There's the value of sleep as a restorative force on our bodies. What is the value of dreaming?
Dreaming provides a form of informational alchemy. It's like group therapy for memories. Dream sleep gathers all of these sort of people and it forces you to speak to the people at the back of the room that you don't think you've got any association with whatsoever. Because when you start to fuse things together that shouldn't normally go together, they cause a marked advance in evolutionary fitness. That sounds like the basis of biological creativity. And so that's one of the functions of dreaming.
Well, it would have to be, especially when you have associations like a zebra in women's lingerie smoking a cigar while drinking a martini. Not that I had that dream.
This is StarTalk special edition, which means I got Gary O'Reilly here.
All right. And Chuck Nice, baby.
That's right. And we've been calling you Lord of Nice. Not just Lord Nice.
So Gary, we're talking about sleep today, I'm told. Which is people spend like a third of their life doing just that.
If you don't have kids, you spend a third.
There you go. I mean, I sleep like absolute dog crap. So...
I don't know what that means, but...
I haven't checked how much dog crap sleeps. So, what do you got for the show today?
All right. Sleep, as we've decided, it's an inescapable part of our daily lives. It's weird. It can transport us into a psychotic state. It can even leave us experiencing time dilation. It can heal us. Anyway, the last time we had a sleep expert on, our audience were very, very impressed. And so it's been a couple of years in the making, but we have brought him back along with Neil, our audience's curiosity. So we're going to have some questions from our audience tagged on to our conversation.
So let us introduce our returning champion, sleep champion, our returning guest, Professor Matt Walker. Matt, welcome back to StarTalk.
It's lovely to be back, gents. Thank you so much for having me.
Excellent. And last we caught up with you, you were at UC Berkeley just tearing down the house, but you've got new digs. What's the latest with you?
I have shifted. I am now a professor of neuroscience and biomedical engineering at UT Dallas at the Center for Brain Health. And here I'm starting a new center for advanced brain performance and sleep innovation. So I thought I would try and mix it up a little bit.
Wait, wait, wait. Advanced brain performance while you're sleeping, or is that a separate thing from sleeping?
It's 24-hour. So we're going to try to augment the human brain both when we are wide awake as well as when we are sleeping.
Okay, now you're spooking me out here.
The word augment, I think, is what spooks me a little bit.
He's going to make sleep zombies.
Don't we have those already? Exactly.
You've also been a TED talker, and you've got the podcast, The Matt Walker Podcast. You couldn't be a little more creative than that.
I know. It took years to come to that creative decision. I mean, there was the marketing, the research dollar spent just to come up with that task, you know? I mean, I thought it was borderline genius. There's so much going on in that title, isn't there? Really, the depth of it, which reflects my own personality. I am desperately shallow, but I have a very deep surface.
I'm desperately shallow with a deep surface.
See what he did there? I like that.
So what we want to know is what you know, it's been a couple of years. What's some new sleep research over those couple of years? And a lingering question that I've just always had is why do we need sleep at all? Is it too early in the show to start off with that question?
I did. I kind of went there because I think about aliens. If they visit us and then you say, 'Excuse me, Mr. Alien, I have to lie down horizontally and go semi-comatose for one-third of Earth's rotation. I'll be back to you.' The alien might just look at you like, 'What the hell is wrong with you?' And so, could you reflect on this so that when the alien comes...
Arguably the best question I've ever received in my entire career. Let me try. So, but I love the way that you frame it because imagine the birth of your first child and the doctor comes into the room. They say, 'Congratulations, healthy baby girl. Everything looks good. We've done all of the tests.' And they're walking out the room and just before they exit, they turn around to you, maybe like the alien, and they say, 'There is just one thing though. From this moment forward and for the rest of your child's entire life, they are going to lapse into a state of non-consciousness. It's going to look like death, but don't worry, it's reversible. And whilst their body lies still, their mind will be filled with bizarre hallucinogenic experiences. And we have absolutely no idea why this happens. Good luck. Take care. All the best.'
Well, my response would be, I'll have what the baby's having. Yeah, sign me up for that. That sounds really damn good.
But it's so perplexing because from an evolutionary perspective, sleep is the most idiotic of all behaviors. You're not finding a mate. You're not reproducing. You're not foraging for food. You're not caring for your young. And you're vulnerable to predation. On any one of those five grounds, sleep should have been strongly selected against in the course of evolution unless it serves an absolutely vital set of functions. And 50 years ago, to your question, we used to say, well, why do we sleep? And the best answer we had was we sleep to cure sleepiness, which is the idiotic equivalent of saying that we eat to cure hunger. No, you eat for all sorts of physiological reasons. Now, 50 years later, based on the wealth of the data, we've had to upend the question and ask: is there any major physiological system of your body, or is there any operation of your mind, that isn't wonderfully enhanced by sleep when you get it, or demonstrably impaired when you don't get enough? And so far, the answer seems to be no. And we can dive into the different functions, but I would say to your first part of the question, what's kind of fresh and new or just amazing, I would say two things. The first, we've been looking at what we call genetic short sleepers. So these are people who, based on the evidence, can get away with as little as about five to six hours of sleep and show no impairment in their brain or their body, whereas everyone else, it's a nose dive like a dot into the ground in terms of functions.
I fear I may be one of those, by the way, Matt, because I'm completely content with five and a half hours of sleep.
Yeah, but you can also sleep anywhere at any time.
Ah, that's a giveaway, actually.
Don't keep describing, because then he's going to have a word for it, and I worry when anytime they have a word for something I do.
Keep going. Yeah, I was going to say we call it chronic sleep deprivation, but I mean, if you can actually fall asleep rapidly almost anywhere, sometimes we wonder, is there a lingering sleep debt somewhere in the system where you have such a pressure for sleep that literally you can sleep within a heartbeat? That tends to bring a few sort of warning bells. But I mean, most people like you, Neil, would say, 'I wonder if I'm one of those sleepers.' Just to put it in context, statistically, based on the evidence, you're more likely to be struck by lightning in your lifetime than you are to be one of these genetic short sleepers, the probability of which is very small.
Have you been struck by lightning?
No, he didn't say both would happen to you. He's comparing two separate statistics.
Maybe that's the progression. You get struck by lightning and then you can't go to sleep anymore.
That is not what the man said. Okay, Matt, continue.
That's what we call augmenting the human brain with a bolt of lightning.
And there's at least one movie on that phenomenon with John Travolta.
Yes. He's hit by lightning and he turns completely brilliant.
And he can predict earthquakes and move stuff with his hands and things.
But we're actually just coming back. So we're doing a mini version of that. We've actually developed a headband which inserts a small amount of voltage into the brain. And it's so small you typically don't feel it, but it has a measurable impact on your brain waves. And what we've managed to do is create a stimulation protocol where you just wear it for 10 minutes before bed, and it's like a child on a swing. They're moving their feet and nothing happens. But if you start pushing them and giving them some momentum, at some point you can stop pushing them and they keep swinging. And that's what we're doing with the brain. We're sort of singing in time with your electrical brain waves and we're amplifying those brain waves almost. It's almost like electrically fertilizing the soil on your prefrontal cortex so that when you go into sleep, you germinate more powerful deep slow brain waves. So it's quite far away from John Travolta's experience in terms of the voltage magnitude, but not dissimilar. But coming back to the short sleepers, sorry, I keep losing track.
What this tells us is something absolutely remarkable. Not just that this exists and there's a genetic modification for it, but it means that somewhere along the way, Mother Nature has figured out how to zip-file sleep. She's been able to essentially compress eight down into six. And if we can start to find out the mechanisms, and we're digging into this now, we think you've got some good understanding as to how these genetic sort of mutants are able to accomplish this shorter sleep. What that means is that maybe think about a world of CRISPR and gene editing. Could it be that at some point everyone selects to be a genetic short sleeper?
Let me ask you this, Matt, based on what you just said. Is it possible that the genetic anomaly, this mutation...
Stop calling me a mutation.
Is it possible that the mutant... the Tyson mutant?
You turned him into an X-Man.
Like the most obscure X-Man ever. Tyson, what's your power? WATCH. I JUST SLEPT EIGHT HOURS. Okay.
I'm so cruel to you. I am so sorry, man. I got no respect.
Is it possible that when you find this anomaly, that you may not be able to make that a reality for every other person, because sometimes genes are expressed in sets, not just one particular gene, especially when it comes to mutations like that?
Yeah. So the nice thing is that we've been able to identify exactly which specific gene. In fact, there are actually right now there are four of these genetic short-sleeping genes. If you want to select from the sort of catalog menu that I'm sure is going to be on offer anytime in the next 10 years, maybe go for what's called the DEC2 gene. It's one of the shorter-sleeping genetic mutations. But yes, you don't have to run into that problem because of the selectivity and specificity of the gene identified. You can go right in there.
I mean, I'm trying to listen.
Hey, Matt, this is all I'm saying. I'm going to email you offline. I need in on this.
Do you know how much money you're sitting on?
Like, people don't need stimulants. You don't need... like, you're actually getting what you need in the amount of time that you're supposed to get it. You just shorten the time the brain needs to regenerate for that coming day. That's insane.
Exactly. Isn't that amazing as a concept?
Yeah, absolutely. Do we take this to the nth degree and say, well, we can reprogram our brains to need no sleep at all?
Is that too far out, or is that achievable?
That's too weird. It's an interesting concept.
Would you want to stay up 24 hours a day, seven days a week if you could? Now, believe me, I used to do meth, so I've done it. But thank you for laughing at that, Matt, because these two are just as silent as church mice right now.
Tumbleweed. I see them across the screen right now.
We're not laughing at your meth jokes, Chuck. I'm sorry.
He's in Texas now, so he gets to reference tumbleweed. You see, that's how that works.
But would I want to? I don't know. There's something magical about the state of a deep sense of relaxation and restoration that I feel when I come out of deep sleep, but also dreaming. I would be so sad to lose the optionality of dreaming. So, I don't think I would.
These days, we're used to getting things delivered on demand: groceries, a new gadget, or the latest book expanding your view of the universe. And now you can add T-Mobile 5G home internet to that list. Just order from T-Mobile and enjoy same-day delivery with DoorDash. And you can set it up yourself in about 15 minutes. No advanced engineering degree required. That means more time doing the things you actually enjoy, like streaming a space documentary or going down a rabbit hole about exoplanets, asteroids, or whatever's pulling your curiosity. And those online explorations are a lot easier with the fastest 5G home internet. So if you're moving into a new place or just ready to upgrade your connection to something a little more advanced, visit t-mobile.com/homeinternet to check availability and get your home internet delivered today. Same-day delivery for most internet-eligible customers. See if it's an option during checkout. Fastest according to UCLA speed test intelligence data, second half 2025. All rights reserved.
Before we go to Q&A, because this is a Patreon episode, right?
Yes, it is, from our Patreon members, from the Patreon people.
And because they're thinking about sleep. So there's the value of sleep as a restorative force on our bodies and minds, perhaps. But then, what is the value of dreaming? And is that any different from daydreaming?
Ooh, yes, it is. Based on the architecture of the... based on the patterns of brain activity, they're not quite the same thing. But to your first part of the question, what does dreaming do? And we have to be clear: what does dreaming do above and beyond the stage of sleep that it comes from? So we have two main types of sleep: non-REM sleep and REM sleep. And most dreaming comes from REM sleep, or rapid eye movement sleep.
And it's not just whether you have REM sleep. REM sleep has a series of different physiological functions. But dreaming on top of REM sleep also has selective benefits, and there are at least two. The first is that dreaming provides a form of informational alchemy, which is that every morning when you wake up having gone through dreaming, you wake up with a revised mind-wide web of associations. Because it's during dreaming that we take all of the information that we've recently learned and we collide it with this back catalog of information that we've stored up across a lifetime, and we don't start to make the obvious connections during dreaming. That is what we do when we're awake. Dreaming is biased towards building the more distant, non-obvious associations.
So the whole thing is, they say, sleep on it.
That's where you get that phrase from. Sleep on it.
Correct. How many times has someone ever said to you, you know, Neil, you should really stay awake on a problem?
No one tells you that. No one says that.
They tell you to sleep on a problem. And that's exactly one of the functions. It's almost like group therapy for memories. Everyone gets a name badge, and then dream sleep gathers all of these sort of people and it forces you to speak to the people at the back of the room that you don't think you've got any association with whatsoever. But when you do, you find it's a distant, non-obvious connection, because when you start to fuse things together that shouldn't normally go together, but when they do, they cause a marked advance in evolutionary fitness. That sounds like the basis of biological creativity.
And so that's one of the functions of dreaming.
Well, it would have to be, especially when you have associations like a zebra in women's lingerie smoking a cigar while drinking a martini. How do you actually relate that to anything in your life? Tell me that. Not that I had that dream.
Was it a friend that had a friend, that a friend of yours told you?
You know, there's very few sleep questions that have ever left me dumbfounded.
So let's get to the questions. We have a bunch of questions here. With Matt's explanation about dreaming, then to take sleep out of our lives completely wouldn't make any sense at all, would it?
No. Especially because, and I mentioned there was a second function that is perhaps even more relevant to that want of keeping it, which is that dreaming provides a form of overnight therapy. Dreaming is emotional first aid, and it's during dreaming at night when we take difficult, sometimes painful experiences, and dreaming acts like a nocturnal soothing balm, and it just takes the sharp edges off those painful, difficult memories so that you come back the next day and you feel better about that experience.
I got one. I'll tell you what happened to me the night of September 11th.
2001. Four blocks from the collapse of the towers. And so I have to get my family out.
I was going to say you were still... you go ahead.
No, no, it was traumatic. I maintained composure, but it was traumatic. I had to get my two kids. One is nine months old, one is four and a half. And I collect my wife in Midtown because we live downtown. And we went up to my parents in Westchester, New York. Okay, very safe distance from... And they were running trains in one direction. Yeah, they weren't taking people back in. Okay, so the reason why I'm saying this is at the end of the day, I went to sleep and I woke up 11 hours later.
And I was astonished because it didn't feel like 11 hours, but I'm echoing your point. My brain had to process what the hell just happened.
Exactly. And that was more than a day's worth of content, I would say.
And so is it just the easy explanation here that my brain wasn't ready for me to wake up yet? It was still processing all this disparate content that didn't happen in a typical day.
We see this time and time again. Whether it's whether you're learning vast amounts of information that requires memory consolidation and the cementing of new information into the architecture of the brain, or that you've had difficult emotional experiences, there is a selective drive and a demand from your brain and your body to get more sleep to see if it can reconcile the weight of the kind of burden of life that you've given it that prior day. And so it fits exactly, I think, with your experience. You know, there's a beautiful... an American entrepreneur, E. Joseph Cossman, had a wonderful phrase. He once said that the best bridge between despair and hope is a good night of sleep.
And I would say that in the past 20 years of studying sleep and mental health, we've not been able to discover a single psychiatric condition in which sleep is normal. And I think that tells me everything that I need to know about the intimate relationship between your sleep health and your mental health.
You're saying your body knows.
That explains a lot about me. Thank you, Matt.
I'm understanding myself much better now.
Should we dive into... send us the bill for that? Let's get some Patreon questions.
Okay, Matt, sit up straight. Here we go. Ronald, great name. Ronald Nigel McWilliams from Selma, Alabama. Thank you for what you do. You're welcome. Thank you for being one of our Patreon group. Let's put the glasses on. If the brain can generate a fully immersive reality during dreams without external input, what does that reveal about waking consciousness? Are dreams just neural noise, or do they expose that what we call reality is always a controlled construction of the brain, with sleep revealing the machinery more clearly?
That's quite a deep one. That's a big question.
Just so I understand the question, is it that the brain is processing your awake state?
I was going to say your woke state, but that's got baggage today. Okay.
Your awakened state.
And does your brain know that that is an objective reality versus what it dreams about? Is that where he's trying to get at?
I think what he's saying is that no, all of reality is a perception of our brain. So when we go to sleep, does that kind of perceptive reality then just become neural noise, or does it serve a purpose to reveal the machinery more clearly?
That was good. That was good. Great question. Wonderful synopsis. I would say what this question to me reveals is an uncomfortable truth about your dreams, which is that your brain can build an entire universe. So, space, time, faces, emotions, memory, narrative, coherent out of nothing.
There's no light hitting your eyes. There's no sound. There's no world. You're cut off from reality. But in the dark of this thing that we call our skull, it is manufacturing a fully convincing reality, and it does it every single night. And that has an implication, because if the brain can do it when essentially the doors are closed, what makes you so sure that what you experience when your eyes are open...
Don't mess with us like that now. Stop messing with us.
I'm going to have to go further, because the reality is it actually isn't any different than that. So what we call reality right now is also a construction. It's a model that your brain is building behind your eyes. And the only difference is that the waking perception is almost like a controlled hallucination, one that's essentially tethered to time, second by second by second. And that information is streaming from your senses. That's the only difference between your waking consciousness and your dreaming consciousness.
Yeah, you're coming in and out of the matrix there, just in case you didn't know.
Programs, hacking programs. Yes.
But no, so it's a wonderful demonstration that I think there are these hard boundaries that we think of that are actually much more porous than we imagined. That there's this thing called the dreaming state and the waking state. They're very similar in some ways, except that dreaming has a feature to it that really gives it away, which is that you have no logical, rational reasoning or control. And that's where you start to believe things which are not there. So you hallucinate. You are delusional. You get confused about time, place, and person. You're suffering from disorientation. And then how wonderful, you wake up in the morning and you forget most if not all of that dream experience. So you're suffering from amnesia.
If you were to experience any one of those five things when you're awake, you would be seeking some psychological treatment. But for reasons that we now understand based on the patterns of brain activity when you go into dreaming, this seems to be a normal biological and psychological process. And the principal reason that dreams are the way that they are is because the thing that makes us most human, which is called the prefrontal cortex, that part of the brain, unlike the rest of the brain, the brain lights up when you go into REM sleep. In fact, some parts of your brain are 30% more active than when you're awake, which is stunning, except for the prefrontal cortex that goes offline. So now you have these emotional centers, these memory centers, the visual centers, the motoric centers of the brain. They're all active, but the kind of prison guards, they've left the building and the prisoners are running amok. And that's the beauty of dream sleep. There is no sort of CEO in control with top-down regulation. There's no logical, rational control.
The inmates are running the asylum.
Basically, that's exactly what it is. And we believe that there's good utility to that. That's where you get kind of the loosey-goosey, everything starts to get connected together in these wacky, strange ways. No wonder you can solve problems in your sleep in a way that you can't with this very rigid way of thinking that is the waking state.
Wow, that is... now you've scared me.
However, that's... so your dreams were the world's first psychologist, first of all, right?
They were exactly. It is your therapist.
Your therapist in a therapist.
Inner therapist.
Wow, what you just said there, Matt, actually answered Aaron Ganon's question as well. So Aaron, thank you for your question. So let's move on to Sam, who says, 'Greetings, Dr. Tyson, Lord Nice, Gary, and Mr. Walker. My name is Sam and I'm writing to you from the home of Casey Jones, Jackson, Tennessee.'