I have a theory. I think when they kidnap Nancy Guthrie, it was all about money, and then she dies and they freak out because they've committed murder. You kidnap somebody and they die as a result of the anguish and the fright. It's felony murder.
Mark, we have received two emails today, Friday, when we're doing this, from a man who claims he knows where Nancy Guthrie's kidnappers are, who they are, and will lead authorities to them for the price of one Bitcoin. And I am going to lay out everything we know, the communications with the FBI, and I want to hear from you and everybody watching and listening. Is this guy a fraudster or the real deal? So let me tell you what we got today, early, early this morning. So this guy, he starts out by saying, "I am not the idiot who recently called in a tip about her burial site in Mexico." Now, there were reports recently that somebody had said that they knew where she was in Mexico. He's saying, "I'm not that guy." Although he did tell us earlier, when she was supposedly still alive, that they had taken her to Mexico. But here's where it gets...
Wait, so people understand, is this somebody who had previously sent a note which you turned over to the FBI?
We've turned all the notes over to the FBI.
And is this one that the FBI gave some credence to? Not this particular one, but an earlier one.
Well, he's referring to somebody who made a statement that her body was buried in Mexico. I have no idea whether the FBI took it seriously. He's saying it's not me. But this is what's interesting. He says only two are directly involved, and I doubt they would be the ones to call in and snitch on themselves. So I think that's really interesting because he has told us before, if you believe him, that there are multiple kidnappers but a main guy. This is the first time he's given us a number where he says two. So he says there are two kidnappers, and he's basically saying it wasn't me that made that other comment that circulated recently about Mexico, and it certainly wasn't them because why would they snitch on themselves. So that's kind of interesting.
Is this when did this guy or this person first email or send you a note?
Days after we received the first ransom note. Days.
Okay. So this is somebody who's been sending to you all along.
And at the beginning, almost every day, we've received at least a dozen of these from the same guy.
And I'm going to, you and I have talked about this before, you can do a pretty good triage on whether somebody is 5150 just on the basis of the notes they send.
He's not 5150. He's either legit or a sophisticated fraudster. He's one of the two. He's either legit or really sharp and knows how to defraud people. But there is nothing in these notes that make him seem off-kilter in terms of his...
Well, and you've got more experience than most, in fact, 98% of the population, at being able to detect who's off-kilter, to use your term.
So then this is where it gets really interesting. He says, "I have a phone stashed in a secure location, guaranteeing both the information it stores and the safety of the phone." What it contains is my definition of delivering this on a silver platter: a short video of the main guy with Nancy the day that was probably her last. And then he says, in addition to that, the phone has the names and addresses of the kidnappers. So he is saying he has a video of Nancy because he had said earlier that he had seen Nancy with the kidnappers there, that if you believe him, he has some close connection to the kidnappers. That's what he says. But he says he is not involved in the kidnapping and has repeated that over and over and over.
So without being cynical, the fact that he only wants one Bitcoin seems odd to me. Number one. Number two, since this has started, Bitcoin has not exactly skyrocketed in value.
It's about 60,000 bucks now. A little less.
Yeah. And so has he changed the amount he's asked for over time?
Well, in a way, yes, because initially he had asked for what amounted to 100,000 in Bitcoin, and now he's asking for one, which is, like I said, just under $60,000. I agree with you. I mean, it's like if this guy is really... now, he says the reason he wants the money is because he has to go underground. And he gets more detailed here, but he's saying that he is basically on the run because these kidnappers appear to know that he has all this information and he's scared of them and he has to go underground. And he goes on in this letter, in this email, to say that he can see if the money is put into the Bitcoin address that he gives, but he will not access it until after the kidnappers are caught because he doesn't want to access it and then have it traced to him if the kidnappers are still on the loose. So he's...
And I would assume that you, as a subsidiary of Fox, cannot pay for this information.
I'll tell you, I called the FBI about a month ago.
And I said, look, I said, I may be really naive here, and I don't know, but I keep asking you guys, you know, is this guy a kook? Is he a fraudster? And you tell me you don't know, but you also say you're really trying to track him down. And you know, it's like you're not dismissing it. And I just got this feeling it might be true. So what if we do a documentary and we actually pay the Bitcoin into the account to trigger this and follow where it leads us, and obviously we'll work with you. So this was about a month ago, and the first reaction I got was, "Well, that's kind of interesting. Let us run it up the flagpole." And I called him back a couple days later, and they said, "We're still talking about it." And then I kind of got ghosted for almost a month, and I called back a half dozen times, and they never returned my call, and I just figured, okay...
Well, when you say they didn't answer the call, the FBI. So have you responded? Is this an interactive relationship, or are you not able to respond to what he said?
I can't respond. But we respond in a different sort of way, and I'll tell you in a minute. But let me just say...
A couple of days ago, the FBI did call me, and they said, well, look, you know, they knew about what I had requested, and they said, look, we feel we're closer to finding this person. And they said this person might actually be a woman. And that's all they said. They didn't say why they thought that, but...
I was going to... That's interesting they said that because I was going to ask you if there was any indication that this was a female.
That doesn't mean anything.
No, I know. I know. But then they said on the documentary thing to stand down, that they were working on it. And I said fine. And so because there were these stories that had come out this week that, you know, the second ransom note said that Nancy had died, it seems like that's what triggered this guy into...
We understand this person did not tell you that Nancy is dead.
Well, and he is essentially... he told us that there...
I'm going to call him he just because that's what we've...
He told us this early on. At one point he said essentially time is of the essence, and then in a follow-up email said time is no longer of the essence, and...
How early or how long after a week...
Disappears a week. Okay. And so...
So yeah, I mean, he has essentially told us over time that she was dead.
And again, we've been sending all of these to the FBI, and they have spent a lot of time with my IT team. A lot of time and multiple FBI agents who have been trying to crack the code of both this guy's email and the first kidnapping note. They've spent a lot of time with our team. As far as I know, they were not able to crack it. I know that until a month ago, they certainly were not able to crack it. I don't know what they've done with this guy.
Is this guy the one that you know... remember when Savannah did that really tugs at your heartstrings, emotionally laden...
"Please bring us back." And there was two interpretations. One was she wanted the remains. The other, you know, are people who wanted to be positive or think positively were interpreting it differently. Is this guy the one that you believe was saying that she's already gone?
No. The reason that Savannah... that's a really important point. There was a... The first ransom note said she was safe but scared. We received that, as did two Tucson television stations. The second note was only sent to one of the Tucson television stations. And what came out this week is in that second note, which was sent five or six days after the kidnapping, it said she was dead. And they were basically saying, you know, we didn't do it, she died. And it was that second ransom note from the kidnappers. We know both notes were written by the same people because it was the same... it had the same Bitcoin address for the ransom. So it was that second note that said she was dead. And yes, that weekend on, I believe it was Saturday night, is when Savannah came out with that really heart-wrenching statement where she said, "Bring us back, bring us to our mother so we can bring her home and celebrate." That felt to me back then like they knew she had died. When you say bring her back so we can celebrate...
The Bitcoin address given by notes one and number two, number two only going to one station, is a different Bitcoin address than the Bitcoin address in this note that we're talking about today.
Yeah. And the reason we know that this note today is written by the same person is that the last one we received before this one, the last one we received said, "I'm not going to get in touch with you anymore. I'm going to deactivate the Bitcoin account." And we never published the Bitcoin address. So in this note, he says, "I have a new Bitcoin address that you can send this money to." And then he references the old one just to show it's the same guy. And we never published that Bitcoin address, and it is the exact same one.
Have you published any of these notes?
We haven't published the notes in full. We've quoted from them.
Have you even shown anything of it?
No, we've never shown any of the notes, but we've...
Well, shouldn't we show a little bit of this?
Well, I mean, I've read a lot of this to you, and you know, when he says... he says, "Look, if you send me the Bitcoin, I will let you know where this phone is, and it's in a safe location that's easily accessible if you are guided to it." To me, that feels like a safe deposit box. And he says that the phone is turned off, but I will lead you to that safe deposit box and give you the password so you can access the phone. So that's what he says. Now...
So if this guy or woman is not a fraudster, what I... and I think I said this to you once before, and I would hopefully they're listening or hear it, why don't they just go to a lawyer and have the lawyer work on a contingency to broker the information, which then keeps the anonymity of the client and allows the information to get wherever. You don't even have to rely on a Bitcoin. The lawyer can keep the money in a trust account pending the confirmation of the information or the phone or whatever else it is. I don't know why they make it so cloak and dagger when there seems to be a rather simple way to navigate this.
That's actually a really interesting idea. And he certainly hasn't raised it. And one of the reasons he might not want to do that is if he's a fraudster...
Right? And so that's what tends to lead me to believe that the person is a fraudster, because otherwise go to a lawyer who's got attorney-client privilege with you, who has a trust account that you can receive whatever funds and not have to disclose, meaning not have to disclose to the general public, so to speak, and then let the lawyer broker this deal so that you can then take that information and if you have some interest in getting this solved, that's the way to solve it.
Okay? I will double down with you on that and say there is more evidence he's a fraudster. And then after I tell you what that evidence is, then I'll tell you why he might not be a fraudster. So...
Oh my goodness. Okay. I'm going to get my fraudster whiplash.
You are going to get fraudster whiplash. Let's first go towards doubling down on fraud.
So you had asked me earlier, is this one-way communication or are we able to communicate with him? We cannot send him emails or anything like that. That is a one-way street that we don't have any ability to do that. Never have. However, we have a website and we have television shows and we have social media, and on all of those we have said things really directly to him. And I said something to him early today after getting this email, and I said, look, you could be an absolute scammer, and there's a reason the FBI and the Guthrie family hasn't paid you. So it's got to give them pause whether you're the real deal or not. So what about this? Send us... and this is the way we've communicated with him. I put this on social media and on the website today, and I said, "Send us a screen grab from the video of Nancy Guthrie, something, just a screen grab that shows you're the real deal, and we will immediately forward it to the FBI." And I would assume if they think it's real, they're going to pay the money. So a couple hours after we posted that, he sent another email saying, "I'm not going to do that because the metadata will lead them directly to me, and I'm not going to take that chance." So that made me think this guy's full of it.
Right? Because once again, you could show it to a lawyer confidentially. The lawyer can take a look. The lawyer does not have to access the metadata. But the lawyer can then do a reverse proffer to the FBI or the authorities. The lawyer could also, if you're worried about being apprehended or if you're worried about your liability, so to speak, then they can do... if it turns out to be true and you're not a fraudster, they can work out some kind of an arrangement for you.
That's right. Okay. So that's my doubling.
What leads you to the other? Where's the whiplash on the other end?
So I send these two emails today to the FBI, and they are saying, "We're on it. We're on it."
You know, it's like, "Stop sending us these stupid emails." And I'm not getting that. And so I'm just really confused. Why are they spending time on this guy if they don't believe that he might be legit? But on the other hand, if they think he even might be legit, why not roll the dice on 60 grand, which in the greater scheme of things, you know, it's not going to break the bank. But if they're spending this much time trying to figure out who he is, then roll the dice on this thing. Because the guy... there was a point, Mark, where I don't know, a month in, I did a social media post again, the only way we could contact this guy, and I just said, "Look, the FBI literally asked me to do this social post and say to you that if this is a scam, they will find you, they will charge you, they will prosecute you, and they will send you to prison." And they had actually asked me to say that, and I did. And he sent me an email back saying, "I am well aware that anybody who pulls a scam like this can be prosecuted and sent to prison. I am not doing that." So look, I don't know, but I mean, if zero to 100 is he's telling the truth and zero is no credibility, where are you on the spectrum?
Well, right now, until you give me some other piece of information that I didn't have eight minutes ago, I'm giving it about a 65, a 65 out of 100.
Is that worth rolling the dice?
Yeah, I think that is worth rolling the dice.
So you would roll the dice?
If I'm you and I've got a website like you've got, I would roll the dice.