has such a data advantage where because of search, everyone has let them behind their paywall. Everyone has let them see parts of the internet that no one else sees. Again, we can look at the restrictions on various spots. What are the robots.txt files and everything else for a huge portion of the internet? And the answer is that Google just has privileged access. And until we level that playing field, either by bringing Google back to the same level as everyone else or bringing everyone else up to the same level as Google, like I worry that this is their race to win. And that's bad. Like the world certainly shouldn't have one AI company. I don't think you should have five AI companies. I think we should be playing for a world where we have 500,000 AI companies, and we make it as easy as possible for any of them to thrive and survive.
John Coogan 1:28:55 ↗
Okay. Talk to me about the defaults on robots.txt where people are allowing scrapers, where Googlebot can come in, where Gemini can come in. What's been your thinking on defaults? How has it evolved, and then what's the reaction from your customer base been to those defaults?
Matthew Prince 1:29:14 ↗
Yeah. So, I think this is actually a really nuanced issue, and the answer is going to be different for a number of different companies, and in some cases we don't know what the right default is. So, here's where I think the things that are very straightforward. Excuse me. If you have a knowledge base, so Cloudflare has a knowledge base on, you know, how to use Cloudflare Workers in order to build systems. Excuse me. Tickle in my throat. No problem. If you have something like that, then of course you want that to be in AI systems, and that should be default scrape no matter what.
On the other hand, if you're a publisher, which is ad or subscription supported, maybe you don't want that to be in because AI bots don't click on ads. And if they're taking all the content that you're generating and then just regurgitating it in a place where you don't get any benefit from that, that's a real problem for the business model of media companies. And again, I think what we're seeing is the media companies have really locked down who has access to their content. And you're seeing much better deals from the likes of Condé Nast, Dotdash Meredith, Reddit, who are getting more for their content from the AI companies because at the end of the day, whoever has the most data is going to be the winner that's there. What I think is somewhat unfair, and again, back to the same issue, is Google because of search is still getting almost everything for free whereas everyone else is having to pay for it. That seems wrong. That seems like something that we need to fix in some way. And again, that either we need to bring everyone else up or bring Google back down to everyone else's level. But that's one of the things we're worried about. I think the most interesting thing that people aren't talking about today is what's going to happen to retail. What's going to happen to small businesses that are out there? AI is this massively consolidating force. And if you look at three of the biggest retailers in the world, Walmart, Target, and Amazon. What's interesting is again these are hugely well-resourced companies, smart people working at them, no lack of financial resources across them to do whatever is right, and they have come to three completely different conclusions on what you should do about agentic commerce. In the case of Walmart, throw the doors open to the catalog, let every agent in, and in the short term I think that's clearly the right answer. But I worry over time that the agents are going to just keep trying to figure out how can we cut Walmart out over time. And I don't know what brands mean in a world where, you know, your agent is shopping on your behalf. Brands are a way for humans to have shortcuts that understand quality and value that goes away in a world of agentic commerce. Agents will figure that out for you and report back, and brands might not matter as much. And including a massive brand like Walmart, Amazon is taking the complete opposite strategy. They're literally suing Perplexity saying your agents aren't welcome here.
John Coogan 1:32:12 ↗
Again, two... But that's because they have a massive advertising business and they know that the agents aren't...
Matthew Prince 1:32:18 ↗
Well, so is Walmart.
John Coogan 1:32:20 ↗
Sure.
Matthew Prince 1:32:20 ↗
Yeah. But how material is it for Walmart versus...
John Coogan 1:32:25 ↗
It's a pretty big... like all I mean there's any of those sponsored listings on Walmart and they're all doing the same stuff.
Matthew Prince 1:32:32 ↗
I think I would argue it's something different. I think Amazon thinks that they have to win the agent war themselves and so Alexa has to get much better at it whereas Walmart doesn't have as much of a stake in this. So, this is a giant bet, I think, from Amazon that their agent will be able to shop better than anyone else's. That isn't my experience with Alexa yet, but again, a huge amount of resources that are going into that. Target has what I think is sort of the, oh, let's split the baby kind of approach, which is agents are allowed, but they have to be the ones that are listed on the Target website. That obviously is not going to be a long-term sustainable approach, but I think that shows how challenging this is going to be. And what I really worry about is going forward, like if you think about what small businesses that you shop with, your local butcher, your local, you know, flower store, those things, a lot of it is because of the interpersonal relationships that you have with those shop owners. If those go away, if your agent is doing this all on your behalf, if we all become some version of the Jetsons, where, you know, how does George do his shopping? He asks Rosie, the helpful robot, to go do it for him, and eggs show up and he doesn't really care, you know, where they came from. I worry that that's going to put enormous pressure on small businesses and I don't know that small businesses have the tools today to be able to figure out how to exist and thrive in this world of agentic commerce and that's something that I'm enormously worried about.
John Coogan 1:33:50 ↗
Jordi,
Jordi Hays 1:33:50 ↗
I think yeah, I think it's warranted. I still think at the end of the day with physical products it's like, you know, I care a lot about like I'm drinking this here. I'm drinking this because our friend Andrew Huberman, this is the brand that he's aligned with. Like if I just sent an agent to go buy me a Yerba Mate, maybe it comes back with something else, but then I'm still like, ah, just get me the podcast in a can, please. Anyway, so a lot to figure out. The exciting thing I feel like is that so many different companies are reporting that LLM traffic is converting at a high rate, which tells me that it is a great tool for product research. But yeah, there is a lot of questions of like, yeah, how do you... GEO is kind of like a dark art right now. It's very hard to understand, it's far easier to kind of understand how you're showing up in results than it is to maybe influence it yet.
John Coogan 1:34:47 ↗
A lot of things to figure out. I did have one, I wanted an update on the ski season from you. We saw numbers, you know, basically traffic down like 20% year-over-year.
Matthew Prince 1:35:01 ↗
Probably. Yeah. So one thing before, like I agree we don't quite know how this is going to play out, but I do think it's important that we articulate what we're trying to play for. So I want to play for a world where there's not five AI companies, there's 500,000, where there's not, you know, a small set of massive media conglomerates, but anyone can be a content creator. I mean, you guys are a perfect example of what I want to make sure continues to exist as we get into a world that is more AI-driven. And then for businesses, we need to make sure that you can be a small business and still thrive. That there is a way to have a level playing field and that there can be tens of millions of businesses around the world that can actually do that. And that's what we're thinking about. That's what we're partnering with folks like Visa and Mastercard, American Express, PayPal, you know, Shopify, Adobe, Salesforce to try and figure out how do we give those tools. And I think that's one of the most important questions. The business model of the internet over the next five years is going to change radically. Rarely does something that big have that big a change. And I think if you're not thinking about what that change is going to be, then again, I don't think you're worrying about the most important question today. In terms of the ski season, no reason the skiing should be distracting you from thinking about what the future business model of the internet should be. It is grim. I'm sitting in Park City, Utah. It is the worst ski season. I mean, I'm 51 years old. My first year of skiing, I was the 76-77 season. This is as bad as that season.
John Coogan 1:36:28 ↗
No, it's good timing for you. Like a lot of people, you know, pray for snow. You were kind of like a bad ski season is kind of convenient for you right now. You need to be pretty locked in.
Matthew Prince 1:36:37 ↗
I am. I'm trying to get Vail to sell me Park City and then return it to local ownership and make it the star that it is. And I think...
John Coogan 1:36:47 ↗
Yeah. So Vail is trading at less than two times revenue. We've covered kind of the history of the business. Like at what point do you just buy the whole thing?
Matthew Prince 1:37:01 ↗
I don't think it makes sense. I don't want to run Vail. That doesn't sound like much fun, but I think somebody should. And you know, if you could acquire Vail for, you know, $5 billion with some leverage and you need about a billion dollars of equity, I know a guy who will write you if you're an activist investor on...
John Coogan 1:37:19 ↗
That's what I was saying. One way you get your prize, your trophy, Park City, is you just buy Vail and then you spin out Park City yourself and...
Matthew Prince 1:37:27 ↗
Yeah, that seems maybe we'll get to that point. I would much rather somebody else who's like good at those things that goes again like, you know, Elliott Management if they want to go buy Vail and then sell me Park City. That would be, it seems like an almost, it's getting close to being a no-brainer.
John Coogan 1:37:42 ↗
Amazing. Well, we're hoping to follow that story. Thank you so much for coming on the show. Good luck with the...
Matthew Prince 1:37:48 ↗
Good luck with the Italians and thank you for all the support coming on the show early. It's been huge.
Jordi Hays 1:37:53 ↗
How's your Italian?
Matthew Prince 1:37:54 ↗
My Italian is not particularly good. So...
Jordi Hays 1:37:57 ↗
He has a great Italian lawyer. I bet he's got a guy who's over there.
Matthew Prince 1:38:01 ↗
A lot of good employers. Full employment.
John Coogan 1:38:06 ↗
Well, have a great rest of your day. Enjoy the rest of your day and we'll see you soon. Appreciate it. Big fan.
Matthew Prince 1:38:10 ↗
Goodbye. Thank you.
John Coogan 1:38:12 ↗
Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform that grows with your business and lets you sell in seconds online, in store, on mobile, on social, on marketplaces, and now with AI agents. Delian...
Jordi Hays 1:38:24 ↗
Delian Asparouhov, the co-founder of Varda, the partner at Founders Fund. Hit him with a flashbang. Got him.
John Coogan 1:38:36 ↗
We got to hit him with a smoke grenade too. Ask him to do an intro as the smoke clears. Throwing smoke.
Jordi Hays 1:38:43 ↗
Throwing smoke.
John Coogan 1:38:47 ↗
And look who it is. It's Delian. As the smoke clears, we have the partner from Founders Fund on the stream. It really takes a second to clear. Okay. We're clear. We're clear. Delian, good to have you here. Hope you're doing well. Thanks for hopping on the show. How are you doing? How's your week going? You're ripping checks. You're in business. Money's flowing.
Jordi Hays 1:39:06 ↗
Is it? Yeah. Is the bear market over? I mean, and you know, last year you kind of felt like things were getting a little crazy. Maybe you didn't find any opportunities you love. Then you started the year with a bang.
Delian Asparouhov 1:39:21 ↗
Mhm.
Jordi Hays 1:39:22 ↗
Started the year with a bang.
Delian Asparouhov 1:39:23 ↗
I feel like, you know, I think I'm just like addicted to investing over the holidays. I realized over the past like nine years that I've been in venture, I think seven of those years I've signed a term sheet within 48 hours of Christmas Day. And I don't know if that speaks to the fact that I just like I'm addicted to work or something about like Santa Claus makes me want to send out some presents or something like that. But yeah, it definitely feels like a busy season. I was catching up with another investor and he was like, same thing here. Like one of the best deals we did was basically over Christmas.
John Coogan 1:39:50 ↗
Is the deal flow from like serendipity at the holiday parties or is it just networking from the internet? Like where are you meeting founders these days?
Delian Asparouhov 1:39:58 ↗
I admit that like I think a part of it is if you were trying to preempt, around no better time than to do it over the holidays because like nobody's chatting at the office. There's no like hallway conversations etc. You can have these just like very quiet conversations. Founders like it because they don't have to deal with like, you know, a bunch of noise. You like it because you feel like you can do this like one-on-one negotiation and basically just set the deadline of like, you know, I've now done this a couple years in a row where it's like, yeah, signed by New Year's otherwise like deal's off basically. And it feels harder to enforce that type of deadline like during the like, you know, school year basically. And so, I think that's part of why, you know, on both sides I like it. It's like as a founder, you can kind of test the waters and if it gets shot down, whatever. Nobody heard about it. Everybody's gone for the holidays. You come back into the office, your employees don't know, your board doesn't know, no VCs know, and if it does go, then like, you know, great.
John Coogan 1:40:42 ↗
I think it's convenient as a founder. The holidays can be so annoying because like it becomes like kind of poor form to just be like, you know, slamming people, your team with emails around Christmas Eve, Christmas, slamming the VCs with... And yeah, so I think it's a win-win. Just obviously anytime you're talking terms it becomes wildly distracting because you're like this is maybe the most important thing for my business right now. But if you can use that stretch of like seven days where you're not really supposed to be like, you know, you're not operating but you're allowed to negotiate terms. By the way, I did want to point out I did make sure that I wore my TPN quarter zip today. So this is how I have a... you have a horse on that. Is that a little horse there? We got another horse there. Let me get it. Oh, other way. Other way into the sunshine.
Jordi Hays 1:41:30 ↗
It's coming on. It's coming on the screen.
John Coogan 1:41:33 ↗
Wow.
Jordi Hays 1:41:36 ↗
You guys have a hole so you guys can...
John Coogan 1:41:38 ↗
Oh, yeah. Yeah. 2026 is a good year for us. We're... talk to us about the barbell strategy, early stage, growth stage. Is this actually pushing you out on the barbell? Was Series A your sweet spot and now it's seed and Series C? Is this going to be a permanent thing? How are you thinking through that?
Delian Asparouhov 1:41:56 ↗
Yeah, I think if you look at some of the best like deep tech hardware industrial, you know, sort of companies over the past like 15 years, they have a very interesting like PPS, you know, sort of growth curve where effectively you have like typically a seed round that happens, and I'm just going to give like, you know, somewhat fake numbers here but, you know, indicative of like, you know, a buck per share basically, the like early incubation days. You then have like Series A that'll be like four or five times higher basically, like five bucks a share, and then a lot of times what you'll see is years of super diminishing basically PPS growth until you sort of get to the other side of like the R&D, production hell, etc. And then all of a sudden, you just have huge step function changes like over and over and over again. And this is true on everything from like the early days of like Nvidia, Tesla, like, you know, Apple all the way down to like some of the more, you know, sort of recent, you know, sort of more, you know, deep tech industrial, you know, sort of startups. And so what to do as like an investor basically? Well, you know, you can, you know, I think do the seed rounds where I do think they're, you know, attractive versus reward. You get some amount of IRR just like through Series A, etc. And then what you effectively want to do is do that last round where it's flat and then allow it to basically, you know, basically grow, you know, from there. And I think what I've like started to realize is like that is the style of company that I like to do. It has a very different PPS curve relative to like SaaS, AI, etc., which are honestly just like much more like, you know, clear smooth sort of like, you know, typically obviously exponential curves if it's like a, you know, sort of great company, right? Like if you look at Ramp for example, there was just clear step ups all throughout. Obviously had the like, you know, they did a great job of like, you know, marking themselves down in like the 2022 basically, you know, sort of crash, and I think that was proven to them, and then basically smoothly upwards basically since then. And so the way that's played out is like, you know, now over the past couple years, I've much more consistently done basically like super early stage pre-seed and a founder basically like, you know, early early, you know, industrial deep tech companies. And then I sort of sit there and bide my time and wait until what I think is like that basically last round right before the inflection point and then basically you sort of do that round. And I've now done that, you know, over the past year I did basically three like later stage basically rounds like, you know, Series B, Series C, and then like, you know, basically Series C that I just, you know, closed terms on over the holidays. And all of them were companies that I've either been tracking basically since seed or literally been an investor since seed. And we talk about one of those, you know, part of what we were talking about earlier today was, you know, talking about one of those very particular companies. But yeah, I think I'm starting to realize that I like that more than I like doing the like, you know, sort of messy middle in some ways. And so, yeah, want to double down on that and, you know, whatever Tuesday night was cool where I literally felt that happen where I signed two term sheets that were indicative of both ends of the barbell for me.
John Coogan 1:44:27 ↗
What was the amount of work in DD that you did on the Series C company significantly higher? Like how did you actually split the time up? Because this is framed as, you know, 50/50 of Delian's time, but I imagine that there's just more data to pull in, more research to do, more customers to talk to, but at the same time you know the company so much better.
Delian Asparouhov 1:44:46 ↗
Sure. Sure. Yeah.
John Coogan 1:44:48 ↗
So what was it like process-wise?
Delian Asparouhov 1:44:49 ↗
Yeah. I mean, I'm not somebody, I don't think I would ever be able to do like a raw Series C where it's like I've met the company for the first time, have the time to go do the diligence etc. from scratch because it's just like, dude, I've got a company that I got to run, like I can't do that. The thing that I can do though is like get involved early or if it's something I'm like deeply passionate about even if I'm not involved, like track the company super regularly such that I'm kind of doing all that pre-diligence basically like ahead of time. So like let's talk about one of the, you know, some companies that I think exemplifies this strategy where we just announced a $1.6 billion post round led by T. Rowe Price basically last week that I got maybe, you know...
John Coogan 1:45:25 ↗
We're going to have the show, we'll go ring it twice for the hey.
Delian Asparouhov 1:45:29 ↗
Exactly, exactly. I think it's Dallas, you know, fifth unicorn or something like that from like, you know, they see under 25 post all the way through to the...
John Coogan 1:45:36 ↗
Yeah, feel good about it. Chris said, I was texting him earlier, he's like, you're allowed to toot your own horn. I want to do VC brags, you know, hit me up.
Delian Asparouhov 1:45:45 ↗
Um...
John Coogan 1:45:46 ↗
Yeah, we give us the update on Hermeus.
Delian Asparouhov 1:45:49 ↗
Yeah, that's one where like look I got involved in the, you know, basically like company formation basically like, you know, seed round where it was Chris and like maybe one or two, you know, sort of people.
John Coogan 1:45:58 ↗
And so what did diligence on that one look like?
Delian Asparouhov 1:46:00 ↗
Well, it was effectively like, you know, four and a half years of working with Chris very closely, going to every single board meeting, watching the company like adapt over time. And in like, you know, Q1 last year in '25, it was clear there was just like this inflection point that I felt like I could appreciate but not everyone else was really appreciating yet. The first was they basically, you know, for those that don't know, Hermeus basically builds these like automated CNC basically, you know, facilities. They basically cut metal on behalf of, you know, aerospace and defense companies. So, you know, think a lot of the biggest logos in the Founders Fund portfolio. I won't list, you know, sort of all of them since I'm not sure which ones are allowed to be public, but, you know, ones that, you know, build rockets, make drones, you can guess which ones those are. And they cut metal on behalf of those companies. For a long time they were interested in the like R&D production grind, like trying to figure out basically like how to make the economics of the business work, you know, switching from like what were originally quick turn small prototype contracts into like production multi-year, you know, basically large contracts. And in Q1 last year there were two things that happened that just like made it very clear to me that it hit like my spidey instincts of like, oh, this is like the point that I'm supposed to come in and do the Series C. Like my whole job was to have done the seed and then wait for this exact moment. The two things that happened were one, they just got through production hell basically, like the economics started making sense, they were producing, you know, it's going to be way more volume. And then the second thing was, you know, we talked about this a lot, but the defense industry is obviously going through a huge shakeup and there's a whole set of, you know, neoprimes that are coming out that are going to get anointed. And Hermeus was clearly in this transition point from what was previously just purely like a backend sort of supplier of, you know, sort of parts and a vendor into somebody that was becoming more of like a strategic, you know, neoprime. There's going to be co-betting alongside others, but as a neoprime that is focused specifically on production, right? So if we think about groups like, you know, Anduril, Shield AI, you know, name your favorite basically, you know, Mock Industries, name all your favorite, you know, neoprimes, they all roughly follow the same model which is like they are product developers fundamentally, right? Like they go and like design net new products, they may do a decent amount of production and assembly of themselves, but they still are reliant on like out of, you know, sort of house, you know, sort of vendors for a vast majority of their like, you know, subcomponents. Hermeus fundamentally is a very different type of neoprime, right? They are a neoprime that is explicitly focused on production. They do not produce basically like end products themselves. They only amplify others' end products. But that is a significant bottleneck that the, you know, defense, you know, department or, you know, war department is looking to go unlock and is leaning on Hermeus for a wide variety of, you know, programs both directly, you know, as Hermeus as a contractor as well as like co-bidders alongside other neoprimes. And so I think when I think about like, you know, the way that Hermeus was interpreted Q1, Q2 last year, people were squinting at it, they're like, man, these economics have only turned in the last quarter. You know, isn't this just a backend vendor that doesn't have a ton of upside. From my like insider perspective having watched it for five years, I'm like, dude, this is the type of business where once the economics turn a corner, they don't unturn a corner. You know what I mean? It only gets easier from here. We finally got to positive. We're going to 20% margin, 40% margin, 60% margin, and it's like, you know, accumulating advantages, but like materials get easier, the factories get easier, and the states want to send the stuff. It's just like, you know, you're rocking and rolling. But like when people look at like a SaaS business, they don't appreciate that like in like hardware, especially when you're producing something that is like kind of a commodity, there's sort of like semi-infinite demand. There's like not semi-infinite demand for Databricks, you know what I mean? Like, you know, just doesn't, the scale of the market is not nearly as large.
John Coogan 1:49:18 ↗
Ollie, would put your two cents in on that.
Jordi Hays 1:49:21 ↗
Thanks. Hey, sorry. We're obviously investors.
Delian Asparouhov 1:49:24 ↗
Hey, also T. Rowe Price is smart enough to be in both Databricks and, you know, to be clear, big Databricks fan, but at the end of the day, the amount we spend on metal is more than I probably really know what Databricks does, but like whatever they do, the amount that we spend on metal is more than whatever we spend on data.
John Coogan 1:49:44 ↗
Well, well, I mean, reflect on the AI boom, the slop versus steel debate. It felt like AI went through this sort of reset on the narrative towards the back half of last year. Do you have room in your office for a victory lap or are you kind of...
Jordi Hays 1:50:00 ↗
But it feels like we're back to normal. I mean, there's multiple $10 billion deals announced already this year. Nvidia is acquiring stuff for $20 billion, something like that. It feels like the pace is just continuing unabated. There's no real reset there. How did you process like the bubble in venture discourse? Where do you feel like we are now? Where do you think about the new like fundraising landscape, the K-shaped dynamic between the large funds, smaller funds? Like what's your current outlook on the venture capital market broadly?
Delian Asparouhov 1:50:36 ↗
Yeah, I mean it's interesting where like, you know, I won't name names but there's like various venture firms that, you know, have had like funds that they have like half funded, done really great deals out of, and some of these like, you know, top tier names have significant markups even on those investments and still aren't able to like fully close out the fund. So it's like as an LP you're able to like, you know, basically get in immediately, know that your like, you know, LP position is going to be marked up, and a part of it is that you're comparing it that versus like there's so many of these mega, you know, sort of labs, mega rounds where there are so many SPVs that are available that as an LP you're actually trading that against, well, I can just go get the direct position, no fees or much more diminished fees through like an SPV from like a lesser manager. And so you are seeing like, you know, if you look at like, you know, I think there's this like, you know, a graph recently that was just showing like total venture dollars raised by venture firms significantly, like it's still linearly basically down since 2021-22, and that was, you know, shown, I think it was like on Carta or something like that, they were showing basically that data. But I would bet if you looked at like total LP dollars deployed into like tech venture, you know, direct, you know, sort of investments, fund investments, etc., it is almost certainly significantly up since 2021. It's just like Mubadala at some point can access some of these mega rounds just as easily as they can access like directly into, you know, basically like some of the funds that they used to have to, you know, invest into. And so you're getting this odd dynamic where, you know, I think we talked about this even last week a bit, but like a lot of people are doing these like fearless, careless SPVs that are basically like branding exercises for them. So yeah, I think it's like it's a harder time than ever to be an emerging manager. Like there's somebody that like I forget who did this analysis, but it's like it's taking, you know, there's fewer emerging managers taking longer to close. And then it's harder than ever to even as you go and you're like a multi-stage mega fund to still go raise the like equivalent of like the Andreessen $15 billion, you know, sort of total, you know, growth fund. It is non-trivial for people to do that because the things you're going to go invest into in these late stage assets are now, you know, readily accessible directly via the, you know, LPs through all these alternate, you know, sort of vehicles.
Jordi Hays 1:52:39 ↗
And it's not like a huge secret what companies are like the real winners. You don't need to pay fees. It's not like there's like 100 logos. It's like there's like seven logos that matter significant number of dollars. So as an LP, like, you know, why do I care about paying, you know, these fees versus like I know I'm getting into the exact same logo anyways but through this other vehicle.
John Coogan 1:52:59 ↗
So you have sort of like the private Mag 7 that everyone's excited about and LPs are getting direct access to. Is there any effect of the fact that the public 7 are doing so well? I was kind of laughing to myself like if I want exposure broadly to self-driving cars and I buy Google, and humanoids and I buy Tesla, and like there's a number and AI so you buy Google again, and it's like you can get a pretty broad portfolio of like sci-fi bets just by owning the Mag 7, and maybe those get disrupted, maybe you got to pick up other big companies, but it's not like they're completely asleep at the wheel. Is there a little bit of a magnetism from the Mag 7 that might be pulling liquidity towards just public tech companies these days?
Delian Asparouhov 1:53:46 ↗
A bit, but I would say also for most of these LPs they have like, you know, and especially the endowments, they have like pretty clear ratios that they want to maintain across basically like public, private, etc. And so in some ways through the public market, you know, sort of accelerating, they have, you know, if you remember in like 2020 during the crash, there was like the reverse thing basically where like, you know, basically all of a sudden the private books basically weren't, you know, getting marked down nearly enough, they're starting to represent like 20% of an endowment book and they're like we literally have to freeze all private investing. Now you're in some way seeing like, you know, the reverse where, you know, people in some ways counter swung so hard where now some of these groups that want to maintain like a, you know, 7% ratio on private are all of a sudden down to like three and a half and are trying to figure out basically where to deploy. But that's where they're coming with these like, you know, sort of huge checks to the table, but they're seeing that there's like a multitude of options and they want a relatively like, you know, sort of limited set of names and why not just go basically like, you know, more and more direct into those names. And as a founder at some point you're like, well, like I like these venture guys on Sand Hill Road, but at some point when I'm a public company these are going to be the guys that hold my stock when I'm public and so I don't mind prioritizing them, you know, sort of basically directly and having them on board. So in some ways, you know, to tie this all the way back to Hermeus, it's like, yeah, this past round, Hermeus had a multitude of different, you know, offers from, you know, more traditional Silicon Valley venture firms, but it's like, why wouldn't you take a T. Rowe Price where T. Rowe Price is going to be the person that likely just, you know, underwrites part of your IPO, holds it when you're public, you know, scales with you while you're, you know, sort of public. And so you're seeing obviously, you know, those types of firms come in much earlier into venture and then founders by default, you know, sort of prioritizing those. You had obviously had the like wave in like 2021 where a bunch of the VC firms tried to become RAs and enter into like the T. Rowe Price, you know, sort of lane that all mostly obviously turned out to be like a disaster where it was just like these guys are not, you know, sort of public equities, you know, experts and do not understand what it means to, you know, manage that, you know, sort of book appropriately. So I feel like most people have pulled back from that. So I do think, you know, it's a shifting landscape where I just don't think that the current state of liquidity preferences that are given to, you know, like if you invest into a company at $500 billion in the public markets, you do not get a liquidity preference, right? You know, as an investor, I think it's less and less likely that some of these super late stage private companies keep giving that type of liquidity preference to investors. And then I think also the like fee structure on these venture firms is almost certainly going to compress for some of these like super, you know, sort of late stage, you know, types of rounds and funds.

397 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Prince, M. (2026, January 15). Barret is Zo Back, Copper is Metal, Branded Workout Equipment, The BTA Battle, Meta VR Layoffs [Interview transcript]. TBPN. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3006912/

MLA

Matthew Prince. "Barret is Zo Back, Copper is Metal, Branded Workout Equipment, The BTA Battle, Meta VR Layoffs." TBPN, 15 Jan. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3006912/.

BibTeX
@misc{prince2026_3006912,
  author       = {Matthew Prince},
  title        = {Barret is Zo Back, Copper is Metal, Branded Workout Equipment, The BTA Battle, Meta VR Layoffs},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, TBPN. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {jan},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3006912/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}