Bloomberg Audio Studios podcasts, radio, news.
Bloomberg Tech is live from the heart of Silicon Valley with Ed Ludlow in San Francisco.
This is Bloomberg Tech. Coming up, Meta doubles down on AI, boosting its spending outlook as Zuckerberg says its massive investments are starting to pay off. Plus, Tesla beats on profit, but a big cut to its spending plans raises new questions about Musk's AI, robo taxi, and robotics ambitions. And AI reshapes cyber security for both defenders and hackers. We speak with OpenAI president Greg Brockman and Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince.
Let's get right to our top story, and that is Meta shares down almost 7% in the session, on track for their biggest drop since July. I show you the two-day chart because going into earnings there was a lot of buoyancy. It's dragging down technology more broadly. A lot of the chip names also a big drag at the index level.
Meta is creating a new class of non-voting shares, and part of the reason is Mark Zuckerberg. Meta says the CEO was considering leaving California over a proposed wealth tax that could leave him with a multi-billion dollar bill. The new Class C shares give Zuckerberg stock he can sell for cash without immediately reducing his voting control. In return, he's agreed to stay in California or wherever Meta is headquartered for eight years as long as he remains in a full-time leadership role.
That was one story. Let's dive deeper into what else we learned from Meta's earnings report, which was yesterday. Bloomberg's Alexander Lavine is with us. Let's be completely frank about it. The Class C shares story was communicated in a difficult-to-understand way, partly on the call, partly in the earnings statement, but really in a filing, and then there were lots of numbers from earnings. We'll start there. What do we actually learn about how it's going for Meta right now?
Well, we know that Meta delivered really strong third-quarter results, really strong fourth-quarter guidance. They beat analyst estimates on those. And I think that the decision to issue this non-voting stock and Zuckerberg's decision to stay in Silicon Valley to sort of see everything through is a really important statement as Meta enters this next chapter, continues to accelerate into this next chapter. And I think it also just goes to signal that it is confident that its AI bets are paying off, because some of the decision to do this with the shares was, of course, also as the company had said, to help cover some of this enormous AI spending down the line.
Yes, Meta's CFO Susan Lee was asked on the analyst call about the Class C shares, and she said it is a way of diversifying and funding and financing the AI spend that's to come, but she didn't mention the Zuckerberg part of it at all. Capex is narrowed for this year: $135 billion at the bottom end to $145 billion at the top end, which we knew. There seems to be some signals on the direction of travel for Meta. AI seems to be also really boosting the core ad business. What did they say? What were the numbers that they point to to evidence that?
Well, just in the last month, Meta launched these two new products. You had its personal AI agent that was debuted in September, and then you had Meta AI. It's the latest AI model that debuted earlier this month. And what Meta reported was really strong early adoption, strong early traction in all of this. And I think that even though investors do still seem skeptical, as you said, shares fell this morning, even as Zuckerberg and the company projected all this confidence, I think that they are really pointing to the early traction of these products and also the huge number of businesses that are already using their other platforms across their family of apps: Instagram, WhatsApp, Facebook. I think the number that they said was more than 500 million businesses.
They're really pointing to these numbers as evidence that adoption will continue to scale and that it can actually be monetized, which remains the big outstanding question here: how are they actually going to really make money off of all of this. The shares are down 6.5%, on track for the biggest drop since July. But what was weird is when all of this news came out last night, the stock really went up, and things really changed overnight.
Bloomberg's Alexander Lavine, thank you so much for being with us. During Meta's earnings call, Mark Zuckerberg touted the progress of its AI agent tool, Meta AI. We are building out the capacity to serve more than a billion people over the next few years. In the near term, Meta AI is very compute-intensive to run, but we expect to improve its cost efficiency by more than 10x in the next year, which will enable it to be profitable once the revenue lines are at scale.
Let's get more on Meta's results with Minda Smiley, senior analyst at eMarketer. And I want to start with Meta AI. What they also said is that more than 10 million people signed up for Meta AI in the US and Canada in its first six weeks. How do you interpret that data?
Yeah, I mean, that's certainly a good number in terms of early adoption, but I do think when you think about the fact that a lot of these downloads and usage are coming from the fact that Meta has been able to promote Meta AI through its own channels, Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram quite heavily, and they've also just invested a lot of money into marketing Meta AI as well. So I think it kind of waters down those numbers in a way, because I think it points to the fact that a lot of this interest isn't necessarily organic, isn't necessarily genuine. It's really just coming from the fact that people might see something about Meta AI on Instagram, click on it, download it, mess around with it, and then maybe a week later they delete it from their phone.
I've been using Meta AI as much as I can. Like, as somebody interested in technology, if you host a technology news show, you should probably use the technology, right? But I'm still kind of not really using it beyond helping put social posts together. More deep search, maybe it's helping me with my calendar. So I found it interesting that Mark Zuckerberg said that they expect most people to use the free version. The monetization comes elsewhere. Is there any evidence that they've got going on the elsewhere?
Yeah. Well, it's interesting. I mean, they talk a lot about how they hope to maybe collect fees from Meta AI as they help with transactions. One of the stats they pointed out yesterday was that about a quarter of users, or I think they said the main use case at this moment, is shopping, which of course, as a company that's invested quite a lot of money into social commerce, it makes sense that they would want Meta AI to also be a commerce tool. So I think when it comes to monetization, there are a lot of opportunities there. When you think about the fees, when you think about subscriptions, even extending Meta AI to small businesses. But I think a lot of that still remains quite theoretical, right? I mean, there's no guarantee that this will take off. It has to really gain traction with consumers, with businesses, before those monetization lines can really go into effect.
It was still the core ads business that drove the beat, right? I get the stock is down significantly, but ad revenues were more than $63 billion. The street expected below 62. And the interesting point is price per ad, growing at a rate of about 14%, was also beyond expectations. It seems like the AI story really is that they're able to drive higher pricing on ads rather than look at volumes.
Yeah. And it's funny because I think because there's been so much focus on, well, where are they going with AI? What are their ambitions? Everyone wants to hear about Meta AI, and it makes sense, right? They're spending a lot of money. We want to see where they're going with all of this. But the reality is that AI is really fueling their advertising business, which we all know is the core, the bulk of their business model, and it's doing so quite effectively. That's why we continue to see this double-digit growth quarter after quarter, and they keep refining it, keep building on it. And it's helping not only with advertising but also usage and engagement as well.
Minda, I'm not going to ask you to come in here on the mechanics of them issuing a new class of stock. The whole point is that it's structured so that Mark Zuckerberg can sell 20% straight away and cover his tax bill if that were to arise, and 80% is staggered over eight years. But that's the bit I want to talk to you about. Mark Zuckerberg has agreed to stay in role basically for eight years wherever the company's headquartered, California or otherwise. How important is that? You know, the founder CEO continuing to lead efforts like AI.
Yeah, it is important, and it's a question I've been getting recently: you know, what does this all say about Zuckerberg and his commitment to the company, if and when will he step down? And I think it just goes to show that he is committed to this vision. And you know, to what extent it will play out, of course, is a different story. Obviously, we saw what happened with the metaverse. We see that he's going heavily into smart glasses as well, which hasn't gotten as much coverage lately with the launch of Meta AI. But I think it goes to show that he doesn't plan on going anywhere anytime soon.
Minda Smiley, senior analyst at eMarketer. It's been great to have you back on the program. Thank you very much. Coming up, the other earnings story, which was Tesla beats on profit but cuts billions from its spending plans. What that means for Musk's AI, robo taxi, and robotics ambitions. We're going to look at Tesla next. This is Bloomberg Tech.
Okay. Shares of Tesla down, but way off session lows. They were down more than 3% a little earlier. The company beat on profit, but it's the spending outlook that's getting investors' attention. It is cutting its capex plan by more than $5 billion, raising questions about the pace of its AI, robo taxi, and Optimus ambitions. Joining us now is Ben Harwood, New Street Research technology and space infrastructure senior analyst. We'll get to the SpaceX-Tesla merger idea of it all. I mean, yeah, it's really interesting. Capex is being trimmed. Maybe that's just like the reality of how quick they didn't deploy. Does it signal something bigger to you?
No. Hi Ed, thanks for having me on. And the capex cut I see is just mainly a timing issue, and I expect them to ramp up capex, you know, coming into '27 and into 2028. And you mentioned what they're doing on the AI front with FSD, with robo taxi. Actually, everything we saw from that perspective was very positive. So what we saw is that FSD adoption reached again an all-time high. 75% of vehicles now being sold in the US are being sold with FSD, and that's really showing that the new technology that you have with FSD is driving demand, and robo taxi is the fastest scaling.
Let me jump in because the audience knows I use FSD every single day for my 60-mile round-trip commute. I use it. I pay for it myself. But a new Tesla, and I know a lot of the numbers that quarter were existing Tesla owners upgrading, but if you give somebody FSD for free, they might use it for a while. The question is, do they stick with it, right? The take rate, the actual long-term usage.
Do you have a good answer on that?
Yeah, exactly. So that's a good question. So every Tesla owner in the US gets a month for free. What the CFO clarified on the call yesterday when we asked the question is actually 75% of people are buying the technology even when they get it for free. So they'll take it in that first month. So it's very clear that there is a lot of demand for this product. Word is getting out, like I said, 75% of new vehicles are being sold with FSD. That's up 20 points sequentially, and that's going to be up 40 points year on year. So performance of FSD, as you would have noted, Ed, has improved over the past 12 months, and that's really spreading the word, and it's now driving vehicle demand in the US. You know, it's only a US phenomenon now. Hopefully in the first half of next year that technology will be approved in Europe, and then we'll start to see similar numbers coming out of Europe and a strong growth in vehicle demand there.
Ben, very quickly, did you change your price target or call in the stock after last night?
No. So we're still sitting at 600. So very healthy upside from where we are today, but you know, everything that we saw on the quarter was backing up our price target. It's all based upon Tesla becoming an autonomy leader, and exactly what was announced yesterday.
Okay, let's talk about special committees at both Tesla and SpaceX looking at the idea of a merger. Last night Tesla IR said this: they will not be taking questions on the subject, but 24 hours before that Musk disclosed it after he was asked on SpaceX's call. You covered both. You covered the area. What are you modeling for that transaction? How it looks like, who acquires who, and the prices involved.
Yep. Exactly. So we think the acquisition is going to go ahead. It will likely happen by the end of next year, or be announced by the end of next year, so that both the companies and Musk himself can take advantage of the political backdrop that we have right now. I think the Roadster reveal last week really goes to show the fact that there's a lot of collaboration going on between the businesses. I think you'll have SpaceX acquire Tesla, given the fact that Musk has much higher voting control in SpaceX versus Tesla. The Tesla shareholders will want a premium for that acquisition, but you know that there are clear synergies. The Roadster event, as I said, was one of them. But you know, Tesla is a power company. What does SpaceX want? SpaceX wants to roll out data centers. It needs power for that. It will leverage Tesla Megapack.
That's the bit I'm trying to understand. I'm sorry to jump in. You know, Tesla's data center near-term ambition is 400 megawatts. The reach goal for SpaceX next year is 20 gigawatts. Like, those are different scales of commitment. You know, but he talked about the shared goals that they have. It seems like one supporting the other.
Yeah, I would say it's almost two ways. So Tesla can leverage the compute of SpaceX. SpaceX will give Tesla compute that will enable Tesla to improve FSD even faster, ramp up the robo taxi fleet and performance even faster. Tesla will give the Megapack expertise, solar expertise, so SpaceX can roll out its data centers. Even behind the scenes on the rocket front, Tesla provides power components to ensure that they can solve problems on the rocket side of things. But of course, a big objective is for Musk to control one entity as well. But we do see synergies playing out between the two businesses.
Ben Harwood of New Street Research. Great to have you on Bloomberg Tech. Thank you very much. I want to say on that potential merger, Bloomberg's learned there is a push to announce a deal by the first half of next year, with Musk and his advisers looking to get it done while President Trump is still in office. That's all according to sources, and it's the big focus of today's Big Take. Bloomberg's Craig Trudell, who leads our coverage of both companies, is with us. That's the idea, right? It's the environment, as Ben just outlined, that the companies find themselves in, and there is kind of a deadline to get something done.
Yeah, that's absolutely right, Ed. And I think, you know, if we take a step back here, these are two boards stacked with a lot of directors who are quite close with Elon, who go back a long time. Tesla's board, you know, has managed to pull off lining up a pretty incredible pay package for its CEO only just a year ago. So, you know, if and when Elon says jump, there's been a sort of track record there of, you know, them asking how high. So, you know, is that an issue? Probably not. The question I think here is, will there be an administration, you know, to sort of review the prospect of a merger involving such big companies that is going to be supportive? And I think Musk understandably wants to try and make that push while Trump is still in office.
Well, even nearer term, right? We're a couple of weeks away from the midterms, and so from sort of congressional oversight, the makeup of Congress could change. Like, we talk about that in the Big Take.
Yep. Yeah, that's exactly right. And it's not necessarily the case that Congress has all that much of a say here. But it absolutely is the case that, you know, if you're Musk, you're also bracing for the possibility that this could take quite some time. The US, of course, will have a say, but it's not the only country that will have a say. And the fact that China looms so large for Tesla, with such a presence there, and there's some potential conflict there, right, where the fact that SpaceX is a US contractor, a US defense contractor, Starlink doesn't necessarily align with how the CCP, you know, kind of wants their internet to work. Will they have notes and have a view as to whether or not this merger should go through? I think that's one of the big questions here.
I would point out in a regulatory filing they confirmed this morning the special committees. I know it was discussed on the call, and they had the same language, like this isn't a certainty. Just the other thing, of course, is the voting power differences. We're going to get to that in the coming weeks. Bloomberg's Craig Trudell, really great to have you with us. Thank you. Now coming up, IBM, another earnings story, delivered better-than-expected third-quarter results overall, but there's still some concern out there. The stock a little weaker, down seven-tenths of 1%. We got more on those earnings when we return. This is Bloomberg Tech.
IBM delivered better-than-expected sales growth in its third-quarter earnings report, but consulting revenues missed estimates. Ultimately, the numbers have failed to impress investors. There's some concern out there about this shift in corporate technology spending. Joining us to talk more about the earnings is Fatima Bulani, managing director at Citi, who has a buy rating on the stock with a target price of $280. It's interesting because, like, you know, a decline of seven-tenths of a percent is not a lot to write home about, and a lot of what IBM presented was like quite good. There seems to be some worry out there in the market that IBM's just not it right now in the world of technology spending.
Yeah, let me unpack a lot of that, because I think what you're alluding to is IBM is actually a very polarizing stock. Now, just the forensic analysis on the three key print last night, really the headline beats, you know, coming from the infrastructure and software segments of the overall businesses, which in totality are two-thirds of the overall revenue mix. Those are important points to highlight because we saw a reacceleration in those segments, and they indicate to us one very important thing: that the mainframe business is at the very least stable.
Now, you know, in a lot of ways we thought this was a little bit of a surprising redemption quarter on the back of what was a pretty monumental miss for this business back in 2Q. So the fact that this company was able to recapture and recoup two-thirds of these slipped transactions, you know, within a matter of 90 days, we do think that's impressive. But you know, in the same breath, this is not sort of a decisive victory for the bulls, where there is still going to be a lot of work and numbers and execution that IBM is going to have to put up to sort of compel the bears to back off from this narrative around, hey, the mainframe business is under structural duress and existential duress from the AI onslaught from the labs.
That's my question, like, what is IBM in the AI age? Bloomberg's Ryan Vlastelica got on the phone with IBM CEO Arvind Krishna, and you know, he presents that, you know, in the shift to inference, IBM is primed for the AI age. Is that a part of your model?
Yeah, there's a couple of angles to this, right? Our framing here has been IBM is not quite in the AI loser camp, nor are they decisively in the AI winner camp. They're an AI survivor. And we have to remember that IBM is so pervasive in some of the largest and most complex, most heterogeneous IT organizations in the world. So it gives them a pretty important seat at the table, enabling.