Hello everybody and welcome back to TMZ Live. It is a day in the week. It is Tuesday, September 8th. How's everybody doing today? Um, hello, hello, hello. Um, let's see, guys. How's everybody doing? How's everybody's weekend? Uh, how was the long weekend? Did everybody enjoy themselves? Um, I think it was a very... it was very enjoyable for me at least. I think uh nice to be off for a little bit, but how's everybody else doing? Um, hello Antonio. Hello Allan. How's everybody doing?
Um, everybody let me know what they did, what they got up to. What is up? What is up? What is up? What is up? What's up, LJ Antonio? Sean Robert, uh Sean Robinson, Robert Bruno, what up Tracy? Uh good morning, Clara. Fanny, Fanny, May or not? Flash. Okay, M. Um Mike Bradley. Exactly. Let the uh stream begin. [clears throat] Luther Hansen sounds like fun. Um Donna T. Donna [clears throat] T. Hey from Mississippi. Hey from Southern California. What's up, Brandy? What's up, Miss Princess? Brandon, thank you. Nate Hen, hello. Diamond Gem Girl, what's up? How's everybody doing? Um, what is up? What is up, Buster? What's good, DT? Um, DJ J, you're gonna have to wait till tomorrow to figure that out. It's not here. Um, okay, Gary.
Um, nothing like a relaxing weekend. Enjoying the sun, water, and my chosen family. Big mouth bezy. There you go. There you go. Robert, watch a little EU golf. Uh, USA golfers are better looking, Robert. Fair. Fair, fair, fair. Um, I watched LSU smash Clemson 51-10. Lane Kiffin has LSU looking good. Yep, I did see that, Brandon. That was a good game. Or not a good game, but it was good for LSU. Kelly [snorts] Smith, what's up? I know, baby. Uh, Big Mouth BZ. Uh, football's coming back Wednesday, guys, tomorrow night. Um, Black Beauty, I'm doing good. How about yourself? Um, I hope you have a super amazing day. I went to a Dodger game, Alexander. Nice. Did you go to the Dodgers versus the Nationals? It's my squad. They took it to him, though. I watched college football all weekend. There you go. Nate Hen, love that. Natalie Blackbaker, what's up? Uh, what's up, Carlton lineback? How's it going? Uh, this is the Chuck Nasty birthday week, Brandon. Yep. Natalie, where were you at on vacation?
Uh Carlton, well, you will uh uh they will be back, I'm sure. Sweet and Low W. Sweet and Low. Uh Vikings Green Bay Sunday. Woohoo. Antonio, you are rooting for the Packers. Maybe. I'm not 100% sure. Hi all, I'm back after working 12 days at our state fair. I need a nap pit player. Wow. State Fair is no joke, huh? Natalie, I know. Tomorrow night. Yep. It's going down. Exactly. LJ Black Beauty. I'm glad to hear that you're doing well. My favorite time of the year for so many reasons. I know. This is like the best time of the year for sports. It's awesome. Um, went to the Black Crows and Guns N' Roses in San Diego and hung out in the ocean. Fanny, that sounds awesome. Sounds very, very, very, very fun. I set up with who? What up, Miss Mon'nique? How's it going? How we doing? How we doing? Um, Gary Sen, have no idea. Uh, Michelle Wilson, good to see you as well. Miss Scatpack, good morning. Terrace, hello.
Natalie, you were in Maryland. Very nice. Very nice. Um, I did Luther in the pouring rain. Um, it was pretty brutal, but it was okay. Um, what did you think about the Western Michigan and Michigan game? Uh, Nate, I think that Western Michigan got uh scummed. It was zero on the clock. Friday is 25. I know, Brandon. I know. Um, I was not born. Uh, Mary Kemp, what's good? I'm doing well. How about yourself? Sweet and low. Hello. I'm Minnesotan and obviously the Vik Queens. Okay, Antonio. I forgot. I forgot. Hope they will be back. I wish they were here full time. Um, they are here full-time. Carlton. Uh, they will be here tomorrow. Um, your premium YouTube is off and I got ads again. Ah, Brandy, I'm sorry. That sucks. Um, what is up bestie? What is up, Don? How are we doing? Phoenix Fire. Uh, you were at the Ozarks in Missouri. Dang, guys. You did a lot of cool stuff. Uh, there you go, Slate. Uh, Alexander versus Nats Saturday. Someone stole my... Oh, did the Nats win on Saturday? Uh, Alexandra, that might have been the only game they won at that series. Triiona, good morning. I got to spend Saturday with my 5-year-old granddaughter and we colored together. Also trying to get healthier and I've been taking a lot of good walks. Triiona, that's awesome. I'm happy to hear that. Ed Sheeran at MetLife. Wow. My gosh, guys. You guys are doing so much cool stuff with Woodbridge. That sounds cool, [snorts] Miss Mooney. So funny. There you go.
Uh, don't you just love how us regulars are always here, Brandy? I know. I know. Robert, old shirt. Old shirt. Um, Nate Hen, there you go. I can't believe it's... I know. I know, guys. Uh, are they still on vacation? I'm not sure. Let's go, Steelers. There you go. Uh, wow. I was so young, Buffy. I know. I know. So young. Mary Marian, what's up? Golfing in the rain strictly for the hardcore. Luther, I know some people just want it more. Some people just want it more. Uh, who is your favorite Beatle? I plead the fifth. I do not have a favorite Beatle. Um, should I go to see Brandi Carlile this week at Red Rocks? I don't know her. Catalog worth it. Never been to Red Rocks. Red Rocks is the best. You should definitely go if you can. Um, okay, Gary. Uh, Carlton. Oh, they were tomorrow. Nice. I wish they were hosting today. We need them on here. Carlton, well, sorry to disappoint you. [laughter] Um, you got to wait till tomorrow, I guess. Dodgers won. Ah, dang it. I don't actually know if they won any of those games in that series to be honest. You haven't put a ring on it, but you already have a golf widow. What does that mean, Robert? Um, how's your weekend? Do I do anything? I hung out with my buddies, golfed on Sunday, golfed yesterday. Um, all right, guys.
>> Uh, watched uh college football on Saturday. Hung out. It was fun. Heather Stew, what up? What up? How's it going? Did I watch Florida State versus SMU? I watched like the last little bit of it. Are there no gingers at TMZ? Because they don't. Are you serious, Matthew? They do have souls. Um, believe it or not. Uh, Christina Jean Fa, good morning. How was your weekend? What did you do over the fun Labor Day weekend, Christina? I just hung out. >> Uh, didn't do a whole ton. I'm honestly happy I didn't. Andrew is back tonight for the Yankees, Nate. I did see that. I did see that. Do you think it is over for Clemson? They're not the same team they were years ago. Uh, yeah. I mean, they haven't been good in a while um since Trevor Lawrence. So, did you win against your buddies in golf? No, but I did match my best score in the rain, which was pretty cool. Um, can't believe it's been left us. I miss her. I wish he was still here. All right. Yeah, I'm sorry, Carlton. That's uh it's not good. >> Um, I mean, you leave your Robert, she was uh in New York. Um, but no, it's a deal, you know. She knows I play every Sunday is what it is. Um, yeah, I just heard Cody Rhodes. Uh, yeah. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yeah. Yeah, guys, we'll have some exciting stuff to talk about today here in a little bit.
>> Um, hi there. You think many of the TMZ staff will be playing GTA 6 on release day? Delena, I'm not sure. Do I have a picture of myself without a mustache? Uh, somewhere. Um, did you play any golf this weekend, Brandon? You know, I did. Um, hey, hey, hey. Not too much on the Clemson Tigers. Danny Madison, I'm sorry, but they are buns. Um, they are buns. I'm not uh anti-redhead. They are fine with me. Okay, good to hear. Going the distance, are we? What do you mean? You guys are always just saying random random stuff, man. No idea what you guys are saying. Um, let's see. Oops. Uh, you see my comment? I figured out the way to win my bread. What are you guys? You guys just are spewing some crazy stuff, man. Crazy, crazy stuff. [clears throat] How old am I, Christina? I am 23. Um, Mammore Peak Lindsay Clancy lawyer ask for Trump to pardon Antonio. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Um, let's see. Is GTA 6 that good? LJ, nobody knows. It's not out yet. Asus ROG. Okay. Junade Manzor. Hello. Hello. Uh, Jeremy, you weren't on yesterday, Jeremy. Yesterday was Labor Day. Um, let's see. Bunch of randos. Luther Hans, what are you talking? [laughter] >> Oh my gosh. What are you guys talking about, man? Um, my child older than you, Black Beauty. Yeah. Um, >> oh, go for [laughter] it. >> Um, yeah, Jeremy, you guys are like, what are you guys? I don't know. Yes, everyone is still with everyone's still [laughter] here. Um, the hat today is Eagles Super Bowl 59 champs, guys. That is the hat for today. Um, happy birthday, Raven.
That tall sheet I am only 20 that car like [laughter] what dude you guys are wilding man. Lori, I know. Eighth year anniversary of Miller passing, man. Sad, sad, sad, sad, sad. My goat car with a big win over Georgia Tech Thursday night. Brandon, that was fun. That was fun. Um, I know. I know he is. Antonio, what do you think of Trump renaming New Mexico New America? Don't love it. Uh, Shantella, what's up? Um, what do you mean young ones make me feel old, too? Just turned 20. Oh, there you go, Brandy. I am 10 years older than you are, Diamond. There you go. Uh, what I do for Labor Day? Yeah, Labor Day was I didn't do anything yesterday. I just cleaned the house, cleaned my room. Uh, got the house in order. It's best restaurant in your opinion to eat in LA and West Hollywood. I do not eat at West Hollywood ever, so I couldn't tell you. Um, Tony, there you go. How many hats do I own? Too many, big mouth. Too many. Who's your favorite football team? Philadelphia Eagles, baby. Go birds. Um, you that's probably that's not true. That is not true. Is everyone in the chat getting those AARP magazines like me? I haven't even subscribed. I just get them. Free Durk. Okay. Yep. Brit Mack indeed. >> I guess the Angels got eliminated yesterday, so I guess everyone was right about them not making the playoffs. Jeremy. Yeah, they're pretty bad. Um, Mmore the rapper died. Brandy, I doubt it. Um, 30 years since Tupac. Jesus, man. Everything is happening today, huh? Um, there's a New Mexico. Yeah, there is a New Mexico. Just heard about the new Flyers Sixers Arena. What's wrong with the Wells Fargo Center? I don't know, Carlton. I don't know. I did see that though. I mean, probably just a little bit older. Everyone's getting like the Eagles will probably get a new stadium next little while. [snorts] Um, reminds me of the movie Obsession. There you go. Um, I you I got you. I will try and add you after this. All right, guys. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Not anti-West Hollywood. They are fine with me. Nobody's saying we're anti-West Hollywood. Guys, what are you um I was saying I don't eat up there. Um cuz I live uh in the south. I don't think that's true. He did like the tacos. That's true. Brandon, happy for Philly, but go Chiefs. Kronky. Okay. No qualms with you, man. Miss Princess, what's up? What up? What up? What up? New scary movie is Goatated. Is it good? I haven't watched it. Um, we were on a little horror movie kick with my roommates this weekend, though, and that was fun. Um, renamed New Jersey in New York. Okay, Robert. There you go. Can you cook, Terrace? I can cook. Um, so can you. Anybody can cook. Uh, who is Cody Rhodes? He is a wrestler. He's a wrestler. I know, Antonio. That's probably true. New stadium built. How old is the current stadium? New stadium is like 20 something years old, I think, or a little bit less. But I'm not saying they are getting a new stadium. I'm just saying they probably will uh in the next like 10 years. Los Angeles is New Mexico. No, not true. Um Brandon, if you ever see Aiden, if you tell him I said hello and we miss him. I know. I will. I absolutely will, Brandon. Um Trump said America owns the moon. I mean, we were the first ones. We're the first ones there. So, if that's anything to do with it. Uh, unless you don't believe that, of course. Um, yeah. Do you guys believe in that conspiracy theory? Um, I want to see Coyote versus Acme. Christina, I heard it's very good. I heard it's very good. Well, I heard it is doing very well. I'm not 100% sure. Um, I'm not 100% sure uh that I'm not 100% I am not a Oh my goodness. I'm not 100% sure if the movie is good or not, but um I think it'll be fine. Let's see, guys. Let us see. Um uh how long did I live in Italy? In what city, David? I lived in Lucca and I was there for about nine months. A pro at Crock-Pot Cooking, Brandy, that's true. I do get down with the Crockpot. I haven't done that in a while, though. I should do that. Um 20 I know Carlton it's not very old but I think they were talking about it. Um let's see. Brandon, you were talking about horror movies as a kid. My favorite horror movie was Nightmare on Elm Street. Dude, I did not like Nightmare on Elm Street because I lived on Elm Street when I was a kid and that always like freaked me out. Um they never went to the moon, Justin. Okay, so there you go. Um I cook. Are you hungry, babe? Okay. Everyone can't cook, Terrace. Untrue. You ever seen Ratatouille? Everyone can cook. Anyone can cook. Uh, scary movies aren't horror. They're comedy. It's parody movies. Jeremy, that's not true. Uh, no yawning at work, guys. I'm sorry. Sorry. Oh, the lovely moon landing Stanley Kubrick. Okay. It'll be fun defending the moon from invasion. Sure. I need smelling salts. Smelling salts. Yeah, those are fun. Uh, the moon don't exist. Okay, so now we're just going straight up. That doesn't exist. Okay. You think Elvis faked his death and is alive, Jeremy? No, not really. But tomorrow is Colonel Sanders's birthday. I miss [laughter] him. Okay. >> I lived inside myself. I >> like what's You guys are waking up wild on a Tuesday, man. You guys are waking up wild, man. >> Um >> Ratatouille. Black Beauty. Exactly. Ratatouille. Did you know um Antonio, I did not know that. Uh Castiron Skillet Meals. Chucky was and still was my favorite horror film from when I was a kid. I'm 29 now. There you go. >> There you go. >> I don't I don't think I have like a favorite killer slasher person. I do like Freddy Krueger, though. Now, now in hindsight, I do. Titans getting a new stadium next year. I know, Carlton. Uh they don't really deserve it, but uh the moon is made of cheese. Okay, there's actually a street in Detroit called Ugly Street. I guess that must be a street made for ugly people. Okay, I'm not mad at that logic. Salem's Lot 1979 is a film that terrified me as a kid. Fair. Uh, the Pinhead movie is freaking scary. What good movies have you seen lately? Good movies have I seen I saw some movie I really the Anthony Bourdain biopic Tony um is really good. Um, already on both. Oh my gosh, guys are going you guys are just going crazy in the chat, I guess. I mean, hey, do you K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K KFC used to taste good. You don't think the uh herbs and spices hit the salmon anymore? T-shirt woman. That's contagious. Stop, please. And thanks. Apologize. Espresso for me. That'd be great. Our situation in this country is my living version of a horror film. Yeah, fair enough. Big mouth. I just had lunch, Diamond, but thanks. You guys are like, okay, flirting it up. I love it. Uh good morning, Christa. Good morning. Now thinking of it, you look like the brother of the girl in Obsession. I'll take that. Uh, I was asking Nate. Oh, I see. Diamond. My bad. >> Um, Saw movies are creepy. Yeah, >> it's like murder porn is what the Saw movies are. Uh, Nissan Stadium isn't even that old. Opened in 1999. Nissan Stadium. Carlton. What stadium is that? Not sure. Um, I thought I saw him walk by. Not sure. LJ, uh, are you talking about Harve? Harve is just up now. He's up and moving. Random Tuesday. Exactly. I haven't had KFC in forever. Probably still tastes the same. Probably watch Hocus Pocus on Halloween. There you go. All right, guys. Last Yawn of the Day. Uh, Harvey's getting up and moving, guys. So, we are going to start getting ready.
>> Ask him what he wants for lunch. >> Uh, Harvey. >> Yep. >> Do you have anything you're thinking for lunch? >> This has been a rough morning. >> Could save it with a good lunch. >> Uh, either a chicken sandwich or a tuna salad sandwich. >> Could I get a poll for tuna salad sandwich or a chicken sandwich, please? Thank you. You hanging in there? >> Uh, yeah. It's been a rough morning. >> Hey, well, the chat's wishing you well, saying it's going to be okay today. >> They're doing good. They're all just talking about their weekends, their Labor Day weekends. Um, >> you know what you guys have got to watch? Seriously. >> What's that? We [snorts] did a documentary like three or four years ago called 9/11, >> the fifth plane. >> Yeah. >> And it is I just watched it again yesterday because we're going to start promoting it for Friday because Friday is the 25th anniversary. >> It's a I'm so proud of this one. It's really >> That's the one you said is your favorite. Yeah, I think it's my favorite documentary and it's really compelling. There was a fifth plane >> and >> um when you watch it, it's on YouTube. Um it's called 9/11: The Fifth Plane. When you watch it, you will absolutely walk away saying there was a fifth plane. >> Um >> the chat's asking right now how your weekend was. >> It was good. >> Do you do anything interesting? >> Um Yeah. >> Yeah. You don't want to tell the chat. >> No, I just had an interesting dinner with somebody on Saturday. >> Okay. >> And yesterday I had dinner with um or lunch with this guy who used to kind of be a general manager here and we hadn't seen each other in a while and he's great. >> Oh, there you go. >> He's a real mover. Oh, that's awesome. >> He's created these really interesting businesses. He's a great guy. >> Uh Luther Hansen in the chat saying that they've seen the documentary and that it was awesome. >> Yeah. >> Kelly Smith also that I've seen it. >> Bring up that documentary. Did you watch the 9/11 Netflix? I know you've been watching a lot of Netflix documentaries and I was wondering if that made you think of it because it was really good on Netflix. >> No, it's not what made me think of it. I did see the Netflix one. Can't remember. Now I want to watch yours. >> You know what I watched yesterday? I watched an old 60 Minutes piece >> on this black couple that >> um not a couple, brother and sister. >> And they bought a house that they had always been looking at as kids. >> Yeah. >> Um in their neighborhood. >> And they bought it because they had always been looking at it. And the sister told the brother, 'Oh, you got to buy this house. It's up on the market. It's for sale.' And he bought it for $220,000. And it's 10 acres. And when they bought it, they found this area in the back in the woodsy area. >> It was slave quarters. >> Oh. >> And they started doing these family tree things. And it turned out that their great-great relatives, grandfathers, etc. were slaves on that property that they now own. >> Oh wow. >> And it was fascinating. >> That is crazy. It was fascinating. >> Uh yeah, >> he forgot to find something better. >> Okay. >> Okay. Let's get that out of the way so that we can do Market 11. Jeffy B saying that's a big comment. Another plane. I'm definitely intrigued and will be watching. Thanks for giving us the heads up. >> It's really interesting. >> What's [clears throat] it called one more time? >> Uh 9/11: The Fifth Plane. Who is doing this? >> Becker. He's coming out. >> What is this? >> Uh Lindsay Clancy. Her lawyer is asking for a pardon. >> Okay, guys. >> Trump to pardon. Where is Lindsay Clancy? Lawyers asking for a pardon. Any um >> Where is I don't have here the woman who hung her son. >> Why are there no notes? >> You're going to Brendan's desk. >> Can anybody hear me? Can somebody talk to me? >> Does he have a microphone? >> I also can't hear anybody. >> There we go. or whatever. >> Remember you said you were going to use what I did in the lowdown. >> We don't have any information or name, what happened, when it happened. >> Okay. >> Um I talked to the girl, the old miss girls. >> Okay. Um yeah, guys. So we are going to be talking Lindsay Clancy right now. Um lawyer to Trump. Okay. Asking Trump to pardon Lindsay Clancy. Um I know you guys have a lot of thoughts about this story in general. Um whether or not it's about this in particular or not. Lindsay Clancy Trump lawyer asking for pardon. Um so if you guys have any thoughts, questions, critiques, criticisms, whatnot, etc., etc., um please let us know. you watched what I did. >> Um, but yeah, that'd be awesome. Um, yeah, Reed Dornney, I can't believe he asked Trump for a pardon. What makes him think Trump would get involved? The fact that he gets involved with other similar things, not similar things, but other things of this nature. So, um, uh, needs to look up a constants fish. There you go. I know you're clancied out, black people. This is a crazy thing. So, guys, do me a favor. Don't be clancied out and it's gonna be a-ok. Okay. And you can be included. Guys, on a side note, I think Madison is upset at me because I didn't play pool with her and I think she's upset. >> I was We were going to be teammates. Yeah, the same. We actually would have won is [laughter] the thing. >> You guys talk about the Western Michigan game. >> No, that was crazy. >> Robbed. Robbery. Let's not talk about it before we get started. I don't want the comments to You can just stay here. It's fine. >> Okay, let's get this done so that we can do We have Mark at 11. Um, this should be a single shot. >> Okay, here we go.
Welcome to TMZ Live. Uh, Charles is off today. We'll be back tomorrow. Uh, the Lindsay Clancy case. So, her lawyer, Kevin Reddington, is it Reddington? >> Okay, we'll do it again. Here we go. Welcome to TMZ Live. Uh, Charles is off today. He'll be back tomorrow. The Lindsay Clancy case. Kevin Reddington went on Good Morning America. He is, I think, an incredible lawyer. He is, you know, you can agree or disagree with his position on postpartum psychosis, but he undeniably is a great lawyer, which made what happened this morning on Good Morning America really surprising to me.
>> Who is >> What's next for Lindsay? I'd like to say that perhaps Donald Trump, who felt compelled to speak out about this case, may very well, Mr. President, I would hope that you would consider this young lady, [snorts] the type of person she is, what she's been through, and consider a pardon.
How on earth is Kevin Reddington saying this? This is a state trial, and Donald Trump does not have the power to pardon. And this guy is a great lawyer. >> Such a bizarre was bizarre. >> Unless he's trying to drum up a conversation in the public about >> He said pardon, but I know, but the governor of Massachusetts could, but >> that's not who he's asking about. >> It's just weird that this is as basic as it gets. >> As basic as it gets, right? >> And it's just an odd thing if he would have said, 'Hey, put some pressure on, you know, the governor of Massachusetts,' but Massachusetts is not Trump country. Right. Right. Right. >> So, it's like Donald Trump's not going to get any traction in Massachusetts. >> Had he said everybody from your local city council to the governor to the president of the United States should get involved in getting this woman to stop the prosecution, fine. But here he asked for a pardon. Specifically used those words.
Okay. I want to get to something else because this I found um it's just really interesting and tragic. Uh there is a woman named Corey Wells who lives there is a woman named Corey Walsh who lives in Illinois and on September 1st um she allegedly hung her 2-year-old son um while her husband was away on a business trip and then went into the bathroom, I believe, somewhere upstairs and cut herself. Um she was obsessed with the Lindsay Clancy case and had been texting a friend about it. And there are people now who are saying, 'You see what happens when defendants who kill their kids are allowed to raise this defense, they're going to be copycats.' And people are really going after Lindsay Clancy and her legal team for raising a defense which they say opened the door to people who are doing copycats.
It's not just raising the defense. It's also there's been a tremendous amount of public sympathy behind Lindsay Clancy. I think that there might be some statement that they're glomming on to that kind of popularity almost that people are getting the sympathy that they get publicly that might enable people or empower people to do what Corey Walsh did.
And that may be true by the way, but I want to make a point. Um this is opinion, but if Lindsay Clancy opened that door, um that's terrible that people would do something. And again, I have no idea what happened in the Illinois case whether this woman has postpartum psychosis. I don't know that anybody knows at this point. Um, and that remains to be seen if it isn't the case. And you know, she said that she felt her son was possessed by the devil. So, that may be the case. Um, and maybe she's making it up because she just wanted to get out of parenthood. I don't know. But that shouldn't delegitimize a real defense. If Lindsay Clancy really did suffer from postpartum psychosis and apparently 11 jurors believe that, um you can't say well she's not allowed to raise the defense because somebody else is going to do it illegitimately. Um, you know, we have a new show with the New York Post called The Lowdown. Um, which is on YouTube, and we have like eight stories that are making waves around the country. And one of them is this. And you know, the way I see it is there are people who kill somebody and they say it's done in self-defense. And sometimes it really is.
And there are also people who use self-defense illegitimately. Yeah. and you know to justify killing somebody.
But because there are people who do it in the wrong way doesn't mean the people who truly can exercise self-defense shouldn't be allowed to do it. And the same thing should exist for something like Lindsay Clancy for postpartum psychosis.
The one difference is, and I agree with you completely, but the one difference I think some people would draw is that nobody disputes self-defense is a real thing. That is a justification for killing somebody. But 11 people believed it was a real thing in Lindsay Clancy.
I understand that. But there are people who discount that defense altogether.
Well, there may. But 11 people listened to this evidence. And I think most people went into this trial thinking fry her. >> Yeah. >> I mean, she killed her three kids. Yet >> by listening to the evidence, 11 out of 12 people were compelled >> to voting not guilty by reason of insanity.
Right. The chat is wondering because we just saw what you're explaining, the 11 people voting for that. Are we worried that we're going to see more people doing copycat things and getting away with it?
But that's what we just said that there are people who are going to try this illegitimately. But that doesn't mean if you have a legitimate case, you can't raise it because you're afraid that somebody else is going to do something illegitimate.
There's two things that we're talking about. I think what Towanda is suggesting is that people might be inclined to commit the crime in the first place because they know this defense is available and that there's 11 people that they can get in a jury with 11 people that might also get them off as well.
Very hard to believe. There are people who commit murder thinking, 'Oh, I'll just say it's self-defense.' So, it's the same thing. I mean, people will use defenses inappropriately, but that doesn't mean when it really should apply that they shouldn't use it. And that's to me the case of Lindsay Clancy.
The chat also wants to know how do you decipher when this defense comes when it's good and when it's like not.
A jury does that. That's what a jury is for. And in this case, 11 out of 12 people said it was legit.
Hi, Iman here, trial attorney from New Jersey, and I just wanted to quickly comment on the Clancy case. We are all aware that the president spoke on this matter recently and basically implied guilt, saying that she did a horrible thing, which is particularly interesting because the laws in our country don't allow for that, right? We have a justice system and our justice system is innocent until proven guilty. So, number one, that to me is a little bit questionable, but I'm not the president, so whatever. Second, Reddington today got on Good Morning America and said, 'Well, since the president feels compelled to talk about my case, how about giving my client a pardon?' Which is so funny to me as a trial attorney because obviously the jurisdiction is an issue. Everybody knows that. And as a seasoned trial attorney, obviously he knows that. But then why do you say it? >> I mean, I think he said it to poke holes right back, you know? >> But he's not poking a hole. >> I mean, yes and no. We're not talking a hole, but if the president is saying that his client is guilty when she hasn't been found guilty through this system that we have.
Yeah. But you know what? A lot of people have opinions watching a case. Um, you know, look, I remember covering OJ Simpson. People didn't hold back saying either he was guilty or not guilty. It happens all the time and presidents do it, too. >> Yeah. People were also saying >> we're pretty sure it's not guilty by reason of insanity, but that's what >> uh Okay. Is Mark up? >> Yeah. Sorry, I didn't hear. >> Hey, how are you, Harvey? >> You're in um I know exactly where you are. >> Yes, you do. Do you know what this is right here? That looks like an award of some sort. It looks like a graduation thing. >> Correct. And from >> from Irvine. >> Yes. And do you know whose it is? >> One of my prized possessions. >> I >> transfer scar. It's Lyle's from when he graduated when he >> Oh, right. Right. I keep it there and it will remain there until he's out. >> We'll talk about that. >> Okay. >> Okay. We're ready to go. Was it Mark? It's March. >> Yeah. March of 2027. >> And it was supposed to be August of 28, right? >> Correct. Three years. >> Okay. Here we go.
So, Erik and Lyle Menendez are going to get another shot at freedom a lot sooner than we thought. Uh, there was a scheduled parole date of August 2028 where they could go before the parole board again uh and ask for their freedom. Um, that has been moved for some reason uh to March of next year. So, literally we are months away from round two of Erik and Lyle Menendez going before the California parole board um and you know seeking freedom. Um they failed the first time and their lawyer Mark Garagos was enraged and felt it was a kangaroo court. So the question why is it going to be different this time? So uh Mark is joining us. Welcome back, Mark, to TMZ Live.
Thanks, Harvey. Why? I'll jump right in. Yeah. Uh, normally they got what's called a three-year denial, which is the minimum denial. You come back, uh, behave yourself. This is what you should do if you want to be uh, released. You got to adhere to these kinds of recommendations, and you got to do some programming. If you are uh, clean, so to speak, and you do everything you're supposed to do, they have the authority to basically have that, and that's what they did. So, roughly 18 months out of the 36, they've got a new hearing in March of next year. I'm hopeful that um and I know you uh I'll convey that I know you don't think this is any chance of happening, but that maybe Gavin Newsom on the way out the door uh short circuits that. But notwithstanding that, there's always uh the uh parole hearing and I'm quite cautiously optimistic. So look what happened the first time was they started looking at infractions like cell phone violations things like that and they denied them parole. There's a saying in the Jewish religion uh Mah Nishtanah which means why is this night different from all the others? Why would this parole hearing be different uh if it seemed like they were not at all interested in granting parole? Well, one of the um Lyle was actually quite encouraging. Um and they have not had any violations and they've done all of the so-called programming and all of the other things you would need to do. They literally have been exemplary inmates.
And one of the things I just refreshed my recollection that I had kind of blanked on. You know, if you go through this process, I think the percentage of life without parole who've ended up being released, I think there's only one person who's ever reviolated. And I think percentagewise, out of all lifers in California, it's less than 1% that it's a violent act, and it's less than 3% of anybody. But a lot of them just don't get out to try and rec...
No, no, no. I'm talking of the people who get out.
But I'm saying there are a lot of people who apply who don't get out who might commit new crimes. Whether they commit new crimes or not. You were really angry when they were denied parole a few years ago and you felt it was a kangaroo court. You thought the deck was stacked going in. Is this going to be the same cast of characters on the parole board?
I think that they reshuffle the deck, so to speak. And I think that you'll see whoever the commissioners are. I think they've got a better shot this time because we're not in the same overheated atmosphere that we were last time. I think last time it was such a political football, so to speak, that this time I think if it goes according to what normally happens in parole hearings, this is their second shot, and if there's any justice at all, they should be granted.
Well, you mentioned Gavin Newsom. Next year is the windup to the pitch for 2028, and he's running for president, and I cannot imagine Gavin Newsom in this climate paroling or granting clemency to Eric and Lyle Menendez. He will be tarred and feathered soft on crime if that happens, and he clearly has presidential ambitions.
Well, that's true. And this hearing is, I guess, I suppose a cynic might say, conveniently two months after he's out of office if it's in March.
Well, clearly he's still out of office, meaning out of the governor. So he loses his ability to do anything.
Oh, right, right, right, right.
He doesn't have any ability, in fact.
Oh, so you're saying if Bucerra wins, then correct that you think you have a better shot than with Newsom.
Correct. And mind you, there's always this tail to any parole decision. The tail is the governor either does something or doesn't do something within, I believe it's 120 days. So that if Newsom does not and decides that I'm not going to do anything, and I don't know that I agree with you that his political calculation is I'm not going to do this because I'm going to get excoriated, he's got the ability to do what he thinks is the right thing. And the right thing at this point, I think, is that they get their sentences commuted.
That may or may not be the right thing. I just don't see that calculus. I don't see the calculus there. I just don't see it. Well, yes, the political calculus, if you're listening to some political strategist who's telling you why create an issue that's going to be...
Well, he's done some things that are kind of counterintuitive from the traditional conventional wisdom.
But the fact remains that both of them have been exemplary. Both of them have now spent over 20 years with no hope until they were re-sentenced by Judge Jeske last year. Both of them have not done anything, have any violence since then. The what I always call their violations were always, to use a chickism, ticky-tack fouls. And at this point, if they aren't the prototypes for who you would want released, I don't know who is.
Okay, real quick. The family of Celeste Rivas, who was allegedly murdered by David, he's on trial for murder, they said they want the death penalty. And the DA, Nathan Hochman, has not yet decided, but he says it's on the table. Is it realistic that Hochman is going to go for the death penalty?
Well, if he did, I mean realistic in this sense. The death penalty in California is basically, pun intended, dead on arrival. It hasn't been utilized since I think Tookie Williams, and that's decades ago. Number one. Number two, there is currently a moratorium signed by this current governor, Gavin Newsom, on the death penalty. I don't think in LA County that this is a winning move by Nathan Hochman ultimately, but it may be a smart strategic move because when you seek the death penalty, unfortunately, it weeds out a lot of jurors right off the bat. And a cynical person might say, 'Well, if you seek the death penalty, you're going to get a more prosecution jury pool.'
Which is interesting, and I get it. I think it matters. He's 20 years old.
I do too. And that's supposed to be the calculus. You and I are old enough to remember when they used to do what's called Livesy letters, which were named after Kurt Livesy, who was in the DA's office for many years. And Kurt Livesy used to take age into consideration. The committee that was named after him used to take age and lack of criminal background into consideration. The countervailing point to that is going to be that, look, she was young, she was vulnerable, she was homeless or runaway, and all of those things are aggravating factors, so to speak, when you're considering whether to impose the death penalty.
So, you and I do a podcast together every week called Two Angry Men. And there is something you say on Two Angry Men that you just said here. And I want to end by asking you, as somebody you know, who's known you for decades, can you stop saying 'you and I are old enough'? I'm just begging you to stop saying that, please.
I would lose one of the things I bond with Charles over. So, no, I'm not going to.
Okay. I'll see you later. Thanks.
Yeah, we can just, I mean, I did that so we can go show her a knee.
Yeah.
Okay. Come on over here.
Can you do a pickup? Can you come over here and talk to Luca for a quick second?
Yep.
And then you guys can just come back over here with Derek after.
Okay. What's up, Luke?
No, people are just kind of, everyone's still kind of also talking about the Lindsay Clancy thing. And this is kind of an interesting question. Gummy Worms asks, what happens if Lindsay gets out and she wants to have more babies or gets pregnant while she's in the hospital?
Well, you can make that argument about Casey Anthony, right?
I mean, Casey Anthony is free to have kids if she wants to. Yeah.
So, you don't think that there should be like any, like, I mean obviously...
Well, not that, I'm not saying, I'm not saying that.
Well, I don't know. That's just what the question that Gummy's asking is like, what if that does happen?
Like...
You bring up Casey Anthony. Do you think that she like is living a...
Like good life?
Huh?
You think Casey Anthony's living a good life?
Is she living a good life?
I don't know. I can't jump in her head.
Yeah. I don't think she's...
Christine's saying that I don't even know why we're questioning her guilt. I cannot believe watching the trial, seeing her sit there, seeing nothing wrong with her. She just had postpartum exhaustion like 80% of women.
Derek can come over here.
Well, again, explain how 11 cynical jurors, because most people feel the way you do, what you just said, and yet the jury that listened to the evidence seemed swayed by the evidence.
Yeah, and explain that you could have people going into the trial believing there is no excuse for what she did, yet 11 people were swayed to her side. How is that? How is that?
Yeah, that's the question.
Okay, we ready?
Yep.
Okay.
I just... I'm still...
Where is the, where are my notes? Oh, thank you.
Kerianne Parkinson.
Mom can.
We still come in though, right? He goes solo and then we come in. Okay.
Kerianne Parkinson.
Mic down.
Yeah.
Convicted of letting her 5-year-old walk alone near home. I'm still talking about Western Michigan getting robbed.
Well, for my sake, let's talk about a 5-year-old walk alone near your home.
Did you guys watch football this week?
Do you guys think that...
You can come up with a comment?
Yeah. Well, sometimes I'm not great at it today. After a long...
Well, produce.
Anyways, did you guys see that Western Michigan game? Cheaters.
Yeah, clock was zero.
Cheaters.
Clock was zero. Brandon's daughter's new college had a great game yesterday after a two-hour...
SMU.
Yeah, they won. Beat Florida State...
And a nailbiter. Yeah, it was down to the wire. Down to the wire. A lot of good games this weekend.
All right. Now...
College football still mid.
Yeah.
The game like...
I literally, I'm like, wait, come on, Florida State, you got to do better than this. My guy's like, Tallahassee...
Sam, you wouldn't have had that problem.
You would never, would never. They lost though, and then we got to play University of Miami this week, so oops, oops.
Yeah, now we're about to talk about this lady who let her 5-year-old son walk in the neighborhood, who knows the neighborhood perfectly fine, gated neighborhood community, and now she's being charged. Crazy.
Y'all know good and well, we used to always walk home to friends' houses and all that stuff. So, this is what that is.
I know.
Crazy that she's being convicted.
She's great.
Kind of similar to our dodgeball...
Virginia. Here we go.
Kerianne Parkinson, right?
Okay.
I am obsessed with this story. Kerianne Parkinson is a mother of five. She lives in Virginia and she is now a criminal. She was convicted of basically allowing her child to become a delinquent by letting the child roam a half a mile from their house to a nearby pond and roam there alone without parental supervision. They found the child walking to the pond. They brought the child back to the house. Kerianne said, 'Yeah, my son who's 5 years old is more than capable of doing this.' Children's services got involved. They ended up prosecuting her for contributing to the delinquency of a minor, and a judge convicted her.
And I just find this outrageous, but she was so eloquent in explaining on CNN why she did what she did. Listen to this, and then we're going to talk about it.
So Sam and I went for our morning walk that we always go on. And as we were coming home and going past the pond near our house, he was picking up goose feathers and sticking them in his backpack, and then he beat me home. And he was on his bike, and so he dashed into the garage, put his bike away, and as I was walking up to the house, he walked out to me and asked if he could go back to get more. And I kind of thought for a second, I'm like, oh yeah, we just did that walk, I know where he's going, and I said, sure, I'm going to go make lunch, you go there and come right back. And so he went, and then about 20 minutes later, I had a security guard at my front door with my son with wide eyes and a scared look on his face. Workers showed up, and my husband got home from lunch and was talking to them, and they were just insisting a 5-year-old can absolutely never be alone under any circumstances. He has made this walk hundreds of times, and suddenly it was a crime, and I'm a child abuser on a child abuse registry. I have five children. When my third was five, I wouldn't have let her do that same activity because she wasn't ready for that. Everyone should look at their own children and determine what they think is right for their kids. But what we shouldn't do is criminalize people who do know their children and do know what they're capable of and allow them to explore those capabilities.
Okay. Before we go on, the last bite, you had three bites there. The last one when she talks about her 5-year-old, we keep that, but she doesn't need to explain the whole thing. What she needs to say is what she said on CNN. You start with her saying, 'My five-year-old son is more than capable of doing this. Kids are different, and this kid knew how to do this. There was no danger in the neighborhood.' Then she can mention her daughter who isn't capable. But kill the first two things completely. And then put in where she talks about the kid having the knowledge and the wherewithal to walk alone. That's the key to this. Okay. Okay. Coming out of the sound. So, did...
I heard it? Okay, you heard it.
Yeah.
This is exactly...
What you've been talking about.
This is exactly what we've been talking about in our morning meetings.
I want to push back a little bit though. This is a five-year-old child.
I was six, I was 6 years old and I would walk to the movies alone.
The world is a different place now. It's a much more dangerous place in a lot of respects. It's a 5-year-old child. The reason...
I would argue in the world, I would argue it's a safer place in a way. In some respects, it's safer. But leaving a 5-year-old that you have come to the judgment is okay to go collect goose feathers down by the pond is not how we should regulate society in general. I mean, she has come to the judgment. Imagine something bad had happened and she said, 'Well, I thought the kid was okay.' We would never have a crime in these circumstances.
In her neighborhood. It's in her neighborhood. The kid's walking to a pond in her neighborhood.
And abductions are possible. This is a 5-year-old. I don't care how mature. I have a seven-year-old I wouldn't let wander down to the park.
The abduction rate, as she talked about this, that it's virtually non-existent. Okay, it's virtually non-existent. So, she as a parent chooses to allow her child to walk to a pond, and she said, 'I wouldn't do it with all of my kids. I wouldn't do it with my daughter because she's not really able, but I can look at each kid.' And by the way...
So how do we regulate this then? I mean, this is a 5-year-old child. She's always going to come to the judgment that I thought it was okay for this child and something happens. You need to have a criminal sanction for this type of behavior. And you draw it in broad strokes. Letting your child walk down to the pond.
Oh my God. Letting a child walk down to the pond.
It sounds innocuous, but...
Well, our chat is saying like half, it's pretty split, but half of them is saying that even in a gated community, there's no way that they know every single person and that you can say that they can just feel safe. You're not... risky behavior to allow your...
You are going to hermetically seal your child for what, 18 years, and then good luck with this kid being on his own. You know where he is.
You're undoubtedly right that this will harm some kid's ability to be resilient in the future. It'll also save a lot of kids from abduction potentially.
There was literally no risk of abduction in this neighborhood. She talked about this. There were no abductions in this neighborhood. I know you wandered to the movie theater, but a 5-year-old is a little kid. They are kindergarteners, Harvey. They're not even in grade level.
Some people in the group chat do agree with Harvey.
They should. They do. I think so. Well, okay. Well, somebody's saying that this is honestly crazy. We have people getting away with murder, and yet they're wasting time prosecuting moms for their kids. This woman is a... By the way, she's a lawyer now too. She has five kids. She's a lawyer. She's really smart. She is thoughtful. She's a good parent, and she's a criminal contributing to the delinquency of a five-year-old that was walking to a pond.
The criminal sanction seems stiff for her to be on a list, and she's on a CPS list for seven years.
It's unimaginable to me and to many people in this office who have children to let your child wander to a pond unattended.
Wander is crazy. Wander is crazy. That's like a kid riding a bike and then going down the street and his parents can't see him anymore. And now we're saying that he'd wander off.
That's exactly the same. That's exactly the same. He went to the cul-de-sac and went back up, but you can't see him through.
It's exactly the same. Now, people don't do that anymore.
The world you grew up in, with the homemakers and the whole thing, is not the world we live in. Everybody...
Hi, my name is Victor. I'm from Trenton, New Jersey. And I just think that the matter is not on if the child is capable or not. I just think that it's the environment. Like you have to protect your children, and you never know who is going to do what. I understand that they were in a gated community, but there can be abductors in that community even though...
That's fine. But even if it's a gated community, you could have a neighbor who just moved in there that could be crazy and could kidnap your child. Do I think that's true?
But it didn't happen in the neighborhood ever. She talked about that. That's never happened.
Time and god forbid. I understand her thought process behind it. I understand why she did what she did. Was she doing it with ill intent? Absolutely not. But you never know what's going to happen, and god forbid someone snatches your child.
What's the magic age? 18 when they can walk alone. What's the magic age where they can walk alone?
No, I don't think... I think that the magic age should be when they're able to, you know, run away or if they have a cell phone or something like that. I think that they should always be together. Like growing up, when I would go out in the neighborhood with my little siblings, my cousins, we would always be together and we would be in close proximity so that if anything were able to happen, we would be able to go back home or we would be able to call. I don't think that he should have been alone at 5 years old. And especially if she's picking and choosing which child can go alone, I don't think that that's proper. And I think that that can cause your child to be kidnapped, and you never know what happens in this world. You have to protect your children. Do I think she should be convicted? I think that it's a stretch. I think that there's a lot worse things going on in the world. But I think that she should use it as a learning opportunity rather than doubling down because it's only worse.
Oh my god. A learning opportunity. The kid's walking to a pond. Boy, my parents would be in such trouble.
A few... make that D. A few talking points, Harvey.
What if the kid fell in the pond?
Someone said, 'What if the kid fell in a pond?' Or...
'Oh my god...
An animal got him.'
In a gated...
Florida, there's a lot of alligators in gated communities in Florida. What?
It was Illinois.
Okay.
It was Illinois.
Now, on your hand, now what about the people like...
No gators. Illinois.
Five is too young. As if every house in these neighborhoods don't have Ring cameras. Ring cameras are all throughout the neighborhood. Surveillance is everywhere. So if the kid's walking, he's going to be caught on every single person.
At a point, it's like, can a kid play hide-and-seek with their friends without the parents being there?
You can't even ride a bike legit. Like if you ride a bike, you're only like for 30 feet because you can't see three houses down. So then what? They're...
So I can't ride my bike to school anymore. So you definitely can't ride your bike.
I think nobody will tell us.
Five to...
Where would you not get in trouble? Well, somebody, Kate Perry was saying because you made the point where it's like it's a gated community where no abductions ever happened before. Most places where a kid gets abducted, an abduction has never happened before. You know, it's like...
An abduction never happened in this community.
Have you seen a 5-year-old recently? Yeah.
Have you seen how big they are? They're much smaller than you. They come up to your like waist.
What does that have to do with anything?
They're tiny, vulnerable individuals who need protection at all times. Period. You don't have to put them in a marshmallow, but you can't let them wander alone at a pond. It's insanity.
Would you let your kid ride a bike?
Well, Carter's not great on the bike, but like...
Would I let him ride a bike? Yes, I ride a bike with him and we go in the busy streets and I watch him like a hawk. I would never let Carter just toot around La Cienega. Never.
Are you eight years old? And by the way, first of all, you don't live anywhere near La Cienega.
Okay. I don't want to get where I live, but Pico.
I know where you live.
I know where you live. You don't live near Pico either.
You can't get outside of that. You hate...
You don't live anywhere near Pico.
You don't live near Pico?
Yeah. About two miles south of Pico.
Derek, do you know your neighbors?
Yes. And we have a neighbor who is two blocks away. And just now my fifth grade daughter, last year when she was fourth grade and very mature, I let her go to the house and we stood outside and she's watching.
No, no, no, they live two blocks.
Good luck for kids who turn 18, but you know your neighbor and have never...
That's not how it...
Isn't going out for the first time when they're 18 though.
World's safer now.
Because there's no more Charlie Manson and stuff like that, but it's unsafe. There were no laws against... I mean, there was...
In the 80s there were a bunch of abductions, right? Adam Walsh, the whole thing, that was dangerous, right? And so now that we don't allow kids to just wander around the supermarket, they don't get abducted as much. So yes, it's safer because of the way we acted, the way we responded to milk cartons.
So if you want to send a kid to the grocery store, and maybe you should go with him. Loves picking up his own snacks, like this kid with the goose feathers.
Can a kid go two blocks to their friend's house?
That part and the neighborhood that you know, not at five. Not at five.
Cannot go two blocks to a friend's house.
Yeah. They're like, they're laughing.
Five is way too little.
This is messed up.
This is messed up.
She had a very mature...
No, 5-year-old's like, that's like my little cousin. I'm like, I wouldn't like... But my goddaughter is smart as hell. Like she would know how to make it and not walk.
The fact that somebody can just do this and then walk away.
8-year-old you're talking now. That's like Nixie's walk.
What about an 8-year-old who's short?
What about... I'm serious. What about an 8-year-old?
Were you allowed at five? I have a question. Were you allowed to walk around at the age of five?
All the time.
I played hide and seek with my parents. Nobody... no, there were no... kids played outside back in the day.
Yes. This was the 50s, guys. The dawn of America, Great War. And it was great. I would run inside to ask my mom for money if the bakery truck came.
Yes. There were still milkmen who came to the house and brought you jars. This is a different world, man.
Daria, can we drop a milk...
Yeah, the milkman...
Problematic.
Five too young.
I know.
Is five too young to walk by yourself?
Kids started looking like a milkman.
You think we don't have milk anymore?
Harvey, where do you want the sandwich from?
Um...
California Chicken Cafe. Two breasts.
Have a 5-year-old pick it up.
I will say, I will say majority of the chat does not agree.
Yeah, they do not agree. When I was 6 years old, I walked... Oh, speaking of Pico...
Yo, speaking of Pico...
I lived on Spalding...
And I walked to Pico and I went to the theater there and saw The Blob by myself.
You do. You crossed Pico and went to a movie theater...
Went to Fairfax and then took it down to the movie theater and came back.
In today's day and age, your parents would have been arrested.
Stop resisting, Mr. Levin. They would have opened up.