Bloomberg Audio Studios podcasts radio news.
This is the Bloomberg Surveillance Podcast. I'm Jonathan Ferro along with Lisa Abramowicz and Amory Hordern. Join us each day for insight from the best in markets, economics, and geopolitics. From our global headquarters in New York City, we are live on Bloomberg Television weekday mornings from 6:00 to 9:00 a.m. Eastern. Subscribe to the podcast on Apple, Spotify, or anywhere else you listen. And as always on the Bloomberg Terminal and the Bloomberg Business app. We begin this hour with stocks drifting lower as bond yields and crude climb. Ed Yardeni of Yardeni Research writing, 'Given where the 10-year yield stands relative to nominal GDP growth, the current sell-off can't be dubbed the revenge of the bond vigilantes. Not just yet.' Joins us now for more. Ed, welcome. How would you describe the sell-off then with yields at multi-decade highs?
Well, I think when you look around the globe, there are different explanations for what's going on. If you're looking for one explanation for the increase in bond yields around the world, we discussed this last time, it's probably the unwind of the yen carry trade. As the Bank of Japan has been raising interest rates, all those hedge funds and speculators that borrowed money in Japan at near-zero rates are now unwinding their positions. They bought a lot of government bonds, I think, and that explains the global rate increase here in the United States. I would say a more important explanation for what's going on is that we've seen an economy that's really on fire. It's booming. Consumer spending is hanging in there really, really well. The baby boomers are retiring and still spending money. Capital spending is absolutely booming. And as you said, the AI hyperscalers and others just keep borrowing more and more. And then, of course, the deficit is extremely large. So I think the kind of happy spin, if there is one, for this backup in bond yields in the US, I think is to a large extent reflecting the strength of the economy. And that's why TIPS, the real rate, has actually been leading the increase in the nominal yield rather than inflation.
Can you put a positive spin on what's happening elsewhere in places like France, Ed?
No. No, I don't think you can really put a positive spin in France. I mean, France is starting to look like a Greek debt crisis. The Greeks had that debt crisis back in 2010. Bond vigilantes pushed the bond yield all the way up to 40%. And that got the attention of the politicians finally, and as a result, the bond yield now in Greece is below the bond yield in France.
So Ed, do you think that they're hitting the danger zone? The idea where suddenly you do enter this doom loop where higher yields beget higher yields without some sort of fiscal solution?
Well, we're certainly heading into the direction of the danger zone. I've kind of called it a spectrum of bond yield scenarios. On the good end of the spectrum is better-than-expected economic growth leading to an increase in the neutral interest rates. Remember, at the beginning of the year, Fed officials were saying that the Fed funds rate was still slightly restrictive. Now the new Fed chair, Waller, has most recently said that the 25 basis point increase in September in the Fed funds rate was eliminating or removing a dose of accommodation. So now all of a sudden, Fed officials are saying that the real rate's higher, and I think that has to do with stronger economic activity. But look, the other factor, of course, is oil prices. They're up a lot today, and the bond yields, the French bond yield is almost at 5%, 4.9% as last I saw. And meanwhile, the US bond yield is kind of relentlessly moving towards 5.12%, and then we'll be starting to talk about, well, where do we settle this thing between five and a half and six.
Ed, you make a lot of great points. One of them is that the bond vigilantes haven't really come out with pitchforks yet about the US deficit. They are responding more to the strength in the US economy, the borrowing binge that we're seeing from AI, as well as higher oil prices. That could be looked at positively and negatively. The negative side is when they start to care, and if there is an additional round of borrowing ahead of the midterms, after the midterms, if there is ongoing costs tied to the war, in addition to any kind of compromise to expand the deficit, how high could they go if the bond vigilantes actually start to take a look at the deficit?
Well, if they started to really focus on the deficit, they could go higher relative to nominal GDP. One way to kind of try to assess the impact of the bond market on the economy is to look at the bond yield, the 10-year bond yield, which is almost 5.15%, relative to nominal GDP growth on a year-over-year basis, and that's running about 6.5%. I would say that the bond vigilante concept would be a real concern if we started to see the bond yield get up to 6% and higher, because I think once you get above nominal GDP, you do start to slow it down. Right now, the economy is less interest rate sensitive. The consumer, I mean, a lot of the retiring baby boomers, if rates are going up, that's a positive for them in terms of money market fund yields. And the AI borrowers, the market, as you said, is still very liquid. There still may be the AI borrowers are the new sovereign bonds in the sense that investors feel actually more comfortable owning them than they feel owning sovereign debt from, certainly from France and maybe even the United States.
Getting to the heart of the issue. What will it take to slow this all down? What does this Federal Reserve need to do? How far are they willing to go? How hard do you think they're willing to go?
Yeah. Well, you know, the Federal Reserve matters, but not as much as it mattered in the past. Partly that's because the economy is less interest rate sensitive. But let's face it, the problem is fiscal policy. Scott Bessent knows that, and he's kind of trapped because, you know, the only solution he really has is what we're seeing now coming out of France. And the Bessent bazooka would be buying back a lot more Treasury bonds and issuing a lot more Treasury bills. That might calm things down, and that's what he might have to do in the event that this thing really gets out of control. And he's basically conceded that he can't control what's going on, which suggests that he's not all that convinced that using the bazooka is going to do much to make this all go away.
Define out of control. What kind of levels do you think potentially then you'd see the Treasury step in?
Well, again, I think it's all relative to nominal GDP. I'd say it's not just the level, but it's also the speed. If we get to 6% very quickly, I think we could start to see some real cracks in the financial system, and that would probably require the Fed to start thinking about liquidity facilities. If we get there kind of in a leisurely fashion, and I don't think it'll do as much damage. But clearly, right now, all the focus is on the increase in bond yields. That's why back in mid-September we turned more cautious on the market because we did start to perceive that between higher and longer oil prices and stronger-than-expected economic growth and all the demand for credit, that we could have a problem in the bond market, and we do.
Stay with us. More Bloomberg Surveillance coming up after this.
US Treasury yields reaching fresh multi-decade highs. A strong 10-year note sale signaling solid investor appetite ahead of a 30-year bond auction this afternoon. And Guy Husseini of Columbia Threadneedle warning this is a dangerous moment for global bonds, writing higher rates have started to unwind leverage trades all around the world. This process often has a slowly-then-suddenly dynamic. Joins us now for more. Hey, good morning.
Would you still describe things as orderly?
I think so. You know, by and large, corporate bond markets have behaved quite well. The sovereign bond markets, like you were mentioning in terms of the auction, has seen solid demand. And even in France, where we're seeing, you know, low liquidity, French spreads have obviously widened out. So far, I would characterize it as orderly, but it's not guaranteed to stay that way.
Well, let's start with the US and maybe we can move to France. The US at the front end of the curve, things have become a bit more anchored around 4.80, particularly given some of the dovish Fed speak we've seen, and that's been reinforced by some of the softer data as well. The question is still being asked ultimately, though, how hard, how fast does this Fed need to go? How hard and how fast do you think this Fed needs to go?
Yeah, I mean, it's been striking to me how quickly we've pivoted away from sort of high conviction coming out of the September FOMC meeting that these guys are going to front-load the tightening cycle to now they have all the time in the world to relax and sit back. It's very strange. I think it's premature given the data that's continued to come in. But all indications are they're going to sit out of the October meeting and then take another look in December. I think they have to go at least three or four more times.
At least three or four more times in quick succession, or can they take their time? In other words, if they don't hike rates in October, do you expect the yield curve to continue to widen out?
You know, I think there was a really strong case coming out of the September meeting of front-loading the process, offsetting some of the heat we see in the economy right now from a growth perspective and seeing how inflation evolves. At the moment, inflation's on track to end up somewhere in the high twos by the beginning of next year. It's not a bad number, but it's still nowhere near the target. And at this stage, it looks like they're taking a little bit more of a lackadaisical approach. The slower they move, the more they might have to do next year. And that's kind of the risk for them.
So, this is what a lot of people are debating, is how much the Fed has any control or influence over what's happening in the 10-year and the 30-year denominations. We hear from Scott Bessent, the Treasury Secretary, this is a global phenomenon. We talked a lot this morning about all of the bond issuance coming from hyperscalers. Would that really have any effect on the long end of the yield curve if the Fed acted more aggressively?
I think the short answer is yes. I think what distinguishes the repricing here in the US so far this year has really been Fed expectations. It hasn't been the term premium. It hasn't been a lot of inflation risk premium further out on the curve. It's really been like the economy has accelerated. The Fed has license to tighten policy here. And the less they do, the more damage they risk to the longer end of the curve. So I think front-loading this tightening process, and again, look, they have a couple of meetings to get their act together, but front-loading it into the end of the year, into the beginning of next year, gives them a better chance of stabilizing that long end. That's not true in France. France is a distinctly fiscal issue. And the hyperscaler issue, again, I think hyperscaler, that premium is showing up in the corporate bond market. The spillover into the Treasury market so far is there, but it's really relatively small.
Ed, three or four more times potentially for the Fed to hike. That says to me this is going to be painful for some parts of society.