Good news, guys. I've saved up my dollars and I'm ready to finally buy that new graphics card for playing all my favorite video games, of course. So, let's go shopping. I've got around $1,200 to spend. Ideally, though, I would like to spend a little bit less than that if I can. So, I think let's aim for a mid-range GeForce GPU because I have heard over at places like Reddit that GeForce is better than Radeon. So, that's probably correct.
I'd say the GeForce RTX 5060 Ti is what I'm after, the 16 GB model, of course, because, you know, I might play something else other than Fortnite in the future. You never know. So, let's take a look at what I've got here.
Oh, wow. Okay. Uh, not sure what's going on here. Last time I looked, which admittedly was earlier in the year, you could buy a 5060 Ti 16 GB for about $750 Australian.
Now they're starting at $1,150 and they're mostly out of stock. In fact, PC Case Gear has just a single model, a PNY card for $1,049.
Yikes. So, bugger that. Let's go check out another retailer. We'll go over to Mwave. Oh, here we go. $769. Nice. Hang on. Wait. That one's out of stock. Okay. $1,000.
And that model's also out of stock. $1,049.
Okay. Yep, that is in stock. And it's a PNY version again, which I guess is fine. But damn, the ASUS dual model is $1,129.
So, it is pretty rough out here. And that means I am going to need to make a bit more money. And helping me do just that is OREI and their brand new capture card. Today's sponsor spot is brought to you by OREI and their VC 8KT USB 3 external HDMI capture device designed for professional recording and streaming applications. Supporting HDMI input resolutions up to 8K at 60 Hz and 4K at 144 hertz while capturing video at up to 4K at 60fps. It also features an HDMI loop out, microphone input, and 3.5 millimeter line in and line out ports for flexible audio and video integration for advanced production setups. Powered by USB 3.2 Gen 1 with up to 5 Gbits per second bandwidth, it ensures smooth low latency video transmission. Multiple capture formats including YUY2, NV12, I420, and MJPEG are supported as well as HDR, making it suitable for a wide range of workflows. Fully compliant with UVC and UAC standards, the best part is this device requires no drivers for a true plug-and-play experience. It's compatible with Windows 7, 10, 11, Mac OS, and Linux, and works seamlessly with popular software such as OBS, Streamlabs, vMix, Zoom, Microsoft Teams, and more. So, for more information, please check the links in the video description.
Okay, so I know those Radeon GPUs aren't meant to be as good, but I am getting pretty desperate out here. So, let's go take a look. And it looks like based on pricing, at least that I'm seeing here at local retailers, that a GPU called the Radeon RX 9070 XT is the direct competitor to the 5060 Ti 16 GB. They are a little bit more expensive, but pretty similar overall, starting at $1,149.
And there's a lot of models available for $1,249.
So hopefully that's not much slower than the GeForce GPU. Now, just to make sure this isn't some odd Australian pricing thing, I went over to Newegg.com. So state side, they have the 5060 Ti 16 GB starting at $780 US. And that means the 9070 XT is actually cheaper there with the Radeon GPU starting at $740 US. They both have 16 GB of VRAM. So I guess we need to see how they compare. And for that, I have a 52 game benchmark for you, comparing the Radeon RX 9070 XT and GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB to find out which option is best for gamers on an $800 US or $1,200 Australian budget. So then, let's go look at some blue bar graphs. But rather than go over all 52 games tested because that is quite a mammoth task, I'll go over some of the games and make the rest of the graphs available for free over on our Patreon page. So check the video description for that link. Okay, let's get into it.
First test we have is 007 First Light. And here we see the 9070 XT is actually 81% faster at 1440p with the medium settings as frame rates jumped up from 67 FPS to 121 FPS. And that does seem like quite a big jump to me. The 4K results though, they're even worse. Again, using the medium preset, the Radeon GPU was 106% faster, going from a measly 34 FPS with the GeForce GPU to a highly playable 70fps with the 9070 XT.
Switching to the ultra preset didn't help the RTX 5060 Ti all that much. The margins did come down a little bit, but even so, at 1440p, the 9070 XT was still 62% faster and then 78% faster at 4K. So, for native resolution performance, the 5060 Ti is at best limited to 1440p, while 4K is possible with the 9070 XT.
Swinging into Spider-Man 2, the 9070 XT continues to flex on the 5060 Ti. At 1440p, using the very high preset, it averaged 130 FPS compared to just 81 FPS for the 5060 Ti. That is a massive 60% performance advantage. Even at 4K, the Radeon GPU remained rock solid with 80 fps, making it 70% faster than the 5060 Ti, which managed just 47 FPS.
Enabling the demanding ray tracing ultimate preset brings frame rates down, but the hierarchy stays firmly in place. And by that, I mean at 1440p, the 9070 XT delivered a playable 67 FPS, and that made it 60% faster than the 5060 Ti's 42 FPS.
Then at 4K, the 9070 XT averaged 36 FPS, allowing for a 50% margin over the 5060 Ti's cinematic 24fps.
Moving over to Lego Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight, we see the bloodbath continue. At 1440p, using the medium preset, the 9070 XT effortlessly pumped out 234 FPS compared to the 5060 Ti's 149 FPS, and that made the Radeon GPU a cool 57% faster. Bumping the resolution up to 4K makes the Nvidia card's value proposition look even more embarrassing. The 9070 XT crushes it by an 88% margin, delivering a buttery smooth 147 FPS, while the 5060 Ti trails far behind at just 78 FPS.
Then cranking the visuals up to the epic preset gives the RTX 5060 Ti a slight breather in terms of the performance gaps, but it still gets thoroughly outclassed. At 1440p, for example, the Radeon GPU maintained a comfortable 40% lead, hitting 102 FPS versus the GeForce GPU's 73 FPS. Now, pushing the pixel count up to 4K here, the 9070 XT manages to scrape by with an almost 60fps experience. And while not amazing, that did make it 51% faster than the 5060 Ti's rather pathetic 39 FPS. Ultimately, while 1440p is doable on both, anyone hoping for a decent 4K experience here will be severely disappointed by the GeForce graphics card.
Fortnite gives the RTX 5060 Ti its closest showing yet, at least when using the lightweight competitive settings. The 1440p performance mode saw the 9070 XT just 14% faster, though that gap did stretch out to 30% at 4K.
However, once Unreal Engine 5's full graphical suite is unleashed using the Epic quality settings along with ray tracing, normal service resumes at 1440p. The 9070 XT rendered 120 fps and that made it 54% faster than the 5060 Ti's 78 FPS. And then at 4K, the AMD GPU easily wins with a 50% lead with 66 FPS versus 44 fps.
In Forza Horizon 6, the rasterized and ray traced results tell an identical story, and that is one of AMD dominance. Using the extreme preset at 1440p, the 9070 XT was 65% faster, rendering 140 FPS compared to the 5060 Ti's 85 FPS. And then moving to 4K, we see that the 9070 XT breezes past the 100fps mark, while the 5060 Ti fails to hold 60fps, yielding a 76% advantage for the Radeon GPU.
Then, when tossing ray tracing into the mix, this highlights the hardware gap even further. At 1440p, the 9070 XT manages a 79% lead with 75 FPS versus 42 FPS. But then at 4K, both did struggle. But the 9070 XT's 43 FPS is still 79% faster than the unplayable 24 fps produced by the 5060 Ti. And that does mean with some upscaling support, the Radeon GPU would be usable here.
Next up, we have Crimson Desert. And here the 9070 XT maintains a commanding lead. Using the medium preset at 1440p, the Radeon GPU averaged 103 FPS compared to just 67 FPS for the 5060 Ti. So a 50% performance advantage there. Then at 4K, the disparity widens considerably. The Radeon GPU cruises at 66 FPS for a 69% victory, while the GeForce GPU stumbles into sub-40 FPS territory at 39 FPS. Enabling the cinematic quality preset doesn't do Team Green any favors here either. At 1440p, the 9070 XT remained 54% faster, rendering 86 FPS against the 5060 Ti's 56 FPS. Meanwhile, at 4K, the 9070 XT averaged a respectable 53 FPS, beating out the 5060 Ti's 32 FPS by 66%.
So, for a smooth visual showcase at maximum settings, the 5060 Ti clearly punches well below its inflated price point. The Unreal Engine 5 continues to take no prisoners, but the 5060 Ti suffers a particularly grim fate here. At 1440p using the medium preset, the 9070 XT delivered 70% greater performance, managing 51 FPS, while Nvidia's offering crawled along at just 30 fps. Meanwhile, stepping up to the 4K resolution effectively turned the 5060 Ti into a slideshow at 18 fps, whereas the Radeon GPU was 72% faster with 31 FPS. Not exactly lightning quick, but substantially better all the same.
Things though do get downright comical with the epic preset. At 1440p, the 9070 XT is 81% faster and at 4K it widens the gap to 83%, leaving the 5060 Ti choking at a miserable 12fps average with single-digit 1% lows. Simply put, native rendering on a 5060 Ti in this title is essentially unplayable across the board. And it's so bad, in fact, that most of the results wouldn't be made workable even with ultra performance DLSS thrown into the mix.
In Night City, traditionally a stronghold for Nvidia hardware, especially when using ray tracing, the raw tier mismatch here makes for some brutal viewing. At 1440p, using the ultra preset, the 9070 XT sits comfortably at 131 FPS, giving it a massive 90% lead over the 5060 Ti's 69 FPS.
Stepping up to the 4K resolution widens the gap further to 103% where the Radeon GPU maintained a playable 63 FPS average while the 5060 Ti stumbled along at just 31 FPS. Even with ray tracing ultra engaged, the 5060 Ti simply lacks the horsepower to compete. At 1440p, the 9070 XT is nearly twice as fast with a 96% performance advantage. And at 4K, that just proves too punishing for really both GPUs. But the 9070 XT's 26 FPS still places it 86% ahead of the 5060 Ti's slideshow average of 14 fps.
Venturing into the zone at the native render resolution yields another heavy round of defeats for the GeForce GPU. At 1440p with the medium settings, the 9070 XT clocked in at 122 FPS, making it 54% faster than the 5060 Ti's 79 FPS. And we even see the 1% lows of the Radeon GPU smash the 5060 Ti's average frame rate. Then at 4K, the Radeon GPU delivered a 63% uplift, managing 70 FPS, while the 5060 Ti fell short at 43 FPS.
Dialing the visuals up to the epic settings tightens things slightly, but the hierarchy remains undisputed. At 1440p, the 9070 XT stays 52% ahead with 70 fps versus 46 FPS. And at 4K, neither GPU will give you a high refresh rate experience. Yet, the 40 FPS from the 9070 XT still sees it outpace the 5060 Ti by 54% as that GPU only managed 26 FPS.
And the second last game we're going to look at is Pragmata. And here, the Radeon GPU continues its dominant sweep at 1440p using the max quality settings. The 9070 XT rendered 138 FPS, outpacing the 5060 Ti's 89 FPS by 55%. Moving to 4K pushes that lead up to 63% with AMD hitting a smooth 78 FPS while Nvidia struggles to break 50 fps at just 48 FPS. Enabling ray tracing barely slows down the 9070 XT. At 1440p with full ray tracing, the Radeon GPU averaged 135 FPS, enjoying a 63% buffer over the 5060 Ti's 83 FPS. Then at 4K, the 9070 XT averaged a solid 76 FPS for a 69% margin over the 5060 Ti's 45fps.
With both GPUs selling for equivalent money, giving up over 60% of your frame rate for the GeForce badge, it is a tough pill to swallow.
Finally, in Arc Raiders, we see one of the narrowest margins of our test suite. Though the 9070 XT still won every configuration using the epic quality settings with RT static at 1440p, AMD was 30% faster, and it managed to extend that margin to 38% at 4K. Stepping up to the RT epic settings at 1440p sees the margin compressed to its tightest point at 24%, but then at 4K, the gap settles in at 30%, with the 9070 XT reaching 133 FPS while the 5060 Ti achieved 102 FPS. Both GPUs did provide highly playable frame rates, but you're still getting roughly a third more performance out of the Radeon GPU for the same money.
Looking at the massive 52 game average data across the mixed quality settings, the overall picture doesn't really get any prettier for Nvidia. At 1440p, the Radeon RX 9070 XT pulls ahead by 62%, averaging 123 FPS compared to the RTX 5060 Ti's 76 FPS. In fact, the Radeon GPU's 1% lows of 97 FPS comfortably beat the GeForce GPU's average frame rate, highlighting just how wide the hardware gulf really is here. And then stepping up to 4K, the margin widens to 71% in AMD's favor. Here, the 9070 XT delivers a genuinely smooth 72 FPS average, whereas the 5060 Ti gets left struggling in the lower 40s at just 42 FPS with 1% lows dipping down to 33 FPS. So, when paying matching retail prices gets you a GPU capable of fluid 4K gaming on one side versus a GPU that's clearly relegated to 1440p duty at best on the other, the value equation for the 5060 Ti completely falls apart.
And to better illustrate the value equation, here is the cost per frame data based on current Australian retail pricing. Despite coming in $100 cheaper locally, the RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB still costs 48% more per frame based on the 1440p results and then 57% more at 4K. That is crazy. But the situation gets even crazier over in the US. And I strongly suspect Australian pricing will catch up to what we're seeing over there in the next few weeks as retailers are currently hesitant to repurchase RTX 5060 Ti at the current asking prices cuz they are just that absurd. But over on Newegg.com, we see the 5060 Ti is coming in 71% more expensive per frame based on the 1440p data and then an insane 81% more expensive based on the 4K results.
There's really not much more that needs to be said about that. It is crazy. It's hard to say when this madness will end or even how mad things will end up getting. I'm sure if I told you just a few months ago that soon an RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB would cost as much or even more than a 9070 XT, most of you would have laughed me out of the room. And honestly, I wouldn't blame you. That's pretty hard to imagine. But again, here we are. In part, the inflated prices are due to the industry-wide memory shortages. The 9070 XT is now at least 23% over MSRP. Though the RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB, this thing is a little over 80% above its original MSRP or just the MSRP.
Now, although both GPUs do feature 16 GB of VRAM, the GeForce GPU uses GDDR7 memory, whereas the 9070 XT still relies on the older GDDR6 memory. So, there will be some pricing differences there. Tying into this, Nvidia recently notified its board partners that it was hiking prices for its GPU memory bundles, which immediately resulted in significant price hikes for their GPUs, as we've seen with parts like the RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB. To what degree Nvidia has hiked prices, it's not exactly known. I have some off-the-record details, but it sounds like they have added a bit extra on the top, which helps explain the 80% increase for the 5060 Ti.
Nvidia's been able to get away with these extreme prices due to the AI demand, not just from AI data centers, which aren't actually buying GeForce GPUs, but also from those looking to run local AI workloads. And those customers are buying up the hideously overpriced GeForce GPUs. Now, as I understand it, and please note, I am far from an expert on this AI stuff, but as I understand it, there is significantly higher demand for something like an RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB than say the Radeon RX 9070 XT for these local AI workloads. As we've just seen, despite the fact that the RX 9070 XT is a very capable GPU for gaming and it actually beats the 5060 Ti in raw memory bandwidth despite using GDDR6 memory, and this can be important for AI workloads as memory bandwidth dictates text generation speed. But despite that, Nvidia does remain the undisputed king even for those running local AI workloads.
And this demand disparity comes about almost entirely due to software ecosystem support and ease of use. NVIDIA's CUDA architecture is still the foundational software layer for modern AI development. Almost every new AI model, user interface tool, fine-tuned script, and GitHub repository is built, optimized, and tested on NVIDIA hardware first. I'm told if all you want to use is bleeding edge tools like TensorRT-LLM or Llama 2, they explicitly require an Nvidia GPU. So, in short, the 9070 XT is a great option if you're strictly running Linux and want maximum raw bandwidth for text generation. But for everyone else, the RTX 5060 Ti is heavily preferred because it's viewed as the safer bet. It guarantees compatibility with upcoming AI tools. It requires zero troubleshooting and it dominates in image generation.
For these reasons, Nvidia has been able to jack up the prices and still generate sales. But in doing so, fewer and fewer gamers are now going GeForce. Not that I guess Nvidia really cares. Anyway, if you are building a gaming PC and you want more than 8 GB of VRAM, as it stands right now, Radeon really is the only way to go. It's simply not worth paying the massive GeForce tax. And that is going to do it for this video. If you liked it, give it a like. Subscribe for more. Maybe we'll be comparing this to maybe an RTX 5060 in a few months time. So, that could be fun. Make sure you subscribe for that. On a serious note, I do hope this madness ends soon. But yeah, it looks like there's no end in sight, unfortunately.
Anyway, I'll just wrap it up. There's the join button or Patreon. Signing up to either one of those things will give you access to our exclusive Discord server, monthly live streams, behind the scenes content, and Q&A stuff. So, check that out if you're interested. If not, that is perfectly fine. And of course, I would like to thank you for watching this video. I'm your host, Steve. See you again next time.