Chris Cuomo here. Welcome to NewsNation. We do have new developments in the Nancy Guthrie abduction case or missing person case. Just hours ago, a second message regarding the alleged abduction, the assumed abduction of the 84-year-old mom of the Today Show anchor, sent to the same local station that received a note a few days ago. Notice this one's not being called a ransom note like the one TMZ received a few days ago. Why? I don't know. We'll discuss with TMZ's founder, Harvey Levin. He'll be up shortly. I wonder if authorities suspect that someone from the local environment, the local community, is in play here given the repeated connection to media outlets that are familiar only to locals. The news of the note coincided with a lot of renewed activity outside the missing mom's home. NewsNation senior national correspondent Brian Enton is there. Brian, what's your best sense about why the return to this house, which they had again unsealed as a crime scene, only to once again make it one?
Yeah, the timing is interesting, Chris, because it was around the same time that the FBI announced that this new note existed. We were outside the house, as we have been, and all of a sudden, sheriff's department showed up, said, "Everybody's got to go. You've got to move at least a block away. We're closing off the entire area." Luckily, we had our drone up so you can see a little bit of what's going on, but we're now a block away. I saw FBI teams going in, the tinted windows. I tried to look in and I could see the FBI logo on the shirt. There were evidence trucks going in. And they've been going in the house, we could see on the drone, but then also they were behind the house and it almost looked like they had neighbors out there with them pointing out things to them out in the backyard behind the house. Chris,
somebody may have used landmarks in the letter. You know, again, it's the same vexing question, though. Are these letters red herrings or is this somebody who's actually involved? I mean, that's the thing we still don't know. Brian, I appreciate you. Same rules apply. You learned something, get in my ear and I'll come right to you. I do want to bring in TMZ founder Harvey Levin. Earlier in the week, you'll remember TMZ received an alleged ransom note for the return of Nancy Guthrie. The note claimed to have Nancy, asked for millions in Bitcoin, gave two deadlines, unusual, not unheard of, one yesterday, another for Monday. Are there similarities to this new note? A journalist who looked at it said it was well constructed, which was language that Harvey had used in describing the note that they got. Harvey, thank you for joining us here. What is your sense, gut, on whether or not these notes are likely connected to someone who's actually involved as opposed to some sicko looking for attention?
I am increasingly believing that these notes are tied to whoever may have taken Nancy. And I say that because in the first note they mention an Apple Watch. Well, it wouldn't be hard to guess that she had an Apple Watch because there were photographs of her with Savannah, but it says where the Apple Watch was located and it was not in a place that you would necessarily immediately think, and that seemed to pique the FBI's interest. The second thing is that it said that the flood light in the backyard was destroyed. Now, Chris, there is a difference between observing a damaged flood light and calling it a destroyed flood light. That word "destroyed" to me, and again I'm taking a leap here, I realize that, but when you say it's destroyed, that may be something you did. If it's damaged and you just see it, you call it damaged. But if there's a light that's illuminating and you don't want to be seen, you kick it, you disable it, and maybe you destroy it. So that kind of, I found that kind of interesting. And it sounds like these two notes are connected. I heard a KOLD reporter talking about it and the construction of the two letters are similar, she says. And I can tell you the structure of the one that I've seen, it is well written. The grammar is perfect. It is structured and layered, and she said she saw the same thing here, and it has the markings that these are written by one and the same.
Sending something to TMZ, I get. Sending something to KOLD is very specific. Harvey, does that pique your interest as it does mine?
Yeah, I heard what you were saying to Elizabeth and I could not agree with you more. That this is somebody familiar with the Tucson area and is familiar with the local station. And I will go a step further that, you know, they sent it to us and we were more forthcoming than KOLD. They were playing it close to the vest and we got the same letter 12 hours after KOLD did. So it was almost as if they wanted people to, or some media outlet, to talk about it more than KOLD was, and they sent it to us. So I don't know if we're going to get this other letter in another 12 hours from now. I don't know. But it feels to me like it's somebody connected to that area where KOLD broadcasts. And you know, I was thinking of this last night that, you know, this could be one of two things. It's either somebody watching television saying, "Oh wow, there's Savannah Guthrie on the Today Show. She's rich and famous. Let's find a relative." Or it could be somebody who lives in that area and says, "Huh, Nancy Guthrie, I know her daughter is really famous. It's Savannah. And she lives in the same area." And then they hatch a terrible plan. So it feels to me it's the latter. And the fact that they went back to KOLD, which has been covering this extensively, reinforces to me that this may be somebody still in that area. We've kind of figured out a radius, but it may be closer to Tucson than the outside radius that we found.
Yeah, you were reckoning that because of the time factor that they used in terms of what they would need to get Nancy back home, it made you draw somewhat of a suggestion about where they could be. The only thing that bothers me about this in terms of the process is the authorities keep shutting down the crime scene of the house and then opening back up again. It's very unusual. Usually in situations like this, they establish a crime scene and it stays like that until it comes to its conclusion. Hopefully now that they went back to the house, hopefully what they were looking for to coordinate and correlate to whatever was suggested in the letter, hopefully it wasn't spoiled. Harvey, this is an unusual one, don't you think?
Give me your take on that and then go ahead.
It's interesting what you just said. I remember way back when I was covering OJ Simpson that they had a crime scene. They took the tape down at a point a few days after, and then I remember getting a call saying they may have found the knife in the area, and all the tape went back up. And I remember going there and there was a lot of activity. So I don't know what it is they're looking for right now, but it's clearly something that they feel is really important, and it's something that they didn't connect to the person who wrote this letter, and they are trying to connect that. So that doesn't shock me that they would reinstitute a crime scene if there's something that didn't seem important that suddenly seems very important.
Yeah. You know, people were asking why isn't there a lot more camera from all the surrounding community? Well, one, we don't know that there isn't, and two, this is a different kind of neighborhood than where the Kohberger crime, people keep mentioning that one to me, in Idaho. And one of the big differences is that the houses are more elevated there on top of the streets in that surrounding area where Kohberger did his wickedness. And there were street-side cameras. There was more of a trafficked area than this one is. This is not a place where you're going to see cameras on telephone poles and stuff like that. Ring cameras, home security, there weren't a lot of street lights either, right? You know, so you got to play the ball where you find it. Look, hopefully this activity is suggestive of something real for investigators because obviously nobody wants to see this go on any longer than it has to. But it's a weird one. It's a weird one and not just because it involves a TV personality. Harvey, thank you very much. Appreciate the access and the opportunity.
All right, take care. So, just before the show, President Trump actually weighed in on this case. He was on Air Force One and it was very... Let me let you play it and then you tell me what you think of it.
And I think we're doing very well on that regard. You're probably surprised to hear that. I think we're doing very well. Very well. Meaning we have some clues I think that are very strong and I think we could have some answers coming up fairly soon.
Is this a nationwide search? Is this a search going to Mexico?
I'm not talking about a search. I'm talking about a solution. We have some things I think that will maybe come out reasonably soon from DOJ or FBI or whoever that could be...
Yeah, it could be definitive.
Just a lot's taken place in the last couple of hours.
I don't get it. I don't get a solution. Let me bring in former FBI special agent Jennifer Coffindaffer. Look, I think the president, monkey video aside, which I'll deal with after the break, but he knows to not be that insensitive about a situation like this. You don't want to sell above what you know in a situation like this. But the idea of a solution, that's an interesting word, Jennifer, isn't it?
It is a very interesting word. What does that mean? That didn't make much sense to me. But I'll tell you what, I wanted to talk to you, Chris, about the incongruency of these ransom notes. The whole reason for a ransom note is to get money. And it occurs to me that these notes aren't meant to get money. What they are meant to do is cause Savannah Guthrie and her loved ones, it's just torturing them with this. They're not doing anything to get money. So, I'm just wondering what the real motive here is.
You know, the mother is not a nobody. You know, I'm sure her source of pride is, of course, her children, but, you know, she's a well-known Christian author and she does a lot of speaking and stuff like that. So, it's not impossible that this has to do with her life, not Savannah's.
It's not impossible. But what I'm watching is the family suffering. I mean, Lord knows what Nancy is suffering and has suffered, but this whole family has been targeted with this process and these continued notes and messages that keep coming forward. And then to have the president say there's a solution at hand. Obviously, he's talked with them and it seems to me that law enforcement knows a lot more in the last few hours than they've known previous.
How unusual is this case?
Oh, it's so unusual. I was talking about this with Gags earlier that how in the world can you have a case like this that doesn't have the intent of receiving a ransom, but you're sending ransom notes. In other words, typically right after somebody is kidnapped, you would contact the family and you would want to be under the radar. You don't want media involved and you certainly don't want to contact after law enforcement is involved. And look at where we're at. That is their modus operandi. That's what they're doing.
What about reaching out to local TV stations? Yes, TMZ also after. But does that suggest to you that it's someone from the area who has that familiarity with the local TV station?
It does. And there were two local stations contacted. And then this is the first time I heard from Harvey that then 12 hours later they get the note. I agree with him that that was because the other TV stations kept it quiet and that's not what this perpetrator wants. This perpetrator wants this all over the news. They want everybody to look at this and his handiwork. That's what I'm seeing.
Jennifer Coffindaffer, thank you very, very much. Hopefully the president's right to have the confidence that he suggested on Air Force One. Appreciate you. Enjoy the Super Bowl. Have a good weekend.
4 minutes and 35 seconds. Coming up, instead of focusing on healthcare, the economy, we can't get out of the cycle of division because it's what works for one side against the other. And the president is up to an entirely new and new level of disgusting monkey business. And it is racism. That's what it is. And it's more than that. And I'll tell you what, people who think this is about making a joke out of the Obamas and all these other people, no, it's making a monkey out of you. And I'll explain why. And then, NewsNation's newest big shot, Katie Pavlich, joins me with her take.
All right, let's talk about the Obama monkey video. It wasn't an accident. It wasn't a mistake. And I don't care that there are a lot of Democrats in the extended video. You use a quick clip of Obama and his wife as monkeys. You know what message it sends and you know it is wrong and whoever was a part of it should be exposed and disposed of. Of course, the president doesn't take the blame. Of course, they took it down. The message was sent and received. And of course, his mouthpiece tries to put the blame on the rest of us. This is from an internet meme video depicting President Trump as the King of the Jungle and Democrats as characters from The Lion King. Please stop the fake outrage. Fake outrage. Tell that to Senator Tim Scott. He posted this was the most racist thing he's ever seen out of the White House. Interesting choice of words. Most racist as opposed to the only racist thing he's ever seen out of the White House. Scott apparently called the president, asked him to remove the video, and then Trump deleted it. Because if you don't want people to accuse you of being racist, guess what? Don't do things like this. Okay? Now, the Obamas have not responded to the video. I'm not surprised. Instead, the president put out a message to America's athletes on the night of the opening ceremony of the Olympics. To all the athletes, we're proud of you. We're with you. You know, saying all the right things instead of getting down in the mud. Good move. Someone can still take the high road because the current president said moments ago he didn't make a mistake by posting the video. He only watched the first part of the video which was about voter fraud and he gave it to his people and they didn't watch the whole thing.
I argue that the first part of the video should be just as embarrassing for him as the end of the video is obviously offensive. But what comes before it is the real story that motivated the bigotry in the first place. See, while it's good that some Republicans are saying, "Oh, you shouldn't have Obama as a monkey." Oh, great. But they're not saying anything about what came before it. This absurdist nonsense about the 2020 election conspiracies that have been debunked before the two-second monkey crap. 58 seconds of absurd, baseless conspiracies. They don't even mention that. Why would you put this BS with the monkey BS? Here's my take. The president believes that the kind of person who would believe the nonsense that he's putting out about the last election being rigged would be amused, would enjoy depicting the black president and his wife as monkeys. In other words, the joke is not on the Obamas. The president is actively making a monkey out of you. Now, the guy in the video is retired Army Colonel Phil Waldron, an army-trained spook in psychological influence operations, PSYOPs. He circulated a 38-page PowerPoint back in 2020 to the members of Congress, to the White House. He had all these meetings with the Trumpers arguing that they should declare a national emergency to stay in office because China and Venezuela had remote control over our voting machines. No evidence, nothing to support the claims. They were dismissed. The MAGA folk couldn't meet with them enough, but everybody who had a fully functioning cerebellum dismissed the claims until now. It seems the White House is trying to distract with conspiracies that the midterms are rigged just in case, just in case they don't go their way. What they should be doing is meeting where the majority is, our concerns, not monkey business about the past, the dire concerns of the current, specifically the cost of living, specifically healthcare. Now polling as more concerning than groceries, utilities, rent and mortgage payments and gas prices. Let's discuss the state of play. Host of Katie Pavlich Tonight, Katie herself. Good to have you. Happy Friday.
Hey, Chris. Thank you for having me. Good to see you. Happy Friday.
What does this mean? Not so much the monkey business. What does this intense messaging that the elections were rigged mean about the disposition towards the midterms for the administration?
Well, first I think it's really important to point out that the outrage over the depiction at the end of a scroll video, which then automatically went to another video, was not vindictive in nature. Was it a mistake? Yes. Did it cause a problem for the White House all day today? Yes. Is the president upset about it? And there's new reporting out tonight that there are a number of White House staffers who are upset that this occurred because the narrative all day was not on the fact that last night President Trump announced TrumpRx, which means that medication prices are going to go down for Americans because Europeans now are going to pay their fair share when it comes to investment in drugs and the R&D that comes into the research of those drugs. We're not going to be subsidizing Europeans anymore for our medication. They're not talking about the Dow that hit an all-time high today. They had that press conference from the Department of Justice by Benghazi. Exactly. Where they brought justice after 14 years for four Americans who were killed in that attack. And so yes, it was not handled the best way. They should have immediately investigated it and realized that it was an automatic scroll into a video which, as you did play, depicted a number of people and animals. Is it silly? Yes. But was it vindictive? And does it classify the president of the United States as a racist? No. And I think if you look at his policies, people in his cabinet, the people who have visited the White House, including Nicki Minaj recently, to call him a racist or to imply that he is one based on that video is very disingenuous and lacking context.
Well, too bad because let me tell you something. If you don't want somebody to call you that, then you don't do things like this. He didn't show Biden and everybody else. They just showed the Obama part. So it doesn't matter what it clicks and stuff. But they didn't do it on purpose. This is an unforced error which is the issue.
It is an unforced error. But that's very different than being vindictive about it and doing it on purpose. It is an unforced error.
What good purposely clipping it to show that?
Well, first of all, it was absolutely purposely clipped to show the Obama part. It was just part of a much bigger video. That's not the beginning. Well, it's not the beginning of the video. Automatic.
It's not the first thing you would see.
Because it's the end of the video which automatically scrolled into the next video. That's what happens.
Oh, no. I know. I understand how buffering and queuing works. What I'm saying is somebody was a vindictive portrayal of the...
You call it what you want.