Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Seth Carpenter, Morgan Stanley's global chief economist and head of macro research.
I'm Michael Gapen, chief US economist.
I'm Yens Eisenmidz, chief Europe economist.
And I'm Jathan Aaya, chief Asia economist.
And today, our fourth quarterly economic roundtable discussion is going to try to take a wide-angle view on the global economy. And it has held up despite higher interest rates, higher energy prices, geopolitical uncertainty, you name it. It's Thursday, October 22nd at 10 a.m. in New York and 4 p.m. in Frankfurt and 10 p.m. in Hong Kong.
All right then. Let me start with that big question. Why has global growth held up better than maybe would have been expected given everything that we've seen? Mike, maybe I'll start from the US perspective with you. What do you think has mattered most? What is driving this, if I dare use an overused word, the resilience of the economy?
Most of us believe AI-related spending is interest-rate insensitive and geopolitically insensitive, and certainly I think the data has borne that out. And in the direct translation of AI hyperscaler capex spending to growth, we find that AI is accounting for a 4 to 6 percentage point contribution to growth in any given quarter. You could nudge that a little higher if you think it's creating productivity, which we do. And that spending is underpinning asset market appreciation, or certainly has for the past several years, and that is underpinning resilient spending by upper-income households. So I think in the US the clear answer is AI-related spending, but also its linkage to asset markets and upper-income households.
Yens, let me come to you for the European view. I mean, the AI story has been a little bit different in Europe. I think consumer behavior sometimes can be different in Europe than from the United States. What would you say is the story behind the resilience of economic growth there in Europe?
It's similar in the sense that there is a clear element also of AI-related external demand that even in Europe now the phones are ringing, given that we are more typically seen as on the more higher-cost end of the spectrum. So I think there was clearly in the second-quarter data export-led growth elements related to AI or delivery into that. There was also an element of geopolitical tensions helping some of those producers, say the chemical industry in Germany comes to mind, that would deliver products that would previously be delivered out of the Strait. So that is another element. And then, yeah, the consumer held up better than we had expected, or that you could have expected, given the rise in energy prices. So all in all, that got us a relatively solid second-quarter print, and we expect this to be more or less repeated also in the third quarter.
Jathan, the export story is pretty important. You've been writing a lot about a big capex cycle and big industrial cycle in Asia. So when you think about the Asia story and why the economic growth has held up in spite of the global shocks, how would you characterize that?
Yeah, so Asia is benefiting from a strong pickup in capex, which initially was led by the tech sector but is now broadening out to energy, defense, and broader industrial investments. Exports are strong and showing some signs of broadening out from tech to non-tech goods too. This has meant that the region has faced a positive terms-of-trade situation despite higher oil prices. Higher export prices have boosted corporate profits and, in turn, government tax revenues, offsetting the fiscal pressures from higher fuel subsidies.
And when you're thinking about higher interest rates that you are seeing globally and also in Asia, what is different in this cycle is that the macro stability indicators are in a good place. Current account surpluses in the region have widened quite significantly. In fact, it is $1.6 trillion or 4.2% of GDP. Also, what we have is that the private sector balance sheets outside of China are quite healthy. So all in all, both higher oil prices and interest rates have not disturbed the capex and growth cycle in the region.
Is there a lot of dispersion across sectors, across countries for this cycle that you're talking about, Jathan? Can you go a little bit deeper there?
Yeah. So let me start first with the story on investment versus consumption. So initially the growth story in the region started with a pickup in exports and capex, but what we have seen is that this has now broadened out into a dynamic where we see an improvement in the labor market and therefore consumption growth. So we have seen this recovery broadening out from exports to capex to consumption. And within the region, when you're thinking about different economies, initially we saw very strong growth in Korea and Taiwan, but now we have seen growth being strong in all parts of the region, especially in economies like India, Japan, and also some of the Southeast Asian economies like Malaysia and Singapore.
I want to stay on this broadening theme, Michael. Is all of the capex spending, all the investment spending by business in the United States, is it just an AI story? Are we seeing any broadening of the investment story in the US beyond AI, or should we just resign ourselves that the rest of the economy is going to be stagnant?
No, I do think we are seeing evidence of some broadening out. It is most clear in manufacturing. So I do think it points to some broadening out in the AI story beyond the narrow AI story into something that is broader, that both Jathan and Yens have referenced about in a multipolar world needing to build out redundancies in supply chains, maybe there's some incentive to do some reshoring. So whether it's a spillover effect from AI or a spillover effect from geopolitics at large, I do think there's some evidence that we're seeing the broadening out. I would just caution and say just remember manufacturing in the US is relatively small. It's only about 10% of output and maybe 10% of employment, but nonetheless it's there. So it's not just an AI story. I think you can characterize it as a bit broader.