In space, it's incredibly hard. You really don't know how hard it is until you've pushed the envelope and failed. And through that process, you learn so much about yourselves, about the company, about the organization, about your technology. You'll find data that you never thought about when you're designing it or testing it. And so you actually have a chance to make a better product.
Welcome to Next in Space here at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Southern California. With this speaker series, we bring industry leaders and futurists together with JPL trailblazers to convene bold conversations about the future of space exploration. My friends, it does not get much bigger than this. Jason and Dave, thank you so much for joining us on the Next in Space stage.
Thanks for having me. Great to be here.
Jason, you graduated from the Air Force Academy and then served for 7 years. Thank you for your service. How did you transition from a military trajectory to the aerospace industry?
Well, I think we talk a lot about culture, and the culture of the Air Force has always been integrity first, service before self, excellence in all we do. And that culture is something that I bring with me everywhere I go. And at Firefly, you know, we took a little spin on that. And so our values are about passion and accountability and collaboration and excellence. And so you could see how, you know, that's made a big impact on me. The other thing I will say is, you know, I got to work on drones before they were popular. This was 1999, right?
And so, it's a full circle moment working on Moonfall for JPL with the drones going to the moon. But back then it was the UAVs, and I was putting payloads on there, and it was all about the mission. That's what the Air Force was about. It was about the mission. It was very mission focused. And so that's something that is important to carry on to industry. At Firefly, it's all about the mission. And I think that's the same way at JPL. I mean, I think of Mars missions and solar system missions, Voyager, incredible missions that just... I got to tour today and I was just like a kid all over again, inspired, in awe. And there's something about being a kid. You know, kids are so innocent. You know, when they see something that they really, really are fascinated about or excited about, that means something. That means you're on to something really great. And kids love JPL. And that's what it made me feel like coming back here today.
That's great. We do public tours here and it is always exciting to see the spark behind the eye and I think, 'Oh, you're going to be my boss someday here.' Dave, you have been at Caltech JPL for over 37 years and held various senior leadership roles. How did you first come to JPL and what has kept you here so long?
First of all, thanks for asking the question and I'm delighted to be here with Jason. We were standing outside talking about all the things we're doing together and it's tremendously exciting. I started a consulting company and JPL was one of my clients and I ended up hiring on just in 1989, just after or just before the Hubble Space Telescope got launched. And my first job was to work on WFPC2, which was the camera to fix the Hubble Space Telescope. I think what's kept me here is you can have multiple careers in one place. And I know the recent generations are very excited to hop around and put more, you know, skills in their backpack. You can actually do that at JPL while staying here. And I think it really sets it apart. I also think the people here are just exceptional. You know, we've been through a pretty rough couple of years, and what keeps me coming back is the quality and the character of the people here.
That's a great answer. JPL is adapting to a new era of NASA exploration. In addition to our focus on cutting-edge flagship science missions, we are focusing on smaller, faster missions that support both science and future human exploration. Could you both talk a little bit about how we accomplish both of these things and how NASA can take advantage of new space capabilities through industry?
I wouldn't necessarily say smaller. I mean, so Moonfall is going to be pretty tall. If you look at it, it's going to carry those drones, which are sizable themselves. I forget what the height is. It's probably close to 15 feet tall. It's not small. Yeah, so it's not small, but it's very affordable. It's a $75 million contract JPL gave to Firefly to build a carrier and a braking system. And a lot of the components that successfully helped us get to the moon and land on Blue Ghost Mission One are being used on Moonfall as well. I think it's a few things. One are commercial best practices. That was displayed on NASA's Commercial Lunar Payload Services contract. NASA said, 'Hey, we're going to put multiple shots on goal with multiple contractors to use commercial best practices. You do it your way. At the end of the day, you deliver the science data.' And so, we bought the launch vehicle, we designed and built the lander, we integrated all the 10 NASA science payloads, and at the end of the day we used the commercial ground telemetry service to get 120 gigabytes of data back to the Earth and then share that with NASA. So that's a different model. It allowed us to do it in less than four years. So quicker. We did that mission, Blue Ghost Mission One, for $101 million. So it was a tenth of previous lander missions. The next thing we're doing, the next evolution, is we're templating that design and building a production line. And so we're taking commercial best practices from the airline world and other places and creating a pulse assembly line in our new clean room that we'd love to have you over, Dave, to come see. It's massive. And we're going to have, you know, 10 to 12 lunar landers simultaneously being built because we have that pulse assembly line. And then vertical integration is really important. That's helping us with keeping on cost and schedule and quality. So we do a lot of stuff in-house, but we also have a great supply chain that we work diligently with to get their prioritization and their dedication to deliver on cost and schedule. So those are the kind of three things that we're doing using commercial best practices.
Fantastic. David, do you have anything to add to that?
Yeah, you know, what I would say is that first of all, we are going to take advantage of product lines exactly like you're describing, and when we design missions to be able to say, 'Here's what's available out there,' and use that as part of the mission design. I don't think this is the end of flagships. You know, things like Clipper on its way, PRIMA, JPL will still and NASA will still continue to do the flagship for the exquisite measurement. That's, you know, you get like in the case of Clipper, it's a six-and-a-half-year trip there, so you kind of get one shot there. You know, we are also fully embracing a much faster cadence. The administrator loves to talk about more shots on goal. And we have four Ignition Day projects: Eagle, Falcon, Moonfall, Skyfall, here central to half of them. We have always been an organization which is focused on mission success and managing risk. And I think the fact that you do get more shots on goal and the cost of launch has gone down so much, it gives us an opportunity. So, we're trying to use those four missions to really tweak our risk assessment and approach to risk. And it's exciting to see what's happening, decisions being made much faster, testing where you can, and maybe, you know, not getting 20 signatures to close out a problem failure report. You know, empower the cognizant engineers and the group supervisors and managers. So, it's really exciting to see, and the great thing is we'll see the results of this experiment in pretty short order. So, one way or another, it's a pretty dense launch schedule through the end of 2028 into 2029.
Yes, we have five, maybe six that I can think of off the top of my head that are all supposed to launch in 2028. So it's going to be very, very exciting. Jason, environmental testing. I want to talk a little bit about the Blue Ghost lander. Environmental testing for Blue Ghost, the first fully successful commercial lunar lander, happened just up the hill from where we are now at JPL's environmental testing lab. You talked a lot about the future of the Blue Ghost mission and multiple landers. What were the lessons learned from your first Blue Ghost mission, and how do you apply those to those upcoming projects?
Yeah, we learned a lot. I think the biggest thing we learned is we don't know enough about the moon. Literally temperatures, how the dust, the regolith affects radiators and sensors and instruments, how far you can drill into the moon's surface. That surprised us. But you know, it was exactly two years ago from this month that I came and visited the Firefly team going through environmental test here at JPL, and it's why I'm so grateful for JPL. I mean, we get to do vibe test and thermovac test in this historic site. We are licensing some of the technology from JPL and commercializing it, like F Prime. We got the honor... Yeah, great software. We have the honor to support Moonfall and Skyfall. You know, our second Blue Ghost mission to the far side is going to take the JPL user terminal technology, and then we got some launches as well. And so just, I'm so grateful to JPL, Dave. Thank you and your team for everything that you're doing with us. But yeah, the things that we learned were, you know, y'all like surprises, right? I heard about Galileo and some of the challenges that were experienced there, but then it spawned new technologies like compression technology. That's pretty amazing. Well, we had something similar. We experienced higher temperature ranges than was predicted through Apollo-era kind of modeling of that data. There was a huge range of over 500 degrees in temperature swings, and we did not anticipate that. We did test all of our subsystems in the vehicle with margin, so we were good. Everything survived, but it impacted the conops. You know, we weren't able to download data when our radio was getting overheated. What was happening was the sun's rays were hitting our vehicle, which we modeled, but then we didn't model the crater that was next to us that was reflecting back on the back side of our vehicle. We also had dust on our radiator, which made the radiator not as effective. And so all those things combined meant, hey, we had to load shed, we had to do things differently to communicate and downlink the data and talk to the vehicle. So the team came up with something really cool, it's called Project Parasol. And so there was a big GPS antenna because, you know, that was one of the experiments, was to sense GPS from the lunar surface, which, you know, the team did successfully with the Italian Space Agency. But the antenna, the team said, 'Hey, we can turn that into a sunshade.' And so they moved it around and got it in the right angle to shade where the radio was. And it gave us enough margin to downlink the data and continue the mission. So that's one example of something that we learned. And now every radiator that we're going to have on every single lunar lander mission is going to have a cover on it, and that's going to help it from getting the susceptibility to the regolith. And then we just know that much more information and sharing it with the rest of the community too, so that they know as well.
That's fantastic. I want to talk a little bit about learning from failure and how failure can bring sort of revolutionary acceleration, innovation. You mentioned Galileo as a good example of that. Galileo was an incredibly successful mission, but the antenna didn't deploy, and that led to technology that we use today. Could you both share a time in your work or personal lives which you look back and feel grateful for a perceived failure because of the lessons learned or the success that sprung from that failure?
I'm going to share something from work. I think Jason should share from his personal life. So, I'm just joking. I was the project manager on a project called SIM, the Space Interferometry Mission. And one of the things I learned on SIM, and by the way, SIM never got off the ground. And it's, you know, it's sort of two aspects I'll say to it. When the politics at the time, with Maryland politics and Alabama politics, basically SIM got behind James Webb, or what was then the Next Generation Space Telescope. And so I had a crash course in politics, and it really has helped me because after that I had a multitude of jobs where I spent a huge amount of time on the Hill and ultimately ran legislative affairs for JPL. And, you know, I now have a much deeper knowledge about how Washington works, and it's kind of its own place that makes its own weather and normal rules don't apply. On the technical side, tons of technology that we developed for SIM. SIM was an extraordinarily difficult optical instrument, all kinds of deformable mirror delay lines, actuated optics, metrology systems, picometer metrology systems. All of that stuff has led to successful JPL missions, successful classified missions that have done extraordinarily important things for our country. And so it sort of feels like we would have never invested in metrology systems like that, you know, if not for SIM trying to get, you know, SIM approved. It was a decadal-supported mission, and the fact that it didn't just die and go away. But the coronagraph is just loaded with technology that started on SIM. That's the Nancy Grace Roman CGI coronagraph instrument, which will ultimately be what ends up on Habitable Worlds Observatory as well. So, to me, it still stings a little bit that we kind of got politically bamboozled. It also didn't help that SIM, the exciting science that SIM creates, it's a fantastic exoplanet instrument, and the data deliverable is fringes. So you compare fringes with wiggly lines, fringes with the images coming from James Webb. It's a hard sell. So, but anyway, it was a really good lesson for me in both the political and technical arena.
That's great. Jason, something from your personal life. No, I'm just kidding.
Whatever. Oh, I got plenty of those. But about three years ago from yesterday, Firefly was part of a US Space Force mission called Victus Knox. It was the first time that a company launched on a 24-hour call-up from the general. And successfully deployed, at the time, my national security satellite into orbit, flawless launch, and really created this new capability called tactically responsive space. There will be many more. We have several more on contract. The team made it look easy, but it wasn't easy because what had happened was there was a supplier avionics box that was malfunctioning before the launch, and, you know, the countdown was counting. And so that failure turned into an opportunity because the Firefly team, what they did was they said, 'Hey, we've got this R&D avionics flight computer that we've been building in-house. Let's see if we can quickly make that functional and replace that box.' And they did, and it worked out great. It led to Firefly bringing avionics in-house, and now we've got our own flight computers that are being used on our rockets, on our lunar landers, on our orbiters, and all the above. So, it really was a failure that led to an opportunity that is fortuitous for the community.
Fantastic. I want to transition to our show and tell segment. We ask our guests to bring in an object from their professional or personal lives that inspires or speaks to their work. Dave, I see a jewelry box or something on the table there. What was the significance of that? Show it and talk about it. Make sure the camera gets a good shot of it.
Okay. So, this is a piece of multi-layer insulation that was removed from the Hubble Space Telescope when the astronauts installed the Wide Field Planetary Camera 2, which corrected for the spherical aberration on Hubble. For those of you who don't remember, which is most of you, Hubble launched and was a national embarrassment. It was, you know, Jay Leno was making fun of it. It was on the cover of all the papers, the trouble with Hubble, Mr. Magoo with the magnifying glass, the whole works. And I was responsible for building and testing the team that built and tested the instruments, trained the astronauts, and all that. And it was extremely early in my career and very inexperienced, and it was just a huge success. And it was just, you know, it culminated in the middle of the night at Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore watching the... and the original Hubble images were crappy. They were worse than a good ground-based telescope. So you made this huge investment, put this 2.4-meter telescope in space, and you have nothing. So we're there in the middle of the night, and the first corrected images start coming down, you know, no flat-screen monitors, a giant huge, you know, 2,000-pound CRT, and this image starts rastering down from the top, and people just completely lost their minds. Aren't you glad I said minds? And they... I mean, it was loaded with galaxies and stars, and it was unlike anything anybody had ever seen, and people were crying. People were... and it was just fantastic and a wonderful way to kick off a career here. So I keep that in my office as a reminder. Story Musgrave brought that back.
I was going to ask how you got a piece of it. Fantastic. Now, Jason, I'm assuming this isn't just a fancy lamp of some kind. May I help you? It's surprisingly light.
This is a foot pad that we designed and built in-house, and it's carbon composites on the bottom. And there's usually a large carbon composite rod that goes, that's attached to this, and it has honeycomb aluminum crumple zones as well. So, I'll compare it to my nice socks here. You can see the size of the foot pad. It's not much bigger than a human leg. This is what landed on the moon successfully. And there were sensors on there that tripped once we successfully landed and were stable, that told us that, hey, the foot pad's green. But what was interesting about this is the team was very capital efficient. And what I mean by that is it would have been very expensive to try to simulate this landing through traditional means. So what did they do? They went to Home Depot and got a child's sand lot green turtle, you know, little kid pool, filled it up with sand and, you know, lunar simulant, and got a leg press machine. You know about that, right? You got big muscles. They used that to hundreds of times test this out, and it was effective. It worked. But you can see an intern on the leg press. We do have a lot of interns, but this, you can't make this stuff up. I mean, there's pictures of, you know, the turtle pool and the team testing this out, but it worked. You know, it was just very creative. And we talk a lot about at Firefly outthinking the problem instead of throwing bodies or dollars at it. And that's a perfect example of doing that.
Fantastic. Where does this live?
Well, Mare Crisium on the moon.
No, sorry. This actual one.
You know, we have different places around our 200-acre campus that we have, you know, all these hardware pieces. We should create a museum or something someday.
Someday. Yeah, I'm sure you will. Very cool. Thank you for bringing those in. I really appreciate it. Amazing. JPL and Firefly, I want to drill down a little bit on Moonfall and Skyfall. We're working on these incredibly ambitious projects right now. What makes this specific collaboration so effective in bridging the gap between legacy NASA JPL expertise and commercial agility?