Tony, welcome to Giant Ideas.
Tommy, great to be here. Thanks for having me.
I've been trying to get you to do this for literally years, and so I'm really excited that you're going to do it. And tomorrow I'm seeing you do something with Al Gore. So, I'm going to have to beat Al Gore in terms of the quality of my questions today.
It sounds like it's a great competition for the listeners.
Let's see. Let's see where we get to. Let's talk about the iPod and the iPhone. You co-invented the iPhone. You invented the iPod. I want to hear what do people miss when people talk about the story of these incredible sort of smash-hit products which totally changed the world. So much has been written and said about them. But when the historians come to look at this, which they will, what do you think people miss about why these things happened, why they were so powerful, why they worked, what did Apple and you guys get so right, what do people not understand?
In the case of the iPod, Apple was not the company you knew it today, which is a multi-trillion-dollar company. It was worth like three to four billion dollars, which today, you know, is a round for almost a Series B company. Yeah, it's like, 'Okay, yeah, that's how much you get for a round, you know, not even profitable.' So, it was worth almost nothing. It had less than 1% market share. And so, Apple was on the ropes. Steve had already been back a couple of years. Right. He launched the iMac, these gel Lifesaver-colored Macintoshes.
And it was going to be, 'Okay, Apple's back.' And Apple had a kind of a resurgence for a few quarters with the new iMac, and then it all collapsed again because people weren't going to move from Windows machines, PCs, over to Mac. It was just too hard. It just wasn't happening.
There was no Apple retail. Apple was in debt of 500 million dollars. It was barely break even. Apple was on its last legs.
Okay? So, Michael Dell said, famously, 'Just close Apple down, give the money back to the shareholders. That's it. Apple's over.' That was even after the iMac. This was after the iMac.
Because that is kind of a blind spot, that gap in history, isn't it? Where people just look back and go, 'Yeah, they did the iMac and then it was all up into the right.'
Yeah, no, no, the iMac and then the shares crashed.
The shares crashed because there's no more demand.
And they were sitting there and they were still doing the, 'Okay, we're better than Windows, we're better than Windows,' but nobody wanted to move back. Like it was too hard. There wasn't enough software. That was when Microsoft famously invested in Apple.
To help it. When Apple had to sell its ARM shares. It had ARM shares back in the day because it was one of the first investors. It sold those to keep the company alive.
Okay? So very, very different thing. So when you say you're going to build an iPod...
And many people in the team didn't want to do that because there was no cash.
It was like, you're going to distract everyone from this fight we're in.
For this, it's an existential question and decision that's going to be made saying, 'Okay, the Mac is this other thing. This iPod thing is going to help sell more Macs. We're going to go for consumer electronics. We've never done that before for the most part. We're going to make that happen.' And so when you do that, it's a huge bet. Now, I had been in the Valley for 10 years.
And I had gone through countless failures starting with General Magic or whatever. So, and Apple is a failing company again even with Steve back at the helm. Why would I even join? So why should a company go off its script? Why should other people join the company who watched from the outside? It doesn't look good.
And so what is the answer to all these questions? Why did Steve Jobs take the risk? Why did you take the risk to do this?
Okay, so yeah, all those are very good questions. So, the first thing was when Steve said, you know, it's kind of like, you know, Thomas Edison's—no, excuse me, Albert Einstein's definition of insanity: trying the same thing over and over and expecting different results.
So, if you think of that, like, okay, they're sitting here Mac versus PC, Mac versus PC, and it's not going anywhere. Right? So, it's like, what are we going to do? What are we going to do differently? And so, this was the different thing, which was we're going to get back into consumers' hands because they love music and they're going to use iTunes on a Mac and they're going to use an iPod. So, the only way you're going to sell more Macs is by selling iPods because people need to have Macs for that iPod to work.
Which was a strategy, but it didn't work right away.
So, we shipped it after 10 months of the burn-the-boats, we're going to make this iPod. We make a really great first-generation product. And it sold for a quarter or two, and then the sales stopped.
And why? Because nobody else had Macs. And it didn't work with anything else.
And so, Steve's like, we got to fix the product, we got to change these things. So, we changed the product and all the time the team and I were all going, we have to work on Windows, we have to work on Windows. And he's like, no, we're going to sell more Macs because of the iPod. And at the end of the day, the third-generation iPod finally took off. Why? Because it worked on a Windows machine.
Okay, so Steve said no to that until...
Steve said no to a Windows-compatible iPod for two generations of the iPod, the first two generations, because he wanted to sell more Macs. Okay. And the argument was, and I made and other people made on the team was, you've now taken a $300 iPod and made it $2,700. Right. Because you have to buy a Mac, too, and you have to switch your life over. Yeah. So, you were making the switching cost really, really high to get into Apple. Let's make it cheaper.
Okay. And how did that argument eventually—how did you prevail in the end?
How did we prevail in the end? That was the interesting piece, which was we had to go to a third party. His name was Walt Mossberg. He didn't know this, but Walt Mossberg was the tech writer that everybody wanted at The Wall Street Journal. He was the person before Kara Swisher, before Joanna Stern, before all of them. He was the OG. Okay, great guy, and he set the tone for how people would review any product because he was able to make it very consumer. So, we were at odds, and Steve was like, 'No, no, no.' And we were like, 'Yes, yes, yes.' And so, ultimately, we had to go to an opinion-based decision. Steve didn't want to make that opinion-based decision. Neither did we as the team. Steve had to make the decision. So, he said, 'I'm going to let Walt Mossberg tell us, the number one tech reviewer, if this iPod on Windows is good enough to ship or not, because he's going to set the tone.' But he didn't know this.
So, we set up a demo. He tried it. He's like, 'Yeah, it seems pretty good to me.' You know? And so, Steve said, 'Okay, we're going to do it because Walt said it was okay.'
So, that was the really interesting thing because he didn't want to make the decision one way or another. He'd say he was wrong.
Yeah, yeah. I told Steve, 'You know, if you'd have just listened to us 2 years ago, you know?'
Yeah, yeah, whatever. You know, sometimes... Like I've always said at Apple, when we were working under Steve, sometimes there were insane decisions being made. Absolutely insane decisions made. And I learned over the time over my 10 years there. I was like, 'Sanity will prevail. It's just a matter of time.'
Okay. And so, but just going back a bit, tell us a little bit about your vision for the iPod and how you came up with the idea and, you know, what was it about this thing? Because there were MP3 players before. I remember having one before and, you know, they kind of did roughly the same thing. But they were just, you know, orders of magnitude less beautiful, less exciting. How did you—what was your vision?
Well, so the first thing was, you know, I started as a consultant. They hired me and as a consultant, they bought iTunes. Jeff Robin and iTunes—it was bought and then it became iTunes. And they said, 'We're trying to use these MP3 players out there like you mentioned, but they don't hold enough songs. They don't have good battery life. Or they hold a lot of songs and they take forever to transfer. And the interface, if you have lots of songs, it does...' So, we've tried for a few months now to make it work. They're horrible experiences. What would an Apple experience be? An Apple product be for this? And we didn't have the name iPod at the time, obviously. This was February 2001.
Okay? And so, what had happened then was I had already had a startup company making MP3 players, rack-mount ones.
Looking at the future of what a portable one would look like. I was already making portable little devices for 10 years. So, I had a mix, you know, of things and I was a DJ as well. So, I was carrying all these CDs with me around to go between gigs. So, they're very heavy, all the plastic and everything. And so, I had been working on handhelds and I was like, 'Oh, here's this...' We were the first handheld to do audiobooks. So, Audible audiobooks like on the Amazon store, we were the first product at Philips to make Audible audiobooks work on a handheld. And it was like, 'Oh.' And I'm looking at my DJ stuff and I'm like, 'This could be music.' So, and then MP3 player and I'm like, 'Wait a second, we could make a handheld.' So, it first started as a rack-mount pivot player, like literally under your TV. And then it was ultimately going to be a portable product. So, I had already been working on this for a few years with a couple of people. And then Apple called and I was like, 'Oh, yeah, I know something about this. Let me rescan the market.' And I found a company called Portal Player that had a low-power chip for rack-mounted MP3 players, but it was low enough power to make it battery-operated.
Okay, that's cool. And then what we're like is, 'Wait a second, what do we need to do to make an Apple-like product?' So, well, first it has to be low power, it has to fit 1,000 songs. There was a hard drive that came out in January 2001 from Toshiba that allowed us to store basically 1,000 songs. It was a 4 GB or 5 GB drive. And we could store 1,000 songs on that drive, on a hard drive. So, hard drive, battery, processor. Okay, with display. We need to have enough of a display, a bigger calculator display that could just write to display text. But it was not fancy, it was just black and white or grayscale. Okay, great. Okay, then the interface. So, it was all about what were all the problems, make a better interface, make it really fast. So, we gave it FireWire, make sure it could charge fast. FireWire you could charge over it. So, it was all of these things, better, better, better, combine, fit in your pocket with a thousand songs and it worked with iTunes. So, all of those pieces came together because of the problems we saw with the current existing players as well as what would we love to have, which would be the next generation Sony Walkman, which was, you know, my love growing up, those and people on the team. So, it was really about bringing a better music experience into the digital world where you could have a thousand songs in your pocket. Was fast to transfer, fast to select, listen to anything and take all the music—back then all your music—with you wherever you went.
Yeah. And the tagline that does kind of still stay in the mind is a thousand songs in your pocket.
Yeah, you know, today everyone's got unlimited songs in their pocket. They got unlimited everything in their pocket. But back then there was no connection. There was no mobile data network or anything. So, you got a thousand songs. And for us older people, that was like insane. That was, you know, that was a hundred CDs of content. Right?
Let's talk a little bit about some of the product-making philosophy that you had at the time and you developed. Tell us a little bit about the concept of habituation.
Steve had a saying that always was, 'Stay beginner. Stay beginner.' And what that really meant was look at the thing you're making and the marketing and the customer journey as if you were a beginner, as if you have fresh eyes. What confuses you? What excites you? And remember that each of our customers are beginners. And so, don't habituate away a problem that might be inside the device or the product because we've used it enough times and we're like, it's fine. So, habituation—like a perfect example is, you know, you wake up and you get in the shower in the morning and the handle's a little sticky, you know, to set the temperature or the volume of your shower. And you're like, 'Eh, eh, eh, eh.' And you keep wiggling it till you get exactly the right volume and the right temperature. But it's just because you're tired in the morning. After four or five times, you're just like, 'Well, okay, whatever. Okay, whatever.' And you just kind of go through the motions. Well, that's habituation, right?
So, if you were that same guy or gal waking up in the morning and it wouldn't get right to that temperature you wanted right away, you would be mad, right? And so, you have to remember those emotions at that very, very first interaction with that new experience.