Please welcome to the stage chief design officer of consumer devices at Google, Ivy Ross, and author and investor Tony Fadell.
Good morning.
Well, thank you for being here.
Oh, yes, you are here. We're going to introduce ourselves. We've got such a small audience. Let's, you know, all your names. We'll direct a fireside chat.
So in the early 2000s, his efforts to build a pocket-sized device that could hold a thousand songs caught the attention of Apple. Within months, he had been hired by the firm. And less than a year after his first phone call with Apple, the iPod was shipping to customers. He then went on to play a key role in the creation of the iPhone. And after he decided to leave Apple, he co-founded Nest Labs, reinvented the thermostat. And by the way, that was the first device to have some AI in it, and ushered in an era of the interconnected home. But after leaving Nest in 2016, he pivoted and started Build Collective, a fund that advises and invests in startups building solutions to address some of the world's biggest problems, including the climate crisis. Tony is a rare kind of builder, equal parts technologist, entrepreneur, and visionary. And most importantly, he was a mentor of mine. We got to work together for what, a year and a half?
Yeah. Yeah, but it felt so much longer in a good way. It felt... No, and the great thing, we talked about data and intuition yesterday at a talk I was at, and actually here's a guy that taught me about intuition. So that was great.
Someone who's very emotionally in touch, and I'm still trying to get there.
You're an inspiration for me.
Thank you. So why don't we start with how you think about making products? What are the core philosophies that guide your product decisions? What needs to be true for you to say yes to building something? Because I know that we're both builders at heart. You know, when you have a builder mentality, I think you're a builder of whether it's small-scale products, teams, companies, or even architecture, right?
And you can't help yourself, but I watched you in action being that builder. But I know you described this so well in your book Build, but tell us in your own words.
The big, the most important thing, this is what I learned, was pain. Start with the pain. Pain. You know, a lot of people go from the creativity angle and we're going to go from, you know, like, okay, I have this imagined world. I start from the pain. I learned because I had this imagined world when I was a kid, you know, like I want to build this and I want to build that, and I did that all the way up till kind of General Magic. Mark and I wanted to just build these crazy things. And then what I realized at General Magic was we were having so much fun building stuff, we weren't solving anybody's pain at that point. There was no pain around downloadable emails and games and e-ticketing and e-retail like we had all emojis. We were doing all this stuff in 1992, '93. No one knew. There was no even the internet. There was no Wi-Fi. There was even mobile data. Like we were doing... So we're having lots of fun imagining this world. But nobody had the pain of what it meant until 15 years later when they were carrying a laptop to do their internet surfing and then their phone for doing communications and then their iPod for doing entertainment. No one knew that in '93 that they needed the device we were making at General Magic then, which was literally the iPhone 15 years too early, right? So everything in my design philosophy has all been about where's the pain, where's the pain a lot of people feel now, and what is the way we can make a painkiller and hopefully turn that painkiller into a superpower for these people, so that for all these people with the pain, so they go, they transform from pain to, oh my god, this is a whole new world, like, and it's, and I feel empowered in a way that, you know, and so that's, if you start with the pain, then you can get people to listen to what you're building.
But you have to anticipate the pain, right?
You have to anticipate the head of it. Get the timing right. Right. My dad, get the timing right. Not too late.
And definitely not too early.
No. Timing is everything, right? Even if the technology is right, society has to catch up, right?
Yeah. Because walking over here, Tony and I were reminiscing about some things we did where they were early, early ideas that now you look at them and they were, um, they would have been right on. So the iPhone 15 years too early. Then we were doing GL, we were doing glasses. The two of us were making glasses seven years ago. So the Meta glasses that you guys see now, we were making those.
Okay, this is a good one. How do you navigate the tension between ambitious vision and real-world constraints? When do you push and when do you simplify?
Okay. Well, it's always about simplification, but you can't oversimplify. So there's two things. There's one, implementing it, and then there's selecting what it is, right? And what I learned again at General Magic was we took four years to build something and the whole world had changed during those four years and we had to get everything right because it was the creators of the Macintosh who decided they needed to create the next thing and I was like totally in it. It was this General Magic communicator. But when they first made the Mac, they forgot all these things in the first version of the Mac. Oh, we should have put this in and oh, we should have put that in. So with General Magic, we were going to do everything and make sure we make none of the mistakes that we did on the Mac. And it took four years and a lot of hard work and then the market had changed by that, or the, you know, market had changed, the internet showed up. And so what I've learned is this is a long game and you have to ship and you have to ship and understand that usually it's the third version of the product where you nail it all. It takes three versions of the product or a service to get it right. The first one is you ship the first version. The second one is you fix the thing that you shipped, and the third version is make the business work.
Yeah, I was going to say, yeah, the fourth one is where you finally make some margin.
Yeah. And the fourth is like, okay, we get it. We figured it all out, right? And now we're scaling and all that other stuff, but it takes three times to actually get it right. And regardless if it's with software or it's hardware, whatever it is, you have to go through those iterations because you'll never get it right the first time.
And you're finding that true even with, I know you fund a lot of startups now who make hardware. Have things changed or that formula still works, right?
It's still that way because you have what you think is right. Then the market tells you what it's right after you've shipped it and then you go, 'Okay, that's what we're doing. Now, let's make sure we get the business and all the sales right and the customer support right and marketing right and everything.' And that's that. It's just a natural progression. I've seen it with everything. Everything is three, three versions.
And what's your position on the role design plays in all that?
Well, there's designing the product, service, the user interface, whatever it is, but there's designing the entire journey, the customer journey from when they discover you, the marketing, the messaging, how they try the products, how they hear about the products from their friends, all the way through to, you know, using it and updating it. And you need to arc, that whole arc has to be well-designed. It can't just be, oh, here's this cool thing and it just comes out of space. It doesn't work that way. You got to design the whole experience. Yep.
Start to finish.
Okay. So, let's talk about leadership. What are the most common mistakes teams make when trying to innovate?
Um, the, oh, data versus opinion.
So, data-driven decisions versus opinion-making decisions, right? Opinion-made decisions.
When you do anything that's new and different, anything that's new and different, and if it's sufficiently different, you will never get enough data to know when you've got it right till after you've shipped it. Too many, too many people want to, especially in the corporate world, we know a few, especially in a company that comes a lot of data, is we are going to understand all the data and then we're going to make a decision and ship. And it's like if you're going to do anything innovative, you can't get that data. You have to understand there's a gut-level opinion, make a decision. It could be data-informed, but you're still going to have to make that decision. And if you look at most of corporate America, what do they want? They want to be sure to tell the shareholders and their bosses that they're going to get it right. So what do they do? They, I got an idea, then they hire McKinsey or some stupid consultancy. This is my idea. Don't you think it's great? And then you pay them millions of dollars to give you back your stuff with some data around it. Duh. And then they go, see, they even say I'm right. Okay, let's go do this. So everybody goes and does it and then it fails. And then they can say, well, I didn't do it. McKinsey said it was going to be good. You can't fire me. I should get my bonus. These are the guys who said it was going to work. It's such... I can't believe it. And this has been played out for years and years and years and nobody gets the game they're in.
I learned from Tony how you say what you think and you feel with passion. Yeah. No, I think some of you heard me say good morning. I think some of you heard me say yesterday that I believe intuition, you know, everything we take in, 95% of it goes into our subconscious and only 5% in our cognitive mind. So when we get an intuitive hit, the non-data, it's actually coming from more data than from our cognitive mind. So I...
I fully agree with you and this is the thing about AI that people don't understand. This is everyone's like, AI is going to replace us. AI is going to replace us. AI is only as smart as the data gets into it. Right?
And the thing is that data that we put online or that data that we feel comes from our senses.
And our senses are not five senses. We have millions of senses in our body. Why does a hair stand up on the back of our neck? That's a sense. Okay? We don't count that.
These AI agents and what we put on the internet have nowhere near the millions of senses that we have, and then we regurgitate as text or video or whatever, that those agents don't, those AI data pools don't get any of those senses that we have. So at the end of the day, the more we're emotionally in touch with what we do, the more we're psychologically in touch with how we understand and all of these senses around us is going to always keep us ahead. We don't even make camera sensors better than the eye today in all of your phones. We don't make better microphones than our ears. We don't make better speech that are right. We can't replicate and sense the real world with all the digital technologies around us. Okay.
Yeah. Now I say that machines have sensors but not sensory systems. And that's very different.
And those sensors, the systems are also the fidelity of the sensors. Yeah.
And those sensors that we put in all of these things are nowhere near what we have in us.
And so as long as we keep staying in touch with all of those emotions, all of those senses, and staying ahead and using the tools as opposed to fearing the tools, we are going to be superpowers. This is, AI is a superpower, not necessarily always going to replace you.
Yeah, it's funny. We haven't seen each other in years and people have heard me say exactly what you're saying. We are so aligned because I almost think we're going to, AI is going to make us more creative because we're going to have to be, because AI is taking some of the rational things off of our plate to allow us to exercise our imagination and creativity and use it as a tool so that we can co-create together. And we can't even imagine what that looks like. So that could be scary, the unknown for sure. But I think it is imperative because I think we've been operating a bit like machines ourselves with efficiency and productivity. And so the universe sent the machines in. It's like, okay, you humans, now what are you going to do? And so I think we really have to take that challenge on and get to know our sensory systems and ourselves better because we do have a unique perspective and we have to begin to develop what I call the technologies of the sacred, which is the ones we have inside of us that we haven't developed, and then watch out because I think us plus some of AI intelligence is going to take us all to another level.
I fully agree with you and if we look, it's just the pendulum of life swinging. So think about the Middle Ages before the Renaissance, right? When the Renaissance came and we had the magic and everything else, people had, we had systems and we had banking, we had governmental structures and security structures where we could have time for artists and other things to flourish because we had the technology of food and protection and everything else, and so we can get to that next level. The pendulum. We went through the Industrial Age, then we can't, efficiency, efficiency, efficiency. Now it's going to go the other way back to creativity because we're going to have these systems that can help us. Obviously, there's also they can be used for bad, but at the same time, if we use them properly, we can have another renaissance, a renaissance.
Yeah. You know, and I think out of chaos comes creativity. So we're in a bit of the chaos stage, but I am optimistic. But to your point, anything can be used for good or bad. So we have to stay on top of it. And I think AI, not only will it be helpful for us for rational things, but health, education, some of the things Mark talked about. I mean, it's going to do some really amazing, amazing things.
Use it, use it every day.
A little bit. I am playing with it. Yes, I have to. And I enjoy it. And that's how you know it's a reciprocal. It learns from you, you learn from it. So I, and it's going to, it's actually, I can't say a lot, but there are some ways it's going to be used for creativity that will be exciting, which I think will give people more a sense of agency over their own creativity. Are you using it a lot?
I use it constantly. I use it constantly and I use different engines for different things and continually innovating and finding new things. I'm reading about it all the time and seeing how other people are using it and then integrating that into what I do. So whether it's I'm designing a house, remodeling and doing a huge design in Paris right now on a place, and so I'm doing it to do visualizations and I'm doing it for design of a ceiling tile and design like, so I'm doing that, but then I'm also using it to go and learn about certain new types of audio and electrical systems and then I'm like, yeah, like it, I use it in all kinds of different ways. No, I think the key is we all have to share with each other how we're using it because we're co-creating new ways to use it.
There's some incredible blogs, some incredible YouTube channels out there that you can learn a lot that I recommend people dive into.
So, you've raised concerns about the speed of tech development. What does responsible innovation look like today?
It's tough. It's tough because you have all this money pouring in. I remember, it's not the same, but I remember this in 1998, '99, you know, when everybody was rushing to build fiber optic networks around the world and data centers at that thing, and then the crash came and everybody was like, you know, there's not going to be any more bricks and mortar, remember that? Bricks and mortar is dead, you know, and so as we can tell, that didn't happen. So there's a lot of pontification and a lot of BS that's being said about AI today. You know, oh, we're not going to have enough power on the uni-, you know, on the planet and we're going to... No, it's... It's just that we're in definitely 1.0 of this stuff. So when you talk about responsibility, there's one which is what we do to the planet, and then there's what we do to society. And I think the environmental thing, just because of economic pressures, that's going to resolve itself. But when it comes to society, you have the economic pressures in the wrong way around that. And we can see a lot of bad actors out there. And you can see how many deep fakes and a lot of these things. So unfortunately, the companies, we're going to rely a lot on the companies to do the right thing and the governments are going to have to get in line, but it's going to be a while. They just don't move as fast as they need to. But it also is up to the creators to say, 'I'm not going to put up with this.' And which is really interesting because when I see the amount of talent moving from OpenAI to Anthropic, which has been much more stated about being safe and those kinds of things. So the talent, because it's so scarce, can move very quickly to other places where maybe they have better values and systems. So that's a great thing where you didn't necessarily have that. Yeah.
Even 20 years ago, because there's so much, it's the creative destruction happening so quickly now that I think that people are going to choose where they want to be because they know the people are building this stuff are incredibly smart and a lot of them have, you know, good value systems, which is interesting. So talk about building, what's going to be the role of hardware within this AI world? Because I'm sure you saw, well, we were talking backstage about Jony Ive and Sure and OpenAI and the $6 billion sale.
For this mysterious whatever they're building. But what do you think the role is that going to change the role of hardware? The hardware, you know, I've always, when we did Nest, I never wanted more screens in the house. You'd remember this. I hated having screens in the house. I made Nest so it would dim down so you wouldn't see it unless you were really interacting with it. I hated all this digital distraction we had around us. And then what happened was everyone's like, 'Okay, we're going to put more screens in the house,' as you know, which was disappointing. Anyways, but the whole goal was to...
She didn't, that wasn't her decision. Trust me. Trust me, I know whose decision it was. Ivy has a lot more taste. So I guess the way I think about it is that AI allows this stuff to, allows these devices to recede in the background much, much more.
You might have sensors, right? Right.
Like I got a ring, right? But it doesn't have a, it doesn't have a, you know, a display on it as opposed to a smartwatch that has a big ass display and is just an accessory for your phone. Like trying to get rid of this stuff, trying to make it more ambient. And I believe now we have the AI engines to be able to do that. You're seeing that with, you know, the Meta glasses, you're seeing these things. So, and some of the stuff we were doing in the past, which was, okay, make it so that you can be engaged but still have those superpowers with you, but they're not blocking you from the engagement with others. And so I'm hopeful that, you know, because I've been doing some, you know, AI design stuff as well and device design, that it's going to become much more behind the scenes and your devices will become smaller instead of bigger screens going smaller screens because you're going to be able to talk to it or it's going to be able to know and predict what it is you want and ask you things and that kind of stuff. You'll still need a display, but I'm very hopeful that these are going to be able to be minimized over time.
And you think eventually they'll go away altogether?
No, I don't think they'll ever go away. Visual is so powerful in terms of being able to present information. It's, you know, explain, like I'm doing a ton of architecture work and so when I'm on a phone call and I'm like explaining, well, if you put this in this corner of this room, like forget it. Like just put up a drawing and it's so much faster. So you're never going to get rid of the visual. You just can't have the visual. You have to do everything through visual interaction. I just don't think that's smart.
It's funny, at Milan Salone this year, I did a, myself and my team did an exhibition called Making the Invisible Visible, and all the tech writers immediately got on the phone and said, 'Oh, are you saying hardware is going away and dissolving?' I said, 'No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.'
Just like everyone's like, 'Oh, well, this whatever this thing is, it's going to replace a phone.' No. Everyone's like, 'Oh, and this is going to replace this.' If we've learned anything about technology, it's always additive. There's always more things you're going to add. You're not, you usually don't scrape away anything else. Like, oh, personal computers are coming. We're getting rid of mainframes. Guess what? Mainframes are just data centers now. So we don't get rid of technology. We just keep layering things on and making them work together. So this is not, this is not going away.
Yep. You know, a fun fact about Tony is he was born in Detroit. Do you believe it?