That's right, Mr. Finchley. You can own a share of American business. There are over 1,200 companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange, companies which employ more than 11 million people, produce half of all the goods made in America.
Welcome. This is Ask the Compound, the show where you ask and we answer. I am Ben Carlson. Why are luxury stocks crashing in a K-shaped economy? How do you force yourself to put a big pile of cash to work in the markets? Why are energy stocks outperforming even technology stocks in the 2020s? And is housing a terrible investment right now? We're going to answer these questions and more on today's show. Let's do it.
Ask the
[email protected] is our email address. Every week, dozens and dozens of questions coming in. We've got hundreds in the inbox.
It's true. Live chat.
Give us your questions. We'll take them live on the air. Josh is going to be here today. It's a lot of fun. Today's show is brought to you by Exhibit A.
I'm not only a contributor, I'm a user. Financial advisers presenting to a client: what matters more than what you say is what you see. So your words fade into the background. Why settle for outdated, off-brand, screenshotted charts when you only get one chance at a first impression? 200 daily updated visuals on Exhibit A, custom branded so they look like they're built in-house. Your colors, your logo. I am now ghostwriting eight monthly and four quarterly market updates for clients. I have a bunch of charts in there. I give some commentary so you can use it for a presentation, a newsletter, a social post. Exhibit A turns complicated market visuals into stuff clients actually understand. Spend less time building charts and more time helping clients. Free 7-day trial at exhibitaforadvice.com.
I love it. Chart Matt's doing great work over there.
It's like having Chart Matt in your pocket.
That's right. Before we get into it, one of the running bits in the show is you have always been very open about sharing your stock picks. Last week you were freaking out about AI. The AI trade comes back this week. Last night you slapped me and you said, 'What did you say?' You said, 'We're back.'
Yeah.
Today you said you wanted to die.
Okay. So, yesterday last night we're back, baby. Today I'm dead inside, 'cause Oatly is crashing today, down almost 30%.
Yeah. So, why did you go from 'we're back' to 'I'm dead' in the span of 12 hours?
Well, I mean, Oatly reported, and diesel and freight is killing them even though they had revenue growth.
So, this is a stock that was up 50% year-to-date through August. You were just, you know, walking on clouds. You were amazing in the world.
Yeah. Back to all the emotions. It's all the feelings, right?
You were on Cloud 9 and now you're...
I was talking about one of my IRAs yesterday, was doing really well because it's very tech and AI heavy. So, but yeah, woke me up from my dream.
All right. Got a lot of good questions. I love it, Duncan, that you are the roller coaster of emotions.
Well, did you like my joke though? I said they should start paying out a dividend in oat milk quarterly. They should just, since it's been such a bad stock, they should just give away some oatmeal.
They should give you something. You are like the number one fan. All right, let's get into the questions.
First today, we got one from Charlie. Josh's recent talk on WealthPod discussed direct indexing being a differentiator for advisers. As someone who works in the financial planning industry, I typically describe these products as a more tax-efficient way to invest outside of retirement accounts, albeit with a higher fee than a standard low-cost index fund. Is the juice worth the squeeze? What say you?
All right, you ask for Josh, you get Josh. Let's bring him on.
Dude.
Ben says, 'Oatly, Duncan's favorite stock, was up 50% year-to-date and now it's down. This is why the stock market is the greatest game in the world.' And Duncan's like... The look on Duncan's face. Oh yeah. Is it great?
The greatest show. It's the greatest show in town, right?
No. No. We're on the greatest show in town right now.
All right. So, you spoke to Roger Paradiso at Future Proof, did a live — he's from OAY Franklin Templeton. And we've got some questions on direct indexing in the past. And I think there's a lot of people who think, like, why would I ever need to use a tool like this when ETFs exist? And now that you guys did a really good job kind of going through — and this is something we've used for clients for years — I think this is more of a wealth management tool than it is something that any DIY person can plug and play. That's the idea, right? You have to have the right circumstances for it. It's not for everyone.
Yeah. They rolled this out to retail — Vanguard, Schwab. I'm sure they got people to use it. Like if you message people enough, like clients on whatever platform, you'll get people to try things. But it never really caught on as a retail product because this idea of harvesting tax losses throughout the course of the year or managing the gains in a very highly concentrated position where you're looking to dial the amount of tax liability you're accepting in each year — like, this is sophisticated stuff that is not applicable to the sub-$1 million household, or it's only a little bit applicable, but there's better ways to skin the cat. I think this is a wealth management pro...
Look, it's a recurring theme that you will see in finance: something gains popularity with high net worth, ultra-high net worth investors, or with institutions, or with endowments, the product people at these firms will always say, 'Well, let's see if we can create a version of this for retail.' Always, right?
And sometimes it's a thing and sometimes it's not. I think in this case it just isn't important enough for it to have caught fire. But look, if you're managing money for people that have concentrated positions, historically there have been different things that you could do. The big wirehouses had these giant funds that you could contribute your appreciated stock to, and they would eat that stock and give you back a diversified portfolio of other people's stock. They call it an exchange fund. Like, there have always been tools for deferring taxable gains or managing concentration risk. There are option strategies. There's a whole bunch of things you could do. We think that the direct index and custom indexing tools that we use make for a really elegant, complex yet simple answer to that problem.
Yeah. And I look at it more — first of all, it's a technology platform and it's more of a financial planning tool than an investment tool. Investing is part of it, but yeah, it's tax loss harvesting and concentrated position management. You can use options to hedge. You can do long-short stuff. It's more — you can exclude certain stocks if you have exposures to some places. So it's for people who have the right circumstances. So yeah, it's never going to overtake the ETFs. But for people in wealth management, we've seen most of our new money above a certain wealth level is going into this product because it is really useful for the right people.
Yeah, look, if you can get somebody index-like returns and you could exclude certain things that are a risk factor to that client, including stocks that are in the economic sector that they work in, for example, and you can harvest losses throughout — like, one of the charts that we use to explain this to prospective clients who reach out to Ritholtz Wealth, we show them, like, all right, here's the return of the market for a given year. Now, here's how many stocks in the index were down 20% or more. Those were all opportunities to book losses against the gains that you got at the market level. Like, that's to me, that's the power of that strategy. It's not appropriate for everyone. It doesn't always have a use case for everyone. We're obviously, you know, working on post-tax money for the most part in this area. Like, it's for specific use cases. I think, look, I think it's been incredible for our practice. It's helped us help a lot of people, and, you know, but it's — we're holding a hammer. Not everything is a nail, right?
Yeah. I think the average is like 30% of stocks in the S&P are down in a given year, and every year Duncan picks from that basket.
He only buys those stocks.
You know what? I've had some winners, you know.
All right. Duncan's been on the AI train. All right. Yeah. But yeah, some people in the chat are saying this is a solution looking for a problem. It's not though. There are problems that this can solve. It's just not for everyone.
Look at Duncan's stock. It lost half its value since August. I love this game. This is the greatest...
Beautiful. It's perfect entertainment, Duncan. All right, let's do another question.
The one that bothers me more, because Oatly I've always known, you know, it's a small $200 million market cap or whatever. Corning — I'm down in Corning. That one bothers me.
How are you down in Corning? They make fiber optic.
'Cause you missed the rotation, bro.
Yeah, I guess those stocks — they're in favor, then they're out of favor.
I averaged up. That was my problem. I kept buying it. And now...
Do you use stop losses on any positions?
So, that's how you're down in Corning.
I mean, that was a huge winner. You gave it all back, or you bought at the top, or...
I'm basically at cost basis.
Oh, listen. I'm down in stocks, too. It's not, you know...
Yeah, it was like 240 a while back.
It's not easy. It's not easy for anybody.
Yeah, I always have CrowdStrike at least.
This is why we got to laugh about it.
Speaking of stop losses, Philly Fanatic's in the chat. 'Hey Duncan, mention Nike to Josh.' Okay, that's why we use stop losses. I think I bought it at 40 and sold out at 40.
I did the same thing. I bought Nike and I thought, 'Nope, I'm wrong. I'm out of here.'
Almost everyone here bought Nike at some point, it seems like. Yes, we all tried. All right, that's...
I'll do it and I'll do it again. Philly Fanatic.
We can't let go of our youth.
All right, let's do another question.
Okay. Up next, we got one from Nathan. How do you personally force yourself to allocate as cash comes in? I'm guessing I'm in a somewhat similar situation to you, working as an adviser with a couple of different income sources coming in, and I've got a rental real estate portfolio along with a couple of other business interests. I've got myself on autopilot on the retirement plans for myself and spouse. I do buy some stocks and ETFs when I feel an opportunity arises, but I'm constantly accumulating cash and find it very difficult to force that into the market. And it seems way easier to buy real estate with those six-figure amounts than to dump it into the market.
Big time 'not to brag' of the day here. This is just dripping with this.
It also has me picturing Josh as a landlord. It's a financial adviser who's having trouble putting money into stocks for himself. Is that...
I was going to point that out. Yes. It's funny that even financial advisers — I was going to ask him what advice would he give his clients that have this problem? Like, he should be giving it to himself. So obviously he's talking about six-figure amounts. The amount here doesn't matter. Like, you're an adviser. Do you have written investment guidelines in place to put this? Like, this is what happens when you don't. He said he's got some stuff automated, but when you just let cash build up and it forces you to make ad hoc decisions, like, this guy needs some sort of ceilings on these things.
Well, in his defense, he's probably galaxy-braining this, right? He's really overthinking and trying to make sure he outperforms and...
But I think this is true for a lot of people. If you get a bonus or even like a tax refund or something, that money feels different than getting paid from your paycheck, right? So you have this big lump sum and it's like you kind of freeze and you have this paralysis by analysis kind of thing, and it's, 'What do I do?' And I look at this like any sort of asset allocation decision — like, you should have a certain percentage in mind that you're going to put in your brokerage, and you're going to put in your SEP IRA, and you're going to put in your travel fund or your emergency fund or your debt repayment fund or whatever it is, or your 'I'm going to spend this on something enjoyable right now.' Like, you should have some personal thresholds, and one of them should be for real estate. He's saying, 'Well, I just end up buying more rental properties or something.' Like, you should have some sort of bucket for those real estate properties that you won't go above a certain point, so you know where to put the rest of the cash when that part is built up of your portfolio. Like, he should have rules in place. That's obvious. He's an adviser.
Yeah, it sounds like he's making more money than he expected. That's why it's like this sudden...
Oh, I just built my clients and my practice and I'm doing really well, and it's more than he thought it would be. That's what it sounds like.
Which, listen, we're in a bull market. Like, it ain't always going to be that way. One of these quarters it's going to be less than you thought it was. So I don't — I can only speak to what I do. So the number one thing in this world I don't need more of is stock market exposure. So I am the CEO of the firm. I am the largest individual shareholder now. And basically my net worth rises and falls with the stock and bond markets because that's what our clients are invested in and that's the base that we're billing off of. So for better or for worse, I live and die by what the S&P and the Treasury bond market are going to do, give or take, right? So I have tons of personal stock exposure indirectly via my ownership of an RIA. So, I guess that's instructive for this person. It sounds like he owns a firm or he owns a practice or whatever the case.
He's probably investing in real estate to diversify. I'm sure that's...
That's what I was thinking. He's saying the same thing as Josh. He doesn't [want] stock market.
So I'm investing in real estate to stay married. And let me explain to you exactly what I mean by that. So I'm living and dying anyway based on the valuation of my firm. Like, this is most of my net worth, right? We have a ton of equity exposure, right?
Okay. But then also my retirement accounts — I'm fully funding them as soon as possible every year, and they are 100% invested in stocks for the most part. Like, if I have a SEP IRA, 401k, all these things, everything is stocks. Literally my 401k is the same allocations that we invest in for clients, except no bonds, because that's the way I am. That's the way I'm wired.
Okay. So I'm doing that. It's automated. I don't look at, 'Oh, should I do more this, more that?' It's just whatever the formula is, that's what it goes in as — another decision that I don't want to make, right? On the... then I have a spite account. This is a true story at Public. I have a spite account, and the spite account is 25% gold, 25% Bitcoin, 25% Solana, and 25% ETH. These are four things that I think are nonsense, but I can't — but they periodically... they...
Are you staking the Solana?
I'm not staking the Solana. I've been told I've been... So I do this at public.com. I use the Public app. It's a set dollar amount. This is post-tax dollars, not a retirement account. It's a set dollar amount that gets diverted from my bank account into those asset classes in equal weights. The gold part is more than 25% because it's doing better than the other three pieces of... I don't believe in allocating to any of these things. However, if they work, I can't not have any. So, and I wish I were joking around — like, I'll show you a screenshot on Public. You can title the account. It says 'Josh's Spite Account.' And this is my mental emotional hedge because I can't let all these dirtbags on Twitter be making money in something that I'm not. And I know occasionally those things go up. Okay. So I'm doing that.
Then I have a liftoff account. My wife and I maintain an account — not a liftoff, a Good Advice account here at Ritholtz. So we're investing right alongside our Good Advice clients. It was liftoff originally when we were running that through Betterment, and now it's graduated. So we do that. But then the real thing that we're doing is we're buying South Florida real estate. My wife doesn't like living in the Northeast. She hates the weather. She has her whole life. She invented a fake disease that she tells me she has: Raynaud's disease. If anyone in the chat has ever heard of this, feel free to correct me. I think it's fake. But basically...
You know, it's funny. We had one of our advisers move to Florida from Cincinnati, Adam Day. And he said, 'My wife always told me that she was miserable in the weather up north, and she moved to Florida and she's happier.' He's like, 'I think it was actually a thing.'
All right. So she's saying I have Raynaud's disease, which is her fingertips, her toes, and the tip of her nose aren't getting enough circulation in the winter, and it's so painful that she has to live in Boca Raton. So we bought an apartment during the pandemic, like everyone else, from Long Island. It's appreciated in value. So of course we have to sell that. Now we're buying an even better apartment. It's new construction. It won't be ready for four years. So basically what ends up happening is I have to keep a lot of money in cash because I get capital calls for the construction. So every time the developer hits a milestone, they send an email: 'We need a wire for another 10%. We need 30%.' So we have to stay liquid for that. So fortunately there's an interest rate on the money market. So that's what I do. But all of this is automated. Like, I have to make so many decisions as a business owner and an investor every day. The last thing I want is to be like, 'Oh, I just got a lump sum, right?'
What do I do with it? I don't even think about it. It's either going to Boca Raton new construction, or it's going to the spite account, or it's automatically going into the 401k or the Good Advice account, and that's the end of it, and I'm not touching it.
Yes, that's the point. Jason in the chat says, 'Anytime his cash position in his account gets more than 10%, he puts it in the market.' Like, you need to have something like that to guide your actions. And if your place isn't done before four years, Sherry is going to have no fingertips left.
Dude, let's hope it gets built. Let's hope it gets built at all. Florida is the wild west. There's a Mandarin Oriental hotel and condominium project. It's an entire city block in Boca Raton overlooking the golf course. This is like a billion-dollar project.
Wait, are you getting a casino too then, or is it just a hotel?
No, I wouldn't live there. I don't want hotel combined with residents. I hate that. I don't want to share amenities with wackos from Disneyland. But it's like a billion-dollar project. You should see the size of this. The guy, the developer, filed for bankruptcy twice, maybe three times. Like, they keep stopping doing it right.
This project's been going on for 10 years.
The data centers are taking all the construction workers.
Yeah, dude. I think it's because he's trying to finance it in the junk bond market, and either way, like...
So anyway, that's like — I don't even know what question we're answering.
Well, actually, back to Nathan's question real fast. One of my favorite parts of your book, Backstage Wall Street, is talking about murder holes. What is a murder hole right now that he should definitely not be putting his money into?
Boca Raton new construction condominiums.
Fair enough. No, a murder hole is anything where it's an unreasonably high interest rate and you think you're getting it because you're special, or you managed to meet the right person on an airplane or something.
You should not have to reach for yield in this market. This is not the time to reach for yield. You don't have to anymore.
No, not at all. I mean, finance a data center that Google is building. You'll be fine. Like, you could buy corporate bonds. You could buy convertible preferred. Meta just issued 6.5% paper. It'll convert into common stock in 2029. It's a little bit of a reach for yield, but you don't have to do dumb off-market private deals. It's unnecessary.
Yeah. All right, let's do another question.
Okay, up next we got one from Lee. When you were talking about the $8 water and $700 concert tickets — this was on, what are your thoughts? You spoke about how — or was it TCAF, one of them? You spoke about how there's no limit to what people will pay to be in a place that's cool, and how companies are banking on the middle class wanting the same things as wealthy consumers with the help of algorithms. In light of this, I'm curious what you think accounts for the plummeting of luxury fashion stocks like Hermès — is that how you say it? — LVMH and Kering, who owns Gucci and...
Kering. Kering is Gucci and Prada, I think, and then Hermès is Hermès. LVMH is Louis Vuitton and like 60 other brands.
Oh, Kering also owns — oh no, there's another one, Richemont, which is like Montblanc pens, and there's like four — it's like four true luxury conglomerates.
This is my shopping list for next week in Milan. I'm going to be at all the nice places like that and come back with a Gucci bag and so...
So Milan is Ferragamo. That's the home of Ferragamo and Prada. So...
So yeah, Lee just wraps it up by saying, do you think consumers are only open to paying a premium for premier experiences but not luxury products?
This is a great question. I think it's legitimate too because it's like, hey, we hear about this K-shaped economy and people paying for stuff. Why is it? I do think there is something to the idea of the experiences and the stuff you can post on social media mattering more now and carrying more weight than showing off what you can wear materially. How many more people can you reach on social media showing that picture of the trip versus the handbag that you have to show the dozens of people you know in your real life? But let's hear — I have the chart here. Do a chart on Daniel. This is all those companies we mentioned. They're all in some state of drawdown of 35, 40, 50. That's huge.
Burberry was down 60%, came back, and now it's still down like 35. So these companies are all down. Three of them are down 50% or more.
Right. Prada. So LVMH is down more than that.
I think BlackBerry's outperformed Burberry.