There is something you do every single night that is either quietly protecting you or quietly destroying you. And the terrifying part is that you can't feel the difference. You wake up, you go about your day, you might even feel fine. But underneath that, your brain may be accumulating the proteins associated with Alzheimer's disease. Your immune system may be less capable of identifying and destroying cancer cells. Your heart, your metabolism, your emotional regulation, all of it are quietly compromised. Not just from what you ate, not just from whether you exercise, but from how you slept. And yet, we've built an entire culture that treats sleep like it's optional, as a thing you cut out when there aren't enough hours in the day. There's even a kind of pride in it: the early mornings, the late nights, the badge of honor that comes from getting less of it than everyone else. But the science has arrived, and what it's showing us is that we've been making one of the most consequential mistakes of our lives every single night without even knowing it.
The man most responsible for bringing that truth to the world is our guest today. Dr. Matthew Walker is a neuroscientist and professor at UC Berkeley. His book, Why We Sleep, didn't just become a bestseller, it became a cultural phenomenon. It was a book that made millions of people realize that sleep isn't just one pillar of health among many. It may be the one everything else is built on, because how well you eat, how hard you train, how sharp your mind is, all of it depends on how well you sleep. If you're new to Mighty Pursuit, we believe that living well starts with understanding the whole person: mind, body, and spirit. Not as vague wellness cliches, but as deeply interconnected parts of your everyday experience. And today, we're focusing on physical health while also exploring what sleep is doing to your mental health as well. This is a conversation we've been working on for over a year, and it was worth the wait, because when it comes to this subject there are very few people in the world who understand it at this level, and what he lays out here has the potential to change how you think about your health entirely. So let's get into it.
So Dr. Walker, you wrote something in your book that I haven't been able to get out of my head. You wrote, "Scientists have discovered a revolutionary new treatment that makes you live longer and enhances your memory and makes you more creative, makes you look more attractive. It keeps you slim and lowers food cravings, protects you from cancer and dementia, it wards off colds and the flu, it lowers your risk of heart attacks and stroke, not to mention diabetes. You'll even feel happier, less depressed, and less anxious. Are you interested?" And then you wrote, "Nothing about this is a fictitious advertisement." So obviously that's quite the claim. If that is true, why doesn't everybody know this?
I think there's a number of reasons why there is a sort of sleep neglect in society. The first is whoever the PR agent was for sleep probably should have been fired a long time ago, because I say that because there's an image problem in society with sleep, that we see people who sleep sufficiently — and I'm choosing my words carefully — as slothful, lazy, that they are unimportant because they must not be busy. And it's a unique thing relative to the two other bastions of health, which are diet and exercise. People are very quick to tell you, "Oh, I've been going to the gym, you know, five times this past week," or "I've been eating really clean." But almost no one is saying, "I consistently get eight and a half hours of sleep," because there's a concern that people will see you as less than.
So, the first one is an image problem. And by the way, I often think no one looks at a baby or an infant sleeping during the day and says, "Gosh, what a lazy baby." But somewhere between infancy and even childhood, if you look at the data, we not only abandon that sort of celebration of sleep, we very quickly label it with all sorts of negative connotations. So I think that's the first thing: we have an image issue.
The second is we probably haven't had a good national campaign in any major country regarding sleep. So almost every kind of first-world nation has had campaigns about, you know, drunk driving or safe sex or, you know, how to eat healthily or movement and physical activity. I don't know of any nation that has had a public health campaign regarding sleep. So at the government level we've also failed as well. If you come down into schools, there is — I'm not aware of any World Health Organization education module that has been translated into 39 different languages that is taught across the world. We don't educate our children.
And then you take a step down further. We all know of that parent with a teenager who's pulling the covers off on a Saturday morning and saying, "You're wasting the day, you know, get out of bed." And so there's even more of a parent-to-child transmission of sleep neglect. So if you traverse all of these different levels from the government all the way down into the home, there's this persistent erosion of the idea that sleep is, you know, acceptable even. So I think that's part of the problem.
I think the other part of it is just we haven't yet got the word out about the incredible science of sleep. And that's really the reason that I wrote the book. I didn't want to necessarily write a book. I was doing a lot of public lectures and people would say, "So, what book would you recommend?" And there were a couple, but they were probably a little bit old and out of date. So someone said, "I think you should write the book." I thought, "Oh, no." Okay, so I wrote the book and that became the book.
Yeah, no, that's really interesting. I mean, I think we are, you know, obviously since you wrote the book, we are hearing more and more about it. But, you know, the downstream effect of what you're talking about to the average person, it's just like if you have a whole list of things you need to cut out in your life, whether it's like a workout or a meal or something else, like sleep is literally like the first thing that goes. And there is this sort of pride in it sometimes of like, you know, "I'm grinding, I'm working hard." For someone who might be new to this conversation or just getting acclimated with it, what would you say to the person who has the mentality that sleep doesn't matter?
I would give them a collection of examples as to why sleep does matter. And to come back to one of your points, I think you're right. There is now almost not just a rejection of getting sufficient sleep; people will actually try to virtue signal about how little sleep that they're getting. It's almost this — in certain sectors of the workforce there's competitive undersleeping, where people will wear their badge of sleep deprivation on their arm with honor. It's sort of this sleep machismo, this kind of braggadocio attitude, and the idea that "I'll sleep when I'm dead" is unfortunate. And I'll give you some examples in a second, because if you take that mentality you will be both dead sooner and the quality of your life will be significantly worse.
So first, downstairs in your body, there is no major physiological system in your body that isn't wonderfully enhanced by sleep when you get it or markedly impaired when you don't. I can take, for example, a healthy young man, and if I limit them to four to five hours of sleep for five nights, they will have a level of testosterone which is that of someone ten years their senior. So I can age a man by a decade within five nights of short sleep, and we see equivalent impairment in female reproductive health caused by a lack of sleep.
I could also tell you about your metabolic system. There was a great study from the University of Chicago, and they limited people to four hours of sleep for four nights, and then they looked at how well they were regulating their blood sugar. After those four nights of short sleep, their blood sugar control was so impaired that the doctors in the study classified them as being pre-diabetic. So again, I can take you from healthy and set you on a trajectory of diabetes within just a couple of nights.
There's also downstairs in the body an interesting — I would say it's the biggest sleep experiment that is performed on 1.6 billion people. It happens across 70 countries and it occurs twice a year, and it's called daylight savings time. Now, in the spring when we lose an hour of sleep, what we see is a subsequent 24% increase in relative heart attack risk the next day, which is stunning.
One hour of lost sleep. But in the fall, in the autumn, when we gain an hour of sleep, there's a 21% reduction in heart attacks. So it's bidirectional. And you see that same pattern for things like road traffic accidents, rates of hospitalization, tragically even suicide completion.
And there's a study — I've got to tell you about this — there's an amazing study where they looked at the sentencing of federal judges. And because it's the feds, all of the sentencing is cataloged years and years back, lots of data. And they looked at what happened during that spring time change. On the Monday after the time change, the judges dished out much harsher sentences than they typically did relative to the days before, because their mood and their emotion — they were in such a bad mood. So, I mean, it's not a public service announcement, but I'm just saying if you're going up for a probation or sentencing, if you can try to avoid the spring time change.
But that's in your body. Upstairs in your brain, amazing things happen. Learning and memory: sleep after learning essentially hits the save button on new memories so that you don't forget. Sleep before learning does something different. It prepares your brain — almost it's like a dry sponge, you could think of it. It prepares your brain to soak up new information. And without sleep, the memory circuits in your brain almost become waterlogged and you can't absorb new memories very effectively. And that's deep sleep for the most part.
REM sleep, or dream sleep, does something different for memory. It starts to integrate and associate all of the things that you've recently learned with all of your back catalog of information. And so the next day, because of dream sleep, you wake up with a revised mind-wide web of associations that are capable of divining incredible solutions to previously impenetrable problems.
So it's sort of — it's almost like group therapy for memories. You know, everyone gets a name badge and dream sleep gathers everyone in and starts to connect people. Not the obvious connections, though. It makes the really distant, non-obvious connections — the kind of Hail Mary, let's give it a shot and see what happens.
So there's probably another major brain benefit, which is mood and emotional regulation. And I think everyone listening probably has had that experience that if I'm not sleeping well, I'm typically not in the best mood, I am not the best version of myself. And what we've discovered is that without sleep — there's a deep emotional brain center called the amygdala, and it's the sort of centerpiece of strong emotional reactions, both positive and negative.
And what we found is that we deprived people of sleep for one night, and the next day we put them inside the MRI scanner and we showed them a range of kind of emotional pictures, and the deep emotional center started reacting very strongly without sleep. In fact, it was 60% more reactive to negative things relative to when you're well slept.
And the reason was because another part of your brain called the prefrontal cortex, that sits just above your eyes, that's almost like the CEO of the brain, it makes kind of regulation, top-down control decisions. That connection between your prefrontal cortex and your kind of reptilian emotional center had been severed effectively by sleep, disconnected. And so now you became all emotional gas pedal and too little regulatory control brake.
So if that's what happens when you take sleep away, then what is it about sleep that is helpful to your mood and your emotion? Here what we found is that it's actually REM sleep again, dream sleep. But dream sleep, in addition to doing that memory association function, also is a form of overnight therapy. Dreaming takes sort of almost the difficult, painful, sharp edges off the emotional experiences that you've been having, and it acts like a nocturnal soothing balm, and it just kind of takes the sharp edges off so that when you come back the next day it's not as painful anymore, or you don't have that same visceral sort of reaction. So it's a form of overnight therapy. Sleep will divorce the emotion from the memory. So now the next day you have a memory of an emotional event, but it's no longer emotional itself.
And then the final thing I would note, just if I haven't tried to convince people enough of why sleep is important: a sensational discovery made at the University of Rochester by a scientist called Maiken Nedergaard. She was working in mouse models. She discovered three things.
First, everyone has heard of your body's cleansing system. It's called the lymphatic system. For centuries, we didn't think that your brain had a cleansing system. It does. She discovered it. It's called the glymphatic system, named after the cells that make it up, these glial cells.
The second thing that she discovered is that this kind of waste removal system, which uses cerebrospinal fluid to kind of flush the brain out of all of the waste, it's not always switched on in high flow volume across the 24-hour period. It was only when the mice went into sleep and went into deep non-REM sleep, dreamless sleep, that the brain started this kind of washing machine cycle.
The final thing that she discovered is that two of the pieces of metabolic detritus that the glymphatic system was washing away at night were beta-amyloid and tau protein. These are the two underlying culprits of Alzheimer's disease pathology.
So it's goodnight sleep clean. It's sort of like a power cleanse for your brain. And from a biochemical perspective — and this sounds hyperbolic, but it's not really — wakefulness is low-level brain damage. Sleep is your sanitary salvation. And if you're not getting that sleep that you need every night, it's like compounding interest on a bad loan. That's why the Alzheimer's pathology curve gradually increases. So, very long answer to your question as to why people may want to care about their sleep.
No, I love that answer. I think, you know, between the opening quote and your answer, I mean, each one of the things that you just listed — and we'll go into it — it's just like its own massive topic of like how exactly we discovered that and we got there with sleep.
I was just thinking about like myself when I was reflecting on how I've experienced things that you were just talking about. We filmed the first — we filmed in London a few months ago, and I literally felt like I had — we live in New York, filmed in London. Felt like I had like dementia or something because the night before we left I got like three hours of sleep or something like that.
Actually this was two nights before. So then the night before our flight I got like three. So I was running on like five and three, and then we went from New York to London, and like we went five hours ahead, and I thought I was going to be like, okay, I'm going to sleep. I got terrible sleep the past two nights, and then like I didn't fall asleep in London till like 7:00 in the morning or 8:00 in the morning, and I swear like that whole trip I was like — there was such a fog. I like couldn't recall things.
And meanwhile, we had this on the calendar. So I started thinking about this more deeply. I don't know if I would have made these connections before that I was sleep-deprived, but I was like, I literally can't recall anything in my brain. Like I'm forgetting really simple things.
And then the late nights I've worked in the past, I've noticed that like if I work at a really late night, like I'm talking like almost till like midnight, I'll get like very emotional as it's approaching midnight. Like I'll be like a wild mood swing or something like that. And this is like a 16-hour day. I probably had like five hours of sleep.
And so I'm just — you're speaking and I'm like calling all these personal examples in my mind of these things happening. And what's — I mean, to sort of emphasize your point, there's something about the night too, I think, that is strange when it comes to emotions. And it's if you are deprived, or you've fallen asleep and you wake back up and you can't get back to sleep, no matter what, if it's the nighttime, things in the dark of night almost seem twice as bad as they do in the light of day.
Yeah. And if you layer on top of that this emotional brain that essentially has had a regulatory disconnect, then no wonder our thoughts can start to — the rose tint in your glasses is quickly removed by an absence of sleep. And tragically, if you look across the 24-hour clock face and you plot the distribution of suicide attempts and suicide completion, it's not even across the day. A vast majority of suicide attempts and completion happen in those kind of hours between about 1:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. It's so marked.
The one thing that came up for me that I want to get to is like, you know, we've glorified, you know, the people that, you know, get the two, three hours of sleep. I mean, one of the things with, you know, Trump's campaign in 2024, a lot of people were like saying he was like a warrior because he got two or three hours sleep. And this is not a political conversation, but I'm just using it as an example of like when people see a powerful figure that gets like supposedly three hours of sleep at night, or an athlete, or something like Kobe Bryant was another one where it was just like, oh, you four hours of sleep.
Is that basically like you see — are you seeing the outlier of the hundred-year-old who's been smoking cigarettes their entire life and they're fine? Because some people might be hearing all these studies and the personal examples and things we're talking about and being like, "But what about him? He's like running the country, or he was like a world-famous athlete and like top player of all time." What would you say to that?
There were two other heads of state in the past — well, of this century — that were very braggadocio about their insufficient sleep: Margaret Thatcher, Ronald Reagan. Both of them were chest-beaters about how they just didn't need sleep. I've often wondered whether it was coincidental that both of them died of Alzheimer's disease.
Yeah. So, sleep — a lack of sleep can get you at any kind of short-term, midterm, or long-term point.
Short-term, one of the things that most people don't recognize about sleep is car accidents. A non-trivial proportion of car accidents, including fatal car accidents on our streets, are caused by drowsy driving. And the reason is when you start to become sleep-deprived and you're at the wheel of a car, you have what we call microsleeps. And what happens is that your eyelid will start to partially close and you're not aware of it. You have zero conscious awareness of these microsleeps happening.
But when we record on video — you can do sort of studies where you can either do driving simulations or you have them out on a track with cones and they're going around and you film them, and you have electrodes placed all on the head so you can record what's happening inside of the brain — they start to have these microsleeps that last about a second or a second and a half. And the brain essentially just dips its beak into sleep and then comes back again. And as I said, you are completely unaware of it. It's not that you fall asleep literally at the wheel; you're having these microsleeps.
And there are at least two problems. First, if you're traveling at 60, 70 mph on a freeway and you have one of these microsleeps that lasts a second, second and a half, that's enough time for you to drift from one lane into the next into oncoming traffic. So, in other words, that may be the last microsleep that you ever have in life.
The second reason that drowsy driving can be so dangerous is because unlike driving intoxicated — there you typically react too late because of the intoxication and you're impaired and you're slowed — with a microsleep you don't react at all, and so it's not even though you're at least getting some braking in. So that's one of the reasons that a lack of sleep can take you out quite quickly in the sort of the gene pool.
You know, often there was this great study from Harvard, and they found that people who are sleeping six hours or less versus seven hours or more, on a driving simulation, they had about a 30% higher likelihood of getting into an accident.
And people will sort of — I don't know — brag about the six hours, but imagine if a car — you ordered an Uber for your kids to take them to school, and two cars actually turn up by accident, and I pointed to them and said, "One of this car on the right, the black car, that has a 30% higher chance of getting into an accident than the car on the left — which would you choose?" And it's so obvious, of course, but we're making that forced choice so frequently if you look at the number of people who are getting six hours of sleep or less on our roads.
And then midterm, obviously, is things like diabetes, heart attacks. And then the longer term is obviously dementia. And so again, I always want to be so careful though here for people who are listening who struggle with sleep, and we'll hopefully get to speaking about how to try to optimize your sleep.
Don't think of this too much as the doom or gloom. Don't think, "Oh gosh, if I have one or even two back-to-back nights of sleep that I'm going to wake up the next morning and I'm going to have Alzheimer's disease or cancer." No, you're going to be just fine. It's simply that if you are getting insufficient sleep week after week, year after year, it takes its toll and there are real medical consequences. But in the short term, don't worry about it. But let's talk about getting your help when you need it for those patients, and we can go there later. But so yeah, I just want to put that as a proviso.
Also, I'll speak about the optimal way to get best sleep in the kind of ideal world. But to be honest, Matthew, no one lives in the ideal world. We live in this thing called the real world. And so I try to accommodate for that. And also, life is to be lived, for goodness' sake. I don't want to be the healthiest person in the graveyard. So take what I say, build it into your life to try to get some good sleep, but every now and again live a little bit, crack a bottle of wine open, have that with some friends at a weekend, you know, stay up late. That — do it. Just try to moderate it.
I think the time that we're living in is probably the most optimal to have this conversation, because more and more people are becoming interested in physical health. More and more people are becoming interested in longevity. Obviously, so much has been made in the past 15 years now about diet and exercise, and people feel like they've woken up to that in a major way. Where would you place sleep in that equation in terms of pillar of health? Is it equal? Is it like a foundational? What would you say?
I used to say that sleep was the third pillar of health, or I actually said it was the fourth pillar of health alongside diet, exercise, and mental health. Now I think I've changed my tune. I think sleep is the foundation on which those three other things sit. And I'll just give you maybe two examples.
Speaking about sleep and diet: if you're dieting but you're not getting sufficient sleep, then 60% of all of the weight that you lose — and you still lose weight when you're dieting and not getting enough sleep — but the problem is 60% of that weight that you lose comes from muscle mass and not fat. In other words, when you are not sleeping, your body changes what it gives up. And what it will do is it will hold on to the thing that you want to lose, which is the fat, and it will let go of the stuff that you want to keep, which is the muscle.
Another sort of interesting example is probably when you think about — so you can't quite exercise your way out of bad sleep either. I should note, if you are doing exercise, there was a great study that looked at how when you are underslept your blood sugar control starts to become impaired, and we know the mechanism for that, but if you exercise you can actually push back against that, and the severity of the kind of diabetes-like profile is not as bad as a result. So there are some ways in which those sort of things that are foundational but also can be tools in your box to say, if I am sleep-deprived, then it's an even stronger incentive for you to say, "I really should go to the gym," because I can at least reduce down some of the harm that it's doing, for example, metabolically.
But I mentioned the four pillars sort of initially: sleep, diet, exercise, and mental health. The sleep and mental health part is so powerful though, and here's another reason why it's foundational. We do a lot of work in sleep and mental health. In the past — gosh, now 22 years, past 22 years of studying sleep, we have not been able to discover a single psychiatric condition in which sleep is normal.
And that tells me everything I need to know about the intimate relationship between your sleep health and your mental health. And there's an amazing — I've written, I don't know how many different papers and written about it in the book. I've spilled so much ink trying to describe the relationship between sleep and mental health. But there's an American entrepreneur, E. Joseph Cossman, who I just said it so perfectly in a single sentence, and he said the following: "The best bridge between despair and hope is a good night of sleep."
Mic drop moment. I've experienced that in my own life.
Well, I have OCD. I was diagnosed with OCD probably, I don't know, eight — probably almost 10 years ago now. It's crazy how time flies. I've noticed that — and we'll get into my personal example of this later — but I've noticed that when I'm on very little sleep, and OCD is predicated on intrusive thoughts and this kind of treadmill of a thing that happens, it is way worse when I don't sleep. And so it's compounding because you're already in this kind of mental torment and then you don't sleep. And then it's just like when you're up at night, you're ruminating more, which makes you not sleep. And so it's like this cycle.
But that sleep has been really good in regulating — like if I have two hours of sleep throughout the night or I don't sleep at all, I'm in a totally different shape in the morning and the next day than otherwise.
And I think that's such an important point because it tells you that there's a tool that you have. It's freely available every single night, democratically available to pick up in repeat prescription. And it is a way for you to de-risk some of those components of the OCD. And so yes, it's a potential danger when you don't get sufficient sleep, meaning it's a vulnerability, but it also is something that you can control if you invest in sleep, and you can use it as a prescriptive medication almost.
So from my own investigation, it seems like whether sleep is helping or hurting us seems to come down to two things, which is how much we're getting and then how well we're sleeping when we do. Is that correct?
Yes. And I've thought about this a lot, and I think in sleep science the message that at least I started pumping out was all about quantity. You know, somewhere between seven to nine hours. So that's if you're going to focus on sleep, that's how you should target. I think it's a little bit more complex.
If you ask me what good sleep is, I think there are actually four macros of good sleep, just like the three macros of food — fat, protein, carbohydrate. Four macros of sleep, and I use the acronym QQRT. QQRT stands for quantity, quality, regularity, and timing.
So QQRT: quantity, as we've said, seven to nine hours. Quality is how well — we measure quality in at least two ways. The first is how continuous is your sleep? And I'd like to see kind of maybe one or two nice long bouts of sleep throughout the night. That would be good quality of sleep.
Poor quality of sleep would be: okay, you got eight and a half hours, but it took you almost 10 hours of time in bed to get that because you were awake, then you were asleep, you're awake, you're asleep, you were asleep, sleep, sleep, then you're awake, and then you're asleep. That type of fragmented sleep that's littered with all of these awakenings — that is poor quality of sleep, even though you may be getting sufficient quantity of sleep.
If you have a sleep tracker, the best way to measure your quality is something called sleep efficiency. And most trackers will give it to you. And it's simply: of the time that you're in bed, what percent of that time are you asleep? And I like to see at least 85% or more would be kind of good sleep efficiency. So that's QQ.
Then R stands for regularity. Go to bed at the same time, wake up at the same time, plus or minus 20 minutes on either side of your alarm. So you've got kind of like a 40-minute wiggle room, which is not bad.
But we were stunned by how powerful regularity is for your health. And there's a great study from the UK Biobank data set, massive data set, great study, and they looked at over, I think it was 60,000 individuals, and they were tracking their regularity and also their quantity.
Firstly, what they found was that for quantity, the shorter your sleep, the shorter your life. Short sleep predicted all-cause mortality. Highly irregular sleep versus very regular sleep was also associated with significantly higher premature death.
But then they did something really interesting. They said, well, in the same individual, we've got a measure of quantity and we've got regularity. So let's put them in the same statistical bucket and kind of do a Coke-Pepsi challenge to see which one wins out in predicting all-cause mortality. I think a lot of us in the sleep field — I at least did — I thought quantity is going to kill it.
Regularity beats out quantity in predicting all-cause mortality.
Now, that's not to say that you can start sleeping four hours, but do it really regularly and consistently and you'll be fine. They both matter, but goodness does regularity make a massive difference.
The final one, so QQR T stands for timing. And what I mean here is your chronotype. Are you a morning type, evening type, or somewhere in between? You don't get to decide. By the way, chronotype is not your fault.
It's dictated by over 350 genes — 351 genes if you're being specific — determine your chronotype. And it's like your eye color.
And this is a problem in society that we always favor the early bird, the early birds, the sort of the morning types, and we don't seem to like the night owls. We think they're a bunch of lazy people. You know, the first thing I would say is maybe the early bird catches the worm. Maybe that's true. The second mouse gets the cheese, just as a fun note.
What I would also say is that it's unfair to go after the night owls because it's like saying, "Well, we really like people with brown eyes, Matthew. And unfortunately, you have blue eyes, so can you do something about that, please?" I can't. It's not my fault. I was born this way. I can't change it.
And so the reason I bring up chronotype is because where you sleep on the 24-hour clock face matters. If I'm a night owl who likes to go to bed at 1:00 a.m. and wake up at 9:00 a.m., if you put me on the same sleep schedule as a morning type or even just a neutral who likes to go to bed at 10:00 and wake up at 6:00, we both get eight hours. So let's say the eight-hour opportunity is the same.
But if you ask me as a night owl to sleep my eight hours but from 10:00 to 6:00, my quantity and quality is going to be terrible. I'm going to lie in bed for the first hour and a half. I can't fall asleep because my biology is not ready for sleep yet. So I make this point just because where you situate your sleep window on that 24-hour clock face — if you're not sleeping in harmony with your chronotype, your sleep will be significantly more challenging. When you sleep in synchrony with it, it works so well.
And I get people who come into the sleep center. I have a concierge sort of sleep practice where we see clients, and people will come to me and they'll say, "I have terrible sleep-onset insomnia. I'm lying in bed awake for the first hour." Then we do a chronotype test and we find that they're a bit of a night owl, but they're going to bed with the sort of husband because he likes to go to bed at, you know, 10:00 p.m.
You don't have insomnia. You have a mismatch between when you're trying to force your brain to sleep versus when your biology wants you to sleep. And when you fight biology, you typically lose. And the way you know you've lost is disease and sickness.
That's so fascinating because a lot of people probably have diagnosed themselves with insomnia because they're trying to force themselves to go to sleep at a certain time. So just to be clear, are you saying that you could go to bed at 1:00 a.m. and wake up at 9:00? Because there's a lot of myths and things that I've come across of like there's an optimal window for your body to sleep, and if you're outside that window then you're going to get poor quality or worse quality, you're not going to get enough sleep, and it has to be in the nighttime. And like a lot — I feel like I've heard maybe even like sleeping...
This actually being asleep from 10:00 p.m. to 1:00 a.m. is like very important, and that's if you're going to sleep at 1:00 a.m., you're missing that window entirely.
Mhm. Yeah. There's two really interesting things embedded in your question there. The first comes back to what we were saying, which is sort of if you are sleeping in phase with the way that your biological rhythm is designed, then going to bed at 1:00 a.m. and waking up at sort of 9:00 a.m. could be fantastic for you. If you are a night owl and you will get all of the right stages of sleep at exactly the right time, wonderful, perfect.
But if I put a morning type, someone who likes to go to bed at, let's say, you know, 9 p.m. and wake up at 5:00 a.m., if I put them on a schedule of going to bed at 1:00 a.m. and waking up at 9:00 a.m., they're going to have terrible sleep. They will fall asleep, no problem, because it's going to be almost impossible to keep them awake until 1:00 a.m. The problem is their natural biological rhythm is going to start rising about 4:30 a.m. Cortisol will start to rise, their body temperature will rise, and it will eject them out of sleep. So they get hammered on the back end of sleep because they'll probably wake up at like 6:00, 6:30, and they will not be able to get back to sleep even though they've got until 9:00 a.m. before they're allowed to get out of bed.
So, and is this relative to the sun? Like, if you're in the East Coast and you're going to bed at 1 a.m. and then you go on the West Coast, are you technically supposed to still go to bed at 1:00 a.m. as an owl, or should you adjust to the 10:00 p.m.?
What you would do is you would gradually start to sort of adjust. Well, it depends on how long you're going to be in the time zone. I would say if you're going to be there for just like, you know, a couple of days, then try to stay on your same schedule and sleep when you would naturally sleep in New York.
But no, you should try to like thin-slice that equation. It's sort of like coming off a drug. You don't want to go completely cold turkey right away. So you would gradually adopt them. By the way, for jet lag, for every one day you are in a new time zone, your body will catch up by one hour. So if I fly from Los Angeles back home to London, then it's an eight-hour time difference. I have to be in London for at least a week before my circadian rhythm finally catches back up, because every day it can only kind of pop the dial out on the wristwatch and catch up by about one hour, and that's it, exhausted. So that's the first thing: you have to try to ask what is your sort of chronotype.
But the second point I was going to make regarding the time cutoff that you almost described: there's this myth out there that sleep before midnight is like the good stuff, and then, you know, sleep after midnight is not quite as good. There is zero scientific evidence that sleep that you get at 11:59 p.m. is any better than the sleep that you get at 12:01 a.m. It's complete nonsense. Now, there is at least a slightly different way of looking at that.
The way that sleep works is that you have a 90-minute cycle on average, but it's different from one person to the next, but on average it's 90 minutes. And when you fall asleep, you go down into light non-REM sleep. Then you go down into the deeper stages of sleep, deep non-REM sleep, and then after about 60 or 70 minutes, you'll start to rise back up. And then you'll have a REM sleep period.
And then you go back down again, down into non-REM, up into REM. You keep doing that across the night in these 90-minute cycles. What changes is the ratio of non-REM to REM within those 90-minute cycles as you move across the night, such that in the first half of the night, the majority of those 90-minute cycles are comprised of lots of deep non-REM sleep and actually very little REM sleep. But as you push through to the second half of the night, that kind of seesaw balance actually changes, and now you get much more REM sleep and very little deep sleep. So there is some truth to the idea that your deep sleep is kind of skewed towards the start of your sleep phase.
And then dream sleep comes at the end of your sleep phase. And I think that's where that sort of myth comes from, which is the idea that, you know, most, the average person maybe goes to sleep at, you know, 10:00 p.m. And therefore that's in those first two hours, yes, that's where you get lots of rich deep sleep. But the assumption about that myth too is that deep sleep is the good stuff and everything else is not good stuff. That's also a complete myth. Every stage of sleep supports different functions for your brain and your body at different times of night. They're all important. And that's why when people come up to me in the street or something, if they recognize you and say, 'Oh, yeah, you're the sleep guy, and I have a question for you. How do I get more deep sleep?' And I'll say, 'Well, why do you want more deep sleep?' And they'll say, 'Well, isn't that the good stuff?' And the answer is it is good stuff, but so too is actually lighter non-REM sleep, and so too is REM sleep. They all do something. So they all make up the quality of sleep. It's not just one of them.
That's exactly right. Okay. Yeah.
You need all of them, and you need them in sort of a certain degree. It's like the perfect kind of cocktail. You need to just have the right ratio of the ingredients.
Yeah, that's really important because a lot of people might be coming over this conversation. When you say quality, it's like deep sleep. And it's like if I'm not getting the deep sleep, although, and to your point, it's a part of the equation, then I'm not getting good quality sleep. And so why do people wake up in the middle of the night? Like, is that related to those types of sleep? I've got no idea what a sleep specialist is.
No, I'm kidding you.
So it's actually fascinating. Why is it that there seems to be this universal kind of 3:00 a.m. awakening thing? I think it happens too frequently across so many people that there's something there. And when we studied it, there is something there.
When you're awake, and from the moment, everyone listening to this podcast, the moment that you woke up, a chemical started building up in your brain, and that chemical is called adenosine. And the more that adenosine builds up, the sleepier you feel. So adenosine is the sleep molecule, and it develops this pressure — not a hydraulic mechanical pressure, but it's just a chemical pressure — builds up this pressure to sleep.
And after about 16 hours of being awake, you'll start to sort of have that sense of feeling sleepy. That's adenosine, and it's trying to push you down into sleep. And then when we go to sleep, the brain starts to evacuate and gets the chance to reduce down the amount of adenosine.
And it turns out that it's mostly during deep sleep when we clear out all of that sleepiness that's been building up across the day.
I make that point because after about, assuming a standard bedtime of like 10 or 11, by 3:00 a.m., I told you that you've had most of your deep sleep by then. It comes in the first half of the night. And it's during deep sleep where you get the chance to kind of drop down that level of adenosine. So you've actually removed a lot of that sleepiness that's been pushing you down.
However, there's a hormone called cortisol which gets a bad rap in biology. People think it's kind of, you know, bad, bad. It's bad if it's chronically left on and just in constant volume, but naturally, one of the things it's designed to do is wake you up. And about three or four hours before you start to wake up, cortisol, which typically drops to its lowest level in the first couple of hours of sleep, it starts to rise back up again now. And it's getting you prepared to wake up. And what happens is that around 3:00 a.m. is this perfect storm where your adenosine levels are getting cleared out and dropping, and your cortisol is starting to rise. And when those two things meet, it creates this fragile point that when you wake up, it's much harder to get back to sleep. Why? Because you don't have that same weight of sleepiness of adenosine pushing you back down.
It is frustrating. And you know what do you do about it? There are cognitive things that you can do, and there are pharmacological things that you can do. The cognitive things that you can do.
How best to describe it? At 3:00 a.m. when you wake up, your job is to try to get your mind off itself. Because if you're anything like me and I wake up at 3:00 a.m., the rolodex of anxiety starts to begin, and I start to ruminate. And when I ruminate, I catastrophize. And when I catastrophize, I'm dead in the water for the next two hours. It's terrible.
You're way too activated.
Far too activated. And I just can't shut down my mind. There are five different things that you can try to reduce this. The first is a sleep story. Turns out that Calm, the meditation company, they were looking at their — well, this is the story I've heard — they were looking at their usage statistics, and they were finding that rather than people meditating in the morning, which is when they were trying to encourage it, there was also a spike in usage sort of right before bed and then somewhere in the 3:00 a.m. area. And what they realized is that people are self-medicating their insomnia that they're using. So the first is you can do some type of a sleep story. You can also do meditation itself. You can do breath work where you inhale for like five, you hold for five, and then you exhale for eight. I play with the numbers. But this box breathing, you can also do a body scan where you just start at the top of the head and you start to ask, you know, is my forehead tense or should I just relax it down? Just move through your body gradually. And then the final thing is go on a mental walk, but it has to be in vivid 4K detail. So I'm going to think about the walk that I always do with the dog. So I open the drawer. I pick which lead. I'll take the blue one this time. I clip the dog in with my right hand. I open the door with my left hand. Take a left down the — it's that level of detail. And what's common about everything I just told you, a sleep story, meditation, kind of breathing, body scan, they are all designed to get your mind off itself. Because at 3:00 a.m., sleep is like trying to remember someone's name. The harder you try, the further you push it away.
And then the moment that you stop trying, that's when the name comes back to you.
That's been my experience all the time. I mean, it happened last night too. I mean, before, like, I was like, 'Oh, we're going to film this thing in the morning.' And then, you know, we went to bed at like 11, and then I woke up, it was like 1:00, and I was like, 'This is so...' First of all, I felt like I didn't get deep sleep at all. And I was just like frustrated. I'm like, I feel wide awake, and this is really annoying. And then, you know, every — but the times that that has happened in the past, like what you're saying, I feel like it works almost like, I wouldn't say magic, but it is very quickly. When I take my mind off of it. But then when you like hyperfocus and you're like, 'Oh god, I just have to wake up in X amount of hours and then...'
Yeah, that is one of the things that we tried to work on with a technique called cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, or CBTI, which is not only about trying to shut down the mind and quiet the mind, it's also about trying to stop you from kind of almost catastrophizing about the sleep that you're not getting. It's not just about the things in life that I've got to do. It's that you also start to just think, 'Oh my goodness, I'm not sleeping. If I'm not sleeping, it means I'm going to be a total mess tomorrow, and I've got this interview, and there's...' and that type of — it's almost like fatalistic beliefs about how a lack of sleep is going to hurt you, harm you, or just make life miserable.
And we typically say to patients, firstly, don't listen to that British guy on any podcast. That's not going to help you. Don't, you know, because he's always telling you about how bad things are if you don't sleep. Firstly, stop listening to that. Second, remember when you last didn't sleep well and think about the day that came after. You did okay, didn't you?
Things were okay. You didn't screw up the meeting. Your presentation went fine. It wasn't the best thing that you ever did, but you got through it. And you reaffirm the fact that it's not catastrophic by any means, and you have to try to kind of back people away from that negative thinking, these disbeliefs about the consequences. So those are the behavioral techniques.
Pharmacologically, there are ways that you can try to minimize those issues. With insomnia, we have a variety of different subtypes. You can have problems falling asleep, which is sleep onset insomnia. Or you can have problems staying asleep. That's sleep maintenance insomnia. That's the 3:00 a.m. awakening. For sleep maintenance, typically we no longer recommend using the classic sleeping pills, things like Ambien, Lunesta, Sonata. Instead, and here I'm just giving you scientifically descriptive advice. I'm not giving you medically prescriptive advice. I'm not trying to play a medical doctor. But one of the things that we'll use in the practice that I have, because I have clinicians that I work with, there's a medication called Doxepin, and it's typically not well known by doctors as a useful sleep medication. And it works differently. The Ambien, Lunesta, Sonata, they're in a class of drugs that we call the sedative hypnotics. And the problem is sedation is not sleep. But when you take an Ambien, you mistake the former for the latter.
But this medication, Doxepin, it's usually sort of 6 to 12 milligrams people take. It's really interesting that it goes after a chemical that is waking, and that chemical is called histamine. And if you've ever taken the old anti-allergy medications when you had kind of like hay fever or bad allergies, you'd take an antihistamine. And histamine in the body controls allergic reactions. Histamine in the brain does something different. It wakes you up.
And those old-school kind of allergy medications, they crossed the blood-brain barrier, and therefore they also blocked the histamine system in your brain, and it made you drowsy.
So now we realize here's one mechanism that you can use to sort of indirectly create sleep, which is you just remove wakefulness and then allow what comes in in its place, which is more naturally generated sleep. So that's one of those medications that's often used for sleep maintenance insomnia. The other class of medications that are quite useful, they're called the DORAs drugs, D-O-R-A, small s. And there are three FDA approved in the United States. Their chemical names: suvorexant, lemborexant, and daridorexant, which I expect you will remember very quickly for the rest of your — you know. Those are the chemical names, but suvorexant is probably the most well-researched, and its package name, if you want to look for it for anyone to ask your doctor about, it's called Belsomra, B-E-L-S-O-M-R-A, Belsomra. It's kind of a play on good sleep or beautiful sleep.
These medications also work somewhat similarly but a little different. They go deep down into the brain and they find the volume button on another wakefulness chemical which is called orexin, and they just dial down the volume of wakefulness, and then they take a step back, and then what happens once again, sleep typically arrives in its place. So those are the two medications, if you have sleep maintenance insomnia, that I would suggest exploring with a doctor.
Now, you said something really important because off the top we talked about a lot of the consequences, short-term, medium-term, long-term of like the lack of sleep and poor quality of sleep. Now, because the mental piece, right, how do you hold those two things, right? Because there is like my example, I told you like I felt like I had dementia when I went to London. I mean, then there's the emotional regulation, there's the learning. It's like those things are real, but it's like the mental piece is like you need to be able to just like hold that from like an intellectual, like cognitive, I guess, way, and then the mental is like not catastrophize around those outcomes. Do you get what I — like how do you hold those two things together of like there could be really bad outcomes of this and I want to get good sleep, but the more that I fixate on it, it's going to like further the bad outcomes.
I think it's — it's a really hard, almost contradiction, which is I'm telling you that there are consequences of not getting sufficient sleep, but please try to not think about the consequences of not getting sufficient sleep, because thinking about it only makes your sleep harder to obtain. And again, it's just trying to put it in perspective really, which is to say that a chronic, long-term insufficient sleep will cause you ill health. There's no two ways about it. But having, you know, a bad night here or there, those things aren't going to cause you, you know, major issues at all for the most part. But the point is really it's a way to motivate people to try to get the help that they need.
And once you bring a patient in, then you can start to say, 'Look, I know you're having bad nights of sleep, and you've survived it so far. You're here, you're healthy, you've got a job, you've got a functional relationship, you're doing okay, but we're going to get your sea legs back underneath you.' Because at that moment when your sleep controls you, it is a miserable, miserable feeling. And using cognitive behavioral therapy or using these pharmacological tools or a combination of both is the thing that we usually do. You get your sea legs back underneath you, and now you walk into the bedroom and you control your sleep rather than your sleep controls you. And that's a third layer of the cognitive piece of this puzzle, which is I give you the confidence to walk into your bedroom, and no longer is your bed your adversary. It's now the place where you know you're going to get guaranteed consistently good sleep.
And when you flip that cognitive switch, then the other two typically are solved. You stop worrying about the consequences, and also you kind of let go of the idea that life is just going to be a disaster.
I think it highlights a larger overall point for like the average person. You know, I think a lot of people could be taking in this conversation seeing how sleep could be a revolutionary health intervention and a foundational pillar of wellbeing. But the problem is that the difference between sleep and exercise and nutrition or even taking a pill is that like sleep is not in our control in the same way, right? So I could put a veggie in my mouth and get nutrients, and you know, I could take a walk and get the benefits of exercise, but I can't force myself to sleep, you know? So kind of highlighting what we were just talking about, you know, taking in all this information in some way might not excite people but could actually terrify them for the ones that have insomnia. So how would you respond to that, like the lack of control and powerlessness people feel when it comes to the subject?
I would say that is partially true but not completely true. It's true in the sense that I can't just will myself to sleep. Sleep is something that happens to you. It's not something that you make happen. And so in that regard, yes, you are to some degree at the whimsy of the whimsical nature of sleep. Does it arrive? I don't know. I hope so.
The way that I think about it is the following. You can at least set the conditions under which sleep is going to be much more statistically probable. It's not deterministic. It's probabilistic. Meaning I can't say like a one or a zero, guaranteed you're going to get sleep. But what I can at least do is create something where its probability is far, far higher. So I can think about when I get daylight, if I'm physically active, am I eating the right things? Am I watching my caffeine? And am I not consuming alcohol? Am I managing my stress and my anxiety? And there are other features too, but if you can just try to set those things in place, regularity too, I would put in that list probably almost at the top, you're going to give yourself a far, far better chance. So yes to your question, it is not under your conscious control, but also yes, and there are ways that you can make it much more likely.
You know, you mentioned the mind before and the things that we could do to kind of settle the mind or get that out of the way. It does seem like that in many ways is one of, if not the biggest obstacles to sleep. And you mentioned the thing about not — like the more we fixate on sleeping, the less we're actually going to sleep. A few years ago, I went through a pretty traumatic experience where I broke my collarbone, and like this happened, we were on a business trip in San Francisco, and it was very disregulating, and I started fixating on the sleep. I was already in like a bad emotional state because like this whole thing happened. But then I started fixating on my sleep. Like it was like one night I didn't get sleep, and then it was two nights I didn't get sleep, and then it was like that was three or four hours, and then I became increasingly anxious about getting sleep, and it turned into this basically month-long ordeal where I think there was one week where I literally slept every night for like an hour and a half, and like the next day I would wake up, and you would think you would be like hyper tired, and I was, but my mind was so aware, and the catastrophizing around the sleep.
That it just like it wouldn't happen. And so like when I would fall asleep, it was like this is where the power of the mind became so real to me. It was like I would start falling asleep, and then it was like my mind being like, 'You're falling asleep, you're falling asleep, falling asleep.' And then I would wake up. It would like wake me up because I was getting so excited about falling asleep because all day long I was like thinking about it. I was thinking about the fact that I wasn't sleeping. So it was like primary on my mind.
I had to take like a pill. It was trazodone. Trazodone to have an intervention. That was like the only — that's like a powerful drug, and it was the only thing that like kind of helped knock me out, and I slowly weaned off of that. I bring that up because I'm like, is my story, is that just like very extreme, or do a lot of people have those sorts of instances of like anxiety around sleep and then those sorts of ordeals?
No, I think you are very much not alone. And I think so many people listening to that story will think, 'I've gone through something so similar myself.' And we see this a lot with insomnia, which is the thing that initially triggered your insomnia ends up not being the thing that is maintaining your insomnia. Because it was the collarbone, and then it was sort of the stress of the insurance, and that was what triggered it. But then what you said to me, and correct me if I'm wrong, that it's almost as though that kind of faded away, and it was just this innate generalized anxiety about not being able to sleep.
Exactly. And that's one of the things that we also target in cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia is recognizing what was the precipitating event. Okay, good. It was bereavement, an accident, trauma, whatever it was. That's the precipitating event. It's not the thing that is persisting the insomnia. So one thing was sort of the initial instigator, but something else took over as the maintaining agent of the bad sleep. And that matters because it helps us target what we should be focusing on for you in terms of treatment. We don't have to keep going back to the broken collarbone and what that means for you and the stress. Now we have to actually be focusing on the fact that you are hyper — sort of you're overly thinking the consequences of just not being able to sleep night after night after night. That's harsh because I've just told you all of the consequences of not sleeping night after night after night. But we really need to just try to disabuse you of the idea that it's all going to be terrible.
The second part of that is not just trying to soften what your expectations are. And what you're having is what we call anticipatory anxiety. Everything that you're anticipating is it's bad. I'm not going to be able to sleep. It's going to have this consequence, that consequence. Above and beyond that, what we also have to try to manage is the idea that you actually can sleep. And we have to go back to remembering there were times when you could sleep just fine.