I sort of always like the east side better than the west side. Just personally,
It depends what for. See, I think the west side doesn't skip a beat on the water, right? Cuz you got...
But just the whole strip, right? So, you obviously have Battery Park, Tribeca, then you got Soho, Meat Packing,
We're not going to go that far from the train station, but you know what I mean. Like, and then soon and you got Chelsea, Hudson Yards, even Hell's Kitchen's kind of fun on the, you know, the right environment. And then you've got Upper West, Lincoln Square, and then Upper West, which is where I am. And like the whole stretch is just beautiful.
I love the Upper West side.
See, I mean that's the only I lived in Tribeca that when I was single.
Yeah. So, also Alice, it is okay. When we when we start when the show starts properly, you could drop the Halloween British accent and talk normally.
Yeah, exactly. Uh you like on Riverside or
Yeah, I'm on Riverside Boulevard.
One of my favorite neighborhoods.
Oh, yeah. I love it. You know it. Um, my best friend after college, I so I was upper east, he was all the way there, so it's a pain in the ass to go see him, but like
I love that neighborhood.
It's changed completely. So they've they they built the park all the way south to 59th Street now, all on on the water, so
You can run all the way down.
All the way down, and you've got obviously the the [laughter] boat basin.
Oh, it's up on 90 something.
Okay, cuz that's a whole thing also in the summers. Yeah. Yeah. I've got a friend who owns one of those.
Have you ever been there?
It's like a restaurant boat thing.
I I've I think the Upper West Side's beautiful. I also I like Hudson Yards. I would work there.
Hudson, but the but the office is expenses there. It's like
It's $250 a square foot to touch anything on a decently high floor.
I don't It doesn't make sense for us. We're not in the We're not in the two and 20 world. So, um I
Yeah. So, I I think we'll we'll figure it out, but uh I'm delaying that project as long as possible because it's it's a big decision. You got to sign 10-year leases in Manhattan.
Listen, like a lot could happen in the next 18 months. We'll talk a bit about it on this on this pod, I guess. But like, yes, you know, you you could see I mean, it's very plausible that we see a recession before the next election and you might actually get a decent opportunity to scoop some commercial real estate at like attractive prices. A bunch of businesses go pop. Oh, the whole city, God willing.
Lit literally [laughter] anything could happen.
Anything for a good deal. All right, let's go.
Yeah, boys. How we doing? [applause]
It's the compound episode.
Curious about crypto and not sure where to start? Start with Grayscale. Grayscale is the world's largest crypto-focused investment platform and has been in crypto for over a decade. That's a long time when you consider how early we still are in crypto adoption. In markets like these, education matters more than ever. Grayscale provides research, insights, and long-term perspective to help investors better understand digital assets and the evolving crypto ecosystem. Whether you're exploring crypto for the first time or looking to deepen your knowledge, let Grayscale be your guide.
Thank you, Thing One. We appreciate it. Miss Nicole in Halloween regalia. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the best investing podcast in the world. Four out of five dentists say the compound and friends is where they get all their financial news. We appreciate that. [cheering] We have a new guest. I'm so excited. I've been looking forward [screaming] to this conversation since we booked it. Uh I'm really pumped for this. Our [music] guest today is Alex Alman. People call you Alti, I've been told. Is that a thing?
There's a story to that, but yeah, sure.
All right. You'll get into that in one second. Alex is managing director and global head of equities, tactical strategies at Barclays, where he generates thematic ideas and market content for the bank's equities and global markets clients. The Barclays Equity Tactical Strategies or BETS team generates tactical ideas from the trading desk and turns them into research for clients. Before Barclays, Alex was a macro portfolio manager at Millennium and spent a decade running equity trading strategy at Citi. So, he's seen [music] the markets from both the buy side and the sell side. Alex, thank you for being here. We really appreciate it.
The crowd is going wild. Can you hear that? It's unbelievable. It's an exception. Uh for the benefit of the audience, how do you define the term tactical and what is different about the work you do at Barclays versus other tactical trading desks or research groups that refer to themselves as tactical?
Sure. Okay. Well, again, thanks for having me, guys. I mean, tactical is a really easy answer. It just means it's camouflaged and, you know, has has weapons involved, right?
Yeah, exactly. Just unnecessary pockets. No, I mean like tactical in the in the traditional sense of of of Wall Street will mean that rather than thinking about your typical research outfit that will look at 6, 12, even longer time horizon, 6, 12 months, uh we we'll we're kind of trafficking in the shorter time horizon, more suited but not exclusively to the fast money community. So we're thinking one week, two week, four week, maybe you know eight weeks ahead, not really much beyond that. We have thematic views. We've, you know, we have views that have sort of been prevailing for for months if not years in some cases on some structural opinions. But we're generally trying to think four to eight weeks out and say, 'All right, how are we going to make money? What what are markets are going to want to do? Where's the best asymmetry?' And then the other aspect about the tactical consideration is we we traffic a lot in verticals of the market that your traditional research outfits tend to not cover. So we'll think about positioning, derivatives, quant, what are hedge funds up to, you know, and and and these are really important verticals or pillars of the investment process that quite frankly all of the buy side are doing, but a lot of the sell side still kind of don't cover from a traditional research perspective. So we try to basically match the desk investment process to what the buy sides or the guys that we typically talk to what they're doing and that way we can have a pretty sort of like head-to-head convergence. Funds want to know what other hedge funds are up to.
And not purely like from a gossipy sense like they want to probably, but they want to know. So positioning has become something really important in the market. Michael and I joke about it. Anytime there's something going on in the market and we can't explain it, we go
But it's but people want to know, people that are managing money professionally want to know what their peers are doing and they I think they recognize the limitations of like a traditional portfolio manager survey which sort of just comes out like group think. Um so you so I guess you guys become a repository for well here's what your peers are, here are the trades that people are putting on and why, that that that's one aspect of it.
And then there's other aspects about positioning. Okay. So positioning can be instructive because obviously flow tends to dictate price right and price dictates narrative. So in theory you can carve up and quite frankly I do follow this mantra which is if you know if there's a positioning asymmetry that has been built in the market, how does it have the propensity to change price in a very asymmetric way and in doing so can shift the market's perception of a narrative.
And situational awareness was a perfect example of that.
Perfect example of it, right? And you get that periodically throughout any given year. You just need to have a framework in place that allows you to kind of monitor a lot of things simultaneously. So are we monitoring single stock positioning? I mean we can is the short answer but we don't because generally if you aggregate up to like theme, sector, quant, style
Good enough and and of of course like aggregate market. So you want to know how are hedge funds positioned? How are mutual funds positioned? How are CTAs positioned? How are vol control and QIS strategies positioned? How is risk parity positioned? If you kind of get that right. Oh, how's retail positioned? That would be probably the biggest
Is the idea. That's so that's an opportunity to go the other way or not necessarily bet betting against an over an asymmetric positioning but maybe just as like intelligence like where is the money right now?
Correct. And so sometimes it will actually provide an informed conclusion about taking a a contrarian bet. Other times that's not necessarily the case and that applies pretty much universally. So what we tend to do is back test a lot of these positioning reports that we run against what the forward returns of whatever asset we're interested in. And then in some cases it can actually validate the view and reinforce it. So i.e. this position is crowded but actually based upon all of our back testing the crowding means nothing and actually the forward returns are really good. And other times it will say the opposite where you want to take a contrarian bet and and sort of say something controversial. I feel like there is a school of thought that short-term predictions are a total fool's errand and I would say for most for the casual investor of course it is right trying to predict the market in the short term for most people is a total waste of their time, do something else.
But the idea that you have clarity a year out in today's investing world sounds so insane given how fast things are moving that if you are going to make some sort of market call, tactical call, is 0 to 30 days probably is reasonable.
Yes. And so I'll give you a couple of stats that can sort of help clarify that a bit, right? So if I told you that if you were to buy the S, let's just use the S&P, it's easy, right? So if you were to buy the S&P on any given random day and you were to hold that position for 42 trading days, is equate equate to about 2 months, the odds of you making money, right, is about 73%. And your average return would be around about just shy of 200 basis points, 190 basis points. That's pretty good. Right now, that's better than better way better odds than going to a casino and playing any game. So, if you consider that your baseline, you're you're effectively trying to either outperform that or underperform that. And I think that's where the randomness comes in because if you're going to just sort of buy the S&P and hold it and just sort of take a kind of a passive view on it, then you've you're the odds are you're going to be right more time than not. So really what you're ever trying to do if you're going to consider the tactical considerations is you're trying to basically say, okay, are the odds materially deviating from that 73%. And we have a framework which is actually pretty good. Is it perfect? No. Because if it was, I wouldn't be sitting here telling you about it or talking to our customers about it.
You just run run it internally and keep your mouth shut.
I keep my mouth shut from a from a beach.
But you have the data. So the way that a lot of gamblers lose, just a casual gambler, there's uh whatever 20 games over the weekend and they'll bet on 11 of them and there's obviously no edge. You don't have to swing at every pitch. You don't have to bet every game. But when there is reason, when the data says, 'Hey, uh whatever 80% of the time do nothing, right? Right. Mostly noise, but 20% of the time we have a 54% chance of of making contact and we'll swing when it makes sense to do so.'
Yeah. And so in in our case obviously we'll work on kind of the opposite where we're generally looking for the 85s, 80 to 85, 90s in some cases hit rates where we'll look at kind of the forward return profiles whether it's on the S&P, whether it's on a a particular style factor or whether it's even on a sector and the the hit rates look really attractive based upon pretty robust not just back tests but just very long sort of out of sample and in sample periods. So good case in point, right? So our main framework that helps guide whether we want to be bullish or bearish, we it's called Betty. It's Barclays Equity Timing Indicator. We were originally going to call it betting, but then kind of compliance had a bit of an issue with that unsurprisingly. And it's a all it is is that you say we have all the data. Everyone has access to data. If I told you what all of these inputs were, you could build it yourself. It's there's no secret source. It's just a case of aggregating a bunch of stuff that's already available in the market and knowing that when a significant or a sufficient number of them are flashing either positively or negatively, you know in your head and and on paper statistically what the forward returns of the S&P are more likely than not going to do. We have the whole the whole thing laid out and that's really our guiding light with the from a quantitative framework and then the qualitative framework is the positioning. It is talking to customers. It's or it's knowing what the organized narrative is in the market. And hopefully, this is where it becomes more of an art than a science. You've got the science bit, right? The art bit is pulling it all together. This is the bit that AI hasn't figured out yet is like pulling it all together in a way that you can say, 'Okay, all the ducks are in a row. I think we got, you know, now we to use your polls, we have to take a swing.'
Can you go back to what you said about the order? How how you get to narrative? It start like it starts with it starts with what because I agree with the the premise. Uh I just I sort of think like um whatever price is doing that becomes the story that everybody accepts. It just takes a little while for that to be transmitted around the street. And then it's it's funny like you hear you hear people saying something on Thursday like five people will say the same thing and they arrive there because of whatever price just told them. It almost never works the other way where somebody is going against price and and people accept that narrative. Does that make sense? Like what I'm trying to ask you
It it it it does and and that's I would mostly for for the most part I would think I think of that as noise is because people will use price to justify narrative or they'll explain something ex post because a price moved a certain way rather than necessarily providing real intelligence behind it and go actually challenging the view. Does does that make actual sense? Right. And so again, that's not always the case, but there's often times in the market where things just move because maybe there's a big print, someone had to put through a certain trade and it was it was done in a sloppy fashion, moves price, everyone said, 'Oh, what just happened?' That's particularly uh prone like in the oil market at the moment. You know, oil will move around by a dollar or two and then everyone jumps to conclusion that some random headline from someone you've never heard of.
Yeah, that's the reason. And it's like, okay, maybe there was an algo that responds to a certain headline. That's obviously the world we live in. But more often than not, it's just noise.
Do you take every qualitative signal or quantitative signal? And the reason I ask is if you say it's just data and everybody has the data, then there's got to be something else. You need some sort of I don't know, situational awareness for lack of a better phrase here. Um, so for example, the analytics on in football might say go for and fourth and one every time, but there could be well it's like yeah, but we have the momentum, our defense is strong, this offense sucks, just punt it away and live to see another day. So, how much of the qualitative overlay dictates it? Or do you just It's just 100% quantitative. 82% chance we go no matter what.
No, no, no. The the qualitative aspect is really important. And that that's what I was referring to before. And where there's art rather than just just science. There are plenty of strategies in the marketplace that are just literally, you know, inputs and outputs. And if it's good quality inputs, you get good quality outputs and vice versa. But I I'm a big believer that the discretionary overlay is really powerful. It's really important and you know I kind of experienced that firsthand when I was running money as well in in so far that if you just rely on a quantitative process and you inside your own bubble I think it can work. Clearly there's guys who have had phenomenally successful careers running those kind of strategies. But for me personally, I believe there's real power in in talking to the community and getting a really good qualitative assessment of what like the zeitgeist is and then building the quantitative framework alongside that to see if they match up or if there's a discord, right? And if there's some kind of dissonance between the two, then that's to me is usually where there's a real opportunity because I'm a big believer personally that and today in this environment is a perfect example of that where you've got this so-called prevailing narrative that suddenly everyone is bearish on AI, right? Because of what happened in the financing space or or whatever it may be. And you know, I conduct surveys. We just sent out a survey just today uh which we conducted yesterday. We had 200 investors that came, which is a pretty good sample size from from the Wall Street community, and it's a high quality survey, and the and the feedback was overwhelmingly not bearish on on AI, right? Only 60% of people that responded thought that we had a financing problem. I'm like, how can that be? We have a financing problem because we've just gone through one over the past two weeks. So, that number should have been 100%.
So, what does that tell you?
Well, it tells me so that that's the start of a of a story, right? Because you've got dissonance now. You've already got okay customer feedback is everyone's bearish AI, survey says you're wrong. Okay, let's check the positioning data. So, traditional hedge fund PB positioning data from some of my competitors will say hedge fund nets are super low, therefore everyone's bearish and they've all sold tech. What they may not necessarily tell you, and this is in no way we no way me sort of like poo pooing the the quality of work from competitors, but what that data probably doesn't show necessarily or people overlook is that the range of net exposure changes by hedge funds is minimal. It will go to from 48% to 55% back to 48%. Right. Yeah.
Of course, because a lot of these guys are RV pod shops and so they're just running market neutral strategies. So in reality that they have no or little market sensitivity beyond their betas within the portfolio. So I don't care what they're up to. And we again we've run stats around this. So the point being is is that we'll use the positioning data where we think it's valid. So what are retail positioned in? Huge vertical. I mean the largest owner of stocks is the retail community. Next largest owner re mutual funds, right? And levered ETFs. What are they up to? Right? So these are the verticals. What are vol control funds are up to? Those guys have significant equity length, QIS strategies, ditto, CTA, ditto. So you build up like a quantitative picture across your framework and you say, okay, what does the positioning metrics actually look like? Now let's compare that to what the prevailing narrative is and now let's compare it to what our customers are saying.
What do you see in retail? Is it was it is it dumb money as people say or have they been I feel like they've been pretty damn right the past this this cycle with buying dips.
Vast majority of retail would portfolios would have outperformed institutional portfolios. What does that tell you?
Tells us a few things. First and foremost is they have more holding power, right? So, a lot of the hedge fund community are operating on much tighter draw down limits because their mandate on you know their
The retail account is not being observed by anyone other than the holder and the holder's wife.
Yes. And and and and uh and it's something they want to brag about to their their friends at at a dinner party.
I bought the dip. But they're not answering to a committee about why they're uh overweight semiconductors. They're just overweight semiconductors cuz they want to be.
And why they draw down 400 basis points.
Right. And the only thing that will basically cause them to stop out is either their brokerage account basically margin calls them or they lose their job. That's it.
Right. It really is all about people always ask me, 'Oh, what gets retail to sell?' I'm like, 'Lose your job'
Or when your neighbor loses their job. So there's been there's been times where retail has dumped stocks like obviously. Is that is that a buying opportunity or not necessarily?
It depends on the starting point and how long it's been going on for.
So what if I told you we've got data on retail back to around about 1995 like good quality data data and what we do.
Is that relevant still in today's world?
It's more relevant today than I think it's ever been.
Wow, that's surprising. Why do you say that?
Well, because you know the devices Okay, I guess we have to kind of go back into history a little bit. 2019 was a real demarcation for retail trading. Not 2020, 2019. People don't really talk about it. And that's because in October of that year, it's when zero commission trading was introduced, right? And it just so happened to coincide with the launch of Robin Hood and some of the, you know, the more gamified.
This is when Schwab said zero, Fidelity said zero, and zero became the standard.
Zero. Exactly. Yeah. Right. So there was very, very low friction trading. Then what happened? COVID, right? And then what happened?
Bunch of stimulus checks, people sitting at home.
40 million new brokerage accounts open in 18 months.
Exactly. So, but really, I mean, would nonzero zero commission trading have changed it? Probably not. But I do think it's important because, you know, it effectively lowered your transaction friction to to to nothing. And then you got a bunch of people with stimulus checks and nothing to do and they're basically, you know, let's face it, we're all degenerate gamblers. So, a lot of people basically got involved in that and and that obviously coincided with a significant short-term correction in in equities.
They never left after the bear market. They're still here.
They're still here. Oh, no.
No. They they that's not true. They did. So, there was a degree of selling by retail community in 2022. And that was a deliberate financial tightening exercise by the Fed, right?
But it was but it was shortlived. Like, if you look at the percentage of overall volume, it's still pretty it's still high. Is it 25%?
The retail share of trading is still where it was.
Oh, in terms of the share. Yeah.
But what we tend to track is the evolution of both cash balances and margin balances as a percentage versus the natural drift of
Retail got blown out of SPACs and all that [__] just like everybody else did. Nvidia fell 75% and so did Meta in 2022. I mean, that was terrible.
It was yeah it was it was a bad time for retail and and retail genuinely lost money but they didn't they did sell but they didn't it wasn't
They didn't they didn't completely get out of dodge. Yeah. And then ever since then 23, 24, 25, 26 regardless of whether we've had those economic wobbles or not they've just kind of been pretty steady.
So so how is the data from the '90s relevant to today?
So the the in terms of the comparable
Yeah. So, we've blown through everything we saw in the '90s. The ownership of of the US household ownership of stocks today, you've got approximately 2/3 of all American homes that own stocks. That's way higher than
The other stat which I I sort of love to throw around is that the the next highest the 35%
Yeah. 35% of US household net worth is now in equities, the highest ever. The next highest wealth channel is unsurprisingly um home equity. But the gap between
Stocks and home equity in terms of your wealth percentage for closing
Is the widest it's ever been in history going back to the 1960s. We've only
But isn't it obvious why like homes have appreciated 0% over three years thanks to interest rates?
The stock market has doubled. Yep.
Of like of course of course.
It's not causal. It's it's the it's the reverse.
It it's there's a whole bunch of other stuff. I mean, think about over the past really since 2022, mortgages have been completely unaffordable. You know, new homes and existing home sales have plummeted. The housing market's basically been dead or, you know, zombie.
It's a housing market recession.
It's for all intents and purposes with housing really not doing much, right, in terms of prices.
Um, so you've got a bunch of, you know, Gen Y, Gen Zers with money that they savings that they've accumulated. Where are they going to put it? They're not putting it into a new home anymore. They're putting it into the stock market.
Right. So, you've had that constant inflow that we estimate if you think about where like typical new mortgage origination from home equity down payments $200 to $300 billion a year. Plus, you got the 401k money that comes in every year. That's between 8 and $900 billion on our estimation. Right? So, between that, you've got over a trillion. Then you got a trillion dollars of buybacks. Even if you haircut that a little bit for the executions being low, you're still talking about 750 billion. Guaranteed. This is guar almost guaranteed buying like 401k money.
Like the weather like it's coming in.
It's coming in as long as people have jobs.
And it's valuation insensitive and it's just it's it's automated.
Yeah. Because it's effectively like, you know, life plan, you know, retire target, life target, whatever it is, you know, 65. So it's sold.
You had that at 900 billion a year.
Okay. So the way I worked it out was uh number of uh homes in America um and then we sort of haircut that number to assume that not every home can contribute to a 401k whether you for whatever reason then we assume 12% of your cont 12% contribution uh of your paycheck. Um and then and your and your median household income is $88,000.
So we kind of you sort of solve for that maths and you haircut a little bit more. You get to between 8 and 900 billion.
Yeah. So, I wrote I wrote something about that 11 or 12 years ago on my original blog. And I called it the relentless bid and I basically said there's like three things driving this cuz the question back then in 2014 the market had just made an all-time high in 13 and there was still a lot of bad news and euro zone stuff and people I don't understand why does this market ever sell off, right? Like it it just crashed spectacularly. doesn't every time there's bad news it wobbles and then it goes right back to highs and people were struggling with that and I basically said it's the combination of buybacks shrinking the float wasn't even at a trillion a year yet was on the way um this 401k money which I felt had been underappreciated and then a third factor that I don't think anybody was talking about the business model transition from stock brokers to financial planners and wealth management transitioning from my broker trades stocks for me to my broker allocates the ETFs and uh that was trillions of dollars. Like you look at Morgan Stanley going from predominantly trading commissions to predominantly feebased. What does that do to the the way the market behaves? I argued it's a volatility dampener. There's more guaranteed money into the same 500 stocks every time people allocate to their wealth accounts. So, we've been living in that world now for over a decade.
Yeah. [clears throat] And I think it's like
I think it's a big reason for why the VIX so quickly evaporates every time it gets going. Like it just you've got all right, two weeks go by, the 401k money comes in. Um the financial advisers who used to trade stocks, now they're just rebalancing ETFs. You can almost set your watch by it.
Yeah. And then there now on top of that you've got the lever you've got the the the call overwriting ETFs. you've got kind of very deliberate vol selling products that are further suppressing or or supplying gamma and Vega not to use these Greek terms but like uh you know supplying volatility to the market as well on top of that but you know to answer the original question you know retail are kind of all in on stocks part of it involuntary because they've kind of lost faith in the home the home ownership slice and also just the fractional nature of stocks is very appealing to younger individuals, right? I don't need to cough up, you know, if your median home price in the US, I don't know the number off top of my head, but I'm guessing it's between three and $400,000. You know, you're not have to cough up $60,000, $50,000 for a deposit. I can go and buy a share of Nvidia or a share of the SM of SPY or whatever and just forget about it. It unfortunately does create vulnerabilities in our economy, you know, and people ask me all the time, and I know we're getting a bit tangential here, but like what keeps you awake at night? Is it like levered ETFs or is it Iran or is it AI? I'm like, no, it's retail. It's retail is the scary one in the sense that because we've got such a financialized economy, right? Like you even last year during the tariffs when the S&P fell 20%. There was a visible drop in consumption over the subsequent two months.
Huge. And because it's real time, unlike dot com where
That also scared people. There's massive uncertainty in terms of what the economy was going to do. I don't think it was just the stock market falling.
You're right. It wasn't just the stock market falling, but the average individual really had no concept about what the implication of tariffs was going to be in that moment. Right.
I think they were scared. And but more importantly, in 2000 when we had even a it wasn't comparable today, but it was reasonably comparable in terms of the amount of equity ownership in households. You had to wait either for a monthly or quarterly brokerage report, right? Most people did, you know, they were looking
Getting alerts into your hand sometimes a day.
You are seeing your real time wealth adjustment, right? And that's very powerful on both the way up and the way down. You know, I kind of had this running joke
That the stock market is the economy now. The old adage was stock market is not the economy. No, it is the economy now.
I say it all the time and people get pissed off about it, but I really think it's more than ever.
Of of the stock market. It used to be like an avatar, loosely speaking, for how companies are doing. And then people would say, 'All right, but what does IBM and Coca-Cola have to do with Main Street?' Like, now I think it's basically um we've built retirement around the stock market. Everybody's all in. Every household with a high income also has a large 401k. Now we've tied compensation to the stock market. You think about all the young up and coming millionaire households. They all work for companies that are about to go public, just went public, have stock prices, like um this is it. If you can't have a prolonged 2-year bear market without a recession, it's impossible because everybody's wealth effect and everyone's mentality is based on how much money their accounts are worth. And so, I totally agree with you.
Yeah. And the messed up thing is is that I I would challenge any economist on the planet, no matter how good they are, and there are some phenomenal economists I work with at Barclays, but I don't think any of them actually have a cell in their econometric model that measures S&P.
Right. So, they're they're monitoring everything.
Well, the Fed have their FCI process.
The Fed is looking at the the 10-month moving average, looking at the stock market. I'm I think they know when they've overstepped. I watched that play out in 2018. It was the most obvious thing in the world. It come out It come out early December. We're nowhere near uh neutral.
And then on Christmas Eve of all times of year, we're in a 21% statistical bear market. Like just past that 20% threshold. That's doesn't really mean anything. But in the media, bear market, they reversed themselves on Christmas Eve.
Yeah, I remember. And a month later, not only are we perfectly near neutral, actually we're going to start cutting rates again. That's literally what happened. How could it not be the the 10-month moving average or the or the 200 day or whatever.
You know what's amazing about that period in 2018?
It was also a midterm year.
And it was and it was also a new Fed chair.
And Mnuchin was very chatty.
Remember that he came out out of nowhere and said, 'Don't worry, every there's ample liquidity.' And everybody was like, 'What the?' In the great in the great financial crisis um 10 years before there was one Bloomberg terminal at the Fed in Washington.
There's one person in there looking at the markets. You want to bet there's a thousand now.
Oh no, but I I know that the both the Treasury Department have Bloomberg terminals because they they ping me and then so so does the New York Fed as well.
Well, there's a hedge fund manager running it. So I'm just saying like everything is the stock market.
Yeah.
Can I show you a stock market chart? I want to get your thoughts on this. So this has been an interesting year. Um friendly and different reasons. And even though there is the relentless bid, um AI has caused a lot of on-off days, same with software, same with energy, there are a lot of days where the stock market does X and the average stock goes the other way. So this is weird negative beta effect. Um, SocGen has a great chart, chart 15, Daniel, that shows the they say there are 124,750 possible pairs of companies with the within the S&P and at present 40% are negatively correlated. So they show the average stock correlation within the S&P 500 and they compare that today. So the the red line is the average and the black line is today. Mhm.
40% of days we've seen stocks going different directions in the overall index. It is a very funky time within the stock market.
Yeah. So, a lot less like uh 2017 every stock went up together. There was no volatility. Zero.
Matter of fact, today's a perfect example. So, the last couple of weeks we've been talking about the same thing. Breadth sucks. Breadth sucks. Breadth sucks. And we've been saying, 'All right, but that's a feature of a bull market. You want the biggest stocks doing the heavy lifting usually when breadth is leading. Not usually. Um the average stock does better in a bear market. Just think about 2000 is a perfect example of this right after the dot com bubble bust. So today you have the equal weight up 98 basis points. The S&P is down 53.
And it seems to be that this is happening more with more and more and more frequency. There's a bad uh MAG7 report Google today for example and the rest of the market catches a bid.
Yep. And you're you're asking
Just just we're just talking.
We're just talking. Okay. So, I can actually give you there's a there's a pretty good answer for why this is happening.
Oh, yeah. I don't think it's a mystery.
I don't know the answer. What's What's the What's the reason?
Well, I think earlier in the year it was energy. It was a lot of energy stocks going up when the market went down and that was this weird negative beta effect. Yeah. And then it was interest rates, right? interest rates went up, consumer staples got killed, REITs got killed, utilities got killed, Mag 7 was, especially Apple completely undeterred, and Apple's biggest stock in the world. And then it was the software uh AI days on, off, on, off, on, off. I think it's it's been those three things. What else am I missing?
So there there's there's like a unified uh narrative that that basically puts all those together. Um and it goes back to our friends at uh at RV Strategies, relative value, right? So if you think about um multi-manager AUM in 2018, 2019 uh before COVID was around about $300 billion and today it's like a trillion.
Right. So it's basically tripled since COVID.
And so who are you talking about like Citadel and and Millennium and those type of companies? won't name names right but but uh you know multi-managers pods you know the basically guys where effectively their job is to isolate idiosyncratic alpha as opposed to be taking large directional bets right so they'll encourage their managers to run high gross low net exposure and it makes sense right why why has there been explosion at AUM since COVID well because well really since 2022 when interest rates went up and it's because in a high interest rate environment RV strategies are absolute no-brainers right because I deploy a lot of gross on my long side, load of gross on my short side. I actually haven't really deployed a dollar of net, so to speak. I've got plenty of risk, but I take my actual capital haircut for collateral for my PB requirements.
And then you're earning a SP uh you're earning an interest rate on the rest.
Correct. Right. So, whatever your collateral commitments are, let's say that I 15% aside or whatever, but you're
Taking the 70% and you're earning that, you're earning that 5%. You probably even get more than that in relatively safe.
That's the low net part. You're offsetting with your longs and your shorts and then you're collecting an interest rate on whatever you don't have to allocate.
Correct. And because these businesses are run so efficiently, that's why you're given very strict mandates on what your net exposures can be, right? Because it's not you breaching some horrible limit. It's actually just because as an organization, they want to sort of manage effectively the treasury function essentially.
And it's a very good business model. It's, you know, for and all you're doing is you're trying to isolate that idiosyncratic alpha. Now, here's the catch. If everyone's doing it, right? It's not just a handful of funds, right?
Everyone's doing it. Everyone has access to the same risk parameter metrics. So, they're neutralizing their value and their quality and their size and their growth and all the rest of it. They're also obviously neutralizing their sector exposures and they're neutralizing their market exposure. But the number of stocks you can trade has shrunk. We talked about this deequitization already, right? So, um...
You have like 3,000 stocks basically, right? And that number has gone down over time, not up, right? I started in the business with like 10,000.
And it's net negative issuance in the sense that we've had fewer IPOs and more buybacks, so by definition there's less available stock to trade, right? So with those combination of factors plus the ballooning of AUM plus leverage from PBS on top, you end up with this crowding out effect. And everyone will say, 'Oh, okay, hang on a second, it doesn't matter because I've neutralized everything.' No, all you've done is push the crowding into other aspects of your portfolio that you are either aware of or unaware of, right? And this really matters because when you've ballooned the size of the number of strategies, so to speak, you're creating more of these vicious or the propensity for these vicious unwinds.
So everyone unwinds one aspect of a portfolio at once, it hits the stocks three times harder than it otherwise would have.