Welcome back to the Hardware Unboxed question and answer series for October.
That is exactly what it is. It is the question and answer series.
It is indeed. Yes. Part three, because we've already done two parts. Like to keep them about half an hour long. You can, well, should I say, go check them out. Probably just watch the rest of this video, if I'm honest, and then go check the other parts out.
We're going to be talking about some cool stuff. More of your questions that you've asked us via Discord and our YouTube community tab.
Just wanted to address that I'm still alive. Tim hasn't offed me yet.
Steve, well, there was never me going to murder you. It was more that your recent illnesses and you just dropped dead. Anyway,
Seemed like that was insinuated. I'll leave it up to the viewers to decide whether or not you insinuated that that was on the table for me at the end of part two.
Anyway, let's get into part three after this. Today's sponsor spot is brought to you by Thermal Grizzly and their Wire View Pro 2. The best way to safeguard your 12V high-powered connector from melting. This little device plugs in between your graphics card's power connector and the power supply's cable to measure current, voltage, temperatures, and the power of each individual pin. It has a built-in display with configurable views for per-pin current, total power, and temperature, plus audible and visual alarms if thresholds are exceeded. The CNC machined aluminium body includes a semi-passive fan for cooling, automatic data logging, and optional automatic system shutdown via the included splitter cable for extra safety. Thermal Grizzly are so confident that the Wire View Pro 2 will keep your graphics card safe that they're backing the product with an extended warranty covering the GPU connector for two years. That is a crazy level of support. So, for more information, please check the link in the video description. All right, Tim.
Unlike GTA 6, I'm still very much here.
It is coming though, finally. [laughter]
Which, my execution or the game?
Yeah, both. Still feeling threatened, everyone. Um, do you think GTA 6 will be the best optimized game of this generation? And do you think gamers will call it unoptimized anyway? I think my simple answer to that is yes and yes.
Everything's unoptimized. Um, I mean, I've seen the footage of what they're attempting to do on like a base PS5. It looks very impressive. I don't know what frame rate it's going to run at at the end of the day. I think the footage they've shown looks to be 30 FPS, but definitely 30 most.
Yeah. Which, but even the visuals that they're targeting on what is ultimately like, what is the PS5, like an RX 6700 type performance or something like that, it's pretty outdated.
Yeah. I mean, I'm by no means a console expert, as you know. I haven't used one in a very long time, but I have used that particular GPU. And the visuals I saw in that trailer, if it was running at 15 FPS, I would probably still be impressed.
Yeah, it looks pretty incredible on what is, yeah, five-year-old, six-year-old hardware. Um, yeah, the visuals that I saw that I would have thought would be more like PS5 Pro type of stuff, which is a more powerful GPU equivalent of today. Of course, what it looks like on the PS5 is not necessarily what it's going to look like when it comes to PC or how it will run on PC, because whenever Rockstar Games has ported their games from console to PC, they tend to add a lot of visual effects and visual features because it's not just released at the same time. So, historically, what we've seen with like GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2, the sort of two most recent games, um, they've added in a whole bunch of like beyond console stuff. So, if you did crank up to the highest levels, it's probably, it probably will have people saying that it's unoptimized just for that reason of people just going, 'Let's, let's get this on max settings or whatever, and it'll run in a sort of different way.' Um, but if they can get it running how, like if they can get it looking how it looks on that PS5 footage on PC hardware, it'll look amazing and it will run super well for the visuals on a lot of hardware, mainstream hardware that people have. I think the big issue will be if they're locking it to, and we don't know the performance just yet, but if they are locking it to 30 FPS on consoles, that to me suggests a CPU limitation as opposed to a GPU limitation. And so there will be problems, uh, with people's CPUs basically, because most console games that we see today are 60 FPS and the ones that aren't usually run very bad in terms of CPU performance on PC. So again, I think in the previous podcast I brought up The Blood of Dawnwalker. That was a game that was supposed to launch only with 30 and 40 FPS modes on consoles. They did eventually release a 60 FPS mode at launch because the feedback was so negative to having the 30 and 40 FPS modes, but that game does not run particularly well on CPUs on PCs. So, if GTA 6 is 30 FPS because of CPU performance, then it's unlikely you'll get it running at like very high frame rates, um, which will be disappointing.
I think that has been the case. The previous couple of Rockstar games have been quite CPU intensive. Like GTA 5 when it launched on PC was pretty hard on the CPU. Mhm.
Um, Red Dead Redemption 2 from memory was, in some areas, quite taxing. Um, but then again, like the visuals that they're going for look truly next generation, I would say. Yep. Um, they look very, very impressive. So we'll just wait for the PC version. I guess you're not a console... Would you even play, if it came to PC on November 19 or whenever it launches, would you play it or is it not on PC?
Yeah, I'll definitely give it a go for sure. I don't know if I'd play the whole thing, but a lot of those games I do play a bit of.
Okay. Yeah, I just wasn't sure as you're, you know, a big Fortnite fan whether it could pry you away from the old Fortnite or not. But yeah, well, it depends on how busy I am, to be honest, how much gaming time I have available. But yep, I'm sure it's one I'll look at quite closely. Well, when it comes to PC, I'm sure you'll see more content from us. But for now, let's get to the next question.
One here from our Discord community. How do you decide what to make a video on? I was actually hoping you would have some ideas for us. That would be nice. And well, to be fair, the Discord community comes up with a good amount of our videos. So, yeah, they do. Um, does that answer the question? And do you have any ideas?
Well, a lot of the content that we make is related to things that are currently happening. So, if there's like obviously new hardware, fairly straightforward. We don't have to really come up with too much there. We just test the new hardware, right? New features, same sort of thing. The new features are released, we make the content. But then there's obviously a lot of things that come out that are sort of hot topic type stuff, like you recently did that whole 5090 versus 9070 XT thing, which was predicated on a different video that was sort of looking at that, and so you gave your take on it. And a lot of the content ends up being that sort of stuff. Like, yeah, I'm working on a video looking at like frame generation on older Nvidia GPUs because the recent mods have allowed that, and so that's why that video is getting made. It's because it's sort of the thing that's happening right now. Um, and you'll round up. Do you just do like the head-to-heads just because like it's time to update them or?
Yeah. Um, yeah, sometimes it's based on, you know, I've just finished doing the 7900 XTX versus 9070 XT because a lot of people wanted to see that update. So that'll be available on the channel in the next week or so. Um, so yeah, just finished working on that, or pretty much finished anyway. Um, so yeah, that really again, it can be requests, I think it's time to do it because I haven't done it in a long time, I'm personally interested, you know, there's no real, you know, individual reason for why we do any of the things we do really. It just, yeah, is it product releases, requests, interest, all that sort of stuff. So yeah, I think we tend to steer clear of stuff that we're not super interested in. Um, you know, for example, you haven't done a lot of like frame generation benchmarking, for example.
I do like frame gen though. It's a passion of mine.
Um, but yeah, like there's other channels that obviously are more equipped to cover things that they're passionate about in those areas that we just don't really cover. So, for example, like I wasn't super interested in the DLSS 5 mods, so I didn't really look into it all that much because if you've just got someone that's not passionate about a technology making a video, the video tends to be pretty bad. Um, you know, it's just like low energy, low effort. You know, that is the annoying thing about the tech channel because people think like we absolutely have to cover these technologies or, you know, we're doing Nvidia a disservice or whatever, but I feel like you're doing your audience a disservice if you're covering a technology that you're not interested in or just don't feel like doing it. Um, so yeah, it just makes bad content, especially because if the idea was like we have to be fair to Nvidia by covering let's say DLSS frame generation, but then you don't end up, you know, you're not that enthused about it, it's just kind of meh, like whatever, and that comes across in the video. But then other people that are more passionate have genuinely good reasons as to why it's like worth using or whatever. And then it's sort of, are you genuinely being sort of fair, or should people just, who, you know, if you are mildly interested in the feature, go look at someone who is interested in it to get your opinions about it from? I feel like that's sort of a better way to approach those sorts of things. Um, you know, like people always ask me like, 'Oh, I should be looking at like Nvidia Reflex more or like how that goes in games.' I'm like, 'Well, it's mainly a multiplayer feature. Obviously it does have some benefits for single player games, but it's not something I'm hugely passionate about.' And I actually, I think it was at CES a couple of years ago, they had like a Reflex demo. Um, I blind tested it on and off and I couldn't tell the difference. And so, you know, am I the best person to test that feature if I can't actually tell when it changes like a game from 15 to 8 milliseconds or whatever it was of latency? Probably not the best person to test that feature. Leave that to people where they're more sensitive to that sort of thing. Um, yeah, I mean you just can't be everything. You're a human. So some people want you to be everything and think that you're biased or whatever because you can't be everything. But yeah, it's why I found game reviews unattractive because, you know, you could review a genre of games, but that makes you sort of a selective, you know, you review, you know, a narrow selection of games, which I think is probably the way to go about it really because, you know, how many people play a huge range of games very competently? I'm not sure. Maybe serious gamers. I don't know. Even there's so many games that are being released that there's still people that would have like sections of things that they obviously just play like FIFA or FC Sports, whatever it's called now, or like NBA and those sort of games I couldn't imagine testing. I did test NBA for DLSS, but I can't imagine reviewing that sort of game.
Yeah. I mean, we're just regular people. We have preferences for things, but we make those preferences known. If they align with yours, so be it. They don't, you know, like neither of us are that enthused about frame generation. Haven't been since day one. Pretty much just think it's a frame smoothing technology that can be useful, but you know, we're not super excited about it and must have and use it and everything. And probably, um, what took the sting out of it for us is that we knew it was going to be weaponized and used as something to take advantage of gamers and mislead them. So yeah, that does bring the excitement out of things when you have to talk about that stuff in the video as opposed to just making it look at this cool thing and people can use it. So yeah, that always, um, but I think our opinions and takes on these sort of things align with the audience at large for the most part. Like I think, I don't think there's been too, I can't think of anything where we've had an opinion and most people disagree with it.
Yeah, that's right. I mean there's obviously things that are divisive in some ways, like there are people that absolutely love ray tracing and we're a bit cooler on that feature. But then if you're talking about like something where we are definitely in the minority, um, I'm not sure that I feel like between the two of us it's probably somewhere in the middle most of the time in terms of like where gamers are at in a lot of things.
Yep. Because like, you know, the VRAM thing, we want to see, you know, graphics cards come with more VRAM because it allows game developers to do more, it improves games overall, it's better. But we're certainly not saying you can't game on an 8 GB VRAM graphics card. Like we've never said that. We've made it very clear that the vast majority of games work on 8 GB cards. And we've, it's like when we have an opinion on a thing, it doesn't just mean one certain thing. It's like, again, very nuanced. Same thing with the platform support, you know, it's a feature we want to see, we think it should be a feature that all platforms should have, but if you don't have it, it's not instantly a deal breaker because there are other things that can make up for that. So anyway, all right.
How well have the Nvidia 3000, so like the GeForce 30 series, and the AMD 7000 series GPUs aged? How have they aged? I'd say they've aged better than possibly expected because of the stagnation, especially like the affordable GPU stagnation. I think it's been pretty serious.
Yeah. Like there was a risk maybe one or two years ago that 8 GB cards would very quickly just die almost immediately, or like within a very short period of time you'd see the vast majority of newer titles being completely unusable on those cards.
And they should have been.
Yes. I mean now you just get the sort of like low-quality settings, let's nerf everything so it runs on 8 GB GPU sort of thing because developers have to do that otherwise their game doesn't run on most people's GPUs.
Um, you know, things like the 3000 series, RTX 3000, I'd say that has, I think Nvidia's done a better than expected job of supporting features on those cards. There are obviously question marks at the moment about things like frame generation not being supported on that card when it can run. Um, so you know, a few questions you have to throw to Nvidia on that one. But in terms of things like the latest DLSS features, you know, would I have expected much more significant and advanced DLSS models to run on a 30 series card? Probably not. So, the fact that they've continued to support what I think is the most crucial DLSS feature on cards as far back as the 20 series has made those cards last pretty well, as opposed to just restricting like DLSS 4.5 upscaling to the 50 series. You can actually get that running on the old cards. It doesn't run as fast as you might see on the newer model on the newer GPUs, but the fact that they support that I think is pretty good. Um, and that's also the case with things like Ray Reconstruction, also works on those cards. So, that level of support I think's been good. Um, AMD probably not so much on the feature side. They were kind of dragged kicking and screaming to support FSR 4 on those models. Um, you know, they claimed that they're always going to support it or whatever, or you know, we were working hard to make that feature work. I think exposing them and making it clear that it could be done might have dragged them into line a bit on that one. Um, but the fact that it does work I guess has made those cards more attractive. But where they're talking about the 6000 series, which currently doesn't support FSR 4.1.
Yeah. Yeah. I think if you think about a GPU like the RTX 3080, I think people would look back on that much more fondly. I'm not talking about 3080 Ti, 3080, if it had 12 GB of VRAM, I think it would have been much more useful for a lot of, you know, the newer technologies and utilizing them. So, I think that card would have aged a bit better. Of course, they did launch at an awkward time as well. So, I guess that's what killed that series largely, because they would launch, I think they launched and then shortly after that everything went to hell with the cryptocurrency stuff. It was like a month or two after.
I think if people could have gotten a 3080 10 GB for actually for $700, people would have been maybe, yeah, a bit more positive about it today.
Yeah. But I think if it had 12 GB VRAM, people would be, because I've heard from heaps of you guys who had 3080s that have upgraded or want to upgrade because the VRAM is a bit of a problem, because it's like it doesn't fall into the same category as like the more modern, well, as much as the more modern 8 GB cards, because it was a flagship card. You're expecting to use like higher quality textures and things like that. And doing that with some of the more modern rendering technologies, I'm hearing from you guys 10 GB is problematic, which probably makes sense. But um, yeah, I just looked at the question, they say the 7000 series, which actually wasn't released at the same time as, because the 7000 series was released two years after, so I think the 6000 series is the more relevant.
Definitely the more relevant. Well, the 6000 series launched at the same time, and that again, they both came, like the 6000 series at launch was a disaster, because the 6600 I think came in at $330 US, which at the time was horrifically poor value, but it was pumped up from the cryptocurrency boom, and then later they sold for like $200 US or just under that.
Yeah. And those cards, like those AMD GPUs, they obviously had a big strength where there was enough VRAM on most of the models, especially once you got to the 6700, the 6700 was a good price.
The XT, you know, it wasn't like it was a mid-range card. They had higher tier models that also had 16 GB of VRAM which were good. I mean the 6700 had 12, didn't it? But those cards, you know, there were times, especially post-cryptocurrency, where they were available for pretty good prices. But the main thing that holds those cards back is their lack of feature support from AMD. Nvidia's continued to support their cards for a lot longer with all the latest features, and the upscaling side of things on those cards is very weak. Of course, you can use like the modded versions of FSR 4 right now, but the official support for something like FSR 4.1 can't come soon enough on a card like that.
Yeah. I wonder what a modern update between like an RX 6800 versus an RTX 3070 looks like.
Yeah, in terms of performance, it would certainly be interesting.
You get twice the VRAM on the Radeon card there. Haven't.
Yeah, especially when those, once you actually get proper modern upscaling support on that card.
Because I think there's kind of two angles with that content that make it interesting. There's the performance side of things, like what could it just do at the same settings? And then there's also like if you were using Nvidia's features on the 3070, first of all, does that work like from the memory side of things if you start using frame generation? But then how does that compare to AMD's cards with their sort of inadequate features? Like where do you actually end up if you try and like maybe normalize quality?
Yeah, it'd be, there's a few interesting things there, but who knows if we're stuck on content. Maybe there's some content there for us.
Yep. We'll answer the question in depth at some point.
Yeah, we'll see. Um, as for how well they work as general, fine.
I don't know. It's sort of like there's some good stuff and bad stuff, but I don't think there's anything that's out of typical either way on those cards.
They sort of, they are what they are. They're five years old. No, six years old now, because they launched at the end of 2020. So, we're in '26 now.
Yeah. Six years old. You'd expect some aging and they have aged. So, yeah.
Silly. Yes. Uh, it's the fourth anniversary of your 4090 review in which you concluded,
Yeah, like a party popper.
'Until more GPUs arrive, it's hard to say just how good, dumb, or bad value the RTX 4090 is.' What would your answer to that question be knowing everything that we do now? So, some person has dredged up your 4090 review to see what you said four years ago and is now like, time to answer that question.
Well, to be fair, I think the question was answered four years ago. So, bit of context, right? Nvidia led with their flagship card as they often do. So, we got the RTX 4090 first. Super duper expensive, high-end, very basically what I was saying was this thing is very impressive in terms of its performance. Mighty fast, blows everything else that came before it out of the water, but it's stupidly expensive. So, is it worth buying? Is it good? We don't know because we haven't got the Radeon competition and we haven't seen what the rest of the GeForce lineup has to offer. So, if the RTX 4080 came in and it was significantly cheaper but only slightly slower as what we saw with like the previous generation, whereas, you know, your 3090 was considered a dumb card because it wasn't that much faster than the 3080 but it cost substantially more. So, were we going to see that kind of situation repeat itself or not? So, that's really all that comment was about. The following month, we got the RTX 4080. It was $400 US cheaper at $1,200 US. And it offered about the same cost per frame with like less VRAM and stuff. So, it's like if you're going to spend $1,200 US, do you just go all the way to $1,600 US? A lot of people did. So, it meant the 4080 kind of was better than what we thought it might have been because the 4090 was better. I don't know if I said that, because the 4080 was so underwhelming is what I'm trying to say. So, and then the 7900 XT and XTX came along and in my words that was massively underwhelming. Got a few notes here, but I do recall this. AMD claimed ahead of release that it would be 50 to 70% faster than the 6950 XT.
Uh, and that was a real point of contention. Based on that, we polled our audience what they thought it would be, and they said they thought it would be at least 50% faster based on AMD's claims, and that was over 50,000 of you who voted on that. In reality, we found it was on average 35% faster. Um, which again created this point of contention. There was all these arguments, but what was quite humorous about all of that was AMD's own review guide showed 43%, which was less than 50 to 70%. So, I don't know why AMD themselves were saying it was in the range of 50 to 70% when their own review guide showed 43%. Like that's kind of a selective way of going about that, but I guess that's marketing. AMD used to do a lot of that. It's blown up in their face time and time again, but again, they did the same thing with Zen 5. So, have they learned a lesson? I don't know. Um, so with the 7000 series at their MSRP launch prices being very underwhelming and the 4080 being like similar value to the 4090, we got our answer like a month or two after release, and that was that the 4090 was like just fine in an underwhelming world of GPUs. And obviously since then it's aged quite well because everything since then has been somewhat underwhelming. So when all your predecessors end up being very underwhelming, it's like, you know, if I replace Tim with some guy that does a worse job, I'm like, damn, Tim wasn't that bad. Because I think Tim's quite bad. And if I replace him with someone who proves to be worse, I'm joking. People do not take that.
They do not get that. Oh, just to get derailed here, funniest thing ever on the Gears of War E-Day content. Yeah.
You know, I took a jab at the audience like as a joke.
About the, because people genuinely jumped in the comments and were like, "This is a cash grab. The developer sucks." But and we're like, "It's if you own the game, it's free."
Yeah. That was to The Witcher 3 remastered. Yeah.
Witcher 3 remastered. It was free. And people were abusing the developer for doing a remastered cash grab, but if you own the game, it was free. And so I made a joke about that. And I had a couple of people like saying, you know, you're showing your true colors here by attacking your audience and belittling them and blah. And I'm like, it was meant as a bit of a fun, lighthearted jab. It was a joke.
I mean, it was a joke. Those comments were very silly on the Witcher 3.
And I said to one guy, I said to him, I said, but I was being sarcastic. Like I was joking. And he's like, "It didn't come across as sarcasm to me." And I said to him, "It literally said sarcasm on the screen." And he's like, "Oh my bad." [laughter]
So I'm joking. I think Tim does a wonderful job. I very much appreciate him. But if I didn't appreciate him and thought he was crap and replaced him with someone else who did a worse job, I'd be like, "Damn, the 4090 that was Tim wasn't that bad."
Yeah. I think a lot of people would have thought that the 4090, like in the 50 series, you would have gotten 4090 pricing for a lot lower than you've ended up getting.
Oh, of course. Sorry. Yeah, I forgot to enable multi frame generation with 6x mode in my analysis there.
Correct your editorial direction, Tim.
With the 40 series as well, a lot of the series ended up, and AMD series, the whole lineup ended up very underwhelming. And I think when we made a podcast around that time, ranking all of the GPUs from that series.
Hang on, hang on, hang on. Sorry to interrupt you. I distinctly recall you making a post on X that had a lot of poop emojis.
Yeah, you, yeah. Yeah. A lot of the lineup got some poo emojis.
Did like a ranking thing. [laughter]
Some of them got a lot of poo emojis. Like three or four. Yeah, maybe we can find that and bring that up. But
Oh, we're going to put that on screen. It's so good.
In the podcast where we went through and we ranked all the GPUs in that series, we put the 4090 in first place because it was fast. It wasn't, you know, in terms of cost per frame and stuff, it made sense. And so much of the lineup was underwhelming that it just almost by default became the best option.
Well, we thought so. We copped a lot of flack for that because we're out of touch entitled YouTubers.
We gave our reasons which I thought were valid, reasonable, and whatnot. But yeah, we did upset quite a lot of people by that.
We did upset people, but I think I stand by that considering everything that we know now
and because this is what the question was about, considering what we know now.
Yeah, I think we got that one right.
Yeah. So, very forgettable generation in that generation.
So, to further answer your question, not only did I answer this question, like seriously, "This guy, rethink your... I'm joking. Put sarcasm on the screen." But we did answer this question like a month or two after the release with the following reviews, and then we further answered it again in the podcast where we ranked the GPUs, and we ended up putting the 4090 as the best of the generation. So I think that one's like
We've shut the book on that one.
Yep. Yeah, it's done.
All right, let's move on. How can I meaningfully upgrade my performance during this apocalypse?
Well, you can't. Yeah. I mean, no. I mean, the only component that makes sense is a CPU, right?
Yeah. So, if you've got a reasonable GPU already, like even like I said, if it's an RTX 5060 and you're playing a game like Fortnite or Valorant or whatever, and you want to hit those high FPS numbers and you're CPU limited, then if you have a CPU that can be slotted into your platform, you are in luck because you will get... I had a friend who had... and this is the classic we see. So, I've got a friend who's actually like almost pro-level Fortnite player, so very into it. Plays in all the competitive cups and whatever. And he was getting like 100 FPS
and he recently upgraded his GPU because he thought that would be the problem because he's not like a tech-savvy hardware guy. He's, you know, a mad gamer. He had a GeForce RTX 5060.