Russell Brand at times showed up to his rape trial looking like a porn star with his shirt unbuttoned almost down to his belly button. And I can't believe his lawyer let him in court the way Russell Brand looked.
Appearances matter. And I don't mean to say this in a denigrated way, but he looks rapy when he's accused of raping.
I've really been looking forward to this all week. We are going to talk about why Russell Brand was convicted of rape. And we're going to get into three things. One, his pattern of conduct. Two, the media attention in this case, which he said made a difference. And three, appearance, the way he dressed, what he carried into the court, and how that may have made an impact. But what we're dealing with are a couple of things. He was charged with three counts of rape, three counts of sexual assault, one count of attempted indecent assault against six women in total. He was found guilty on one count of rape, three counts of sexual assault. He was acquitted on the remaining counts. The judge said that he will sentence him on Monday, but made it very clear he is going to get significant prison time. So, in terms of...
You know what the first kind of early canary in the coal mine is, if I'm not mistaken, he was remanded into custody, even saying or pleading with the idea that he wanted to go home and see his kids.
Yeah. The judge said nope. So, that means he's not going away. That means that's not 180 days or a year.
No, he's going to get years.
But he talked a lot about this when he made appearances, and his Piers Morgan appearance I think is really revealing, especially as we get into his kind of pattern of conduct that came out in the trial.
For some reason I asked you halfway through, are you a more successful sexual predator now that you don't drink? And you replied yes, but I resent the word predator. I like to think of myself as a conduit of natural forces. After all, the most natural thing in the world for people to do is, isn't it?
And people want to do it. So, all you have to do is remove all the reasons why women don't actually go through with it, like pride and reputation. You just have to unpick the condition stopping women going straight to bed with you.
That sounds like charm, seduction, game. So Mark, this feels like he's almost saying, 'I know what the roadblocks are to having sex with a woman, and I know how to eliminate roadblocks,' which is a really bizarre way of looking at sexual interactions.
Well, you know, the word predator is when you look at somebody as prey. And when you talk about that and he says, 'I object to the use of the word predator,' and then immediately goes for a description which looks like somebody who is trying to consider somebody a prey. That's why lawyers go so crazy when somebody is in the crosshairs or is themselves law enforcement prey and they're making statements like that, and it's an unforced error, so to speak.
You know, and I agree with that. What he said, what came out on the stand was, look, this all occurred, all of the allegations and ultimately the convictions occurred between around 1999 and the early 2000s when he was at the very height of his popularity, of his celebrity in England. And the way it was kind of described in court is he had an MO that he would literally at times pick women, young women, out of the crowd that came to see him and he would then flatter them. He would be charming with them and then once he got them in close quarters his personality would turn radically and he would become ominous. And what is interesting, and I think you've probably seen this in cases, is what they try and do, what prosecutors try and do, is establish patterns. So yeah, you may not believe this one woman standing alone, but listen to all of them talk and they're all coming up with the same pattern.
Yeah. Well, you're right because we frequently will say what you lack in quality you make up for in quantity, meaning that the more people you throw into the mix, the more compelling it is, or the more you get people to say, 'Oh, where there's smoke, there's fire and boy, this is a wildfire.' One of the, there's a couple of crosscurrents going on with Russell Brand. I mean, I used to listen to a friend of mine, a very good friend of mine who I had a podcast with, Adam Carolla, and Adam used to say, 'Why is there,' he would make the observation about people who are accused of either sexual harassment or prosecuting these cases, 'Why are they not really good-looking people?' I mean, there's a lot of people who think Russell Brand is good-looking and therefore these allegations don't seem to jive with somebody who is good-looking.
Because why? Because they could get women on their own without having to do anything.
Correct. I mean, it's kind of the poster child for that kind of thinking, so to speak, was Harvey Weinstein, not Harvey Levin, but Harvey Weinstein. And this idea that they were using the power dynamic, which is so popular when it comes to the experts in terms of explaining these things. But one of the other interesting things about this was this kind of subtext that it wasn't until he had flipped his political or his ideology, if you will, affiliation, and that's when all of these things got resurrected. Because when you take a look at the age of these allegations, I mean some of them they're old enough to vote when you talk about the age of the allegation, and there was this idea of was he being prosecuted? Was there a documentary? And the documentary is also an interesting subcurrent.
Well, that's what triggered this. And the documentary, the BBC documentary was 2023, and that seems to be what triggered all of this.
And that is an occurrence that happens all too often. But it's a double-edged sword. I have seen cases, and I've personally handled cases where a documentary ends up being kind of very effective in getting somebody justice or getting some kind of attention on it. And then you have the opposite here where a documentary can end up being the death knell for somebody in terms of being able to get a fair trial. But there's also the factor of this judge, and I don't know, have you reported on the judge who was handling this case?
Yeah, he was very stern and, you know, that courtroom was all business.
Well, except I think it was monkey business. And I'll explain why. One of the things that you want from a judge is not putting their finger on the scale, letting people try their case. That's the hallmark, at least in the US, and this was obviously in the UK. You don't, I always say as a shorthand, just stay out of my cross-examination. Let me do my thing. You want to rule against me on everything else, just stay out of my cross. The reports are that what was happening during the cross is that the judge was not only interrupting but interrupting at key points where the defense would start to make some traction. The judge would see that and the judge would insinuate himself into the proceeding in such a way that he was telegraphing to the jury that he was making the credibility findings that the jury as the finders of fact should have been making. That is repulsive to me in terms of a judicial role.
Except in this case the jury spent more than eight hours. They acquitted Russell Brand on two of the three rape charges. So it's not as if they were simps for the judge. I mean they went through the evidence and they were able to separate what they believed was, you know, guilt from acquittal.
Except understand if you're a juror, if you have a complete collapse of the evidence. I mean, one of the things that just is mind-boggling to me is that there was one woman who was, and I don't want to get too graphic here for the kids at home, but there was one woman who was talking about mouth to anus contact. And then was talking about being anally penetrated. And then there was another where there was a grabbing of kind of a touching over the clothes, yet he was acquitted of the oral penetration. None of these things hang together unless you saw that there were jurors who were basically trying to find something, almost a stretch in trying to find guilt where it appears just at least from the cold hard record that this was consensual.
Well, then they would have found him, if that's their approach, they would have found him guilty on all three counts of rape and they didn't.
You would think so, but how do you split it up? How do you say that, oh, it was okay, that oral copulation was okay, that was consensual, but the touching was not?
Well, let's get into the way the trial worked and with his argument that the media made it impossible for him to get a fair trial. I think this is actually really interesting because what you're saying is none of it made sense. Listen to this part of this police interview Russell Brand had where they lay out some pretty graphic things and his response is less than compelling.
The condom he had been wearing had been removed at some point before the anal rape and was now on the floor. Mr. Brand then told her to clean up the mess on the bed and he left the room. The male who had answered the door to her then entered the room and told her she had to leave as Mr. Brand had to perform in another show that evening. She then left and was dropped off to Hammersmith Tube by the same driver. What is your response to this allegation?
I have nothing further to add at this time.
Okay. I mean that is laying out some pretty graphic details. So, you know, I think you got to cut these jurors a break in that it was a split verdict. But what about his point that look, there was so much media attention in this case that it was impossible for him to win the day because of the documentaries, because the police interview was broadcast, and that he was a big celebrity and people knew about this going into the courtroom.
Well, I could argue both sides of that because I've argued for years that if you are a celebrity or somebody who's famous as opposed to infamous, if you are famous, you do get your presumption of innocence. If you're infamous, you tend to get a presumption of guilt. It's very rare that somebody who is thought of, you know, the worst human in the world gets a presumption of innocence going into a trial, whereas somebody who is famous or beloved in quarters does get a presumption of innocence. And it obviously depends on who your jurors are. But if it's true that the judge is in the middle of cross and is saying on the record that he finds a witness to be credible that you are cross-examining, that's a tipping of the scales. That's something, how do you get over that? And that tends to explain, depending on when the judge insinuates himself into the cross-examination, can explain the split. That's troubling.
Well, you know, the prime minister actually kind of weighed in on this. Prime Minister Keir Starmer said, and this is a quote, 'It's not always the case that people know everything about people in public life.' I mean, it's not hard to decode that, that what they're saying is that there was another side to somebody like Russell Brand who was considered funny and harmless and whatever. And for this to go all the way up to the prime minister, it actually reminds me way back in the day when Richard Nixon in the middle of the Manson trial said, 'I think they're guilty.' And it became front page news and the jury saw the headline and the whole thing. But the fact that this got to the level where the prime minister was commenting, I think is actually really interesting.
It is interesting, but it also brings up, you know, when I've often heard judges who talk about or characterize the accused or defendants, usually in sentencing, and invoke kind of this jackal and hyena, this, you know, well, on the face of it, they appear to be a jackal but really hyena or vice versa. What that does though, that speaking of code, that's really code for by all accounts these people have lived a life that doesn't jive with what we are doing here now. That can be the case, clearly somebody like Ted Bundy, I can think of, I can give you all kinds of examples where there is a disconnect. However, the disconnect should not, in my opinion, and under the law, should not supply a lack of evidence. And you then go to what kind of outcry was there by the accusers in real time? Were there police reports in real time? Were there what are called fresh complaints to somebody that's a close friend or a family member?
Yeah, but you could argue you've got young women who are up against this huge celebrity. And you know, I understand your point that the faster you go to the police, the harder it is to get out from under the credibility issue, but it is certainly possible for somebody that young dealing with somebody that famous that they wouldn't necessarily do that.