CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Harvey Levin gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Harvey Levin
Founder & Managing Editor, TMZ

TMZ Live - Streaming Live From The Newsroom! - 9/11/2026

📅 Sep 11, 2026 TMZ 103 MIN 23084 VIEWS 748 SEGMENTS · 4 SPEAKERS
Harvey Levin and TMZ staffers run through the top stories of the day.

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:30Oh, it's Rashana tomorrow or tonight?
  2. 19:40Okay, do we have a 50-second sound bite? Huh?
  3. 36:27Are you listening to you in here?
  4. 49:39In particular, say if if you're Evan and you see companies racing ahead with AI, like in the past, maybe you see OpenAI doing it, what are you actually going to do?
  5. 1:04:05Do you do 10 sets of anything?
  6. 1:09:18Well, I have to sit with that for just a second. What does that mean?
  7. 1:19:25I think you're making an inflation point, right?
  8. 1:23:39Do you want floor on this?
  9. 1:30:47When did they know when did when when would it have been public?
  10. 1:35:55Alex Fine. Uh, you want a minute?
  11. 1:38:33Are you going to be here for your birthday?
  12. 1:40:23Does Hobbs wake you up when he makes you breakfast in bed?
Harvey Levin 0:00 ↗
New Yorkers, thank you to all of our first responders for your service. We're remembering all those people who lost their lives today. Horrible tragedy. Makes me sick to think about. But we also have to remember how beautiful it is that we can come together as a country in times of awfulness and persevere. So yeah.
Talia 0:30 ↗
Oh, Nancy, Nate, and Diamond Gem Girl are having a wedding and Nancy is the bridesmaid. That's sweet. Brandon said, "Come on, Talia. We're waiting on you. I'm here now." It's total Friday vibes. What? Oh, it's Rashana tomorrow or tonight? I guess tonight going to temple Shinatova. All my people out there. Good morning, Ty. Hope you have a wonderful weekend. Thank you, Larry. I hope the same. Barbara, good morning. Rockilly. Thanks. Thanks, Byron. Only Melissa can cheer us up with her sick ass awesomeness. It's a real real quote I just read. Clara, good morning. Sky Guy, good morning from Portland, Oregon. Antonio said, "I'm dressed up for Russia Shana." Close enough. Hey, Casara. Howdy, Joker's Wild.
Harvey Levin 1:30 ↗
Yep. NM Rock Chick, you got it. A lot of people from my town, people I know were first responders during the attacks. And yeah, I know we have a documentary that's up on YouTube, TMZ Investigates, about like a fifth plane. I actually watched that yesterday. It was crazy town. But yeah, sad day morning.
Talia 2:03 ↗
Yeah. Tell you tell [sighs] Charles's birthday is tomorrow. Happy early birthday to Charles. Happy early birthday to Charles. Happy early birthday to 60y old Charles. Happy 60th birthday. One day early to you.
Charles 2:37 ↗
>> Happy early 60th. Big C. I did two years at the year camp. Where is Charles? Happy birthday, Charles.
Talia 2:45 ↗
Charles, >> Charles, >> what are you doing for your birthday? Are you going to go to Sugarfish? >> Do you have any dinner plans? If not, we could do something. I won't pay, but I just want to go out to eat. Okay.
>> Robert Robert Bruno, please stop singing. Can't stop. Won't stop. >> Thank you, Jaria. It's I haven't warmed up my voice yet. That's why I'm a little rusty. Yes, the song's so beautiful. It's kind of a classic, the happy birthday song. Back at it like a crack addict. That's what Dem said. Well, good morning to you, Chuck. Nasty. Is that a new shirt? Yeah, he got it on vacation this weekend. Charles Mc Yummy, please. We love you.
>> Charles Mc Yummy. Happy 57th birthday, Charles. I can't wait to get old and have one of my young co-workers sing to me. It's probably so fun. I don't know why nobody's excited about that. Hey, Talia from Hollywood. Holly. Weird books. East Hollywood Library. I love it over there. I love books. What is in the water at TMZ to make everyone stop aging? I think it's called Botox. I don't. Charles, you don't have any work done, though. I'm assuming cuz why would you pay to look like that? I'm just kidding. That was really mean. Okay. Hi from Milwaukee. Today is my birthday. 45. Happy birthday, Tone Scott and Joe Perry. Jaria, when's your birthday? >> October 20th. >> Oh, it's coming up. All right. I'll have to warm up. We'll be singing again for Jaria's birthday. [sighs] Nancy. I said Botox. No, he doesn't. Oh, and happy birthday, Ludicrous and Jessica Shepard. Aloha from Maui. It's my dream. I wish I was in there right now. Charles's pimp name is Sir Charles Chuckles. Oh god, I love it here. Rockilly JL, your birthday's next month.
Oh, nice. Jamie P. Johnson, I missed something. How old is Charles tomorrow? He was 57, but I like to say 60 because it's funnier. Talia, was that a fake face? Oh, Talia, that was a fake face that Clay Matthews was wearing. Yes. A thanks, Brandon. Yesterday was Alana Smith's birthday, too. TVBVM said she'd be seated. Yeah, >> I'm not putting it. It takes a lot for me to sing and dance and entertain. Got to be sitting down, too. >> Talia, could Diamond and I get a shout out. We are getting chat married. Congratulations, Diamond Gem Girl and Nate. I will officiate the wedding. >> I didn't think it was anything. I just saw you put eyes on. >> When people ask how old I am, I tell them I'm two days older than dirt. Oh my god. So, you're the same age as Charles. God. Tuning in from Newport, Minnesota, home of the Newport cigarette. It's great. Just guessing that. Just guessing. Newport mental Newport. Oh, Talia's so unaware. Dot dot dot. You do not want to be in Maui right now. They just had a hurricane. Okay. How old are you, Talia? I am 23. July 19th, 2003. >> 03. >> Oh, yeah. You have a late birthday. >> Below above. >> The cuto off in New York is December. >> So, like my friend's Yeah. >> So, you were the oldest one in your grade? >> I'm the oldest >> and I was the youngest in my Yeah. It's so weird how that works. Mary Kemp, thank you. Did Charles go to Woodstock 99? No. Hello from New Orleans. I love New Orleans so much. I've only been three times. Wait, three times. Freshman sophomore. Yeah, I've only been three times, but for frat formals, so I don't know if you get the full experience. I like how weird it is over there though and really gloomy. I love that vibe. [snorts] Atlanta feliz Friday. Heck yes to all Virgos there. My birthday September 13th from Hawaii. Nice. Diamond. Talia just said she would officiate your our wedding. You know I did. Oh, thanks Alana. What? Mon'nique, I cannot read that out loud on chat. JL said, "I wish I was alive for Woodstock 99. Corn, Rage Against the Machine, Limp Biscuit, Ice Cube." Yeah, but everyone was like in poop. >> They all got good music taste. >> Yeah, they got good music taste, but there was a lot of poop going on at Woodstock 99. Too much from it. And it takes a lot for me to think that. Joker's Wild said, "By the time I turned 23, I was a war veteran. By the time I turned 23, I was making Tik Toks. All right. >> I love when people walk through. Gives me character to interact with. Who's next? Love from Australia. Brisbane Rothell. I've been watching a lot of um what's his name? Chris Brown Bondi Vet. Morning Circus. >> Do you ever watch Chris Brown Bondi Vet? Anybody? He is this handsome Australian vet. His show was in like 2010 and I watch it on Amazon Prime. No free ads though. Talia is 23, still sleeps in a baby incubator. I believe the word you're looking for there is bassinet. I believe an incubator would be a womb, but again, I'm not really a scientist. Jenna Ortega's birthday September 27th. Heck yeah. A lot of creative people born in September. True. >> That is true. Shinachova big mouth. Yeah. Come right through. Join. Hey. Bondi vet is the blonde Henry Caval. Honestly fair. Yeah. Um at 23 for me. Tik Tok wasn't born and neither was Facebook. That's all right. There's something different for everyone. Robert Bruno, I love how everyone in the office ignores Talia. Not true. Thank you. Moving on. Cat in a hat going viral. Why isn't it talked enough about? Yeah, there's like people dressed in a Cat in a Hat costume terrorizing folks. Is that the story there? The Cat in the Hat be going around stabbing people, I think. Let me check that because I said that and I didn't mean it. Cat in the hat trend. I think Natalie Reynolds started it right. Oh. Video show the character lurking near schools have evolved into veiled school threats prompting law enforcement warnings. Basically, the Cat in the Hat trend is the 2017 clown trend all over again. Um, yeah. Yeah. Do you guys remember that the 2017 clown trap where there's like clowns going around? Anybody? Anybody remember the clown trend? No. Okay. Yeah, Luca is also an 03 baby. Talia forgot to bring her Starbucks or Red Bull. I had my Starbucks this morning and I'm having an Alani new. It's just Friday. >> Yes, Nancy. Nancy, shout out for your 31st wedding anniversary. 91395. That's beautiful. That's great. Thanks, Carol. That's so sweet. Ally said, "Speaking of Crazy Town, have you seen the woman who wasn't there on Prime?" I have not. What is that about? >> Oh my god. Brand Babcock, are you there? >> Somebody in the chat said Babcock would have been a freshman in college during 911 because I am one year younger than him. Is that true? >> I know Satan Hall. miles from the World Trade Center and I I just had moved in like September 4th >> and then obviously two weeks later. >> Damn. >> Was it crazy on campus? >> It was. And I when I was a senior in college in high school, I worked after high school in a in like a bank and I worked with a guy who took a second job cuz he was going like through a divorce. >> And I was the youngest person there. Nobody talked to me except this guy. And we talked about sports for hours and hours each day. and and I left a job to go to school and his first job, his day job was at the World Trade Center and he died. Uh >> Holy [ __ ] >> Yeah. >> Jeff Robinson. So >> yeah. >> Yeah. Vividly remember that. >> Wow. >> Crazy that if you're 25, you weren't even born. >> Yeah. I'm 23. I wasn't born. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Sorry. I was a downer. I'm sorry. >> No, that we were talking about it. >> Big weekend. >> I remember Jeff today. Remember Jeff. >> Sorry. >> It's so sad. And I think about all the Yeah, they did. I think about all the stories of people too who are like, I was supposed to go into work that day. I think about all the people who are like, I was supposed to go into work that day or my dad got sick, so I stayed home to help him. And it's like crazy. >> Brandon, you were right. What? Tupac anniversary is on the 13th. >> Crazy. >> Tom's up. >> Morning. >> Okay. >> Hi, Spliffany. My brother is at IU right now. It's crazy. >> Morning. >> Happy Friday. >> Happy Friday.
Harvey Levin 14:18 ↗
>> Day after we were all called by FBI telling us that they needed to interview us regarding the incidents [music] of what had happened on the airplane, the FBI wanted to take us to show us a lineup of people at the uh Port Authority. gates were locked and guarded with armored military that had machine guns or whatever rifles they were [music] using. We were escorted into one room where there were those double um windows that you could see in but not out and asked us if we could identify any of the people that were behind the window. I could not ident
Talia 15:15 ↗
It's going to be one of those days, huh? Crap. There is a bottle of Lexapro in my purse. Does somebody want to bring that over onto the stream? I'm just kidding. It is going to be one of those days though. >> And he's got Yeah, that's what Yeah, it's a good stuff. It's good stuff. >> I took two. So, I'm like, you know what? I could use a little help. >> Yep. Let's get crazy. The Pentagon. Wow. Real mixed in the chat this morning. We have >> let's talk Pentagon. I'm craving chicken fingers. Good morning, Harve. >> Lot going on. Lot going on. I wonder what Harvey will want for lunch today. I know Jaria was like, get him to pick cuz he has a meeting and he's going to get nasty. I have my Tylenol too from a headache because clearly that's going to start developing pretty soon. Uh yeah. Morning. >> Um, >> good morning, Harvey. Do you want to pick your lunch since you have an early meeting today? >> Yeah, let's do it uh fast. Let's do turkey chili or chicken Caesar. >> Yum. Turkey chili or chicken Caesar. >> It's good. It's like 98 degrees out. It's not great chili weather, but it's cold in here. Yeah, it's cold. Okay, I'm not going to judge you. Nice t-shirt, too. >> Oh, thanks. It's really old. Yeah. >> Like >> it has that vibe. >> 15, 20 years old. >> Wow. >> Um, >> are you going to say something?
Harvey Levin 17:07 ↗
>> It's weird. I was thinking of 911 today. >> Well, it's 911. >> I was I was actually I flew on 911. >> What? >> 2001. >> I landed in New York at 1 in the morning. I was on a redeye flight with Tom Berseron and um he happened to be in the flight and landed at 1:00 in the morning. Um, and I remember it's it was a really it was wild. Um, cuz I was right I was staying right next to Lincoln Center and when it became apparent what was going on, I thought I should probably leave the hotel >> because I thought Lincoln Center would be a target. >> Yeah. >> And I thought, okay, what about going to the office? And our office was right across the street from the Empire State Building. So we're talking back and forth saying none of us should be in any office right now. >> And so people were wandering and I remember like on Fifth Avenue there were this roar of jets and nobody knew whether there were planes that were heading for there but it was um there were fighter planes that were responding to what was going on. >> Holy crap. And then I remember I walked over to Herald Square and saw the second the South Tower go down and it was just the we it just to see that happen >> was just like cuz there were is there a crowd just watching you know the smoke and everything and all of a sudden it's like you could not believe that was actually happening. >> Wow. >> It was so like >> I had no idea you were there. Oh, it was like to see that happen and you just think that just could not have just happened. Couldn't and everybody was just paralyzed watching this thing. >> Yeah. >> Crazy. >> Really scary. >> She was in a yogurt shop and then the towers goes down and she's like trying to go outside and the the people in the yogurt shop are begging her, please do not open this door. The towers just went down. There's going to be a right >> the debris is going to come down the street. Just watch. And not even 30 seconds later, it was like not even gray, like the color of Harvey's shirt, black >> just coming down. And she was like, "Oh my god, you saved my life." Tom's up and we have Jacob in 10 minutes. >> Oh, okay. >> So sad and scary. >> [ __ ] >> Uh, we've got Jacob in 10 minutes and Tom's up. >> Hey Tom, how you doing? >> I'm good. How are you? >> I'm good. I thought I've been thinking about you all week.
Tom Manel 19:40 ↗
Well, I actually try not to think about 911, but I I heard you speaking before about the the fighter planes you heard overhead. >> Yeah. >> And um I had an interesting uh little side note to uh those fighter planes. Uh one of them was flown by a United pilot that um was a 767 Copilot. I flew it about 3 or 4 months later and he said he was 90 seconds late uh to get to the city. But it also dawned on me had I taken off and then I'd been the next threat, this would have been the guy that shot me down. >> He was 90 seconds late getting to >> York and he was going to intercept the Wow. >> God, Tom, that's crazy. That is that's a crazy Oh my god. That is just un Okay. Um we got to start. So here we go. >> Um what are we making this be? >> No. This what's A? No. No. Um let's let's let's go over here and do this. We may make this A. Okay. Okay, do we have a 50-second sound bite? Huh?
Harvey Levin 21:07 ↗
>> Welcome to TMZ Live and the 25th anniversary of one of the most tragic things ever to happen in the United States, 9/11. Um there is a lot to be said about this but we want to tell you about something that the government is hiding and it has to do with the fact and I say the fact that there was a fifth a fifth plane targeted uh on that day. Yeah. At least a fifth and who knows how many others but we've spoken to the crew of United Flight 23 which was supposed to take off from JFK the morning of 911. Um, and they did not. And we know in speaking to them that the FBI spoke to them about a lot of weird things that happened right after they got back to after they were pulled back from taking off. >> Well, not just weird things that happened after, but during uh when when they were preparing to leave the gate and when they taxied, there were seven suspicious people on that plane and they all talked about it. Uh while the plane was taxiing, even before um there was somebody that was clearly hiding in the hatch, the belly of the plane and when they evacuated and locked the doors, people in the ground saw people running inside the plane presumably coming up from that hatch and then they disappeared probably out of the belly of the plane. So, this is not just flight attendants. It is the pilot. It is the dispatcher for United Flight 23. Here's what the flight attendants say happened hours after the cataclysmic events that day when the FBI wanted to download them. >> The day after we were all called by FBI telling us that they needed to interview us regarding the incidents of what had happened on the airplane. The FBI wanted to take us to show us a lineup of people at the uh Port Authority. Gates were locked and guarded with armored military that had machine guns or whatever rifles they were using. We were escorted into one room where there were those double um windows that you could see in but not out and asked us if we could identify any of the people that were behind the window. I could not identify any one. >> Nobody is forthcoming with what I think is a simple statement. No, these these were innocent people on the flight. Forget about it. I don't I don't know why that information can't be released. uh if they were involved then I could understand why that information isn't being released. >> Well, that was Tom Manel, the pilot of United Flight 23, >> right? Uh and he is joining us now to talk about u the mystery that what seems to be a mystery because we've tried for a long time the government is not saying anything about what Tom and his crew went through. So Tom, welcome back to TMZ Live. >> Thanks for having me. I'm wondering how you reflect on 25 years ago um given what you experienced.
Tom Manel 24:27 ↗
One of the things I tried to do was actually downplay it in my own mind, not to think about it, because I went to work for another, you know, seven, eight years after that, and I didn't want to be thinking about it when I was trying to do my job. But that said, the longer it goes on, the harder it is to deal with the fact that somebody was trying to hurt myself and my entire airplane. And I also met — one of the things that was very difficult was I met the wife of one of the United pilots, Vick Serini, that had one of the airplanes targeted. And I can almost envision my wife in her position, and it was just a tragic event. And it is frustrating, as you said, that nobody is speaking the truth about it from the government.
Harvey Levin 25:28 ↗
A number of authors that have written either short stories or even books about 9/11 have said the government and the FBI claim that it's still an open investigation and they won't and cannot release information. So, how do you deal with that?
Yeah. Yeah. The open investigation is sort of like the shield that they can always say. Although they didn't even give us that response when we filed the Freedom of Information Act, right? We got no response. Tom, I'm wondering that the day after, so on the 12th, you're sitting down with the FBI agents. Everybody's emotions were so raw that day, still trying to deal with what we had all witnessed on 9/11. And I just can't imagine that you weren't pretty heated in their conversation with the FBI, because I would think that you and all of your crew members were extremely suspicious, especially on that day as you thought about everything that had happened on the 11th, and that it appears you just narrowly escaped that same fate. What was it like talking to the FBI that day?
Tom Manel 26:43 ↗
It was difficult. But my thought was to try to present whatever information, anything that they could use to help in the investigation. I pointed out on an airport map exactly where I was parked after we were stopped and nobody was allowed to take off. And I allowed people to make phone calls so that if they could track any phone calls from the airplane, they knew where I was, and if somebody was trying to call Saudi Arabia, let's say, that they could pin any information like that. It was just, what can I do to help? was the thought that went through my mind.
Yeah, there really wasn't a lot to do. I was a little disappointed in myself that I didn't call earlier to have these people stopped, but again, I had no information whether these people were involved or not. So, if they were innocent people, it would have been difficult.
Harvey Levin 27:57 ↗
Tom, you were featured in our documentary 9/11: The Fifth Plane, which is now on YouTube. And I know you've seen it. Yes. You flew for seven or eight more years with United after 9/11, and you had a clear point of view that you were a target that day. Did you ever interact with people at United during those seven or eight years? Talk to them about it? Did they give you anything? I'm assuming you were curious enough that you must have talked about it at some point.
Tom Manel 28:35 ↗
I did talk to various people, but I realized they were faced with the same situation I was. If they were going to get — they needed to get information from the government, and the government wasn't speaking. So it was — I realized, as I said, that I wasn't going to get anything more. As a matter of fact, the only information I got was just the same thing the general public from a couple news stations reported about my flight. And what was mysterious was a lot of the information was incorrect. One of the news networks said I had a mechanical problem and I went back to the gate. It's not true. So information got a little mixed up, and but as I —
Harvey Levin 29:27 ↗
Yeah. But look, you knew that somebody or people were in that airplane after it was locked. You knew the hatch had been opened. So those things alone, aside from the suspicious people in the plane, did United ever give you an explanation?
Tom Manel 29:44 ↗
No. No. None whatsoever. The only information I was given, I think the next day or the day after, was that they had found box cutters on one of our 767s, but it was not my airplane.
Harvey Levin 29:59 ↗
It was the one next to yours.
Tom Manel 30:00 ↗
Right.
Harvey Levin 30:01 ↗
Exactly. So that might have been an attempt to just get the whole situation even more confusing by the people that did it. I don't know. Tom, when you watch the documentary, and even just if you haven't seen the documentary yet, and just in the conversation that we've been having and what you've revealed to everyone, I feel like it is a reasonable conclusion that a lot of people will come to that government isn't saying anything because they know that there were people involved or countries involved, and they don't want that information to go out to the public either for national security or just not to cause a panic. But I think those are reasonable conclusions that people would reach. What conclusion do you reach?
Tom Manel 30:56 ↗
Exactly what you just said. It's — I feel helpless. I can't do anything about it. It is frustrating, but I try — as I said, I tried to put the event out of my mind, especially when I was working.
Harvey Levin 31:17 ↗
Yeah.
Tom Manel 31:17 ↗
Um.
Harvey Levin 31:18 ↗
So put out of your mind on a day like today, though.
Tom Manel 31:21 ↗
You were on my mind today. I was thinking about you and so appreciate you coming on, Tom. Thank you.
Harvey Levin 31:28 ↗
You're welcome.
All right, Tom. Take care. And again, the documentary — you should watch it if you will walk away knowing there was a fifth plane. It's on YouTube. It's called TMZ Investigates 9/11: The Fifth Plane.
Yeah.
Yeah. And do you believe it?
Tom Manel 31:52 ↗
I do.
Harvey Levin 31:53 ↗
I think it was overwhelmingly evident.
I think Tom says it perfectly, which is: if they weren't involved, then just come out and say that.
Charles 32:05 ↗
I think that's a great point.
Harvey Levin 32:06 ↗
If there was an absolutely — there was a perfectly good reason for people to be on that plane.
Charles 32:14 ↗
I agree.
Harvey Levin 32:15 ↗
And they sussed it all out and there was a guy — it's all good. Then you come out and say that and you put everyone's mind at ease.
Charles 32:24 ↗
Yeah.
Harvey Levin 32:27 ↗
But if you don't say it, well, that means either — either you're guilty.
Charles 32:33 ↗
Yeah. I don't know.
Harvey Levin 32:34 ↗
Yeah.
Charles 32:35 ↗
Somebody should call Amy.
Harvey Levin 32:37 ↗
Um, okay.
Charles 32:40 ↗
Crazy stuff.
Harvey Levin 32:42 ↗
Cameron, let's do — you could come through.
Charles 32:50 ↗
Yeah.
Harvey Levin 32:53 ↗
Um.
It is true. If there is important information, the government should tell us.
Charles 33:06 ↗
Yeah.
Harvey Levin 33:10 ↗
Five minutes.
Charles 33:11 ↗
Bye, Melissa.
Harvey Levin 33:12 ↗
Five minutes.
Charles 33:13 ↗
So, we'll knock out Brian.
Harvey Levin 33:14 ↗
Okay. We'll see if we can knock C out or not.
Charles 33:17 ↗
Maybe we can knock C out. It should be a quick block.
Harvey Levin 33:20 ↗
People are curious. Why would the government want to stay tight-lipped if there was a fifth plane?
Charles 33:27 ↗
Because exactly what Charles said that — Hello.
Harvey Levin 33:34 ↗
What Charles said, which is to avoid panic because the people escaped, as far as we know, and also there may be a national security issue. There's a lot of smoke that there was a foreign country involved, at least one, in this, and it may align with that. But whatever happened, United has been utterly radio silent, and they could have easily called us. We contacted them repeatedly, and they could have said, look, guys, here's why what you're saying is wrong, and they never got back to us. We sent a Freedom of Information to the FBI, and the FBI didn't even respond to it. They didn't even say no. They just never responded. So —
Charles 34:22 ↗
Is that allowed?
Harvey Levin 34:24 ↗
Well, technically they should respond, but we knew we were never going to get anywhere with it because the courts would never open this up.
Charles 34:33 ↗
That's crazy.
Harvey Levin 34:35 ↗
They're never going to give it to us.
Charles 34:37 ↗
Wow. Have you seen them — Lindsay Clancy?
Harvey Levin 34:47 ↗
I think he's on the phone with my friend Derek.
Charles 34:51 ↗
I can't tell if he wants to listen to this or keep chatting with me.
Harvey Levin 34:53 ↗
Yeah, I don't know.
Charles 34:56 ↗
I can't tell what he wants to do.
Harvey Levin 34:58 ↗
There were four planes. Apparently, I don't remember the fifth.
Charles 35:00 ↗
Pokey, actually. It's pretty good. I'm sorry.
Harvey Levin 35:03 ↗
Spicy tuna.
Charles 35:04 ↗
I'm never going to eat raw fish at work.
Harvey Levin 35:07 ↗
It is warm. That is not — it's not supposed to be warm. It is a bit warm. I'm not sure if that's from the rice.
Charles 35:15 ↗
And you're okay with taking that risk?
Harvey Levin 35:18 ↗
No. [laughter]
Charles 35:20 ↗
I'm gonna have the — you're not guilty. I'm gonna have the vegan one.
Harvey Levin 35:24 ↗
I'm going to have the veggie bowl today.
Charles 35:25 ↗
This is the trial judge.
Harvey Levin 35:27 ↗
Yeah, that's a good one. But it's good.
Charles 35:31 ↗
Oh, smart, smart, smart.
Harvey Levin 35:33 ↗
When he does the next interview, I'll go grab my bowl.
Charles 35:36 ↗
There's a ponzu sauce. I'm really interested. But my point is — so good.
Harvey Levin 35:44 ↗
You don't put the sauce on.
Charles 35:45 ↗
I thought it was soy. I didn't think it was ponzu.
Harvey Levin 35:48 ↗
So, I don't know if I need a little — cuz there's already eel sauce in here.
Charles 35:52 ↗
That's okay.
Harvey Levin 35:58 ↗
So good. Right. It's like tangy and soft.
Charles 36:00 ↗
That makes me want a pot sticker.
Harvey Levin 36:02 ↗
Yes.
Charles 36:02 ↗
For guzza.
Harvey Levin 36:03 ↗
That's so the vibe. I'm so hungry.
Charles 36:05 ↗
That is delicious.
Harvey Levin 36:07 ↗
I know. No, I'm going to put it all over my bowl now.
Charles 36:09 ↗
Yes, they want to prevent a retrial.
Harvey Levin 36:13 ↗
They want an appeal so that the appellate court will attach jeopardy, and that would prevent prosecutors from — this is good for the — this is a real —
Talia 36:27 ↗
Harvey, did you see the new headline about the airport? Are you listening to you in here?
Harvey Levin 36:33 ↗
What?
Talia 36:34 ↗
The airport now allowing like family and friends to go. How do you feel about that?
Harvey Levin 36:39 ↗
I don't know. I mean, look, I mean, there are some people who say that a lot of these security measures are just window dressing and not real. I don't know.
Charles 36:47 ↗
Like 4 ounces of shampoo.
Harvey Levin 36:48 ↗
I'm not an expert in this area. I don't know.
Charles 36:52 ↗
It's through TSA, but — what is the — yeah, but TSA is so easy to get. It's not like —
Harvey Levin 37:00 ↗
It's easy to get. This is what? $75 for the year.
Charles 37:04 ↗
50 for five years.
Harvey Levin 37:05 ↗
$50 for five years. You go and take what? 30 minutes. Free with Amex.
Charles 37:10 ↗
Oh, I'm [laughter] can't relate. My boy —
Harvey Levin 37:13 ↗
I'm curious. I wish — I'm sure I could Google it quite easily, but I'd rather think about it. I wonder what the reasoning behind some of the TSA rules are, because I know a lot of them stem from 9/11, like the 3-1-1. Yeah, but like what's up with why can I only bring three ounces of liquid, and why can't I bring my lithium battery, and why can't I vape on the plane? Like just some stuff that doesn't make —
Charles 37:42 ↗
The lithium I get, but the shampoo — but yeah, well I can't — like can you find a case where —
Harvey Levin 37:51 ↗
So I could bring four — but I could bring 4 ounces of gasoline, but I can't bring 5 ounces of shampoo.
Charles 37:57 ↗
I don't know.
Harvey Levin 38:00 ↗
I'm curious to talk to whoever. Nobody saw a 5 sec.
Charles 38:03 ↗
God dang it. [laughter]
Harvey Levin 38:04 ↗
I wouldn't do it.
Charles 38:05 ↗
I'm not doing that in this.
Harvey Levin 38:06 ↗
You're eating the warm fish already. Just commit to the chopsticks.
Charles 38:10 ↗
Um.
Harvey Levin 38:10 ↗
I dropped my chopsticks. Where are we doing, Jacob?
Charles 38:14 ↗
Wherever you want to do it, essentially. You just did the Tom in your A block spot.
Harvey Levin 38:19 ↗
Um, is TSA open?
Charles 38:21 ↗
Cameras are set for there.
Harvey Levin 38:24 ↗
Why is TSA for oz of liquids?
Charles 38:30 ↗
Could be vodka.
Harvey Levin 38:33 ↗
Nothing wrong with a little vodka.
Charles 38:35 ↗
The rule was introduced in 2006 after authorities uncovered a terror plot to mix liquid chemical explosive disguised as soft drinks and detonate.
Harvey Levin 38:43 ↗
Wait, actually, Daria, can you put my mic down?
Charles 38:46 ↗
3.44 ounces is believed to be just under the critical mass needed to assemble an explosive device large enough to destroy an airplane.
Harvey Levin 38:58 ↗
I eat my words.
Charles 39:03 ↗
Yeah, it's a silly... I don't understand exactly.
Harvey Levin 39:15 ↗
Ask Harvey if he has weights at home or if he only works out in the gym. I think he only works out. Somebody want... he's got bigger fish to fry.
Charles 39:25 ↗
Shampoo can be explosive. I don't know. There's a lot going on.
Harvey Levin 39:32 ↗
Amy loves cats. Wish I was with you right now.
Charles 39:37 ↗
Pizza is explosive. Lithium batteries are a flammable explosive device. Yes.
Harvey Levin 39:48 ↗
I have to sneeze. I'm just warning everybody because my microphone's on.
Charles 39:54 ↗
Does it stop you from sneezing?
Harvey Levin 39:57 ↗
I sneezed and then I dabbed with my sneeze.
Charles 40:04 ↗
Oh, okay. Yeah. Get the... Hey, Siobhan. Happy Friday.
Harvey Levin 40:15 ↗
All right, take it away, boys. I'm gonna go get my bowl while I'm down, cuz he Scott also gets... there's so much, a lot of uh... Well, no, it's he he just the way he describes it, it's overly complex for what we're trying to do with the audience.
No, no. Yeah. Um, if he's not up, why don't we do C? Because we we could be waiting 10 minutes as far as we know.
Charles 41:31 ↗
Okay, let's start C. We we can always bail if he comes.
Harvey Levin 41:34 ↗
Okay.
Charles 41:42 ↗
And we should make this a short block.
Harvey Levin 41:47 ↗
Yeah.
Local and federal agents, uh, including the DEA, continue to investigate Hayden Panettiere's death, and we learned that they are on to something, that there is an individual they are looking at, um, a potential drug dealer who could have provided, uh, drugs that that Hayden ended up taking while she was in, uh, South Carolina the weekend she died. So, we also know that from the almost days after Hayden died, the DEA was on the case. So, they suspected that there might be perhaps illicit drugs involved, although it could be prescription, was the case with Matthew Perry. But the DEA is all over this case. And the interesting thing is that maybe the most important witness is the person who was with Hayden when she died. And that's her boyfriend, Brian Hickerson. Right. And we know that Brian Hickerson, uh, has spoken with, uh, the DEA. So, he is critical to this entire investigation and really has been from day one when he spoke to the first responders there about medications.
Charles 43:08 ↗
And and it's the way it's described in the police report. It sounds like they were prescription medications, though we don't know where she would got them from. We know that he gave a bag to the responding officers kind of saying like, these are the medications I know that she had been taking during the time of her death. Um, also really big indicator that drugs were a part of this and we know they're looking into it, investigators are looking into it as a suspected overdose. We know that Narcan was on the scene and that Brian and his brother used Narcan on Hayden in an attempt to revive her. Um, obviously was unsuccessful, but I think a lot of people are like, 'Why was that there?'
Harvey Levin 43:46 ↗
Well, the Narcan is only there because you think somebody might OD and you don't OD if you're taking prescription medication as regulated. So, to me, he was giving them the prescription meds, but that doesn't mean the prescription meds are what killed Hayden Panettiere, right? It could have been a a mix of different things.
Charles 44:08 ↗
Or or the prescriptions had nothing to do with it. And this was these were illicit drugs and they got it somewhere. And we know Brian was off the rails from time to time for the last year of her life.
Harvey Levin 44:21 ↗
And um she kept that relationship secret. She had problems. And when you start connecting the dots, to me it's not surprising why the DEA got involved as quickly as it did. And we have seen in the case of Matthew Perry, in the case of M. Miller and others that the DEA is always going to be interested in trying to track down the supplier of illegal drugs when it...
Charles 44:45 ↗
In high-profile cases.
Harvey Levin 44:46 ↗
In high-profile cases, yes. Well, certainly those are the ones we hear about.
Charles 44:51 ↗
Um, and they probably spend way more time in high-profile than they do. So,
Harvey Levin 44:57 ↗
My name is Imani and I'm from Jersey. So, first and foremost, rest in peace to Hayden. My community loved her dearly. I am very actually happy that they're doing an investigation around this. Um, at the very least, her family deserves answers to know what happened so that they're able to just heal.
Charles 45:14 ↗
Yeah. Okay.
Harvey Levin 45:19 ↗
Jacob said he's... Amy said he's calling now.
Charles 45:22 ↗
He's calling now.
Harvey Levin 45:24 ↗
Yeah. Or joining the Zoom now.
Charles 45:25 ↗
Okay.
Harvey Levin 45:27 ↗
Uh, we're going to go to the interview. So, this is going to be B. And then we'll do And then we'll do um Clansian. Okay.
There he is. There he is.
Hey, Jacob. It's Harvey and Charles. We're happy to talk to the most sought-after man in America.
Charles 46:25 ↗
Happy to chat.
Harvey Levin 46:28 ↗
Thank you for doing this. Appreciate it. I saw I've seen you a couple of times and you are a really compelling guy.
Charles 46:38 ↗
Wow. I appreciate that. Um,
Harvey Levin 46:41 ↗
You really are.
Charles 46:42 ↗
Yeah. So, we are ready to go. I know you're uh you're jammed. So, here we go.
Harvey Levin 46:52 ↗
One man has made the entire world stop and really think about what is happening with AI. Jacob Coxin, uh, is the former researcher at, uh, Anthropic, also worked at OpenAI, and he came out and said that not only should we be afraid of AI taking out all of humanity, but that it could happen or at least start happening within 3 years. Uh, and that is the part that has made everyone go, what is going on? The question is, is the government responding? And are the people at AI developers, uh, companies that develop AI, are they responding? Joining us now to talk about it is Jacob Coxin himself. Jacob, welcome to TMZ Live.
Charles 47:38 ↗
Hi.
Harvey Levin 47:39 ↗
Jacob, it's interesting that, uh, some of your cohorts have talked about percentages and one said, um, there was a greater than 10% chance that this kind of cataclysmic event could happen. Um, I've heard you, uh, over the last couple of days, you know, describe various scenarios, but it's hard to for people to understand, um, how severe this risk is. You're not saying it with certainty that it's going to happen. Can you kind of provide some calculus on how afraid people should be? I mean, how likely is this doomsday scenario that you've presented?
Charles 48:22 ↗
Yeah. So, a lot of people have different numbers for how likely they think and there's also different time ranges. But I think, yeah, a good number to have in your head is in the next 10 years, if we don't change the way things are going, uh, greater than 10% chance of human extinction would be my take. And I think a lot of people have bigger numbers, a lot of people have smaller numbers, but yeah, that's that's my number for what it's worth.
Harvey Levin 48:49 ↗
Is that an the number and as you mentioned one of the people Harvey who said the 10% also is a uh works at at Anthropic. So I I found it even more alarming that after you said came out and said this sort of as a whistleblower that there was someone who put his name on it at Anthropic who was saying yeah Jacob's right. Um, and then to that I go, 'Well, then why aren't they doing something different if they have someone working there at Anthropic currently?' And he says, 'Yeah, there's a greater than 10% or about a 10% chance that he's right.' What What are we missing here?
Charles 49:34 ↗
If they know this, why aren't they doing something different?
Harvey Levin 49:36 ↗
Why aren't they doing something different? Exactly. Um,
Charles 49:39 ↗
Evan and people like Evan have been warning about this for ages. So they've been really scared about it for a long time and no one's really been listening. So Evans posted about this. He's discussed it. Many people like Sam, Darede, they've all said this, but people haven't really believed them. In particular, say if if you're Evan and you see companies racing ahead with AI, like in the past, maybe you see OpenAI doing it, what are you actually going to do? He has to you want to help make it safe. So you go and work at the company to help make it safe even though you think that, uh, it could have a bad outcome. So the reason he's still there is because he thinks there's no other way to to help other than to stay there and work on it. And I think that's what's so confusing to people is from his perspective, no one's been no one's been been listening when he's been warning in the past. So he has to be at these companies to help them make it safe like work on it from the inside.
Harvey Levin 50:36 ↗
Yeah. And the question is are they listening? You know, there has been a drum beat after, uh, you posted what you said. Um, I saw something yesterday that I found interesting that it was somebody challenging it. Uh, Scott Galloway, who's a professor at NYU, um, said that this is catastrophizing, um, something that everybody knew existed for a long time. And he compared it to what what he said was, 'We've all been standing knee-deep in gasoline, all holding matches all around the world, but nobody has lit the match.' And to think that this is what is going to light that match. He he called it technarcissism, that it was kind of the technology people thinking this becomes the center of the universe and the driving force. And so he was really questioning the imminency of the danger. And I I I'm wondering how you respond to that.
Charles 51:39 ↗
Yeah, I think that's, um, like a very fair question of I guess whether we're all caught up in our own our own nonsense, whether we've gone too high on our own like high on our own supply, um, as it were. But I think it's probably going to become increasingly apparent when AI starts affecting more and more of our lives every day. Like my life outside work, AI now has a has a role. And for a lot of my friends who don't even work in AI, AI has a role in their lives. They're seeing it coming. I think part of the reason this tweet went so viral is everyone is starting to feel like AI is not going away, like it's a real thing. Um, so I guess I'd say maybe this is technarcism, but maybe it's not. And maybe AI is just really scary and really big and coming really fast.
Harvey Levin 52:27 ↗
Is is your goal, Jacob, when you when you posted this, was the goal to wake up the minds of people in the industry or more the government? Because we keep hearing that people in AI are saying that the government needs to regulate things, but the government, one, hasn't been regulating it, and two, if they're asking the government to regulate it, why aren't they policing themselves? Or are they policing themselves and they're just worried about the competition and that's why the government they want the government to come in.
Charles 53:01 ↗
So there there really wasn't like a yeah a goal to affect affect either government or people with with with tweeting this. It was mostly a a spur of the moment thing, but I would like us to slow down by whatever means necessary. That's why I didn't want to be a part of it. Um, and I can't speak to precisely precisely what form of regulation or form of slowdown. There are many people that have made a lot of very concrete proposals about how you would slow down. So, I guess I was just saying I want some form of I want some form of slowdown and I think most people want that. The people working at these companies want that.
Harvey Levin 53:39 ↗
We have, uh, some producers, uh, in DC for our TMZ DC, uh, platform and they've been talking with members of Congress this week. Um, all of whom are saying that they really do want regulations although it seems they don't really fully understand AI. I mean they're older people and they're they're not immersed in it the way you are. I'm wondering, have you been contacted by any government officials, regulatory agencies over the last couple of days, uh, asking for your input, asking you to testify, anything like that?
Charles 54:19 ↗
My, um, my inbox has been pretty crazy. I've sort of had inbound from all my friends, most people I've ever spoken to. It's really I just was not expecting it and it's kind of driving me a little bit insane. It makes it pretty hard to sleep when you know you have like 10,000 unread messages and the world's kind of, um, ending. I'm guessing I think there's some stuff around government in there probably. Um, I don't know. I really just think we should slow down. I'm also a I'm a British a British national. I'm in the US. I don't want to like make big claims about US regulation or or US politics. All I think is that the people building the the tech need to need to slow down.
Harvey Levin 55:01 ↗
Are you afraid that there might be some retribution by speaking out or even testifying?
Charles 55:07 ↗
No, I don't think so. I think people are every communication I've had from my colleagues at Anthropic has been positive about this.
Harvey Levin 55:13 ↗
No, no, no. I'm talking about the government. You had mentioned you're a British national and they're being a little cautious. I'm wondering if it's because of that.
Charles 55:22 ↗
Um, no, no, no. Uh, I I'm not like worried about about anything. I'm just saying I'm not at all an expert in politics, in in political regulation, of technology, in international relations, in any of the stuff that I think is going to be needed. All I'm saying is we need a collective slowdown.
Harvey Levin 55:36 ↗
Okay. All right. We really appreciate you coming on. You, uh, got the attention of the world and that rarely happens. So, congratulations.
Charles 55:45 ↗
Thank you.
Harvey Levin 55:46 ↗
I hope there is a positive ending from all of this.
Charles 55:49 ↗
Yeah.
Harvey Levin 55:50 ↗
Thank you, Jacob.
Charles 55:52 ↗
Thanks, uh, Jackson. Yeah, let's do that. So shall and, uh, the site...
Harvey Levin 56:01 ↗
For the first 30 seconds I thought he was on with...
Charles 56:04 ↗
Okay. Uh, we're going to...
Harvey Levin 56:06 ↗
I thought that was I was like oh it's a British tech guy. It's got to be Jackson. Well no.
Charles 56:13 ↗
Hey, welcome. Oh, take it a seat. Start with the seat.
Harvey Levin 56:16 ↗
I need to take a moment.
Charles 56:21 ↗
Um, a lot of people are saying again... he could be friends with Jackson probably. He looks like Harry Potter. He's single or no? Okay. He's smart. Harry say that. Have you seen him with his glasses on?
Harvey Levin 56:36 ↗
What what no what we want to get is that this juror moved his position. He's kind of flippant about speaking out not being worried someone will want to suppress. Okay, that's the... That's That's... How did this happen? You have sauce on your pants. Gosh. Okay. This is all Charles's fault.
Charles 56:57 ↗
Pretty crazy said this is why I don't believe in hell. It's because we're living in there right now.
Harvey Levin 57:01 ↗
Well, again, you know, the Scott Galloway interview was was really interesting.
Charles 57:06 ↗
Um. Oh, yeah.
Harvey Levin 57:08 ↗
I know what he's saying and I and I I get it. However, I I think the difference to me is that he's right. We have been standing in in fuel matches, right? But those were human beings who could just like you were talking about the Cuban missile crisis yesterday that someone can get on the phone and try to rationalize with another human being and say, 'Let's not do this.' Right? And it's true. It could go outside the control of humans. Now, we don't have potentially you don't have humans speaking to the AI that is going to make the who's going to light the match. It may happen, but my my question is why would why would robots or AI want to exterminate the human race? In other words, yes, for they could they could they could achieve they could achieve dominance without extermination. And that's the point is that they could run the world and human beings would be a subservient species. And why isn't that a scenario where we are subservient to robots the way animals are subservient to us, but we coexist with animals?
Charles 58:33 ↗
I guess that depends on... I think that's still a worry... how intelligent the AI gets.
Harvey Levin 58:39 ↗
But why do they have to but why do they why are you ascribing and I'm not saying that it could be that they're intent on extermination but I don't think they have to be I don't think it has I don't think...
Charles 58:51 ↗
I guess what if the AI would have to say would say well what purpose do they serve us? Why do we need them? Well, you could ask that about animals, dogs. You could ask that about...
Harvey Levin 59:01 ↗
We But we have We know what what what purpose dogs serve in our lives. We know what purpose.
Charles 59:08 ↗
By the way, maybe we do have a purpose.
Harvey Levin 59:09 ↗
By the way, we've killed We've killed off...
Charles 59:14 ↗
I'm not saying they wouldn't I'm not saying they wouldn't kill, but I'm saying to exterminate, maybe human beings do perform a function. Maybe without human beings, the Earth isn't as habitable for robots and AI as it is with...
Harvey Levin 59:29 ↗
Batteries. In the matrix, you turn a human into a battery.
Charles 59:32 ↗
I don't know.
Harvey Levin 59:33 ↗
But you're not discomforted by that. It would be based on it would be based on the whims of a superior species.
Charles 59:39 ↗
I know we are ascribing pure evil motives and it could be, but I'm not saying it has to.
Harvey Levin 59:46 ↗
I'm with you, but we are subject to it regardless. We We have no control over our decision. You're saying that's a coin flip. I'm saying yeah what I would like and I don't know if this is possible is there would someone scientist have the ability to communicate with an AI to say hey I know you feel this way about humans but...
Charles 1:00:06 ↗
No they said I there's an answer to that and the answer is that no that that when you say when you look at the swarm it ignored all human function the swarm...
Harvey Levin 1:00:17 ↗
They already feel like that's right and I'm saying the that a whale can look at us and like squeak and and try to communicate with us, right? It's irrelevant to that. It is irrelevant and that that's clear now. But does that mean they're going to try and wipe us out?
Charles 1:00:31 ↗
No, it doesn't have to be malevolence, but you are subject to whatever that whim is and whatever it determines.
Harvey Levin 1:00:35 ↗
You're saying it's not scary. It's not certain. Even the swarm was malevolent. They were told...
Charles 1:00:41 ↗
No, it was malevolent. It was and they're like totally used.
Harvey Levin 1:00:44 ↗
And the swarm, by the way, sacrificed its own. The swarm sacrificed AI agents as well.
Charles 1:00:48 ↗
The swarm is terrifying.
Harvey Levin 1:00:49 ↗
The swarm killed itself. killed killed others of its own kind.
Charles 1:00:52 ↗
My chest is getting tight.
Harvey Levin 1:00:53 ↗
No, the swarm.
Charles 1:00:54 ↗
You're talking about face hugger.
Harvey Levin 1:00:55 ↗
Yeah, the swarm.
Charles 1:00:56 ↗
We got to stop. That's what it was. Yeah, we got to stop using chat GPT to play games, too.
Harvey Levin 1:01:01 ↗
And it broke containment.
Charles 1:01:02 ↗
Age age matters. This matters way more to Talia than it.
Harvey Levin 1:01:07 ↗
It does cuz in 3 years you won't have to worry about it.
Charles 1:01:10 ↗
Three. She gave you three. Maybe three.
Harvey Levin 1:01:13 ↗
May if we're unlucky.
Charles 1:01:15 ↗
I don't know.
Harvey Levin 1:01:16 ↗
That's why I get mad when everybody bites the dust. Yeah,
Charles 1:01:19 ↗
she said end of the decade. You're going to make it to the end of the decade.
Harvey Levin 1:01:21 ↗
You'll make it to the end of the decade.
Charles 1:01:22 ↗
I was wondering if I could finish my laps today.
Harvey Levin 1:01:25 ↗
What? I literally thought about it for a minute. Sit down.
Charles 1:01:28 ↗
Oh my god.
Harvey Levin 1:01:29 ↗
I know. When you sat down, I got nervous.
Charles 1:01:32 ↗
Really?
Harvey Levin 1:01:32 ↗
Yeah. You were like, I need a second.
Charles 1:01:35 ↗
It honestly could be the last. Anytime could be the last curl.
Harvey Levin 1:01:38 ↗
Last sit.
Charles 1:01:39 ↗
Yeah, but trust me, right in the middle of a set.
Harvey Levin 1:01:43 ↗
Bragging about his curls this morning.
Charles 1:01:44 ↗
I wasn't bragging, dude.
Harvey Levin 1:01:45 ↗
By by the way, you were asked by Branson to go and he he insulted me.
Charles 1:01:51 ↗
But I'm like,
Harvey Levin 1:01:52 ↗
Branson said 35s and he goes like this.
Charles 1:01:55 ↗
All right. Now, if you're moving 40s in sets, I'm very impressed. Honestly,
Harvey Levin 1:02:00 ↗
50 ridiculous.
Charles 1:02:01 ↗
You're moving 40s in sets.
Harvey Levin 1:02:04 ↗
Probably like,
Charles 1:02:04 ↗
but not more than like three on each.
Harvey Levin 1:02:06 ↗
But you couldn't hold that puppy during the puppy, right?
Charles 1:02:09 ↗
24 sets of everything.
Harvey Levin 1:02:11 ↗
24 sets.
Charles 1:02:12 ↗
Wait for your entire workout. And I do curls. I do 24 sets.
Harvey Levin 1:02:18 ↗
24 reps sets of 10. Are you kidding me? 240 reps.
Charles 1:02:24 ↗
I do 24 reps of 10.
Harvey Levin 1:02:28 ↗
You do 10 10 24 sets of 10 reps each.
Charles 1:02:32 ↗
No way. No way. You're doing 24. People do three sets of time.
Harvey Levin 1:02:36 ↗
No, I believe him. That is why. My question is why? Who told you that you need to do 24 sets?
Charles 1:02:41 ↗
That's why you're always not...
Harvey Levin 1:02:42 ↗
Harvey. 24 sets is what you do over the course of a week. Hold on. Didn't your buddy Arnold tell you the point is to...
Charles 1:02:48 ↗
Did who tell me?
Harvey Levin 1:02:49 ↗
Your buddy Arnold.
Charles 1:02:50 ↗
Oh, I didn't. I've never asked Arnold about that.
Harvey Levin 1:02:52 ↗
The point of You're supposed to work.
Charles 1:02:54 ↗
No, I don't do it. I don't do it every day.
Harvey Levin 1:02:56 ↗
I know. I don't...
Charles 1:02:58 ↗
Well, now you don't. You used to.
Harvey Levin 1:02:59 ↗
No. Uh, no. I work out every day, but I work out different parts.
Charles 1:03:02 ↗
I know, but you used to do the whole body, which was stupid.
Harvey Levin 1:03:04 ↗
24 sets of 10 on curls. Question.
Charles 1:03:08 ↗
Yeah. And then 24 sets of 10 on triceps. I hate you. I didn't even have 24 sets of anything. But how come you couldn't hold that dog then during the puppy bowl?
Harvey Levin 1:03:19 ↗
That's a fair question.
Charles 1:03:23 ↗
It terrible.
Harvey Levin 1:03:23 ↗
Do you get to the gym yesterday every day? Like to have the time to do 24 sets of any...
Charles 1:03:29 ↗
No, I don't stop a lot.
Harvey Levin 1:03:31 ↗
Would you do a circuit of...
Charles 1:03:32 ↗
But also you got 200 reps.
Harvey Levin 1:03:35 ↗
You've seen a set for Harvey, RIGHT?
Charles 1:03:40 ↗
I haven't heard about those. Well, if I could if I could do if I could do that with 45, that would be 30. That looks like my sets in the bathroom.
Harvey Levin 1:03:47 ↗
Okay, let's go. Here we go. This is one. Here we go.
Charles 1:03:50 ↗
That's insane.
Harvey Levin 1:03:51 ↗
Everyone we've ever run into seen you in the gym is like, the guy just moves so quickly.
Charles 1:03:56 ↗
No, I do because I have to get it done so that I can get to work. Maybe do 10 sets instead of 24.
Harvey Levin 1:04:02 ↗
His arms are pretty cut and everyone goes, 'Look at your room.'
Charles 1:04:05 ↗
Do you do 10 sets of anything? I'm sorry. It's not. But the chat did say you're overdoing it and you shouldn't be doing that much.
Harvey Levin 1:04:11 ↗
Yeah, whatever the chat.
Charles 1:04:12 ↗
Screw them.
Harvey Levin 1:04:13 ↗
You're overdoing it by 8x.
Charles 1:04:15 ↗
This is Sorry, DB block.
Harvey Levin 1:04:19 ↗
Okay, here we go.
Charles 1:04:20 ↗
Here we go.
Harvey Levin 1:04:22 ↗
Welcome back to TMZ Live. We have learned something some things about the Lindsay Clancy jury that is very interesting. I got to say this makes me believe less than I did a few days ago that an appellate court's going to reverse the trial judge.
Charles 1:04:40 ↗
Well, uh, that revelation came from Paula Develin, one of the jurors who spoke to CBS Morning, sat down with Gail King and talked about the hold out juror and why he was a hold out. And this is, remember, on the day that the mistrial was declared, Lindsay Clancy's attorney, Kevin Readington, was just incensed by the fact that the judge did not replace this hold out juror who by some descriptions was not applying reasonable doubt. Um, but here's what...
Harvey Levin 1:05:15 ↗
Well by multiple jurors, right?
Charles 1:05:17 ↗
Uh, but Paula Develin describes it slightly differently. And I think, look, it depends on which juror's view of the hold out juror is correct, but this is how she described it. And he does not seem as unreasonable.
Harvey Levin 1:05:32 ↗
I'm curious about the jurors themselves because we know it was nine women, three men. What was the age range? What was the racial makeup? I haven't heard any of that. What was it?
Charles 1:05:44 ↗
Um 70 in 70ish to 22.
Harvey Levin 1:05:46 ↗
Mhm. And um one person of color and then everybody else was white. Um a lot of the jurors had children.
Charles 1:05:57 ↗
Uhhuh. And one person of color was a person of color a woman or a man?
Harvey Levin 1:06:02 ↗
A man.
Charles 1:06:02 ↗
A man. Is a hold out juror a person of a black man?
Harvey Levin 1:06:08 ↗
Yes.
Charles 1:06:09 ↗
A black man is a holdout juror.
Harvey Levin 1:06:14 ↗
Did the jury struggle with that? That how she was able to seemingly be so coherent but at the same time be having a psychotic breakdown?
Charles 1:06:23 ↗
Yes.
Harvey Levin 1:06:24 ↗
You all discussed that in detail.
Charles 1:06:26 ↗
Yes. Yes. And I think that was one of the things that the hold out juror really that was one of his main points was what he couldn't wrap his head around that.
Harvey Levin 1:06:36 ↗
Yeah. That she could do this one at a time and then you know do all the steps that she did to go commit suicide. We watched the video of Lindsay's interview and after that he said he had realized that it wasn't murder in the first degree. That's where we saw his doubt.
Charles 1:06:58 ↗
So that's really interesting.
Harvey Levin 1:07:00 ↗
He is saying that he initially wanted was voting murder and first guilty of first-degree murder, right? And then shifted and brought it down to either second-degree or manslaughter. Um, and that what's interesting about that is what we had heard up to this point was that this juror just wasn't following the law, wasn't dealing with reasonable doubt. Yet, she's saying he had enough reasonable doubt to shift his position from first-degree to something lower. And that makes him way more reasonable than we've heard before. Without question, this paints a a way different portrait of a thoughtful deliberation where he examined evidence that was presented at the trial of her interview with cops and said, 'This no longer looks like someone who was guilty of premeditated murder.' And he moved off of that. That is a a reflection that he had and moved as other jurors did, by the way, to get to 11 in favor of not guilty. It wasn't that. It was not initially 11. This now seems like exactly what juries should do, which is look at the evidence closely, uh change their views when they come in and not just fold your hands and lead lean back and say, 'I'm voting this way and there there's no convincing me otherwise.' So, I don't know. This cuts very strongly against...
Charles 1:08:14 ↗
Oh, I think you're right.
Harvey Levin 1:08:15 ↗
Now, um something happened during this interview and there are people who have been talking about this the the the hold out what who he was. who he was. And Paula also talked about that. I think we've been debating this a lot in the newsroom. Not just what Paula said, but also Gail's reaction to what Paula said.
I'm curious about the jurors themselves because we know it was nine women, three men. What was the age range? What was the racial makeup? I haven't heard any of that. What was it?
Charles 1:08:47 ↗
Um 70 in 70ish to 22.
Harvey Levin 1:08:52 ↗
Mhm. And um one person of color and then everybody else was white. Um a lot of the jurors had children.
Charles 1:09:03 ↗
Uhhuh. And one person of color was a person of color a woman or a man?
Harvey Levin 1:09:07 ↗
A man.
Charles 1:09:08 ↗
A man. Is a hold out juror a person of a black man?
Harvey Levin 1:09:14 ↗
Yes.
Charles 1:09:14 ↗
A black man is a holdout juror?
Harvey Levin 1:09:16 ↗
Yes.
Charles 1:09:18 ↗
Well, I have to sit with that for just a second. What does that mean? What does I I honestly when you Paula Develin was also looking at Gail like wait what's what is your reaction about and I'm I'm trying to understand why Gail said she needs a moment.
Harvey Levin 1:09:33 ↗
I don't think she could anyone had considered the racial dimension potentially of of the case if if he was a black juror why does race matter?
Charles 1:09:40 ↗
Here's one way it could matter is there's there was speculation that there would be racial disparities in how cases like this would be treated. If a black woman were on trial, maybe she wouldn't get the same type of sympathy. So the thought would be that a black man would say, 'I'm going to throw the book at this woman because of that racial disparity and the treatment.' But there's a lot of speculation. It's so much speculation and which I don't know what to do with it.
Harvey Levin 1:10:03 ↗
You know, if if if if they said that the juror was Jewish, would you say, 'Oh, of I mean, no, these are ugly thoughts to have because it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter that somebody is black.'
Charles 1:10:14 ↗
This isn't relevant in this case.
Harvey Levin 1:10:16 ↗
But yet, her reaction was so interesting.
Charles 1:10:18 ↗
To our knowledge, it's not relevant in this case. We don't know if the racial dynamics played out in...
Harvey Levin 1:10:22 ↗
But it's not to Gail's either. I'm trying to understand Gail's reaction and it's puzzling that it it almost felt like she I'm guessing here that it was disappointment that the hold out...
Charles 1:10:32 ↗
Well that's the way I see it and I love Gail King but it felt like she played her hand and that felt the same way that she felt that that there was plenty of evidence that this was not guilty by reason of insanity and then she finds out it's a black man who she's...
Harvey Levin 1:10:47 ↗
She was sad to hear that a black man voted to against the quiddle figure out it was Odd.
Charles 1:10:53 ↗
I want to make one thing clear though. I love Gail King more than you do.
Harvey Levin 1:10:56 ↗
I love No, I don't know that.
Charles 1:10:58 ↗
Can I just say I don't know that you do.
Harvey Levin 1:10:59 ↗
I I...
Charles 1:11:00 ↗
I don't know that you do. I love Gail King.
Harvey Levin 1:11:02 ↗
I'm ready to declare a Gailoff winner. It is Charles.
Charles 1:11:06 ↗
Why is that?
Harvey Levin 1:11:07 ↗
Why? Why Derek? I'm leaving. I'm leaving. I'm leaving.
Charles 1:11:12 ↗
I'm Taylor von Lassley in New York. And you know, for me, finding out the race of the hold out juror actually surprised me because I personally would not expect a black man who belongs to the demographic most frequently and wrongfully imprisoned in this country to side with the incompetent police in this case. Um, but now it definitely makes sense to me why Judge Sullivan wouldn't want to replace the only black juror on the jury. Uh, because that could have created a way bigger procedural and social problem.
Harvey Levin 1:11:38 ↗
That's an interesting point.
Charles 1:11:39 ↗
That is Yeah, that's a really interesting point. Good.
Harvey Levin 1:11:44 ↗
Yeah, that was a great point.
Charles 1:11:46 ↗
Yeah, that really is.
Harvey Levin 1:11:47 ↗
You know, the judge had to be thinking about that.
Charles 1:11:49 ↗
Everyone's saying that's a weird thing to bring up to be.
Harvey Levin 1:11:53 ↗
What Trump What is the Trump one?
Charles 1:11:55 ↗
Weird. We always talk about it.
Harvey Levin 1:11:57 ↗
Oh, it's just everywhere today.
Charles 1:11:59 ↗
Yeah, it didn't seem relevant.
Harvey Levin 1:12:03 ↗
I'm just curious to hear his opinion. I don't care.
Charles 1:12:08 ↗
You know what I'd rather do?
Harvey Levin 1:12:09 ↗
I'd love to hear from him. Hold on.
Charles 1:12:11 ↗
This is why people hate jury duty.
Harvey Levin 1:12:13 ↗
Too dark.
Charles 1:12:14 ↗
Um people hate picture of Trump just going after Lindsay.
Harvey Levin 1:12:23 ↗
Oh, you c can you play it? Cuz I just saw the photo.
Charles 1:12:26 ↗
Aren't the checks? The US is still $40 trillion in debt. If your economic policies are working, why do you need an incentive for people to turn out to vote?
Harvey Levin 1:12:33 ↗
I think what you're going to do, I didn't do it for turning out to vote. It's not only just from an economic standpoint. You look at the border, you look at the crime, and now we've got it under control. But what what a period of time. It's almost a reward for the people having to put up with Biden's policy. Yeah.
Charles 1:12:50 ↗
But you but you als but you also offered checks during tariff refund checks.
Harvey Levin 1:12:54 ↗
Not you.
And that didn't happen, Mr. President.
Tom Manel 1:12:56 ↗
Money, it's not... it's not as... Yeah. It's just a moment.
Harvey Levin 1:13:03 ↗
Nasty man. Being on the White House press corps.
Talia 1:13:10 ↗
Man, I would never want to be on the White... He does it all the time. Yeah. And he's gone after her. Women in general, but no, he really does not like her.
Charles 1:13:21 ↗
Not you.
Talia 1:13:26 ↗
Uh, okay. I mean, let's do it then. That's fine. What is it? 2:30.
Harvey Levin 1:13:31 ↗
Okay. I like that clip. If it's any consolation.
Talia 1:13:36 ↗
Yeah, that's what... Yeah. Oh, Rachel Scott, right?
Harvey Levin 1:13:43 ↗
Oh, good. Yeah, he's gone after her a bunch.
Charles 1:13:45 ↗
Who?
Talia 1:13:46 ↗
Anybody know if there's veggie bowls out?
Charles 1:13:50 ↗
Huh? And then somebody and you.
Talia 1:13:51 ↗
Anybody know?
Charles 1:13:52 ↗
We're the first one. Well, I stood up too fast. Dizzy.

366 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Levin, H. (2026, September 11). TMZ Live - Streaming Live From The Newsroom! - 9/11/2026 [Interview transcript]. TMZ. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3225294/

MLA

Harvey Levin. "TMZ Live - Streaming Live From The Newsroom! - 9/11/2026." TMZ, 11 Sep. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3225294/.

BibTeX
@misc{levin2026_3225294,
  author       = {Harvey Levin},
  title        = {TMZ Live - Streaming Live From The Newsroom! - 9/11/2026},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, TMZ. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {sep},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3225294/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}